Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
RAMESH CHANDRA SUMAN
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Shanti Prakash, Adv.
versus
GENERAL MANAGER (NW-III)/(DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY)
STATE BANK OF INDIA AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Siddharth Sangal & Ms. Richa
Mishra, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
13.01.2026
%
1.
This writ petition is directed against order dated 24 th July, 2014
passed by the Disciplinary Authority, the appellate order dated 5th
November, 2014, and the order dated 4th June, 2015 passed by the Review
Committee. By the disciplinary order, the Petitioner was visited with the
penalty of “censure” coupled with a monetary penalty of INR 20,000/-.
Factual Background
2.
The Petitioner, at the relevant time, was posted as Chief Manager at
the Mainpuri Branch of the State Bank of India, Mainpuri, Uttar Pradesh.
During his tenure, certain issues arose in relation to measures adopted by the
branch in respect of accounts of Shri Harsh Chet and Shri Praful Chet, who,
apart from being borrowers of the Bank, were also landlords of the branch
premises. The Bank proceeded under the framework of the Securitisation
and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
Act, 2002 Act1 in relation to the said borrowers.
3.
A departmental proceeding was initiated against the Petitioner on the
allegation that, while functioning as Chief Manager, he failed to discharge
duties with devotion and diligence, acted in a manner unbecoming of a Bank
official, and acted prejudicially to the Bank’s interest, thereby violating Rule
50(4) of the State Bank of India Officers’ Service Rules, 1992.2 The charge,
as framed, referred to the statement of imputations, which contained
multiple allegations.
4.
A departmental inquiry was held. Upon conclusion, the Disciplinary
Authority, by order dated 24th July, 2014, recorded that Allegation No. 1
stood proved and Allegation Nos. 5 and 6 stood partly proved, and imposed
the penalty of censure along with a cash penalty of INR 20,000/-.
5.
The Petitioner preferred a statutory appeal, which was rejected by the
Appellate Authority by order dated 5th November, 2014. A review was also
preferred, which was rejected by the Review Committee by order dated 4 th
June, 2015. Aggrieved, the Petitioner has approached this Court seeking
judicial review of the disciplinary action, the appellate affirmance, and the
review rejection.
Petitioner’s Case
6.
Counsel for the Petitioner assails the impugned order on multiple
grounds, summarised as follows:
6.1.
The disciplinary proceedings are alleged to be biased, pre-determined,
and arbitrary, with the inquiry report reflecting a closed mind and ignoring
or misreading the defence material. It is contended that the Petitioner acted
“SARFAESI Act”
“SBI Service Rules”
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
within the permissible authority of a Chief Manager in matters of recovery
and NPA management, and that the proceedings were initiated to harass him
and stall his career progression, including promotions due around 2014.
6.2.
The inquiry is vitiated by breach of natural justice, as the complaint
and investigation report forming the foundation of the proceedings were not
supplied to the Petitioner, thereby denying him an effective opportunity of
defence.
6.3.
The appointing authority for the Petitioner’s post was the Chief
General Manager, SBI, Local Head Office, New Delhi. Therefore, the
General Manager, being an authority lower than the appointing authority,
could not have acted as the Disciplinary Authority.
6.4.
On merits, the finding on Allegation No. 1 is assailed on the ground
that the Petitioner acted in accordance with the Regional Office instructions
dated 30th June, 2011, which prescribed pre-conditions for credit of rent
arrears and withdrawal of cases that were not fulfilled by the landlords, who
were wilful defaulters and whose account had turned NPA.
6.5.
Similar objections are raised with respect to the findings on
Allegation Nos. 5 and 6, which were held to be partly proved. It is
contended that recovery measures were initiated pursuant to directions of the
Regional Office and within the Petitioner’s authority under the SARFAESI
Act. It is urged that the inquiry proceeds on unwarranted assumptions
regarding the manner of taking possession or affixation of notices, while
attributing liability to the Petitioner even for events occurring after his
transfer.
6.6.
The appellate order is a non-speaking affirmation and does not deal
with the Petitioner’s grounds in a reasoned manner. The same allegation is
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
raised against the review order, which, according to the Petitioner,
mechanically endorses the inquiry findings without independent scrutiny.
6.7.
Without prejudice, it is urged that the punishment of censure coupled
with a monetary penalty of INR 20,000/- is disproportionate because the
Petitioner has not caused any loss to the bank, acted in accordance with
directives issued by the Bank, and served with sincerity. The Petitioner
emphasises that even a minor penalty of censure has serious civil
consequences in a banking organisation, particularly for promotion and
career progression.
6.8.
The disciplinary action is discriminatory. The Petitioner points out
that other officers who held charge of the branch during earlier periods,
when the account turned NPA and rent issues allegedly persisted, have not
been proceeded against. He also asserts that he belongs to the Scheduled
Caste community and contends that his career growth has been curtailed on
account of prejudice.
Respondent’s Case
7.
Submissions of the Respondent Bank are summarised as follows:
7.1.
This writ petition is an impermissible attempt to seek appellate
reappreciation of departmental findings. The inquiry, it is urged, was
conducted strictly in accordance with the applicable service rules; the
Petitioner was afforded due opportunity at all stages; and the findings are
based on documentary evidence. Interference under Article 226 is limited to
cases of jurisdictional error, breach of natural justice causing prejudice, or
perversity based on lack of evidence, none of which is made out.
7.2.
The disciplinary action has been taken by the authority prescribed
under the SBI Service Rules and the internal allocation of disciplinary
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
powers. The Petitioner’s assertion that only the appointing authority can act
as the Disciplinary Authority is legally untenable. The Petitioner has neither
produced the relevant rule nor demonstrated any rule-bar in support of this
contention.
7.3.
The allegation of non-supply of the complaint and investigation report
is misconceived. It is submitted that the inquiry proceeded on documentary
and contemporaneous record, not on any undisclosed material. The
complaint, it is urged, merely triggered the process and did not form the
evidentiary basis of the findings. Further, the Petitioner fully participated in
the proceedings and has failed to show any prejudice arising from the
alleged non-supply.
7.4.
On merits, emphasis is placed on Allegation No. 1, the principal
charge, relating to non-compliance with approved instructions concerning
adjustment of rent arrears and closure of the borrowers’ NPA account.
Reliance is placed on the minutes dated 26th May, 2011, which record a
structured course of action, whereby the due rent of the bank premises was
to be calculated after verification of the bank records and, upon such
determination, the amount found payable was to be deposited in the loan
account of the owners; further, it was stipulated that any remaining balance
in the said NPA account would be deposited by the owners themselves so as
to enable its immediate closure, with the entire exercise to be completed by
30th June, 2011. The inquiry findings, it is submitted, flow from the
Petitioner’s failure to ensure compliance within the stipulated timeline.
7.5.
The Petitioner has attempted to portray the Regional Office letter
dated 30th June, 2011 as a complete re-casting of the earlier decision. It is
submitted that the departmental authorities examined the Petitioner’s
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
reading of that communication and, on a reasonable appraisal, concluded
that it did not justify withholding adjustment of arrears. The Petitioner had
introduced an unwarranted unilateral pre-condition inconsistent with the
approved decision.
7.6.
With respect to Allegation Nos. 5 and 6, which were partly proved, it
is submitted that the inquiry adopted a balanced approach, faulting not the
initiation of recovery per se, but the manner in which steps were taken,
resulting in avoidable institutional exposure. It is submitted that these
findings are also rooted in the record and are not amenable to reappreciation
in writ jurisdiction.
7.7.
The appellate and review orders are reasoned and reflective of due
application of mind. It is submitted that the authorities are not required to
render judgments akin to courts, and it suffices that the substance of the
grounds has been considered.
7.8.
On proportionality, it is urged that the penalty imposed, i.e., censure
with a monetary penalty of INR 20,000/- is a minor and measured response
to proven lapses of devotion and diligence that adversely impacted the
Bank’s interest and reflected disobedience of directions. The Petitioner’s
apprehension of impact on promotion cannot convert a minor penalty into
one that shocks judicial conscience.
7.9.
Allegations of bias, malice, “hidden hands”, and discrimination on
account of Scheduled Caste status are bald, vague and unspecific. Such
allegations
cannot
displace
a
disciplinary
finding
supported
by
contemporaneous record, particularly where the Petitioner has not impleaded
or identified specific individuals whose mala fides are alleged, nor pleaded
material particulars showing differential treatment on comparable facts.
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
Analysis and Findings
8.
The challenge arises from departmental action culminating in a minor
penalty. The function of judicial review under Article 226 in disciplinary
matters is supervisory, not appellate. This Court is to examine whether the
process suffered from jurisdictional infirmity, denial of fair opportunity
causing prejudice, perversity in the sense of findings resting on no evidence,
or punishment that is so disproportionate as to warrant interference.
Reappreciation of evidence, reweighing of competing inferences, and
substitution of the Court’s view for the disciplinary view are outside this
remit.
9.
The petition raises five main heads: (i) competence of the Disciplinary
Authority, (ii) procedural fairness and non-supply of documents, (iii)
perversity of findings on merits, (iv) non-application of mind by the
appellate and reviewing authorities, and (v) proportionality. The allegations
of mala fides and discrimination stand as a separate theme. Each is dealt
with in turn.
Competence of the Disciplinary Authority
10.
The Petitioner asserts that the Chief General Manager was the
appointing authority and, therefore, the General Manager could not act as
the Disciplinary Authority. The submission, as framed, proceeds as if
disciplinary competence must invariably vest only in the appointing
authority. Service jurisprudence does not accept such a broad proposition.
Competence is determined by the applicable rules and the internal
delegation or designation of disciplinary powers for the particular grade and
cadre.
11.
The Petitioner has failed to place on record the relevant rule to
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
demonstrate that the General Manager lacked disciplinary competence in
respect of an officer of the Petitioner’s grade. Rule 67 of the SBI Service
Rules classifies penalties, with clauses (a) to (e) constituting minor penalties
(including censure under clause (a)) and clauses (f) to (j) constituting major
penalties. Rule 68(1)(ii), which governs the initiation and procedure for
disciplinary action, restricts the imposition of penalties under clauses (e) to
(j) of Rule 67 where the Disciplinary Authority is lower in rank than the
Appointing Authority, unless imposed by the Appointing Authority or a
higher authority. However, no such embargo operates in respect of the
penalty of censure or recovery of INR 20,000/- imposed in the present case.
In the absence of any demonstrated rule-bar or lack of jurisdiction, this
contention cannot vitiate the disciplinary action.
Procedural fairness and non-supply of complaint and investigation report
12.
The Petitioner alleges that the complaint and the investigation report
were not supplied to him. The controversy on the principal charge turns on
the contemporaneous minutes dated 26th May, 2011, the subsequent
communications, and the Petitioner’s own defence that the Regional Office
letter imposed pre-conditions. Those are issues the Petitioner did contest on
record. On these pleadings, the proceedings cannot be set aside on this
ground.
13.
Even accepting the grievance at face value, invalidation is not
automatic. The core question is whether non-supply deprived the Petitioner
of a fair opportunity to meet the case against him and caused real prejudice.
14.
The disciplinary record, as extracted in the impugned order, reflects
reliance on documentary exhibits and contemporaneous record. The
Petitioner participated in the inquiry, articulated a detailed defence, relied on
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
documents, and examined defence witness material. The Petitioner has not
demonstrated that any undisclosed complaint or investigation report
constituted the substantive foundation for the finding, or that a specific
exculpatory aspect contained therein could not be urged because the
document was withheld. The objection is thus devoid of merit.
Merits and the “no evidence/perversity” threshold
15.
Allegation No. 1 is the principal allegation, concerning the
adjustment/credit of rent arrears payable by the Bank to the landlords, and
the linkage of that adjustment to the borrowers’ loan account which was
categorised as non-performing. The departmental finding is that the
Petitioner did not credit the arrears of rent in the borrowers’ loan account
and thereby disobeyed lawful instructions, resulting in continued
irregularity. The Petitioner’s defence is that the Regional Office letter dated
30th June, 2011 required the landlords first to deposit INR 2,98,920/- and
withdraw cases and complaints, and only upon fulfilment of those conditions
could the arrears be adjusted or paid.
16.
The minutes of the meeting dated 26th May, 2011, reproduced in the
record, record a structured arrangement. The calculation of due rent was to
be undertaken and the amount found due was to be deposited in the
landlords’ NPA loan account. The minutes then contemplate closure of any
remaining balance by the owners. The timeline was fixed, with the work
relating to due rent and the loan account to be completed by 30th June, 2011.
17.
The Petitioner’s defence seeks to invert that sequence by treating the
landlords’ deposit and withdrawal of litigation as a strict pre-condition for
the Bank’s credit of arrears. The Disciplinary Authority considered that
defence and, on an appraisal of the minutes and subsequent correspondence,
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
declined to accept that the Petitioner was entitled to withhold crediting the
arrears in the manner done. That appraisal represents a plausible
departmental view on contemporaneous record.
18.
The test in writ jurisdiction is not whether another view is possible,
but whether the adopted view is unsupported by record or irrational. On the
record extracted, the finding on Allegation No. 1 cannot be characterised as
a finding based on no evidence. The contemporaneous minutes and the
timeline fixed therein provide a rational basis for the conclusion that the
Petitioner’s conduct departed from the approved course.
19.
Allegation Nos. 5 and 6 were recorded as partly proved. The
Petitioner’s objections on those allegations invite reappreciation of the
recovery process, the necessity and manner of taking possession, and the
downstream consequences of recovery steps. The Disciplinary Authority has
taken a calibrated view, and the findings rest on documentary material and
the departmental understanding of compliance within the Bank’s recovery
framework. No perversity is made out.
Appellate and review orders
20.
The Petitioner contends that the appellate and review orders are
unreasoned. An appellate authority in departmental matters is required to
consider the substance of the grounds and decide whether interference is
warranted. It is not obliged to draft an elaborate judgment in the manner of a
court, particularly where the disciplinary order itself sets out the evidentiary
basis and the reasoning.
21.
The appellate authority upheld the findings and declined interference.
The reviewing authority also declined to reopen the matter. The petition
does not demonstrate that any material defence was ignored altogether or
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
that the appellate or reviewing authorities proceeded on an irrelevant
consideration. The challenge on this head, therefore, does not justify
interference.
Allegations of mala fides, “hidden hands”, discrimination, and Scheduled
Caste bias
22.
The petition contains allegations suggesting malice, jealousy,
conspiracy, and discrimination on account of Scheduled Caste status,
coupled with a plea of selective action vis-à-vis other officers. Such
allegations, serious in content, require pleading of material particulars and a
demonstrable
factual
foundation.
Generalised
assertions,
without
identification of responsible decision-makers, particulars of comparable
cases, and pleading of specific discriminatory acts, cannot displace a
disciplinary finding supported by contemporaneous record.
23.
The plea that other officers were not proceeded against is also
insufficient in the abstract. Departmental liability is assessed on role,
decision-making, and the specific acts imputed. Absence of action against
others, without establishing parity in role and responsibility on materially
identical facts, cannot vitiate the action against the Petitioner.
Proportionality
24.
The departmental findings pertain to lack of due diligence and
disobedience of instructions in a matter bearing upon the Bank’s
institutional interest and NPA management. The penalty imposed comprises
censure coupled with recovery of INR 20,000/-, which is a minor penalty. It
neither entails termination of service nor reduction in rank, nor does it carry
any long-term disqualification.
25.
The submission that the penalty may affect promotion does not, by
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
itself, render the punishment disproportionate in judicial review. Once
misconduct is established on record and the penalty is modest, the threshold
for interference on proportionality is not met.
Conclusion
26.
The petition does not disclose any jurisdictional infirmity, denial of
fair opportunity causing prejudice, perversity in the findings, or punishment
warranting interference under Article 226.
27.
The writ petition is dismissed. Pending applications, if any, also stand
disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
JANUARY 13, 2026/ng
W.P.(C) 10201/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/01/2026 at 13:23:50
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review