Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~1, 32 & 33
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 04th August, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010292062004
+
W.P.(C) 7987/2004, CM APPL. 35754/2018
……Petitioners
B.C. PANT & ORS.
Through:
Mr. L.K. Singh, Advocate.
versus
….Respondents
UOI & ANR.
Through:
Mr. Bhagwan Swarup Shukla, CGSC
with Mr. Dashmesh Tripathi,
Advocate for UOI.
#
CNR No. DLHC012269112018
+
W.P.(C) 8922/2018, CM APPL. 34316/2018
RAKESH BATRA & ORS.
Through:
…… Petitioners
Mr. L.K. Singh, Advocate.
Versus
#
….Respondents
Mr. Bhagwan Swarup Shukla, CGSC
with Mr. Dashmesh Tripathi and Mr.
Praveen Gupta, Advocates for UOI.
CNR No. DLHC010224322021
+
W.P.(C) 7195/2021, CM APPL. 22690/2021
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
VINODI KUMARI
Through:
…..Petitioner
Mr. L.K. Singh, Advocate.
versus
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
….Respondents
Through: Mr. Bhagwan Swarup Shukla, CGSC with
Mr. Dashmesh Tripathi and Mr. Praveen
Gupta, Advocates for UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J. (Oral):
The Dispute
1.
These petitions arise from a dispute concerning the pay structure of
Assistants, Stenographers and certain employees in the promotional
hierarchy of the Sangeet Natak Akademi [“the Akademi”] and its constituent
units. The controversy traces its origin to the decision of the Government of
India to revise the pay scale of Assistants in the Central Secretariat Service
and Grade ‘C’ Stenographers in the Central Secretariat Stenographers
Service from INR 1,400-2,600 to INR 1,640-2,900 with effect from 1st
January, 1986. The dispute has remained alive for more than three decades
and, in the present round, has been pending before this Court since 2004.
2.
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 concerns the foundational claim that the Rules,
Regulations and Service Bye-laws of the Akademi themselves entitle its
Assistants and Stenographers to the pay scale granted to the corresponding
categories in the Central Government, independent of the doctrine of ‘equal
pay for equal work’.
3.
W.P.(C) 8922/2018 and W.P.(C) 7195/2021 arise from orders issued
in 2018 withdrawing grade pays granted after implementation of the 6 th
Central Pay Commission [“CPC”], directing retrospective refixation of pay
and proposing recovery. W.P.(C) 8922/2018 is by a group of employees of
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
the Akademi and its constituent units, namely, Rabindra Rangshala and
Kathak Kendra. W.P.(C) 7195/2021 is by Vinodi Kumari, whose challenge
extends to the pay attached to the post of Section Officer, the non-functional
grade pay and regularisation of her promotion as Deputy Secretary.
Constitution of the Akademi and its Governing Instruments
4.
The Akademi was constituted by a Resolution of the Ministry of
Education dated 31st May, 1952 and was subsequently registered as a society
under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. Its Memorandum of Association
[“MoA”] authorises the creation of administrative, technical and ministerial
posts and the framing of Rules, Regulations and Bye-laws. Clause 3(xxvi) of
the MoA permits additions, amendments, variation or rescission of those
instruments from time to time with the approval of the Central Government.
5.
Under Rule 13, the “general superintendence, direction and control of
the affairs of the Akademi” vest in its Executive Board. Rule 15(vii), subject
to approval of the General Council, empowers the Board to incur
expenditure on the establishment, create posts considered necessary and
prescribe the terms and conditions of appointment. The proviso to that subclause requires Government approval for creation and filling of posts whose
maximum pay exceeds INR 2,000 per month. Rule 15(xiii), separately,
empowers the Executive Board to prescribe the terms and conditions of
service in respect of all posts under the control of the Akademi.
6.
The Service Bye-laws were approved by the Government of India,
Department of Culture, on 28th February, 1995 and by the General Council
of the Akademi on 26th April, 1995. Chapter V deals specifically with “Pay
and Allowances”. Bye-law 19 provides that the scales of pay for posts under
the Akademi shall be as specified in Schedule ‘A’, as amended from time to
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
time. Bye-laws 20, 21, 22 and 23 deal respectively with initial pay and
increments, special and personal pay, drawal of pay and allowances. Byelaw 57 governs residuary conditions of service.
Pay-Scale History
Before implementation of the 4th CPC, Assistants and Stenographers
7.
in the Akademi were drawing the scale of INR 425-800. Upon
implementation of the 4th CPC, they were placed in the replacement scale of
INR 1,400-2,600.
By Office Memorandum dated 31st July, 1990, the Government of
8.
India revised the scale of Assistants in the Central Secretariat Service and
Grade ‘C’ Stenographers in the Central Secretariat Stenographers Service
from INR 1,400-2,600 to INR 1,640-2,900 with effect from 1st January,
1986. The Office Memorandum also extended the scale to certain nonparticipating organisations where the posts were in comparable grades,
carried the same classification and pay scale and were filled through a
similar method of recruitment by open competitive examination.
9.
The employees of the Akademi sought the same revision. In April
1992, the Akademi informed them that the Department of Culture had
declined the request, relying upon a Ministry of Finance Office
Memorandum dated 11th December, 1990 which stated that the instructions
dated 31st July, 1990 were not applicable to autonomous bodies. However,
the matter did not end there; on 2nd December, 1994, the Finance Committee
reconsidered the claim and recommended the higher scale. The Executive
Board also supported that recommendation on 7th December, 1994.
10.
After approval of the Service Bye-laws in 1995, the matter was again
considered by the Finance Committee and the Executive Board. At the
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
meeting of 27th July, 1995, the representative of the Department of Culture
informed the Board that the issue of parity was under examination. The
Akademi thereafter addressed detailed communications dated 19 th April,
1996 and 15th July, 1996 to the Department of Culture. It relied upon the
method of recruitment, the duties performed, the earlier identity of scales,
and the position of Assistants and Stenographers as the feeder cadre for the
post of Superintendent, later redesignated as Section Officer. No favourable
decision followed.
The First Round of Litigation
11.
The affected Assistants and Stenographers instituted C.W. No.
3790/1995. By judgment dated 16th October, 1998, a Single Bench of this
Court allowed the petition and directed grant of the scale of INR 1,6402,900 with effect from 1st January, 1986.
12.
On 10th December, 1998, the Executive Board considered the
judgment. It approved revision of the scale in respect of the successful
Petitioners and, separately, extended the revised scale to all other serving
Assistants and Stenographers of the Akademi and its constituent units.
13.
The Union of India preferred LPA No. 93/1999. By judgment dated
31st May, 2002, the Division Bench allowed the appeal and rejected the
claim to the higher scale insofar as it rested on the principle of ‘equal pay
for equal work’. The judgment of the Single Bench was set aside.
14.
The Petitioners approached the Supreme Court. The first Special
Leave Petition was withdrawn with liberty to seek review before the
Division Bench. The review petition was dismissed on 18 th December, 2003.
The Petitioners thereafter filed SLP (C) No. 7916/2004.
15.
By order dated 30th April, 2004, the Supreme Court declined to
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
interfere with the rejection of the claim founded upon ‘equal pay for equal
work’. It, however, noticed a distinct claim which had not been
“independently and objectively considered”, namely, whether the Rules,
Regulations and Service Bye-laws of the Akademi themselves provided for
payment of the scale of pay and allowances applicable to similar personnel
under the Government of India.
16.
The Supreme Court observed that if the Bye-laws constituting the
conditions of service provided for a particular scale of pay and allowances,
the right to claim the same could arise de hors the general principle of
parity. It required the competent court to examine the language and object of
the relevant provisions and, in particular, to determine whether the scale
contemplated was that of the Central Secretariat Service or some other
category of Central Government employees. Liberty was granted to work
out the rights, if any, flowing from the Bye-laws, and the issue was directed
to be considered afresh, uninfluenced by the observations in the judgment
under challenge before it.
17.
Even before the Supreme Court passed the order dated 30 th April,
2004, the Department of Culture had, by communication dated 26 th March,
2004, directed the Akademi to restore the scale of INR 1,400-2,600 with
effect from 1st January, 1986, substitute the corresponding scale of INR
5,000-8,000 with effect from 1st January, 1996 and recover the alleged
excess payment. The communication proceeded on the effect attributed to
the dismissal of the review petition. The Akademi issued the consequential
Office Order dated 30th April, 2004.
18.
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 was thereafter instituted pursuant to the liberty
granted by the Supreme Court. The Petitioners challenge the communication
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
dated 26th March, 2004 and the Office Order dated 30 th April, 2004, and
seek adjudication of the claim on the footing of the Akademi’s own
governing instruments.
Interim Proceedings in W.P.(C) 7987/2004
19.
On 18th May, 2004, this Court issued notice and stayed operation of
the communication dated 26th March, 2004 and the Office Order dated 30th
April, 2004. The order noticed at some length the provisions of the Service
Bye-laws under which Central Government rules had been adopted for
different incidents of service. On 17th January, 2008, after hearing the
Respondents, the Court confirmed the interim protection. It recorded a
prima facie view that the Bye-laws appeared to contemplate parity in service
conditions and placement in the pay structure, independent of ‘equal pay for
equal work’. The Court also took account of the prejudice which
retrospective recovery would occasion. Rule was issued and the petition was
directed to be listed as a regular matter.
20.
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 was dismissed in default on 21st December, 2017,
after repeated non-appearance on behalf of the Petitioners. By order dated
4th September, 2018, it was restored to its original number. That order also
expressly revived the interim protection which had existed before dismissal.
The 2017-2018 Action and the Later Petitions
21.
While W.P.(C) 7987/2004 and its interim protection were still
subsisting, the Autonomous Bodies Cell of the Ministry of Culture inspected
the Akademi. By communication dated 25th October, 2017, the Ministry
required the Akademi to identify and rectify pay fixations which it regarded
as erroneous before implementation of the 7th CPC recommendations.
22.
After W.P.(C) 7987/2004 was dismissed in default, the Akademi and
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
its constituent units issued orders during 2018 withdrawing grade pay of
INR 4,600 granted to Assistants and Stenographers, revising it to INR 4,200
with retrospective effect and proposing consequential refixation and
recovery. The Petitioners in W.P.(C) 8922/2018 specifically plead that the
action followed because the Respondents treated the earlier interim
protection as having come to an end upon dismissal of the 2004 petition.
23.
The impugned exercise was not confined to Assistants and
Stenographers. It also sought withdrawal of the Non-Functional Selection
Grade granted to Upper Division Clerks, the non-functional upgradation
carrying grade pay of INR 5,400 granted to Section Officers and Private
Secretaries after four years in grade pay of INR 4,800 and, in some
instances, benefits under the ACP and MACP schemes.
24.
W.P.(C) 8922/2018 has been instituted by twenty-seven employees of
the Akademi and its constituent units. Their principal challenge is to the
retrospective withdrawal of grade pay of INR 4,600, its substitution by INR
4,200 and the consequential recovery.
25.
W.P.(C) 7195/2021 has been instituted by Vinodi Kumari. Her
promotion as Assistant was ultimately antedated to 8 th November, 1996,
following intervention by the National Commission for Scheduled Castes.
Her pay was fixed with grade pay of INR 4,600 with effect from 1st January,
2006. She was promoted as Section Officer on an ad hoc basis with effect
from 22nd July, 2008 with grade pay of INR 4,800 and was subsequently
granted the non-functional grade pay of INR 5,400 after completion of four
years in that grade. Orders dated 26th April, 2018 and 17th May, 2018
withdrew the benefits. She also seeks regularisation of her promotion as
Deputy Secretary from 1st February, 2018.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
Petitioners’ Contentions
26.
Mr. L.K. Singh, counsel appearing for the Petitioners, advances the
following submissions:
26.1. The present claim does not seek to reopen the finding on equal pay for
equal work. The right asserted arises from the Rules, Regulations and
Service Bye-laws of the Akademi, which are binding conditions of service
and were approved by the Government of India.
26.2. Bye-law 20 is relied upon as part of a larger scheme under which the
Akademi consciously adopted Central Government norms for pay fixation,
increments, allowances, pension, leave, conduct and disciplinary matters.
The expression “corresponding categories” is said to refer, in the case of
Assistants and Stenographers, to the Central Secretariat Service and the
Central Secretariat Stenographers Service.
26.3. The Akademi itself repeatedly identified those categories as the
appropriate comparators. Its Finance Committee and Executive Board
supported the higher scale in 1994 and thereafter the communications of
1996 reiterated that position. The Executive Board, which is empowered to
prescribe conditions of service, then extended the higher scale on 10 th
December, 1998, not merely to the successful litigants but to all serving
Assistants and Stenographers of the Akademi and its constituent units.
26.4. The plea of res judicata is untenable because the Supreme Court
expressly found the claim founded on the Rules and Bye-laws to be
unexamined and preserved it for fresh adjudication. The dismissal of
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 was for default and was subsequently recalled.
26.5. The 2018 action was taken on the assumption that dismissal in default
had removed the obstacle to withdrawal. It ignored the reasoned interim
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
orders and, after restoration, the express revival of those orders. The
employees had no role in fixing their pay and there was no fraud or
misrepresentation. Retrospective refixation and recovery after decades are
therefore assailed as arbitrary and inequitable.
26.6. In Vinodi Kumari’s case, grade pay of INR 4,800 attached to the post
of Section Officer and the later non-functional grade pay of INR 5,400 are
an independent source. The petition specifically relies upon decisions taken
in February and March 2009 before those benefits were implemented. Her
claim for regularisation as Deputy Secretary is pressed separately.
Respondents’ Contentions
27.
Mr. Bhagwan Swarup Shukla, CGSC for Union of India, opposes the
petitions and, on behalf of the Respondents, contends as follows:
27.1. The Akademi is an autonomous society. Its employees are not Central
Government servants. Government funding, administrative control or
adoption of some Central Government service rules cannot by itself confer a
right to every benefit available to members of the Central Civil Services.
27.2. Bye-law 20 concerns the manner of fixation of pay within a scale
already prescribed for an Akademi post. It does not itself select or alter the
scale of pay. The scale of INR 1,640-2,900 was a Secretariat-specific
upgradation and the Office Memorandum dated 11 th December, 1990
expressly stated that the instructions dated 31 st July, 1990 were not
applicable to autonomous bodies.
27.3. The recommendations of the Finance Committee and Executive Board
did not receive the approval required for recurring financial liability. The
decision dated 10th December, 1998 was taken only to implement the Single
Bench judgment and lost its foundation when that judgment was reversed.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
27.4. The petitions are also said to be barred by res judicata and
constructive res judicata because the earlier claim to parity was rejected by
the Division Bench and not interfered with by the Supreme Court.
27.5. For the benefits arising under the 6th CPC, reliance is placed upon the
Office Memorandum dated 7th October, 2008. While Part ‘A’ of the revised
pay structure could be adopted by eligible autonomous organisations, the
upgraded structures in Part ‘B’ did not apply automatically and required a
case-specific examination by the administrative Ministry through its
Integrated Finance Division.
27.6. Reliance is placed upon State of Maharashtra & Anr. v. Bhagwan &
Ors.1 and UOI v. Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers Assn. & Anr.2, and
the other decisions cited in the written submissions, to emphasise judicial
restraint in matters of equation of posts and fixation of pay, particularly in
cases of autonomous bodies.
27.7. Once the higher fixation was found to be unauthorised, refixation and
recovery followed as a matter of course. Reliance is also placed on certain
refund conditions contained in some of the individual fixation orders.
Issues for Determination
28.
The following questions arise for determination:
(a)
Whether the claim founded upon the Rules, Regulations and Service
Bye-laws is barred by res judicata or constructive res judicata;
(b)
what consequence follows from Chapter V of the Service Bye-laws,
particularly Bye-laws 19 and 20, read with the wider service framework and
the expression “corresponding categories”;
(2022) 4 SCC 193.
(2023) 19 SCC 482.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
(c)
What is the effect of the decisions of the Finance Committee and
Executive Board, including the decision dated 10 th December, 1998, and
whether any further Government approval was required;
(d)
Whether the 2018 withdrawal of the 6th CPC grade pays and other
consequential benefits can be sustained;
(e)
Whether retrospective refixation and recovery are permissible in the
circumstances of these cases; and
(f)
What relief, if any, is due to Vinodi Kumari in relation to the post of
Deputy Secretary.
Analysis
Res Judicata
29.
The objection based on res judicata cannot be accepted. The earlier
adjudication attained finality only in respect of the claim founded upon
‘equal pay for equal work’. The Supreme Court accepted the rejection of
that claim. At the same time, it expressly recorded that the claim founded
upon the Rules, Regulations and Service Bye-laws had not been
“independently and objectively considered”. It left that claim open,
identified the questions which would arise in adjudicating it, and required
fresh consideration uninfluenced by the judgment under challenge before it.
30.
The consequence is clear. A matter which the Supreme Court
expressly found to be unexamined, and preserved for independent
adjudication, cannot be treated as one already heard and finally decided.
Constructive res judicata is equally untenable; it cannot be invoked to
foreclose the very inquiry which the Supreme Court directed this Court to
undertake.
31.
The dismissal of W.P.(C) 7987/2004 on 21st December, 2017 does not
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
change this position. It was a dismissal for non-prosecution, not an
adjudication on merits. Once that dismissal was recalled and the interim
order expressly revived, the petition stood restored to the same footing as
before. The preliminary objection is, therefore, rejected. At the same time,
the Court must keep within the limits of the Supreme Court’s order: the
claim based merely on ‘equal pay for equal work’ cannot be reopened; the
present inquiry is confined to rights, if any, flowing from the Akademi’s
own governing instruments.
Scope of Judicial Review in Pay Matters
32.
The governing principle is settled. The equation of posts and
formulation of pay structures ordinarily fall within the domain of the
executive and expert bodies. That exercise involves assessment of several
factors,
including
qualifications,
method
of
recruitment,
duties,
responsibilities, promotional avenues, internal relativities and financial
implications. A writ court does not undertake a fresh job evaluation, nor
does it presume parity merely because two posts bear the same designation.
33.
Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers Assn. reiterates these
principles and cautions courts against substituting their own assessment for
that of the competent authority. Bhagwan likewise holds that employees of
an autonomous institution cannot claim, as a matter of right, every service
benefit available to Government employees merely because the institution is
funded or controlled by Government or has adopted certain Government
service rules.
34.
Those decisions, however, do not conclude the present controversy.
Bhagwan was a case where the service rules of the autonomous institution
did not confer the pensionary benefit claimed, and the State had consciously
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
declined to extend it. Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers Assn.
concerned a claim for equation of posts and pay scales despite differences in
the governing recruitment framework, responsibilities and promotional
avenues. The present case stands on a different footing: the Court is required
to construe the Akademi’s own Government-approved Service Bye-laws, the
Akademi’s institutional decisions, and the limited inquiry expressly kept
open by the Supreme Court.
35.
The distinction is important. The Court is not comparing duties afresh,
nor is it reviving ‘equal pay for equal work’ under another label. It is only
determining what service conditions the Akademi adopted for its employees,
which Central Government category its own record identifies as
corresponding to the posts in question, and whether the Respondents could
undo that position without examining the governing instruments and
material institutional decisions.
The Governing Scheme
36.
The relevant provisions in Chapter V of the Service Bye-laws read as
follows:
“19. Scale of Pay
The scales of pay for posts under the Akademi shall be as specified in
Schedule ‘A’ as amended from time to time.
20. Initial pay and increments
In the matter of fixation of pay on initial appointment or promotion or
appointment to another post and regulation of increments, the
employees shall be governed by the same rules as are applicable to
central government employees of corresponding categories.
21. Special Pay and Personal Pay etc.
In the matter of granting any special pay, personal pay, honorarium,
fee to any employee rules as are applicable to central government
employees of corresponding categories shall be the guiding factors.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
22. Drawal of Pay
a.
An employee shall be entitled to the pay of the post to which
he/she is appointed from the date on which he/she assumed charge of
the post in accordance with the provision under Rule 36 of the Byelaws.
….
23. Drawal of Allowances
Employees shall be entitled to draw all allowances at such rates and
subject to such conditions as may be prescribed by the Government
for its employees from time to time.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
37.
Bye-law 57 completes the scheme. Where a condition of service is not
provided for in the Bye-laws, the matter is to be dealt with in accordance
with Government rules and orders. Its proviso enables a concession allowed
by Government to be allowed to Akademi employees, subject to the same
rules and conditions governing such grant of concession. The Bye-laws
elsewhere adopt, apply or use as guiding factors the Central Civil Services
rules governing leave, pension, conduct, disciplinary proceedings,
suspension and several other incidents of service. The definitions of “pay”,
“special pay”, “personal pay”, “permanent post” and “temporary post” are
also drawn from the Fundamental Rules.
38.
Bye-law 19 makes Schedule ‘A’ the repository of the scales of pay for
Akademi posts. Therefore, Bye-law 20 cannot be read as automatically
substituting every later Central Government scale into Schedule ‘A’. When
the Service Bye-laws came into force in 1995, Schedule ‘A’ recorded INR
1,400-2,600 for Assistants and Stenographers. That entry is part of the
approved instrument and must be given effect unless it is amended in the
manner contemplated by the governing framework.
39.
The Respondents’ construction, however, stops at the existing entry in
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
Schedule ‘A’ and overlooks the words “as amended from time to time” in
Bye-law 19. Schedule ‘A’ is therefore the formal repository of pay scales,
but it is not immutable. The Executive Board’s authority over service
conditions is material in this context. Rule 15(xiii) provides:
“15. The Executive Board shall have the following powers and
functions, namely:
…
xiii. to prescribe the terms and conditions of service in respect of all
posts under the control of the Akademi”
Rule 15(xiii), thus, places the prescription of terms and conditions of service
within the Executive Board’s authority. That authority is not collateral or
merely advisory; it forms part of the rule-based mechanism through which
service conditions are considered, adopted and, where necessary, placed for
formal approval under the governing instruments. Chapter V reinforces the
same approach.
40.
Thus, the correct reading is neither that the Akademi surrendered all
autonomy over its pay structure, nor that the reference to Central
Government employees is irrelevant to the scale attached to a post. The scale
begins with Schedule ‘A’; the manner in which pay is fixed and increments
are regulated is governed by the corresponding Central Government rules;
and revision of the scale, when considered, must be examined within the
institutional arrangement which the Rules and Bye-laws themselves create.
Which is the “Corresponding Category”?
41.
The expression “corresponding categories” in Bye-law 20 is not
superficial. The Supreme Court specifically required the Court to decide
whether the governing framework contemplated the Central Secretariat scale
or some other Central Government scale. That question must be answered
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
from the record of the Akademi.
42.
The record contains unusually clear evidence on this point. In 1988,
while considering upgradation of the post of Superintendent in the Akademi
to Section Officer, the Integrated Finance Division of the Government
examined the staffing pattern. Its note records that Assistants and
Stenographers of the Akademi in the pre-revised scale of INR 425-800 were
comparable to Assistants and Stenographers in the Central Government. It
also noticed the graduate qualification for Assistants, the possibility of
deputation from equivalent Government posts and the promotional
movement from Assistants and Stenographers to Superintendent.
43.
The same note went further. It considered Section Officer in the scale
of INR 2,000-3,500 to be the appropriate next higher post and observed that
the “balance may not be disturbed” because the lower posts as well as the
higher posts around that level followed the same pattern as in the Central
Government. Government approval was thereafter conveyed on 17 th
November, 1988 for upgradation and redesignation of Superintendent as
Section Officer in the scale of INR 2,000-3,500.
44.
This assumes significance for a reason independent of equal pay. The
1988 exercise was not a general plea for parity; it was the Government’s
own appraisal of the Akademi’s cadre structure while considering an actual
service decision. In that appraisal, Assistants and Stenographers of the
Akademi were treated as corresponding to their Central Government
counterparts. The identity of the pre-revised scale of INR 425-800, the
application of the 4th CPC replacement scale of INR 1,400-2,600, and the
Government-approved upgradation of the promotional post of Section
Officer to the Central Government level all point in the same direction.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
45.
The institutional position remained the same when the dispute over
INR 1,640-2,900 arose. The Finance Committee recommended the higher
scale on 2nd December, 1994. The Executive Board fully supported it on 7th
December, 1994. After the Service Bye-laws were approved, the issue
remained under consideration. The detailed communications of 19 th April,
1996 and 15th July, 1996 again placed the Akademi’s own assessment before
the Government: recruitment was through open competition and a duly
constituted Selection Committee, the posts formed the same feeder level in
the cadre, and the Akademi considered its Assistants and Stenographers to
correspond to their Secretariat counterparts.
46.
These materials are not being relied upon to revive the claim rejected
under Article 39(d). Their relevance is narrower, but decisive: they answer
the interpretive question left open by the Supreme Court. When the
Akademi
used
the
expression
“corresponding
categories”
in
its
Government-approved Service Bye-laws, its own contemporaneous service
record identified, for these posts, Assistants in the Central Secretariat
Service and Grade ‘C’ Stenographers in the Central Secretariat
Stenographers Service as the corresponding Central Government categories.
That record is sufficient to identify the relevant comparator for purposes of
Bye-law 20, without converting the inquiry into one of pay parity.
47.
The 1995 entry of INR 1,400-2,600 in Schedule ‘A’ does not defeat
that conclusion. It records the scale then formally entered in the approved
Bye-laws; it does not amount to a final rejection of the higher scale which
the Akademi had already supported and continued to pursue. Since Schedule
‘A’ was expressly amendable “from time to time”, the next question is
whether the later institutional decisions could be given effect, and what
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
further approval, if any, was required.
Was Further Government Approval Required?
48.
The Respondents’ approval argument requires some separation. Rule
15(vii) does not create a general requirement of prior Government approval
for every revision of pay scale. Its proviso is directed to the creation and
filling of posts whose maximum pay exceeds the prescribed limit. Rule
15(xiii), separately, empowers the Executive Board to prescribe the terms
and conditions of service for posts under the Akademi’s control. These
provisions cannot be collapsed into a broad proposition that the Executive
Board is powerless to take a service decision merely because that decision
has financial consequences.
49.
There is, however, another provision which cannot be ignored. Clause
3(xxvi) of the MoA requires Central Government approval for an addition to
or amendment of the Rules, Regulations and Bye-laws. Since Bye-law 19
makes Schedule ‘A’ the repository of the scales of pay, a formal alteration
of the scale entered in that Schedule would ordinarily require the approval
contemplated by the MoA. The Board’s decision was therefore not irrelevant
or void. At the highest, a further institutional step remained to be completed.
50.
The Petitioners are seeking a scale which their employer had
approved and which the Finance Committee had affirmed and the Executive
Board had supported before the first writ was decided. The Akademi twice
placed reasoned recommendations before the Government. The Executive
Board ultimately extended the scale to the entire serving cadre. What
remained in dispute was the Government’s concurrence with that
institutional decision.
51.
The Government was entitled to examine that question. It was
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
required, however, to examine the right question. The communication dated
26th March, 2004 did not do so. It reasoned that because the Single Bench
judgment had been set aside and the review dismissed, the employees were
not entitled to the higher scale and recovery should follow. That
communication preceded the Supreme Court order dated 30 th April, 2004. It
could not, and did not, undertake the independent examination of the Rules
and Service Bye-laws which the Supreme Court thereafter directed.
52.
The 2017 and 2018 exercise does not cure the defect. The
Autonomous Bodies Cell proceeded on the broad premise that orders
applicable to CSS, CSSS and allied Central Government cadres had been
erroneously made applicable to an autonomous body. The consequential
orders repeat that conclusion and direct withdrawal. There is no examination
of Bye-laws 19 and 20, no consideration of the Government’s own 1988
appraisal of the cadre, no analysis of the 1994 and 1996 institutional
decisions and no consideration of the legal significance of the Executive
Board resolution dated 10th December, 1998.
53.
The Government has, thus, repeatedly answered the generic question
whether the Office Memorandum dated 31st July, 1990 applied proprio
vigore to autonomous bodies. The Supreme Court required a different
question to be answered in this case: what right, if any, follows from the
governing instruments and service history of the Akademi. That exercise has
still not been performed in the administrative orders under challenge.
The Authorities Relied upon by the Respondents
54.
The decisions cited by the Respondents do not require a different
conclusion. They recognise that employees of an autonomous institution
cannot claim parity with Government employees merely because the
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
institution is funded by the Government, has Government representatives in
its governing body or has adopted Government Service Rules. Nor can the
Court ordinarily undertake the exercise of equating posts or determining pay
scales, which is primarily within the domain of the executive and expert
bodies. Those principles, however, do not conclude the distinct question
arising from the Akademi’s own Service Bye-laws and the decisions taken
under that framework.
55.
The caution in those decisions is accepted. It does not dispose of a
case in which the institution’s own Service Bye-laws use Central
Government categories as a reference point for pay fixation, the
Government’s own finance wing had identified the relevant cadre
correspondence, the governing body repeatedly approved the higher scale
and the dispute is about the legal effect and formal approval of those
decisions. Nor is judicial review in pay matters an absolute prohibition. UOI
v. D.G.O.F. Employees Association & Anr.3 illustrates that where the
applicable Pay Commission recommendations and the historical position
bear upon the pay structure governing the employees, the Court may
examine whether the administrative decision declining to extend the higher
pay scale represents a rational and correct application of the governing
framework, without itself undertaking the exercise of determining the
appropriate pay scale.
56.
The Court is therefore not fixing a pay scale by undertaking its own
assessment of the work performed. The inquiry is narrower: whether the
Respondents could withdraw a pay structure consciously adopted and
2023 INSC 995.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
implemented by the Akademi, without engaging with the Service Bye-laws,
the Government’s earlier cadre appraisal and the material institutional
decisions. On that limited ground, the impugned action cannot be sustained.
Moulding the Relief
57.
Ordinarily, where a recommendation requires approval of another
authority, the safer course is to set aside an infirm decision and remit the
matter for a fresh exercise. That is not an inflexible rule. Article 226 is
couched in wide terms and enables the Court to remove injustice and mould
the relief to meet the requirements of the case. Where a public authority has
failed to exercise, or has wrongly exercised, the discretion conferred upon it,
including by ignoring relevant considerations and materials, the Court can
issue directions to compel the exercise of that discretion in a proper and
lawful manner and, in a proper case, may itself pass the order or give the
direction which the authority should have passed or given had it properly
and lawfully exercised its discretion.4
58.
UOI & Anr. v. S.B. Vohra & Ors.5 also cautions that statutory duties
should ordinarily be allowed to be performed by the concerned authorities at
the first instance and that the Court should ordinarily refer the matter back
with suitable directions. The Supreme Court further held that only in
exceptional cases may the High Court interfere and that such jurisdiction
must be exercised with care and circumspection. The question, therefore, is
whether the circumstances of the present case warrant such intervention
rather than relegating the Petitioners once again to the statutory authority.
59.
A bare remand at this stage would do little justice. The foundational
See: Comptroller and Auditor General of India v. K.S. Jagannathan & Anr. (1986) 2 SCC 679.
(2004) 2 SCC 150.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
petition has remained pending since 2004. The employer’s Finance
Committee and Executive Board had taken their position even earlier. The
Government’s own Integrated Finance Division had, in 1988, identified the
corresponding cadre and approved the next promotional level on that basis.
The scale of INR 1,640-2,900 was actually implemented, successive
revisions followed, and the employees arranged the remainder of their
service careers around that pay structure. For most of this period, the
position was protected by orders of this Court.
60.
In these exceptional circumstances, remitting the parties to another
round of administrative consideration would serve no useful purpose. It
would only prolong a controversy which the existing record is sufficient to
resolve. The communication dated 26th March, 2004 and the consequential
Office Order dated 30th April, 2004 are set aside. The decision of the
Executive Board dated 10th December, 1998, read with the earlier decisions
of the Finance Committee and Executive Board, shall be treated as the
Akademi’s institutional adoption of the scale of INR 1,640-2,900 for the
serving Assistants and Stenographers covered by that decision. Respondent
No. 1 shall, within eight weeks from today, complete the formal approval or
regularisation required under Clause 3(xxvi) of the MoA and make, or cause
to be made, the corresponding entry in Schedule ‘A’ or the relevant service
records, as may be administratively necessary.
61.
This direction is confined to the cadre and period which form the
subject matter of these petitions. It does not hold that every future revision
notified for the Central Secretariat will automatically apply to the Akademi.
The Government and the Akademi shall not reopen the pay already extended
to the Petitioners and the employees covered by the impugned orders on the
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
grounds rejected in this judgment.
The 6th CPC Benefits and the 2018 Orders
62. The later petitions require one further distinction. The Office
Memorandum dated 7th October, 2008 permitted eligible autonomous
organisations to adopt the revised pay structure in Part ‘A’ of the First
Schedule to the CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008. It made clear that upgraded
structures in Part B did not apply automatically. Such upgradations required
a category-specific examination by the administrative Ministry, having
regard to functional justification, financial capacity and identity of the prerevised scale, followed by the prescribed financial concurrence.
63.
The Office Memorandum therefore assists neither side in the absolute
form in which the matter has been argued. It negatives automatic
transposition of every Part ‘B’ benefit. At the same time, it contemplates
extension of such benefits to an autonomous body after a case-specific
examination. The 2018 orders do not reveal that exercise. They proceed
from the generic premise that CSS or CSSS orders had been wrongly
applied because the Akademi is autonomous.
64.
The grade pay of INR 4,600 granted to Assistants and Stenographers
cannot be viewed in isolation from the pay history which has now been
examined. The employees were already drawing the higher pre-revised scale
under the Executive Board decision and under judicial protection. The
subsequent grade pay was granted through formal orders of the Akademi. Its
withdrawal in 2018 rested upon the same premise on which the foundational
scale was sought to be withdrawn. Once that premise fails, the consequential
withdrawal of grade pay of INR 4,600 cannot survive against the Petitioners.
65.
The case of Section Officers requires separate attention. In Vinodi
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
Kumari’s case, the Respondents, in their Counter Affidavit, themselves
acknowledge that she was granted grade pay of INR 4,800 on promotion as
Section Officer and thereafter grade pay of INR 5,400 on completion of four
years, pursuant to an order of the Ministry of Finance. Their answer is that
the latter benefit was not applicable to autonomous bodies and was therefore
withdrawn on the observations of the Ministry of Culture. The petition, on
the other hand, specifically refers to deliberations and decisions in February
and March 2009 preceding implementation of the benefits. The Counter
Affidavit does not deal with those specific decisions; it answers the issue
only by invoking autonomous status and the 2017 inspection report.
66.
That is insufficient to sustain a retrospective withdrawal. The ordinary
grade pay attached to a promotional post cannot be treated as an error
merely because an earlier feeder-cadre benefit is disputed. A non-functional
upgradation which was sanctioned, and acted upon for years, also could not
be withdrawn without examining the decision by which the Akademi
adopted it and the case-specific process contemplated by the Office
Memorandum dated 7th October, 2008. The 2018 orders contain no such
analysis. They are therefore unsustainable qua the Petitioners in these
proceedings. This conclusion does not declare a general entitlement of all
employees of every autonomous body to the same Part ‘B’ benefits. It
addresses the validity of the orders by which benefits already granted to
these employees were withdrawn.
67.
The same applies to ACP and MACP consequences which were
disturbed merely as a derivative of the impugned pay reduction. If any
arithmetical or employee-specific correction is independently necessary
under the governing ACP or MACP scheme, it may be made after notice and
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
for reasons unrelated to the propositions rejected in this judgment. The
blanket 2018 exercise cannot furnish the source for such correction.
Recovery and the Effect of Prolonged Pendency
68.
There is, in any event, no basis for recovery. The employees did not
secure the higher fixation by fraud, concealment or misrepresentation. The
scale was granted through formal institutional decisions. Pay was fixed by
the employer. The proposed withdrawal and recovery were stayed on 18th
May, 2004, and the protection was confirmed on 17 th January, 2008 after the
Court recorded a prima facie case and specifically noticed the prejudice
which recovery would cause. Except for the interval caused by dismissal in
default, the protection continued and was expressly revived upon restoration.
69.
The legal basis of the fixation remained under consideration before
this Court and was protected by judicial orders for more than two decades.
By this judgment, the Court has recognised the foundation on which that
fixation rested and has set aside the impugned withdrawal.
70.
Accordingly, no amount already paid shall be recovered. Any amount
recovered pursuant to the impugned orders shall be refunded. The pay and
service benefits of the Petitioners and the employees covered by the
impugned orders shall be restored to the position which obtained
immediately before the 2018 withdrawal, together with consequential
fixation under subsequent pay revisions. In the case of employees who have
retired, pension, gratuity and other retiral benefits shall be recomputed,
where necessary, on that basis and shall not thereafter be reopened on
account of the controversy decided in these petitions.
Vinodi Kumari’s Promotion as Deputy Secretary
71.
The remaining prayer of Vinodi Kumari concerns her promotion as
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
Deputy Secretary. The order dated 1st February, 2018 promoted her on an ad
hoc basis. An ad hoc appointment does not, by itself, confer a right to
regular promotion from the same date. The Respondents state in their
written submissions that the promotion was subsequently regularised after
vigilance clearance, but the order evidencing such regularisation has not
been placed before the Court.
72.
The appropriate course is, therefore, limited. If an order regularising
her promotion has already been passed, it shall be communicated to her and
given full effect, including such consequential benefits as follow from its
terms. If no such order exists, her case shall be placed before the competent
Departmental Promotion Committee or other prescribed authority for
consideration under the applicable Recruitment Rules from the date on
which the vacancy was available and she became eligible. The decision shall
be taken within twelve weeks from today.
Conclusion and Relief
73.
The petitions are accordingly allowed in the following terms:
(a)
The objection based on res judicata and constructive res judicata is
rejected. The claim arising from the Rules, Regulations and Service Byelaws remained open by virtue of the Supreme Court order dated 30 th April,
2004.
(b)
The communication dated 26th March, 2004 and the consequential
Office Order dated 30th April, 2004 are quashed.
(c)
The Executive Board decision dated 10th December, 1998, read with
the earlier decisions of the Finance Committee and Executive Board, shall
have effect in terms of paragraphs 60 and 61 above. The formal approval
and consequential amendment or entry in Schedule ‘A’ or the relevant
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
service records shall be completed within the period stipulated therein.
(d)
The communication dated 25th October, 2017 and the consequential
orders issued during 2018 are quashed insofar as they withdraw or reduce,
the grade pay of INR 4,600, the sanctioned grade pay attached to the post of
Section Officer, the non-functional grade pay of INR 5,400 and derivative
ACP or MACP benefits solely on the ground that the relevant Central
Government orders were inapplicable to an autonomous body.
(e)
The pay and service benefits covered by the impugned orders shall be
restored to the position obtaining immediately before the impugned
withdrawal, with consequential fixation under subsequent pay revisions. No
recovery shall be made of amounts already paid. Any amount already
recovered pursuant to the impugned orders shall be refunded within eight
weeks from today. Pension, gratuity and other retiral benefits shall be
recomputed, wherever necessary, on that basis.
(f)
Any independent employee-specific correction under the ACP or
MACP scheme, for reasons unconnected with the basis rejected in this
judgment, may be undertaken only after notice to the concerned employee
and by a reasoned order. No such exercise shall result in recovery of
amounts protected under clause (e).
(g)
In the case of Vinodi Kumari, if her promotion as Deputy Secretary
has already been regularised, the order shall be communicated and
implemented within four weeks from today. If no such order exists, her case
shall be considered by the competent Departmental Promotion Committee or
other prescribed authority within twelve weeks from today in terms of
paragraph 72 above, with consequential benefits if she is found entitled.
74.
The petitions, along with any pending application(s), are disposed of
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
in the above terms.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
AUGUST 4, 2026/nk
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
20:01:46
W.P.(C) 7987/2004 & connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review