Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PREM NARAYAN SINGH
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1397 of 2010
BETWEEN:RAMSNEHI S/O CHHABIRAM RATHORE,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: GOVT.SERVANT
R/O. P.S. LINE DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI ANSHUMAN SHRIVSTAVA - ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
GOVT. THRU.P.S.BNP DEWAS
DISTT.DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI RAJESH JOSHI - GOVT ADVOCATE)
Heard on
: 21.12.2023
Pronounced on : 29.01.2024
This criminal appeal having been heard and reserved for judgment, coming on
for pronouncement this day, the court passed the following:
JUDGMENT
This criminal appeal under Section 374 of Cr.P.C. has been filed by the appellant
being aggrieved by the judgment dated 29.10.2010, passed by the learned Sessions
Judge, Dewas, in Sessions Trial No. 11/2010, whereby the appellant has been convicted
for offence under Sections 325, 452, 294, 506 (Part-II) of IPC, 1860, and sentenced to
undergo 02 years, 06 months, 03 months and 03 months R.I with fine of Rs. 5000/-,
Rs.100/-, nil and nil respectively with default stipulations.
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
2. The prosecution case in brief is that on 16.08.2009, at about 9.00 pm
complainant Vikramsingh, constable, Police Station Bank Note Press, Dewas got a phone
call from appellant, who happens to be a constable, enquiring about Constable
Shyambahadur, for which the complainant replied that Shyambahadur is in night patrol.
Thereafter
again complainant received a call from the appellant with regard to
Shyambahadur.
When the complainant was giving necessary information, then the
appellant hurled abuses and later on appellant armed with wooden stick came to the
police station and started assaulting the complainant due to which he sustained injury on
his left hand wrist, left hand finger, shoulder and in hip. Thereafter, the appellant hurled
abuses when the complainant left the police station in rescue, the appellant chased him
with wooden stick till Sai Mandir, however, the complainant fled away from the spot. It
is alleged that the appellant was under liquor intoxication. Subsequently, the complainant
lodged a report under sections 333, 294, 506 (part-II) and 452 of IPC at crime no.
448/2009 against the accused. Then, the investigation into the matter started.
3. In the course of investigation, a spot map of the incident place was prepared,
the injured Vikramsingh was medically examined, the accused was arrested and after
completion of the investigation, a charge sheet was presented before the Court of
Session. After completion of investigation, charges under aforementioned offences were
framed and read over to the accused. On which, the accused denied and claimed to be
tried.
4. In order to bring home the ingredients of the case, the prosecution has
produced as many as 11 witnesses namely Vikram Singh (PW-1), Hemant Kumar Dhabi
(PW-2), Deepak (PW-3), Rajesh Parmar (PW-4), Dr.R. C. Verma (PW-5), Dr. S.S.
Malviya (PW-6), Vishnu Prasad (PW-7), Anil Evan (PW-8), Thakesingh (PW-9),
Ravindra Yadav (PW-10) and Satish Samadiya (PW-11). Kishore Singh (DW-1) was
examined on behalf of defence witness. In Examination of accused under Section 313 of
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
Cr.P.C appellant has also taken the plea of alibi that at the time of the incident he was on
duty at State Bank of India, Moti Bungalow Branch and in this way he has taken the plea
of alibi. Having analyzed the evidence on record, the learned Trial Court convicted the
appellant as aforesaid.
5. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the the appellant is innocent and
the learned trial Court has convicted the appellant wrongly without considering the
evidence available on record. No eye-witness except complainant has supported the
prosecution story. As per the statement of the complainant incident was witnessed by
Deepak Pujari (P.W.3), Rajesh Parmar (P.W.4) however, they have not supported the
prosecution case. So far as the intoxication of the present appellant is concerned, there is
no MLC report available in this regard.
6. It is further submitted that the complainant has also stated that the incident has
been witnessed by two police personals one is Head Constable – Thakesingh (P.W.9)
and other one is Hemant Dabi (P.W.2), however both of them have not supported the
prosecution story. Thakesingh (P.W.9) is an hearsay witness. With regard to injuries
sustained by complainant, the statement of Dr.R.C. Verma (PW-5) is required to be seen
especially para 3, in which it has been deposed that the weapon / instrument by which the
injury was caused has not been produced before him. Doctor has opined that the injury
might have been caused by collusion of vehicle.
7. The counsel has drawn the attention of this Court to paragraph two of the
statement of Dr. S.S. Malviya (PW-6). Counsel further submitted that no CDR with
regard to call details of the incident has been produced before the Court. Counsel for the
appellant has also drawn the attention of the Court to Para 6 of the statement of
Investigating Officer. Learned counsel further submitted that there are material omissions
and contradictions in the statement of the prosecution witnesses. He alternatively
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
confines his arguments on the point of sentence. Counsel for the appellant assures that
the appellant will not involve in such criminal activities in future. He also submitted that
the appellant has suffered approximately thirty days custody period. He is having regard
to all circumstances which resulted in appellant's conviction and further keeping in view
the fact that the appellant was facing trial before the concerned Court for more than 14
years, therefore, he prayed that the appeal be partly allowed and the sentence awarded to
the appellant be reduced to the period already undergone by enhancing the fine amount.
8. On the contrary, learned Govt. Advocate has opposed the prayer. He supported
the judgment by submitting that the case is well fortified by statement of the complainant
as well as the testimony of medical evidence and it is also well supported by FIR, hence
testimony of injured witness cannot be disbelieved, therefore, he prays for dismissal of
the appeal.
9. Heard learned counsel for both the parties and perused the record.
10. In view of the rival submissions, arguments advanced by both the counsels for
the parties and the evidence available on record, the point of consideration is as to
whether the finding of the Trial Court of convicting and sentencing the appellant is
incorrect in the eyes of law and facts?
11. So far as the offence under Section 294/506 of IPC is concerned, it would be
appropriate to consider that Vikram Singh Rathore (P.W.1) himself has stated in his
Examination in Chief that accused has hurled abuses, however, he has not stated anything
as to whether he was annoyed by the abuse. In this regard complainant Vikram Singh
Rathore (P.W.1) has admitted in cross examination regarding obscene abuses of accused
over phone, but nothing has been mentioned regarding annoyance. After going through
the whole testimony, the annoyance has not been emerged. On this aspect the law laid
down by this Court in the case of Dhal Singh v. State of M.P. reported as 1957
MPLJ -21
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
"That in the class of society to which the parties belonged the abuses
had no more significance than mere platitudinous utterances signifying
the enraged state of the persons mind. As the accused were villagers
and filthy abuses were not uncommon among villagers and in the strata
of society to which they belonged, the sting was taken out of the words
and they could not be characterised as obscene within the meaning of
Section 294 of the IPC. Annoyance is the gist of the offence under
Section 294 and in the absence of positive proof of annoyance, there
could be no offence under Section 294, IPC."
12. In view of the above case law, it is envisaged that annoyance is main substance
of the offence punishable u/s 294 IPC. The above proposition has been followed by
Hon'ble High Court of M.P. in Roshanlal v. State of M.P. reported in 1966 MPLJ-87
Note-172 and Kamal Singh v. State of M.P., reported as 2002 (4) MPHT-7.
1 3 . Virtually, in colloquial language such type of abuses are often used and
therefore, they cannot be accepted in their literal sense. In Om Prakash Vs. State of
M.P. reported in 1989 MPLJ 657, it has been held by Hon'ble High Court that no literal
significance can be attached to the abuses. They only delineate the enraged state of mind.
Further, in Sharad Dave and another Vs. Mahesh Gupta and others, reported in
2005 LawSuit (MP) 442, Hon'ble High Court of M.P. endorsing the aforesaid ratio
decidendi adumbrated as under:-
"Mere platitudinous utterances signifying the enraged state of the
person's mind would not be sufficient to attract the application of
the provisions of section 294, of the Indian Penal Code. Thus
mere 'vulgar abuses' do not constitute offence under section 294
of the Indian Penal Code."
14. In light of the aforesaid propositions, in the case at hand, since no prosecution
witness deposed any thing about causing annoyance before the Court, the prosecution,
therefore, has failed to prove that accused committed obscene act by abusing
complainant, which annoyed others. In the upshot, accused persons deserve to be
acquitted from the charge of the offence u/s 294 of IPC.
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
15. Now coming to the point of criminal intimidation, in order to bring home the
evidence of criminal intimidation to cause death punishable under Section 506(Part-II) of
IPC, the prosecution is required to prove that the accused threatened the victim to cause
his death or grievous hurt to a person or another in whom, he is specially interested. On
this aspect after considering the definition of criminal intimidation under Section 506 of
IPC, Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Manik Taneja and another Vs. State of
Karnatka and another reported as 2015 LawSuit (SC)52 ordained as under:
"14. A reading of the definition of "Criminal intimidation" would
indicate that there must be an act of threatening to another
person, of causing an injury to the person, reputation, or property
of the person threatened, or to the person in whom the threatened
person is interested and the threat must be with the intent to
cause alarm to the person threatened or it must be to do any act
which he is not legally bound to do or omit to do an act which he
is legally entitled to do."
1 6 In view of the aforesaid propositions, the threatening is most important
ingredient of criminal intimidation. If the threat be to cause death or grievous hurt, the
offence would be punishable under Section 506 (Part-II) of I.P.C, however in the whole
testimony of complainant Vikram Singh Rathore, nothing has been mentioned regarding
threatening anywhere.
Vikram Singh Rathore (P.W-1) has stated that he has been
threatened by the conduct of accused, however, it is also not mentioned in Roznamcha
Sana and other documents. Other witnesses have also not adverted anything in this
regard. As such since threatening or causing fear has not been revealed by the
prosecution witnesses, hence the offence punishable under Section 506 (Part-II) is not
proved and therefore, appellant deserves to be acquitted from the charge of offence
under Section 506 (Part-II) of IPC. In this sequence the findings of learned trial Court
regarding conviction under Section 294 and 506 (Part-II) is liable to be and is hereby set
aside.
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
17. Further turning to the issue of house trespass as well as causing grievous
injury in order to fortify this aspect prosecution has succeeded in proving its case
beyond reasonable doubt that appellant has committed trespass by entering in the Police
Station with the intention of cause injury to the complainant and thereafter caused
grievous injury by using stick. As such the findings of learned trial Court regarding
conviction of accused under Section 325, 326 and 452 of IPC is found flawless and
immaculate in the eyes of law and fact.
1 8 . In order to fortify this aspect, Vikram Singh Rathore - Head Constable
(502)/Complainant (P.W.1) has deposed that on 16.08.2009 at 10.30 pm
accused
Ramsnehi called him on telephone he has asked as to where Shyambahadur resides and
what is his mobile number. In reply, this witness stated that he is not remembering the
mobile number and Shyambahadur resides in quarters situated behind kothwali. After
that Constable Ramsnehi came in person and started hurling abuses. At 10.30 pm when
complainant started having his dinner, Constable Ramsnehi assaulted on his head with
lathi initially, he rescued himself by backing from the place, further he again assaulted and
caused injury on his hand.
Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that had the
incident happened the complainant would have informed to his senior officers, however,
the statement of complainant found support from Hemant Kumar Dabi Constable 329
(P.W.2), who has clearly stated that he had heard obnoxious sounds.
19. In this consequence, Hemant Kumar Dabi Constable 329 (P.W.2) has also
stated that he has seen complainant Vikram Singh (P.W.1) whose hand was injured and
blood was oozing. Further he also articulated that after asking about the incident Vikram
Singh has adverted that accused Ramsnehi has abused and beaten him. The statement of
this witness has also not been rebutted in cross examination. Certainly, other witnesses
Deepak (P.W.3), Rajesh Parmar (P.W.4) have not supported the prosecution case, but
the testimony of complainant also finds support from the statement of Dr. R.C. Verma
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
(P.W5) the medical witness who has opined in his Examination in Chief regarding four
injuries:
1.Lacerated wound - 3.5 x 0.5x 0.5 cms on the front side of left hand.
2. Swelling of 3.8 x 1.0 cm in the little finger of the left hand.
3. Swelling of 5.5 x 3.8 cm in the right upper thigh.
4. Swelling of 3.5 x 1.8 cm in the left cheek.
20. In cross examination the doctor has been challenged on many points but he
has clearly stated that such type of injuries cannot be caused in one accident. That apart
Dr. S. S. Malviya (P.W.6) has also supported the prosecution case and stated that he has
conducted X-ray examination on the left hand of the complainant and found fracture
thereon as per X-ray report (Ex.P/7). Vishnu Prasad (P.W7) has also supported the
prosecution case and stated that on 16.08.2009 his duty was on Cheeta Patrolling Squad
and he has obtained wireless message from the B.N.P. Dewas Police Station and he was
informed that complainant Vikram Singh had received injuries. In para-3 of his
Examination in Chief he has also stated about the fact that Ramsnehi, the accused was
intoxicated by taking liquor. Anil Evane (P.W.8) is the witness of investigation and he
has arrested the appellant and seized wooden stick from him. The statement of this
witness has not been rebutted in his cross-examination. Thake Singh Dholiya (P.W.9)
has also supported the prosecution case although on some point he has been declared
hostile. Ravindra Yadav -Sub Inspector (P.W.10) and Satish Samadiay (P.W.11), the
witnesses of investigation have also supported the prosecution case.
21. Learned counsel for the appellant has vehemently demonstrated that even when
the police witness have not supported the prosecution case, how the person who is also
the police constable can be convicted only on the basis of complainant's testimony. In
reply learned Govt. Advocate submitted that since the complainant is an injured person,
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
his testimony has greater weight and when the complainant's testimony is supported by
medical report of doctor the same must be relied upon.
22. In this case the defence witness Kishore Singh -Constable No.223 (D.W.1) has
also been examined and he has stated that at the time of the incident Ramsnehi was on
duty with him but in cross examination he graphically conceded that after 8.00 pm on
6.08.2009 he had no knowledge regarding the incident. As such the testimony of defence
witness is also of no use.
23.
It is pertinent to mention that being an injured witness the testimony of
Vikramsingh (P.W.1) has special status in the eyes of law.
On this aspect
Chandrashekar Vs. State of Tamilnadu reported in (2017) 13 SCC 585], endorsing
another case of the Supreme Court, viewed as under :10. Criminal jurisprudence attaches great weightage to the evidence of a
person injured in the same occurrence as it presumes that he was
speaking the truth unless shown otherwise. Though the law is well
settled and precedents abound, reference may usefully be made to
Brahm Swaroop v. State of U.P., (2011) 6 SCC 288 observing as
follows:
"28. Where a witness to the occurrence has himself been injured in
the incident, the testimony of such a witness is generally considered
to be very reliable, as he is a witness that comes with an in-built
guarantee of his presence at the scene of the crime and is unlikely to
spare his actual assailant(s) in order to falsely implicate someone."
24. In the light of the aforesaid principle the testimony of injured Vikram Singh
(P.W.1) has its immanent value because it finds support from the testimony of Dr. A.S.
Malviya (P.W6) and Dr. R.C. Verma (P.W.5).
That apart the testimony of this
complainant is also backed by Hemant Kumar Dhabi - Constable 329 (P.W.2) and
Rajesh Parmar (P.W.4) and other police witnesses on same aspects.
25. As per section 134 of Evidence Act, no particular number of witnesses shall in
any case be required for the proof of any fact. On this aspect the law laid down by
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case
of Vithal Pundalik Zendge Vs. State of
Maharashtra reported, AIR 2009 SC 1110 is worth referring to the context of the case.
Relevant para 6 and 7 of the said judgment is reproduced below:6. On a consideration of the relevant authorities and the provisions
o f the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (in short the 'Evidence Act') the
following propositions may be safely stated as firmly established: (i)
As a general rule, a court can and may act on the testimony of a
s ingle witness though uncorroborated. One credible witness
outweighs the testimony of a number of other witnesses of
indifferent character.
(ii) Unless corroboration is insisted upon by statute, courts should
not insist on corroboration except in cases where the nature of the
testimony of the single witness itself requires as a rule of prudence,
that corroboration should be insisted upon, for example in the case
of a child witness, or of a witness whose evidence is that of an
accomplice or of an analogous character.
(iii) Whether corroboration of the testimony of a single witness is or
is not necessary, must depend upon facts and circumstances of each
case and no general rule can be laid down in a matter like this and
much depends upon the judicial discretion of the Judge before
whom the case comes.
7. Therefore, there is no hesitation in holding that the contention that
in a murder case the court should insist upon plurality of witnesses,
is much too broadly stated."
2 6 . So far as the arguments regarding non supporting of other independent
witnesses it is well settled that no criminal case can be overboarded due to non
availability of independent prosecution witnesses. In this regard, the following verdict of
landmark judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court rendered in the case of Appa Bhai vs.
State of Gujarat, reported as AIR 1988 SC 696 is worth referring here as under:
"10.......Experience reminds us that civilized people are generally
insensitive when a crime is committed even in their presence. They
withdraw both from the victim and the vigilante. They keep
themselves away from the Court unless it is inevitable. They think
that
crime like civil dispute is between two individuals or parties and they
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
should not involve themselves. This kind of apathy of the general
public is indeed unfortunate, but it is there everywhere whether in
village life, towns or cities. One cannot ignore this handicap with
which the investigating agency has to discharge its duties. The court,
therefore, instead of doubting the prosecution case for want of
independent witness must consider the broad spectrum of the
prosecution version and then search for the nugget of truth with due
regard to probability if any, suggested by the accused......"
27. In the case of Mohd. Naushad Vs. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), reported
in 2023 LawSuit (SC) 659, the Full Bench of Hon’ble the Apex Court, considering the
kind of apathy adopted by the general public in not coming forward to depose to
associate with the prosecution, endorsed the aforesaid verdict. As such, only on the
basis of non-examination of any independent witness, the prosecution case cannot be
thrown out, specially when the testimony of witnesses inspires confidence.
28. At this juncture, the attention of this Court drawn by learned counsel of
accused towards the opinion of Hon'ble Apex Court in Subhash Harnarayanji Laddha
v. State of Maharashtra reported in (2006) 12 SCC 545, wherein it was held that
"Suspicion, howsoever grave may be is no substitute for proof." It is further contended
that in lack of any independent eye witness, the accused can not be convicted on basis of
fictitious story.
29. On this point, this Court intends to rely on State of Rajasthan v. N.K.,The
accused reported in (2000) 5 SCC 30, wherein, Hon'ble R.C. Lahoti J. on behalf of the
Full Bench viewed as under :"....It is true that the golden thread which runs throughout the cobweb of criminal jurisprudence as administered in India is that nine
guilty may escape but one innocent should not suffer. But at the
same time no guilty should escape unpunished once the guilt has
been proved to hilt. An unmerited acquittal does no good to the
society. If the prosecution has succeeded in making out a convincing
case for recording a finding as to the accused being guilty, the Court
should not lean in favour of acquittal by giving weight to irrelevant or
insignificant circumstances or by resorting to echnicalities or by
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
assuming doubts and giving benefit thereof where none exists..."
30. Regarding the plea of alibi taken by the appellant that at the time of the incident,
he was on duty at State Bank of India, Moti Bungalow Branch, it may be possible that
after the alleged incident the appellant would have gone to that place. It is by now well
settled that if a plea of alibi has been taken by accused that must be proved by accused
himself and if he fails it will be taken as another incriminating circumstances in favour of
prosecution case. On this aspect the law laid down by Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of
Mukesh and Another vs. State (NCT of Delhi) and Ors. reported as (2017)6 SCC 1 is
relevant to be considered which as under:"While weighing the plea of ‘alibi’, the same has to be weighed against
the positive evidence led by the prosecution, i. e. , n o t o n ly the
substantive evidence of PW-1 and the dying declarations, Ex.PW-27/A
and Ex.PW-30/D-1, but also against the scientific evidence, viz., the
DNA analysis, finger print analysis and bite marks analysis, the
ac c urac y of which i s scientifically acclaimed. Considering the
inconsistent and contradictory nature of the evidence of ‘alibi’ led by
the accused against the positive evidence of the prosecution, including
the scientific one, we hold that the accused have miserably failed to
discharge their burden of absolute certainty qua their plea o f ‘alibi’.
The plea taken b y them appears to be an afterthought and rather may
be read as an additional circumstance against them."
31. In view of the aforesaid discussions and analysis of the evidence it can be
safely concluded that prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that appellant
has committed house tress pass with preparation for causing hurt to injured/complainant
and in this sequence he has voluntarily caused grievous hurt to the complainant. As such
the findings of learned trial Court regarding conviction of appellant under Section 452 &
325 of IPC is immaculate and infallible in the eyes of law.
32. Now turning to the sentencing part of the case, learned counsel for the
appellant placing reliance on the judgment of Naib Singh Vs. State of Punjab reported
in (1986) 4 SCC 401, Manohar Das Vs State of Madhya Pradesh and other
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
reported as (2007) 2 MPWN 60 has submitted that the appellant has already suffered
approximately 30 days of jail sentence and deposited the fine amount, hence the
punishment of imprisonment may be reduced to the period already undergone by
enhancing the fine amount. It is also contended that the appellant has lost his job on
account of this case. On this aspect, the view of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Jaswinder Singh (dead) through legal representative Vs. Navjot Singh and others
reported in AIR 2022 SC 2481 Para No. 26, 27 and 28 are reproduced below :
"26. An important aspect to be kept in mind is that any undue
sympathy to impose inadequate sentence would do more harm to
justice system and undermine the public confidence in the efficacy of
law. The society can not long endure under serious threats and if the
courts do not protect the injured, the injured would then resort to
private vengeance and, therefore, it is the duty of every court to
award proper sentence having regard to the nature of the offence and
the manner in which it was executed or committed. It has, thus, been
observed that the punishment to be awarded for a crime must not be
irrelevant but it should conform to and be consistent with the atrocity
and brutality with which the crime has been perpetrated.
27. A three Judges Bench of this Court in the State of Karnataka v.
Krishnappa 12 while discussing the purpose of imposition of
adequate sentence opined in para 18 that “.....Protection of society
and deterring the criminal is the avowed object of law and that is
required to be achieved by imposing an appropriate sentence.”
Sumer Singh v. Surajbhan Singh (2014) 7 SCC 323.
28. The sentencing philosophy for an offence has a social goal that
the sentence has to be based on the principle that the accused must
realise that the crime committed by him has not only created a dent
in his life but also a concavity in the social fabric. While opportunity
to reform has to be kept in mind, the principle of proportionality also
has to be equally kept in mind."
33. Hence, I am not inclined to let off the appellant with period already undergone.
This is a case, where a police constable has assaulted another head constable who had
sustained grievous injuries. Owing to that injury caused by appellant, the injured had
suffered a grave pain threatening his life. In such circumstances, the accused may not be
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
offered for any leniency or sympathy. However, the fact, that the appellant has suffered
ordeal of this case since 2009 i.e. approximately 14 years, is to be considered as
mitigating circumstance.
3 4 . Looking to the factual matrix of the case and considering the aforesaid
mitigating circumstance, the sentence of two years rigorous imprisonment under Section
325 of IPC seems to be on the higher side and the same is required to be rectified.
3 5 . Having contemplated all circumstances of the case, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the sentenced for the offence under Section 325 of I.P.C. be
reduced to 6 months by enhancing the fine amount of Rs.10,000/- and in default, he will
suffer 3 months and the period which he has already suffered be adjusted. Insofar as, the
sentence awarded under Section 452 of IPC is concerned, is hereby affirmed.
36. In view of the aforesaid terms, the present appeal is partly allowed and
disposed off.
37. A copy of this judgment alongwith the record be sent to the learned trial Court
for information and necessary compliance.
38. The appellant is directed to surrender before the learned trial court within 15
days from the pronouncement of this judgment. If he fails to surrender before the learned
Trial Court, the Trial Court will proceed to comply with order and send the appellant in
jail for suffering the remaining jail sentence, as aforesaid.
39. The order of learned trial Court regarding disposal of the seized property
stands confirmed.
Certified copy as per rules.
(PREM NARAYAN SINGH)
JUDGE
sumathi
Signed by: SUMATHI
Signing time: 30-012024 11:32:03
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review