Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:40895
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
FAO(FC) No.48 of 2026
Rakesh Kumar
Decided on: 23.09.2026
… appellant.
Versus
Sarla Devi
… Respondent
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1Yes
____________________________________________________
For the appellant:
Mr. Gurinder Singh Parmar, Advocate.
_
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge (Oral)
CMP(M) No.1571 of 2026
By way of this application, a prayer has been made for
condonation of 7 days’ delay in filing the appeal.
2.
Having heard learned Counsel for the parties, we are of
the considered view that as the delay in filing the appeal is not all
that inordinate, we allow the application and condone the delay. The
application stands disposed of.
FAO(FC) No.48 of 2026
3.
Be registered. By way of this appeal, the appellant has
assailed the order passed by the Court of the learned Additional
Principal Judge, Family Court, Amb, District Una, H.P., in petition
Registration No.9 of 2019, titled Rakesh Kumar versus Sarla Devi,
decided on 17.06.2026, in terms whereof, the petition filed by the
appellant under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship
Act, 1956, for the grant of a decree of custody of the minor Vansh
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:40895
Thakur, son of the appellant in his capacity as the natural
guardian/father of the minor son, has been dismissed by the learned
Court below.
4.
Learned Counsel for the appellant argued that the
impugned judgment is perverse and not in accordance with law, as
the learned Court below erred in not appreciating that as the
appellant is the natural guardian of the minor son, he has the first
right over the custody of the child. Learned Counsel further argued
that the learned Court below also erred in not appreciating that as
the appellant was not given custody of his minor child, there would
be no bonding between him and the minor child and this would be
an impediment to the growth of the minor child after his maternal
grandparents, to whom his custody has been granted are no more.
No other point was argued.
5.
Having heard learned Counsel for the appellant and
having perused the judgment under challenge, we are of the
considered view that this appeal has no merit.
6.
The findings recorded by the learned Court below while
dismissing the petition of the present appellant are cogent findings,
which in the course of submissions made by the learned Counsel for
the appellant could not be demonstrated to be perverse or not borne
out from the record.
7.
In fact, we are quoting Para-34 onwards of the judgment
passed by the learned Court below for ready reference hereinbelow:-
2026:HHC:40895
“...34. Thus, the minor child has been living with the
respondent, his maternal grandmother, essentially since
his infancy. As of today, considerable time has elapsed,
and the child has been in the continuous care and
custody of the respondent for the overwhelming majority
of his life. The child has become fully acclimatized to his
current living environment. He has developed deep
emotional bonds with the respondent, who has been his
primary caregiver and the only constant parental figure in
his life following the demise of his mother.
35. The record before this Court demonstrates that the
minor child Vansh Thakur is now regularly attending
school and is pursuing his education in a settled and
stable manner. The respondent has been bearing all the
expenses
of
the
child's
education
and
upbringing.
Uprooting the child from his current environment and
school, and transplanting him into an entirely different
family setting with the petitioner, would undoubtedly have
a cascading and adverse effect on the child's overall wellbeing, his academic progress, his emotional stability, and
his growth and development. The courts have consistently
held that continuity and stability in a child's educational
and social environment are vital components of the child's
welfare, and any disruption to the same must be avoided
unless there are compelling reasons to the contrary.
36. In the course of proceedings, the minor child Vansh
Thakur has appeared before this Court. After personal
interaction with the child, the Court found that the child
has given unequivocal and clear consent to stay with his
maternal grandmother, the respondent Sarla Devi. The
child expressed his preference firmly and without any
hesitation.
2026:HHC:40895
37. The wishes of a child, particularly when the child is of
sufficient age and understanding to form an intelligent
preference, are a factor of great weight in custody matters.
In the present case, the minor child has attained an age
where he is capable of articulating his preference, and his
desire to remain with the respondent is a significant
indicator that his emotional and psychological well-being
is best served in the custody of the maternal grandmother.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in multiple decisions, has
emphasized that the wishes of the child, while not
determinative, are an important factor and must be given
due consideration. In the present case, the child's
expressed preference aligns with the other factors pointing
towards the welfare of the child being best served in the
respondent's custody.
38. It is also pertinent to note that the petitioner, by his
own admission, did not have effective physical custody of
the minor child for any substantial period since the child's
infancy, Even during the lifetime of the child's mother, the
petitioner did not file any petition for custody of the child.
The petition was filed only after the death of Sapna Devi.
Furthermore, the respondent has stated this, and the
petitioner has not effectively rebutted it, that the petitioner
did not pay maintenance as ordered by the Court, nor did
he take active steps to maintain a relationship with the
child during his formative years. While a father's right as
a natural guardian under the Act is not in question, the
exercise of such right must yield to the paramount
consideration of the welfare of the child.
39. In the present case, while the petitioner, as the
biological father, has a statutory right recognised under
the Act, the exercise of that right must be measured
2026:HHC:40895
against the comprehensive welfare of the child. The
petitioner's legal right as natural guardian does not
automatically entitle him to physical custody where the
welfare of the child demands otherwise.
ORDER
40. In light of the above discussion and for the reasons
stated herein, the present petition filed by the petitioner
Rakesh Kumar under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and
Guardianship Act, 1956, seeking custody of minor Vansh
Thakur, is hereby DISMISSED.
41. However, it is clarified that the petitioner, being the
biological father of the minor, may seek and exercise
visitation rights in accordance with the interim order
already passed by this Court dated 20.04.2019 (as
modified on 14.05.2019), or may file a fresh application
for appropriate visitation rights as the father of the child.
42. No order as to costs.”
8.
A perusal of the above paragraphs of the judgment
demonstrate that the learned Court below while dismissing the
petition, took into consideration the fact that the minor child was
living with his maternal grandmother since his infancy. As the child
was
in
the
continuous
care
and
custody
of
the
maternal
grandmother for the overwhelming majority of his life, he had
become fully acclimatized to his living environment and had also
developed deep emotional bonds with his maternal grandmother,
who was his primary caretaker and also a constant parental figure
in his life after the demise of his mother. Learned Court below also
took note of the fact that the minor child was regularly attending a
2026:HHC:40895
school and pursuing his education in a settled and stable manner
and that his entire expenses were being borne by the maternal
grandmother and it observed that in these circumstances, uprooting
the
child
from
his
current
environment
and
school
and
transplanting him into an entirely different family setting with the
appellant herein, would have a cascading and adverse effect on the
child's overall well-being, his academic progress, his emotional
stability, as well as his growth and development.
Learned Court
below thereafter observed that the personal interaction with the
child demonstrated that the child unequivocally wanted to stay with
his maternal grandmother and the child had expressed his
preference in this regard firmly and without any hesitation. Learned
Court below also observed that the wish of the child, particularly
when the child was of sufficient age so as to form an understanding
of an intelligent preference, was to be given due weightage and on
the basis of these observations, the learned Court below dismissed
the petition by holding that the emotional and psychological wellbeing of the minor child would be best served in the custody of the
maternal grandmother.
9.
The findings returned by the learned Court below, as
observed by us hereinabove also, are cogent and well reasoned. We
totally agree with the reasoning given by the learned Court below in
the judgment. In the circumstances as have been mentioned in the
judgment passed by the learned Court, the custody of the child
2026:HHC:40895
obviously with the maternal grandmother, with whom the minor
child is residing since his infancy after the demise of his mother, is
best for the overall growth and emotional stability of the child.
10.
As far as the contention of the learned Counsel for the
appellant that until and unless physical custody of the child is not
given to the appellant, no binding will develop between him and the
child is concerned, we do not agree with the same. In our considered
view, this purpose can be served in case the appellant seeks
appropriate visitation rights in his capacity as the father of the child,
so that in the interregnum, he can develop emotional bond with the
child without uprooting him from the emotional comfort zone in
which he presently is with his grandmother.
11.
Accordingly, in light of the above observations, as we do
not find any merit in the present appeal, the same is dismissed, so
also the pending miscellaneous application(s), if any.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
(Yogesh Jaswal)
Judge
September 23, 2026
(Rishi)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review