Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:474-DB
Reserved on 06.01.2026
Delivered on 08.01.2026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Service Bench No. 528 of 2022
Dr. Rakesh Sinha
………Petitioner
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand and Others
..………Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:Mr. Shobhit Saharia, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Mr. K.N. Joshi, learned Deputy A.G. for the State.
---------------------------------------------------------------------Coram:
Hon'ble Ravindra Maithani, J.
Hon'ble Alok Mahra, J.
Hon'ble Alok Mahra, J. (Per.)
It is stated that the petitioner was working on the
post of Chief Medical Officer (C.M.O.), District Rudrapur, and
superannuated
from
service
on
31.03.2015.
After
his
retirement, a preliminary enquiry relating to alleged fake taxi
bills came to light on 03.05.2016. The then Joint Secretary,
Medical
Education
Department
was
appointed
as
the
Preliminary Enquiry Officer, who submitted his report on
09.08.2016, wherein it was alleged that an irregular payment
amounting to ₹83,31,000/- had been made towards forged
taxi bills. Pursuant thereto, a charge-sheet was issued to the
petitioner calling upon him to submit his reply and also to
indicate whether he desired a personal hearing and to
disclose the names of witnesses whom he wished to examine
or cross-examine. The petitioner submitted his explanation.
Thereafter, a five-member enquiry committee was constituted
to enquire into the alleged misappropriation and loss caused
to the public exchequer on account of payments made against
alleged forged taxi bills incurred during visits of the Hon’ble
Chief Minister. The enquiry committee, after considering the
material on record, concluded that the petitioner had acted in
violation of the Finance Rules, resulting in gross financial
irregularities and consequential loss to the public exchequer.
2.
letter
It is further stated that respondent no.2, vide
dated
20.11.2014,
had
written
to
the
Principal
Secretary, Medical, Health & Family Welfare, Government of
Uttarakhand, seeking appointment of a competent enquiry
officer.
The
enquiry
report
prepared
by
the
previous
committee was enclosed with the said letter. An F.I.R. dated
07.02.2015 was also registered alleging that a sum of
₹83,31,000/- had been misappropriated by M/s Kala Tours
and Travels, Dehradun, by submitting forged and fabricated
taxi bills. Subsequently, the Investigating Officer submitted a
report allegedly establishing charges against the petitioner. A
charge-sheet was thereafter served upon the petitioner
alleging that the expenditure incurred under Budget Head
No.3 (Council of Ministers) had been wrongly disbursed under
Budget Head No.12 (Medical, Health and Family Welfare). The
petitioner submitted his reply to the said charge-sheet. Vide
letter dated 19.02.2018, the enquiry report was supplied to
the petitioner. On the basis of the enquiry report, an order
dated 21.12.2018 was passed imposing penalty upon the
petitioner
by
directing
recovery
of
₹83,31,000/-;
that,
thereafter, respondent no. 3 issued an Office Order dated
19.08.2019 directing deduction of 50% of the provisional
pension accruing to the petitioner.
3.
Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner approached the
Uttarakhand Public Service Tribunal under Section 4 of the
U.P. Public Service Tribunal Act, 1976, seeking quashing of
the order dated 21.12.2018 and 19.08.2019. The Tribunal,
vide judgment and order dated 24.05.2022, dismissed the
claim petition holding that there was no illegality in the
punishment order and upheld the penalty imposed upon the
petitioner. Hence, the present writ petition has been filed for
the following reliefs:
(i)
A writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari
quashing the judgment and order dated 24.05.2022
passed by the Uttarakhand Public Service Tribunal,
Bench
at
Nainital,
in
Claim
Petition
No.31/NB/DB/2020 (Dr. Rakesh Sinha vs. State of
Uttarakhand);
(ii)
A writ of certiorari quashing the Office Order
No.2045/XXVIII-2/2018-01(31)2014 dated 21.12.2018,
whereby a penalty of recovery of ₹83,31,000/- by
deduction of 50% of monthly pension was imposed,
along with all consequential orders, and a writ of
mandamus directing refund of the amount already
recovered with interest;
(iii) A writ of mandamus directing the respondents to
release the regular pension, arrears thereof with effect
from 01.03.2015, and all other retiral benefits including
gratuity, provident fund, group insurance and other
dues withheld by the respondents.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit
that the charge-sheet was issued on 14.10.2016, more than
one and a half years after the petitioner’s retirement, and the
petitioner submitted his reply on 30.01.2017. It is contended
that
the
enquiry
was
conducted
without
supplying
documentary evidence, without examining any witnesses, and
without affording opportunity of cross-examination, and yet
the Enquiry Officer submitted his report on 02.02.2018, in
gross violation of principles of natural justice. It is further
submitted that the only allegation against the petitioner was
that verified taxi bills were cleared under Budget Head No.12
instead of Budget Head No.3, which, at best, amounted to a
procedural lapse and not misconduct warranting recovery
from pension.
5.
Learned counsel contends that under Regulation
351-A of the Civil Service Regulations, once departmental
proceedings are initiated after retirement, the procedure
applicable to proceedings leading to dismissal from service
must be strictly followed. Since dismissal is a major penalty,
the enquiry ought to have been conducted strictly in
accordance
with
Rule,
including
oral
enquiry,
which
admittedly was not done. Reliance is placed upon Roop Singh
Negi vs. Punjab National Bank, (2009) 2 SCC 570, wherein
the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that a departmental enquiry
is quasi-judicial in nature and findings must be based on
legally admissible evidence, and that documents cannot be
relied upon without being proved by witnesses. Further
reliance is placed upon Managing Director U.P. Jal Nigam
(Rural) Vs. Babban Singh and Another 2023 SCC OnLine All.
774, Deokinandan Prasad Vs State Of Bihar & Ors (1971) 2
SCC 330 and D.S. Nakara and Other vs. Union of India (1183)
1 SCC 305, to contend that pension is a property right and
cannot be curtailed except in strict compliance with law. It is
also contended that payments were made strictly pursuant to
directions issued from the Chief Minister’s Office, after
verification and budget clearance by the Financial Controller,
and no audit objection was ever raised by the Treasury or
Accountant General. The petitioner derived no personal
benefit and has been made a scapegoat.
6.
Per contra, learned State Counsel would submit
that the petitioner retired from government service on
31.03.2015, and that an FIR was lodged against him alleging
misappropriation of a sum of ₹83,31,000/- by raising fake
taxi bills. It is contended that a charge-sheet was duly served
upon the petitioner and that, in view of his retirement, the
disciplinary
authority,
after
due
consideration,
ordered
recovery from his pension in exercise of powers under
Regulation 351-A. It is further submitted that the payments
in question were not made under the prescribed Head of
Account but were released under different Heads, and that
the petitioner had effected the payments without obtaining
prior approval from his superior officers and without proper
verification of the bills. It is lastly submitted that the
petitioner expired on 10.02.2023, and thereafter his widow is
being paid family pension.
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the
petitioner would submit that the State’s contentions are
misconceived, factually incorrect, and legally untenable; that,
mere
lodging
of
an
FIR
alleging
misappropriation
of
₹83,31,000/- does not establish misconduct, and no criminal
trial ever found the petitioner guilty; that, recovery from
pension, a vested right under Article 300-A, can only follow a
full departmental enquiry under Regulation 351-A with a
finding of grave misconduct and no such enquiry was
conducted. The allegations regarding payment under an
incorrect budget head or failure to verify bills are irrelevant,
unsupported, and arbitrary; that, the petitioner retired on
31.03.2015 and passed away on 10.02.2023; upon death,
disciplinary proceedings abate, and family pension cannot be
subjected to recovery; that, withholding and recovery of
pension is thus arbitrary, violative of Articles 14 and 300-A,
and contrary to settled law.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record.
9.
It is an admitted and undisputed fact that the
petitioner retired from government service on 31.03.2015 on
attaining the age of superannuation. It is also not in dispute
that an amount of ₹83,31,000/- was released by the
department in favour of M/s Kala Tours and Travels,
Dehradun. The identity of the said firm, its bank account
details, and the entire financial trail were at all times within
the knowledge and control of the departmental authorities. If
at all any amount was wrongly released, it was incumbent
upon the respondents to initiate appropriate proceedings for
recovery against M/s Kala Tours and Travels, Dehradun, the
actual recipient of the funds. In the event the petitioner was
found guilty of misconduct, punishment could have been
imposed strictly in accordance with law. Admittedly, no
disciplinary proceedings were ever initiated against the
petitioner during his service tenure. The charge-sheet was
issued for the first time on 14.10.2016, i.e., more than one
and a half years after his superannuation, in complete
violation of the mandatory requirements of Regulation 351-A
of the Civil Service Regulations.
10.
The power of the State to withhold pension or to
direct recovery from a retired government servant is governed
exclusively
by
Regulation
351-A
of
the
Civil
Service
Regulations. For a proper appreciation of the controversy at
hand, it is pertinent to reproduce Regulation 351-A, which
alone prescribes the conditions and procedures under which
the State may exercise such power.
“351-A. The Governor reserves to himself the right of
withholding or withdrawing a pension or any part of it,
whether permanently or for a specified period, and the
right of ordering recovery from pension of the whole or part
of any pecuniary loss caused to Government, if the
pensioner is found in departmental or judicial proceedings
to have been guilty of grave misconduct, or to have caused
pecuniary loss to Government by misconduct or negligence
during his service, including service rendered on reemployment after retirement.
Provided that—
(a) such departmental proceedings, if not instituted while
the officer was on duty either before retirement or during
re-employment—
(i) shall not be instituted save with the sanction of the
Governor;
(ii) shall be in respect of an event which took place not
more than four years before the institution of such
proceedings; and
(iii) shall be conducted in accordance with the
procedure applicable to proceedings in which an order
of dismissal from service may be made;
(b) judicial proceedings, if not instituted while the officer
was on duty, shall have been instituted in accordance
with law;
(c) the Public Service Commission shall be consulted before
final orders are passed.
Explanation—For the purposes of this article—
(a) departmental proceedings shall be deemed to have
been instituted on the date on which the charges framed
against the pensioner are issued to him;
(b) judicial proceedings shall be deemed to have been
instituted—
(i) in criminal cases, on the date of filing of complaint or
charge-sheet; and
(ii) in civil cases, on the date of presentation of the
plaint.”
11.
A plain reading of Regulation 351-A makes it clear
that no recovery from pension or retiral dues can be ordered
in the absence of a valid and lawful departmental or judicial
proceeding culminating in a finding of guilt. The said
regulation permits recovery from pension only where the
pensioner is found guilty of grave misconduct or negligence in
duly instituted departmental or judicial proceedings. Where
departmental proceedings are initiated after retirement, they
must be sanctioned by the Governor, relate to an event not
more than four years old, and be conducted strictly in
accordance with the procedure applicable to dismissal from
service.
Departmental
proceedings
are
deemed
to
be
instituted only upon issuance of a formal charge-sheet. Any
enquiry conducted without following the prescribed procedure
is void and unenforceable.
12.
In the present case, admittedly, no disciplinary
proceedings were pending against the petitioner on the date of
his retirement. The charge-sheet was issued after a lapse of
more than one and a half years from the date of retirement,
without obtaining the mandatory sanction of the Governor,
and in patent violation of Regulation 351-A of the Civil Service
Regulations. The Explanation appended to Regulation 351-A
itself clarifies that departmental proceedings shall be deemed
to have been instituted only on the date on which the charges
framed against the pensioner are issued to him. Since the
charge-sheet
was
issued
post-retirement,
without
prior
sanction of the Governor, the initiation of proceedings was
impermissible in law. Furthermore, no regular departmental
enquiry, as contemplated under the applicable service rules,
was ever conducted. No witnesses were examined, no
evidence was led, and the petitioner was not afforded any
opportunity of cross-examination or effective hearing. The
impugned action, therefore, stands vitiated on account of
gross
non-compliance
with
the
mandatory
statutory
provisions as well as flagrant violation of the principles of
natural justice, rendering the recovery from pension wholly
illegal and unsustainable.
13.
The law regarding pension is clear and well settled.
Pension is a vested legal right, not a bounty, and can be
withheld or recovered only under law after proven misconduct
in a valid disciplinary proceeding. In D.V. Kapoor v. Union of
India (1990) 4 SCC 314, the Supreme Court held that
reduction or recovery of pension requires a finding of grave
misconduct in a lawful enquiry. Similarly, in State of
Jharkhand v. Jitendra Kumar Srivastava (2013) 12 SCC 210,
pension and gratuity were recognized as “property” under
Article 300-A, which cannot be withheld or recovered without
statutory authority. In State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (2015) 4
SCC 334, the Court held that recovery from retired employees
without adjudication of misconduct is illegal and oppressive.
The State’s claim that payments were made under an
incorrect budget head or without verification is legally
irrelevant, as administrative lapses, absent fraudulent intent
or personal gain, do not constitute grave misconduct. The
petitioner retired on 31.03.2015 and passed away on
10.02.2023.
14.
Since the so-called disciplinary proceedings were
initiated and conducted in clear violation of Regulation 351-A
of the Civil Service Regulations, inasmuch as no prior
sanction of the Governor was obtained before instituting such
proceedings after the petitioner’s retirement, the entire
disciplinary
inquiry
Consequently,
any
is
non-est
order
in
directing
the
eyes
recovery
of
law.
from
the
petitioner’s pension, founded upon such void proceedings, is
wholly illegal, without jurisdiction, and liable to be quashed.
15.
Consequently, the writ petition is allowed. The
order dated 24.05.2022 passed by the Uttarakhand Public
Service Tribunal and the Office Order dated 21.12.2018
directing recovery of ₹83,31,000/- from the petitioner’s
pension are hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to
refund the amount already recovered along with interest and
to release all admissible retiral dues, including pension,
arrears,
gratuity,
and
other
consequential
benefits,
in
accordance with law, within the stipulated period.
(Alok Mahra, J.)
08.01.2026
(Ravindra Maithani, J.)
08.01.2026
Mamta
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review