Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~14 to 20
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 16.02.2026
+
W.P.(C) 17810/2025, CM APPL. 73570/2025
(14) LALJI
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashok Kumar Sabharwal,
Mr. Shobhit Sabharwal, Advs.
versus
M/S GANESH INDUSTRIES
.....Respondent
Through:
+
W.P.(C) 17915/2025, CM APPL. 74110/2025
(15) RADHESHYAM GOND
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashok Kumar Sabharwal,
Mr. Shobhit Sabharwal, Advs.
versus
M/S GANESH INDUSTRIES
....Respondent
Through:
+
W.P.(C) 17916/2025, CM APPL. 74112/2025
(16) RAM VRIKSH
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashok Kumar Sabharwal,
Mr. Shobhit Sabharwal, Advs.
versus
M/S GANESH INDUSTRIES
.....Respondent
Through:
+
W.P.(C) 17918/2025, CM APPL. 74114/2025
(17) MAAN SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashok Kumar Sabharwal,
Mr. Shobhit Sabharwal, Advs.
versus
M/S GANESH INDUSTRIES
.....Respondent
Through:
+
W.P.(C) 17924/2025, CM APPL. 74125/2025
(18) MADHUBAN
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashok Kumar Sabharwal,
Mr. Shobhit Sabharwal, Advs.
versus
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
M/S GANESH INDUSTRIES
.....Respondent
Through:
+
W.P.(C) 17927/2025, CM APPL. 74132/2025
(19) DAYARAM GAUR
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashok Kumar Sabharwal,
Mr. Shobhit Sabharwal, Advs.
versus
M/S GANESH INDUSTRIES
.....Respondent
Through:
+
W.P.(C) 17933/2025, CM APPL. 74150/2025
(20) RAMESH
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashok Kumar Sabharwal,
Mr. Shobhit Sabharwal, Advs.
versus
M/S GANESH INDUSTRIES
.....Respondent
Through:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN DATTA
SACHIN DATTA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The present petitions assail the awards rendered by the Presiding
Officer, Labour Court, Rouse Avenue Courts, New Delhi, in L.I.R Nos.
8371/16; 8372/16; 295/17; 8370/16; 8369/16; 8375/16 and 8367/16,
whereby, the claims of the petitioners for reinstatement and back wages
were rejected in identical conspectus.
2.
Although the factual conspectus is identical across the matters, for the
sake of convenience, W.P. (C) 17810/2025 is taken as the lead matter for the
purpose of reference to the factual conspectus and relevant documents, inter
alia, the impugned award.
3.
The factual background as set out by the petitioner is that the
petitioner was employed as a ‘karigar’ with the respondent for
approximately 10 years. It is submitted that despite the petitioner’s repeated
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
demands for statutory benefits, the respondent failed to extend the same. On
01.11.2015, the petitioner’s services were terminated without notice,
payment of salary arrears for the preceding 2 months, notice pay,
retrenchment compensation or other legal dues. Consequently, the petitioner
filed a complaint before the Labour Commissioner, Nimri Colony, Ashok
Vihar, Delhi. Thereafter, the petitioner served a demand notice dated
13.11.2015 upon the respondent, which elicited no response. The Labour
Commissioner referred the matter to the concerned Labour Court.
4.
Before
the
Labour
Court,
the
petitioner/workman
sought
reinstatement, continuity of service, full back wages (including earned
wages) and consequential benefits with interest. The respondent, before the
Labour Court, categorically denied that the petitioner/workman was ever
employed with the respondent.
5.
In the above background, the Labour Court framed the points that
arose for consideration as under:
“5. From the pleadings of the parties, vide order dated 21.03.2018 the
following issues were framed by the Ld. Predecessor of this Court:1. Whether the dispute between the workman and
management is an Industrial dispute? OPM.
2. Whether the management had terminated the service of
workman? OPW.
3. As per reference “Whether the services of the workman
Sh. Lalji S/o Sh. Govind aged 37 years have been
terminated illegally and unjustifiable by the management;
if so, to what relief is he entitled and what directions are
necessary in this respect? OPW.
4. Relief”
6.
The Court examined the rival contentions of the parties in
considerable detail and rendered a categorical finding that the petitioner
failed to establish his employment with the respondent. In view of thereof,
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
the Labour court observed that in absence of proof of employer-employee
relationship, the question of illegal termination of the petitioner did not
arise. Consequently, the claims for reinstatement and back wages were
dismissed. In this regard, the relevant extracts of the impugned award are
extracted as under:
“The initial complaint before Assistant Labour Commissioner Ex.
WW1/6 as well as complaint to SHO, PS Sultanpuri Ex.WW1/8 was filed
against the management by workman along with 10 other workmen. On
the other hand the management has taken a categorical stand since the
inception of the proceeding in its reply to the Labour Inspector dated
18.11.2015 and has maintained in its pleadings before this Court as well
as deposed in evidence by way of affidavit that no other employee except
three permanent employees have been working for it and that the
workman had never worked for the management. Despite specific
testimony of MW1 in this regard, he was not cross- examined on the said
point. Not even a suggestion was given to him to deny the same. It is well
settled law that if the opposite party fails to cross-examine a witness on a
certain point, then the said party is deemed to have accepted the same as
true. In this regard, the Apex Court in case titled as Sarwan Singh Vs.
State of Punjab, AIR 2002 SC 3652, held as under:"It is a rule of essential justice that whenever opponent has declined
to avail himself of the opportunity to put his case in crossexamination, it must follow that evidence tendered on that issue
ought to be accepted."
Therefore, the deposition of MW-1 on this aspect that only three
employees were working with the management ought to be accepted on
this ground alone. In the present case, not only the workman failed to
cross-examine MW1 on the aforesaid point or to put any suggestion
denying the same, he also failed to depose as to the number of workmen
employed with the management or the identity of such workmen. If the
workman was working with the management for ten long years as stated
by him, he would definitely have knowledge regarding the number of
employees or the identity of the employees working for the management.
The silence of the workman on this aspect goes against him. Since
testimony of MW1 regarding having only 3 workmen working in the
establishment has remained uncontroverted, it raises serious doubts over
the claims of the 11 workmen (vide Ex. WW1/6), including the workman
herein.
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
Further, the workman has also failed to examine any independent witness
or co-worker employed by the management to substantiate his claim. The
testimony of independent witness or co-worker would have given credence
to the claim of the workman, but he failed to examine any such witness. No
reason was assigned by the workman as to why he did not examine any
other witness like co-worker, neighbourer of the management or the
customer of the management. It is difficult to believe that no one had seen
the workman working for the management despite his claim of having
worked for 10 long years with the management. Therefore, an adverse
inference is drawn against the workman on this aspect also.
In support of his contention that he was employee of the management, the
workman has produced and relied on two slips Ex.WW1/2(Colly) which
are stated to be attendance card. The same were put to MW1 during his
cross-examination and he categorically stated that same were not issued
by the management. A bare perusal of these so called attendance card
reveals that the neither name of the management who issued these cards is
mentioned nor any signature or seal is affixed on these cards. Therefore, it
can not be made out who, if anyone at all, has issued these cards. Not only
that, the period to which these cards might pertain is also not mentioned.
There is nothing on these cards to connect them to the management. The
MW1 was given suggestion during his cross examination that one Mukesh
or foreman used to mark attendance on the card, however, he
categorically denied the same. Neither Mukesh or the person alleged to
have made entries in the card was examined by the workman, nor
admitted handwriting of any such person was produced before the court
for comparison. As such, workman has failed to prove that Ex. WW1/2
was issued by the management and the same is of no help to the claim of
the workman.
Thus, in light of above discussion, it follows that there is no evidence
produced by the workman to prove that he was employee of the
management, except his bald oral testimony, which has been controverted
by the management by oral testimony of MW1, who denied that the
workman was employee of the management and he remained firm during
cross-examination. There is no reason to disbelieve the oral testimony of
MW1 and believe the oral testimony of workman. No reason was assigned
by the workman, as to why the Court should believe his oral testimony and
disbelieve the oral testimony of MW1. Since, the initial burden of proving
employee- employer relationship was upon the workman, in light of above
discussions, I hold that the workman has failed to discharge the said
burden.
Since, the workman has failed to prove that he was the employee of the
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
management, the question of his illegal termination by the management
does not arise. Accordingly, issues no.2 & 3 are also decided in favour of
the management and against the workman.
19. Relief:
In view of discussion above, I hold that the Workman is not entitled to the
relief claimed by him in his Statement of Claim and accordingly, his
Statement of Claim is dismissed. Reference stands answered in aforesaid
terms. Requisite number of copies of this award be sent to the competent
authority for necessary compliance. File be consigned to the Record
Room.”
7.
The impugned award categorically records that the workman, despite
claiming to be employed with the respondent for about a decade, failed to
furnish any particulars regarding the number of employees of the respondent
or even their identities. In this regard, the Labour Court observed as under:
“In the present case, not only the workman failed to cross-examine MW1
on the aforesaid point or to put any suggestion denying the same, he also
failed to depose as to the number of workmen employed with the
management or the identity of such workmen. If the workman was working
with the management for ten long years as stated by him, he would
definitely have knowledge regarding the number of employees or the
identity of the employees working for the management. The silence of the
workman on this aspect goes against him.”
8.
Further, the stand of the respondent/ management that it had only
three permanent employees and the petitioner/ workman never worked for
the respondent was accepted by the Labour Court, noting that the testimony
of the concerned witness (MW‑1) on this point remained uncontroverted.
The relevant portion of the impugned award reads as under:
“On the other hand the management has taken a categorical stand since the
inception of the proceeding in its reply to the Labour Inspector dated
18.11.2015 and has maintained in its pleadings before this Court as well as
deposed in evidence by way of affidavit that no other employee except three
permanent employees have been working for it and that the workman had
never worked for the management. Despite specific testimony of MW1 in
this regard, he was not cross- examined on the said point. Not even a
suggestion was given to him to deny the same. It is well settled law that if
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
the opposite party fails to cross-examine a witness on a certain point, then
the said party is deemed to have accepted the same as true. In this regard,
the Apex Court in case titled as Sarwan Singh Vs. State of Punjab, AIR 2002
SC 3652, held as under:"It is a rule of essential justice that whenever opponent has
declined to avail himself of the opportunity to put his case in
cross-examination, it must follow that evidence tendered on
that issue ought to be accepted."
Therefore, the deposition of MW-1 on this aspect that only three employees
were working with the management ought to be accepted on this ground
alone...... Since testimony of MW1 regarding having only 3 workmen
working in the establishment has remained uncontroverted, it raises serious
doubts over the claims of the 11 workmen (vide Ex. WW1/6), including the
workman herein.”
9.
The labour Court also found the documentary evidence relied upon by
the workman to be unreliable. The alleged attendance cards (Ex.WW1/2)
were held to be devoid of any evidentiary value whatsoever, and incapable
of establishing any nexus with the respondent. The relevant extract of the
impugned award in this regard is as under:
“In support of his contention that he was employee of the management,
the workman has produced and relied on two slips Ex.WW1/2(Colly)
which are stated to be attendance card. The same were put to MW1
during his cross-examination and he categorically stated that same were
not issued by the management. A bare perusal of these so called
attendance card reveals that the neither name of the management who
issued these cards is mentioned nor any signature or seal is affixed on
these cards. Therefore, it can not be made out who, if anyone at all, has
issued these cards. Not only that, the period to which these cards might
pertain is also not mentioned. There is nothing on these cards to connect
them to the management..... As such, workman has failed to prove that
Ex. WW1/2 was issued by the management and the same is of no help to
the claim of the workman.”
10.
A perusal of the impugned award leaves no manner of doubt that the
Labour Court, upon a detailed appraisal of the evidence adduced by both the
parties and a thorough examination of the relevant facts and circumstances,
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
held that the workman/ petitioner failed to establish employer- employee
relationship. The findings rest on a reasoned evaluation of the record. This
Court finds that no ground is made out to warrant interference with the
same.
11.
The petitioner has essentially sought to re-agitate the same issue/s
which have already been dealt with by the impugned award. It is well settled
that in writ jurisdiction, this Court does not undertake re-appraisal of
evidence or interfere with factual findings unless they are perverse or
contrary to law. This Court finds no patent illegality in the impugned award
so as to justify interference therewith. In Syed Yakoob v. K.S.
Radhakrishnan, 1963 SCC OnLine SC 24, it has been held as under:
“7. The question about the limits of the jurisdiction of High Courts in
issuing a writ of certiorari under Article 226 has been frequently
considered by this Court and the true legal position in that behalf is no
longer in doubt. A writ of certiorari can be issued for correcting errors of
jurisdiction committed by inferior courts or tribunals : these are cases
where orders are passed by inferior courts or tribunals without
jurisdiction, or is in excess of it, or as a result of failure to exercise
jurisdiction. A writ can similarly be issued where in exercise of
jurisdiction conferred on it, the Court or Tribunal acts illegally or
properly, as for instance, it decides a question without giving an
opportunity, be heard to the party affected by the order, or where the
procedure adopted in dealing with the dispute is opposed to principles of
natural justice. There is, however, no doubt that the jurisdiction to issue a
writ of certiorari is a supervisory jurisdiction and the Court exercising it
is not entitled to act as an appellate Court. This limitation necessarily
means that findings of fact reached by the inferior Court or Tribunal as
result of the appreciation of evidence cannot be reopened or questioned in
writ proceedings. An error of law which is apparent on the face of the
record can be corrected by a writ, but not an error of fact, however grave
it may appear to be. In regard to a finding of fact recorded by the
Tribunal, a writ of certiorari can be issued if it is shown that in recording
the said finding, the Tribunal had erroneously refused to admit admissible
and material evidence, or had erroneously admitted inadmissible evidence
which has influenced the impugned finding. Similarly, if a finding of fact is
based on no evidence, that would be regarded as an error of law which
can be corrected by a writ of certiorari. In dealing with this category of
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
cases, however, we must always bear in mind that a finding of fact
recorded by the Tribunal cannot be challenged in proceedings for a writ
of certiorari on the ground that the relevant and material evidence
adduced before the Tribunal was insufficient or inadequate to sustain the
impugned finding. The adequacy or sufficiency of evidence led on a point
and the inference of fact to be drawn from the said finding are within the
exclusive jurisdiction of the Tribunal, and the said points cannot be
agitated before a writ Court. It is within these limits that the jurisdiction
conferred on the High Courts under Article 226 to issue a writ of
certiorari can be legitimately exercised (vide Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Syed
Ahmad
Ishaque [(1955)
SCR
1104] Nagandra
Nath
Bora v. Commissioner of Hills Division and Appeals Assam [(1958) SCR
1240] and Kaushalya Devi v. Bachittar Singh [AIR 1960 SC 1168]
8. It is, of course, not easy to define or adequately describe what an error
of law apparent on the face of the record means. What can be corrected by
a writ has to be an error of law; hut it must be such an error of law as can
be regarded as one which is apparent on the face of the record. Where it is
manifest or clear that the conclusion of law recorded by an inferior Court
or Tribunal is based on an obvious mis-interpretation of the relevant
statutory provision, or sometimes in ignorance of it, or may be, even in
disregard of it, or is expressly founded on reasons which are wrong in
law, the said conclusion can be corrected by a writ of certiorari. In all
these cases, the impugned conclusion should be so plainly inconsistent
with the relevant statutory provision that no difficulty is experienced by
the High Court in holding that the said error of law is apparent on the
face of the record. It may also be that in some cases, the impugned error
of law may not be obvious or patent on the face of the record as such and
the Court may need an argument to discover the said error; but there can
be no doubt that what can be corrected by a writ of certiorari is an error
of law and the said error must, on the whole, be of such a character as
would satisfy the test that it is an error of law apparent on the face of the
record......”
12.
In Pepsico India Holding (P) Ltd. v. Krishna Kant Pandey, (2015) 4
SCC 270, the Supreme Court observed as under:
“14. While discussing the power of the High Court under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution interfering with the facts recorded by the courts or
the tribunal, this Court in Chandavarkar Sita Ratna Rao v. Ashalata S.
Guram [(1986) 4 SCC 447] , held as under : (SCC pp. 458-59, para 17)
“17. In case of finding of facts, the Court should not interfere in
exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution.
Reference may be made to the observations of this Court
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
in Bathutmal Raichand Oswal v. Laxmibai R. Tarta [(1975) 1 SCC
858 : AIR 1975 SC 1297] where this Court observed that the High
Court could not in the guise of exercising its jurisdiction under
Article 227 convert itself into a court of appeal when the legislature
has not conferred a right of appeal. The High Court was not
competent to correct errors of facts by examining the evidence and
reappreciating. Speaking for the Court, Bhagwati, J. as the learned
Chief Justice then was, observed at AIR p. 1301 of the Report as
follows : (SCC p. 864, para 7)
‘7. The special civil application preferred by the appellant was
admittedly an application under Article 227 and it is, therefore,
material only to consider the scope and ambit of the jurisdiction
of the High Court under that article. Did the High Court have
jurisdiction in an application under Article 227 to disturb the
findings of fact reached by the District Court? It is well settled
by
the
decision
of
this
Court
in Waryam
Singh v. Amarnath [(1954) 1 SCC 51 : AIR 1954 SC 215] (AIR
p. 217, para 14) that the
“power of superintendence conferred by Article 227 is, as
pointed out by Harries, C.J., in Dalmia Jain Airways
Ltd. v. Sukumar Mukherjee [AIR 1951 Cal 193] , to be
exercised most sparingly and only in appropriate cases in
order to keep the subordinate courts within the bounds of
their authority and not for correcting mere errors”.
This statement of law was quoted with approval in the
subsequent decision of this Court in Nagendra Nath
Bora v. Commr. of Hills Division [AIR 1958 SC 398] and it was
pointed out by Sinha, J., as he then was, speaking on behalf of
the Court in that case : (AIR p. 413, para 30)
“30. … It is, thus, clear that the powers of judicial
interference under Article 227 of the Constitution with orders
of judicial or quasi-judicial nature, are not greater than the
power under Article 226 of the Constitution. Under Article
226, the power of interference may extend to quashing an
impugned order on the ground of a mistake apparent on the
face of the record. But under Article 227 of the Constitution,
the power of interference is limited to seeing that the tribunal
functions within the limits of its authority.”’”
XXX
XXX
XXX
16. In Indian Overseas Bank v. Staff Canteen Workers' Union [(2000)
4 SCC 245 : 2000 SCC (L&S) 471] , this Court considered a similar
question with regard to the power of the High Court under Article 226
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
against the findings recorded by the Industrial Tribunal. Reversing the
decision of the Single Judge and restoring the fact-finding decision of
the Tribunal, this Court held : (SCC pp. 259-60, para 17)
“17. The learned Single Judge seems to have undertaken an
exercise, impermissible for him in exercising writ jurisdiction, by
liberally reappreciating the evidence and drawing conclusions of
his own on pure questions of fact, unmindful, though aware fully,
that he is not exercising any appellate jurisdiction over the
awards passed by a tribunal, presided over by a judicial officer.
The findings of fact recorded by a fact-finding authority duly
constituted for the purpose and which ordinarily should be
considered to have become final, cannot be disturbed for the
mere reason of having been based on materials or evidence not
sufficient or credible in the opinion of the writ court to warrant
those findings, at any rate, as long as they are based upon some
material which are relevant for the purpose or even on the
ground that there is yet another view which can reasonably and
possibly be taken. The Division Bench was not only justified but
well merited in its criticism of the order of the learned Single
Judge and in ordering restoration of the award of the Tribunal.
On being taken through the findings of the Industrial Tribunal as
well as the order of the learned Single Judge and the judgment of
the Division Bench, we are of the view that the Industrial
Tribunal had overwhelming materials which constituted ample
and sufficient basis for recording its findings, as it did, and the
manner of consideration undertaken, the objectivity of approach
adopted and reasonableness of findings recorded seem to be
unexceptionable. The only course, therefore, open to the writ
Judge was to find out the satisfaction or otherwise of the relevant
criteria laid down by this Court, before sustaining the claim of
the canteen workmen, on the facts found and recorded by the
fact-finding authority and not embark upon an exercise of
reassessing the evidence and arriving at findings of one's own,
altogether giving a complete go-by even to the facts specifically
found by the Tribunal below.”
13.
Further, the Supreme Court in Krishnanand v. Director of
Consolidation, (2015) 1 SCC 553, held as under:
“12. The High Court has committed an error in reversing the findings of
fact arrived at by the authorities below in coming to the conclusion that
there was a partition. No doubt, the High Court did so in exercise of its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. It is a settled law that
such a jurisdiction cannot be exercised for reappreciating the evidence
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
and arrival of findings of facts unless the authority which passed the
impugned order does not have jurisdiction to render the finding or has
acted in excess of its jurisdiction or the finding is patently perverse. In the
present case, though the High Court reversed the concurrent findings of
the authorities below and came to the opposite conclusion on matter of
facts, the High Court did not do so on the ground that the authorities
below acted in excess of their jurisdiction or without jurisdiction or that
the finding is vitiated by perversity.”
14.
In the circumstances, this Court finds no merit in the present petitions;
the same are, accordingly, dismissed. All pending applications also stand
disposed of.
SACHIN DATTA, J
FEBRUARY 16, 2026/ss
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
14:41:18
W.P.(C) 17810/2025 & Connected Matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review