Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 29th October, 2025
Pronounced on: 09th February, 2026
CRL.A.1548/2025
+
STATE (GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI)
Through:
Versus
.....Petitioner
Ms. Richa Dhawan, APP for State.
MEETU SINGH
S/o Bhagmal
R/o Village Balsa, P.O Kansa Koti
Tehsil and P.S. Rohru
District Shimla, Himachal Pradesh.
Through:
+
.....Respondent
Mr. Sujit Jaiswal, Advocate.
CRL.M.C.2431/2017, CRL.M.A.9874/2017
1.
RAMESH CHANDER
S/o Sh. Dariya Singh
R/o 229, Type-I, Police Colony
Shalimar Bagh, Delhi.
2.
JAGBIR SINGH
S/o Late Bhim Singh
R/o H.No.678/29, Gali No.2,
Malviya Nagar, Sonepat, Haryana.
3.
RAMPAL
S/o Late Sita Ram
R/o H.No.476, Platinum Apartments,
Sector-18, Rohini,
Delhi.
.....Petitioners
Through:
versus
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
Mr. Jayesh, Advocate.
STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
.....Respondents
Through:
Ms. Richa Dhawan, Ld. APP for
State.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
CRL.A.1548/2025
1.
A Criminal Petition under Section 378(1) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure (hereinafter referred to as “Cr.P.C”) has been filed on behalf of
the Petitioner/State challenging the Order dated 06.05.2017 passed by
learned Special Judge, CBI-01, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, acquitting the
Respondent in case FIR No. 121/2012 under Section 30/40/41 of the Wild
Life (Protection) Act, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as “Wildlife Act”) and
directing registration of FIR against the Police officials.
CRL.M.C. 2431/2017
2.
A Petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C has been filed on behalf of the
Petitioners/Complainant to challenge the Judgment dated 06.05.2017 passed
by learned Special Judge, CBI-01, Central District, Delhi in Criminal
Appeal No. 14/2016, who has set aside the conviction of the Respondents
under Section 51 Wildlife Act of Learned M.M dated 22.10.2016 and
acquitted the Respondents.
CRL.A 1548/2025 & CRL.M.C.2431/2017
3.
The brief facts in the aforesaid two matters are that on 04.05.2012,
at about at about 5 PM, Const. Rampal received a secret information
regarding illegal trade of wild animal skins. He shared the information with
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
I.O. Inspector Satya Prakash who informed the Senior Officers, who
directed him to take action. Consequently, I.O. Inspector Satya Prakash
organized a Raiding Team comprising of himself, ASI Baljit, ASI Ramesh,
HC Jitender, HC Jagbir, Const. Sunil, Const. Amit, Const. Pradeep, Const.
Rampal and Const. Jagbir and the secret informer. They made the Departure
Entry vide DD No.21 at about 05:30 P.M. at SIT Crime Branch, Rohini,
Delhi.
4.
Thereafter, the Raiding Team reached Karnal Bypass, G.T. Road. At
about 06:30 P.M., on the pointing out of the secret informer,
Respondent/Meetu Singh was apprehended by HC Jagbir and Const.
Rampal. Thereafter, three leopard skins wrapped in plastic sheet were
recovered from the plastic katta (bag) which the Respondent was carrying.
The skins were seized vide Seizure Memo Ex. CW-1/A. Thereafter, FIR
No. 121/2012 under Section 30, 40 and 41 of the Wild Life (Protection)
Act, 1972, was registered.
5.
The Accused Meetu Singh was interrogated and arrested and his
Disclosure Statement was also recorded. On the next day i.e. 05.05.2012, he
was produced before the concerned Court along with the case property and
was remanded to Judicial Custody. The case file was released to the
concerned Officials of the Wild Life Department and the case property was
handed over to the I.O. Inspector Satya Prakash for onwards transmission to
the Wild Life Institute, Dehradun for Expert opinion.
6.
The Scientific Analysis Report was received, giving an opinion that
all the three skins were of Leopard (Panthera Pardus), vide Report dated
03.09.2012. It was further mentioned that Leopard is a specified animal and
listed under Schedule I of the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972.
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
7.
Shri R.R. Meena, Wildlife Inspector filed the Complaint under
Section 55 of the Wildlife Act against the Respondent.
8.
After the cognizance was taken and the Respondent appeared in
response to the Summons, the Complainant in the pre-charge evidence,
examined CW1, Inspector Satya Prakash, CW2, HC Jagbir Singh and
CW5, HC Rampal who were part of the Raiding Team and proved the Raid
and the seizure of the Leopard skins from the Respondent.
9.
CW3, C.P. Sharma Senior Technical Officer from Wildlife Forensic
Cell, Dehradun proved the Forensic Report, Ex. CW3/A.
10.
CW4, R.R. Meena, Wildlife Inspector deposed that on 21.09.2012 he
had received the file from Const. Ram Pal, P.S. Crime Branch for necessary
action under the Wildlife Act. Thereafter he filed the Complaint, Ex.
CW4/A under Section 55 Wildlife Act.
11.
After the pre-charge evidence, Charges were framed against the
Respondent/Meetu Singh under Sections 49 and 49(B)(1) of the Act
punishable under Section 51 of the Act, for being found in possession of
three Leopard skins (uncured) with no valid licence or documents for
keeping the Leopard skin.
12.
In the post-charge evidence, the same Witnesses were examined and
duly Cross-Examined by the Counsel for the Respondent.
13.
The Statement of the Respondent was recorded under Section 313
read with Section 281 Cr.P.C. wherein he denied all the incriminating
evidence and claimed that he was falsely implicated in this case. He did not
lead any evidence in his Defence.
14.
The learned ACMM in his Judgment dated 22.10.2016, relied on the
Testimony of PW1, Inspector Satya Prakash, CW2, HC Jagbir Singh and
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
CW5, HC Rampal, who had consistently deposed about the apprehension of
the Respondent and recovery of the Leopard skin, to convict the Respondent
under Section 49 Wildlife Act.
He was sentenced to three years
imprisonment and fine of Rs. 10,000/-, vide Order dated 11.11.2016.
15.
The Respondent preferred an Appeal before the Court of Sessions
against his Conviction.
16.
Learned Special Judge, CBI in his Impugned Judgment dated
06.05.2017 noted the unreliability of the manner in which the Respondent
was apprehended and also the manner in which the investigations were
conducted. In the light of the discrepancies and contradictions, benefit was
extended to the Respondent who was acquitted, vide Judgment dated
06.05.2017.
17.
Aggrieved by the Acquittal, the aforesaid two Appeals have been
preferred by the Appellants. The Appeal No. 1548/2025 (Leave to Appeal
No.462/2017) has been filed by the Complainant, Ramesh Chander.
18.
Appeal No. 1548/2025 has been filed by the State which is
essentially aggrieved by the directions given by ld. ASJ to send the copy of
judgment to the Joint Commissioner (Vigilance), Delhi Police to initiate
appropriate Disciplinary action against the aforesaid four Police officials
namely Inspector Satya Prakash, ASI Ramesh, Const. Rampal and HC
Jagbir for having committed the illegal acts. It was further directed that the
formal FIR under Section 167/220/34 of the Indian Penal Code be registered
and the original handwritten documents, Ex. CW1/A to CW1/F be sent to
CFSL for comparison by an expert opinion and thereafter a final Report
under Section 173 Cr.P.C. be submitted to the Court.
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
19.
The grounds of Appeal are that the Complainant witnesses were
examined on behalf of the Prosecution, who supported the case on all
material grounds. It has not been appreciated that in the case of Bunty @
Guddu vs. State of M.P., AIR 2004 SC 261 it had been held that it is not
necessary to cite all the members of the Raiding party, as Witnesses and the
Prosecution was at liberty to choose two or some of them, in order to save
the time of the Court from repetitive depositions on the same factual aspects
of the case. The evidence of the Witnesses were consistent, which has not
been appreciated in the right perspective.
20.
It is, therefore, submitted that the Acquittal by the Learned Special
Judge is bad in law and the Conviction as awarded by learned ACMM vide
Order dated 22.10.2016 be restored.
21.
In Appeal No. 1548/2025, learned Additional Public Prosecutor
for the State has further argued that the signatures of Inspector Satya
Prakash differed in different documents because his hand used to shake and
was not stable. Such discrepancy in the signatures, could not have been a
basis to discredit the documents prepared by Inspector Satya Prakash. It is
further submitted that learned Special Judge has passed strictures against the
Police officials which were not merited as they were only discharging their
duty and the remarks made against them in the Judgment, may be expunged.
Submissions heard and record perused.
22.
As per the case of the Prosecution, a secret information was received
by CW5, Const. Rampal on 04.05.2012 at about 05:00 PM, which he
conveyed to Inspector Satya Prakash, the I.O. who formed a Raiding Team
consisting of himself, Const. Rampal and eight other Constables/Police
Officials. Inspector Satya Prakash made a DD entry No.21 at about 05:30
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
P.M at SIT Crime Branch and thereafter, they went to Karnal Bypass, G.T.
Road. At about 06:30 PM on the pointing out of secret informer, the
Respondent was apprehended and from his possession, three uncured
leopard skin were recovered.
23.
Section 50 of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 provides that the
Police Officer not below the rank of Sub Inspector is empowered to inspect
and seize the wildlife products which are in contravention of the provisions
of the Act.
24.
The Learned Special Judge has noted that after the alleged recovery of
Leopard skin from the Respondent, Inspector Satya Parkash arrested him
vide Arrest Memo, Ex. CW1/E and recorded his Disclosure Statement, Ex.
CW1/D. He also prepared the Personal Search Memo, Ex. CW1/F.
However, the perusal of the three documents indicate that they were not
prepared by Inspector Satya Prakash, in his own handwriting. They all were
prepared in three different handwritings, in three different pens and ink.
25.
It was further observed by Ld. ASJ that the perusal of these
documents reflected that the Disclosure Statement, Ex. CW1/D and Arrest
Memo, Ex. CW1/E appear to have genuine signatures of Inspector Satya
Prakash while the signatures on Personal Search Memo Ex. CW1/F
appeared to be different. Likewise, even the Site Plan, Ex. CW1/E did not
appear to be in the handwriting of Inspector Satya Prakash and it was in
different handwriting and in a different pen and ink. His alleged signatures
also appear to be different and forged. Reference was made to the crossexamination of CW1, Inspector Satya Prakash who deposed that on
03.05.2012 he had gone out of station and had handed over the file to ASI
Ramesh, for further investigations.
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
26.
It was concluded that it appeared that ASI Ramesh was the person
who had completed all the investigations and had prepared various
documents, but the signatures of Inspector Satya Prakash were obtained
subsequently or they were manipulated. It was thus held, that Inspector
Satya Prakash was never a Member of the alleged Raiding Team and had not
organized the Team or conducted the Raid on 04.05.2012, as was alleged in
the Complaint. It was in fact, ASI Ramesh who had conducted the
investigations.
27.
It was further observed that as per Section 51 of the Wildlife
(Protection) Act, it is only a Police Officer above the rank of Sub Inspector
who was competent to conduct the investigations. Therefore, the
preparation of documents by Inspector Satya Prakash was necessitated and
manipulated. ASI Ramesh who has shown to have conducted the entire
Raid/proceedings was not competent to conduct the search or effect the
alleged recovery.
28.
In this regard, it may be observed that while the investigations are
being conducted, the documents may be prepared by any Official who is part
of the Raiding Team, but so long as the signatures are those of the concerned
person, these documents cannot be faulted merely on the ground of having
been prepared by some other official. It is evident that when all the
investigations which are done on the spot, the IO may not be able to prepare
all the Paper work himself, and some documents may be prepared by the
person assisting him in the investigations in preparing the documents.
Merely because these documents were in different inks or different
handwriting, would not per se reflect that they had been manipulated or that
the signatures of Inspector Satya Prakash had been forged and had been
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
manipulated and had been obtained subsequently. This in itself could not
have been a ground to doubt the entire investigations/proceedings or that
Inspector Satya Prakash was not the person concerned to conduct the
investigations.
29.
Admittedly, the documents i.e. Disclosure Statement and the Arrest
Memo had the original signatures.
There is no reason to question the
presence of Inspector Satya Prakash, in conducting the Raid
30.
The next aspect of significance which emerges is the manner in
which the Respondent was apprehended.
31.
According to the Testimony of CW1 Inspector Satya Prakash, he
along with all the members of the Raiding Team had gone to Karnal Bypass
and had apprehended the Respondent, while he was walking down the road.
Pertinently, in his Personal Search, a Bus ticket was recovered, though the
same was not found on record.
32.
Apparently, the Respondent had got off the Bus and had been
identified by the secret informer, but significantly, neither CW1 nor CW2
nor CW5 deposed how the Respondent reached the spot. There is a huge
ambiguity on this aspect; the claim of the witnesses that he was present at
G.T. Karnal Road and recovery of three uncured Leopard skins were made
by him at that spot, is not beyond doubt.
33.
A further doubt is created as the Seizure Memo, Ex.CW1/A had the
FIR number mentioned on the top, even though the FIR had been registered
subsequently. The Supreme Court in the case of Radhey Shyam vs. State of
Haryana, (2001) 10 SCC 206 had observed that while the FIR gets
registered first and the Seizure Memo prepared subsequently, but the very
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
fact that there is a mention of FIR on the Seizure Memo shows that it was
prepared before the registration of FIR.
34.
The Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Prithvi Pal Singh @ Munna
vs. State, 2000 (1) JCC (Delhi) 274 had also in the similar circumstances had
observed that such procedural abrasions reflect upon the veracity of the
Prosecution case and robs the efficacy of the evidence of the aforesaid
Police Officials regarding the alleged recovery from the Appellant’s
possession.
35.
In the present case as well, considering the discrepancy of the FIR
number featuring over the Seizure Memo, thereby indicating that the Seizure
Memo had been prepared subsequently, creates a doubt about the recovery
itself.
36.
To conclude, serious doubts have emerged from the Testimony of the
Complainant witnesses with regard to the manner of apprehension of the
Respondent and the alleged recovery. The benefit of doubt has been rightly
extended to the Respondent while acquitting him. The present Crl. M.C
No.2431/2017 filed by the Complainant, challenging the acquittal of the
Respondent, is accordingly dismissed.
37.
The State in its Appeal No.1548/2025 is essentially aggrieved by the
strictures and the directions given by the Ld. ASJ, directing Disciplinary
enquiry and the FIR against the Four Police Officials.
38.
The learned Special Judge, observed that the handwriting on the
various Memos were different and the signatures of IO Satya Prakash
appeared to be different. Thus, it was directed that the copy of the Judgment
to be served to Joint Commissioner (Vigilance), Delhi Police with the
directions to initiate appropriate Disciplinary action against the aforesaid
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
four Police officials namely Inspector Satya Prakash, ASI Ramesh, Const.
Rampal and HC Jagbir for having committed the illegal acts. It was further
directed that the formal FIR under Section 167/220/34 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 be registered and the original handwritten documents,
Ex.CW1/A to CW1/F be sent to CFSL for comparison by an expert opinion
and thereafter, a final Report under Section 173 Cr.P.C be submitted to the
Court.
39.
However, in the light of observations herein above, that this cannot be
a ground to disbelieve the presence of IO on the spot, or to conclude that the
investigations were manipulated. Therefore, the observations made by the
Learned Special Judge directing the Disciplinary Enquiry and the
Registration of FIR with specific directions of how the investigations
should be carried out, is absolutely unwarranted. Such part of the
Judgment is, therefore, set aside.
40.
The Crl.M.C No.2431/2017 is hereby dismissed. Appeal No.
1548/2025 of the State to the extent of challenging directions for
Disciplinary action/registration of FIR, is allowed to the extent that such
directions are set aside.
41.
The
aforesaid
Criminal
Appeal
No.1548/2025
and
CRL.M.C.2431/2017 are disposed of accordingly, along with the pending
Application(s).
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEB RUARY 09, 2026/VA
CRL.A.1548/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:43:31
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review