Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 12.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 20.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 20.02.2026
+
W.P.(C) 8707/2009
RAJNI
Through:
...Petitioner
Mr. Sachin Chauhan, Adv.
versus
GOVT. OF NCT & ORS.
Through:
...Respondents
Mr. Vikrant Nilesh Goyal,
Mr.Yash Basoya, Mr. Rakshit
Tyagi and Mr. Kunal Dixit,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
By way of the present petition filed under Article 226/227 of
the Constitution of India, 1950 [hereinafter referred to as ‘the
Constitution’] the Petitioner assails the correctness of order dated
29.01.2009 [hereinafter referred to as ‘IO-1’] passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi [hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Tribunal’], whereby the Original Application (OA)
filed by the Petitioner came to be dismissed.
2.
Along with assailing the order passed by the Tribunal, the
Petitioner also seeks to challenge the findings of the Enquiry Officer
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
[hereinafter referred to as ‘Impugned Findings/IF’], the Order dated
08.12.2006 passed by the Disciplinary Authority [hereinafter referred
to as ‘IO-2’] and the Order dated 01.05.2007 passed by the Appellate
Authority [hereinafter referred to as ‘IO-3’], all of which found the
Petitioner to be guilty of corruption.
3.
In order to comprehend the issue arising for the adjudication of
this Court, the relevant facts are required to be noticed.
BRIEF BACKGROUND OF THE CASE:
4.
On 11.09.2002, the Petitioner was appointed as a Woman
Constable in Delhi Police on compassionate grounds. While she was
posted as a Daily Diary (DD) Writer at Police Station, New Ashok
Nagar, Delhi, on 06.09.2005, a departmental case arose against her out
of an allegation that, during a sting operation conducted by the
Sansani programme of Star News Channel, one Mr. Neeraj Kumar,
acting as a decoy, came to the reporting room to lodge a NonCognizable Report (NCR) regarding loss of his mobile phone. The
Petitioner allegedly demanded Rs. 200/- and accepted Rs. 150 for
lodging the said NCR; such transaction was stated to have taken place
in the presence of HC Hari Kishan, who was the Duty Officer at the
relevant time and was supposed to sign the said NCR.
5.
The aforesaid incident was video graphed with a concealed
camera and, subsequently, was telecasted on 14.09.2005 in the
Sansani programme, a video-CD of this telecast later formed the
central piece of evident in the departmental proceedings.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
6.
Consequently, on 10.01.2006 a join departmental inquiry was
ordered against the Petitioner and Head Constable (HC) Hari Kishan
under the Delhi Police (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1980
[hereinafter referred to as ‘Rules of 1980’]. Following which the
Enquiry Officer (EO) appointed thereby, served upon the Petitioner a
summary of allegations and thereafter framed a specific charge against
the Petitioner for having demanded Rs. 200/- and accepted the illegal
gratification of Rs. 150 from Mr. Neeraj Kumar, for writing and
registering the NCR relating to the missing mobile phone.
7.
During the course of the aforesaid enquiry, the EO examined
two prosecution witnesses in order to prove the duty roster, DD entries
and the NCR, depicting that the Petitioner was on duty as DD writer
on 06.09.2005 and the NCR with respect to the missing phone was in
fact lodged. On the other hand, the Petitioner examined one defence
witness. Notably, during this enquiry, despite efforts being made by
the EO, neither Mr. Neeraj Kumar nor any representative of the Star
News Channel appeared to give evidence.
8.
Resultantly, the EO by way of the IF, found that although there
was no direct oral evidence from the decoy or media personnel yet the
video-CD of the telecast clearly depicted the Petitioner demanding
and accepting money from a person for registration of the
missing-mobile NCR. Placing a principal reliance on the said CD, the
EO concluded that the charge against the Petitioner stood proved.
9.
The aforesaid findings of the EO were duly served upon the
Petitioner, whereafter she submitted her written representation before
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
the Disciplinary Authority (DA). However, after considering the
record, inter alia the presentation made by the Petitioner, the DA by
way of IO-2, imposed the penalty of dismissal from service upon the
Petitioner for proven misconduct of demanding and accepting the
illegal gratification during the course of her official duty as a DD
writer.
10.
Whereafter, the Petitioner preferred a statutory appeal,
challenging the IO-2, however, the said appeal also came to be
dismissed by way of IO-3, affirming the punishment of dismissal and
affirming that the CD clearly showed the Petitioner demanding and
accepting money for lodging the NCR.
11.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner approached the Tribunal,
challenging the very initiation of the departmental enquiry, the IF, IO2 and IO-3, thereby seeking reinstatement with consequential benefits.
However, the Tribunal, by way of IO-1, dismissed the OA filed by the
Petitioner, upholding the enquiry and the punishment imposed. It is
in these circumstances that the Petitioner has invoked the writ
jurisdiction of this Court.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
12.
This Court has heard learned counsel appearing for the parties
and with their able assistance has perused the paper book.
13.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner, assailing the IF, IO-1, IO-2,
and IO-3, has made the following submissions13.1 It has been argued that the entire disciplinary actions
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
exclusively rest upon an edited video-CD allegedly telecasted on
14.09.2005 by a private television channel. In this regard, it has been
submitted that no independent complaint was ever lodged, no recovery
of alleged illegal gratification was effected, no independent witness
supported the allegations, and no contemporaneous material was
collected by the department. The sole basis of the charge and
consequent finding of guilt was the edited electronic recording
supplied by the channel, without any independent verification of its
authenticity or integrity.
13.2 It has been argued that once the authenticity of the video-CD
was specifically disputed by the Petitioner at the very inception of
inquiry, it was incumbent upon the department to prove the said
electronic record in accordance with law. However, in the present
case, the maker of the document, namely Mr. Neeraj Kumar, was
neither examined nor made available for cross examination. Reliance
in this regard has been placed upon Roop Singh v Punjab National
Bank1, wherein it was held that the findings based on unproved
documents are perverse and suspicion cannot take the place of proof.
13.3 It is also the Petitioner’s case that, reliance upon an edited
broadcast clip, without production of the original and unedited
footage, vitiates the proceedings. Relying on Raja Ram Pal v.
Speaker, Lok Sabha & Ors.2, it is argued that the Supreme Court
recognized evidentiary value only in original and unedited footage.
Hence, an edited telecast meant for public broadcast cannot constitute
(2009) 2 SCC 570
(2007) 3 SCC 184
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
conclusive proof of misconduct in disciplinary proceedings.
13.4 During the course of the arguments, a query was posed by this
Court, as to whether strict rules of evidence apply to departmental
enquiries. In response to which, learned counsel fairly submitted that
the provision of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 [hereinafter referred to as
‘Act of 1872’], are not strictly applicable. However, it was argued that
the principle of natural justice must be complied with. In addition, it
was submitted that where a particular document forms the sole
foundation of the finding of guilt, the department is under an
obligation to examine its maker so as to afford the delinquent officer
an effective opportunity of cross-examination.
13.5 Lastly, it has been further argued that, in disciplinary
proceedings, documents are ordinarily proved through departmental
witnesses whose names are furnished in advance, thereby enabling the
delinquent officer to exercise the valuable right of cross-examination.
The right of cross-examination, it is submitted, is an integral facet of
natural justice. In the absence of examination of the author or
custodian of the electronic record, the Petitioner was deprived of any
meaningful opportunity to challenge its authenticity, contents or
source.
14.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondent has made the
following submissions14.1 It has been contended that the video-CD in question does not
merely contain an edited narration but clearly depicts the Petitioner
accepting money while discharging official duties. It is contended that
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
there is no dispute raised by the Petitioner regarding the act of
acceptance of money as captured in the video recording. In such
circumstances, the visual evidence of receipt of money by a police
official, while on duty, by itself constitutes substantive and
compelling material indicative of corrupt conduct.
14.2 It is further argued that once the act of acceptance is visibly
recorded and forms part of the material on record, the defence sought
to be raised by the Petitioner, namely, that there was no proof of
demand or that her voice was not subjected to forensic examination,
does not dilute the evidentiary value of the recording.
14.3 According to the Respondents, the gravamen of the misconduct
lies in the receipt of illegal gratification, and the video footage
unequivocally establishes such receipt. It is contended that the absence
of a voice test or proof of demand, would not cast any reasonable
doubt on the authenticity or probative value of the video-CD,
particularly in the context of departmental proceedings where strict
rules of evidence are not applicable.
ANALYSIS:
15.
This Court has considered the submissions made by the parties,
however, before adverting to the rival submissions, it is pertinent to
highlight the well-settled scope of interference by this Court in
exercise of its writ jurisdiction in matters arising out of departmental
proceedings.
16.
The Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan & Ors. v Bhupendra
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
Singh3, relying upon State of Andhra Pradesh v S Sree Rama Rao4,
highlighted the restrictive scope of writ jurisdiction. It was held that
the High Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction, does not act as a
court of appeal over departmental enquiries, and its intervention is
only confined to four specific cases; firstly, if there is a lack of
jurisdiction or procedural illegality, secondly, if there is a violation of
natural justice or statutory rules, thirdly, if the conclusions reached
upon is based on ‘no evidence’ or material wholly extraneous to the
record and fourthly, if the findings are so perverse that no reasonable
person could have reached them.
17.
It is equally important to highlight that it is trite law that a
departmental or domestic enquiry is neither a criminal trial nor a
proceeding before a court of law, rather it is merely a fact-finding
exercise undertaken by a respective department in a quasi-judicial
capacity to determine the misconduct and maintain discipline in the
service. The Supreme Court in State of Haryana v Rattan Singh5, had
set out the principle governing the disciplinary proceedings, which is
as follows:
“4. It is well settled that in a domestic enquiry the strict and
sophisticated rules of evidence under the Indian Evidence Act may not
apply. All materials which are logically probative for a prudent mind
are permissible. There is no allergy to hearsay evidence provided it
has reasonable nexus and credibility. It is true that departmental
authorities and Administrative Tribunals must be careful in evaluating
such material and should not glibly swallow what is strictly speaking
not relevant under the Indian Evidence Act. For this proposition it is
not necessary to cite decisions nor text books, although we have been
taken through case-law and other authorities by counsel on both
sides. The essence of a judicial approach is objectivity, exclusion of
2024 INSC 592
AIR 1963 SC 1723
(1997) 2 SCC 491
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
extraneous materials or considerations and observance of rules of
natural justice. Of course, fair play is the basis and if perversity or
arbitrariness, bias or surrender of independence of judgment vitiate
the conclusions reached, such finding, even though of a domestic
tribunal, cannot be held good. However, the courts below misdirected
themselves, perhaps, in insisting that passengers who had come in and
gone out should be chased and brought before the tribunal before a
valid finding could be recorded. The „residuum‟ rule to which counsel
for the respondent referred, based upon certain passages from
American Jurisprudence does not go to that extent nor does the
passage from Halsbury insist on such rigid requirement. The simple
point is, was there some evidence or was there no evidence — not in
the sense of the technical rules governing regular court proceedings
but in a fair commonsense way as men of understanding and worldly
wisdom will accept. Viewed in this way, sufficiency of evidence in
proof of the finding by a domestic tribunal is beyond scrutiny. Absence
of any evidence in support of a finding is certainly available for the
court to look into because it amounts to an error of law apparent on
the record. We find, in this case, that the evidence of Chamanlal,
Inspector of the Flying Squad, is some evidence which has relevance
to the charge levelled against the respondent. Therefore, we are
unable to hold that the order is invalid on that ground.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
In substance, it was held that the domestic tribunals are not bound by
technical rules of evidence. The parameter to test the findings is
whether there is some evidence which a reasonable person would
accept, and not whether the Act of 1872 has been meticulously
followed. At this stage, it also becomes pertinent to state that, in a
departmental proceeding, the standard of proof is not that the
misconduct must be proved beyond all reasonable doubt, but the
standard of proof is as to whether the test of preponderance of
probability has been met.
18.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the present case, it may be
noted that the Petitioner’s arguments pertaining to the findings arrived
at essentially invites this Court to reassess the evidentiary value of the
video-CD and the departmental witnesses. However, we are afraid that
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
this Court lacks the power to do so or substitute its own conclusions
on credibility or apply criminal trial standards of proof.
19.
This Court is of the view that in the present case, the EO by
way of the IF, recorded a reasoned finding, whereas the DA and
Appellate Authority independently reviewed the material and the
video-CD in order to uphold the dismissal, whereafter the Tribunal
also affirmed the enquiry and punishment. This chain of concurrent
factual determinations, based on oral, documentary and electronic
material disclosed to the Petitioner, does not convince this Court that
it is a case of no evidence or there has been a violation of natural
justice. As far as the grievance that the CD is edited or that the decoy
and TV personnel were not produced is, concerned, we are of the view
that, such argument at best, is about sufficiency and appreciation of
evidence, which lies beyond the narrow compass of writ jurisdiction.
20.
Additionally, the enquiry against the Petitioner was held under
the Rules of 1980, wherein two prosecution witnesses were examined
to prove the duty roster of the Petitioner, DD entries and the NCR,
whereas one witness was examined on behalf of the Petitioner.
Moreover, the Petitioner was supplied with the video-CD, allowed to
cross-examine and to lead defence evidence, and to make a
representation against the findings. Thus, the enquiry was conducted
as a domestic, fact-finding process where the Act of 1872 does not
strictly govern admissibility.
21.
It has been argued by the Petitioner that, since the decoy and
TV channel personnel were not examined the video-CD is unproved
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
and the case is governed by Roop Singh (Supra). However, in Roop
Singh (Supra), no witness was examined to prove the documents or
alleged confession, the management witnesses merely tendered
documents and the report was based on no evidence at all. The ratio
in the aforesaid judgment is directed against the enquiries conducted
entirely on unproved papers without any oral evidence.
22.
On the contrary, in the present case, two departmental witnesses
were examined. PW-1 proved the roster and NCR linking the incident
to the Petitioner, while PW-2, having seen the telecast made a
contemporaneous report and deposed about the demand and
acceptance of money. Moreover, her defence witness only stated that
he personally did not see or hear any money being taken. In this
regard reference may be made to the judgment of Supreme Court in
Airports Authority of India v Pradip Kumar Banerjee, 2025 INSC
149, wherein it was observed that non-examination of complainant
was not per se fatal as long as some reliable material on record exists.
The relevant paragraphs are as follows:
“28. Further, we are unable to sustain the finding of the Division
Bench that the non-examination of the complainant is fatal to the case
of the appellant-Authority. It is well settled principle of law that even
in a criminal case pertaining to demand and acceptance of illegal
gratification, the courts are empowered to record conviction, where
the decoy turns hostile, and the prosecution case is based purely on
the evidence of the Trap Laying Officer and the trap witnesses. In this
regard, we are benefited by the judgment of this Court in
Bhanuprasad Hariprasad Dave v. State of Gujarat, 26 wherein it was
held thus:
“7. . . . It is now well settled by a series of decisions of this
Court that while in the case of evidence of an accomplice,
no conviction can be based on his evidence unless it is
corroborated in material particulars but as regards the
evidence of a partisan witness it is open to a court to
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
convict an accused person solely on the basis of that
evidence, if it is satisfied that that evidence is reliable. . .
.”
29. In the case at hand, the subject matter concerns a domestic
enquiry, where the strict rules of evidence prohibiting admissibility of
confessional statements recorded by the police officials do not apply.
Likewise, non-examination of the decoy cannot be treated to be fatal
in the domestic enquiry where other evidence indicts the delinquent
officer. As has been held by this Court in the case of Narender
Singh(supra), even a confession of the delinquent employee recorded
by the Trap Laying Officer during the criminal investigation can be
relied upon by the Disciplinary Authority.”
23.
Reference, at this stage, may also be made to Rattan Singh
(Supra), wherein it was observed that the disciplinary forums evidence
is not confined to evidence admissible under the Act of 1872, and
even hearsay evidence can be considered, if it has reasonable nexus
and credibility, subject always to the test of some probative value and
fairness. The emphasis is on whether the disciplinary authority’s
conclusions are based on some material which a reasonable person
would accept, not on strict compliance with technical evidentiary
rules.
24.
In the present case, the non-examination of the decoy and the
channel staff must be tested against two head: (i) the availability of the
other evidence, in particular, the official records, statements of PW-1
and PW-2 and the video-CD; and (ii) the conduct of the Petitioner.
25.
The Petitioner undisputedly, failed to initiate any civil or
criminal action alleging defamation, fabrication, or manipulation of
the telecast despite its broadcast to the public at large on 14.09.2005
and its use in the disciplinary proceedings. Her challenge in the
enquiry remained at the level of asserting that the video-CD was
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
unclear, prone to camera tricks, and her voice was not subjected to
forensic testing. However, she did not adduce any technical expert,
nor any contemporaneous complaint suggesting that the telecast was
fabricated. This omission, while not shifting the burden of proof, is a
relevant circumstance when assessing the plausibility of her denial
under the preponderance of probabilities standard, particularly in light
of concurrent findings of fact by the EO, DA, Appellate Authority and
the Tribunal that the video-CD is genuine and clearly depicts her
accepting money while on duty.
26.
The defence witness, a public person, stated that he neither
heard nor saw the Petitioner taking money; he did not contradict that
such a telecast had occurred or that the NCR and duty entries were in
the Petitioner’s handwriting. On this material, the insistence that the
decoy and channel staff must necessarily be examined, failing which
the enquiry fails, goes beyond the settled disciplinary jurisprudence.
27.
As far as reliance placed by the learned counsel for the
Petitioner on Raja Ram Pal (Supra) is concerned, the same is
distinguishable, to the extent that the said judgment falls in context of
parliamentary proceedings and constitutional review concerned in the
case.
28.
Significantly, the Petitioner has not denied that she is the person
appearing in the video nor has she disputed the act of acceptance of
money as depicted therein. Her defence is primarily that there was no
demand or that her voice was not forensically examined. In a
disciplinary context, where a police official is visually recorded
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
accepting money in the course of official duty, such material
constitutes relevant and cogent evidence from which an inference of
misconduct can reasonably be drawn on a preponderance of
probabilities. The absence of a voice test or independent recovery
does not obliterate the evidentiary value of the visual recording.
CONCLUSION:
29.
In view of the foregoing discussions, the concurrent findings
recorded by the Enquiry Officer, affirmed by the Disciplinary
Authority, the Appellate Authority and the Tribunal, cannot be said to
be perverse or arbitrary.
30.
This Court does not find any jurisdictional error, manifest
illegality, or patent infirmity in the impugned orders/findings.
31.
Accordingly, having found no merit, the present petition is
dismissed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
FEBRUARY 20, 2026
s.godara/hr
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
13:13:09
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review