Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:18953
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 6484 of 2022
….…..
Ram Narayan Tiwary, aged about 64 years, son of Late
Mahabir Tiwary, posted as an Assistant Teacher, Project
Girls High School, Garu, Post and Police Station Garu,
District - Latehar (Jharkhand) (Now Retired).
..… Petitioner (s)
Versus
1.
The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary,
Department of School Education and Literacy, Project
Building, Post & P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi.
2. The Director (Secondary Education), Department of
School Education and Literacy, Project Building, Post &
P.S. Dhurwa, District - Ranchi.
3. The District Education Officer, Latehar, Post & P.S. Latehar, Distt. - Latehar.
..... Respondent(s)
….…..
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
CORAM:
….…
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondents
C.A.V. ON: 12/06/2026
: Mr. Bijay Kr. Pandey, Adv
Ms. Anjana Kumari, Adv
: Mr. Ashutosh Anand, AAG-III
Mr. Sahbaj Akhtar, AC to AAG-III
PRONOUNCED ON:29/06/2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The instant writ application has been preferred by the
petitioner for quashing of the order contained in memo no. 776
dated 05.04.2021, whereby the claim of the petitioner for
recognition of service on the post of Assistant Teacher has
been denied. Further prayer has been made for directing the
respondents to recognize the service of the petitioner on the
post
of
Assistant
Teacher
w.e.f.
01.01.1989
with
all
consequential benefits.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner was
appointed as an Assistant Teacher of Biology on 16.01.1985 at
Project Girls High School, Garu, which was later selected as
the “Project School” on 30.03.1985, in the financial year 19841
2026:JHHC:18953
85, by the District Three-Man Committee, constituted vide
Govt. letter no. 142 dated 23.02.1985.
Thereafter, on 14.04.1987, the salary benefits were
extended to the untrained teachers of the Project Schools
selected in the financial year 1981–82 w.e.f. 01.04.1986; but
no such extension was made for the teaching and non-teaching
staff of the schools selected in the year 1984-85. Moreover, a
direction vides letter no. 142 dated 04.02.1989 was issued by
the State, which provided that the teachers having the
minimum requisite qualification of trained graduate would be
entitled to recognition of service after approval of the School
Service Board, and the same was applied retrospectively.
4.
The impugned action was challenged before the Patna
High Court, which travelled to the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
resulting in the constitution of a Full Bench at Patna High
Court, which delivered the judgment on 07.02.1999, reported
in 2000 (1) PLJR 287, denying the retrospective application of
the letter dated 04.02.1989. It was held therein that the
procedure for recognition of the services of teaching and nonteaching staff could not differ merely because the schools were
selected in different financial years. Thereafter, the State
preferred several appeals against the decision of the Full
Bench, and the appeals were disposed of by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of State of Bihar v. Project
Uchcha Vidhyalaya Shikshak Sangh reported in [(2006) 2
SCC 545], dated 03.01.2006, which directed the Chief
Secretary to constitute a Three-Man Committee to examine and
scrutinize the individual claim of the teaching and nonteaching staff.
5.
Pursuant thereto, the Three-Man Committee, alias Alam
Committee, was constituted, which decided that the services of
only those teachers would be recognized who were appointed
2026:JHHC:18953
and trained before 04.02.1989.
6.
It was also stated in the report of the Committee that the
service of the petitioner cannot be recognized on the ground
that his appointment letter is fabricated, as two dates of
appointment are shown therein, and his appointment was
made after the selection of the school. Meanwhile, the services
of several similarly situated teachers were recognized vide
orders dated 09.02.2011 and 17.08.2016.
7.
The petitioner allegedly retired on 31.12.2016 after
rendering 60 years of service. Thereafter, the State issued a
notification on 25.04.2018. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner
moved the writ court, which was decided in his favour, but the
respondents did not comply with the said order, resulting in
contempt proceedings, which are still pending.
8.
Meanwhile, the State issued an impugned order vide
memo no. 776 dated 05.04.2021, which denied the claim of the
petitioner for recognition of service on the post of Assistant
Teacher. Hence, this writ application.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
ground for non-recognition of service of the petitioner, taken by
the Alam Committee, is non-est in light of the policy decision
taken by the State vide letter no. 2743 dated 06.10.2012 that
the teachers appointed by the Managing Committee up to
04.12.1989 will be considered for recognition of their services,
either trained or untrained, and thus, the appointment of the
petitioner made in 1985 or 1987 is not relevant as he was
appointed much prior to 04.02.1989.
He further submitted that in light of the Govt. notification
no. 1272 dated 25.04.2018, providing that the graduated
teachers
completed
having been appointed
their
training
before
before
04.02.1989
30.09.2007
would
and
be
considered for recognition of their services. Since the petitioner
2026:JHHC:18953
was a graduate and trained prior to 04.02.1989, his claim is
squarely covered under the said notification as the cut-off date
of appointment has been extended.
10. It was also pointed out by learned counsel for the
petitioner that, as per the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
dated 03.01.2006, the Regional Deputy Director of Education
had inspected the school and submitted a status report to the
Alam Committee in 2007, wherein the petitioner was shown
working in the school.
He further submitted that the Jharkhand Academic
Council, Ranchi, has issued an appointment letter dated
13.03.2014 to the school in the name of the petitioner for the
evaluation
of
the
answer
books
of
the
matriculation
examination 2014; hence, it is wrong to say that the school
was closed in 2006 and the petitioner has not been working in
the school.
11. It was also submitted that, as per the direction of the
Deputy Commissioner and the District Education Officer, the
police camp has been installed in school premises, and all
classrooms were occupied by the CRPFs, due to which girl
students did not attend the school, and they had no option left
other than appearing in the matriculation examination from
other High Schools; therefore, no passing record of students is
available.
12. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submitted
that as per the report of the Alam Committee, the appointment
letter shown by the petitioner is illegal and invalid as two dates
of appointment are shown therein, i.e., one is 16.01.1985 and
another is 28.01.1987, making it evident that the said
appointment itself is a backdoor entry.
He further submitted that, as per the letter no. 131 dated
20.02.1985, the power of appointment of teachers in the
2026:JHHC:18953
Project High Schools has been ceased w.e.f. the date of
issuance of the letter, and since the petitioner was appointed
on 28.01.1987, that is much after the date of issuance of the
aforementioned letter, his appointment itself is “void ab initio”.
13. Learned counsel for the respondents pointed out the fact
that as per the villagers, the school had not been functioning
since 2006, therefore, the petitioner was unable to show his
continuous presence in the school between 1987 and 2017,
and the evidence produced by him, including the appointment
letter and the teachers’ attendance register are forged and
fabricated.
14. Further, learned counsel for respondents also relied on the
judgment delivered by this Court in the case of State of
Jharkhand v. Bal Mohan Prasad (LPA No. 138 of 2019) and
further
submitted
that
acting
upon
the
findings
and
recommendations of the Alam Committee, the State declared
several schools, including the petitioner’s school, as closed and
non-functional vide Resolution no. 1272 dated 25.04.2018.
15. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and upon
perusal of the materials available on record, it transpires that
the petitioner claims recognition of his service as Assistant
Teacher from 01.01.1989 on the basis of his appointment in
Project Girls High School, Garu; whereas the respondents have
denied such claim by the impugned order mainly on the
ground that the petitioner's appointment is void ab initio and
the documents relied upon by him were found doubtful in the
scrutiny conducted by the Alam Committee pursuant to the
direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
16. The dispute, therefore, needs consideration with regard to
the validity of the petitioner's appointment and his consequent
entitlement
to
recognition
of
benefits.
service
and
consequential
2026:JHHC:18953
17. In the present case, first of all, in order to ascertain the
validity of the appointment of the petitioner, it is necessary to
consider the report of Alam Committee, wherein it transpires
that the petitioner has claimed to have been appointed on
16.01.1985; however, on perusal of his appointment letter
attached by the petitioner, it was found that the date of
appointment shown by him is incorrect, as according to the
contribution letter, the Secretary, School Managing Committee,
has signed it on 28.01.1987.
18. It further emerges from the record that even though the
petitioner has been issued appointment letter on 15.01.1985
and the petitioner has subsequently submitted his joining
before
the
Secretary,
Proposed
Girls
High
School
on
16.01.1985; however, evidently his joining has been accepted
by the Secretary, School Managing Committee on 28.01.1987,
i.e., much after lapse of more than two years; which itself
creates the doubt of the genuineness of the appointment letter.
19. Thus, this Court finds that the documents relied upon by
the petitioner disclose two different dates in relation to his
appointment,
viz.,
16.01.1985
and
28.01.1987,
thereby
creating a serious doubt regarding the authenticity of the
petitioner's claim of appointment on 16.01.1985, inasmuch as,
the contribution letter has been back dated to show that the
petitioner has been appointed prior to the identification /
recommendation by the three men committee under the
chairmanship of Deputy Commissioner to recognize the school
as Project Girls High School.
20. Further,
on
perusal
of
the
letter
no.
dated
20.02.1985, issued by the Education Department, Government
of Jharkhand, it appears that the power of appointment of
teachers by the Managing Committee in the Project High
Schools has been ceased w.e.f. the date of issuance of the
2026:JHHC:18953
letter. Thus, the appointment of the petitioner made after the
issuance of the aforementioned letter, i.e., on 28.01.1987, is
“void ab initio”.
21. Additionally, the petitioner was unable to prove his
presence from 1987 to 2006; rather the proof of his signature
in the teacher's attendance register between 2007 and 2017 as
has been produced by him seems to be doubtful, inasmuch as,
even as per the testimony of the villagers, the school has not
been functioning since 2006, and the building is also
dilapidated.
22. This Court further finds that though the school was
established in the year 1984-85, however, the petitioner was
unable to show himself working at the school before 2006.
Also, the enrolment or appearance of students in the
matriculation examination was not proved by any evidence, as
there has been no direct receipt from the school for any board
exam since 1986.
23. In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court finds
that the petitioner has failed to produce any cogent material to
establish his continuous discharge of duties in the school
during the period from 1987 to 2006, and the attendance
records relied upon by him after 2006 do not seem authentic in
view of the fact that the school had ceased to function since
the year 2006 itself.
24. The Report in the Alam Committee for the petitioner’s
school is mentioned in Serial No. 77 and it reveals that, the
land of the school, with an area of 1.54 acres, was donated and
registered in the name of the Governor. However, on inspection
of the related documents, several deficiencies were found by
the Alam Committee; the name of the donor was not mentioned
on the judicial stamp, the signatures of the executors, viz., Mr.
Etwa Oraon and Mr. Suresh Oraon, were not verified by any
2026:JHHC:18953
advocate, and the area of land, the name of the witness, and
the date of execution were also not mentioned.
25. Further, on perusal of the letter no. 323 dated 23.03.2021
issued by the District Education Officer, Latehar, to the
Respondent No. 2, it appears that the concerned land is
maintained under the Schedule Tribe Account’s Raiyat Land
Register of the East (CS) and the land agreement and the
donation letter in the name of the Governor have not been
provided by the School, and as per the letter of the Circle
Officer, there is no land in the name of Project Girls High
School, Garu. In light of the foregoing facts, this Court finds
that the land on which the dilapidated structure of the school
stands was never lawfully vested in the school, and it was
functioning merely as a shell institution in the garb of frivolous
and fabricated documents.
26. This Court further finds that the issue relating to the
recognition of service of teaching staff of Project Schools and
the findings recorded by the Alam Committee is no longer res
integra. In this regard, reference may be made to the judgment
rendered by the Division Bench of this Court in The State of
Jharkhand v. Bal Mohan Prasad (LPA No. 138 of 2019),
wherein it has been observed that the writ Court took a very
unusual direction while ignoring the findings of the Alam
Committee, as there is a group of teachers falling under the
separate category of “closed schools”. The Committee examined
the records of several Project Schools and gave specific reasons
for not recognizing the appointment of the teaching and nonteaching staff of those schools.
The reasons cited by the
Committee include that some of the schools were selfproclaimed and not selected by a 3-man committee, some had
no infrastructure and no facilities of drinking water and toilet,
and some had a smaller number of students enrolled and
2026:JHHC:18953
qualified for the matriculation examination. Additionally, it was
found that the appointment of some staff was suspicious, some
were lacking essential qualifications, some were found to be
involved in criminal cases, and some had already left the
school. Based on the findings and recommendations of the
Alam Committee, several schools, including the petitioner’s
school, were closed by the State as they were non-functioning,
vide Resolution no. 1272 dated 25.04.2018.
27. In view of the discussions made hereinabove and on
perusal of the materials on record, this Court is of the
considered view that the appointment of the petitioner is
invalid, because he has presented forged documents related to
his appointment and continuous discharge of services at the
School, falsely implying that his date of appointment was
before the school selection date, and that he was rendering
continuous service from his date of appointment to the date of
superannuation, only in order to get his services recognized
retrospectively, and as such, he is not entitled to the claim
sought by him in the instant writ application.
28. Accordingly, the instant writ application is dismissed.
Pending I.A.(s), if any, also stand closed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
Dated:29/06/2026
Amardeep/
Uploaded on
01.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review