Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
Reserved On
: 17/08/2026
Pronounced On : 20/08/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION (FOR CANCELLATION OF BAIL) NO.
18928 of 2026
==========================================================
RAJESHBHAI CAPTAIN KESHVANPILLAI JOHN
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR.
==========================================================
Appearance:
ALAY A DAVE(8219) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MR NIRAJ SHARMA, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE SANJEEV J.THAKER
CAV ORDER
1.
This is an application for cancellation of bail preferred
by the present applicant – original complainant under Section
483(3) of the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita (‘the BNSS’ for
short), seeking quashing and setting aside the impugned order
dated 30.05.2026, passed by the learned trial Court i.e. City Civil
&
Session
Judge,
Ahmedabad
in
Criminal
Misc.
Application
No.3722 of 2026, whereby the learned trial Court has granted
regular bail to the respondent–original accused in connection with
FIR being C.R. No.11191023260103 of 2026 registered with Vadaj
Police
Station,
punishable
under
District
Ahmedabad
Sections
316(2),
City,
for
316(4), 318(3),
the
offences
61(2), 336(2),
336(3), 338, 340(2) and 344 of the Bhartiya Nyay Sanhita.
2.
Rule. Learned APP waive service of notice of rule for
and on behalf of respondent – State.
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
3.1
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
Learned
advocate
appearing
for
the
applicant
has
vehemently submitted that the learned trial Court has failed to
appreciate
the
gravity
and
seriousness
of
the
offence
alleged
against the respondent–accused and has mechanically granted bail.
It is submitted that the impugned order has been passed without
proper consideration of the material available on record, which has
adversely affected the ongoing investigation. It is further contended
that the possibility of the respondent–accused tampering with the
prosecution evidence and influencing witnesses cannot be ruled out.
3.2.
It is further submitted that while considering the bail
application preferred by the respondent–accused, the learned trial
Court did not adequately examine the evidence collected during the
course of investigation and therefore, committed a grave error in
exercising its discretion in favour of the accused. The learned
advocate has drawn attention to the serious allegations levelled
against the respondent–accused in the FIR and submitted that the
nature
and
gravity
of
such
accusations
were
not
properly
appreciated by the learned trial Court while granting bail.
3.3
the
Referring to the documents and material collected by
Investigating
submitted
that
Officer,
ample
learned
evidence
has
advocate
been
for
the
gathered
applicant
during
the
investigation, which, prima facie, establishes the direct involvement
of the respondent–accused in the commission of the alleged offence.
Despite the availability of such incriminating material, the learned
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
trial
Court
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
failed
to
assign
proper
weight
to
the
same
and
erroneously granted bail to the respondent–accused.
3.4
It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned order
granting bail suffers from non-application of mind and improper
appreciation of the material on record. Considering the seriousness
of
the
offence,
the
strength
of
the
evidence
collected
during
investigation and the likelihood of prejudice to a fair investigation,
it is submitted that the present application may be allowed by
cancelling
the
bail
granted
to
the
respondent–accused
in
the
interest of justice.
State
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the
has
adopted
the
submissions
advanced
by
the
learned
advocate for the applicant and has further submitted that the
impugned order granting bail to the respondent–accused is contrary
to the material available on record. It is contended that the
learned Trial Court has granted bail without properly appreciating
the
evidence
collected
during
the
course
of
investigation
and
without taking into consideration the gravity and seriousness of
the offence alleged against the respondent–accused.
4.1
It is further submitted that the learned Trial Court
has failed to consider the affidavit filed by the Investigating
Officer, wherein specific grounds were raised opposing the grant of
bail. The contents of the said affidavit, which were material and
relevant for deciding the bail application, have not been duly
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
considered
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
by
the
learned
Trial
Court
while
exercising
its
discretion in favour of the respondent–accused.
4.2
It is, therefore, submitted that the learned Trial Court
has exercised its discretion in an erroneous manner and that the
impugned order deserves to be set aside and this Hon'ble Court
may be pleased to allow the present application, cancel the bail
granted to the respondent–accused.
5.1
Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the
respective parties and upon perusal of the impugned order passed
by the learned Trial Court as well as the material available on
record, this Court is of the view that the present application has
been filed merely on the basis of presumptions and assumptions,
without placing on record any cogent material or demonstrating
the
existence
warranting
of
any
interference
supervening
with
the
or
prevailing
circumstances
order
granting
bail.
In
the
absence of any substantive material to justify the relief sought,
the application does not merit consideration.
5.2.
Considering the role attributed to the present applicant is
that
there
are
allegations
that
the
accused
nos.1
and
in
connivance with each other had prepared false bills towards the
rent expenses of hotel Asha situated at Jamnagar and the same
were prepared during their employment and the same was passed
after verification which was found that all the accused had in
connivance
with
each
other
misappropriated
the
funds
of
the
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
complainant.
working
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
The
with
fact
the
remains
company
that
and
respondent
the
role
no.2
attributed
was
not
to
the
respondent no.2 is receiving the said amount from the complainant
who happens to be the uncle and thereafter the said amount was
transferred in the account of other persons whom respondent no.2
knew.
5.3 The prosecution case, in brief, is that Accused Nos.1 and 2, in
collusion
with
each
other,
prepared
false
bills
showing
rent
expenses for Hotel Asha situated at Jamnagar. These bills were
processed and cleared during their employment. On verification, it
was found that the bank account mentioned in the documents did
not belong to the person or entity in whose name the expenses
were shown. It is the case of the prosecution that due to this,
funds were wrongly diverted and the complainant company suffered
loss.
5.4 It is further alleged that by following this method, the accused
persons,
acting
with
common
intention,
misappropriated
and
diverted company funds. The total loss is stated to be around
Rs.3,60,08,222/-. The chargesheet refers to the preparation of bills,
their approval, movement of money through different accounts, and
the role of each accused in the said process. As far as Respondent
No.2 is concerned, the material collected during investigation has
to be seen in light of his specific role. It is not in dispute that
Respondent
No.2
was
not
an
employee
of
the
complainant
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
company. There is no allegation that he was involved in preparing,
checking, or approving the bills related to Hotel Asha. There is
also nothing on record to show that he had any control or
responsibility
over
the
accounts
or
financial
affairs
of
the
complainant company.
5.5. The main allegation against Respondent No.2 is that his bank
account
was
used
for
receiving
part
of
the
alleged
diverted
amount. The investigation further shows that the amount received
in his account was later transferred to another person known to
him. It is also stated that the amount came to him from Accused
No.1, who is said to be his uncle. Thus, the allegation against
Respondent No.2 is mainly based on the flow of money through
his account and its further transfer.
5.6. It is important to note that the investigation is already
complete and the chargesheet was filed on 17.04.2026. The case of
the prosecution rests on documents such as bank records, bills and
other material collected during investigation. There is no allegation
that after release on bail, Respondent No.2 has tried to interfere
with the investigation, tamper with evidence, influence witnesses,
or misuse the liberty granted to him.
5.7. The fact that Respondent No.2’s bank account was used for
receiving and transferring money is certainly a circumstance that
will be examined during trial. However, by itself, it cannot be
treated as final proof of his involvement in the entire alleged
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
offence. Whether he had knowledge of the transaction, whether he
was part of any conspiracy, and whether the movement of money
was part of a planned act are all issues that will have to be
proved during trial on the basis of evidence.
5.8. It is also relevant that the main allegations of preparing and
processing false bills relate to Accused Nos.1 and 2, who were
employees of the complainant company. Respondent No.2 was not
employed with the company. Therefore, his alleged role is different
in nature and has to be examined only on the basis of material
specifically linking him to the offence.
5.9.
The
order
granting
regular
bail
was
passed
after
the
chargesheet had already been filed on 17.04.2026. This shows that
the Court was aware that investigation was complete and the
prosecution material was already on record. No fresh circumstance
has been shown to indicate that Respondent No.2 has misused the
liberty granted to him after being released on bail.
5.10. It is a settled position of law that bail once granted should
not be cancelled lightly. Cancellation is justified only when there
are strong reasons such as misuse of liberty, attempt to influence
witnesses, tampering with evidence, likelihood of absconding, or
similar conduct. At the same time, the Court can interfere if the
order granting bail suffers from serious legal or factual error.
5.11.
In
the
present
case,
considering
the
role
attributed
to
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
Respondent No.2, the fact that he is not an employee of the
complainant company, the absence of any allegation of involvement
in preparation or approval of bills, the nature of allegation limited
to use of his bank account, the completion of investigation, and
filing of chargesheet, this Court does not find any new or strong
ground to cancel the bail already granted.
5.12. The allegations are no doubt serious and involve a large
amount of money. However, seriousness alone is not enough to
cancel bail, especially when investigation is complete and there is
no material showing misuse of liberty. The questions regarding his
knowledge, intention, and connection with other accused will be
decided during trial.
5.14
It is further pertinent to note that it was never the
case of the prosecution that the presence of the respondent–
accused was required for any further investigation.
5.15
The learned trial Court, while granting bail, imposed
stringent conditions to secure his presence and ensure that the
investigation and trial were not prejudiced. Significantly, since the
date of grant of bail, no untoward incident has been reported.
5.15
Moreover, it is not the case of the present applicant–
original complainant that the respondent–accused has, at any point
of time, tampered with the evidence, attempted to influence or
intimidate witnesses, obstructed the course of justice, or committed
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
breach of any of the conditions imposed while granting bail. In
the absence of any such supervening circumstance or material
demonstrating misuse of liberty by the respondent–accused, the
present application seeking cancellation of bail appears to have
been filed merely on the basis of conjectures and apprehensions,
which cannot constitute a valid ground for cancellation of bail in
law.
5.16
Upon a careful examination of the findings recorded
and the conclusions arrived at by the learned Judge, this Court
finds that all the relevant facts and circumstances of the case
have been duly considered. The impugned order reflects proper
application
of
mind
to
the
material
available
on
record,
and
detailed as well as cogent reasons have been assigned by the
learned Judge while passing the said order. This Court does not
find any perversity, illegality, or infirmity in the reasoning adopted
by the learned Trial Court warranting interference.
5.17
It
is
well
settled
that
the
parameters
governing
rejection of a bail application at the initial stage and cancellation
of bail already granted by a competent Court are distinct and
operate in different
spheres. Once bail has been granted, its
cancellation can be justified only upon the existence of cogent and
overwhelming circumstances, such as misuse of liberty by the
accused or the emergence of supervening circumstances warranting
such cancellation.
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
5.18
In
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
the
present
case,
the
learned
advocate
for
the
applicant has failed to point out any supervening circumstance
that has arisen subsequent to the grant of bail. Furthermore, it is
not
even
the
case
of
the
applicant
and
the
State
that
the
respondent–accused has misused the liberty granted by the Court,
breached any of the conditions imposed, tampered with evidence,
influenced witnesses, or otherwise acted in a manner prejudicial to
the fair conduct of the proceedings. In the absence of any such
material, no case is made out for cancellation of the bail granted
by the competent Court.
5.19
In the case of P. Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh &
Anr., reported in (2022) SCC Online SC 552, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court
has enumerated
the
circumstances,
when
bail
could
be
canceled and one of the conditions stated therein is the misuse of
the liberty granted to the accused concerned by the Court by
involving himself in a subsequent crime.
5.20
Further, it would be fruitful to refer to the decision of
the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Ajwar Vs. Waseem reported
in 2024 INSC 438, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed
that the same Court which granted bail to an accused can cancel
the bail if there are serious allegations against him, even if the
accused has not misused the bail. If there are serious allegations
against the accused, even if he has not misused the bail granted
to him, such an order can be canceled. However, once bail is
granted, it ought not to be canceled in a mechanical manner. An
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
unreasonable or perverse order of bail may invite
interference by the Apex Court. Personal liberty is one of the
cherished Constitutional freedoms, and once bail is granted during
the pendency of the trial, it must only be retracted in the face of
grave
circumstances.
The
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
the
decision, in paragraphs 27 and 28, has observed as under :
“27.
The considerations that weigh with
the appellate Court for setting aside the
bail order on an application being moved
by
the
aggrieved
party
include
any
supervening circumstances that may have
occurred
after
granting
relief
to
the
accused, the conduct of the accused while
on bail, any attempt on the part of the
accused
to
procrastinate,
resulting
in
delaying the trial, any instance of threats
being extended to the witnesses while on
bail,
any
attempt
on
the
part
of
the
accused to tamper with the evidence in any
manner. We may add that this list is only
illustrative
and
not exhaustive.
However,
the court must be cautious that at the
stage of granting bail, only a prima facie
case needs to be examined and detailed
reasons relating to the merits of the case
that may cause prejudice to the accused,
said
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
ought to be avoided. Suffice it is to state
that
the
bail
order
should
reveal
the
factors that have been considered by the
Court for granting relief to the accused.
28.
In
Jagjeet
Singh
(supra),
a
three-
Judges bench of this Court, has observed
that the power to grant bail under Section
439 Cr.P.C is of wide amplitude and the
High Court or a Sessions Court, as the
case may be, is bestowed with considerable
discretion while deciding an [2024] 5 S.C.R.
Ajwar
v.
Waseem
and
Another
application for bail. But this discretion is
not
unfettered.
reflect
due
The
order
application
of
passed
must
judicial
mind
following well established principles of law.
In ordinary course, courts would be slow to
interfere with the order where bail has
been granted by the courts below. But if it
is found that such an order is illegal or
perverse or based upon utterly irrelevant
material, the appellate Court would be well
within its power to set aside and cancel
the bail.”
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
5.21
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
In the case of Gurcharan Singh and others Vs. State
(Delhi Administration), reported in (1978) 1 SCC 118, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court had an occasion to observe that the concept of
setting aside the unjustified, illegal or perverse order is totally
different from the concept of canceling the bail on the ground that
the accused has misconducted himself or because of some new
facts are requiring such cancellation. In Paragraph No.16, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court Court has observed as under :
"16. Section 439 of the new Code confers
special powers on High Court or Court of
Session regarding bail. This was also the
position under Section 498 CrPC of the old
Code. That is to say, even if a Magistrate
refuses to grant bail to an accused person,
the High Court or the Court of Session
may order for grant of bail in appropriate
cases. Similarly under Section 439(2) of the
new Code, the High Court or the Court of
Session may direct any person who has
been released on bail to be arrested and
committed to custody.
Section
498(2) was
different
language
In the old Code,
worded
when
it
in
somewhat
said
that
a
High Court or Court of Session may cause
any person who has been admitted to bail
under sub-section (1) to be arrested and
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
may
commit
words,
under
him
to
Section
custody.
In
498(2)
the
of
other
old
Code, a person who had been admitted to
bail by the High Court could be committed
to
custody
only
by
the
High
Court.
Similarly, if a person was admitted to bail
by a Court of Session, it was only the
Court of Session that could commit him to
custody. This restriction upon the power of
entertainment
of
an
application
for
committing a person, already admitted to
bail, to custody, is lifted in the new Code
under Section 439(2). Under Section 439(2)
of the new Code a High Court may commit
a person released on bail under Chapter
XXXIII by any Court including the Court
of
Session
to
custody,
if
it
thinks
appropriate to do so. It must, however, be
made clear that a Court of Session cannot
cancel
granted
a
bail
which
has
already
been
by the
High
Court
unless
new
circumstances arise during the progress of
the trial after an accused person has been
admitted to bail by the High Court. If,
however, a Court of Session had admitted
an accused person to bail, the State has
two
options.
It
may
move
the
Sessions
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
Judge if certain new circumstances have
arisen which were not earlier known to the
State
and
necessarily,
therefore,
to
that
Court. The State may as well approach the
High Court being the superior Court under
Section 439(2) to commit the accused to
custody.
When,
however,
aggrieved
by
order
the
the
of
State
the
is
Sessions
Judge granting bail and there are no new
circumstances that have cropped up except
those already existed, it is futile for the
State to move the Sessions Judge again
and it is competent in law to move the
High Court for cancellation of the bail.
This position follows from the subordinate
position of the Court of Session vis-a-vis
the High Court."
5.22
The
aforesaid
observations
made
by
the
Hon'ble
Supreme Court has been reiterated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in the case of Puran Vs. Rambilas & Anr., reported in (2001) 6
SCC 338 as well as in case of Abdul Basit alias Raju & Ors. Vs.
Mohd. Abdul Kadir Cahudhary & Anr., reported in (2014) 10 SCC
754.
5.23
In the case of Ranjit Singh Vs. State of M.P., reported
in (2013) 16 SCC 797, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
under in Para-19 :
"19. It needs no special emphasis to state
that
there
is
distinction
parameters
for
grant
cancellation
of
bail.
between
the
bail
and
of
There
is
also
a
distinction between the concept of setting
aside
an
unjustified,
illegal
or
perverse
order and cancellation of an order of bail
on
the
ground
that
the
accused
has
misconducted himself or certain supervening
circumstances warrant such cancellation. If
the order granting bail is a perverse one
or passed on irrelevant materials, it can be
annulled by the superior court. We have
already referred to various paragraphs of
the order passed by the High Court. We
have already held that the learned trial
Judge has undefined misconstrued the order
passed by the High Court. However, we
may hasten to add that the learned Single
Judge
has
supervening
taken
note
circumstances
of
to
certain
cancel
the
bail, but we are of the opinion that in the
obtaining factual matrix the said exercise
was not necessary as the grant of bail was
absolutely
illegal
and
unjustified
as
the
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
court below had enlarged the accused on
bail on the strength of the order passed in
Ranjeet Singh v. State of M.P. [Ranjeet
Singh v. State of M.P., MCRC No. 701 of
2013,
order
dated
1-
2-2013
(MP)]
remaining oblivious of the parameters for
grant of bail under Section 439 CrPC. It is
well
settled
though
in
involves
law
that
exercise
grant
of
of
bail
discretionary
power of the court, yet the said exercise
has to be made in a judicious manner and
not as a matter of course."
5.24
At this juncture, the observations made by the Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
Haryana,
reported
recollected.
It
was
Dolat Ram & Ors. Vs. State of
case
of
in
1995(1)
observed
SCC
therein
349,
that
is
required
very
to
cogent
be
and
overwhelming circumstances are necessary for an order directing
the cancellation of the bail already granted. The grounds for
cancellation of bail though are broad, but illustrative and not
exhaustive; are interference or attempt to interfere with the due
course of administration of justice or evasion or attempt to evade
the due course of justice or abuse of the concession granted to the
accused in any manner. The Court should satisfy for availability of
the grounds for satisfying of the bail or cancellation of the bail
and one of the possibility is accused being absconded. The bail
once granted, should not in a mechanical manner, without any
R/CR.MA/18928/2026
grounds,
or
supervening
CAV ORDER DATED: 20/08/2026
circumstance,
which
affects
the
very
principle of fair trial be cancelled.
5.25
In the present case, the impugned order passed by the
learned Trial Court is founded upon sound legal principles and is
supported by cogent and well-reasoned findings. This Court finds
no infirmity, perversity, or illegality in the said order so as to
warrant interference in exercise of its jurisdiction.
6.
Thus, in view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances,
this Court is of the considered opinion that the applicant has
failed to make out any case warranting interference with the
impugned order granting bail in favour of the respondent–accused.
No sufficient grounds, reasons, or supervening circumstances have
been brought on record so as to justify cancellation of bail or to
persuade this Court to take a different view than that taken by
the learned Trial Court.
7.
Accordingly, the present application is rejected. Rule is
discharged.
(SANJEEV J.THAKER,J)
URIL RANA
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review