Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN
THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 16th March, 2026
Pronounced on: 29th June, 2026
%
+
1.
2.
RSA 19/2017, CM APPL. 1905/2017 (stay)
RAM ASHRYA UPADHYAY
S/o Sh. Devender Upadhyay
....Appellant No.1
KRISHNA NAND UPADHYAY
S/o Sh. Devender Upadhyay
R/o RZ-H-141, Raj Nagar, Part-II
Palam, New Delhi
....Appellant No.2
Through: Mr. Jitender Saini, Advocate.
versus
VIJAY NARAIN UPADHYAY
S/o Kanshi UPadhyay
R/o 109, Maha Mandir, Munirka
New Delhi-110076
.....Respondent
Through: Counsel for Respondent (appearance
not given)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J
U D G M E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 has been preferred by the Appellants assailing the
Judgment and Decree dated 24.08.2016 whereby the learned Additional
District Judge, Delhi in RCA No.13/2014, has affirmed the Judgment and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
Decree dated 28.02.2013 of the learned Civil Judge in Civil Suit
No.640/2012, decreeing the Suit for Possession, Damages and Mesne
profits.
2.
The Respondent/Plaintiff instituted a Civil Suit No.640/2012 for
Possession, Damages and Mesne Profits in respect of property bearing No.
RZ-H-141, Raj Nagar Part-II, Palam, New Delhi, measuring approximately
150 square yards (hereinafter referred to as the “Suit Property”).
3.
The facts in brief are, that the Plaintiff had purchased the Suit
Property from one Smt. Saroj Chopra on 24.11.1984 through a set of
documents comprising General Power of Attorney, Agreement to Sell,
Receipt, Affidavit and Will. It was a vacant plot, possession of which was
delivered to him on which he constructed three rooms, one kitchen, latrine,
bathroom on the Ground Floor and one room on the First Floor, from his
own resources.
4.
The Plaintiff further asserted that the Defendants are his nephews
and were permitted to occupy one room on the first floor of the Suit
Property, on account of the close family relationship between the parties.
According to him, such an occupation was purely permissive and did not
confer any independent right upon the Defendants.
5.
The Plaintiff/Respondent asserted that he had kept the possession of
entire Ground Floor under the lock and keys and the Defendants/Appellants
had been given only one room on the First Floor. However, when he visited
the Suit Property in the first week of January, 2002, to his utter shock and
surprise, he found that the Defendants had occupied the entire Ground Floor
as well, after breaking open the locks of the premises. The Plaintiff
approached the local police, but they refused to take any action.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
6.
It was further alleged that with the passage of time, the Defendants
started asserting rights in respect of the Suit Property and unauthorizedly
occupied additional portions thereof. Despite repeated requests and
demands, they failed to vacate the premises. The Plaintiff asserted that the
Defendants had been allowed to live on license basis only in respect of one
room on the First Floor, but they have trespassed into the entire Ground
Floor as well since January, 2002.
7.
It was further claimed that if the premises was given on rent, it
would have fetched Rs.4,000/- per month as rent. Therefore, the
Defendants/Appellants are liable to pay Damages @Rs.4,000/- per month
w.e.f. 01.01.2002. A sum of Rs.28,000/- was claimed to have become due on
account of unauthorized use and occupation of the premises w.e.f.
01.01.2002 till 31.07.2002. Further, Mesne Profits were claimed for the
unauthorized use and occupation, till the vacant possession was handed over
to the Plaintiff.
8.
The Plaintiff served a Legal Notice dated 14.08.2002 which was
returned with the endorsement “no such person.” The Plaintiff thus, filed
the Suit for Possession, Damages of Rs.28,000/- for unauthorized use and
occupation and Mesne Profits.
9.
In their Written Statement, the Defendants took a preliminary
objection that the Suit Property was a Joint Family Property having been
purchased from the joint family funds in the name of Sh. Kanshi Upadhyay,
father of the Plaintiff and grandfather of the Defendants. Moreover, the
Plaintiff is the Power of Attorney Holder, which does not confer any right
title or interest on the Plaintiff. He can only act as per the instructions from
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
and on behalf of the original owner, but cannot claim any title on the basis
of GPA.
10.
The Plaintiff has not approached the Court with clean hands and has
suppressed material facts. The Court has no jurisdiction. The Suit has not
been valued correctly for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction, as the
value of the Suit Property is more than Rs.5,00,000/-. It is submitted that the
Suit is liable to be dismissed, on these preliminary grounds.
11.
On merits, the Defendants/Appellants admitted that the Suit
Property admeasuring 150 sq. yards, is located in the area of Palam Village
in the colony known as Raj Nagar Extension, Delhi and that it is in their
possession. However, it was denied that the Property was purchased by the
Plaintiff from one Smt. Saroj Chopra for valuable consideration on
execution of sale documents, namely, General Power of Attorney,
Agreement to Sell, Affidavit, Receipt and Will, etc. dated on 24.11.1984. It
was claimed that the Plaintiff had only identified the Property and informed
Sh. Kanshi Upadhyay, the grandfather, about the Property being available
and the suit property had been purchased from the Joint Family Funds.
12.
At that time in the year 1984, the Defendants were residing with the
Plaintiff and his first wife, Smt. Sarosta Devi. The Plaintiff did not have any
children of his own at that time and treated the Defendants as his own
children; likewise, the Defendants treated the Plaintiff as their father. In the
year 1988, Plaintiff and Smt. Sarosta Devi were blessed with a daughter. In
November or December, 1986, the Plaintiff told the Defendants that there
was an apprehension that some unscrupulous persons may occupy the plot as
it is in an unauthorized colony and they should set up a Mandir at that place
and also construct the residential accommodation. The Plaintiff was in a job,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
working as Pujari and he apprehended that he may lose the job at any time;
therefore, if the Defendants set up their own temple, it would be in the
interest of the family including the Plaintiff.
13.
The Defendants further claimed that at the time of execution of the
documents for purchasing the Suit Property it was informed to the Plaintiff
that the documents would be executed in the name of Sh. Kanshi Upadhyay.
14.
When the Defendants went to the Suit Property, they realized that it
was a low lying area and a lot of filling was required. Consequently, the
Defendants requested the Plaintiff for financial assistance in filling the land
and raising the construction, but the Plaintiff refused to provide any
financial help; instead told the Defendants that they should pay him
something for using the said land. Thereafter, with the intervention of the
elders, it was agreed that the Defendants would be given the right to use and
construct on the land, and since, there was also contribution of the Plaintiff,
in order to compensate the Plaintiff, the Defendants would pay Rs.200/- per
month and the construction on the plot would be raised by the Defendants
from their own funds or from the contribution of their grandfather, who was
also the father of the Plaintiff. It was also agreed by the Plaintiff that he
would never ask the Defendants to vacate the Suit Property or else, the
Defendants would not have made any investment in filling or raising
construction on the Suit Property. It was further claimed that no money was
contributed by the Plaintiff for raising the construction.
15.
The Defendants claimed that since then, they have been regularly
paying Rs.200/- per month to the plaintiff, however, now the Plaintiff
wants to take undue benefit, as no receipt for the same, was ever issued by
the Plaintiff.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
16.
The relations between the Plaintiff and the Defendants remained
cordial till July, 2001 when the Plaintiff remarried after the death of first
wife in September, 2000. The last rites of Smt. Sarosta Devi were also
performed by the Defendants.
17.
The Defendants claimed that they had raised the entire construction
from their funds and some contribution from their grandfather. The Suit
Property was constructed in parts and initially, only three rooms and one
kitchen were constructed on the Ground Floor, and the back boundary wall
was constructed in 1987. The Mandir in the premises was established in the
year 1988. Thereafter in 1992, one room was constructed on the First Floor
and Gumbad of the temple was constructed above the said room. A septic
tank, a latrine and a raised platform, were also constructed.
18.
It is only after the remarriage of the Plaintiff, that he became
dishonest and filed the present Suit. He intends to take benefit of the original
title deed of the Suit Property which is in his possession, and he may have
fabricated some documents to show his title in the Suit Property.
19.
It was submitted that the possession of the suit premises was handed
over jointly to the joint family of the Plaintiff and Defendants, headed by the
grandfather. The Plaintiff was never in possession of the suit premises.
20.
The Defendants further denied that they came in the year 1991 from
their native Village Mohammadpur Kusum, P.O. Mahrore, Distt. Ghazipur
(U.P.), to Delhi. It was claimed that the Defendant No.1 came to Delhi in the
year 1979, whereas the Defendant No. 2 came to Delhi in the year 1983 and
stayed at Munirka Village at the residence of the Plaintiff, who is till date
staying in Munirka Village. It was denied that they had no shelter to live or
that they had been initially permitted to occupy one room on the First Floor
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
of the suit premises, on license basis. The Defendants thus, submitted that
the Suit of the Plaintiff was liable to be dismissed.
21.
On the basis of the pleadings, the following issues were framed
which are as under:-
22.
i.
Whether Suit Property is not properly valued for
the purpose of Court fee and jurisdiction? OPD
ii.
Whether Suit Property is a joint Hindu
family/ancestral property qua the parties, if so its
effect? OPD
iii.
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to recover the
possession of the Suit premises? OPP
iv.
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of the
damages/mesne profit, if so at what rate and for
which period? OPP
v.
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to claim interest?
If so, at what rate and for which period? OPP
vi.
Relief.
The Plaintiff, Mr. Vijay Narain Upadhyay examined himself as
PW-1 and tendered his evidence by way of Affidavit, Ex.PW-1/A. He proved
the Site Plan, Ex.PW-1/7 and also the chain of documents Mark „A‟ to Mark
„E‟.
23.
PW-2, Mr. Deep Chand Sharma deposed that the Plaintiff was
working as a Pujari in Maha Mandir Munirka and he used to visit the temple
for worship. He further deposed that he had supplied the building material to
the Plaintiff between 1985 to1988 and also provided Masons and labour for
raising construction on the Suit Property.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
24.
PW-3, Smt. Janki and PW-4, Mr. G.C. Shrivastav have tendered
their evidence by way of Affidavits and deposed that they had visited the
Suit Property, and witnessed Plaintiff's possession thereof.
25.
Defendant No. 1, Sh. Ram Ashrya Upadhyay as DW-1, has
tendered his Affidavit of evidence, Ex.DW-1/A. He proved the document,
Ex.DW-1/1 whereby he had handed over a sum of Rs.20,000/- to the
Plaintiff.
26.
DW-2, Sh. Shyam Sunder Chaubey in his evidence vide Affidavit,
Ex.DW-2/A, proved the Receipt dated 20.10.1984 as Ex.DW-1/1 whereby the
Plaintiff had signed the receipt in his presence.
27.
DW-3, Sh. Krishna Upadhyay has tendered his evidence Affidavit
as Ex.DW-3/A and proved the documents, Ex.DW-3/1 to Ex.DW-3/4.He
deposed documents relating to his training, licence, identity card and
employment registration to show his long residence in Delhi and denied that
he first approached the Plaintiff for shelter in 1991.
28.
The learned Civil Judge considered the evidence of both the parties
and held that the defence taken by the Defendants that the Suit Property had
been purchased from Joint Family Funds was not established by any cogent
evidence. The best witness to support his assertions was Sh. Kanshi
Upadhyay, grandfather but he had not been examined as a witness.
29.
The Plaintiff had produced the Agreement to Sell, Ex.PW-1/1 and
other documents, namely, GPA, Will, Possession Receipt etc. whereby he
had purchased the Suit Property from one Smt. Saroj Devi.
30.
It was further held that the Defendants had failed to prove that they
had raised construction, but even if, their defence was accepted, the right of
the Plaintiff to seek Possession could not be denied in the light of his title
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
documents. The Defendants were therefore, proved to be the licensees and
the Plaintiff having terminated the license, was entitled to Recovery of
Possession. However, it was held that no evidence had been led in regard
to the Mesne Profits/Damages and the same were denied. The Suit for
Possession was accordingly decreed by the learned Civil Judge vide
Judgment dated 28.03.2013.
31.
Aggrieved thereby, the Defendants preferred a Regular Civil
Appeal, RCA No. 13/2014. The learned ADJ independently re-appreciated
the entire evidence, and observed that the documentary chain produced by
the Plaintiff, traced rights from the previous owners through Smt. Saroj
Chopra and ultimately in favour of the Plaintiff through registered
documents. The Appellate Court further held that the Plaintiff had
established a better claim to the Suit Property, whereas the Defendants had
failed to establish any legally recognizable competing title. Consequently,
the findings of the learned Trial Court were accordingly affirmed, and the
Civil Appeal was dismissed, vide Judgment dated 24.08.2016.
32.
Aggrieved, the Appellant/Defendant has preferred this Regular
Second Appeal.
33.
The grounds of challenge are that the learned Trial Court and the
learned ADJ failed to appreciate that the suit property was acquired from
joint family funds and Ex.DW1/1 established the contribution by Sh. Kanshi
Upadhyay, Grandfather of the Defendants, towards its purchase.
34.
It is further submitted that the findings returned by the said Courts,
are contrary to the evidence on record and that the Plaintiff's claim has been
erroneously preferred over that of the Defendants’.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
35.
It has also been argued that the Civil Court lacked jurisdiction in
view of Section 185 of the Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954 and that the
Appellate Court failed to properly consider the Application filed under
Order XLI Rules 25 and 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 seeking
framing of an additional issue and permission to lead additional evidence.
36.
Per contra, Plaintiff/Respondent in his Written Submission has
submitted that the plea of joint family ownership, is wholly unsupported by
any documentary or cogent evidence. The learned Trial Court duly
considered the Receipt DW1/1 as relied upon by the Appellant, and gave a
categorical finding that it was neither filed with the Written Statement nor
was there any pleading to that effect. Moreover, the Appellant has failed to
prove that the said Receipt, bear signature of the Respondent. The learned
Trial Court held that there was no documentary proof that the Appellant has
produced to support their case. The Appellants had failed to produce their
best witness, i.e. the Grandfather, Sh. Kanshi Upadhyay. The crossexamination of the Defence Witnesses reflected that Appellant has failed to
prove his case and was not interested in telling the truth.
37.
Similarly, the learned ADJ, on the basis of the registered
documents, reaffirmed that the Respondent has undoubtedly established that
the Suit Property was owned by the Plaintiff. It is further observed that the
Appellants have not filed any document to show that the said Suit Property
was purchased in their grandfather’s name or that it was purchased from the
Joint Family Funds. Only document relied upon by the Appellant was Ex.
DW1/1, which was never produced with the Written Statement nor was
there any pleading to this effect.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
38.
The Plaintiff/Respondent placed reliance upon Arikala Narasa
Reddy v Venkata Ram Reddy Reddygari & Anr. (2015) 5SCC312 wherein
the Supreme Court held that there can be no dispute to the settled legal
proposition that “as a rule relief not founded on the pleadings, should not be
granted”. Thus, a decision of the case should not be based on the grounds
outside the pleadings of the parties. In the absence of pleadings, evidence if
any, produced by the parties, cannot be considered. Therefore, it is neither
desirable nor permissible for a court to frame an issue not arising on the
pleadings.
39.
It is further contended that the Defendant/Appellant has at Appellate
stage, raised certain questions in respect of Delhi Land Reform Act. The
said issue has been raised for the first time during the present Second
Appeal. Moreover, the area in which the Suit Property lies, i.e. Palam
Village, Delhi was officially declared urban by the Delhi Revenue
Department, vide Notification dated 24.10.1994.
40.
Reliance is placed on the judgment of this Court, Indu Khorana v
Gram Sabha & Ors. 2010 SCC OnLine Del 1334 wherein this Court has
held that once rural area is urbanized by issuance of Notification under
section 507(a) of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957, provisions
of Delhi Land Reform Act, shall cease to apply.
41.
It is contended that both the learned Trial Court and the learned
First Appellate Court have concurrently found that the Defendant/Appellant
failed to establish any title or ownership rights in their favour and that the
findings so recorded are based upon proper appreciation of the evidence on
record. It is, therefore, submitted that no substantial question of law arises
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
for consideration in the present Second Appeal, which is liable to be
dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused.
42.
The case of the Plaintiff, Sh. Vijay Narain Upadhyay was that he
was the owner of the suit property. The defendants were given a permissive
right to occupy one room on the first floor, but they encroached upon the
ground floor and Are in unauthorized occupation of the suit property.
43.
To prove his case, plaintiff, as PW-1, had deposed that he had
purchased the Suit Property from one Smt. Saroj Chopra, wife of Sh. M.K.
Chopra, for valuable consideration, on the basis of General Power of
Attorney, Agreement to Sell, Receipt etc., Ex.PW-1/1 to Ex.PW-1/5. It had
been explained that Smt. Saroj Chopra herself had purchased the suit
property by virtue of a registered Sale Deed from one Mr. Rizak S/o Sh.
Bharthu and Khajan Singh. Smt. Saroj Chopra had handed over the peaceful
and vacant possession of the plot to the Plaintiff where after, he had raised
the construction of his house from the year 1985 to 1988, in instalments. He
constructed three rooms, kitchen, latrine, bathroom on the Ground Floor and
one room on the First Floor, as shown in the site plan, Ex.PW-1/7.
44.
The testimony of the Plaintiff and the documents proved that Smt.
Saroj Chopra was the erstwhile owner having a registered Sale Deed in her
name, which established her ownership in the suit property. She further
executed the Agreement to Sell, etc. Ex.PW-1/1 to Ex.PW-1/5 in favour of
the Plaintiff, which established the ownership rights of the Plaintiff in the
Suit Property.
45.
The Defendants pertinently have not claimed any document of
purchase of Suit Property in their name nor have they challenged the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
execution of the documents in favour of the Plaintiff. It was however,
asserted that Plaintiff had merely identified the property, on the asking of the
grandfather, Sh. Kanshi Upadhyay and the Suit Property was purchased
from the Joint Family Funds in the name of their grandfather.
46.
However, no document whatsoever has been produced by the
Defendants to reflect that the Suit Property was purchased in the name of
grandfather. The Defendants claimed that the documents had been retained
by the Plaintiff, which again is not tenable. The documents which have been
produced by the Plaintiff clearly show that the sale documents had been
executed in his favour.
47.
The Defendants had claimed that the Suit Property was purchased
from the Joint Family Funds but the Written Statement as well as the
evidence of Defendant No. 1, is absolutely silent about the existence of Joint
Family or there being a joint family nucleus, from which the funds were
given for purchase of the suit property. Bereft of any evidence of there being
a Joint Family, the defence of the Appellant was not tenable and has been
rightly rejected by the learned Civil Judge, as well as by the learned ADJ.
48.
The Defendants had relied upon a Receipt, Ex.DW-1/1 asserting that
vide this Receipt, a sum of Rs.20,000/- had been given by the Defendant
No.1 to the Plaintiff. The learned District Judge had noted that this Receipt
was absolutely untrustworthy, firstly, because it was not filed along with the
Written Statement and there was no mention of the same in the Written
Statement. Secondly, the Respondent/Plaintiff had denied his signatures and
had also denied its execution. There was no evidence whatsoever that the
Receipt has been executed by the Plaintiff. Thirdly, the Appellants
themselves had asserted that the suit property had been identified by the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
Plaintiff to be purchased later from the Joint Family Funds in the name of
the grandfather. There is neither any pleadings nor any evidence to show
from where did the Appellant No. 1 get the sum of Rs.20,000/- and why did
he pay the same to the Plaintiff. The learned ADJ, therefore, rightly
observed that this document did not inspire the confidence and was not
acceptable.
49.
Furthermore, DW-1, had claimed that he and his younger
brother/Appellant No. 2, Sh. Krishna Nand Upadhyay, along with Sh.
Kanshi Upadhyay and the Plaintiff, were present at the time of purchase of
the suit property, but he was unable to give the details of the lawyer, the
Notary Public or any particulars to explain the execution of the documents.
The falsehood became more evident from the fact that he claimed that the
suit property was purchased from Sh. Pawan Solanki, which is absolutely,
and blatantly false, in the light of the title documents produced by the
Plaintiff along with the Sale Deed, in the name of Smt. Saroj Chopra, the
erstwhile owner.
50.
Another pertinent aspect which needs to be mentioned is that the
Appellants themselves have stated in their Written Statement, that when they
went to visit the suit plot, they found it to be in a low lying area and were
told by the Plaintiff to fill the land and to build a temple, to prevent its
unauthorised occupation by unscrupulous persons. The Defendants have
themselves stated that the Plaintiff was a Pujari and apprehending loss of his
job, had told them to build a temple for which the funds were to be provided
by the grandfather of the Defendants or the money was to be raised by the
Defendants, with no contribution from the Plaintiff. However, not a single
document or source or the expenditure incurred in the construction, has been
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
disclosed by the Appellants. Rather, the Plaintiff himself has stated that the
construction was done in phases from 1988 to 1995. Moreover, the
Appellants admitted that they were regularly paying Rs.200/- per month to
the Plaintiff though, no receipt was being issued. This again fortifies the
claim of the Plaintiff that the Defendants had been inducted only as a
licensee and were permitted to occupy the First Floor but subsequently,
trespassed into the ground floor.
51.
The learned District Judge has rightly held that the Defendants
were unable to prove any right, title in the Suit Property nor that they had
raised the construction. In fact, the overwhelming evidence on record and
their admissions in the Written Statement, as well as in their evidence,
established that they had been permitted to reside on the First Floor and had
subsequently, taken possession of the Ground Floor. Their status in the Suit
Property is, only that of a licensee. Even if for the sake of arguments, it is
accepted that they had raised any construction, but the fact remains that they
were only a permissive user. Once the Legal Notice dated 14.08.2002 was
served upon the Defendants, their license stood terminated and they became
liable for eviction.
52.
The learned Civil Judge had denied the Mesne Profits and Damages,
but no Appeal has been preferred by the Plaintiff.
53.
The learned ADJ has rightly upheld the Judgment of the learned
Civil Judge dated 28.02.2013 directing the eviction of the Appellants from
the suit premises. No substantial question of law has been raised in this
Second Regular Appeal and the challenge is only to the facts, which
cannot be a ground for consideration in the Second Appeal.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
54.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby
dismissed. Pending Application(s), if any, are also disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 29, 2026/RS
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:54:33
RSA 19/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review