The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. In the decision reported in Prakasan and Another v. State of Kerala [2016 KHC 96], this Court observed that, if the forwarding note is not produced and marked, it cannot be said that prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that the articles were produced in Court in the same condition in which it was seized and it reached the chemical examiner’s lab in a tamper proof condition and the chemical analysis report relates to the representative sample said to have been taken from the large quantity of contraband article alleged to have been seized from the possession of the accused. Paragraph 11 of the above judgment reads thus: ‘11. Merely because seizure was effected alone is not sufficient to convict the accused for the offence alleged. It must be further proved by the prosecution that the articles seized had reached the Court in tamper proof condition and the prosecution 2025:KER:27260 has to further prove that the chemical analysis report relates to the sample said to have been taken from the contraband article alleged to have been seized from the possession of the accused. In this case the specimen impression of the seal used for sealing the sample has not been produced. PW 3 had stated that he had used metal seal for sealing the sample and he did not remember the letters in that seal. Further he had no case that he had handed over specimen impression of the seal used fo…
19. Upon hearing the submission of the counsel and perused the records, I am of the view that the prosecution has failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt. The impugned judgment is liable to be set aside, in my view. In the light of the above discussion, I am of the considered opinion that the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside. Both the trial court and the appellate court overlooked serious illegalities which cut the very root of the prosecution story. In the result, (i) Criminal revision petition is allowed. (ii) The impugned judgment is set aside. (iii) The revision petitioner/2nd accused is acquitted and he is set at liberty. (iv) The bail bond, if any, executed by the revision petitioner stands cancelled. (v) Fine, if any, paid by him shall be refunded. Sd/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27260
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO. 651 OF 2013
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 18.12.2012 IN Crl.A NO.812 OF
2003 OF ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT (ADHOC)-III, THALASSERY ARISING
OUT OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 10.11.2003 IN CC NO.713 OF 1998 OF
JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF FIRST CLASS, MATTANNUR
REVISION PETITIONER/APPELLANT/2ND ACCUSED:
RAMACHANDRAN, AGED 56 YEARS
S/O.KUNHIRAMAN NAIR, KANDUMKUNNU AMSOM,
KANDUMKUNNU, KANNUR DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
SRI.C.P.PEETHAMBARAN
SMT.MINI.V.A.
RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM-682 031
OTHER PRESENT:
Sri. Ranjit George-PP
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
28.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Crl.R.P.651/2013
2025:KER:27260
ORDER
This criminal revision petition is preferred impugning the
judgment of the learned Additional Sessions Court, Adhoc-III, Thalassery in
Crl.A.No.812/2003.
2.
The revision petitioner herein is the 2nd accused in Crime
No.294/1996 of Iritty Police Station registered for offence punishable under
Sections 55(a) and 65 of the Abkari Act.
3.
The prosecution case is that, on 12.09.1996, accused
nos.1 to 3 were found transporting illicit liquor, without permit or any
sufficient documents. The 1st accused is the driver of the lorry bearing
registration no.KBT 4117, 2nd accused is the cleaner and the 3rd accused is the
owner of the lorry.
4.
The trial court convicted and sentenced the 2 nd accused
to undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months and to pay a fine of
Rs.25,000/-. It is further directed that, in default of payment of fine, the
accused shall undergo simple imprisonment for three months. The accused
nos.1 and 3 were absconded and the case against them was split up.
5.
The appellate court confirmed the sentence and
conviction imposed by the trial court.
Crl.R.P.651/2013
2025:KER:27260
6.
Impugning the judgment of the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Thalassery, the accused preferred this revision.
7.
Before the trial court, PWs.1 to 7 were examined, Exts.P1
to P5 were marked. PW1 is the Sub Inspector, PWs. 2 and 3 are the mahazar
witnesses.
PW4 is a witness to the scene mahazar. PW5 is the Circle
Inspector who detected the crime on the alleged date of occurrence. DW1
prepared the seizure mahazar. After the closure of the prosecution evidence,
the accused was questioned under Section 313(1)(b) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure.
8.
I have heard Adv. Renjit George, learned Public
Prosecutor and the learned counsel appearing for the revision petitioner.
9.
The learned Public Prosecutor submitted that the
impugned judgment is legally sustainable and no interference, whatsoever,
is warranted in this matter. He further submitted that the prosecution has
succeeded in alleging and proving the charge against the revision petitioner.
10.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the revision
petitioner submitted that the impugned judgment is illegal, irregular and
improper. Both the trial court and the appellate court had failed to note the
illegalities and improprieties in this case.
11.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
Crl.R.P.651/2013
2025:KER:27260
prosecution has failed to allege and prove the charge against the accused
beyond reasonable doubt. He submitted that the penal statutes are to be
interpreted strictly within the four corners of the statute.
Suspicion,
however strong it may be, it would not be a substitute for proof. The
impugned judgment is based on surmises and conjectures.
12.
Before further discussion, it may be fruitful to extract
the relevant sections:
“Section 55. For illegal import, etc. - Whoever in
contravention of this Act or of any rule or order made under
this Act
(a)
imports, exports, [transports, transits or
possesses] liquor or any intoxicating drug; or
(b)
Manufactures liquor or any intoxicating drug;
(c)
xxx
(d)
taps or causes to be tapped] any toddyproducing tree, or
(e)
draws or causes to be drawn] toddy from any
tree; or
(f)
constructs or works any [distillery, brewery,
winery or other manufactory in which liquor is
manufactured; or
(g)
uses, keeps, or has in his possession any
materials, still, utensil, implement or
apparatus whatsoever for the purpose of
manufacturing liquor other than toddy or any
intoxicating drug;
or
(h)
bottles any liquor for purposes of sale; or
(i)
Sells or stores for sales liquor] or any
intoxicating drug;
shall be punished.-”
“Section 65: What things liable to confiscation. - In any
case in which an offence has been committed under this Act,
Crl.R.P.651/2013
2025:KER:27260
the liquor, drug, materials, still, utensil, implement or
apparatus in respect [or by means] of which an offence has
been committed shall be liable to confiscation.
Any liquor or intoxicating drug lawfully imported,
exported, transported, manufactured had in possession or
sold or toddy lawfully drawn or tapped along with, or in
addition to any liquor, intoxicating drug or toddy, liable to
confiscation under this section, and the receptacles, packages
and coverings in which any such liquor, intoxicating drug,
materials, still, utensil, implement or apparatus as aforesaid
is or are found, and the other contents, if any, of the
receptacles or packages in which the same is or are found,
and the animals, carts, vessels or other conveyances used in
carrying the same, shall likewise be liable to confiscation.”
13.
I have heard the rival submission of the counsel for the
parties and perused the records.
14.
Admittedly, the main contention of the learned counsel
for the revision petitioner is that, the forwarding note was not prepared and
marked by the prosecution. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner
would further submit that the prosecution has failed to prove the case
beyond reasonable doubt and the accused is entitled to get the benefit of
doubt.
15.
In a decision reported in Unnikrishnan Nair v. State
of Kerala [2020(4) KLT 376], it is held that, in the absence of the
forwarding note admitted in evidence, it cannot be found that the
prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that the very same sample
Crl.R.P.651/2013
2025:KER:27260
taken at the spot of the occurrence had reached the chemical examiner for
analysis in a tamper proof condition.
16.
In the instant case, admittedly, forwarding note was not
produced and marked in evidence.
17.
In the absence of the forwarding note admitted in
evidence, it cannot be found that the prosecution has proved beyond
reasonable doubt that the very same sample taken at the spot for occurrence
had reached the chemical examiner for analysis in a tamper proof condition.
18.
In the decision reported in Prakasan and Another v.
State of Kerala [2016 KHC 96], this Court observed that, if the
forwarding note is not produced and marked, it cannot be said that
prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that the articles were
produced in Court in the same condition in which it was seized and it
reached the chemical examiner’s lab in a tamper proof condition and the
chemical analysis report relates to the representative sample said to have
been taken from the large quantity of contraband article alleged to have
been seized from the possession of the accused. Paragraph 11 of the above
judgment reads thus:
‘11.
Merely because seizure was effected alone is
not sufficient to convict the accused for the offence alleged. It must
be further proved by the prosecution that the articles seized had
reached the Court in tamper proof condition and the prosecution
Crl.R.P.651/2013
2025:KER:27260
has to further prove that the chemical analysis report relates to
the sample said to have been taken from the contraband article
alleged to have been seized from the possession of the accused. In
this case the specimen impression of the seal used for sealing the
sample has not been produced. PW 3 had stated that he had used
metal seal for sealing the sample and he did not remember the
letters in that seal. Further he had no case that he had handed
over specimen impression of the seal used for sealing the article to
any one. He had further stated that he did not know what
happened to the articles after he had entrusted the same to
Alathoor Excise Range. According to DW 4, PW 3 had affixed the
seal of the Circle Inspector and he did not know what was written
in that seal. Further neither in the seizure mahazar nor in the
search list, the nature of seal used was mentioned as well. Quite
unfortunately forwarding note was not seen produced or marked
in this case. Without forwarding note on file, it is not possible to
ascertain as to whether the specimen seal impression of the seal
used for sealing the sample has been provided to Court or the
chemical examiner to satisfy the genuineness of the sample
produced. Further it will be seen from the property list produced,
though not marked, that they were produced on 10/04/1998
before the magistrate who was in charge of the jurisdictional
magistrate and it was directed to be kept in the custody of the
excise official with a direction to produce the same on 15/04/1998
before the concerned Court. But it is seen from the property list
that it was produced before the Judicial First Class Magistrate
Court - I, Palakkad, as he was in charge of Judicial First Class
Magistrate Court, Alathoor, on that day. It is seen from the
property list 'not marked' that though there was a direction to
produce the article on 15/04/1998, it was not seen produced on
that day and the magistrate had issued a memo to the Excise
Inspector to produce the same, by order dated 16/04/1998 and it
is seen that on 17/04/1998 with a new property list, they produced
same cannases not produced the entire articles in the same
condition it was produced as per the earlier property list, at the
time when it was produced on 17/04/1998, the cannases were
empty. No permission was obtained from the Court for destruction
of the articles. But it is seen from Ext. P8 that he had got
Crl.R.P.651/2013
2025:KER:27260
ratification from the Assistant Excise Commissioner for
destroying the toddy. Though it was done as per R.8 of the Kerala
Abkari Disposal of Confiscation Articles Rule, 1996 and a reading
of that Rule will go to show that, it will be applicable only in cases
where confiscation has been ordered by the authority. So under
the circumstances, it cannot be said that there was no possibility
for tampering the articles before the same was produced in Court,
though the same was produced earlier on 10/04/1998 before the
magistrate who was in charge of the jurisdictional magistrate at
that time with the direction to produce the same on 15/04/1998,
but it was not produced on that day. Later it was produced on
getting a memo from the concerned Court, that too after
destroying the toddy said to have been seized from the vehicle
without orders of the Court. Further in the absence of specimen
seal impression of the seal used for sealing the article having been
produced in Court and in the absence of producing and marking
the forwarding note which is expected to contain the specimen seal
impression of the seal used for sealing the sample for the purpose
of enabling the chemical examiner to verify and satisfy regarding
the genuineness of the sample produced for examination, it cannot
be said that the prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt
that the articles were produced in Court in the same condition in
which it was seized and it reached the chemical examiner's lab in a
tamper proof condition and the chemical analysis report relates to
the representative sample said to have been taken from the large
quantity of contraband article alleged to have been seized from the
possession of the accused. If this was not proved to the satisfaction
of the Court, then it cannot be said that the prosecution had
succeeded in bringing home the complexity of the accused in the
commission of the crime and that benefit must be given to the
accused. This was so held in the decision reported in Sasidharan v.
State of Kerala [2007 KHC 3404: 2007 (1) KLT 720], Joseph v.
State of Kerala [2009 (4) KHC 537: 2009 (2) KLD 915: 2010 (1)
KLT SN 18] and Majeedkutty v. The Excise Inspector, Kollam
Range [2015 (1) KHC 424: 2015 (1) KLD 262 : 2015 (1) KLT 624].
These aspects were not properly considered by the Court below
before coming to the conclusion that the prosecution has proved
the case against the accused beyond reasonable doubt and
Crl.R.P.651/2013
2025:KER:27260
consequential conviction entered is unsustainable in law and the
same is liable to be set aside.’
19.
Upon hearing the submission of the counsel and perused
the records, I am of the view that the prosecution has failed to prove the case
beyond reasonable doubt. The impugned judgment is liable to be set aside,
in my view.
In the light of the above discussion, I am of the considered opinion
that the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside. Both the trial court and
the appellate court overlooked serious illegalities which cut the very root of
the prosecution story.
In the result,
(i)
Criminal revision petition is allowed.
(ii)
The impugned judgment is set aside.
(iii)
The revision petitioner/2nd accused is acquitted and he is
set at liberty.
(iv)
The bail bond, if any, executed by the revision
petitioner stands cancelled.
(v)
Fine, if any, paid by him shall be refunded.
Sd/-
K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
Sbna/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review