Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (WA) No.20/2023 in
WA No.25/2023
Date of order: 14.08.2023
Union of India & ors
Rakesh Kumar
Vs.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
:
Mr. M. Chanda, Adv with
Mr. K. Abinav, Adv
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv
For the Respondents :
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
In view of the good grounds shown, the delay of about 194 days
in preferring the appeal is condoned and the appeal is taken on record.
2.
The appeal is taken up for immediate consideration.
3.
The appellant herein has suffered a punishment of compulsory
retirement passed by the General Assam Rifles Court for the appellant
having overstayed his leave without sufficient cause for a period of 439
days. At the relevant point of time, the appellant was an Assistant
Commandant (MO) in the force.
4.
The primary grounds canvassed by the appellant in the writ
petition carried against the order of punishment and the appellate order
rejecting the appellant’s appeal were that the principles of natural
justice were not followed in the sense that no copy of the inquiry report
or no finding of the disciplinary authority agreeing with the inquiry
report was forwarded to the appellant. It is apparent on a plain reading
of the writ petition that the approach of the appellant herein was as in
disciplinary proceedings conducted in civilian organisations where an
inquiry officer is appointed before whom the delinquent has a chance to
rebut the evidence against him following which the inquiry officer’s
report is dealt with by the disciplinary authority, whereupon, the
disciplinary authority issues a notice to the delinquent, upon satisfying
himself of the evidence against the delinquent, to consider whether to
proceed to award some form of punishment to the delinquent.
5.
In such disciplinary proceedings, the delinquent has a chance to
adduce evidence to counter the charges levelled against him before the
inquiry officer and, again, has a chance to persuade the disciplinary
authority to not agree with the findings of the inquiry officer to the
extent they are against the delinquent. Both at the inquiry stage and at
the consideration for punishment stage, reasons are required to be
recorded and the delinquent is served the inquiry report and the
reasoned order of punishment.
6.
In the ordinary disciplinary proceedings in any civilian
government organisation, the disciplinary authority, upon receipt of the
report of the inquiry officer, has several courses of action open. First,
the disciplinary authority may altogether disagree with the inquiry
officer’s report and find that the evidence on the charges to be
completely lacking. In such a case, the disciplinary authority does not
have to forward the inquiry report to the delinquent, but he merely
closes the disciplinary proceedings and informs the concerned employee
accordingly. Secondly, the disciplinary authority may, prima facie,
agree with some of the findings and, prima facie, disagree with some
others and may require the inquiry officer to reconsider the matter upon
notice to the delinquent. Thirdly, the disciplinary authority may, prima
facie, agree with some of the findings and, to such extent, call upon the
delinquent to show-cause why he should not be punished in such regard.
Finally, the disciplinary authority may, prima facie, agree completely
with the inquiry officer’s findings and refer the inquiry report to the
delinquent as to why the findings should not be upheld and the
delinquent appropriately dealt with.
7.
However, in a disciplined force as any Central Armed Police
Force, the procedure for conducting disciplinary proceedings is laid
down in the statute governing such force or the rules framed under the
governing statute. It is not necessary that every report or every finding
be communicated to the delinquent. There are checks and balances to
ensure that the findings rendered are confirmed by a superior official.
The emphasis is on discipline being maintained in a disciplined force
and, as long as the delinquent has been heard on the charges and
findings are rendered which are confirmed by a superior official, the
procedural integrity is maintained.
8.
The discussion in this case need not have been as long as it is,
since the appellant herein was charged with unexplained absence from
duty for 439 days and his justification therefor was the apparent illness
of his mother. On the face of it, the matter appears to be so absurd that it
can be hardly expected of a disciplined force to accept such excuse,
unless exceptional circumstances are cited.
9.
It must also be said at this stage, that the scope of judicial
review is limited here to ascertain the procedural fairness and an
enquiry as to whether the delinquent in this case had an opportunity to
defend himself. This Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution, does not sit in an appeal over the decision of the
disciplinary authority and does not go into the sufficiency of the reasons
in such regard. It is the decision-making process, rather than the
decision itself, which is reviewed as to its reasonableness.
10.
A tentative charge-sheet was served on the appellant on August
31, 2013. He was charged under Section 26 of the Assam Rifles Act,
2006 for unexplained absence from his post. Two instances of absence
without justification of 28 days and 439 days were cited against him.
There is no dispute that the appellant herein was aware of the chargesheet and participated in the proceedings, initially before a court of
inquiry and, finally, before a General Assam Rifles Court. Indeed, the
appellant herein availed of every opportunity available under the statute
and the rules framed thereunder to furnish an explanation and get away
with the same. After the conclusion of the matter before the Assam
Rifles Court, the appellant applied for mitigation in terms of Rule 115
of the Assam Rifles Rules, 2010. He also preferred an appeal before the
Director-General against the promulgation of punishment that was
issued on January 5, 2015. In course of his appeal to the DGAR, the
substantial ground is captured in the following paragraph:
“(v) The disciplinary proceedings did not take the cognizance of
compelling circumstances and justification submitted by me for
my absence and sentenced me to a harsh punishment of
compulsory retirement. The quantum of punishment in this case
exceeds the natural justice.”
11.
What cannot be missed is the complete failure on the part of the
appellant herein to complain of any procedural irregularity or any
prejudice suffered by the appellant as a consequence thereof. Though at
this stage in appeal against the writ court’s order some specious grounds
have been sought to be raised as to the reasons for the punishment not
being furnished to the appellant, the appellant was aware of his rights in
accordance with the statute and the rules governing him and, at the time
of his domestic appeal, the appellant did not raise such grounds. As a
consequence, the appellant is estopped at this stage from complaining of
any procedural irregularity or the reasons for his punishment not being
furnished to him.
12.
In any event, even upon a trial being conducted by an Assam
Rifles Court, there does not appear to be any specific provision in the
statute or in the rules for furnishing the reasons to the delinquent. It
appears that reasons ought to be recorded by a Force Court for the
purpose of the confirming authority being persuaded to confirm the
punishment proposed or recommended. There is no dispute that the
confirming authority in this case duly confirmed the punishment
recommended by the Force Court and the nature of such punishment
was communicated to the appellant on January 5, 2015 which prompted
him to prefer the domestic appeal on or about February 2, 2015.
13.
One of the grounds that has been urged by the appellant is that
the punishment was not commensurate with the nature of the offence
that he was charged with. It is the further case of the appellant that not
only was the punishment harsh, but also that such a punishment may not
have been permissible since Section 26 of the Act, under which the
appellant was charged and which provides for a punishment that may
extend up to three years in prison.
14.
On behalf of the respondents, copious references have been
made to the statute and the rules framed thereunder, including Section
57 of the Act and the scale of punishment set down in sub-section (1)
thereof. To boot, Section 57(2) of the Act provides that the descending
order of punishment, in terms of its harshness, is indicated in subsection (1) of the provision. Since the punishment of compulsory
retirement in this case is found at Section 57(1)(d), it is a lesser form of
punishment that a term of imprisonment for three years which is
covered by clause (b) of the same provision. Section 58 of the Act
permits an Assam Rifles Court, on convicting a person, inter alia, under
Section 26 of the Act to award the particular punishment with which the
offence is stated in the relevant provision or, in lieu thereof, any of the
punishments lower in scale set out in Section 57 of the Act. Several
provisions from the rules, including the procedure to be followed for
recording evidence by a court of inquiry and the procedure to be
followed by an Assam Rifles Court have been placed from the rules.
There does not appear to be any merit in the vague and general refrain
of the appellant that the prescribed procedure was not followed or that
any prejudice has been occasioned to the appellant as a consequence
thereof.
15.
Apropos the appellant’s assertion that he was not given the
relevant documents for him to either defend himself or understand why
he has been punished to the extent that he has been, the respondents
refer to a receipt of October 17, 2014, a copy whereof appears at page
119 of the appeal papers. It is the undeniable position from such receipt
that the appellant herein was duly forwarded the inquiry report
pertaining to his initial period of 28 days’ absence and the subsequent
period of 439 days’ absence. In addition, the summary of evidence in
respect of either charge was also forwarded to the appellant and duly
received by the appellant.
16.
The respondents also refer to a previous occasion where the
appellant was absent without justification for a further period of 450
days some time in 2007 and 2008. Though some minor punishment was
suffered by the appellant for such long absence without justification, the
Assam Rifles Court and the confirming authority were well within their
rights to consider the general conduct of the appellant herein in
habitually absenting himself from his post without sufficient cause. As a
consequence, the punishment of compulsory retirement awarded to the
appellant does not shock the conscience of the Court, since the appellant
was employed in a disciplined force.
17.
The judgment and order impugned dated December 1, 2022 has
taken all relevant considerations into account. It is evident on a reading
of such judgment that the primary thrust of the appellant before the writ
court was that the procedure which was required to be followed in view
of the judgment reported at (1993) 4 SCC 727 (Managing Director,
ECIL v. B. Karunakar) had been breached. Since the procedure in
respect of Assam Rifles is completely different and is not covered by
the CCS Rules and is, rather, laid down in its independent statute and
the rules framed thereunder, the reference to the Karunakar’s case was
completely misplaced.
18.
Further, as noticed above, the grounds sought to be urged in the
writ petition were never canvassed in course of the domestic appeal.
19.
There is no merit in the appeal and the writ court was perfectly
justified in dismissing the petition and leaving the appellant to his fate.
20.
WA No.25 of 2023 is dismissed.
21.
Since the appellant has lost his service, he is spared the costs
that he richly deserved in carrying this eminently avoidable appeal.
22.
MC (WA) No.20 of 2023 is disposed of.
(H. S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
14.08.2023
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review