The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. In view of our conclusion that the blacklisting order dated 09.01.2019 passed by the Corporation is contrary to the principles of natural justice, it is unnecessary for us to consider the other contentions of the learned counsel for the appellant. Having regard to the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present C/SCA/5497/2026 ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026 case, we deem it appropriate not to remit the matter to the Corporation for fresh consideration.”
6. Considering the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, as referred above, in the facts of the present case, the action undertaken by the respondent No.5 – of blacklisting the vehicle of the petitioner being Hyundai Verna car No. GJ-12-EE-2992 on ‘Vahan Portal’ is quashed and set aside. However, liberty is reserved for the respondent authority to initiate appropriate proceedings after issuance of show cause notice and after following due process of law.
9. With petition the aforesaid stands allowed observations, to the the present aforesaid extent. Direct service is permitted. (NIRZAR S. DESAI,J) Pallavi Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/5497/2026
ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO.
5497 of 2026
=====================================================
RAJUBHAI KARSHANBHAI KOLI
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS.
=====================================================
Appearance:
MR JAY N SHAH(10668) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
MR HARSH N SHAH ASSISTANT GOVERNMENT PLEADER for the
Respondent(s) No. 1,2,3,4,5
=====================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIRZAR S. DESAI
Date : 17/07/2026
ORDER
1.
By way of the present petition, the petitioner
herein has prayed for the following reliefs:
“(a) This Hon’ble Court may be pleased to admit
and allow this petition;
(b) This Hon’ble Court may be pleased to issue
appropriate writ, order or direction, directing
the respondents to produce the records before
this Hon’ble Court leading them to take action
of blacklisting the vehicle on Vahan Portal
bearing Hyundai Verna car No. GJ-12-EE-2992;
(c) This Hon’ble Court may be pleased to issue
appropriate writ, order or direction to quash
and set aside the action of the respondent No.5
– RTO of showing the status of vehicle bearing
Hyundai
Verna
car
No.
GJ-12-EE-2992
as
blacklisted from ‘Vahan Portal’, which is at
C/SCA/5497/2026
ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026
Annexure- A;
(d) Pending
admission
final
hearing
and
disposal of this petition, direct the respondent
Nos.2 to 5 to remove the endorsement on Vahan
Portal as being blacklisted of vehicle bearing
Hyundai Verna car No. GJ-12-EE-2992 which is at
Annexure – A;
(e) Grant such other and further relief
thought fit in the interest of justice.”
2.
Heard
appearing
Mr.
for
Jay
the
N.
Shah,
petitioner
learned
and
Mr.
as
advocate
Harsh
Shah,
learned Assistant Government Pleader appearing for
the respondents.
3.
The petitioner herein is aggrieved by the action
undertaken by the respondent No.5 – RTO of showing
the status of vehicle being Hyundai Verna car No. GJ12-EE-2992 blacklisted on the ‘Vahan Portal’, which
is owned by the petitioner.
4.
Mr. Jay N. Shah, learned advocate appearing for
the petitioner, submitted that the petitioner is the
owner of the vehicle being Hyundai Verna car No. GJ12-EE-2992.
that
the
Mr.
Shah,
action
of
blacklisting
the
learned
the
advocate,
respondent
vehicle-in-question
submitted
authority
on
of
‘Vahan
C/SCA/5497/2026
ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026
Portal’ is without granting opportunity of hearing
and the same is against the cardinal principles of
natural justice.
4.
Mr.
Harsh
Shah,
learned
Assistant
Government
Pleader appearing for the respondent-State, was not
in a position to controvert the aforesaid submissions
advanced by Mr. Shah, learned advocate appearing for
the petitioner.
5.
At this stage it is apposite to refer to the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. v/s. Deputy Commissioner of
Central Excise reported in (2015) 8 SCC 519, relevant
para-27 of the order reads thus:
“27. From the aforesaid discussion, it becomes
clear that the opportunity to provide hearing
before making any decision was considered to be
a basic requirement in the Court proceeding.
Later on, this principle was applied to other
quasi-judicial authorities and other tribunals
and ultimately it is now clearly laid down that
even in the administrative actions, where the
decision of the authority may result in civil
consequences, a hearing before taking a decision
is necessary. It was, thus, observed in A.K.
Kraipak's case (supra) that if the purpose of
rules
of
natural
justice
is
to
prevent
miscarriage of justice, one fails to see how
C/SCA/5497/2026
ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026
these rules should not be
administrative inquiries.”
made
available
to
5.1 In the case of UMC Technologies Private Limited
v/s. Food Corporation of India and Anr. reported in
AIR 2021 SC (CIVIL) 833, relevant Paras-13, 14, 16,
17, 18, 19 and 26 reads thus:
“13. At the outset, it must be noted that it is
the first principle of civilised jurisprudence
that a person against whom any action is sought
to be taken or whose right or interests are being
affected should be given a reasonable opportunity
to defend himself. The basic principle of natural
justice is that before adjudication starts, the
authority concerned should give to the affected
party a notice of the case against him so that he
can defend himself. Such notice should be
adequate and the grounds necessitating action and
the penalty/action proposed should be mentioned
specifically
and
unambiguously.
An
order
travelling beyond the bounds of notice is
impermissible and without jurisdiction to that
extent. This Court in Nasir Ahmad v. Assistant
Custodian General, Evacuee Property, Lucknow and
Anr. , 1 has held that it is essential for the
notice to specify the particular grounds on the
basis of which an action is proposed to be taken
so as to enable the notice to answer the case
against
him. If these conditions
are not
satisfied, the person cannot be said to have been
granted any reasonable opportunity of being
heard.
14. Specifically, in the context of blacklisting
of a person or an entity by the state or a state
corporation,
the
requirement
of
a
valid,
particularized and unambiguous show cause notice
is particularly crucial due to the severe
C/SCA/5497/2026
ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026
consequences
of
blacklisting
and
the
stigmatization that accrues to the person/entity
being blacklisted. Here, it may be gainful to
describe the concept of blacklisting and the
graveness of the consequences occasioned by it.
Blacklisting has the effect of denying a person
or an entity the privileged opportunity of
entering
into
government
contracts.
This
privilege arises because it is the State who is
the counterparty in government contracts and as
such, every eligible person is to be afforded an
equal
opportunity
to
participate
in
such
contracts,
without
arbitrariness
and
discrimination. Not only does blacklisting takes
away this privilege, it also tarnishes the
blacklisted person’s reputation and brings the
person’s character into question. Blacklisting
also has long-lasting civil consequences for the
future business prospects of the blacklisted
person.
16. The severity of the effects of blacklisting
and the resultant need for strict observance of
the principles of natural justice before passing
an order of blacklisting were highlighted by this
Court in Erusian Equipment & Chemicals Ltd. v.
State of West Bengal in the following terms:
“12. ... The order of blacklisting has the
effect of depriving a person of equality of
opportunity
in
the
matter
of
public
contract. A person who is on the approved
list is unable to enter into advantageous
relations with the Government because of the
order of blacklisting. A person who has been
dealing with the Government in the matter of
sale and purchase of materials has a
legitimate interest or expectation. When the
State acts to the prejudice of a person it
has to be supported by legality.
XXX XXX
15. ... The blacklisting order involves
civil consequences. It casts a slur. It
C/SCA/5497/2026
ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026
creates a barrier between the persons
blacklisted and the Government in the matter
of
transactions.
The
black
lists
are
instruments of coercion.
XXX XXX
20.
Blacklisting
has
the
effect
of
preventing a person from the privilege and
advantage
of
entering
into
lawful
relationship
with
the
Government
for
purposes
of
gains.
The
fact
that
a
disability is created by the order of
blacklisting indicates that the relevant
authority
is
to
have
an
objective
satisfaction. Fundamentals of fair play
require that the person concerned should be
given an opportunity to represent his case
before he is put on the blacklist.”
17. Similarly, this Court in Raghunath Thakur
v. State of Bihar,
struck down an order of
blacklisting for future contracts on the ground
of non-observance of the principles of natural
justice. The relevant extract of the judgment in
that case is as follows:
“4. ... [I]t is an implied principle of the
rule of law that any order having civil
consequences should be passed only after
following the principles of natural justice.
It has to be realised that blacklisting any
person in respect of business ventures has
civil consequence for the future business of
the person concerned in any event. Even if
the rules do not express so, it is an
elementary principle of natural justice that
parties affected by any order should have
right
of
being
heard
and
making
representations against the order.”
18. This Court in Gorkha Security Services v.
Government (NCT of Delhi) and Ors. has described
blacklisting as being equivalent to the civil
C/SCA/5497/2026
ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026
death of a person because blacklisting is
stigmatic in nature and debars a person from
participating
in
government
tenders
thereby
precluding him from the award of government
contracts. It has been held thus:
“16. It is a common case of the parties that
the blacklisting has to be preceded by a
show-cause notice. Law in this regard is
firmly grounded and does not even demand
much
amplification.
The
necessity
of
compliance with the principles of natural
justice by giving the opportunity to the
person against whom action of blacklisting
is sought to be taken has a valid and solid
rationale behind it. With blacklisting, many
civil and/or evil consequences follow. It is
described as “civil death” of a person who
is foisted with the order of blacklisting.
Such an order is stigmatic in nature and
debars such a person from participating in
government tenders which means precluding
him from the award of government contracts.”
19. In light of the above decisions, it is clear
that a prior show cause notice granting a
reasonable opportunity of being heard is an
essential element of all administrative decisionmaking
and
particularly
so
in
decisions
pertaining to blacklisting which entail grave
consequences for the entity being blacklisted. In
these cases, furnishing of a valid show cause
notice is critical and a failure to do so would
be fatal to any order of blacklisting pursuant
thereto.
26.
In
view
of
our
conclusion
that
the
blacklisting order dated 09.01.2019 passed by the
Corporation is contrary to the principles of
natural justice, it is unnecessary for us to
consider the other contentions of the learned
counsel for the appellant. Having regard to the
peculiar facts and circumstances of the present
C/SCA/5497/2026
ORDER DATED: 17/07/2026
case, we deem it appropriate not to remit the
matter
to
the
Corporation
for
fresh
consideration.”
6.
Considering the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court, as referred above, in the facts of the
present case, the action undertaken by the respondent
No.5
–
RTO
of
blacklisting
the
vehicle
of
the
petitioner being Hyundai Verna car No. GJ-12-EE-2992
on ‘Vahan Portal’ is quashed and set aside. However,
liberty is reserved for the respondent authority to
initiate appropriate proceedings after issuance of
show cause notice and after following due process of
law.
9.
With
petition
the
aforesaid
stands
allowed
observations,
to
the
the
present
aforesaid
extent.
Direct service is permitted.
(NIRZAR S. DESAI,J)
Pallavi
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review