Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 270/2026, CM APPL. 1213-1214/2026
RAM SHARAN
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Ankit Bhadoria, Mr. Umesh
Singh, Ms. Karishma, Ms. Nisha
Kumari, Mr. Vijay Partap and Mr.
Sunil Rawat, Advocates.
versus
CENTRAL BANK OF INDIA AND ANR
Through:
.....Respondents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
%
1.
ORDER
09.01.2026
This writ petition challenges charge-sheet dated 31st March, 2014,
inquiry report dated 9th March, 2015 and order dated 15th May, 2015 passed
by the Disciplinary Authority, imposing the penalty of dismissal from
service on the Petitioner. The dismissal has been affirmed in appeal and
again in review.
Factual Background
2.
The background relevant to the present petition is as follows:
2.1.
The Petitioner joined Respondent No. 1 Bank as a clerk on 23 rd April,
1990. He was promoted to the post of Manager Scale-I on 12th June, 2006
and thereafter to Middle Management Grade Scale-II on 11th June, 2011.
2.2.
He was posted at the Khera Bajhera Branch, District Meerut, with
effect from 12th June, 2011. He served there until 7th August, 2013. He was
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
thereafter posted at Sahukara Branch, Bareilly from 8th August, 2013 to 14th
June, 2014, and subsequently at Navyug Market Branch, Ghaziabad.
2.3.
During an audit conducted in June, 2012 for the year 2011-2012, the
audit team raised objections relating to certain irregularities. The Bank
called upon the Petitioner to explain the alleged lapses pertaining to the
period when he was posted at Khera Bajhera Branch. A memorandum dated
2nd January, 2014 was issued in relation to the period from 20th June, 2011 to
7th August, 2013.
A charge-sheet dated 31st March, 2014 followed. A departmental
2.4.
inquiry was conducted, culminating in an inquiry report dated 9th March,
2015, which held the substantial charges proved. Acting on the inquiry
report and the Petitioner’s representation, the Disciplinary Authority
imposed the penalty of dismissal from service by order dated 15 th May,
2015.
2.5.
The statutory appeal against this order was dismissed on 26th October,
2015. The Petitioner thereafter preferred review. The review petition, though
stated to have been filed in 2016, was ultimately decided by the Reviewing
Authority by order dated 25th November, 2024, affirming the dismissal and
rejecting, inter alia, the contentions of procedural unfairness, caste-based
bias, alleged insufficiency of evidence, and disproportionality of penalty.
The Reviewing Authority recorded that no new material was brought in
review, and that the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority had
dealt with the matter independently and in accordance with the Central Bank
of India Officer Employees (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1976,
including Regulation 4(j), to the following effect:
“Observations & findings of the Disciplinary Authority:The Disciplinary authority has accorded his Charge wise verdict as follows:
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
Considering all the verdict of charge, the Disciplinary Authority imposed
the following punishment to the CSOE:
“Dismissal, which shall ordinarily be a disqualification for future
employment in terms of Regulation 4(j) of Central Bank of India Officers
Employees (Discipline and Appeal) Regulation, 1976 as amended up to
date”.
Observations of the Appellate Authority:
The Appellate Authority has carefully perused all the relevant papers/
documents starting from issuance of memorandum 1032 dated-31.03.2024
till the passing of Final order of the Disciplinary Authority vis-à-vis appeal
dated 19.06.2015 preferred by the appellant and observed that the
principles of natural justice was duly observed during the conduct of inquiry
and full opportunity was given to the Appellant to rebut the charges levelled
against him.
While going through the appeal. The Appellate authority has observed that
the appellant has not brought in any new fact in respect of charges levelled
against him vide said memorandum. The appellate Authority find that the
appellant in his appeal only raised the point that he was awarded the harsh
punishment because he belongs to a suppressed community. In this regard,
the undersigned is of the opinion that the penalty as imposed by the
Disciplinary authority is commensurate with the gravity of the proven
charge not on the basis of caste.
In view of the above, The Appellate authority is of the opinion that this
appeal is devoid of merit and does not warrant any intervention and hence,
as Appellate authority, he confirms the punishment awarded to the
Appellant by the Disciplinary authority vide order No. DA/ELBBILASP/2015-16/11 dated-15.05.2015.
Crux of the Review Petition submitted by Mr. Ram Saran (Ex. Employee
No. 88218):
a) The employee claims that their review appeal, submitted on 24.02.2016,
was misplaced by the branch or regional office, resulting in delays. Argues
that procedural lapses by the bank should not penalize the employee.
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
b) Asserts that their dismissal and subsequent handling of the case reflect
caste-based discrimination. Claims injustice due to belonging to the Dalit
community.
c) Contends that some charges were not fully or conclusively proven.
Alleges the Disciplinary Authority acted arbitrarily, ignoring the Inquiry
Officer's partial findings and imposing an excessive penalty.
d) Denies culpability in fake CKCC loans, claiming subsequent branch
managers identified borrowers. Justifies suspicious cash and transfer
transactions in personal and family accounts as loans from relatives,
unsupported by evidence. Dismisses liability for irregular transfer entries,
claiming they were account holder actions beyond his control. Argues that
audit irregularities were routine and rectified over time, States excess
financing in CKCC loans was within revised regional guidelines, denying
any wrongdoing.
e) Asserts the punishment of dismissal is disproportionate, claiming it was
imposed without fair consideration of mitigating factors. Seeks quashing of
dismissal and reconsideration of the penalty.
OBSERVATION OF REVIEWING AUTHORITY
It is observed from the case on record that the issues raised in the instant
Petition relating to the charge have already been raised by the Petitioner in
his earlier submissions to the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate
Authority in the respective contexts. In other words, the issues raised in the
present Review Petition relating to the charges were already in the
knowledge/consideration of the Disciplinary Authority/ Appellate Authority
at the relevant time and the penalty imposed on him was after consideration
of the said issues raised by him earlier. Further, I observe that IA/DA have
dealt with the case independently and judiciously and DA has passed his
final order accordingly.
Thus, no new evidence/material as such has been produced by the Petitioner
in support of his subject Review Petition.
As the matter stands and as the records indicate, the aspects relating to the
charge raised by the Petitioner vide his Review Petition are the same in
their essence, context and the spirit as the ones raised by him before the
earlier authorities. The petition in question does not contain any new
material or evidence which could not be produced by him before the
respective authorities at the relevant time and which would alter the theme
of the case against him. His petition more or less revolves around one
aspect of accusing/alleging the Disciplinary and Appellate Authority
without any cogent reason and basis. A thorough examination of the facts
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
and evidence reveals that the contentions are baseless, and the decision to
dismiss the employee stands justified under the Central Bank of India
Officer Employees (D&A) Regulations, 1976. Contentions are as under:
1.Acknowledgement and processing of Review petition:
The employee's claim that their review application was misplaced by the
branch or regional office holds no merit. Record confirms that the review
petition was duly acknowledged by the Navyug Market Branch, Ghaziabad.
However, the petition did not reach the concerned office or authority for
disposal.
Although the stipulated timeline for disposing the review petition has
elapsed, in the interest of providing natural justice to the petitioner, the
review petition has been accepted for consideration despite the delay.
2. Allegations of Bias Due to Caste:
The claim of caste-based discrimination is unfounded and lacks supporting
evidence. The disciplinary proceedings were conducted impartially, strictly
adhering to the principles of natural justice. The findings and decisions
were based on documentary evidence and witness testimonies, with no
relevance or consideration given to the applicant's caste. The attempt to
introduce caste as a defense appears to be an afterthought to divert
attention from the gravity of the charges proven against the employee.
3. Inquiry Authority and Disciplinary Authority's Findings:
The employee's contention that the Disciplinary Authority deviated from the
Inquiry Officer's findings without due reason is incorrect. Regulation 4 of
the Central Bank of India Officer Employees (D&A) Regulations, 1976,
empowers the Disciplinary Authority to independently assess the Inquiry
Officer's findings. In this case, the authority provided a reasoned and
detailed order highlighting the substantial evidence that warranted the
employee's dismissal.
Contrary to the employee's assertions, the charges of fraudulent practices,
including sanctioning fake CKCC loans and engaging in suspicious
financial transactions, were conclusively proven based on undisputable
evidence. The claim that some charges were not fully proved does not
negate the severity of the established misconduct.
4. Financial Irregularities and Misconduct:
The employee has attempted to downplay their role in approving fake loans
and facilitating unauthorized transactions, claiming ignorance or
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
attributing responsibility to others. However, the fraudulent CKCC loans
sanctioned to the employee (e.g.. loans to Rameshwar, Horilal. and others)
demonstrated gross negligence and willful disregard of bank policies.
The employee's personal and family accounts reflected substantial cash
deposits and suspicious transactions far exceeding legitimate income levels.
The explanation provided regarding funds borrowed from relatives and
friends lacks corroboration and fails to justify the discrepancies. Transfer of
funds between accounts without proper authorization further underscores a
deliberate attempt to manipulate records for personal gain.
5. Dismissal Justified under Regulation 4(j):
The punishment of dismissal, which is ordinarily a disqualification for
future employment, is commensurate with the gravity of the employee's
misconduct. The bank cannot condone such acts of fraud and negligence
that undermine its financial integrity and operational reputation.
Conclusion of the Reviewing Authority:
The review appeal fails to provide any new or compelling evidence to
overturn the decisions of the Disciplinary Authority and Appellate
Authority. The employee's actions constitute a serious breach of trust and
professional ethics, justifying the penalty imposed.
It is respectfully submitted that the bank's decision to dismiss the employee
was appropriate, lawful, and necessary to uphold the principles of
accountability and integrity. The review appeal should, therefore, be
dismissed without any relief.
Accordingly, the penalty imposed on him does not warrant any interference/
modification at the hands of the Reviewing Authority.
1, therefore, hereby uphold the penalty imposed by the Disciplinary
Authority and confirmed by the Appellate Authority, as under:
“Dismissal, which shall ordinarily be a disqualification for future
employment in terms of Regulation 4(j) of Central Bank of India Officers
Employees (Discipline and Appeal) Regulation, 1976 as amended up to
date”.
The Review petition submitted by the petitioner stands disposed of.”
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
Petitioner’s Case
3.
Counsel for the Petitioner assails the charge-sheet dated 31st March,
2014, the inquiry report dated 9th March, 2015, and the consequent order
imposing dismissal, as also the appellate and review orders affirming the
penalty. The challenge is advanced on four broad planks: vagueness and
non-disclosure of governing norms; denial of a fair opportunity in the
inquiry;
perversity
in
findings
on
the
articles
of
charge;
and
disproportionality of the penalty. The same are summarised as follows:
Vagueness and non-disclosure of applicable norms
3.1.
It is urged that the charge-sheet is not framed in conformity with the
Central Bank of India Officer Employees (Discipline and Appeal)
Regulations, 1976. Counsel submits that the articles of charge are imprecise
and fail to specify the exact rule, circular, guideline or CKCC norm said to
have been breached. The Petitioner’s submission is that disciplinary action
predicated on alleged violation of CKCC rules is unsustainable when those
rules were not supplied to him, thereby depriving him of an effective
defence.
3.2.
The charge-sheet proceeds on a broad assertion of “irregularities”
without demonstrating any quantified loss to the Bank. It is urged that, even
on the Bank’s case, the loans were adjusted or the amounts were credited to
the concerned borrowers’ accounts, and the proceedings seek to elevate
routine audit objections into grave misconduct.
Denial of reasonable opportunity and breach of natural justice
3.3.
The next submission is that the inquiry stands vitiated for breach of
principles of natural justice. The Petitioner claims that he was denied the
benefit of an assisting officer/defence representative and, as a result, was
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
placed at a material disadvantage in meeting a multi-charge case involving
banking documentation and account trails. It is urged that the manner of the
proceedings, read as a whole, reflects denial of a meaningful opportunity of
hearing.
3.4.
Counsel also contends that the Management’s case rests substantially
on complaints and statements attributed to account holders, yet the
concerned account holders were not produced before the Inquiry Officer for
examination. This, it is argued, deprived the Petitioner of the right to
confront and cross-examine the principal source of allegations, particularly
in relation to the assertion that certain CKCC loans were “fake” or
sanctioned in the names of persons other than the real applicants.
Challenges to findings on the principal charges
3.5.
Addressing Charge No. 1, counsel submits that the allegation of
sanction of a “fake” CKCC loan is not established by legally acceptable
material. It is argued that the Bank did not prove the CKCC rules allegedly
violated, did not examine the maker/signatory of the loan documents, and
did not produce any independent verification report to substantiate the claim
that the applicant was not the genuine borrower. Counsel questions how the
Management witness identified the “real” applicant and submits that, if the
loan were indeed fictitious, the absence of any criminal complaint or
contemporaneous action by the Bank undermines the credibility of the
allegation. The Petitioner’s case is that the amount was credited to the
borrower’s account and, on that basis, the finding of “fake loan” is a
conclusion, which is a surmise.
3.6.
As regards Charge No. 2, counsel similarly disputes the finding that
the CKCC loan was sanctioned on the basis of an impersonation or a
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
substituted photograph. It is urged that the loan was sanctioned on 11 th May,
2013; the Petitioner was transferred out of the branch with effect from 7 th
August, 2013; and the account was closed on 7th September, 2013. The
Petitioner submits that the loan was fully adjusted, and no loss is shown. It is
argued that the Management relied on the complaint/statement of the
account holder (Horilal) without producing him in evidence and without
placing any comparative photograph, SDM report, field verification report,
or supporting investigation record before the Inquiry Officer. The finding is
therefore founded on unproved complaints and that suspicion has been
allowed to take the place of proof.
3.7.
Counsel places particular emphasis on the manner in which the
Disciplinary Authority dealt with Charge No. 3 (and certain other charges),
where the Inquiry Officer is stated to have returned a finding of “partly
proved”. It is urged that the Disciplinary Authority treated such charges as
fully proved without adhering to the safeguards that apply when the
Disciplinary Authority disagrees with the Inquiry Officer’s conclusions. No
adequate opportunity was afforded to the Petitioner to meet the reasons for
disagreement and that the Disciplinary Authority’s conclusion rests on
suspicion rather than a reasoned assessment of the evidence.
3.8.
With respect to Charge No. 7, counsel submits that the finding that the
Petitioner permitted diversion of CKCC funds for purposes other than croprelated activity, including to discharge an alleged vehicle loan liability of the
Bank Facilitator/1 Bank Correspondent,2 is incorrect and unsupported by the
record. It is argued that the Disciplinary Authority proceeded on assumed
“BF”
“BC”
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
linkages between transfers and alleged end-use, without producing the
governing policy or establishing a demonstrable prohibited transaction
attributable to the Petitioner. The Petitioner also disputes the specific
observation about transfer of Rs. 60,000/- from the account of the Business
Correspondent to his account, contending that it does not reflect in his
account statement and that the inference is factually erroneous.
3.9.
Similar submissions are advanced in relation to Charge Nos. 8 and 9.
It is urged that these are, in substance, audit-related irregularities arising
from operational constraints, including absence of a second officer at the
branch, and that the authorities treated procedural deviations as misconduct
without proving dishonesty or loss. In relation to Charge No. 9, the
Disciplinary Authority misread the circular pertaining to enhancement of
scale of finance, and that the Petitioner acted within the revised limits. The
Inquiry Officer had, at best, found the charge partly proved, but the
Disciplinary
Authority
escalated
the
conclusion
without
adequate
justification.
3.10. Overall, counsel submits that the findings of the Inquiry Officer, as
adopted and expanded by the Disciplinary Authority, rest on conjecture and
unproved allegations. The Petitioner relies on the settled principle that,
however strong, suspicion cannot substitute proof, and that a disciplinary
finding must be supported by cogent material.
Appellate and review orders: non-speaking and mechanical
3.11. Counsel further submits that the appellate and review orders do not
cure these defects. It is urged that the Appellate Authority and the
Reviewing Authority have not undertaken an independent appraisal of the
Petitioner’s specific grounds, have not addressed the infirmities pointed out
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
in relation to evidence and procedure, and have affirmed the penalty in a
mechanical manner. The Petitioner contends that the statutory remedies,
therefore, did not receive meaningful consideration.
Penalty: disproportionate and tainted by extraneous considerations
3.12. Finally, it is urged that the penalty of dismissal is grossly
disproportionate. Emphasis is placed on the Petitioner’s length of service,
promotions earned, and the assertion of an otherwise unblemished record. It
is argued that the authorities failed to consider mitigating circumstances,
including the alleged lack of loss to the Bank, and imposed the severest
penalty when lesser penalties were available. Counsel reiterates the plea of
bias rooted in caste-based discrimination, submitting that the harshness of
the penalty and the manner of consideration of his representations point to
an unfair approach.
Analysis and Findings
4.
The writ jurisdiction is not an appellate forum over departmental fact-
finding. Interference is warranted only if the inquiry is vitiated by breach of
natural justice, the findings are based on no evidence, the conclusion is
perverse in the Wednesbury sense, or the penalty is so disproportionate that
it shocks the conscience. The Supreme Court has repeatedly cautioned that
re-appreciation of evidence and substitution of the Court’s view for that of
the disciplinary authority is impermissible.3
5.
A disciplinary proceeding is not a criminal trial. The strict rules of the
Evidence Act do not apply, and a finding can rest on material that a
reasonable person would accept as probative in the context of service
Union of India v. P. Gunasekaran, (2015) 2 SCC 610; State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur v. Nemi Chand
Nalwaya, (2011) 4 SCC 584; B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India, (1995) 6 SCC 749.
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
discipline. The test is not proof beyond reasonable doubt, but whether there
is some evidence on which the conclusion can reasonably rest.4
6.
In the banking sector, the standard expected is exacting. A bank
officer deals with public money and institutional trust. Even where a
transaction does not crystallise into immediate pecuniary loss, serious
deviations from lending discipline, due diligence norms, and integrity
expectations can justify major penalty.5
Vagueness of the charge-sheet and “no loss to the bank”
7.
The challenge to the charge-sheet as “vague” does not survive
scrutiny. The articles of charge, as reflected in the final order, are chargespecific and event-specific: fake CKCC loans (Charge Nos. 1 and 2),
suspicious cash and transfer patterns across identified accounts (Charge No.
3), CKCC disbursements being routed and diverted through the branch’s
BC/BF ecosystem with a specific vehicle loan being serviced (Charge No.
7), reckless sanctions and a catalogue of lending irregularities tied to an
audit trail and regional office instructions (Charge No. 8), over-financing
and missing loan files (Charge No. 9), and breach of delegated powers in
sanctioning three high-value loans (Charge No. 10). These are not broad
generalities. They are allegations capable of being met, and the record shows
that they were, in fact, met through the inquiry.
8.
The submission that “no loss was caused” also does not carry the
Petitioner far. Banking misconduct is not confined to realised pecuniary
loss. A bank is entitled to insist on compliance with credit policy, KYC
discipline, security creation and registration, proper appraisal, staged
State of Haryana v. Rattan Singh, (1977) 2 SCC 491.
Disciplinary Authority-cum-Regional Manager v. Nikunja Bihari Patnaik, (1996) 9 SCC 69; Chairman
and Managing Director, United Commercial Bank v. P.C. Kakkar, (2003) 4 SCC 364.
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
disbursement, end-use monitoring and avoidance of conflicted dealings with
borrowers and facilitators. The Disciplinary Authority has, in terms,
recorded outstanding exposure on Charge No. 1, and on Charge No. 8, has
also recorded the systemic risk created by the manner of processing and
disbursement, including the likelihood of accounts slipping into nonperforming category. The absence of an FIR, or the fact that one account
was later closed, does not sterilise the underlying misconduct.
Denial of assisting officer and breach of natural justice
9.
The Petitioner asserts denial of an assisting officer and denial of
opportunity. In writ review, such a plea must be anchored to the record. The
petition does not place on record any contemporaneous refusal order or any
demonstration of prejudice arising from the alleged denial. A bare assertion,
without the supporting trail, is insufficient to invalidate a completed inquiry,
particularly where the Petitioner pursued a statutory appeal and review
thereafter.
10.
The natural justice challenge also fails on the same principle. The
appellate order records compliance with natural justice and adequate
opportunity. The Reviewing Authority has again recorded that the
proceedings were conducted on documentary evidence and witness
testimony. In the absence of demonstrable denial of opportunity and
resultant prejudice, the Court would not unsettle the disciplinary outcome.
Non-examination of “real” account holders and “no FIR”
11.
The Petitioner has repeatedly emphasized that the “real” borrowers
were not produced, no FIR was lodged, and therefore Charge Nos. 1 and 2
could not be held proved. This argument proceeds on a criminal trial
template, which does not govern service discipline. The findings on Charge
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
Nos. 1 and 2 are rooted in documentary material (loan file documents and
exhibits), the audit and verification trail, and the deposition of the
management witness. On Charge No. 1, the Disciplinary Authority has
recorded specific infirmities: the photograph and identity proof not matching
the real borrower, the misleading pre-inspection report, absence of postsanction inspection, and failure to create bank charge/mortgage registration
in the relevant land records. On Charge No. 2, while noticing that the file
and cash voucher were not produced, the Disciplinary Authority has relied
on the manner in which the photograph on the loan file was confronted to
the management witness, and the conclusion that the borrower whose
identity was used did not in fact take the loan.
12.
Whether the Bank chose to lodge an FIR or not is a matter of
institutional discretion and does not affect culpability in departmental
proceedings. The primary question iswhether the Petitioner adhered to the
due diligence and lending discipline expected of a managerial officer, and
whether the material supports the conclusion that he did not. The record, as
reflected in the final order, supplies relevant material for that conclusion.
Disagreement with the Inquiry Officer and the plea of “suspicion replacing
proof”
13.
The Petitioner urges that the Disciplinary Authority differed from the
Inquiry Officer and, on that account, the order is vitiated. The final order
shows that the Disciplinary Authority did not proceed mechanically. It
accepted the Inquiry Officer’s reasoning on some articles (Charge Nos. 5
and 6), exonerated on Charge No. 4 by giving reasons, and differed on
Charge Nos. 3, 8, and 10 with detailed reasoning.
14.
The disciplinary authority is not bound to rubber-stamp the inquiry
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
report. Where it disagrees, the law requires procedural fairness, which
ordinarily includes putting the delinquent employee to notice of the points of
disagreement and inviting a response.6 The record shows that the Petitioner
preferred a statutory appeal against the order of the Disciplinary Authority in
2015 and a review thereafter, raising substantially similar grounds on merits
and on proportionality, and the Reviewing Authority expressly recorded that
the issues were earlier urged and considered. The Petitioner has not placed
any clear, contemporaneous material demonstrating that he was denied the
opportunity to respond to the proposed disagreement, or that he raised such a
complaint at the earliest stage and was shut out. In writ review, the Court is
concerned with demonstrable procedural prejudice, not hypothetical
prejudice pleaded after the event.
15.
The “suspicion cannot replace proof” submission also cannot be
accepted at this level of review. Charge Nos. 3 and 7 are not framed as mere
suspicion. Charge No. 3 rests on account statements and the mismatch
between known salary and heavy cash and inter-account transfers, coupled
with the recorded interlinkage with borrowers and BC/BF accounts. Charge
No. 7 rests on a trail of CKCC proceeds being routed into a specific savings
account and servicing a BF’s vehicle loan liability, alongside a transfer of
Rs. 60,000 to the Petitioner from the BC’s account. The Disciplinary
Authority found the defence explanation to be unsubstantiated and
inconsistent with the transaction pattern. These are factual evaluations
backed by documentary material, and the writ court does not re-weigh them.
“CKCC rules/guidelines not supplied” and “no stipulation for transfer
transactions”
Punjab National Bank v. Kunj Behari Misra, (1998) 7 SCC 84.
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
16.
The Petitioner asserts that the bank did not produce CKCC rules and
loan policy guidelines, and that there was “no stipulation” for transfer
transactions. This is answered, on the record, in two ways. First, the
Disciplinary findings do not hinge on an obscure policy document. They rest
on elementary banking norms: KYC diligence, proper appraisal, creation of
security interest, registration of mortgage where required, pre and postsanction
inspections,
sanction
documentation,
end-use
monitoring,
avoidance of disbursing entire limits in one tranche where staged
disbursement is inherent, and avoidance of conflicted dealing with
borrowers and intermediaries.
17.
Second, even on the Petitioner’s own framing, the defence was not
that the transactions did not occur, but that they were benign. The
Disciplinary Authority rejected that explanation as uncorroborated and
inconsistent with the linkages found. The order records that the Petitioner
failed to justify the transaction web between his accounts, borrower accounts
and BC/BF accounts. That is an assessment of plausibility on the basis of
preponderance of probabilities, which is the correct standard of proof in
service discipline.
Proportionality of penalty
18.
The penalty is supported by the proved charges. This is not a case
where a single technical lapse has been escalated into dismissal. The proved
misconduct, as recorded, includes sanctioning of fake loans on deficient
KYC and inspection discipline (Charge Nos. 1 and 2), suspicious and
disproportionate personal and family account transactions with borrower and
BC/BF linkages (Charge No. 3), diversion and misuse of agricultural credit
through BC/BF channels with a recorded personal receipt (Charge No. 7),
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
reckless sanctioning with a catalogue of basic lending norm violations and
an asserted false rectification certificate (Charge No. 8), excess finance and
missing files (Charge No. 9), and sanctioning beyond delegated powers
under a group concept (Charge No. 10). A bank is entitled to treat such
conduct as destructive of trust. Dismissal, in such circumstances, cannot be
characterised as shockingly disproportionate.
Conclusion
19.
The disciplinary process, viewed as a whole, does not disclose
procedural unfairness of the kind that warrants writ interference, nor does it
disclose a “no evidence” case. The findings rest on documentary material,
account trails, and the inquiry record as analysed by the Disciplinary
Authority. The Appellate and Reviewing Authorities have reaffirmed the
disciplinary outcome, including by dealing with the plea of caste bias and
recording absence of supporting material. The Court would not re-enter the
factual arena to re-assess credibility, re-calculate inferences from bank
records, or substitute its own view on what inferences ought to be drawn.
20.
The writ petition is devoid of merit and is accordingly, dismissed.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
JANUARY 9, 2026
nk
W.P.(C) 270/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/01/2026 at 13:30:04
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review