The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. In view of the facts and circumstances, and considering the submissions advanced on behalf of the Respondent that the post of Senior Crane Operator is a promotional designation, and that the mention thereof in the appointment letter dated 17.08.1992 was an inadvertent error, this Court is of the considered view that the workman, in the absence of any evidence on record showing his actual promotion to the post of Senior Crane Operator, cannot be held entitled to the pay scale applicable to that post. However, since it is not in dispute that the workman has, at all material times, functioned and continues to function as a Crane Operator, he is entitled to be paid the pay scale applicable to the post of Crane Operator, that is, Rs.1370-41-1790-45-2015-15, as prescribed under the circular dated
21. 12.1993, and not the lower pay scale of Rs.1205-34-1545-38-1811.
24. In view of the above, the present petition is partly allowed and the impugned award dated 27.10.2005 is set aside with the consequential reliefs in the aforesaid terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 09th September, 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010699462006
+
W.P.(C) 1617/2006
RAM BHAWAN SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Aditi Anup, Adv.
versus
NATIONAL BUILDING CONSTRUCTION .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Mukesh Kr. Sharma, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
The present petition is filed under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India, assailing the award dated 27.10.2005
(hereinafter referred to as the “Impugned Award”) passed in I.D. No.
56/2003, whereby the Learned Labour Court held that the workman
was regularised vide appointment letter (Ex.WW1/4), and there is no
evidence to prove that the workman was promoted from Crane
Operator to Senior Crane Operator.
2.
Briefly stated, the workman/Petitioner was employed on
18.03.1986 and, by appointment letter, was regularised for the post of
Senior Crane Operator w.e.f 02.04.1992, on the implementation of the
new IDA-based revised scale of pay as applicable to the equivalent
post in the respective grade.
3.
It is the case of the workman that he is educated up to the 9th
standard, holds a valid driving licence for heavy goods vehicles, and
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
18:13:34
W.P.(C) 1617/2006
has old experience in crane operation. It is his case that he was
regularised w.e.f 02.04.1992, in the pay scale of Rs.1205-34-1545-381811. He submits that, in terms of the management's own circular
dated 21.12.1993, he ought to have been paid the pay scale of
Rs.1370-41-1790-45-2015-15 applicable to a Crane Operator or in
accordance with the appointment letter, Rs.1410-50-1910-60-2330-17
applicable to a Senior Crane Operator. However, the Respondent
continued to pay him at the pay scale of Rs.1205/- up to the year 1996,
without any justification.
4.
The workman sent demand notices dated 04.07.2001 and
09.07.2001.
5.
Thereafter, the workman raised an Industrial Dispute against the
Respondent. Pursuant to the failure of the conciliation proceedings,
the dispute was referred to the learned Tribunal, and at terms of
adjudication of reference are as:
“Whether Sh. Ram Bhavan Singh, S/o Sh. Sarjoo Singh,
Sr. Crane Operator is entitled to pay scale of Rs. 141050-1910-60-2330, and if so, to what relief is he entitled
and what directions are necessary in this respect?”
6.
The learned Labour Court framed issues, which are as follows:
“1) Whether Central Government and not the Delhi
Government is the appropriate government? If so, its
effect.
2) As per terms of reference.”
7.
The learned Labour Court, vide its impugned Award dated
27.10.2005, held that the workman failed to adduce evidence that he
was promoted from crane operator to Senior crane operator, and the
principle of equal pay for equal work will not be applicable as the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
18:13:34
W.P.(C) 1617/2006
other workmen promoted are senior to the workman and have been
working before the workman
8.
Aggrieved thereby, the present petition has been filed.
9.
The learned counsel for the Petitioner submits that the workman
was regularised as a Senior Crane Operator, as is evident from the
appointment letter (Ex. WW1/4). However, despite regularisation, the
workman was continued to be paid lower than the pay scale applicable
to even a Crane Operator. She submits that the Respondent has
created three distinct categories/designations, each carrying a separate
pay scale, which are as follows:
“i) Regular Establishment
ii) Work Establishment
iii) Nominal Muster Roll (NMR)”
10.
She submits that the Respondent, vide circular dated
21.12.1993, placed the pay scale of Crane Operator at Rs.1370-411790-45-2015-15 applicable to a and Rs.1410-50-1910-60-2330-17
for Senior Crane Operator, but the workman has been paid even lower
than the Crane Operator.
11.
She submits that the categorical distinction drawn by the
Respondent between a regularised workman and a directly recruited
workman holding the same designation cannot be sustained in law, as
the pay scale must follow the post held and not the mode of entry into
service. In support of her submissions, she places reliance upon the
judgment of Kamlakar and Ors. v. Union of India and Ors,
MANU/SC/0374/1999.
12.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the Respondent submits that
the workman was earlier engaged as a Nominal Muster Roll (NMR)
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
18:13:34
W.P.(C) 1617/2006
employee and was thereafter regularised and not promoted, pursuant
to a settlement arrived at, with the Union, and not by way of direct
recruitment against the post of Senior Crane Operator under the
Respondent's Recruitment Rules. He further submits that the
designation of “Senior Crane Operator” came to be inadvertently
mentioned in the appointment letter issued to the workman.
13.
He further submits that there exists a clear and legally
sustainable distinction between a Crane Operator who is directly
recruited and thereafter promoted to the post of Senior Crane
Operator, and the workman, having secured regularisation only on the
strength of the settlement with the Union and not based on promotion.
In support of his submissions, he places reliance upon the judgment
of Union of India & Anr. v. Narendra Singh, Civil Appeal No. 5865
of 2007
14.
I have heard both the parties and perused the material placed on
record.
15.
It is the case of the workman that he was employed on
18.03.1986 vide Employee Code No. 5595 and was thereafter
regularised as a Senior Crane Operator w.e.f 02.04.1992 in the regular
establishment. Since then, he has been paid a pay scale lower than the
one applicable to his designation. Aggrieved thereby, the workman
raised an industrial dispute, and vide award dated 27.10.2005 passed
in I.D. No.56/2003, the learned Industrial Tribunal held that the
workman was not entitled to any relief, and that his case could not be
compared to that of crane operators P.K. Sinha and S.K. Ravindran, as
they were already senior workmen.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
18:13:34
W.P.(C) 1617/2006
16.
The learned Labour Court, while dealing with Issue No.1, held
that the reference made by the Secretary (Labour), Government of
NCT of Delhi, was maintainable, and that the said authority, being an
instrumentality validly acting pursuant to delegation by the Central
Government, was competent to refer to the Respondent being an
instrumentality of the Central Government. Insofar as Issue No.2 is
concerned, the learned Labour Court held that although the workman
was appointed/regularised to the post of Senior Crane Operator, the
pay scale paid to him, even after such regularisation, was not
commensurate with the said designation. However, the learned Labour
Court proceeded to hold that the workman could not claim parity with
P.K. Sinha and S.K. Ravindran, as the said workmen were promoted 2
years before the Petitioner/workman; it does not emphasise the point
that the workman is being given pay lower than that of a Crane
Operator.
17.
It remains undisputed that the Petitioner was regularised by an
appointment letter dated 17.08.1992 and the post mentioned in the
letter of regularisation was Senior Crane Operator. Even though the
argument that the designation of Senior Crane Operator was
inadvertently mentioned in the appointment letter was not taken
before the learned Labour Court and has been urged before this Court
in the present petition, the same in the opinion of this Court has some
merit. The post of Senior Crane Operator is a promotion post from the
feeder post of Crane Operator from employees who join the
department as a Crane Operator either through direct recruitment or
by way of regularisation as has been done in the case of Petitioner.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
18:13:34
W.P.(C) 1617/2006
18.
Petitioner does not dispute that he was employed initially on a
nominal muster roll and was thereafter regularised by appointment
letter dated 17.08.1992. The said regularisation, therefore, could have
only been to the post of Crane Operator and not to a promotional post
of Senior Crane Operator.
19.
It is also not the case of the Petitioner that at any time he was
promoted to the post of Senior Crane Operator and, thus, in the
absence of any material to that effect, the Petitioner cannot seek
entitlement to the pay scale applicable to Senior Crane Operator.
Therefore, even though the appointment letter refers the designation as
Senior Crane Operator, the same, in the opinion of this Court has been
wrongly mentioned and does not confer the said post to the Petitioner
without him being subjected to the process of promotion.
20.
It is not the case of the Petitioner that a workman could have
been directly recruited or regularised to the post of Senior Crane
Operator in the absence of policy in that regard. At the same time, the
argument advanced by the Respondent that different pay scale even
for the post of Crane Operator would be payable to the employees
who have been taken on the roll through different modes is also not
merited.
21.
The Petitioner in that regard has rightly placed reliance upon
the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in case of Kamlakar
and Ors. (supra). The Hon’ble Apex Court categorically held that
once employee belongs to the same cadre, the distinction between
direct recruits and promotes ceases to be relevant for equal treatment
in the matter of pay scale within that cadre.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
18:13:34
W.P.(C) 1617/2006
22.
The Respondent, therefore, cannot be allowed to discriminate
and provide different pay scales to the Crane Operators despite
holding the same post and belonging to the same cadre and also
discharging the same duties only because some are direct recruits and
some joined through regularisation.
23.
In view of the facts and circumstances, and considering the
submissions advanced on behalf of the Respondent that the post of
Senior Crane Operator is a promotional designation, and that the
mention thereof in the appointment letter dated 17.08.1992 was an
inadvertent error, this Court is of the considered view that the
workman, in the absence of any evidence on record showing his actual
promotion to the post of Senior Crane Operator, cannot be held
entitled to the pay scale applicable to that post. However, since it is
not in dispute that the workman has, at all material times, functioned
and continues to function as a Crane Operator, he is entitled to be
paid the pay scale applicable to the post of Crane Operator, that is,
Rs.1370-41-1790-45-2015-15, as prescribed under the circular dated
21.12.1993, and not the lower pay scale of Rs.1205-34-1545-38-1811.
24.
In view of the above, the present petition is partly allowed and
the impugned award dated 27.10.2005 is set aside with the
consequential reliefs in the aforesaid terms.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
SEPTEMBER 9, 2026
“SK”
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
18:13:34
W.P.(C) 1617/2006
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review