Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 26.11.2025
Pronounced on: 06.02.2026
W.P.(C) 10265/2015
RAN SINGH AND ANR.
Through:
…..Petitioners
Mr. Dhananjay Singh Sehrawat
and Ms. Ritika, Advocates.
versus
DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION AND ORS.
....Respondents
Through:
Mrs.
Avnish
Ahlawat,
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Nitesh Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza
Alam and Mr. Mohnish
Sehrawat,
Advocates
for
R1/DTC.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
The present Writ Petition has been filed challenging the order
dated 15.07.2015 passed by the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as
‘Tribunal’) in O.A. No. 1870/2014, titled Ran Singh and Anr. v.
Delhi Transport Corporation and Ors., whereby the learned Tribunal
dismissed the O.A. filed by the petitioners herein.
FACTUAL MATRIX:
2.
The Petitioners were working as Conductors with the
respondents, that is, the Delhi Transport Corporation (hereinafter
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
referred to as “DTC”). At the relevant point of time, the Petitioners
were also active office bearers of the recognised majority union of
DTC and were stated to be vocal in highlighting and opposing various
administrative and functional issues within the Corporation.
3.
This dispute traces its origin to Charge Sheet No. Narela
Depot/A.L.(T)/CS-26/11/241 dated 09.08.2011, which was issued to
the Petitioners jointly with one Shri Jagphool Singh, Driver. The said
charge sheet was issued by the Depot Manager, Narela Depot, and was
based on a report allegedly submitted by one Shri Surender Singh,
ATI, who was stated to be present at the time of the alleged incident.
The relevant part of the charge sheet is produced herein below:
“It is desired that you explain that why
departmental action be not initiated against
you under Regulation 15(2) of Delhi transport
Corporation (Appointment &Conditions of
Service) Act 1952.
That on 06.08.11, at around 11 o'clock, you,
using unparliamentary language with Sh. Ran
Singh, Coductor, B. No. and Sh. Jagphool,
Driver, B.No.10566, entered in the room of
Depot Manager where the Depot Manger was
talking to Surender, DTC. T.n0.16942.You and
your friends jointly bolted the room from
inside. You picked up the Depot Manager from
his chair and manhandled him.
Sh. Surender tried to pacify and opened the
door and hearing that many employees
accumulated and some body informed the
Police at No.100.Before the police came, you
fled away from the Depot premises.
From the aforesaid acts, you disrupted the
administrative work of the Depot and spoilt
the image of the Corporation.
Thus you have violated Para I9(f)(g)(h) &m of
the standing orders governing the conduct of
the D.T.C. employees.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
Sh. Surender, T.N0.16942, has produced
report dated 6.8.11 ,which is the basis of this
charge sheet. A copy is attached herewith. On
passing the final orders your past record shall
be kept in mind. If you want a personal
hearing, apply for the same in your reply. Your
reply should reach the undersigned within 10
days of the receipt of this charge sheet. If you
want to peruse any relied document, available
on record, report within 24 hrs. to the
undersigned, from the receipt of this charge
sheet.
From the perusal of documents, report within
24 hrs to the undersigned and thereafter
within 10 days reply to the charge sheet. If you
are unsuccessful, it would be presumed that
you have nothing to reply to the charge sheet
and under the provisions, action shall be taken
against you without any reference to you.”
4.
The allegations contained in the charge sheet dated 09.08.2011
were that on 06.08.2011 at about 11:00 a.m., the Petitioners, along
with Shri Suresh, Conductor,
and Shri Jagphool Singh, Driver,
entered the room of the Depot Manager while he was interacting with
Shri Surender Singh, ATI. It was alleged that the Petitioners and their
associates used unparliamentary language, jointly bolted the room
from inside, lifted the Depot Manager, namely Shri. R.B.L Srivastava,
from his chair and manhandled him. It was further alleged that Shri
Surender Singh, ATI attempted to pacify the situation and opened the
door, several employees had also gathered outside, the police was also
informed, however, before the arrival of the police, the Petitioners fled
from the depot premises. The said chargesheet dated 09.08.2011 was
based on the report submitted by Shri. Surender Singh, ATI who was
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
purportedly inside the room.
5.
Pursuant to the said charge sheet dated 09.08.2011, a
departmental enquiry was conducted against all the charged
employees. It is stated by the petitioners that during the enquiry, Shri
Surender Singh, ATI, categorically denied any manhandling of the
Depot Manager and had further stated that he had been called upon by
the Depot Manager and was compelled to submit the report dated
06.08.2011, which ultimately formed the basis of the charge sheet.
6.
Upon conclusion of the enquiry, vide order dated 03.10.2012,
Shri Jagphool Singh, Driver, was imposed the penalty of “stoppage of
his next increment with cumulative effect”. However, the said penalty
was imposed after his retirement and was therefore incapable of being
enforced. Significantly, as regards the Petitioners namely Shri Ran
Singh and Shri Suresh, vide order dated 02.11.2012, the chargesheet
dated 09.08.2011 was withdrawn with a direction that a fresh
chargesheet will be issued in the due course of time.
7.
Thereafter, a report was allegedly called for from Shri R.B.L.
Srivastava, Senior Manager/Depot Manager. Based on such
subsequent report dated 20.11.2012, a fresh charge sheet bearing No.
RM(N)/CS-01/12/782 dated 20.12.2012 was issued to the Petitioners
by the Regional Manager (North), an authority admittedly lower in
rank than the Chairman-cum-Managing Director. The second
chargesheet is reproduced herein under:
“It is desired that you explain that why
departmental action be not initiated against
you under Regulation 15(2) of Delhi Transport
Corporation (Appointment and Conditions of
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
Service )Act,1952 read with 4(e) of Delhi Road
Transport (Amended) Act1971:
That on 06.08.2011, at about ll'O Clock, you
alongwith with Sh. Suresh Kumar , Conductor,
B.No.l6261 and Sh. Jagphool, Driver, B.No.
10566, entered in the room of Sh.
R.B.L.Srivastava ,Sr. Manager (T)/Depot
Manager without permission, and forced out
the scheduled section employees sitting there.
You along with with. Conductor, B.No.l6261
and Driver, B.No. 10566 jointly bolted the
room from inside, and shouted and abused Sh.
R.B.L.Srivastava and used unparliamentary
language on him. You were in a toxic
condition at that time. At that time, hearing the
noise, employees of other sections and staff
employees gathered and got the door opened.
In the interregnum, some body informed the
Police at No. 100 . Before the Police came,
you fled away from the Depot premises.
From the aforesaid acts, it is clear that you
disrupted the administrative work oi the Depot
and spoilt the image of the Corporation. Thus
you have violated Para IS (f,g,h&m) of the
standing orders governing the conduct of
D.T.C.Employees.
Report No.4223 dated 20.11.12 which is the
basis of the charge sheet, is attached herewith.
Your reply should reach the undersigned
within 10 days of the receipt of this charge
sheet. If you want to peruse any relied
document, available in record, report Within
24 hrs.to the undersigned, from the receipt of
this charge sheet.
If you fail to report within 24 hrs to the
undersigned for perusal of documents and
thereafter within 10 days reply to the charge
sheet, it would be presumed that that you have
nothing to reply to the charge sheet and under
the provisions, action shall be taken against
you without any reference to you.”
8.
The second charge sheet dated 20.12.2012 related to the same
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
incident dated 06.08.2011, but alleged materially altered and varied
the allegations against the petitioners. In place of the allegation of
manhandling, it was alleged that the Petitioners shouted, abused, and
used unparliamentary language against Shri R.B.L. Srivastava, Senior
Manager /Depot Manager. For the first time, it was alleged that the
Petitioners were in a “toxic condition”. It was further alleged that
scheduled section employees were forcibly removed from the room
and that employees from other sections gathered and got the door
opened.
9.
It is the case of the Petitioners that under the provisions of the
Delhi Road Transport Act and the applicable service regulations, the
Chairman-cum-Managing Director of DTC is the competent
Disciplinary Authority in respect of DTC employees. Though certain
disciplinary powers were delegated to Depot Managers and Regional
Managers, in the present case the Chairman himself exercised
disciplinary jurisdiction and consciously withdrew the charges against
the Petitioners. According to the Petitioners, the second charge sheet
was founded on a report allegedly given by the Senior Manager/Depot
Manager after a lapse of more than one year and three months from
the date of the alleged incident. It is the case of the petitioners that
even though no such report had been submitted contemporaneously on
06.08.2011, the subsequent report dated 20.11.2012 and the charge
sheet dated 20.12.2012 were manufactured and tailored with the sole
object of reviving charges that had already been withdrawn by the
competent Disciplinary Authority.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
10.
A departmental enquiry was thereafter conducted pursuant to
the charge sheet dated 20.12.2012. The Enquiry Officer submitted a
report holding the charges to be proved against the Petitioners.
11.
Acting on the enquiry report, the Regional Manager, purporting
to act as the Disciplinary Authority, passed orders dated 29.11.2013,
imposing upon the Petitioners the major penalty of “removal from
service”.
12.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioners preferred departmental
appeals dated 05.12.2013, followed by addenda dated 03.01.2014. The
appeals were, however, dismissed by the Appellate Authority vide
orders dated 01.04.2014, without granting any substantive relief.
13.
Aggrieved by the said charge sheet dated 20.12.2012, the
disciplinary orders dated 29.11.2013, and the appellate orders dated
01.04.2014, the Petitioners approached the learned Tribunal by filing
O.A. No. 1870/2014, seeking quashing of the charge sheet and the
orders passed thereon, reinstatement with all consequential benefits
and continuity of service, costs, and other appropriate reliefs.
14.
The present proceedings arise from the challenge to the
outcome of the said Original Application and the disciplinary action
taken against the Petitioners, giving rise to the issues which now fall
for consideration before this Court.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS:
15.
The
learned counsel for
the petitioners submits that
notwithstanding the withdrawal of the charges by the highest
disciplinary authority, the respondents proceeded to issue a fresh
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
charge sheet dated 20.12.2012, on the basis of a belated and tailored
report submitted after one year and three months of the purported
incident. The learned counsel for the petitioners further submits that
the fresh charge sheet was issued by the Regional Manager who had
no authority to act as the Disciplinary Authority, rendering the
document of second charge sheet as void ab initio.
16.
It is further submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioners
that in the second charge sheet the scope of accusations was
artificially escalated to include allegations of intoxication, which were
entirely absent in the initial complaint. Such escalation, without any
factual basis or contemporaneous observation, is indicative of
concocted charges and is a deliberate attempt to malign the petitioners
thereby prejudicing their position.
17.
According to the Petitioners, the second disciplinary inquiry
was a colourable exercise of power, undertaken with the sole objective
of removing the Petitioners from service. The learned counsel for the
petitioners submits that the entire enquiry conducted pursuant to the
second charge sheet was a farce, marked by withholding of crucial
documents, absence of credible witnesses, and glaring contradictions
in the management’s version of events.
18.
It is further submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioners
that no material exists on record to establish either the presence of the
Petitioners at the alleged incident or any misconduct attributable to
them. On the contrary, employees similarly placed were either
exonerated or inflicted with far lesser punishment, clearly evidencing
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
discriminatory treatment. The appellate proceedings, it is argued, were
equally perfunctory and culminated in a non-speaking order, betraying
complete non-application of mind.
19.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the
withdrawal of the initial charge sheet by the Chairman-cum-Managing
Director concluded the matter insofar as disciplinary jurisdiction was
concerned. The issuance of a fresh charge sheet by the Regional
Manager, an authority subordinate to the Chairman, was wholly
without jurisdiction and rendered the entire proceedings void ab initio.
It is submitted that no reasons whatsoever were recorded for the
reissuance of the charge sheet on the same set of allegations, further
vitiating the action.
20.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the reports
forming the basis of the two charge sheets are mutually contradictory
and irreconcilable. The charge sheets dated 09.08.2011 and
20.12.2012, though ostensibly arising out of the same incident, depict
materially different versions.
21.
It is further argued by the learned counsel for the petitioners
that there was a complete absence of any contemporaneous complaint
or record supporting the allegations. Documents obtained from the
management, including duty registers, security guard reports, and
depot records, show that the Petitioners completed their duties on the
alleged date and were paid in full. No record exists of any scuffle,
misconduct, or premature departure from duty.
22.
The learned counsel for the petitioners also relies upon the fact
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
that the police were called to the depot in connection with the alleged
incident, and upon inspection, the police concluded in DD No. 23A
dated 06.08.2011 that no scuffle had taken place. This independent
verification, it is submitted, demolishes the management’s version and
establishes that the allegations were fabricated post facto to justify
disciplinary action.
23.
The learned counsel for the Petitioners further submits that the
very foundation of the disciplinary proceedings is vitiated inasmuch as
Sh. R.B.L. Srivastava, reporter of the incident forming the basis of the
second charge sheet dated 20.12.2012, never deposed before the
Inquiry Officer. It is contended that the entire departmental action
rests upon an unproved and untested report, which was neither
substantiated through oral evidence nor subjected to crossexamination by the Petitioners.
24.
It is submitted that several defence witnesses, including Sh.
Sushil Kumar, Sh. Krishna Kumar, Sh. Praveen Kumar, Sh. Naveen
Kumar, and Sh. Jai Bhagwan, consistently deposed that no scuffle or
use of unparliamentary language had occurred and that the Petitioners
performed their duties without incident. These testimonies remained
unrebutted, yet were completely ignored by the Enquiry Officer and
the Disciplinary Authority, demonstrating wilful disregard of material
evidence.
25.
The learned counsel further contends that the punishment
imposed upon the Petitioners is grossly disproportionate and
discriminatory. While other employees involved in the same incident
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
were either exonerated or awarded minor penalties, the Petitioners
were visited with the extreme penalty of removal from service, despite
the absence of any proof of misconduct.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS:
26.
The learned counsel appearing for the respondents submits that
the scope of judicial review in matters arising out of disciplinary
proceedings is extremely circumscribed. It is contended that
interference by this Court is permissible only to examine the decisionmaking process and not to re-appreciate evidence or substitute its own
conclusions for that of the disciplinary authorities. According to the
Respondents, the Petitioners have failed to point out any illegality,
perversity, or procedural impropriety in the conduct of the
departmental proceedings so as to warrant interference with the orders
of punishment or their confirmation by the appellate authority.
27.
It is further submitted by the counsel for the respondents that
the Petitioners have been unable to demonstrate any prejudice caused
to them on account of the disciplinary proceedings being initiated
afresh. No specific plea has been raised as to how the Petitioners were
deprived of an opportunity to present their defence or how the
principles of natural justice were violated. In the absence of any such
pleading or material, it is contended that the Petitioners cannot, at a
subsequent stage, question the validity of the findings recorded by the
Inquiry Officer.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
28.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
conduct attributed to the Petitioners amounts to grave misconduct,
including insubordination and disorderly behaviour within the
premises of the Corporation. It is urged that such conduct strikes at the
core of discipline in a public transport undertaking and, once proved,
justifies strict disciplinary action. It is further contended that the
punishment imposed cannot be said to be disproportionate from any
perspective.
29.
Addressing the issue of issuance of a fresh charge sheet, the
learned counsel for the respondents submit that the earlier charge
sheet dated 09.08.2011 was withdrawn on technical grounds, as the
then Depot Manager was himself a party to the incident and therefore
not competent to act as the disciplinary authority. It is contended that
since the findings in the earlier inquiry were not proper, the
disciplinary authority was justified in disagreeing with the same and in
ordering a de novo inquiry by issuing a fresh charge sheet on the same
misconduct, strictly in accordance with the Standing Orders and
settled principles of law.
30.
It is further submitted by the learned counsel for the
respondents that the fresh charge sheet dated 20.12.2012, issued by the
Regional Manager (North), was based on the report dated 20.11.2012
submitted by Shri R.B.L. Srivastava, the then Depot Manager, who
was the victim of the alleged misconduct. The Respondents contend
that the Regional Manager was the competent disciplinary authority
and that the charge sheet was issued after obtaining due approval from
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
the competent authority. Consequently, the orders dated 29.11.2013
passed by the Disciplinary Authority and 01.04.2014 passed by the
Appellate Authority are stated to be lawful and valid.
31.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the mere
fact that the Petitioners were office bearers of a recognised union,
does not grant them any immunity from disciplinary action. It is
contended that no employee, irrespective of designation or position, is
above discipline, and the charges of grave misconduct, once proved,
must attract appropriate consequences.
32.
The learned counsel for the respondents further submit that the
case of the Petitioners cannot be equated with that of Shri Jagphool
Singh, Driver. It is urged that in his case, the disciplinary authority
was the Depot Manager, the reporter was Shri Surender Singh, ATI,
and the punishment was imposed after his retirement. In contrast, the
disciplinary authority in the case of the Petitioners was the Regional
Manager (North), and the reporter was Shri R.B.L. Srivastava himself.
Therefore, the Respondents contend that the plea of discrimination is
misconceived.
33.
It is also submitted by the learned counsel for the respondents
that the delay in submission of the report dated 20.11.2012, does not
vitiate the proceedings. According to the Respondents, once the earlier
charge sheet was withdrawn on technical grounds, it became
necessary to follow the proper procedure by calling for a report from
the competent reporter. The Respondents deny any malafide or
premeditated intent in this regard.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
34.
It is contended that after receipt of the inquiry report, show-
cause notices proposing the penalty of removal from service were
issued to the Petitioners. Their replies were duly considered by the
Disciplinary Authority, which, finding no merit therein, imposed the
penalty of removal from service vide order dated 29.11.2013. The
appeals preferred by the Petitioners were also considered by the
Appellate Authority and were rejected by a reasoned order dated
01.04.2014.
35.
Learned counsel for the respondents emphasises that the
adequacy or sufficiency of evidence cannot be gone into by this Court
in exercise of judicial review. Reliance is placed on the judgment of
the Supreme Court in U.P. Cooperative Federation Ltd. & Ors. v.
L.P. Rai, (2007) 7 SCC 81, to contend that unless specific perversity
or violation of procedure is shown, the findings of the Inquiry Officer
cannot be interfered with.
36.
Reliance is also placed on Kuldeep Singh v. Commissioner of
Police & Ors., (1999) 2 SCC 10, wherein the Supreme Court observed
that while findings based on no evidence would be perverse and
amenable to judicial scrutiny, findings supported by some acceptable
evidence, however scant, cannot be interfered with in judicial review.
37.
Further reliance is placed on V. Ramana v. APSRTC & Ors.,
(2005) 7 SCC 338, to submit that courts should not interfere with
administrative decisions unless they are illogical, suffer from
procedural impropriety, or shock the conscience of the Court. It is
contended that the scope of judicial review is limited to examining
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
deficiencies in the decision-making process and not the correctness of
the decision itself.
38.
It is lastly submitted that the acts alleged against the Petitioners
fall squarely within the ambit of misconduct under Paragraph 19(f),
(g), (h) and (m) of the Standing Orders of the respondent-Corporation,
including disorderly behaviour and acts detrimental to the interests of
the organisation. The relevant clauses of the Standing Order are
reproduced herein below
“f) Habitual breach of any rules, law,
instructions or orders etc. applicable to the
employees of the Authority.
g) Disorderly behavior in the premises of the
Authority.
h) Habitual negligence of duties and lack of
interest in the Authority's work.
XX XX
m) Any other activity not specifically covered
above, but which is prima facie detrimental to
the interests of the organization.”
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
39.
We have considered the submissions advanced on behalf of the
parties.
40.
At the outset, it is necessary to reiterate the well-settled position
that in matters arising out of departmental proceedings, the scope of
judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
limited. The Court does not sit as an appellate authority over the
findings recorded by the disciplinary authority or the Tribunal.
Interference is warranted only where the decision-making process is
shown to be vitiated by perversity, patent illegality, violation of
principles of natural justice, or lack of jurisdiction.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
41.
It is undisputed that the first charge sheet, dated 09.08.2011,
arose from an alleged incident on 06.08.2011. The charges against the
Petitioners were dropped and withdrawn pursuant to the approval of
the Chairman-cum-Managing Director (CMD) of the RespondentCorporation, vide order dated 04.09.2012. Though the same stated that
a fresh charge sheet would be issued in due course of time, however,
the issue is whether the second charge sheet can at all be issued on the
same allegations.
42.
In the present case, the controversy does not merely relate to the
appreciation of evidence or proportionality of punishment, but strikes
at the legality of the very initiation of departmental proceedings by
issuance of a second charge sheet against the petitioners after the
earlier charge sheet had been dropped and withdrawn, may be on
technical infirmities.
43.
The Chairman-cum-Managing Director (CMD) being the
highest
disciplinary authority under the
applicable
statutory
framework had ordered for withdrawal of the Charge Sheet, albeit
further directing for a fresh Charge Sheet to be issued. The order dated
04.09.2012, however, has not been placed on record. Therefore,
sufficient reasons for the said approval of dropping of the proceedings
have not been sufficiently stated. Consequently, the precise reasons
which weighed with the competent authority in withdrawing the
charge sheet have not been disclosed. In the absence of such material,
the respondents’ contention that the earlier proceedings were
withdrawn merely on “technical grounds” cannot be accepted.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
44.
The decision to withdraw the charges was not a tentative or
interlocutory step, but a conscious exercise of disciplinary jurisdiction.
Once such jurisdiction was exercised and the proceedings were
dropped, the disciplinary process in respect of the incident stood
concluded. While a co-delinquent arising from the same incident was
visited with a penalty, the proceedings against the Petitioners were
expressly withdrawn. In the absence of any rule expressly permitting
reopening of concluded disciplinary proceedings on stated grounds
and by the same or a higher authority, the re-initiation of proceedings
against the Petitioners cannot be sustained. No such enabling
provision has been brought to the notice of this Court.
45.
The subsequent issuance of a fresh charge sheet dated
20.12.2012, admittedly on the same incident dated 06.08.2011,
therefore, raises a serious jurisdictional issue. The second charge sheet
was issued by the Regional Manager (North), an authority subordinate
in rank to the Chairman-cum-Managing Director, who had earlier
withdrawn the charges. In the absence of any statutory provision
authorising a subordinate authority to revive or reinitiate disciplinary
proceedings already dropped by the competent authority, the action of
issuing the second charge sheet cannot be sustained. The explanation
offered by the respondents that the earlier charge sheet was withdrawn
on “technical grounds” finds no support in the material placed on
record.
46.
Equally significant is the fact that the second charge sheet is not
a mere reiteration of the first, but contains materially altered and
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
aggravated allegations. It is now based on an alleged complaint of teh
Depot Manager, which complaint is made after almost one year and
three months of the incident. While the first charge sheet alleged
manhandling of the Depot Manager, the second conspicuously omits
the said primary allegation and instead introduces new assertions of
shouting, abuse, intoxication, and forcible removal of staff from the
room. These are not minor variations but go to the root of the alleged
misconduct. The introduction of new and more serious allegations
after withdrawal of the earlier charge sheet, without any
contemporaneous material, lends considerable force to the Petitioners’
plea of arbitrariness and colourable exercise of power.
47.
Such a course strikes at the heart of fair procedure, as findings
of guilt cannot be sustained on the basis of untested and
unsubstantiated material.
48.
The contention of the Petitioners that the earlier report by Shri
Surender Singh, ATI, stood discredited during the first inquiry, where
he categorically denied any manhandling and stated that he was
compelled to submit the report, has not been effectively rebutted by
the respondents. Once the management itself accepted the infirmity in
the earlier report and withdrew the charges, it was incumbent upon the
respondents to demonstrate a legally permissible basis for reopening
the matter. The belated report dated 20.11.2012 does not satisfy this
requirement.
49.
The
record
further
reveals
that
independent
material
contemporaneous to the alleged incident does not support the
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
management’s version. The DD entry No. 23A dated 06.08.2011
records that no scuffle had taken place. Depot and duty records
indicate that the Petitioners completed their duties and were paid in
full. These aspects, though specifically raised by the Petitioners, have
not been meaningfully addressed either by the Inquiry Officer or by
the Disciplinary Authority.
50.
The plea of discrimination raised by the Petitioners also merits
consideration. Sh. Jagphool Singh, against whom allegations arising
from the same incident were levelled, was visited with a minor
penalty, whereas the Petitioners were inflicted with the extreme
penalty of removal from service. The distinction sought to be drawn
by the respondents on the basis of different reporters and disciplinary
authorities does not adequately explain the stark disparity in
punishment, particularly when the substratum of the alleged
misconduct remains the same.
51.
Insofar as the proportionality of punishment is concerned,
removal from service is the severest civil consequence. In the facts of
the present case, where the allegations themselves are clouded by
contradictions, lack of contemporaneous evidence, and procedural
infirmities, the punishment imposed shocks the conscience of this
Court.
52.
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the disciplinary proceedings initiated pursuant to the charge sheet
dated 20.12.2012, the consequent orders dated 29.11.2013 passed by
the Disciplinary Authority, and the Appellate Orders dated 01.04.2014
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
cannot be sustained in law. The order dated 15.07.2015 passed by the
learned Tribunal in O.A. No. 1870/2014 is, therefore, liable to be set
aside.
53.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The Impugned Order
dated 15.07.2015 passed by the learned Tribunal, as well as the charge
sheet dated 20.12.2012, the disciplinary orders dated 29.11.2013, and
the Appellate Orders dated 01.04.2014 are hereby quashed. The
Petitioners shall be entitled to reinstatement, with all notional benefits,
including continuity of service and seniority.
54.
However, given the fact that the petitioners have not performed
their duties in the interregnum, they shall be entitled to only 50% of
the back wages for the period between the date of termination of their
services till their reinstatement or if they have already reached the age
of superannuation, till such date.
55.
There shall be no order as to costs.
MADHU JAIN, J.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
FEBRUARY 6, 2026/P
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 10265/2015
NEGI
17:19:15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review