Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 14.01.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 05.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 05.02.2026
+
+
W.P.(C) 8524/2025, CM APPL. 36939/2025, CM APPL. 36941/2025, CM
APPL. 52435/2025, CM APPL. 76481/2025 and CM APPL. 76482/2025
DEVYANSHU SURYAVANSHI & ORS.
versus
.....Petitioners
STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ANR.
.....Respondents
W.P.(C) 10070/2025, CM APPL. 41825/2025 and CM APPL. 41828/2025
TUSHAR SHARMA & ORS.
.....Petitioners
versus
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL & ORS.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 12471/2025 and CM APPL. 50923/2025
PAVNI SHARMA
versus
.....Petitioner
STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION (SSC) AND ANR
.....Respondents
+
+
W.P.(C) 14070/2025 and CM APPL. 57706/2025
RAKESH MAHATO
versus
.....Petitioner
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
W.P.(C) 15634/2025
VAIBHAV SINGH
.....Petitioner
versus
SHAFF SELECTION COMMISSION HQ & ORS.
+
.....Respondents
W.P.(C) 8525/2025, CM APPL. 36942/2025 and CM APPL. 36944/2025
ABHI NAITAN & ORS.
.....Petitioners
versus
STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ANR.
.....Respondents
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
Present for Petitioners:
Mr. Gauhar Mirza, Mr. Aditya Bharat Manubarwala, Ms. Abiha Zaidi, Ms.
Tanishka Grover, Mr. Pritam and Ms. Priyam Karma, Advs. in W.P.(C)
8524/2025 and W.P.(C) 8525/2025.
Mr. K. K. Sharma and Mr. Harshit Agarwal, Adv. in W.P.(C) 12471/2025.
Mr. Arun Kumar Singh and Mr. Dhanajaya Kumar Tyagi, Advs. in
W.P.(C) 15634/2025.
Present for Respondents:
Ms. Arunima Dwivedi, CGSC along with Ms. Himanshi Singh and Ms.
Priya Khurana, Advs. in W.P.(C) 8524/2025, W.P.(C) 12471/2025 and
W.P.(C) 8525/2025.
Mr. Jagdish Chandra CGSC along with Ms. Maanya Saxena, Mr.
Siddharth Bajaj, Advs. in W.P.(C) 10070/2025 and W.P.(C) 15634/2025.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
Through the present Writ Petitions under Articles 226 and 227
of the Constitution of India, the Petitioners assail the correctness of
the Order dated 30.05.2025 passed the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi [hereinafter referred to as „the
Tribunal‟],
in O.A. Nos.1102/2025, 1750/2025, 1405/2025,
1408/2025 and 1814/2025, as well as the Orders dated 17.07.2025 and
11.08.2025 passed by the Tribunal in O.A. Nos.1606/2025 and
1943/2025, respectively [hereinafter collectively referred to as
„Impugned Orders‟].
2.
By way of the Impugned Orders, the Tribunal dismissed the
Original Applications (OAs) challenging the final results and answer
keys of the Combined Graduate Level Examination (CGLE), 2024
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
conducted by the Staff Selection Commission (SSC), holding that the
alleged infirmities in the evaluation of the Tier-II examination,
relating to grant of “bonus marks” for 22 questions and alteration of
answers in the Final Answer Key released after declaration of results,
stemmed from a conscious decision of the Subject Matter Experts
(SMEs) committee of the SSC and therefore, did not warrant judicial
re-evaluation.
3.
With the consent of learned counsel representing the parties, the
present Writ Petitions are being disposed of by this common
judgment.
FACTUAL MATRIX
4.
In order to comprehend the issues involved in the present case,
relevant facts, in brief, are required to be noticed.
5.
The SSC issued the notification for the CGLE, 2024 on
24.06.2024 for filling approximately 17,727 vacancies. Paragraph 13
of the said advertisement delineates the examination scheme,
comprising two stages, Tier-I and Tier-II. It also incorporates a
provision for normalization of marks through a specific formula, as
detailed in the notice dated 07.02.2019.
6.
The Tier-I Computer-Based Examination was conducted in
September 2024, and the results thereof were declared on 05.12.2024.
The Tier-II Examination, comprising Paper-I (Session-I with three
sections and Session-II) and Paper-II, was conducted on 18.01.2025
and 20.01.2025. It is stated that one component thereof, namely the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
Data Entry Speed Test Module (Session-II), could not be conducted as
scheduled due to a technical glitch and was subsequently held on
31.01.2025.
7.
On 21.01.2025, the SSC published the tentative Answer Key for
Paper-I of the Tier-II Examination, pursuant whereto representations
were invited and submitted by candidates in respect of the disputed
issues/answers.
8.
The SSC declared the final result and published the list of
candidates shortlisted for posts other than Junior Statistical
Officer/Statistical
Investigator
on
12.03.2025.
Thereafter,
on
18.03.2025, after obtaining post preferences and declaring the final
result, the SSC released the Final Answer Key as well as the final
scores of candidates in the Tier-II Examination.
9.
It is further recorded in the pleadings that, under the
Revised/Final Answer Key, nine (09) questions from the examination
conducted on 18.01.2025 and ten (10) questions from the examination
conducted on 20.01.2025 were declared invalid. Attention was also
drawn to a tabulated list of twenty-two (22) questions in respect of
which grace marks were awarded uniformly to all candidates,
including those who had not attempted the questions or had furnished
incorrect answers to the disputed questions.
10.
Aggrieved thereby, the candidates instituted the aforementioned
OAs before the Tribunal, which came to be dismissed on, inter alia,
the following grounds:
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
i.
The courts do not possess expertise in all academic disciplines
and, in matters relating to the evaluation of examination answer keys,
the views of SMEs merit due deference, particularly where divergent
opinions are possible.
ii.
While the scope of judicial review extends to areas within
judicial expertise (such as Law), the Tribunal held that it could not sit
in appeal over decisions involving subjects such as Mathematics,
English, or General Knowledge, and therefore refrained from
substituting its own assessment for the considered view of the SMEs
of the SSC.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
11.
Heard learned Counsel for the parties at length and, with their
able assistance, perused the paper book.
12.
Learned Counsel representing the Petitioners has submitted as
follows:
i.
Judicial review is available even in academic matters when the
examination question setting has been riddled with lacunae and the
evaluation of the answers has been faulty. Reliance is placed upon the
judgments rendered in Staff Selection Commission & Anr. v.
Shubham Pal & Ors.1; Shivraj Sharma v. Consortium of National
Law Universities & Ors.2; Siddhi Sandeep Ladda v. Consortium of
2025 SCC OnLine Del 7145
2025:DHC:2838-DB
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
National Law Universities & Ors.3; and Salil Maheshwari v. High
Court of Delhi4.
ii.
The Respondents arbitrarily applied normalisation to twenty-
two (22) questions without justification or adherence to the
methodology prescribed under the SSC notice dated 07.02.2019,
resulting in an undue dilution of merit.
iii.
The grant of equal marks to all candidates for invalid questions
is also assailed as unfair, as it benefits those who answered incorrectly
or did not attempt the questions. Reliance is placed on Guru Nanak
Dev University v. Saumil Garg & Ors.5 to submit that marks ought to
be awarded only to candidates who attempted the disputed questions.
iv.
The Petitioners furnished specific instances, including Question
ID 630680674736 (Mathematics) and Question ID 630680522658
(English), where the most appropriate option could reasonably be
deduced despite minor typographical errors.
13.
Per contra, learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that
Courts and Tribunals ought to defer to the opinion of experts in
academic matters, as they do not possess the requisite expertise in all
disciplines to re-evaluate such decisions. Reliance is placed on
Mahesh Kumar v. SSC & Anr.6; Ran Vijay Singh & Ors. v. State of
Uttar Pradesh & Ors.7; Ashish Singh & Ors. v. UOI & Ors.8; and
2025 INSC 714
2014 SCC OnLine Del 4563
(2005) 13 SCC 749
2021:DHC:861-DB
(2018) 2 SCC 357
2023:DHC:000778
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
Freya Kothari v. Union of India9 to contend that a presumption of
correctness attaches to the evaluation process. It is further submitted
that full marks were awarded only in cases where the SMEs found the
questions to be ambiguous.
14.
No other submissions were advanced by learned counsel for the
parties.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
15.
The issue that arises for consideration is whether the Tribunal
was justified in declining to interfere with the final answer key and
evaluation process of the CGLE, 2024, in view of the settled
principles governing the scope of judicial review in academic matters.
16.
At the outset, it is necessary to elucidate the scope of judicial
review in matters of academic evaluation. It is well settled that Courts
and Tribunals, in exercise of writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution, do not function as appellate bodies to reassess answer keys or the merits of academic judgments made by
SMEs unless the decision-making process is shown to be vitiated by
patent illegality or arbitrariness.
17.
The Supreme Court in Ran Vijay Singh (supra) has
underscored that where the governing rules do not provide for reevaluation or scrutiny of answer sheets, judicial interference is
permissible only in rare and exceptional cases demonstrably involving
a material error.
W.P.(C) 13668/2022
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
18.
The judgment of this Court in Mahesh Kumar (supra) is further
instructive. The Court observed that academic matters are best left to
the academics. Courts should not re-evaluate or scrutinize answer
sheets, as they lack the expertise to do so. The correctness of
evaluation must be presumed. In the event of doubt, the benefit should
ordinarily go to the examining authority rather than the candidate.
Sympathy or compassion cannot guide judicial intervention. It is
further observed that an error by the examining authority affects the
entire body of candidates, and the examination process cannot be
derailed merely because some candidates feel aggrieved.
19.
The above-mentioned decision was subsequently upheld by the
Supreme Court in SLP(C) No. 1951/2022. The Apex Court observed
that where Courts have no expertise, academic matters are best left to
the academic authorities. These authorities clearly underscore that, in
normal circumstances involving technical or multi-disciplinary
examinations, judicial review is strictly circumscribed.
20.
Furthermore, this Court in Freya Kothari (supra), Salil
Maheshwari (supra), and Ashish Singh (supra) has consistently held
that judges are not, and cannot be, experts in all fields. Where
conflicting views arise in the evaluation of answer keys, the Courts
must defer to the opinion of the experts and cannot assume the role of
academic authorities themselves. These decisions underscore that
judicial review in academic matters is necessarily circumscribed, and
intervention is warranted only in cases of patent illegality,
arbitrariness, or manifest procedural infirmity.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
21.
The reliance placed by the Petitioners on the judgments in
Shivraj Sharma (supra) and Siddhi Sandeep Ladda (supra) is
misplaced. In those cases, the Courts exercised judicial review over
the question-setting and evaluation process of the Common Law
Admission Test (CLAT). The subject matter in those cases was law, a
field in which the Courts possess specialized expertise. The Courts
were thus competent to assess the correctness of questions and
answers and, where necessary, override the views of the experts.
22.
The present case is clearly distinguishable. The CGLE, 2024
comprises
questions
across
multiple
disciplines,
including
Mathematics, English, History, Logical Reasoning, Chemistry, and
General Science. These are areas in which this Court does not possess
the
requisite
technical
or
academic
competence.
In
such
circumstances, the scope of judicial review is necessarily limited. The
Court cannot act as an appellate body to re-evaluate the considered
opinions of SMEs. Intervention is warranted only where there is a
clear error of law, patent arbitrariness, or manifest procedural
impropriety. None of these conditions is established in the present
proceedings.
23.
Additionally, the rationale articulated by the SSC for awarding
marks uniformly in respect of incorrect/ambiguous/multiple correct
answers‟ questions cannot be rejected in its entirety. In an
examination scheme involving negative marking, a discerning
candidate may consciously refrain from attempting a doubtful or
ambiguous question to avoid penal consequences, notwithstanding the
time and effort invested. In such circumstances, distinguishing
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
candidates who attempted the question and those who did not may
itself result in inequity. The policy of extending benefit to all
candidates, when a question is declared invalid for want of a unique
correct answer, therefore rests on a discernible logic aimed at
mitigating unintended prejudice. At the same time, while different
examining bodies may legitimately adopt different corrective
mechanisms, such a policy must remain an exception rather than the
norm and cannot be invoked to mask systemic deficiencies in
question-setting or evaluation.
24.
The further reliance placed on Guru Nanak Dev University
(supra) to contend that marks ought to be awarded only to candidates
who attempted the disputed questions is misplaced. In the said case,
the examination did not involve negative marking, nor did it concern a
selection process of the scale involved in the present case. The factual
matrix therein, including the limited number of candidates, is
materially distinct, rendering the principle inapplicable to the
controversy at hand.
25.
Notably, the Petitioners were justified in pointing out specific
instances, including Question ID 630680674736 (Mathematics) and
Question ID 630680522658 (English), where, notwithstanding minor
typographical errors, the most appropriate option could reasonably be
deduced by a diligent and well-prepared candidate. Such errors,
though characterised as minor, ought not to have found place in a
competitive examination of this magnitude and do reflect a lack of due
care at the stage of framing and vetting of questions. At the same time,
once the examining authority, acting on expert opinion, chose to treat
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
the questions as ambiguous and adopted a uniform method of
moderation, the Court cannot substitute its own assessment for that of
the SMEs.
26.
This Bench in order to satisfy has also examined the questions,
opinions of the SME Committee and interacted with the concerned
official of the Board. In this case, it is not possible to conclusively
hold that the Final/Revised Answer Key is incorrect and the decision
taken by the Board was unjustified in given facts and circumstances.
27.
At this juncture, we find it necessary to record our considered
observations regarding the administrative stewardship of the SSC in
the conduct of the CGLE, 2024. The uniform grant of grace marks in
as many as twenty-two (22) questions to all candidates, including
those who had either not attempted the questions or had furnished
incorrect answers, represents a serious deviation from the principles of
competitive merit and procedural fairness. The magnitude of these
revisions is not merely incidental; it bespeaks a systemic lapse in the
framing, vetting, and finalisation of the question papers and answer
keys, including issues of translation parity, which should have been
unambiguous from the outset.
28.
By declaring final results prior to the publication of the final
answer key, SSC effectively insulated its decision-making from timely
scrutiny, thereby presenting aspirants with a fait accompli and
shielding systemic errors from challenge. While the sanctity of expert
opinion is acknowledged, the performance of the experts in this
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
instance reflects a degree of casualness and lack of rigour that cannot
pass without judicial notice.
29.
The requirement to revisit and revise expert opinion on such a
scale underscores avoidable deficiencies in both question-setting and
evaluation. Recruitment examinations of this nature are not mere
administrative exercises; they directly impact the careers of young
aspirants and shape the integrity of public service. Consequently, the
SSC is obliged to ensure that ambiguities are minimised and that
moderation mechanisms do not inadvertently penalise candidates, who
have made genuine effort, nor reward non-attempts, thereby
safeguarding the level playing field that lies at the heart of competitive
merit.
30.
Although the issue relating to the release of the final answer key
after declaration of results was not pressed before the Tribunal and
does not arise for adjudication in these petitions, we cannot ignore the
resulting anomaly. A candidate who correctly attempted a question in
one language version may suffer disadvantage due to defects in
another, while candidates who did not attempt the question stand to
benefit. Such an outcome underscores the need for clear, consistent,
and transparent policies to govern ambiguous or defective questions.
31.
In light of the above, we expect the SSC to adopt a more
circumspect and systematic approach in the framing, vetting, and
finalisation of question papers and answer keys. Institutionalising a
clear and transparent policy for addressing ambiguities and objections
will not only enhance the credibility of examinations but also
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
significantly reduce avoidable litigation. While no directions are
warranted in the present case, the SSC must exercise greater academic
rigour and administrative diligence in all future examinations, so as to
prevent recurrence of the shortcomings evident in the present exercise.
32.
Viewed cumulatively, while the conduct of the SSC in the
present examination reveals serious lapses in academic rigour and
administrative diligence that merit strong judicial disapproval, the
corrective measures ultimately adopted were founded on expert
opinion and cannot be characterised as vitiated by patent illegality,
arbitrariness, or procedural impropriety warranting interference in the
exercise of writ jurisdiction. The Tribunal, therefore, acted within the
permissible bounds of judicial restraint in declining to interfere with
the final answer key and evaluation process. Notwithstanding our
expressed concerns, the settled principles governing judicial review in
academic matters compel this Court to uphold the impugned
decisions.
CONCLUSION
33.
In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered
opinion that the refusal of the learned Tribunal to interfere with the
impugned action represents a reasoned exercise of discretion,
consistent with the settled principles governing judicial restraint in
matters relating to academic evaluation.
34.
Accordingly, the Impugned Orders are upheld.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
35.
The present Writ Petitions are dismissed. All pending
applications also stand disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
FEBRUARY 05, 2026
sp/sh
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:41:26
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review