The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. The learned Single Judge has followed the above Judgment and Order passed in Letters Patent Appeal No.1071 C/LPA/1208/2025 ORDER DATED: 17/11/2025 of 2017, which is squarely applicable to the facts of the case of the respondent – original petitioner and following the same, the petition was dismissed.
9. In view of the above, no interference is called for in the impugned Judgment and Order passed by the learned Single Judge, which is based on the Judgment and Order passed by the Division Bench of this Court in Letters Patent Appeal No.1071 of 2017 and we do not =nd any distinction in the facts of the case of the respondent – original petitioner with that of the petitioners of the Special Civil Application No.17487 of 2012.
10. The appeal, therefore, being devoid of any merit, is accordingly dismissed summarily, with no order as to costs. (BHARGAV D. KARIA, J) (L. S. PIRZADA, J) Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/LPA/1208/2025
ORDER DATED: 17/11/2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO. 1208 of 2025
In R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4572 of 2018
==========================================================
RAJKOT DISTRICT PANCHAYAT & ANR.
Versus
SAVJIBHAI MEGHJIBHAI KALIA & ANR.
==========================================================
Appearance:
KAASH K THAKKAR(7332) for the Appellant(s) No. 1,2
MS KRISHNA DESAI, AGP for the Respondent(s) No. 2
MR ASIT B JOSHI(2567) for the Respondent(s) No. 1
MR GAURAV K MEHTA(5227) for the Respondent(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE L. S. PIRZADA
Date : 17/11/2025
ORAL ORDER
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA)
1.
Heard learned advocate Mr.Kaash K. Thakkar for the
appellants
2.
By this appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent, the
appellant – Rajkot District Panchayat has challenged the
Judgment and Order dated 06.10.2025 passed by the learned
Single Judge in Special Civil Application No. 4572 of 2018.
3.
The brief facts of the case, as recorded by the learned
Single Judge and reiterated by the learned advocate for the
appellants, are as under:-
“The brief facts leading to ling of this petition
are such that the petitioner came to be appointed
as Live Stock Inspector with respondent
C/LPA/1208/2025
ORDER DATED: 17/11/2025
Panchayat on 22.5.1982; upon completion of 9
years of service the petitioner was granted First
Higher Pay Scale on 28.12.1992; thereafter, the
respondent Panchayat passed an order giving
temporary promotion on the post of Extension
o+icer with DRD agency on deputation to the
petitioner on 15.5.1998; the petitioner was
posted at Jam Kandorna as Extension O+icer on
26.5.1998, however, the petitioner did not accept
the promotion on deputation vide applications
dated 23.5.1998 and 2.6.1998; the post of
Extension O+icer was downgraded on 22.9.1998.
2.1 It is stated that the petitioner made a
representation on 31.10.1998 and 28.11.1998
that in view of downgrading of post of Extension
o+icer, First Higher Pay Scale maybe granted
and earlier order of withdrawing of Higher Pay
Scale may be cancelled; on 30.12.1998, the
respondent no.2 passed an order of withdrawing
the rst Higher Pay Scale as petitioner had
denied to accept the promotion order dated
15.5.1998; on 10.10.2003, the petitioner
approached the Tribunal, wherein the Tribunal
quashed and set aside the order dated
30.12.1998 and remanded the matter to be
decided afresh; the respondent, without deciding
the matter afresh, on 21.10.2002, kept on asking
the petitioner as to whether the petitioner is
ready and willing to accept the promotional post;
on 24.10.2002, in reply, the petitioner accepted
and gave consent; on 1.11.2002, the petitioner
realized about the downgrading of the post of
Extension o+icer and therefore stated that the
petitioner is ready to accept the promotion only
if it is a regular promotion; on 10.2.2004, by the
impugned order, after remand of the Tribunal,
the respondent no.2 once again rejected the
submission of the petitioner and upheld the order
of withdrawal of the rst Higher Pay Scale;
thereafter, on 12.3.2010, when the petitioner
made several representations and as there was
no reply or response, Special Civil Application
C/LPA/1208/2025
ORDER DATED: 17/11/2025
No.3236 of 2010 was led before this Court and
this Court directed the respondent authority to
decide the representation within a stipulated
time.
2.2 It is stated that in the meanwhile, Special
Civil Application No.17487 of 2012 led by one
similarly situated person came to be allowed vide
order dated 12.4.2017 and therefore the
petitioner once again made representation dated
27.7.2017 along with copy of the judgment of
Special Civil Application No.17487 of 2012
requesting to give similar treatment to the
petitioner, however, the respondent no.3
rejected the representation of the petitioner on
the same ground that earlier petitioner had
refused to accept the promotion and therefore
higher pay scale is withdrawn by the authority
and therefore this petition is led. By way of the
amendment being granted by order dated
10.2.2004 passed in Civil Application No.2 of
2023, the prayer 9 (AA) was amended in the
petition.”
4.
Learned advocate Mr.Kaash Thakkar appearing for the
appellants
tried
to
draw
the
distinction
between
the
petitioners of Special Civil Application No. 17487 of 2012,
who are admittedly similarly situated employees as the
respondent - original petitioner and there is no distinction
with regard thereto. It was submitted that the petitioners in
Special Civil Application No. 17487 of 2012 were the
employees, who have taken the promotion and thereafter, the
Government downgraded the post of Extension O:icer,
equivalent to Live Stock Inspector on 22.09.1998 whereas, in
the facts of the present case, the respondent – original
petitioner refused to take the promotion dated 23.05.1998 and
thereafter detailed order of transferring and posting was
C/LPA/1208/2025
ORDER DATED: 17/11/2025
passed on 26.05.1998, posting the petitioner at Jamkandorana
along with the petitioners of the Special Civil Application No.
17487 of 2012.
5.
It was further submitted that the respondent thereafter,
in the year 2002, again in response to the consent sought by
the appellants on 21.10.2002, gave a conditional consent for
deputation as Extension O:icer, however, the same was
withdrawn by respondent vide letter dated 01.11.2002.
6.
It was therefore submitted that the facts of both the
cases are di:erent.
7.
On perusal of the facts narrated and taking into
consideration the observations made in the Judgment and
Order dated 12.04.2017 passed by the learned Single Judge in
Special Civil Application No. 17487 of 2012, wherein it is
observed
that
once
the
post
of
Extension
O:icer
is
downgraded by the State Government on 22.09.1998, there
was no question of any promotion to be given to the petitioner
by the respondent, irrespective of whether the consent is
obtained or not, by the time of placing the petitioner on
deputation as Extension O:icer. The reasoning of the learned
Single Judge has been a:irmed by the co-ordinate Bench in
Letters Patent Appeal No.1071 of 2017, by observing as
under:“4. Having considered the submissions of
learned advocate Shri Munshaw the following
undisputed position emerges from the facts on
record:
C/LPA/1208/2025
ORDER DATED: 17/11/2025
(1) On completion of 9 years service in the year
1991, the respondent-original petitioner was
granted the rst higher grade scale by an order
dated 28.12.1992 with e+ect from 1.9.1991. The
higher grade scale granted was that of Rs.14,002300 revised scale Rs.4,500-7,000/(2) The order dated 15.5.1998, 15.5.1998,
though styled as an order of promotion to the
post of Extension O+icer, it was in e+ect an
order sending the respondent on deputation
outside the Panchayat, to the District Rural
Development Agency Agency.
(3) The petitioner requested his inability to
resume duty at the place he was sent on
deputation. Before the nal notice to resume on
deputation as Extension O+icer, vide an order
dated 30.09.2008 and the impugned order dated
30.12.1998, withdrawing the higher grade scale,
the District Rural Development Agency itself
downgraded the post of Extension O+icer to that
of Livestock Inspector. In other words, the
posting to D.R.D.A even otherwise no longer was
a promotion.
5. Bene ts of higher grade scale are extended to
employees, as there could be dearth of avenues
of promotion. The scheme contemplates
withdrawal of bene t of higher grade scale on
an incumbent refusing regular promotion. If the
order dated 15.5.1998 is perused what becomes
apparent is that, though the order states that
the respondent-original petitioner was being
temporarily promoted, it categorically further
stated that such a promotion was on deputation
to the District Rural Development Agency. The
Agency to which the respondent was being sent
is an autonomous body not within the
Panchayat. Therefore, the order of 15.5.1998
was in e+ect an order sending the respondent
on deputation, without his consent. Therefore
the condition attached to the order that in the
C/LPA/1208/2025
ORDER DATED: 17/11/2025
event, such promotion is refused, the higher
grade would be withdrawn was not a valid
condition, as the order was not in e+ect, an
order of promotion but an order sending the
respondent on deputation, without his consent
and therefore could not have imposed a
condition that it did. It is a well settled
proposition of law that no employee can be sent
on deputation, without his consent. The order of
15.5.1998,
asking
the
respondent-original
petitioner to resume at Dhoraji under the
D.R.D.A, was admittedly an order of deputing
the respondent on a post outside the Panchayat,
for which his consent was not obtained. Once
that be so, it cannot be said that, the petitioner
had refused promotion. Order dated 15.5.1998,
without consent was an order non-est. The
consequential
order
dated
30.12.1998,
withdrawing the higher grade scale would
therefore naturally fall Dat and be held to be
illegal. The learned Single Judge, in our opinion.
was therefore completely justi ed in holding
both the orders as bad and arbitrary and
quashing the same.
6. Even, otherwise, before the order of
30.12.1998 was passed, withdrawing the higher
grade scale, which we have held to be bad, as a
result of the order of 15.5.1998, to be so too, by
an order dated 29.9.1998, the post of Extension
O+icer, a promotional post, on which the
respondent-original petitioner was expected to
resume his duties, was itself downgraded to that
of Livestock Inspector. Admittedly therefore
even otherwise, there was no question,
independently, of the petitioner, having refused
promotion, when by virtue of the order of
29.9.2008, the post no longer remained a
promotional post.”
8.
The learned Single Judge has followed the above
Judgment and Order passed in Letters Patent Appeal No.1071
C/LPA/1208/2025
ORDER DATED: 17/11/2025
of 2017, which is squarely applicable to the facts of the case
of the respondent – original petitioner and following the same,
the petition was dismissed.
9.
In view of the above, no interference is called for in the
impugned Judgment and Order passed by the learned Single
Judge, which is based on the Judgment and Order passed by
the Division Bench of this Court in Letters Patent Appeal
No.1071 of 2017 and we do not =nd any distinction in the
facts of the case of the respondent – original petitioner with
that of the petitioners of the Special Civil Application
No.17487 of 2012.
10.
The appeal, therefore, being devoid of any merit, is
accordingly dismissed summarily, with no order as to costs.
(BHARGAV D. KARIA, J)
(L. S. PIRZADA, J)
STANCY GOMES
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review