Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
CAN 1 of 2019 (Old CAN 8317 of 2019)
Aniruddha Kar & Ors.
Versus
West Bengal State Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd. & Ors.
With
WPA 24642 of 2018
With
CAN 1 of 2019 (Old CAN 8318 of 2019)
Rakesh Kumar Srivastava & Anr.
Versus
West Bengal State Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd. & Ors.
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Soumya Majumdar
Mr. Victor Chatterjee
For the WBSEDCL
:
Mr. Joydeep Kar, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Sujit Sankar Koley
Mr. S. Deb
Heard on
:
26.02.2024, 03.04.2024, 14.06.2024,
08.11.2024, 07.02.2025, 04.04.2025,
02.05.2025, 13.06.2025, 12.12.2025, &
19.12.2025.
Judgment on
:
19th March 2026.
Raja Basu Chowdhury, J:
1. Both the writ petitions raised common questions, accordingly the
same are taken up for consideration together. The petitioners
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
claimed to have passed the intermediate from the Institute of Cost
Works Accountants of India (in short “ICWAI”), a statutory body
constituted under an Act of Parliament. On the basis of a
requisition sent by the respondent no.1 to ICWAI expressly agreeing
to provide opportunity to the selected candidates, for undergoing
practical training under the respondent no.1, the petitioners were
selected as Semi-Professional Accounts Personnel as trainees. The
initial deployment was for a period of 6 months. The orders based
on which the petitioners were selected dates back to January, 2010.
2. According to the petitioners, the respondent no.1 had approved a
recruitment policy in the year 2010 whereby recruitment through
campus interview was one of the modes of recruitment. According
to the petitioners, the petitioners are rendering service since the
year 2009-10 in the Accounts Department of the respondent no.1.
At the time of initial engagement, the petitioners received a stipend
of Rs.6,000/- per month. The aforesaid trainee service has since
been extended from time to time and the petitioners continue to
work as trainees with the respondent no.1 till date. According to the
petitioners, the works executed by the petitioners have been
recognized and appreciated by the Assistant Manager, who has also
on the basis of the petitioners’ performance and service had
forwarded their case of regularization, for consideration by the
General Manager of the respondent no.1. The petitioners at the time
of filing the writ petition, were receiving a fixed remuneration of Rs.
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
14,000/- per month. The petitioners contend that the service
rendered and the work performed by them are integral part of the
finance and accounts department of the respondent no.1 and
without the service of the petitioners, the respondents would not be
able to function properly. The petitioners claim that the jobs
performed by the petitioners are same and identical as the jobs
performed by the Junior Executives (Finance). According to the
petitioners, the post of Junior Executive (Finance) is the base post
in the financial cadre. According to the petitioners, they have been
continuously rendering their services at par with the Junior
Executives (Finance) and as such are entitled to equal pay for equal
work, which has been denied. The petitioners also contend that
there is hostile discrimination between the petitioners and the
Junior Executives (Finance) and as such interference is called for.
The petitioners have already served the respondent no.1 for more
than a decade and as such though, the respondent no.1 had offered
opportunity to the petitioners to participate in the recruitment by
providing age relaxation upto 27 years, such age relaxation does not
assist the petitioners as the petitioners have crossed the relaxed age
of 27 years. According to the petitioners, though the petitioners had
participated in the selection process of 2013, 2014 and 2015,
however, the petitioners could not succeed. Notwithstanding the
same, the petitioners continue to discharge their functions as
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
trainees at the fixed remuneration. It is in the facts noted
hereinabove, the instant writ petitions have been filed.
3. Mr. Majumder, learned senior advocate appears for the petitioners
and has placed before this Court the judgments delivered in the
case of Jaggo v. Union of India & Ors., reported in 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 3826, Shripal & Anr. v. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad,
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 221 and Dharam Singh & Ors.
v. State of U.P. & Anr., reported in 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 818, to
contend that the respondents cannot be permitted to exploit the
petitioners by retaining them as trainees on the one hand, without
providing them with adequate remuneration as the same seeks to
infringe upon the rights of the petitioners as guaranteed under
Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India. He has also
relied on the following judgments:
i. Union of India & Ors. v. Vartak Labour Union (2), reported
in (2011) 4 SCC 200,
ii. Durgapur
Casual
Workers
Union
&
Ors.
v.
Food
Corporation of India & Ors., reported in (2015) 5 SCC 786,
iii. State of M.P. & Ors. v. Yogesh Chandra Dubey & Ors.,
reported in (2006) 8 SCC 67 and
iv. State of Karnataka & Ors. v. M. L. Kesari & Ors.,
reported in (2010) 9 SCC 247.
4. Mr. Kar, learned senior advocate appears for the respondents.
According to the respondents, the petitioners were deployed as
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
trainees and as such the respondent no.1 has no obligation to
absorb the trainees so deployed. According to Mr. Kar, most of the
trainees had appeared in the regular selection process for the post
of
Junior
Executive
(Finance)
competing/participating
in
and
regular
several
candidates
after
selection
process
were
successful and had been engaged in the regular post of the
respondent no.1. Unfortunately, although, the petitioners availed of
the opportunity but could not succeed; the respondents thus,
cannot be made responsible therefore. Admittedly, the petitioners
were not deployed in the regular sanctioned posts, they also could
not be successful in the regular selection process and as such they
have no right to seek for absorption. According to the respondents,
although, the petitioners had been unsuccessful in the first
attempt, a second opportunity was given to the petitioners by
relaxing
their
Unfortunately,
age
to
despite
participate
in
the
they
above,
the
selection
process.
could not avail
the
opportunity. It is the respondents’ contention that Regulation 11 of
the Company Service Regulation WBSEBEST is applicable in
respect of regular employees of the respondent no.1 holding
sanctioned post and not for any other category of employees like the
petitioners, who do not have any right as they are not recruited
through regular recruitment process. They are the trainees who
were employed to give them exposure and gain experience on the
basis of an understanding with the institute. According to Mr. Kar,
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
the appointment of the petitioners cannot be regularized in the light
of the judgment delivered in the case of Secretary, State of
Karnataka & Ors v. Umadevi (3) & Ors., reported in (2006) 4
SCC 1. It is contended that the judgment delivered in the case of
Umadevi (3) (supra) is a Constitutional Bench judgment and as
such the ratio of the judgment still holds the fields.
5. Heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties
and considered the materials on record.
6. It is not in dispute that the petitioners had been selected in their
capacity as Semi-Professional Accounts Personnel, who had passed
intermediate examination of the ICWA and were accordingly
deployed as trainees for a period of 6 months. It is also not in
dispute that the aforesaid trainees, who are the petitioners, have
since been continued by successive agreements. With the passage
of time, the applicable rates/stipend paid to the petitioners have
been enhanced. Having regard to the case made out by the
respective parties and noting that the petitioners are in continuous
employment though in their capacity of trainees for more than a
decade, this Court in order to consider whether the petitioners are
entitled to the relief as sought for has considered the recruitment
policy of 2010 of the respondent no.1. As would appear from the
aforesaid recruitment policy, the said policy, inter alia, provides that
the recruitment shall be made in the mode and manner provided for
in such policy and no recruitment shall be made otherwise than
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
through any one of the following methods. To morefully appreciate
the methods of recruitment, the same is extracted hereinbelow:
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
7. As would appear from the above, one of the modes of recruitment is
through the scope of walk-in interview, campus interview in the
institute of repute with prior intimation, after observing standard
practice reflecting transparency of the selecting institute and/or the
candidates. Admittedly, in this case, the respondent no.1 had
approached the Chairman, East India Regional Council of ICWAI
and on the basis of interview had selected candidates/students to
provide them an opportunity of practical training. In the instant
case, the above training has, however, been continued for an
unlimited period. In the interregnum, however, in terms of an office
order, the respondent no.1 had permitted the trainees to participate
in a regular selection process by relaxing the upper age limit for
professionally
semi
qualified
trainees
having
qualified
ICWA
intermediate examination or equivalent for the post of Junior
Executive (Finance). It is also not in dispute that the petitioners had
participated in such process and some of the participants who had
been successful from amongst the trainees, had been recruited.
Unfortunately, the persons who did not succeed were continued as
trainees with the respondent no.1. Although, it has been stated by
the respondents that the petitioners cannot be equated with the
other
regular
employees
and
no
backdoor
appointment
is
permissible in the light of the judgment delivered in the case of
Umadevi (3) (supra), however, I find that it is not in dispute that the
petitioners continue to remain employed with the respondent no.1
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
despite
having
not
succeeded
in
the
recruitment
process.
Ordinarily, if the petitioners were not found to be successful, the
respondents ought not to have permitted the petitioners to
continue, such is not the case. I find that the petitioners claim to be
discharging the duties as Junior Executive (Finance). I also find
that there is no denial of the fact that the petitioners are
discharging the same work as of the Junior Executive (Finance).
What is disputed, however, is the right of the petitioners to claim
the status of the Junior Executive (Finance) without the petitioners
being appointed to such post through regular recruitment process.
The respondent no.1 is, however, not shy to retain the petitioners in
the post of trainee by paying the petitioners a meagre amount for
decades together. For more than 15 years, the petitioners are
discharging their duties in their capacity as Junior Executive
trainees. I find that the Manager, Finance & Accounts of the
respondent no.1 had prepared a note-sheet dated 8 th May, 2013
wherein it has been recorded that although, the petitioners had
initially been selected for training, however, their engagement after
successful completion was extended with the approval accorded by
the Board of Directors in the meeting held on 29th March, 2010 and
consequently the subsequent extension were all done with the
approval
of
the
Chairman-cum-Managing
Directors
of
the
respondent no.1. Such note-sheet further records that the trainees
have been discharging their duties continuously, delivering the
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
goods that too with “Colossal effort” and the said note-sheet further
records that the annual report of the year 2009 -10, 2010-11 and
2011-12 were finalized far early compared to the other years and
those trainees put in sizable effort for such early finalization. It has
also been categorically indicated that the trainees have played a
pivotal role in implementation of the system based inventory
module in various units which facilitated in curbing the delay in
preparation of trial balance of the units and their importance has
been felt by reasons of shortage of manpower availability in the
finance and accounts discipline. It is in the light of the above, that a
recommendation had been made to extend the engagement of the
aforesaid trainees. Although, the writ petitions have been opposed
on the ground that the petition is in fact a plea for regularization,
however, I find that the respondents themselves having utilized the
employees without according approval to the appointment of the
petitioners in the regular post in terms of the recruitment policy of
2010 seeks to interfere with the rights of the petitioners as
enshrined in the Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
Admittedly, there is shortage of manpower, the trainees are utilized
to fill in the gap. The continuous discharge of duties by the
petitioners ordinarily, and having regard to the recruitment policy of
the respondents cannot be said to be back door entry since, the
respondents themselves have proceeded to formulate a policy for
selecting eligible candidates through walk-in-interview and campus
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
interview in the institute of repute. If the petitioners were not
successful, the respondents ought not to have extracted the service
from the petitioners in the guise of retaining the petitioners as
trainees. Imparting practical training, in my view, cannot be
permitted to continue for more than one and half decades. The
judgment delivered in the case of Umadevi (3) (supra), which was
rendered to curtail the practice of backdoor entries has been set up
by the respondents to fraudulently extract work from the petitioners
by treating them as trainees without engaging them on regular
basis. The petitioners are being engaged for extended periods in
roles
which
are
integral
to
the
organization’s
functioning.
Continuous engagement of the petitioners as trainees not only
contravenes labour standard but also exposes the organization to
legal challenge and undermines employees’ morale, and the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has already deprecated such practice in the case of
Jaggo (supra). In the case of Shripal (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has also recognized that the employer should not be
permitted to utilize manpower by misuse of ‘Temporary’ labels.
8. In the light of the above, I am of the view that the services of the
petitioners cannot be continued by treating them trainee any
further. Since, the respondent no.1 has been enjoying the services
of the petitioners and have been benefited from their service to a
great extent as has been recognized in the minutes prepared by the
Manager/Finance of the respondent no.1, the petitioners should
WPA 25162 of 2018
with
WPA 24642 of 2018
forthwith be regularized with immediate effect against the posts
which were directed to kept vacant in terms of the interim orders
passed by this Court on 7th December, 2018 in both the matters,
and should be treated at par with the Junior Executive (Finance)
from the date of filing of the writ petition. All consequences shall
follow.
9. The writ petitions along with the connected applications also stand
disposed of.
10.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be made
available to the parties upon compliance of requisite formalities.
(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J.)
Later:
Mr. Koley, learned advocate representing the respondent no.1,
prays for stay of operation of this judgment, the same is considered and
refused.
(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review