Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 30.07.2026
Judgment delivered on: 17.08.2026
Judgment uploaded on: As per Digital Signature~
#
CNR No. DLHC014172602018
+
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018
RAMA CONSTRUCTION CO
.....APPELLANT
versus
DELHI STATE INDUSTRIAL & INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD
.....RESPONDENT
#
CNR No. DLHC010003732018
+
FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
DELHI STATE INDUSTRIAL & INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD
.....APPELLANT
versus
M/S RAMA CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
.....RESPONDENT
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Appellant
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Avinash Trivedi and Mr. Rahul
Aggarwal, Advs. for Rama Construction
Company.
:
Ms. Tajinder Virdi, Adv. for DSIIDC.
Mr. Vikrant Narayan Vasudeva, Adv. for
DSIIDC.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J.
1.
These two appeals under Section 37 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (‘the Act’) arise from the same impugned order of
the learned Single Judge dated 10.09.2018 in OMP (COMM.) 250/2016, and
as such, are being decided together by this common order. For the sake of
convenience, the appellant and the respondent in FAO(OS)(COMM)
277/2018 (who are inversely the respondent and the appellant in
FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019) shall be referred to hereinafter as ‘Rama
Construction Company’ and ‘DSIIDC’ respectively
2.
At the outset, we may narrate a brief factual background of the
present controversy. DSIIDC had awarded Rama Construction Company the
tender for “construction of pakka school building for Government school at
Gazipur” for an amount of Rs. 4,93,84,902/- vide letter dated 10.01.2005.
Pursuant thereto, an agreement dated 24.03.2005 was executed between the
parties.
3.
Disputes arose between the parties and a Sole Arbitrator was
appointed by DSIIDC. Though various claims made by Rama Construction
Company were allowed by the Arbitrator, and some were challenged before
the learned Single Judge, this appeal is limited to the decision of the learned
Single Judge with respect to claims no. 17, 18 and 20.4. The petition under
Section 34 of the Act was disposed of, rejecting the challenge made by
DSIIDC to claim no. 18 and holding that claim no. 17 shall be restricted to
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
Rs.4,07,218/- as against an amount of Rs. 19,52,087/- granted by the learned
Arbitrator, and also reducing the interest granted under claim no. 20.4 from
10% to 8% on the remaining claims.
4.
The conclusion of the learned Single Judge on claim no. 17, which is
reproduced below, has been challenged by Rama Construction Company in
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018.
“The Arbitrator hence considered final bill no.-2 in
order to award Claim No.-17. The claimed amount
under Claim No.-17 was only Rs.22,98,591/-. This is
also as per the rejoinder submissions, CD-17. Since,
the amount claimed is only Rs22,98,591/- and the
amount already paid was Rs.18,91,373/-, the balance
amount would have only been Rs. 4,07,218. The
Arbitrator, therefore,_ erred in taking the claimed
amount as per CD-24 without considering the
documentation and the proceeding sheet of 3rd
November, 2012. CD-24 was admittedly submitted
pursuant to order dated 3rd June, 2013 which was just
before the passing of the award. The objection raised
by the Respondent in respect of the final bill having
been considered by the Arbitrator, CD~24 could not
have been taken into consideration. Thus, Claim No.17 is .restricted to Rs. 4,07,218/-. The absence of any
documentation in the impugned award as to the
calculations recorded on 3rd November, 2012 and
sudden increase in Claim no.-17 just before passing of
the award lends credence to the case of the Petitioner
that an inflated calculation has been wrongly
considered by the Arbitrator.”
5.
On the issue of interest, the learned Single Judge has held on the
remaining claims, the interest shall be 8%, as against the 10% granted by the
Arbitrator. This modification has been challenged in this appeal.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
6.
Similarly, the finding of the learned Single Judge in claim no. 18,
reproduced below, has been challenged by DSIIDC in FAO(OS)(COMM)
6/2019.
“14. Further, no details whatsoever were given to
substantiate the argument that the increase in the value
of the work was not because of increase in quantum of
work but on account of increase in cost of materials. In
the absence of the same, the challenge to this is
untenable.”
CLAIM NO. 17
7.
On claim no. 17, the submission of Mr. Avinash Trivedi, the learned
counsel for Rama Construction Company is primarily that the learned Single
Judge could not have modified the award rendered by the Arbitrator and
reduced the same from Rs. 19,52,087/- to Rs.4,07,218/-. The claim is
relatable to price escalation as governed by Clause 10CC of the Agreement.
The Arbitrator held that the delay in the work was attributable to DSIIDC
and hence, Rama Construction Company is entitled to escalation of the
entire period of execution of work.
8.
The claim initially made by Rama Construction Company was for an
amount of Rs. 11,05,080/-. It is a conceded position that an amount of Rs.
18,91,373/- (Rs. 13,94,312/- + Rs. 4,97,061/-) was paid by DSIIDC to Rama
Construction Company. For determining the escalation, Rama Construction
Company relied on the Base Price Index of September 2004, as the Index of
August 2004 was not available at the time. When the Index for August 2004
became available, the claim was revised and increased to Rs. 22,98,591/- by
a way of a subsequent amendment application, which was allowed. This
increase is primarily based on the index of August 2004.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
9.
The Arbitrator instead of the claimed amount of Rs. 22,98,591/-,
granted an amount of Rs. 19,52,087/-, by relying upon CD-24, which is the
revised calculation statement filed by Rama Construction Company. The
conclusion of the Arbitrator on claim no. 17 is as under:“(viii). In view of my discussion as above I hold that
Claimant are entitled to the escalation payment for the
whole work and that too with base Price Index of
August 2006. The work as measured quarter wise, 8th
and 9th in particular, and as also verified by the
Respondent during the hearings from the MBs, has
been considered by the Claimant in their revised
calculations in statement CD-24. The total admissible
amount works out to Rs.38,43,460/- out of which a sum
of Rs.18,91,373/-is already paid against Bills No.1 and
2. The balance amount still due is Rs.19,52.0872 and
the same is awarded in favour of the Claimant.”
10.
The aforesaid would reveal that the conclusion drawn by the
Arbitrator is that the total admissible amount under the said claim works out
to Rs. 38,46,460/- out of which, Rs. 18,91,373/- having already been paid,
Rama Construction Company shall be entitled to balance amount of
Rs.19,52,087/-.
11.
The submission of Ms. Tajinder Virdi, the learned counsel for
DSIIDC is that the Arbitrator had failed to consider the proceeding sheets
dated 03.11.2012, calculations were submitted in respect of escalation
payable, and Rama Construction Company itself had agreed that only an
amount of Rs. 7,65,301/- was due. According to her, therefore, the
Arbitrator could not have granted any amount in excess of Rs. 7,65,301/-.
She has also submitted that the learned Single Judge has rightly held that the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
Arbitrator erred in relying upon CD-24 without considering the objections
raised by DSIIDC on its applicability.
12.
The learned Single Judge, while setting aside the conclusion of the
Arbitrator, held that the revised claim being for Rs. 22,98,591/-, and Rs.
18,91,373/- having been paid, Rama Construction Company is only entitled
to balance amount of Rs. 4,07,218/-. It was held that the Arbitrator erred in
taking the claim amount as per CD-24 without considering the
documentation and the proceeding sheet dated 03.11.2012. CD-24 is the
revised calculations given by Rama Construction Company to contend that
the total admissible amount works out to Rs. 38,43,460/-, out of which Rs.
18,91,373/- has already been paid against final bill nos. 1 and 2.
13.
Relevant part of the proceeding sheet dated 03.11.2012, reads as
under:
“3. Claim No.17. (10CC):
(i). Rt submitted a statement, which was submitted
earlier by the Ct under his letter Dt 16.7.07 to the Rt,
Pg. 10/RD-9, after checking its calculations, and the
same was marked as RD-10. The amount claimed by
the Ct in his SOC was Rs 11,05,080/- However, due to
calculation mistakes, the same works out to Rs
7,65,301/- as detailed below and this change is agreed
to by both Parties. Pg 10/RD-9 refers
Total gross amount of 2nd Escalation Bill inclusive of
1st Escalation Bill
= Rs.26,56,674/Less already paid (i) against 1st Bill Rs. 13,94,312/(Net was Rs. 13,21,194/-)(ii) against 2nd Bill Rs. 4,97,061/Total Rs 18,91,373/(-) Rs. 18,91,373/Hence balance amount as per Claim = Rs. 7,65,301/(ii). Rr stated that the above statement as prepared by
Ct has following deficiencies
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
a. The Labour rate as per Clause 10CC, Pg.99/Agmt,
the Li is minimum wages in Rupees of an unskilled
adult male mazdoor fixed under rules as applicable on
the last date of the quarter previous to the one under
consideration. The Ct has, however, taken the average
of the wages of the three months of the quarter under
consideration
b. The figures of gross value of work done for the 3rd
and 4th quarters of the year 2005, are not as per the
RA Bills, though the sum of the two figures comes out
to be unchanged.
c. The value of work done considered by the Ct for the
8th quarter ie Nov. 06 to Jan 07, is Rs. 1,11,69874/whereas it should be Rs. 52,08,147/-.
d. After above corrections Rt has worked the Balance
amount as per Claim as Rs.2,08,551/-against the figure
of Rs.7,65,301/-.
(iii) Rt further stated that they had already paid
escalation under 10CC for the work done upto the
stipulated Date of Completion, which according to
them is 30.11.2006, ie for the work paid upto 16th RA
Bill, list of RA Bills at Pg. No.3/RD-7 refers.
(iv). Rt may offer his comments on quantification given
by the Ct in CD-17. The calculations of the amount
claimed may be shown separately for the period
beyond the stipulated date of completion already
decided by the AT, i.e.22.1.2007 and for the period
beyond that, by the Ct and commented upon by the Rt
there after. I
(v). Ct filed an amendment application Dt.3.11.2012
for this Claim and the same was marked as CD-20. Rt
may furnish his comments on it by 30.11.2012.
(vi). Hearing was adjourned at this stage and as
decided in consultation with both the Parties the next
hearing will be held on 15.12.2012 at 11.00 hrs at 87,
Ankur Aptts, 7, L.P. Extension Delhi-110092.”
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
14.
The aforesaid proceedings also refer to the fact that Rama
Construction Company had filed an application to amend the claim on
03.11.2012, marked as CD-20. The DSIIDC in paragraph 8 of its reply took
the following stand:
“8. That the contents of Para 8 are denied as
incorrect. It is denied that the revised amount of
escalation under Clause 10CC, based on the initial
base cost index for August 2004 and for civil
components of construction materials worked out as
per CD-17 dated 01.10.2012 is Rs.22,98,591/-. It is
submitted that there is no due amount under Clause
10CC payable by the Respondent to the Claimant.”
15.
Even in paragraph 11 of the reply, DSIIDC opposed the attempt of
Rama Construction Company to revise the amount to Rs. 22,98,591/-.
16.
In the proceedings held on 16.02.2013, the Arbitrator allowed the
application for amendment, stating the following:
“1.1. On 1.10.2012 before commencement of their presentation on
this Claim, Ct had filed their Rejoinder for this Claim vide
document Dt.1.10.2012, CD-17. In this Rejoinder they had prayed
that under the circumstances they may be allowed to revise the
amount of this claim from Rs.11,05,080/- to Rs.22,98,591/- under
Section 23(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and
that will be in the interest of justice. The same prayer was
reiterated by them in their document Dt.3.11.2012, CD-20. This
amendment in the claim has been objected to by the Rt on account
of (i). Issue of claim towards cost index of August 2004 was not
taken in SOC nor prior to filing of the present claim petition and
the issue is time barred (ii). Escalation is not payable for extended
contract period. (iii). Ct had agreed not to claim extra for delay in
work. (iv). Ct is trying to change the subject matter of the dispute
as well as is trying to refer to a complete new cause of action
which was never referred to present Arbitral proceedings and (v).
Ct is barred from raising such a dispute when the matter has
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
reached the final arguments. Rt's documents RD-9 and RD-11
refer.
1.2. I have perused the documents submitted by the Parties and
submissions made by them. The reference of this Claim made by
the competent authority i.e. Chief Engineer, reads "Payment for
escalation under clause 10CC paid less than due". Below this
subject matter is given the break up of the amount claimed. The
amendment sought by the Ct does not in any way change the
subject matter of the claim as it remains the same i.e. the
"Payment for escalation under clause 10CC paid less than due". It
is only the details of the amount claimed which are sought to be
modified by the Ct. No specific cause of action is mentioned in the
claim referred. Whether the claim or part of it is barred by
limitation, or not admissible as per terms and conditions of the
contract etc, are matters to be deliberated upon later after the
issue of allowing proposed amendment is decided. It is also not
correct to say that the issue is being raised at the final arguments
stage when the fact is that the amendment issue has been raised
before commencement of the arguments. The Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, is a specific Act which applies to
Arbitration. Its Clause 23(3) reads as follows.
"23(3) Unless otherwise agreed by the parties, wither party
may amend or supplement his claim or defence during the
course of the arbitral proceedings. unless the arbitral
tribunal considers it inappropriate to allow the amendment
or supplement having regard to the delay in making it."
Under the circumstances as explained above, I do not consider it
inappropriate to allow the amendment sought by the Ct and as
such the same is allowed.”
17.
The learned Single Judge in paragraph 9 of the impugned judgment
has held as under:
“9. A perusal of Clause 10CC makes it clear that the All India
Wholesale Price Index as on the date of tender is the applicable
index. It is a fact that the initial claim was filed on the basis of
the September, 2004 index. This is clear from a reading of the
proceeding sheet dated 3rd June, 2013. The initial Claim No.Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
17 was to the tune of Rs.11,05,080/-, which was revised by
filing a subsequent amendment due to which the claim was
increased to Rs.22,98,591/-, in the rejoinder submissions. The
specific averment by the Respondent in para 17.9 of the
rejoinder submission is as under:
“17.9 The claimant submits herewith a statement
with detailed calculations of escalation under clause
10CC showing net payable amount of Rs.22,98,591/to the claimant. In this respect it is submitted as
follows:
(i) The claimant submitted tender for this work on
16.08.2004. The index for civil components of
construction materials during August 2004 was
applicable as initial index. Initial index for August
2004 was not available when payment of escalation
bill under clause 10CC was pending for payment. In
these circumstances, the claimant had requested
vide C-23 dated 11.12.2006 (page 42) to pay the
escalation bill by adopting the index for September
2004 on provisional basis and the bill will be revised
when the index for August 2004 would be available.
The index for escalation under clause 10CC adopted
as initial cost index for August 2004 (203.94) is
submitted herewith.”
This amendment was allowed on 16th February, 2013 in terms
of Section 23 (3) of the Arbitration Act. The use of the All India
Wholesale Price Index for construction material was
substituted as per the Correction Slip for General Conditions of
Contract for CPWD Works 2003 (hereinafter „Correction
Slip‟), which incorporated corrections up to 4 th April 2003.
Thus, no fault can be found with the fact that the Index for
August, 2004 was considered by the Arbitrator. The objection,
however, raised by Mrs. Salwan is in respect of the fact that the
proceeding sheet dated 3rd November, 2012, specifically
recorded that the balance amount as per the claim i.e. Claim
No.-17 would only be Rs.7,65,301/- based on RD-2 i.e. final bill
no.-2. The relevant portion of the said order reads as under:
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
“3. Claim No.17: (10CC) (i). Rt submitted a
statement, which was submitted earlier by the Ct
under his letter Dt16.7.07 to the Rt, Pg.10/RD-9, after
checking its calculations, and the same was marked
as RD-10. The amount claimed by the Ct in his SOC
was Rs.11,05,080/However, due to calculation mistakes, the same works
out to Rs.7,65,301/- as detailed below and this change
is agreed to by both Parties. Pg.10/RD-9 refers.
Total gross amount of Ct’s 2nd Escalation Bill
inclusive
of
1st
Escalation
Bill
=Rs.26,56,674/Less already paid (i)against 1st Bill Rs.13,94,312/(Net was Rs.13,21,194/-)(ii)against 2nd Bill Rs. 4,97,061/Total
Rs.18,91,373/(-)
Rs.18,91,373/Hence, balance amount as per
Claim
= Rs.7,65,301/”
The Learned Arbitrator has, while dealing with Claim No.-17
clearly held that though by the time the final award was passed,
the third bill i.e. final bill no.-3 was submitted, the difference
between the final bill no.-2 and final bill no.-3 was not much.
The Arbitrator observed as under:
“(a). Two escalation bills No.1, Dt. 17.7.2006 and
No.2, Dt. 16.7.2007 submitted by the Claimant were
paid by the Respondent after some adjustments in the
amounts. As per Claimant the Escalation Bill No.2
was for the whole work as the work was completed by
Jan.'2007, though the Respondent had recorded the
date of completion as 5.3.2007. In support of the
same Claimant relied upon the final bill as submitted
by them on 28.5.2007 as per which value of work
done, for agreement items only on which 10CC is
payable, is Rs.5,28,74,627/- and the Escalation bill
No.2 is also for almost the same value of the work
done of Rs. 5,28,51,262/-. The difference is negligible
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
and is inconsequential. The 3rd bill had to be
submitted by the Claimant as 2nd bill was not paid in
full. But for the claim under consideration I do not
intend to look into this Bill No.3 as the same is of no
relevance. Based on the above facts I, however, hold
that the escalation bill No.2 was for the whole work
which as per the Claimant was completed by January,
2007 and accordingly the escalation bill No.2 also
showed the last quarter for which 10CC was claimed
as Nov. & Dec.2006 and Jan 2007 i.e 8th Qr. In the
amended claim also the Claimant has claimed for the
whole work only.”
The Arbitrator hence considered final bill no.-2 in order to
award Claim No.-17. The claimed amount under Claim No.-17
was only Rs.22,98,591/-. This is also as per the rejoinder
submissions, CD-17. Since, the amount claimed is only
Rs.22,98,591/- and the amount already paid was Rs.18,91,373/,
the balance amount would have only been Rs. 4,07,218. The
Arbitrator, therefore, erred in taking the claimed amount as per
CD-24 without considering the documentation and the
proceeding sheet of 3rd November, 2012. CD-24 was admittedly
submitted pursuant to order dated 3rd June, 2013 which was
just before the passing of the award. The objection raised by
the Respondent in respect of the final bill having been
considered by the Arbitrator, CD-24 could not have been taken
into consideration. Thus, Claim No.-17 is restricted to Rs.
4,07,218/-. The absence of any documentation in the impugned
award as to the calculations recorded on 3rd November, 2012
and sudden increase in Claim no.-17 just before passing of the
award lends credence to the case of the Petitioner that an
inflated calculation has been wrongly considered by the
Arbitrator.”
18.
On a conspectus of the above, it is clear that the claim was decided by
the Arbitrator based on final bill no. 2. The conclusion of the Arbitrator that
an amount of Rs. 38,43,460/- was the total admissible amount was based on
CD-24, which was given by Rama Construction Company pursuant to the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
order dated 03.06.2013, which was merely three days prior to the passing of
the award dated 03.06.2013. The learned Single Judge held that since the
Arbitrator had based his calculation on final bill no.2, he could not have
alternatively relied upon CD-24, the applicability of which was contested by
DSIIDC. Further, the learned Single Judge held that the calculations
recorded in the proceedings sheet of 03.12.2012 were not dealt with by the
Arbitrator, and as such, accepted the case of DSIIDC that an inflated
calculation was wrongly considered by the Arbitrator.
19.
We are in agreement with the conclusion of the learned Single Judge.
The award dated 06.06.2013, despite recording that claim no. 17 is being
decided based on the final escalation bill no.2, is conspicuously silent on the
recording in the proceeding sheet/ order dated 03.12.2012, that the balance
amount for the claim, after considering final bill no. 2, is only Rs. 7,65,301/.
The said order specifically records that the amount is agreed to by both the
parties. The Arbitrator overlooked this crucial factor, and relied upon a
revised calculation statement unilaterally submitted by a party merely days
before passing the order, the applicability of which was contested by the
other party. This is an issue that goes to the root of the matter and constitutes
patent illegality under Section 34 of the Act. The learned Single Judge was
justified in holding that the Arbitrator had erred in considering an inflated
calculation to arrive at the figure of Rs. 19,52,087/-. The proceeding
sheet/order dated 03.11.2012 having clearly recorded that Rs. 13,94,312/and Rs. 4,97,061/- were already paid by DSIIDC to Rama Construction
Company against final escalation bills no. 1 and 2 respectively (the
cumulative amount being 18,91,373/-), the learned Single Judge had rightly
deducted the amount from the amended claim amount of Rs. 22,98,591/- to
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
arrive at the figure of Rs. 4,07,218/-, as the amount payable by DSIIDC
under claim no. 17.
CLAIM NO. 18
20.
Insofar as the challenge made by DSIIDC to the judgment of the
learned Single Judge on claim no. 18 is concerned, the said issue primarily
relates to the grant of incentive to Rama Construction Company on the
ground that they have completed the project before the extended stipulated
date of completion. The Arbitrator allowed the claim in favour of Rama
Construction Company, and considering the tendered value of Rs.
4,93,84,907/- and the value of work done on the basis of stipulated date of
completion, which was extended by 226 days, awarded a bonus of 1% per
month as incentive, subject to a maximum of 5%, which works to Rs.
26,69,145/-. The case of DSIIDC is that the Arbitrator has wrongly held that
the additional work was awarded to Rama Construction Company when, in
fact, the value of the work changed only because of increase in the price of
material, and not the quantum of work. It is their case that incentive would
be payable as per Clause 2A of the GCC only if the work is completed
before the extended date of contract by reason of increase in the quantum of
work and not otherwise. The case of Rama Construction Company is that the
calculation by the Arbitrator is justified as DSIIDC itself had submitted that
15% additional work was awarded to the respondent.
21.
Clause 2A of the GCC reads as under:
“2A. In case, the contractor completes the work ahead of
scheduled completion time, a bonus ® 1 % (one percent) of the
tendered value per month computed on per day basis, shall be
payable to the contractor, subject to a maximum limit of 5%
(five percent) of the tendered value. The amount of bonus, if
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
payable shall be paid along with final bill after completion of
work.”
22.
The conclusion of the Arbitrator is as under:
“(iv). I have carefully examined and analyzed the submissions
made by both the Parties. It is an undisputed fact that incentive
(bonus) Clause 2A on Pg. 222 of the Agmt, is part and parcel of
the Agmt entered into between the Parties. This Clause 2A is at
para 10 of the ‘Corrections Slip for General Conditions Of
Contract for CPWD Works 2003 starting from Pg. 219 of the
Agmt. Paras 27 to 29 of these corrections, deal with
modifications in Escalation Clause 10CC of the Agmt which
has been followed by both the Parties and Contractor’s Claim
No. 17 for balance escalation is also based on these
modifications in Clause 10CC only. Applicability of these
corrections under that Claim has never been objected to or
disputed by the Respondent. Inconsistent approach of the
Respondent in respect of these two Clauses by arguing that
Clause 2A is not applicable whereas Clause 10CC which has
already been implemented based on which payment also made,
and both of which are forming part of the same Document of
the Agmt, cannot be appreciated. Therefore the Respondent’s
stand that Clause 2A is not applicable in the instant case is
totally devoid of any merit. Entry at Sl No. 4 in EOT Proforma
Pt II, Pg 132/CD-2, filled by the Respondent themselves,
reveals that a percentage of 80% has been considered for that
hindrance and not 100% to work out the period of extension,
and as such it is wrong on the part of the Respondent to say
now that the hindrances were not calculated by them on a
proportionate basis. The stipulated date of completion as
already decided earlier, is 22.1.2007 and not 30.11.2006 as
stated by Respondent EE. Clause 12.1.1 of the Agmt provides
that time for completion in the event of deviations resulting in
additional cost, be extended in the proportion which the
additional cost bears to the original tendered value plus 25% of
the time so calculated or such further additional time as may be
reasonable. Hence minimum 25% extra has to be considered
and not 15% as considered by the Respondent. The scheduled
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
completion time as per the contract was 22 months. On account
of hindrances which are attributable to Respondent such as
delay in issue of revised drawing for FF slab, delay in
providing of electrical conduits, stoppage of work of 3rd and
4th floors by DD and extra time required on account of
additional work, the scheduled completion time gets
contractually extended by 226 days. Against this the additional
time taken by the Claimant Contractor was only (5.3.200722.1.2007)=42 days. Thus the work was completed (226-42) =
184 days before the deemed extended scheduled completion
time.”
23.
The learned Single Judge has in paragraph 13 of the impugned order,
observing that the above findings are on a complete appreciation of the facts,
held that the conclusion drawn by the Arbitrator is justified. Further, by
referring to the judgment of this Court in Union of India v. N.N. Buildcon
Pvt. Ltd., FAO (OS) 438/2015, the learned Single Judge rejected the
contentions on behalf of DSIIDC. We find no reason to interfere with the
conclusion of the learned Single Judge.
24.
With regard to the submission that the Arbitrator failed to consider
that the value of the work increased due to the higher cost of material and
not due to additional work being allocated, the learned Single Judge held as
under:
“13...
These findings being on a complete appreciation of facts, the
only submission of Mrs. Salwan is that the Arbitrator did not
consider that the quantum of work was not increased, but the
value of the work was increased due to higher cost of the
material used. This fact ought to be established by independent
evidence. The DSIIDC had pleaded as under:
“That it is humbly submitted that the contents of Claim
No.18 being false and misleading are denied as untenable.
That it is humbly submitted that the actual date of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
completion is beyond the stipulated date of completion.
Hence, incentive is not admissible.”
14. Further, no details whatsoever were given to substantiate
the argument that the increase in the value of the work was not
because of increase in quantum of work but on account of
increase in cost of materials. In the absence of the same, the
challenge to this is untenable.”
25.
The Arbitrator has given a finding of fact that the scheduled
completion of time got contractually extended by 226 days due to the delay
on part of DSIIDC and also on account of additional work. In the impugned
order, the learned Single Judge held that since DSIIDC has failed to provide
any evidence to substantiate its claim that the increase in value of work is
not attributable to additional work, but to increase in cost of material, such a
finding cannot be faulted. We are in agreement with the views taken by the
Arbitrator and the learned Single Judge.
26.
Much reliance has been placed by Ms. Virdi for DSIIDC on the
judgment in the case of Navyuga Engineering Co. P. Ltd. V. Public Works
Department and Anr., FAO (OS) 264/2014, to contend that the original
scheduled time cannot be extended by the Arbitrator in the absence of any
specific agreement between the parties, and as such Clause 2A is not
applicable in the present case. However, such a contention flies in the face
of Clause 12.1 of the Agreement, which, as held by the Arbitrator, provides
that in the event of deviations resulting in additional cost, time for
completion shall be extended in the proportion which the additional cost
bears to the original tendered value, plus 25% of the time so calculated or
such further additional time as may be reasonable.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
27.
Further, as canvassed by Mr. Trivedi for Rama Construction
Company, in Navyuga Engineering (supra) there was no contention to any
additional work being carried out, contributing to the extension or increase
in value of work. Per contra, in N.N. Buildcon (supra), this Court observed
that the time for completion was extended by four months due to extra work
awarded to the contractor. We reproduce the relevant part of N.N. Buildcon
(supra) as under.
“8. In the present case, the period of completion available to
the contractor was 14 months. Because of additional work
awarded to the contractor, the contractor would be entitled to
additional time of four months i.e. the total time available to the
contractor to complete the originally stipulated work and the
additional work was 18 months. In addition, the contractor
would be entitled to the benefit of the time during which delay
occurred on account hindrances caused by the employer. In the
present case, the delay in completion of the work as held by the
Arbitrator is 5.3 months only. While computing the period
taken by the Arbitrator to complete the work, the period of
hindrances and delay have to be excluded from the time taken
by the contractor. The Arbitrator has accordingly worked out
the period of delay comprising of hindrances as 9.7 months
from which 5.3 months have been excluded and the balance left
was 4.4 months. This period of 4.4 months will enure to the
credit of the contractor and clearly, the contractor has
completed the work in a period less than the period available to
the contractor. The originally stipulated period available to the
contractor was 14 months and the period of hindrances
(including time for extra work) as worked out was 9.7 months
thereby totaling to 23.7 months. The work has been completed
with a delay of 5.3 months. This added to the stipulated period
of 14 months would make it 19.3 months. If this is excluded
from the total period as available to the contractor (i.e. 23.7
month), the balance left is 4.4 months.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
9. As per Clause 2A, the contractor would be entitled to bonus
if the work is completed ahead of the stipulated date. Clearly,
the Arbitral Tribunal has correctly computed the period and
has rightly held that the claimant was entitled to bonus. We find
no infirmity in the impugned judgment whereby the learned
Single Judge has affirmed the findings of the Arbitral Tribunal
and dismissed the objections raised by the appellant.”
28.
Going by the above, we are of the view that the judgment in Navyuga
Engineering (supra) is distinguishable on facts and that the learned Single
Judge was justified in relying upon the judgment in the case of N.N.
Buildcon (supra), which is more in consonance with the facts of the present
case.
29.
As such, we are in complete agreement with the conclusion of the
learned Single Judge with regard to this issue as well.
CLAIM NO. 20.4
30.
Insofar as the challenge to claim No. 20.4 in FAO(OS)(COMM.)
277/2018 is concerned, we note that the learned Single Judge has reduced
the interest granted by the Arbitrator on claims other than escalation from
10% to 8%. The reduction was made by the learned Single Judge
considering the fact that the matter has remained pending in arbitration for
years, though the award of the contract was in the year 2005 and the date of
completion was 2007, and no major delay was caused by the respondent,
Further, it was also noted that the respondent was duly represented in the
arbitration proceedings and had also paid a substantial part of the bills. The
law with regard to power of the Court under Section 34 of the Act to modify
the interest granted by the Arbitral Tribunal has been conclusively settled by
the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Gayatri Balasamy v. M/s
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
ISG Novasoft Technologies Limited, (2015) 7 SCC 1, wherein, the majority
opinion held as under:“72. The next question that arises is: do courts possess the
power to declare or modify interest, especially post award
interest? In respect of pendente lite interest, Section 31(7)(a)
(Annexure A), states that unless otherwise agreed by the
parties, the arbitral tribunal may include in its sum for the
award, interest, at such rate it deems reasonable on whole or
part of the money for whole or part of the period on which the
cause of action arose and the date on which the award is made.
In respect of post-award interest, Section 31(7)(b) (Annexure
A) states that unless an award provides for interest on a sum
directed to be paid by it, the sum will carry an interest at a 2%
higher rate than the current rate of interest prevalent on the
date of the award, from the date of the award till the date of
payment. The explanation defines the expression ‘current rate
of interest’.
73. There can be instances of violation of Section 31(7)(a),
and the pendente lite interest awarded may be contrary to the
contractual provision. We are of the opinion that, in such
cases, the court while examining objections under Section 34
of the 1996 Act will have two options. First is to set aside the
rate of interest or second, recourse may be had to the powers
of remand under Section 34(4).
74. For the post award interest in terms of Section 31(7)(b), the
courts will retain the power to modify the interest where the
facts justify such modification. This is why the standard rate
stipulated in clause (b) applies when the award itself does not
specify the applicable post award interest. There can be a
situation where the party to be paid money is at fault and is
guilty of delay which may require a modification in the rate of
interest. In the absence of grant of post award interest in the
award, the court also possesses the power to grant post award
interest. Clearly, as per the legislative mandate, it is not the
sole prerogative of the arbitrator.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
75. Compare Section 31 of the 1996 Act with Section 31 of the
Model Law. While both sections are titled similarly – “Form
and Contents of Award” – only the 1996 Act addresses interest
in Section 31(7). The Model Law does not provide standards
governing the determination of interest rates. Thus, Section
31(7) is a unique creation of the Indian legislature. It was not
borrowed from the Model Law. Specifically, under Section
31(7)(b), the legislature has established a standard rate of
interest to guide the arbitrator’s discretion when it comes to
determining the post-award interest rate. While the arbitrator
retains his flexibility based on facts and circumstances of the
case, the standard set by the legislature must weigh in on their
consideration. Further, as there is a standard prescribed by the
legislature, the post-award interest awarded can be scrutinized
by courts against the standards prescribed.
76. Our reasoning is bolstered when considering the practical
aspects. Arbitral tribunals, when determining post-award
interest, cannot foresee future issues that may arise. Post
award interest is inherently future-oriented and depends on
facts and circumstances that unfold after the award is issued.
Since the future is unpredictable and unknown to the arbitrator
at the time of the award, it would be unreasonable to suggest
that the arbitrator, as a soothsayer, could have anticipated or
predicted future events with certainty. Therefore, it is
appropriate for the Section 34 court to have the authority to
intervene and modify the post-award interest if the facts and
circumstances justify such a change.
77. Inherent in the discussion above, is the court's power to
both increase or decrease the post-award interest rate. It would
be incorrect to state that the court's power to interfere with this
interest rate is limited solely to decreasing the interest rate.
Situations may arise where the rate should be increased due to
delays or obstructions in the execution of the award. Interest
rates may also fluctuate over time.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
78. However, the court, while exercising this power, must be
cautious and mindful not to overstep its role by altering the
interest rate unless there are compelling and well-founded
reasons to do so. In exercising this power, the court is not
acting in an appellate capacity, but rather under limited
authority. For instance, the 1996 Act stipulates a standard
post-award interest rate. When the statute itself benchmarks a
standard, unless there are special and specific reasons, the rate
of interest stipulated by the statute should be applied.
79. Nevertheless, this limited power is significant, as it can help
avoid further rounds of litigation. Without it, the court may be
forced to set aside the entire award or order a fresh round of
arbitration because of an erroneous interest rate rather than
simply adjusting this rate.”
(emphasis supplied)
31.
As can be seen from the above, in case the Court finds any illegality
in the pendente lite interest granted by the Arbitral Tribunal, it only has two
options:-
32.
(i)
To set aside the rate of interest granted; or
(ii)
To remand the matter under Section 34(4) of the Act.
The power of the Court to modify the rate of interest is only available
when the interest granted is post-award interest. In the present case, as the
10% interest granted by the Arbitrator was pendente lite, the learned Single
Judge could not have modified the same. If there was any illegality in the
grant of interest, the learned Single Judge could only have either set aside
the same, or remanded the matter back to the Arbitrator. We note that the
learned Single Judge did not find any illegality in the interest granted, but
modified it for the reason that the matter has been pending in arbitration for
a long time. We are of the view that in light of law laid down in Gayatri
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
Balasami (supra), the learned Single Judge erred in modifying the rate of
pendente lite interest granted by the Arbitrator. We set aside the conclusion
of the learned Single Judge in claim no. 20.4, and uphold the decision of the
Arbitrator granting 10% interest pendente lite.
CONCLUSION
33.
In view of the foregoing, the challenges made to the impugned
judgment with regard to the findings of the learned Single Judge on claim
nos. 17 and 18 are devoid of merit and are rejected. The challenge to the
finding of the learned Single Judge on claim no. 20.4 is sustained, and the
impugned judgment is set aside to this extent. The appeals are disposed of.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
AUGUST 17, 2026/sr
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
10:02:02
FAO(OS)(COMM) 277/2018 and FAO(OS)(COMM) 6/2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review