Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Judgment Reserved On:13.08.2026
Judgment Delivered On:24.08.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
AT NAINITAL
Criminal Misc. Application No.1727 of 2026
Raman Panwar.
………………… Applicant.
Versus
The State of Uttarakhand & another.
……………Respondents.
With
Criminal Misc. Application No.1725 of 2026
Raman Panwar.
………………… Applicant.
Versus
The State of Uttarakhand & others.
……………Respondents.
Present:
Mr. Raj Kishor Chaudhary, Mr. Aishwarya Sharma, Mr. Vivek Vaibhav, Ms. Ayushi Nagar and Mr.
Altaf Hussain, learned counsels for the applicant.
Mr. Himanshu Sain, learned AGA, for the State of Uttarakhand.
Mr. T.A. Khan, and Mr. D.K. Sharma, learned Senior Advocates assisted by Mr. Mohd.
Shafy, learned counsel for the respondent.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rakesh Thapliyal, J.
1.
These two petitions are preferred by the applicant – Raman
Panwar, challenging the order dated 22.07.2026, passed by the
learned Judicial Magistrate – IInd , Haridwar in Criminal Case
No.2435 of 2023 and Criminal Case No.3419 of 2023, respectively,
whereby the Trial Court has deferred the “pronouncement of it’s
order” on an application filed under Section 451 of CrPC.
2.
The challenge is primarily on the ground that the order
impugned is defeating the mandate of the judgment and order
passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court dated 06.05.2025 in Criminal
Appeal No.2525 of 2025, whereby the directions were issued to
the Trial Court to decide the application filed under Section 451 of
CrPC in accordance with law, therefore, the Trial Court should
not defer the “pronouncement of it’s order”, merely on the
ground that in the Transfer Application, the High Court ask
certain comments/narratives from the Trial Court.
3.
At this juncture, the brief history of the present case is also
required to be discussed here.
4.
The informant who is the applicant, herein, lodged an FIR
on 07.06.2022 bearing FIR No.0177 of 2022, against one Mr. Rakesh
Mehra for the offences punishable under Sections 420 and 506 of
IPC, at Police Station - Kankhal, District Haridwar, with the
allegations of cheating, criminal breach of trust and criminal
conspiracy, and during investigation, it was revealed that
substantial amount constituting the alleged proceeds of crime
were transferred by the principal accused – Rakesh Mehra, to the
bank accounts of his daughters, namely, Madhavi Arora and
Anushka Arora, who are the respondent nos.2 and 3 herein.
5.
The first chargesheet was filed on 23.04.2023, against the
respondent nos.2 and 3, and second chargesheet was filed on
05.12.2023, against Mr. Rakesh Mehra, as “Absconder” since he
never joined the investigation. During investigation Rs.31.21
Crores allegedly siphoned off which were lying in the Bank
Account of
chargesheeted persons were freezed. During
investigation it was found that a sum of Rs.10,28,63,336/- were
transferred in the account of Madhavi Arora, and an amount of
Rs.12,77,22,000/- were transferred in the account of Anushka
Arora, and an amount of Rs.5,44,45,568/- was standing in the
name of Mr. Rakesh Mehra. Thereafter, two separate applications
were filed under Section 451 of CrPC, before the learned Judicial
Magistrate, IInd Haridwar, on 19.01.2024 and on 13.05.2025
respectively.
6.
In the meantime entire proceedings arising out of Case
Crime No.177 of 2022, was challenged in two separate
proceedings (1) Criminal Miscellaneous Application No.135 of
2024, “Rakesh Mehra Vs. State of Uttarakhand and others” under
Section 482 CrPC (2) WPCRL No.159 of 2023, “Anushka Arora
and another Vs. State of Uttarakhand and others”.
7.
During the pendency of the aforesaid proceedings, on
29.01.2024 this Court passed restrain the Trial Court from passing
any order on an application moved under Section 451 of CrPC,
which is read as under:“5. In the meantime, learned trial court is restrained
from passing any order on the application moved by
the complainant for releasing the entire money lying
debit/freezed in the accounts of the present applicant.”
8.
Against the aforesaid order dated 29.01.2024, the present
applicant approach to the Hon’ble Supreme Court preferred
Criminal Appeal No.2525 of 2025, which was allowed on
06.05.2025, relevant extract of which read as under:“7. Having regard to the submissions made by the
learned counsel and to the record of the case, it appears
that the respondent No.3 is absconding since 08.06.2022
and despite the issuance of Non-bailable Warrant and
Look Out Notice, the respondent No.3 is not appearing
before the Trial Court. From the Charge Sheet filed
against the respondent No.3 - accused also, it appears
that the proceedings under Sections 82 and 83 of Cr.P.C.
were initiated against the accused – Rakesh Mehra, i.e.,
the respondent No.3 herein.
8. It also appears that the appellant is the authorised
representative of M/s. Patanjali Ayurved Limited and
M/s. Divya Pharmacy (complainant), who has filed the
application under Section 451 of Cr.P.C. seeking release
of the entire money lying debit/freezed in the accounts of
respondent No.3 in favour of the applicant, which
application is under consideration before the concerned
Trial Court. However, the High Court has passed the
impugned order restraining the Trial Court from passing
any order on the said application moved by the
complainant i.e., the present appellant for releasing the
money lying debit/freezed in the accounts of the
respondent No.3 – accused, who is absconding.
9. The impugned order passed by the High Court being
illegal and not tenable at law, the same is required to be
set aside and is hereby set aside.
10. The appeal stands allowed accordingly.
11. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
12. It goes without saying that the application filed by the
appellant before the Trial Court under Section
451 Cr.P.C. shall be decided in accordance with law.”
9.
The aforesaid judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court was placed
before the Trial Court on 13.05.2025 alongwith an application
with the following prayer:“It is therefore prayed that the pending release
application of the applicant may graciously be heard and
decided in pursuance of the order passed by the Honorable
Supreme Court of India dated 06.05.2025.”
10.
In compliance to the aforesaid order of Hon’ble Apex Court
the Trial Court, heard both the parties on an application under
Section 451 CrPC on 15.07.2026 and post the matter on 22.07.2026
for orders, which read as under:“पुकार पर प�ावली पेश �यी। पक्षकार� के िव�ान अिधव�ागण
उपिस्थत है। पक्षकार� के िव�ान अिधव�ा को �रलीज संबंिधत
�क�णर् �ाथर्ना प� अ�तगत धारा 451 दण्ड ���या संिहता पर
सुना गया। प�ावली �रलीज संबंिधत �क�णर् �ाथर्ना प� अन्तर्गत
धारा 451 दण्ड ���या संिहता पर आदेश हेतु �दनांक
22.07.2026 को पेश हो।
11.
Now on 22.07.2026 instead of pronouncing the order the
Trial Court post the matter on 10.08.2026, by observing that in
two pending Transfer Applications i.e. Transfer Application
No.22 and 29 of 2025, the High Court by Memo/UHC-Criminal
Section, dated 17.07.2026 received on 18.07.2026, ask the
comments/narratives by 23.07.2026, therefore, in such a situation
it is not proper for the Trial Court to pass the order. Entire order
dated 22.07.2026 is being reproduced, hereinasunder:“प�ावली पेश �ई। प�ावली आज वादी मुकदमा के �रलीज
�ाथर्ना प� एवं अिभयु�गण के उ� �रलीज �ाथर्ना प� पर
�स्तुत आपि� एवं अिभयु�गण के िव�ान अिधव�ागण के �ारा
उठाये गये तकर्, �क 'क्या माननीय उ�राखण्ड उ� न्यायालय म�
िवचाराधीन Criminal Transfer Application C447 No.
29 of 2025, Anushka Arora and another Vs. State
of Uttarakhand and others के लिम्बत रहते वादी मुकदमा
के �रलीज �ाथर्ना प� का िनस्तारण �कया जा सकता है?, पर
आदेश हेतु िनयत है।
माननीय उ�राखण्ड उ� न्यायालय �ारा Criminal Transfer
Application C447 No. 29 of 2025, Anushka Arora
and another Vs. State of Uttarakhand and others म�
�दनांक 17.07.2026 को पा�रत आदेश क� �ित, माननीय
उ�राखण्ड
उ�
न्यायालय
के
Memo/UHC-Criminal
Section dated 17.07.2026 के साथ इस न्यायालय को
�दनांक 18.07.2026 को �ा� �ई। माननीय उ� न्यायालय के
आदेश का ससम्मान अवलोकन �कया गया। उपरो� आदेश म�
माननीय उ� न्यायालय �ारा इस न्यायालय को उपरो�
Transfer Application के संबंध म� comments/narrative
�दनांक 23.07.2026 तक �स्तुत �कये जाने हेतु आदेिशत �कया
गया है।
माननीय उ�राखण्ड उ� न्यायालय के उपरो� आदेश के दृि�गत
हस्तगत वाद क� प�ावली म� आज आदेश पा�रत �कया जाना
न्यायोिचत �तीत नह� होता है। अतः प�ावली अि�म आदेश हेतु
�दनांक 10.06.2026 को पेश हो।”
12.
Now being aggrieved with the aforesaid two separate
orders of Trial Court in both the applications, these two petitions
are preferred under Section 528 of BNSS, 2023.
13.
In the meantime miscellaneous Application No.135 of 2024,
and WPCRL No.159 of 2023, wherein the proceeding arising out
of Case Crime No.177 of 2022 were challenged were also
dismissed by this Court by common judgment and order dated
17.06.2026, which was assailed by respondent nos.2 and 3 only,
before the Hon’ble Apex Court, however the SLP was dismissed
on 09.07.2026. While dismissing the SLP the Hon’ble Apex Court
also observed that the order impugned shall not prejudice the
Trial Court if any application seeking discharge is submitted by
the accused, and if any such application is moved the same will be
considered on its own merits in accordance with law. Now
pursuant to the liberty as above, the respondent nos.2 and 3,
moved discharge application through their counsel before the
Trial Court, which is pending for consideration.
14.
In the meantime, the respondent nos.2 and 3, also sought
Anticipatory Bail and the Coordinate Bench granted them interim
protection that in an event of their arrest during investigation,
they shall be enlarged on interim bail though there was no
pending investigation, since charge was already filed way back in
the year of 2023 though trial court proceeding was put on hold
since matter was pending in the High Court in two pending
proceedings which were dismissed on 17.06.2026.
15.
Learned counsel for the applicant pointed out that “Rakesh
Mehra”, also challenged the Trial Court proceedings in C482
No.135 of 2024, which was also dismissed on 17.06.2026 but
neither he challenged before the Apex Court the said judgment
nor put appearance before the Trial Court and the entire Trial
Court proceedings is still put on hold. Apart from this he also
pointed out that the discharge application has been moved by the
respondent nos.2 and 3, pursuant to the liberty given by Hon’ble
Supreme Court though their counsel without putting their
appearance before the Trial Court which is not permissible. He
also submits that instead of joining trial court proceeding, the two
Transfer Petitions have been moved i.e. Criminal Transfer
Application(C-447) No.29 of 2025, “Anushka Arora and another
Vs. State of Uttarakhand and others” and Criminal Transfer
Application(C-447) No.22 of 2025, “Rakesh Mehra Vs. State of
Uttarakhand and others”, for seeking transfer of the Trial on the
ground that the Presiding Officer of Trial Court is biased since
there is an interpolation in the order-sheet of the Trial Court dated
12.05.2026.
16.
He also submits that in both the pending Transfer Petitions
there is no interim order except that they can pray for
adjournment despite this by the order impugned the learned
Judicial Magistrate deferred the “pronouncement of it’s order”
only on an excuse that in pending Transfer Petitions, on an
administrative side certain narratives/comments has been asked
for, therefore, deferring the “pronouncement of the order” on
such excuse is untenable and illegal.
17.
On the other side, Mr. T.A. Khan, learned senior counsel
submits that so far as the order of Hon’ble Apex Court dated
06.05.2025 passed in Criminal Appeal No.2525 of 2025, is
concerned, there is no such direction that a particular Presiding
Officer or a particular court of a particular District will hear the
application. He draw attention of this Court to the averment as
made in para 2 of the counter affidavit, which is being reproduced
hereinasunder:“2. That the present application filed by the applicant
is an abuse of process of law the application has been
filed in order to make an influence on the trial court.
When the matter is already subjudice in the transfer
application filed before this Hon'ble Court and the
applicant is appearing before the Hon'ble Coordinate
Bench in Transfer Application, he should have wait
till the decision of the transfer application. So far as
the order dated 06.05.2025 passed by the Hon'ble
Apex Court is concerned, it was passed in the matter
of the father of the answering respondents and even in
the order dated 06.05.2025 there was a direction that
the trial court will decide the money release
application but there was no direction that a
particular presiding officer or a particular court of a
particular district will hear the application. If the
answering respondents are having life threats in
appearing in the District of Haridwar and when the
presiding officer is under the influence of the firms of
the applicant and when there were no chances of
substantial justice, the respondents no. 2 & 3 were
free to make an application for the transfer of the
trial.”
18.
Mr. Khan, learned senior counsel also draw attention to
paragraph 16 of the counter affidavit and submits that the order of
Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 29.01.2024 passed in Special Leave
to Appeal (Criminal) No.2714 of 2024, was passed behind their
back and they were not aware about the proceeding, since notice
was served upon their uncle intentionally, with whom there was
some dispute and the SLP No.2714 of 2024, could not be
contested, and the order was passed in absence of their father.
19.
So far as Transfer Petitions are concerned Mr. Khan, submits
that it is statutory right of the respondent nos.2 and 3, and the
same cannot be overlooked and therefore the Trial Court is right
in deferring the “pronouncement of it’s order”.
20.
In addition to this Mr. T.A. Khan, learned senior counsel,
submits that the present applicant is representative of a Company
and is very highly influential person and there is regular threat,
particularly in District Haridwar, and the Presiding Judge is
under their influence and there is no hope of fair justice.
21.
In response to such submission learned counsel for the
applicant submits
that
the
answering
respondents
since
beginning are avoiding trial court proceedings, which is put on
hold since 2023, and all these excuses are nothing but to avoid
trial court proceeding and they never make any complaint of any
threat perception and such a plea already turn down by this
Court as well as by Hon’ble Supreme Court.
22.
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that when in
every Forum the respondents could not succeed, then they are
harping upon their Transfer Petitions by raising allegations
against the Presiding Officer that he is biased. He submits that
the entire conduct of the respondents, herein, are in fact reveals
that they have no trust on the judicial system and without putting
appearance before the Trial Court they are now questioning on
the integrity of Trial Court.
23.
He further submits that in compliance of the Hon’ble Apex
Court’s directions, the Trial Court already heard and post the
matter for “pronouncement of it’s order” but defer the
pronouncement only because of the reason that the High Court
called for a routine administrative report or query from the Trial
Court. He submits that mere filing of the Transfer Petition does
not pause the trial unless the High Court passes a specific written
judicial order staying the proceedings and the Trial Court is duty
bound to continue it’s work.
24.
Lastly learned counsel for the applicant concluded his
submissions that once the Hon’ble Apex Court specifically
directed the Trial Court to decide the application moved under
Section 451 of CrPC, no administrative query or pending Transfer
Petition can override the direct command of Hon’ble Supreme
Court, and by withholding the order, Trial Court has failed to
mandate the judicial discipline.
25.
Heard the arguments of learned counsel for the parties and
perused the entire record including the judgment and order
passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court dated 06.05.2025 in Criminal
Appeal No.2525 of 2025 and also the order impugned, and is of
the firm opinion that the Trial Court has no business to
overlooked the direction of Hon’ble Apex Court on an excuse that
comments/narratives has been called for on an administrative
side by the High Court. The Hon’ble Supreme Court is the
Highest Court of the land and by withholding the order of
Highest Court, this Court of the firm opinion that the Trial Court
has failed to maintain the judicial discipline.
26.
Asking comments on an administrative side from the
concerned Magistrate is completely a different issue, therefore,
the Trial Court should not mix-up both the issues. The Hon’ble
Apex Court passed the order on 06.05.2025 by directing the Trial
Court to decide the application moved under Section 451 of CrPC
in accordance with law, and now one year has been passed,
despite this the said application has not been expedited so far
though it was heard finally on 15.07.2025 and therefore on an
excuse that comments/narratives has been asked for on an
administrative side the Trial Court has no business to defer the
“pronouncement of it’s order”.
27.
At this juncture, it is also relevant to mention, here that
these Transfer Applications are pending since 2025, and even the
plea of biasness was never been raised by the respondents in any
Forum either before the Hon’ble Apex Court or before this Court
during the pendency of earlier C482 Application No.135 of 2024,
and WPCRL No.159 of 2023, which were decided by order dated
17.06.2026 which now attains finality.
28.
The Trial Court must understand that the directions of the
Hon’ble Apex Court are binding precedents under the law and
such directions cannot be overlooked, bypassed, or ignored on
any
excuse
whatsoever,
which
override
any
pending
administrative query or transfer petition. For all purposes, the
Hon’ble Apex Court’s direction will prevail.
29.
The Trial Court has committed a grave error by mixing up
two completely different issues. A pending transfer petition
where an accused is only given the liberty to request an
adjournment does not give the Trial Court the absolute right to
overlook the explicit mandate of Hon’ble Apex Court decision.
Deferring the order under the garb of pending transfer petition is
impermissible. The Trial Court is held to be responsible for
violating the clear mandate of the Hon’ble Apex Court if it
continues to hesitate.
30.
To uphold the majesty of law and enforce the mandate of
Hon’ble Apex Court, both the petitions are disposed of finally
with the following directions:“Trial Court is directed to proceed and pronounce the
order in furtherance of it’s order dated 15.07.2026 on
pending applications preferred under Section 451 CrPC
strictly as per the mandate of Hon’ble Apex Court’s
direction vide judgment and order dated 06.05.2025
passed in Criminal Appeal No.2525 of 2025 within two
weeks’ from the date of presentation of copy of this
order.”
31.
Let copy of this order be sent to the concerned Trial Court
immediately for necessary compliance.
(Rakesh Thapliyal, J.)
24.08.2026
NR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review