Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:22444
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 17474 of 2025
Decided on: 16.06.2026.
…..Petitioner
Rajesh Kumar
Versus
State of H.P and others
..Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. T.S. Chauhan, Senior
Advocate with Ms. Abhilasha
Bhardwaj, Advocate.
For the Respondents:
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate
General
with
Mr.
Rajat
Choudhry, Assistant Advocate
General.
------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Petitioner’s
name
was
registered
in
the
respondent- Department of Labour and Employment with
specific registration No.20090110919. Over period of
time,
petitioner’s
aforesaid
registration
had
been
renewed. However, in the last renewal carried out on
10.02.2025, the date of registration of the petitioner was
mentioned as 10.02.2025. According to the petitioner, his
date of registration should have been reflected as
17.06.2021
i.e.
when
he
improved
his
educational
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
2026:HHC:22444
qualifications
and was accordingly registered as such
with the respondent department on 17.06.2021.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and
considered the case file.
3.
There
is
no
dispute
that
respondent
department had registered petitioner’s name as Exserviceman
vide
N.C.O.571.30
SD
improved
his
registration
01.09.2020.
educational
No.20090110919,
Petitioner
qualifications
thereafter
and
his
registration under the same registration number was
accordingly renewed on 17.06.2021 with next date of
renewal assigned as June, 2024. Petitioner, however, did
not get his registration
renewed within the stipulated
time period. Petitioner got his name registered again in
the office of
respondent No.3 on 10.02.2025. The
respondent department considered this registration as
new registration though assigned
him the same old
registration number. In view of respondents’ treating
petitioner’s
registration
on
10.02.2025
as
fresh
registration, the petitioner lost his seniority of about three
years. Feeling aggrieved, he has instituted this writ
petition seeking directions to the respondents to mention
his date of registration as 17.06.2021
10.02.2025.
instead of
2026:HHC:22444
4.
For assigning 10.02.2025 as fresh registration
date of the petitioner, the respondents in their reply have
fallen back upon Clause 7.32 of the National Employment
Service Manual and submitted that petitioner should have
been diligent in keeping track of date of lapse of his
registration; He should have applied for renewal of
registration within the prescribed time limit of three years
with two months grace period. The said clause reads as
under:“Renewal of Registration
7.32 The renewal period will be of 3 years
uniformly for all types of applicants. The
registrants will be allowed to renew their
registration in person or by prepaid post on any
working day or by online method during the
period of three months of registration namely the
month in which renewal falls due and following
two months.
Note: In case of job-seekers whose renewal
of registration is going to lapse within the next six
months,
a
regular
reminder
through
email/sms/mobile phone/by post should be sent,
at least once in a month, to the job-seekers for
updating
their
profile/
renewal
of
their
registration. This would help the job-seekers to
avoid the problems arising due to lapsing of their
registration due to non-renewal in due time.”
No doubt, it was incumbent upon the petitioner
to have applied for renewal of his registration number
within the stipulated period, however, at the same time, it
cannot be ignored that in terms of note to Clause 7.32
extracted above, it was also the responsibility of the
2026:HHC:22444
respondents to have sent reminder through E-mail/SMS/
mobile phone/by post to the petitioner for updating his
profile/ renewal of his registration. Admittedly, such
recourse was not adopted by the respondents in the
instant case.
Learned Assistant Advocate General also relied
upon following Clause 7.35 of the Manual to contend that
for petitioner’s not applying for renewal within the
permissible period, his registration card has to be treated
as lapsed and removed from Live Register to be placed in
the Dead Register; Therefore, petitioner is not entitled for
registration w.e.f. 17.06.2021; That
respondents were
justified in treating petitioner’s registration afresh w.e.f.
10.02.2025 when he had applied for renewal of his
registration as petitioner’s previous registration w.e.f.
17.06.2021 would constitute dead registration. The said
clause reads as under:“Lapsing of Index Cards
7.35 The registration card should be
reviewed for lapsing in the first week of the fourth
month following the month of registration. For
example, registration card prepared in the month
of January, will be removed from the Live Register
in the first week of April. Such lapsed cards will be
retained separately for two months. This will
constitute the Dead Register.”
In the instant case, while considering the
petitioner’s application for renewal of his registration,
2026:HHC:22444
respondents have assigned the same registration number
to the petitioner on 10.02.2025 as was assigned to him on
17.06.2021.
The
respondents
have
themselves
not
treated the registration number of the petitioner dated
10.02.2025 as dead registration. Petitioner’s registration
number has been kept alive. Object behind renewal of
registration
in employment exchange is also to have
database of those who have not yet been provided
suitable employment and are still interested in seeking
employment through the aegis of respondent- Labour &
Employment department. It is not the case of the
respondents
that
petitioner
had
been
employed
somewhere else during the period his registration had not
been renewed.
The instructions placed on record at Annexure
P-5 pertaining to registration have not been disputed by
the respondents. In terms of these instructions, more
specifically with the heading “online renewal”, provision
has made even for condoning the delay in not applying for
renewal
in
interpretation
time
though
according
of
aforesaid
to
respondents’
instructions,
registration
cannot be renewed after the assigned date of renewal and
certainly not beyond the grace period. Be that as it may,
2026:HHC:22444
instructions would not carry the same binding force as is
available to a statute.
For the petitioner, reliance has also been
placed upon N.K. Puran Singh versus State of H.P
and others2. In the aforesaid case, the petitioner therein
had applied for the post of police constable (reserved for
Ex-serviceman). His candidature was rejected by the
Interviewing Board on the ground that he had been
registered with the employment exchange in the year
2010. His registration was not
renewed within the
permissible period. Petitioner’s name
was
registered
afresh with the employment exchange on 26.11.2013.
The respondents therein reckoned petitioner’s seniority
w.e.f. 26.11.2013 i.e. fresh date of registration. This
action was not countenanced by the Hon’ble Division
Bench. Allowing the petitioner his seniority w.e.f. the year
2010, it was held that:“The apt and germane rules, enjoining upon
the petitioner the necessity of his after his initial
registration in the year 2010 with the employment
exchange concerned getting it renewed for
maintaining his seniority, absence whereof
forbidding and interdicting the petitioner from
participating in the interview for the post
concerned to be filled up amongst others by Exservicemen, have not been placed on record. For
lack of adduction of apt and relevant rules by the
respondents with a disclosure therein that the
CWP No.458/2015, decided on 17.04.2015.
2026:HHC:22444
petitioner even when he got himself registered
with the employment exchange concerned in the
year 2010 there was an enjoined legal obligation
cast upon him to get his registration renewed for
fastening seniority qua registration, fillips hence an
inference that omission, if any, on his part to
obtain renewal of his registration did not strip him
of his seniority to be reckonable hence from 2010.
Consequently, the ground as meted out by the
respondents of his having not produced the record/
endorsement of his maintaining his seniority after
his initial registration with the employment
exchange concerned, rendering his candidature to
be dis-cardable as well as prohibiting him to
participate in the interview, is wholly un-tenable as
well as flimsy rather his seniority is to be computed
from the year 2010 when he initially got himself
registered with the employment exchange even
without his having produced any record before the
interviewing board qua the factum of his having
maintained his seniority with the employment
exchange concerned. Besides, the lack of omission
of production by the petitioner of his X-10 card
registered with the employment exchange
concerned before the said selection committee
though is contended to be a ground for rejection of
his candidature, it also is an entirely pretextual
ground in as much as given the fact of his
sponsorship by the employment exchange
concerned which would not have occurred unless
his name stood registered with the employment
exchange concerned, besides its hence fastening a
legitimate claim for his consideration for selection
by the interviewing board, dispels the effect, if any,
of the omission on his part to produce his X-10 card
registered on 18.11.2010. In view of above, the
present petition is allowed. The respondents are
hence directed to consider the candidature of the
petitioner by subjecting him to an interview by a
duly constituted interviewing board and in case he
stands selected, then he shall be, in accordance
with rules, appointed .against a vacancy occuring
in future. All pending applications stand disposed
of.”
2026:HHC:22444
Ratio of above decision is applicable to the
facts of instant case as well.
5.
For the foregoing, this writ petition is allowed.
The respondents are directed to
registration
of
petitioner
10.02.2025
mentioned
as
in
assign the date of
17.06.2021
Annexure
instead
P-4.
of
Pending
miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
June 16, 2026
yogesh
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review