Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:39837
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.17671 of 2025
Reserved on : 07.09.2026
Date of Decision: 17.09.2026
_______________________________________________________
Rajinder Kumar & others
…….Petitioners
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & others
… Respondents
_______________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Shailender Kashyap, Mr. Sumit Sharma
and Mr. Dhananjay Singh, Advocates.
For the Respondents: Mr. Rajan Kahol & Mr. Vishal Panwar,
Additional Advocate Generals with Mr. Ravi
Chauhan & Mr. Anish Banshtu, Deputy
Advocates General, for the respondentState.
Mr. Vedhant Ranta, Advocate, for
respondent No.2.
Ms. Gunjan Sharma, Advocate vice Mr.
Atul Jhingan, Advocate, for respondents
No.3 to 6.
____________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, Judge(oral):
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with order dated
06.10.2025 passed by respondent No. 2, whereby representation
dated 23.04.2025 filed by petitioners in terms of order dated
04.06.2025 passed by this Court in CWP No. 9318 of 2025, titled
Rajinder Kumar and others versus State of Himachal Pradesh,
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:39837
praying therein to release/issue sale letters and title deeds of
properties or land as detailed in agreement to sell dated 05.01.2022
came to be rejected, petitioners have approached this Court in the
instant proceedings filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
praying therein for following reliefs:“1. Issue a writ in Certiorari for setting aside the impugned order
dated 06.10.2025 passed respondent No.2 being perverse,
without application of mind and against the settled principles
of law, in the interest of justice, equity and fair play;
2. Issuance of the writ in the nature of mandamus directing the
respondent No.2 to issue/release the Sale Letters and Titled
Deeds of the properties/land as detailed in the Agreement to
sell dated 05.01.2022, executed in between petitioner No.1
and respondent No.3 and also in favour of petitioners No.2 to
6 in view of the OTS request letter dated 17.06.2019
(Annexure P-1) wherein respondent No.3 had specifically
mentioned that the offered amount would be either by
company or by sale of collateral as per sale cum settlement
order, although this OTS proposal was initially rejected, a
revised OTS offer dated 13.02.2021 (Annexure P-3) was
submitted, wherein respondent No.3 informed that the OTS
amount would be paid through the sale of the petitioners as
per their instructions to buyers already arranged by them
against the sale letters to be issued by respondent No.2 or
partly by the company itself and subsequently through a
letter dated 26.11.2022 (Annexure P-6), respondent No.3
deposited 25% of the OTS amount (Rs. 17 lakhs), clarifying
that the amount had been received as an advance from a
prospective buyers and was being paid towards the
settlement, subject to the issuance of sale letters by
respondent No.2, whereby it was further explained that the
land had already been sold and the payment made to the
2026:HHC:39837
corporation and therefore respondent No.3 requested
issuance of the sale letters to the buyers arranged by them,
so that the balance sale amount could be realized towards
the full and final settlement under the OTS, as in two
representations
dated
29.03.2023,
respondent
No.3
submitted details of the balance payments, reiterating that
the funds had been arranged through the buyers of the
property and again requested respondent No.2 to issue sale
letters in favour of those buyers who were making payments
on their behalf, in view of the statement dated 19.07.2025
(Annexure P-16) made before the Managing Director,
HPSIDC during a personal hearing, respondent No.3 once
again requested respondent No.2 to issue the sale letters in
favour of the petitioners, acknowledging that they were the
buyers arranged for the purpose of completing the OTS;
3.
It is further prayed that during the pendency of the present
writ petition respondent No.2 may kindly be directed not to
issue/release title deeds of the properties /land as detailed in
Agreement to Sell dated 05.01.2022 (Annexure P-4) and
representations abovesaid, for the reason, respondent No.3
has shown his illegal, dishonest intentions of grabbing the
title deeds of the properties/land as detailed in the
agreement to sell dated 05.01.2022 which is evident from the
issuance of Legal Notice dated 01.05.2025, suddenly taking
U-turn from his commitments, undertakings through number
of
representations
26.11.2022
and
dated
29.03.2023
17.06.2019,
and
most
13.02.2021,
pertinent
the
statement made before respondent No.2 on 19.07.2025
during the proceedings in pursuance to the directions of this
Hon’ble Court vide order dated 04.06.2025 passed in CWP
No. 9318 of 2025, titled Rajinder Kumar and others vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others, necessitating to
make the above interim prayers before this Hon’ble Court
2026:HHC:39837
2.
Quintessential facts, as emerge from the pleadings
adduced on record by the respective parties, are that respondent No.
2, Himachal Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation
(hereinafter, 'HPSIDC'), sanctioned a term loan of Rs. 5 crore in
favour of respondent No. 3, M/s Pankaj Spinners, for setting up an
industrial unit in the year 2011-12. Since afore company failed to
repay the amount, in the year, 2016 respondent No. 2-HPSIDC filed
an application under Section 31 of State Financial Corporations Act,
1951 (hereinafter, 'Act'), in the Court of learned District Judge, Solan
for recovery of term loan along with interest. During the pendency of
afore application, proposal for One Time Settlement (hereinafter,
'OTS') mooted by respondent No. 4, proprietor of respondent No. 3,
came to be approved by BoD of respondent No. 2-HPSIDC in the
year 2017. However, on account of failure of respondent No. 3 to
complete OTS, sum of Rs. 50 lakh deposited by it was forfeited by
respondent No. 2 and legal proceedings initiated against respondent
Nos. 3 and 4 came to be revived. Subsequently, afore case was
transferred to learned Additional District Judge, Nalagarh and the
primary property of respondent No. 3, mortgaged with respondent No.
2 was sold in auction for Rs. 3.80 crore by the learned Additional
District Judge and the sale proceeds were transferred to respondent
No. 2. Later, respondent No. 3 submitted an offer for OTS of Rs. 75
2026:HHC:39837
lakh vide letter dated 17.06.2019, requesting that the balance
payment be made either by the company or through sale of collateral
property,
as
contemplated
under
the
sale-cum-settlement
arrangement. The said proposal was not accepted by respondent No.
2 and respondent No. 3 was advised to substantially enhance the
OTS proposal vide letter dated 02.07.2019 (Annexure P-2).
Accordingly, vide letter dated 13.02.2021 (Annexure P-3), respondent
No. 3 enhanced the OTS proposal from Rs. 75 lakh to Rs. 1 crore.
Most importantly, while enhancing the OTS proposal, as detailed
hereinabove, respondent No. 3 disclosed the source and manner of
payment of the proposed OTS amount by stating that " amount would
be paid from the sale of properties as per instructions to buyers
(already arranged by us) against the sale letter to be issued by you or
partly by us”, meaning thereby, respondent No. 3, while enhancing
the OTS proposal from Rs. 75 lakh to Rs. 1 crore, specifically
apprised respondent No. 2 that OTS amount was to be arranged from
the sale of properties to prospective buyers already arranged by it.
After addressing aforesaid communication, respondent No. 3 entered
into an Agreement to Sell dated 05.01.2022 with petitioner No. 1 for
arranging funds towards satisfaction of the OTS liability (Annexure P4). Subsequently, respondent No. 2 approved the OTS proposal in its
2026:HHC:39837
meeting held on 01.10.2022 (Annexure P-5) with a counter-offer of
Rs. 1.10 crore against the proposal of Rs. 1 crore.
3.
Respondent No. 3 vide communication dated 26.11.2022
addressed to respondent No. 2, stated that the company did not have
any business activity and that dues of the Corporation were to be paid
by selling the collateral land. It also brought to the notice of
respondent No. 2 that buyers had already been shortlisted and that an
advance amount had been received from one of the buyers, who were
ready to make immediate payment for clearance of the dues.
Aforesaid letter shows that respondent No. 3 requested respondent
No. 2 to issue sale letters in favour of the buyers (petitioners Nos. 3
and 5), who were ready to pay 25% of the balance amount (Annexure
P-6). Respondent No. 2 accepted the upfront payment of 25% of the
OTS amount, amounting to Rs. 17 lakh, after being informed that the
amount had been arranged through the proposed sale of the collateral
land.
4.
Vide letter dated 29.03.2023 (Annexure P-7), respondent
No. 3 requested respondent No. 2 to issue sale letters in favor of the
petitioners by furnishing the details of amounts, demand drafts, and
buyers’ names. Simultaneously, vide another letter dated 29.03.2023,
respondent No. 3 introduced another buyer, namely KPJ Industries
(respondent No. 6), along with the earlier listed buyers, requesting
2026:HHC:39837
therein to release the original title deeds along with the sale letter
(Annexure P-8). On 07.12.2023, respondent No. 2 issued a "No Due
Certificate" in favor of respondent No. 3 recording that the Board of
the Corporation had approved the revival of the earlier OTS dated
01.10.2022 for Rs. 1.10 crore and since the entire sanctioned amount
had been repaid, nothing was due from respondent No. 3 (Annexure
P-9). Since, despite there being issuance of "No Dues Certificate”,
respondent No. 2 did not take any steps for issuance of sale letters
and release of original title deeds for almost two years, petitioners
Nos. 2 to 6 had made a detailed representation dated 23.04.2025
before respondent No. 2, seeking issuance of sale letters and release
of original title deeds in favour of the said petitioners, thereby
requesting an opportunity of personal hearing with advance notice, in
accordance with the principles of natural justice (Annexure P-10).
5.
After receipt of the representation dated 23.04.2025,
respondent No. 3 issued a legal notice dated 05.05.2025 to petitioner
No. 1 for forfeiting the earnest money paid by petitioner No. 1, for the
reason that the said petitioner failed to honour the conditions of the
agreed terms, handwritten MOUs, contractual obligations, etc.,
thereby causing financial loss to respondent No. 3. In response
thereto, vide communication dated 09.05.2025, reply was filed to the
2026:HHC:39837
said notice stating therein that respondent No. 3 had no lawful basis
to forfeit the earnest money.
6.
It is pertinent to take note that prior to filing the petition at
hand, petitioners had approached this Court by filing CWP No. 9086
of 2025, titled Rajinder Kumar & Ors. v. State of H.P. & Ors.,
raising the same and similar grievance. However, vide order dated
30.05.2025, the said petition was withdrawn by the petitioners due to
some technical defect in the petition, however liberty was reserved to
file fresh petition on the same grounds (Annexure P-14). Thereafter,
petitioners filed CWP No. 9318 of 2025, titled Rajinder Kumar & Ors.
v. State of H.P. & Ors., before this Court and same was disposed of
with a direction to respondent No. 2 to decide the representation,
preferably within three weeks. While passing the aforesaid order, this
Court also stayed the issuance of sale letters/title deeds to
respondent No. 3 during the pendency of the proceedings (Annexure
P-15). In the aforesaid background, petitioners, besides filing the
representation, appeared before respondent No. 2 and during the
course of proceedings, petitioner No. 1 and respondent No. 3 arrived
at a settlement, and their statements were recorded before
respondent No. 2 on 10.07.2025 (Annexure P-16).
7.
However, vide communication dated 06.10.2025, final
order was conveyed to the petitioners by respondent No. 2, intimating
2026:HHC:39837
therein that in view of the clarification given by the Principal Secretary
(Industries), respondent No. 2 cannot issue a sale certificate to the
petitioners, even if it is presumed that respondent No. 4 had managed
funds to clear the OTS from the present petitioners as the said land
was not auctioned by way of public auction under any provisions of
the State Financial Corporations Act, 1951 and the said funds were
arranged by the loanee at his own level. In the aforesaid
communication, it also came to be communicated that respondent No.
2 can only issue a sale certificate when the mortgaged/attached
property is sold in a public auction under Section 29 of the State
Financial Corporations Act, 195 and as per the notification of the
Government of Himachal Pradesh vide Notification No. IndustryA(F)10-5/2015, dated 06.05.2017, exemption under Section 118 of
the H.P. Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972 will be applicable only
when the property is sold under any of the provisions of the State
Financial Corporations Act, 1951 (Annexure P-17). In the aforesaid
background, petitioners have approached this Court in the instant
proceedings, praying therein for the reliefs, as have been reproduced
hereinabove.
8.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone
through the record carefully.
2026:HHC:39837
9.
Precisely, the grouse of the petitioners, as has been
highlighted in the petition and further canvassed by Mr. Shailender
Kashyap, Advocate duly assisted by Mr. Sumit Sharma and Mr.
Dhananjay Singh, Advocates, representing the petitioners, is that
impugned order dated 06.10.2025 is cryptic, non-speaking and suffers
from complete non-application of mind, as the material issues raised
by the petitioners in their representation dated 23.04.2025 have not
been addressed. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that
respondent No. 2 knew from the very inception of the OTS that the
amount was being arranged by selling the collateral/mortgaged land.
He submitted that respondent No. 2 was well within its rights to reject
the acceptance of the amount, however, respondent No. 2 without
raising any objection, accepted the amount, which means that
respondent No. 2 had given its consent to the arrangement of funds
by way of selling the land in question. Mr. Kashyap further submitted
that if respondent No. 2 had any objection to the proposed mode of
arrangement of funds or to the involvement of the petitioners as
prospective buyers, the same ought to have been raised at the
relevant stage, but respondent No. 2 neither rejected the payment nor
objected to the source of funds and instead continued to receive and
appropriate subsequent payments.
2026:HHC:39837
10.
Mr. Kashyap further submitted that respondent No. 2
itself issued the 'No Due Certificate' dated 07.12.2023 (Annexure P9), which indicates that there remained no outstanding financial
liability of respondent No. 3 towards respondent No. 2 and once the
dues of respondent No. 3 stood fully discharged and the certificate
had been issued, respondent No. 2 was required to release the title
deeds and issue the sale letters.
11.
To the contrary, Mr. Vedhant Ranta,
learned counsel
representing respondent No. 2, submitted that respondent No. 2
cannot issue sale certificate on the ground that the said mortgaged
property is neither sold/auctioned in public auction by respondent
No. 2 under Section 29 of the State Financial Corporations Act, 1951
and as per notification No. Ind.-A(F)10-5/2015, dated 06.05.2017,
exemption under Section 118 of the H.P. Tenancy and Land Reforms
Act, 1972 would only be applicable when the property is sold under
the provisions of the SFC Act. While admitting that respondent No.3
submitted representation
on 02.05.2023 and 31.05.2023 to issue
Sale Certificate, Mr. Vedhant Ranta, submitted that
on seeking
clarification of Government of Himachal Pradesh, Manager of
respondent No.2 rightly rejected the representation of the petitioners
on the basis of clarification letter dated 12.09.2023.
2026:HHC:39837
12.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
material available on record, this Court finds that respondent No.3,
which had availed loan to the tune of Rs. 5 crore for setting up an
industrial unit in the year 2011-12, failed to repay the amount, as a
result thereof, proceedings under Section 31 of the State Financial
Corporation Act, 1951 came to be initiated against respondent No.3 in
the Court of learned District Judge, Solan for recovery of term loan
alongwith interest. It is also not in dispute that during the pendency of
the aforesaid proceedings, OTS of respondent No. 4(proprietor of
respondent No. 3) was approved by the Board of Directors of
respondent No. 2 in the year 2017, but since respondent No. 3 failed
to complete the OTS, sum of Rs. 45 lakh deposited was forfeited and
the legal proceedings were revived before the learned District Judge
in the year 2019. It is not in dispute, rather stands admitted that
pursuant to orders passed by learned Additional District Judge,
Nalagarh, primary property of respondent No. 3 mortgaged with
respondent No. 2 was sold in auction for Rs. 3.8 crore by the learned
Additional District Judge and the sale proceeds were transferred to
respondent No. 2.
13.
issuance of
At this juncture, the dispute is only with regard to
sale letter/
title deeds to petitioners pursuant to the
clearance of an offer made by respondent No. 3 for OTS of Rs. 75
2026:HHC:39837
lakh vide letter dated 17.06.2019. Since sum of Rs. 75 lakh offered
under OTS vide letter dated 17.06.2019 was not acceptable to
respondent No. 2, respondent No. 2, vide communication dated
13.02.2021, enhanced its OTS proposal from Rs. 75 lakh to Rs. 1
crore, which subsequently came to be approved at the rate of Rs.
1.10 crore.
14.
At this stage, it would be apt to take note of
communication
dated
17.06.2019
(Annexure
P-1),
whereby
respondent No. 4, promoter of respondent No. 3, after sale of the
primary property for a sum of Rs. 3.80 crore, requested respondent
No. 2 to accept the balance payment of Rs. 75 lakh either by the
company or by the sale of collateral as per the sale-cum-settlement
order. However, as has been observed hereinabove, afore proposal
was rejected vide communication dated 02.07.2019 (Annexure P-2)
with the clear-cut observation that proposal given under One Time
Settlement may be enhanced.
15.
Vide communication dated 13.02.2021, respondent No. 3
enhanced the OTS amount from Rs. 75 lakh to Rs. 100 lakh, but while
making such offer, it specifically came to be clarified that the amount
to be paid will be from the sale of properties as per our instruction to
the buyers already arranged by us against the sale letter to be issued
by you, or partly by us.
2026:HHC:39837
16.
Vide communication dated 31.10.2022 (Annexure P-5),
respondent No. 4, promoter of respondent No. 3, specifically came to
be informed that proposal of Rs. 1 crore was considered by the BODs
of the corporation in its meeting held on 01.10.2022, which has given
a counter-offer of Rs. 1.10 crore only on the following terms and
conditions:
“ 1. Resolved that the settlement dues accepted by Sh. Joginder
Khanna, Promoter of the company be and is hereby approved at a
total consideration of Rs. 1.10 crore inclusive of all misc/legal dues
etc.
2. It was further resolved that the promoter shall deposit the settled
amount by 31/03/2023 on interest free basis with a minimum 25%
of the settled amount to be deposited within one month of
conveying of the approval of settlement. If was further resolved
that the in case of their inability to adhere to the time schedule
above, the restored and recovery proceedings shall be continued/
initiated as per legal options available.”
17.
Immediately after receipt of the aforesaid communication,
respondent No. 4, being the promoter of respondent No. 3, vide
communication dated 26.11.2022 agreed to the counter offer made by
respondent No. 2 and represented to arrange a sale letter in favour of
the buyers so that some advances may be arranged from the buyers,
namely Marine Medicare, Suresh Kumar and any other buyer which
may notify. Besides above, vide another letter dated 26.11.2022
(Annexure P-7), which is reproduced hereinabove, respondent No. 4,
Director of M/s Pankaj Spinners, forwarded six demand drafts made
2026:HHC:39837
from the account of persons from whom the petitioners had arranged
the amount of Rs. 1.10 Crore agreed to be paid under One Time
Settlement.
18.
Careful perusal of the aforesaid communication clearly
reveals that respondent No. 4 specifically requested respondent No. 2
to issue sale letter in favour of the buyers buying the property. After
receipt of aforesaid amount, as detailed in communication dated
26.11.2022, respondent No. 2, vide communication dated 07.12.2023
(Annexure P-9), apprised respondent No. 4 that Board of the
Corporation has approved the revival of the earlier One Time
Settlement of 01.10.2022 in favour of the company M/s Pankaj
Spinners Pvt. Ltd. and issued 'No Dues Certificate'. Since, despite
issuance of the 'No Dues Certificate', sale certificates were not issued
in favour of the petitioners, they, vide representation dated
23.04.2025 addressed to the Managing Director, requested for
issuance of sale certificates. Since aforesaid representation as well as
subsequent legal notice issued at the behest of the petitioners was
not paid any heed, petitioners approached this Court in the instant writ
petition, which came to be disposed of with a direction to the
respondents to consider and decide the pending representation.
Ultimately, vide communication dated 06.10.2025, representation
2026:HHC:39837
dated 23.04.2025 submitted by the petitioners in terms of orders
passed by this Court came to be rejected.
19.
Precisely, the question, which needs to be determined in
the case at hand, is whether respondent No. 2, after having accepted
entire OTS amount amounting to Rs. 1.10 Crore that too after being
expressly informed that the amount had been arranged through the
proposed sale of the collateral land, could have denied issuance of
sale certificates in favour of the petitioners or not.
20.
Careful perusal of communications dated 17.06.2019
(Annexure P-1) , 13.02.2021 (Annexure P-3), 26.11.2022(Annexure
P-6), and 29.03.2003 (Annexure P-8), clearly demonstrates that
arrangement for payment through prospective buyers was not an
afterthought, but was consistently disclosed to respondent No. 2 by
respondent No. 3.
21.
Though, having taken note of dispute inter se petitioners
and respondent No. 2 with regard to issuance of the sale certificate,
there appears to be no reason for this Court to go into the question of
the issuance of the legal notice dated 01.05.2025, seeking therein to
forfeit the earnest money, but yet having taken note of the facts as
discussed hereinabove in their entirety, this Court has no hesitation to
conclude that conduct of respondent No. 3 in issuing the legal notice
dated 01.05.2025 and seeking to forfeit the earnest money is contrary
2026:HHC:39837
to its own earlier representation made before respondent No. 2 and
this Court. Respondent No. 3 repeatedly acknowledged that
petitioners were the prospective buyer and that amounts were being
arranged through them towards the satisfaction of its OTS liability.
Respondent No. 3 had earlier stated on oath before this Court in CWP
5936 of 2021, titled M/s Pankaj Spinners vs. Himachal Pradesh State
Industrial Development Corporation Limited and another, that it had
two willing buyers, namely Rajinder Kumar and M/s SSF. Plastics
India Private Limited and sought permission to sell the mortgaged
property by way of negotiation of settlement-cum-sale through
respondent No. 2 (Annexure P-18).
22.
Though, there is no specific denial with regard to
issuance
of
communications,
as
detailed
hereinabove,
and
subsequent approval given by the Board of Directors of respondent
No. 2, but an attempt has been made to refute the claim of the
petitioners on the ground that mortgaged property is neither sold nor
auctioned in a public auction by respondent No. 2 under Section 29 of
the State Financial Corporation Act, 1951 and as per that notification
No. Industry-A(F)10-5/2015, dated 06.05.2017 no exemption under
Section 118 of the HP Land Revenue Act can be granted.
23.
Most importantly, respondent No. 2, after having
received representations from respondent No. 3 dated 02.05.2023
2026:HHC:39837
and 31.05.2023, praying therein to issue the sale certificate, referred
the matter to the Government for clarification on the point that
"whether the Corporation can issue sale certificate to the promoter of
the company/buyer and will they get an exemption from Section 118
of the HP Tenancy and Land Reforms Act?". Respondent No. 2
received clarification from the Government of Himachal Pradesh,
wherein they came to be advised that no sale certificate is to be
issued to the promoter of the company or to the proposed buyer as
the said mortgaged property is neither sold nor auctioned in a public
auction by respondent No. 2 under Section 29 of the State Financial
Corporation Act and as per notification No. Industry-A(F)10-5/2015,
dated 06.05.2017.
24.
There cannot be any dispute qua the fact that mortgaged
property was neither sold nor auctioned in a public auction by
respondent No. 2 under Section 29 of the State Financial Corporation
Act and
as such, as per Notification No. Industry-A(F)10-5/2015,
dated 06.05.2017, exemption under Section 118 of the HP Land
Revenue Act will not be applicable to the mortgaged property involved
in
the
case
communication
at
hand.
dated
However,
13.02.2021
having
carefully
perused
(Annexure
P-3),
whereby
respondent No. 3 enhanced its OTS proposal from Rs. 75 Lakh to Rs.
1 Crore, this Court is persuaded to agree with counsel representing
2026:HHC:39837
the petitioners that respondent No. 3 had disclosed the source and
manner of the payment of the proposed OTS amount by stating that
"amount would be paid from the sale of the properties as per our
instructions to buyer (already arranged by us) against the said letter to
be issued by respondent No. 2 or partly by us." The rightful claim of
the petitioners, who, under a bona fide belief that they would be
issued sale certificate qua the property for which they have paid
substantial amount, cannot be permitted to be defeated.
25.
Most importantly,
after issuance of
the aforesaid
communication dated 26.11.2022, respondent No. 3 entered into an
agreement to sell dated 05.01.2022 with petitioner No. 1 for arranging
the funds towards satisfaction of the OTS liability and subsequently
respondent No. 2 approved the OTS proposal in its meeting held on
01.10.2022 with a counter-offer of Rs. 1.10 Crore against the proposal
of Rs. 1 Crore.
26.
Careful perusal of letter dated 31.10.2022 clearly reveals
that respondent No. 2 never objected to arrangement of funds by
respondent No. 3 through petitioners, rather, after having received
entire OTS amount, i.e., Rs. 1.10 Crore, it itself proceeded to issue
No Dues Certificate vide communication dated 07.12.2023 (Annexure
P-9).
2026:HHC:39837
27.
At this juncture, it is important to take note of the
communication dated 26.11.2022 (Annexure P-7), whereby six
demand drafts amounting to different amounts, as detailed in the
aforesaid communication, came to be handed over to respondent No.
2. In afore communication it specifically came to be apprised that
such amounts are being paid from the account of the petitioners, who
came forward to bail out respondents No. 3 and 4 qua recovery of
remaining sum of Rs. 75 Lakh. Even after receipt of communication
dated 26.11.2022, whereby factum with regard to arrangement of
funds by the petitioners had come to the knowledge of respondent
No. 2, coupled with the fact that respondent No. 3 while forwarding
afore letter had specifically requested respondent No. 2 to issue sale
certificates in favour of persons, who have forwarded the demand
drafts and thereafter Board of Directors of respondent No. 2 itself
proceeded to approve One Time Settlement for sum of
Rs. 1.10
crore and issued No Dues Certificate. In afore background, it is not
open for respondent No. 2 to deny issuance of sale certificates on the
ground that property in question was neither auctioned nor sold under
Section 29 of the State Financial Corporations Act.
28.
Though, having taken note of Notification No. Industry-
A(F)10-5/2015, dated 06.05.2017, this Court is persuaded to agree
with counsel for respondent No. 2 as well as learned Additional
2026:HHC:39837
Advocate General that sale certificate can be issued qua the property
which is sold under any provision of the SFC Act, so that the
exemption under Section 118 of the H.P. Land Revenue and Tenancy
Act is availed by a person, who purchased the property, but since in
the case at hand, respondent No. 2 itself taking note of prayer made
by respondent No. 3 for One Time Settlement, coupled with the fact
that respondent No. 3, while making such prayer had clarified that
funds are being arranged from private parties/petitioners and after
acceptance of OTS, sale certificates are to be issued in favour of the
petitioners, respondent No. 2 cannot be permitted to raise the ground
as is sought to be raised in the impugned order dated 06.10.2025.
29.
At this juncture, it is apt to take note of the fact that
primary property of respondent Nos. 3 and 4 was sold in public
auction for a sum of Rs. 3.80 crore, whereas remaining sum of Rs. 75
lakh was decided to be liquidated by the petitioners by arranging
funds and such proposal of them was accepted for a sum of Rs. 1.10
crore. Though, this Court is of the view that even aforesaid settlement
arrived at inter se respondent No. 2 and respondent Nos. 3 and 4 can
be said to be part of proceedings initiated against respondent Nos. 3
and 4 under Section 29 of the Act, but even if it is presumed that
remaining sum of Rs. 25 lakh was not paid by way of auction or sale
of the property in question, this Court is persuaded to agree with the
2026:HHC:39837
counsel of the petitioners that in case respondent Nos. 3 and 4 had
not made any proposal to pay balance sum of Rs. 75 lakh by OTS,
remaining property of the petitioners would have been sold by
respondent No. 2 in public auction and in that situation, buyer would
have been issued sale certificate.
30.
Since prime property of respondent Nos. 3 and 4 came to
be sold in public auction for sum of Rs. 3.80 crore and for remaining
sum of Rs. 75 lakh, petitioners themselves brought prospective
buyers and which proposal was accepted by respondent No. 2,
coupled with the fact that respondent No. 3, while bringing factum of
arrangement of money through prospective buyers, brought it to the
notice of respondent No. 2, who subsequently proceeded to accept
the proposal for one-time settlement that too during the proceedings
pending under Section 29 of the Act, this Court, without going into the
legality of proposition of law mooted at the behest of respondent No. 2
as well as the notification No. Industry-A(F)10-5/2015, dated
06.05.2017, finds it a fit case where direction can be issued to
respondent No. 2 to issue sale certificate in favour of the petitioners,
who bona fide, with a view to bail out the petitioners came forward to
liquidate the outstanding liability of the petitioners with a clear-cut
understanding that in the event of clearance of entire remaining
2026:HHC:39837
amount, they shall be issued
sale certificate qua the property in
question.
31.
Consequently, in view of the detailed discussion made
hereinabove, this Court finds merit in the present petition and
accordingly, same is allowed with a direction to respondent No. 2 to
release the title deeds of the property/land, as detailed in the
agreement to sell dated 05.01.2022 (Annexure P-4) in favour of
petitioners. However, having taken note of the fact that this Court has
not commented upon the legality and correctness of Notification No.
Industry-A(F)10-5/2015, dated 06.05.2017, coupled with the fact that
instant order has been passed in peculiar facts and circumstances
and shall not be treated as a precedent, rather findings given herein
shall remain confined to the disposal of the instant petition. Pending
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
September 17, 2026
(shankar)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review