Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
Reserved On
: 02/09/2026
Pronounced On : 14/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION (FOR CANCELLATION OF BAIL) NO.
4753 of 2023
==========================================================
RAJESHKUMAR SHANKARLAL SOLANKI (MALI)
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR MB RANA(2760) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR for the Respondent(s) No. 1
UMARFARUK M KHARADI(8155) for the Respondent(s) No. 2,3
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE SANJEEV J.THAKER
CAV ORDER
1.
This
is
an
application
for
cancellation
of
bail
preferred by the present applicant – original complainant
under Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973, seeking quashing and setting aside the impugned order
passed by the learned trial Court, whereby the learned trial
Court has granted regular bail to the respondent/s-accused in
connection with FIR being C.R. No.11195034220484 of 2022
registered with the Palanpur East Police Station, District :
Banaskantha, for the offences punishable under Sections 306,
511, 384, 506(1) and 114 of the Indian Penal Code.
2.
Rule. Learned APP and learned advocates waive
service of notice of rule for and on behalf of respondent –
State and respondent/s – accused, respectively.
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
3.
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
Learned advocate appearing for the applicant has
vehemently submitted that the learned trial Court has failed
to
appreciate
the
gravity
and
seriousness
of
the
offence
alleged against the respondents–accused and has mechanically
granted bail.
3.1
It is further submitted that while considering the
bail application preferred by the respondent/s–accused, the
learned trial Court did not adequately examine the evidence
collected during the course of investigation and therefore,
committed a grave error in exercising its discretion in favour
of the accused. The learned advocate has drawn attention to
the
serious
allegations
levelled
against
the
respondent/s–
accused in the FIR and submitted that the nature and
gravity of such accusations were not properly appreciated by
the learned trial Court while granting bail.
3.2
by
Referring to the documents and material collected
the
Investigating
Officer,
learned
advocate
for
the
applicant submitted that ample evidence has been gathered
during the investigation, which, prima facie, establishes the
direct
involvement
of
the
respondent/s–accused
in
the
commission of the alleged offence. Despite the availability of
such incriminating material, the learned trial Court failed to
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
assign proper weight to the same and erroneously granted
bail to the respondent/s–accused.
3.3
Learned advocate for the applicant has submitted
that the role of the respondent/s-original accused is not just
of simple threats but it is a case of proselytizing as observed
in the earlier order and the learned Judge has overturned
the observations made in the earlier order while granting the
bail. He submitted that the respondent nos.2 and 3 are
headstrong persons and therefore, there is great possibility
that they may jump the bail. He submitted that the learned
Court below has wrongly come to the conclusion that there is
a change in the circumstances and wrongly entertained the
bail application of respondent nos.2 and 3 herein.
3.4
It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned order
granting
bail
suffers
from
non-application
of
mind
and
improper appreciation of the material on record. Considering
the seriousness of the offence, the strength of the evidence
collected during investigation and the likelihood of prejudice
to a fair investigation, it is submitted that the present
application may be allowed by cancelling the bail granted to
the respondents–accused in the interest of justice.
4.
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
the
State
has
adopted
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
the
submissions
advanced
by
the
learned advocate for the applicant and has further submitted
that the impugned order granting bail to the respondents–
accused is contrary to the material available on record. It is
contended that the learned Trial Court has granted bail
without properly appreciating the evidence collected during
the
course
consideration
of
investigation
and
the
gravity
seriousness
and
without
taking
of
the
into
offence
alleged against the respondents–accused.
4.1
It is, therefore, submitted that the learned Trial
Court has exercised its discretion in an erroneous manner
and that the impugned order deserves to be set aside and
this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to allow the present
application and cancel the bail granted to the respondents–
accused.
Per contra, learned advocate appearing for the
5.
respondents–accused has opposed the present application and
submitted that the impugned order granting bail is wellreasoned and speaking order passed upon due consideration of
the facts and circumstances of the case. It is contended that
the learned Trial Court has exercised its discretion judiciously
and
in
accordance
with
settled
principles
of
law
and,
therefore, no interference is warranted by this Hon'ble Court
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
in exercise of its jurisdiction. It is further submitted that the
learned trial Court took the prima facie view of releasing the
respondent/s-accused
on
bail
and
therefore
also,
this
application is required to be rejected.
5.1
It is further submitted that while passing the
impugned
order,
the
learned
Trial
Court
has
extensively
considered all the relevant aspects, including the nature of
allegations, the material collected during the investigation,
and
the
submissions
appreciating
learned
the
Trial
advanced
entire
Court
by
both
the
sides.
After
available
on
record,
the
appropriate
to
enlarge
the
material
found
it
respondents–accused on bail. Hence, it cannot be said that
the
order
suffers
from
any
illegality,
perversity
or
non-
application of mind so as to justify cancellation of bail.
5.2
to
It is also submitted that the prosecution has failed
point
out
any
supervening
circumstances
warranting
cancellation of bail. In particular, it is not the case that the
respondents–accused
have
violated
or
flouted
any
of
the
conditions imposed while granting bail. There is no allegation
that the respondents–accused have attempted to tamper with
evidence, influence witnesses, obstruct the course of justice, or
misuse liberty granted by the Court.
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
5.3
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, it
is submitted that no case is made out for cancellation of
bail. The present application, being devoid of merits, deserves
to be rejected and the bail granted to the respondents–
accused may kindly be continued.
6.
Having heard the learned advocates appearing for
the respective parties and upon perusal of the impugned
order passed by the learned Trial Court as well as the
material available on record, the following points emerge:
6.1
The allegations against respondent No.2 arise from
his relationship with the niece of the applicant – original
complainant. It is the case of the applicant that respondent
No.2
came
relationship
in
contact
with
with
her.
He
his
is
niece
alleged
and
to
developed
have
a
gradually
influenced her and thereafter her mother and brother also.
When the father of the niece objected
to her continued
contact with respondent No.2, he was allegedly threatened
with
photographs
and
videos
of
his
daughter
in
a
alleged
that
respondent
No.2
the
family
compromising condition.
6.2
It
is
further
remained
in
contact
with
members
of
the
applicant’s brother and attempted to influence them to follow
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
a particular religion. When the applicant’s brother objected to
such conduct, his nephew filed proceedings by way of habeas
corpus. During those proceedings, the niece, her mother and
her brother stated that they did not want to live with or
accompany
the
applicant’s
brother.
They
expressed
their
desire to live separately. It is also the case of the applicant
that his brother had attempted to commit suicide.
6.3
The record shows that respondent Nos.2 and 3
had earlier filed applications for regular bail. The same came
to be rejected by the learned 3
Banaskantha
Thereafter,
at
Palanpur,
respondent
No.3
rd
by
Additional District Judge,
order
preferred
dated
an
16.09.2022.
application
for
regular bail before this Court. On 30.11.2022, the Coordinate
Bench of this Court permitted respondent No.3 to withdraw
the application with liberty to approach the competent Court
after filing of the chargesheet. After the chargesheet was
filed, the successive bail application came to be allowed on
22.12.2022.
6.4
While granting regular bail after charge-sheet, the
learned trial Court considered the material collected during
the investigation. It is noticed that respondent No.2 and the
niece of the applicant were in a relationship. The statements
of the wife, son and daughter of the applicant’s brother were
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
also considered. Their statements were recorded under Section
164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. They stated that
respondent
Nos.2
and
had
not
kept
them
in
illegal
confinement. They also stated that they had not been forced
to convert to another religion. They further stated that no
money was demanded from them and that the applicant’s
brother was not compelled to convert to another religion.
They also did not support the allegation that respondent
Nos.2 and 3 had abetted the suicide attempt.
6.5
The
learned
trial
Court
also
considered
the
proceedings arising from the habeas corpus petition, where
the concerned family members had stated that they did not
want to accompany the applicant’s brother. The learned trial
Court also took into account the fact that respondent Nos.2
and 3 were in custody since 01.09.2022 and that they had no
criminal antecedents.
6.6
By way of this application, the applicant – original
complainant has challenged the grant of regular bail mainly
on the ground that the material circumstances were not
properly appreciated by the learned trial Court. According to
the applicant, the allegations regarding threats, influence and
pressure upon the family members, the circumstances leading
to the habeas corpus proceedings and the suicide attempt of
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
the applicant’s brother required greater consideration.
6.7
At this stage, it is necessary to keep in mind the
limited
scope
Cancellation
of
of
an
bail
application
for
stands
a
on
cancellation
different
of
bail.
footing
from
rejection of bail. When bail is being considered, the Court
decides whether the accused should be released. Once bail
has been granted, the Court must examine whether there is
sufficient reasons to withdraw the liberty already granted.
6.8
Further, bail can certainly be cancelled where the
accused misuses the liberty, threatens or influences witnesses,
tampers with evidence, commits another offence, avoids the
proceedings or violates the conditions of bail. Further, it can
also be cancelled where the order granting bail is shown to
be based on no consideration of the relevant material or on a
consideration which is wholly unreasonable.
6.9
been
In the present case, no such circumstance has
brought
on
record.
There
is
no
allegation
that
respondent Nos.2 and 3 have misused the liberty granted to
them after their release. There is no material to show that
they
have
investigation,
threatened
tampered
any
with
witness,
interfered
evidence
condition of bail.
or
with
the
violated
any
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
6.10
The
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
submissions
made
by
the
applicant,
in
substance, call upon this Court to reconsider the material
which was already before the Court when the regular bail
application was decided, that too it was filed after chargesheet. The learned trial Court had considered the statements
recorded
under
Section
of
the
Code
of
Criminal
Procedure. It had also considered the stand taken by the
concerned family members in the habeas corpus proceedings.
The
period
of
custody
and
the
absence
of
criminal
antecedents were also taken into account.
6.11
The fact that the applicant’s brother attempted to
commit
suicide
However,
at
is
this
undoubtedly
stage,
the
a
serious
question
circumstance.
whether
the
acts
attributed to respondent Nos.2 and 3 amount to abetment of
suicide is a matter to be established during the trial. The
allegations in the FIR cannot, by themselves, be treated as
proof of the offence.
6.12
The
allegations
regarding
the
relationship,
the
alleged threats and the alleged influence upon the family
members will have to be tested on the basis of evidence. The
statements of the concerned family members recorded under
Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure are also a
part of the material which was considered while granting
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
regular bail. This Court, while examining an application for
cancellation, cannot ignore that material merely because the
applicant seeks a different appreciation of the same.
6.13
The seriousness of the allegations is a relevant
consideration while deciding bail. However, it is not by itself
sufficient to cancel bail which has already been granted. The
applicant
has
to
show
some
substantial
ground
for
interference. In the present case, such ground has not been
established.
6.14
This
Court
is
impugned
order
dated
22.12.2022
considering
the
relevant
material.
The
concerned
witnesses,
material
relating
the
also
unable
to
accept
that
was
passed
without
statements
to
the
the
of
the
habeas
corpus proceedings, the period of custody and the antecedent
position of the accused were before the learned trial Court.
The reasons recorded by the learned trial Court cannot be
said to be so unreasonable or perverse as would justify
cancellation of bail.
6.15
It is true that the earlier bail application had
been rejected on 16.09.2022 by the learned trial Court, but it
was
before
the
charge-sheet.
chargesheet
was
filed
and
However,
respondent
thereafter,
No.3
had
the
been
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
permitted by the Coordinate Bench of this Court to approach
the competent Court after filing of the chargesheet. The
subsequent bail application was therefore considered in the
changed circumstances and on the material then available
before the Court. The grant of bail cannot be interfered with
merely because bail had earlier been refused.
7.
At this juncture, the observations made by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Dolat Ram & Ors. Vs.
State of Haryana, reported in 1995(1) SCC 349, is required
to be recollected. It was observed therein that very cogent
and overwhelming circumstances are necessary for an order
directing the cancellation of the bail already granted. The
grounds
for
cancellation
of
bail
though
are
broad,
but
illustrative and not exhaustive; are interference or attempt to
interfere with the due course of administration of justice or
evasion or attempt to evade the due course of justice or
abuse
of
the
concession
granted
to
the
accused
in
any
manner. The bail once granted, should not in a mechanical
manner, without any grounds, or supervening circumstance,
which affects the very principle of fair trial be cancelled.
8.
Having considered the entire material, this Court
finds that the applicant has not shown any misuse of liberty
by respondent Nos.2 and 3 or any subsequent circumstance
R/CR.MA/4753/2023(GJHC240053272023)
CAV ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
which requires cancellation of their bail. The grounds urged
by
the
applicant
essentially
seek
reconsideration
of
the
impugned order by which bail was granted. That by itself is
not sufficient for cancellation of bail.
9.
Accordingly, the present applications are rejected.
Rule is discharged.
(SANJEEV J.THAKER,J)
SRILATHA
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review