Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
RSA 54/2026, CM APPL. 18104/2026 (under Order XLI Rule 5 CPC)
.....Appellants
RAJESH AGGARWAL
S/O SH. SITA RAM AGGARWAL
SITA RAM AGGARWAL
S/O LATE SH. P. C. AGGARWAL
BOTH R/O C-17, SATYAWATI COLONY,
ASHOK VIHAR PHASE 3,
DELHI-110052
Through:
Appearance not given
VERSUS
.....Respondent
VIJAY KUMAR
S/O SH. MOHAN SINGH
R/O HOUSE NO 1119
GALI NO 11, SADAR NALA ROAD
HOSHIYAR SINGH MARG
DELHI-110006
Through: None
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
ORDER
23.03.2026
%
CM APPL.
(Exemption)
18105/2026
(Exemption),
CM
APPL.
1.
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The Application stands disposed of.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
18106/2026
CM APPL. 18107/2026 (under Section 5 of Limitation Act on behalf of the
Appellant for Condonation of Delay of One Day in filing the Appeal)
CM APPL.18108/2026 (under Section 5 of the Limitation Act on behalf of
the Appellant for Condonation of Delay of 100 days in re-filing the Appeal)
3.
The above two Applications have been filed on behalf of the
Appellant seeking Condonation of 1 day‟s delay in filing the Appeal and
Condonation of 100 days‟ delay in re-filing the Appeal.
4.
For the reasons stated in the Applications, the delay of 1 day in filing
the Appeal and delay of 100 days in re-filing the Appeal is condoned.
5.
Both the Applications are allowed and stand disposed of accordingly.
RSA 54/2026:
6.
Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 read with Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟) has
been filed on behalf of the Appellants against the Judgment and Decree
dated 20.08.2025, of the learned Senior Civil Judge, upholding
the
Judgement and Decree dated 07.10.2024 of the learned Civil Judge, whereby
the Suit of the Respondent / Plaintiff, was decreed and the Respondent /
Plaintiff was declared as owner of the Suit Property and held entitled
for Recovery of Arrears of Rent @Rs.40/- per month.
7.
The Respondent / Plaintiff Vijay Kumar had filed a Suit bearing No.
1262/2017 for Declaration, Permanent Injunction and Recovery of Arrears
of Rent.
8.
The brief facts as narrated by the Respondent / Plaintiff, are that he
had purchased the Suit Property i.e., Shop bearing No. 6033-6034, ad
measuring 32.22 square yards, Basti Harphool Singh, Sadar Nala Road,
Hoshiyar Sigh Marg, Delhi-110006 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Suit
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
Property’) from one Shri Deepak, son of Dilbagh Singh, through a
registered Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016. Shri Deepak had handed over to him
the entire chain of documents of the erstwhile owners.
9.
In the Sale Deed, it was clearly mentioned that Defendant No. 1
Rajesh Aggarwal was a tenant in the Suit Property, on a monthly rent of
Rs.40/-. It was further specified that the Plaintiff shall be entitled to receive
the rent from Defendant No.1 Shri Deepak from whom the Suit Property
was purchased, had also addressed the Letter dated 20.12.2016 to Defendant
No.1 requesting him to pay the rent to the Plaintiff, in respect of the Suit
Property w.e.f. 20.12.2016. The Plaintiff claimed that despite receiving the
Letter, the Defendant No.1 failed to pay the rent to the Plaintiff, from
01.01.2017 and is in arrears of rent.
10.
The Plaintiff after purchasing the Suit Property, paid the Mutation Fee
and got the Suit Property mutated in his name in the records of the North
Delhi Municipal Corporation, on the basis of the Sale Deed. Thereafter, the
Plaintiff cleared the arrears of House Tax amounting to Rs.32,373/-, on
03.01.2017.
11.
The Plaintiff’s counsel issued Legal Notice dated 31.01.2017 which
was served upon Defendant No.1 Rajesh Aggarwal with a request to pay the
arrears of rent from 01.01.2017 till 28.02.2017 @ Rs.40/- per month and
thereafter, from 01.03.2017 @ Rs.44/- excluding electricity and water
charges.
12.
The Defendant No.1 / Rajesh Aggarwal replied through Letter dated
15.02.2017, claiming that Defendant No.2 Sita Ram Aggarwal, father of
Defendant No.1 Rajesh Aggarwal, was the owner of the Suit Property since
more than the last twenty years and was enjoying ownership rights, having
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
purchased the Suit Property from Smt. Suchint Kumari, wife of Late Shri
Nanak Chand.
13.
The Plaintiff explained that Shri Deepak, his predecessor in interest,
had purchased the property from Shri Vikram Grover, legal heir of Smt.
Suchint Kumari, who had died intestate on 10.07.2004. Her other legal
heirs, namely (i) Smt. Vimmi Grover, wife of Shri Parveen Juneja and
daughter of late Shri Nanak Chand, (ii) Smt. Jyoti Devi, wife of Shri Parmod
Sehgal and daughter of late Shri Nanak Chand, and (iii) Shri Pankaj, son of
Shri Nanak Chand, and late Smt. Suchint Kumari, had executed
Relinquishment Deed dated 06.08.2011, in favour of Shri Vikram Grover
son of late Shri Nanak Chand and Smt. Suchint Kumari.
14.
It was asserted that the Defendant No.2 Sita Ram Aggarwal had no
right and title in the Suit Property. That Defendant No.1 and 2 in collusion
with each other, intended to usurp the Suit Property of the Plaintiff. The
Defendants had also threatened to create third party rights in the Suit
Property and to sell it to some builder and involve the Plaintiff in false and
fabricated cases.
15.
The Plaintiff thus, filed a Suit for Declaration of being the owner of
the Suit Property; Recovery of Arrears of Rent and to restrain the
Defendants from creating a third party right in the Suit Property.
16.
The Suit was contested by the Defendants / Appellants, who in their
Written Statement, took the defence that the Defendant No.1 Rajesh
Aggarwal had no concern with the Suit Property and that the Suit was liable
to be dismissed. It was further claimed that there was no relationship of a
landlord and tenant between the Plaintiff and Defendants, and that the Suit
was not maintainable.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
17.
It was denied that the Plaintiff was the owner and in possession of the
Suit Property or that he had purchased the Suit Property from Shri Deepak,
vide a registered Sale Deed.
18.
The Appellants / Defendants took a defence that the title documents /
Sale Deed in favour of the Plaintiff, are false and fabricated. It was claimed
that previously, Defendant No.2 Sita Ram had been inducted as a tenant in
the Suit Property, by deceased Jagannath, son of Shri Moti Ram. After his
death, the Suit Property was sold by his son, Badrinath to Smt. Suchint
Kumari by virtue of registered Sale Deed dated 02.07.1982. Defendant No.2
Sita Ram, thus, became the tenant of Smt. Suchint Kumari, a fact which was
very much in the knowledge of the Plaintiff.
19.
The Defendant No.1, Rajesh Aggarwal admitted that he had duly
responded to the Legal Notice sent by the Respondent, to inform him that he
had no tenancy rights in the Suit Property and in fact, his father Defendant
No.2 Sita Ram was the owner, since last more than 20 years.
20.
The Defendant No.1 thus, asserted that there existed no relationship
of landlord-tenant between him and the Plaintiff and that his father
Defendant No.2 Sita Ram, who had been initially inducted in the property as
a tenant, had subsequently purchased the property from Smt. Suchint
Kumari for a sale consideration of Rs.40,000/-, through GPA, Agreement to
Sell, Will, and Receipt, all dated 18.11.1994.
21.
The Defendants / Appellants further asserted that the Plaintiff was not
in possession of any valid Sale Deed, and that it was a manipulated
document which had no value in the eyes of law. Smt. Suchint Kumari had
already sold the property to Defendant No.2 Shri Sita Ram, by executing
sale documents dated 18.11.1994. The Defendants denied that they were in
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
arrears of rent and asserted that the Suit of the Plaintiff was liable to be
dismissed.
22.
The Plaintiff in his Replication, re-affirmed the assertions as made in
the Plaint.
23.
The Issues on the pleadings were framed on 20.07.2018, as under :
“(1.)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the decree of
injunction, as prayed for? OPP
(2)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the decree of
declaration, as prayed for? OPP
(3.)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of
arrears of rent @ Rs.40/- since 01.01.2017 till
28.02.2017 and @ Rs.44/- since 01.03.2017 and future
rent from defendant No.1? OPP
(4.)
Whether there is no relationship between the
plaintiff and defendants as landlord and tenant? OPD
(5.)
Relief.”
24.
The Plaintiff in support of his case, examined himself as PW-1 and
proved his documents.
25.
The DW-1 Rajesh Aggarwal, Defendant No.1, and DW-2 Sita Ram
Aggarwal, Defendant No.2, deposed in support of their case and produced
the photocopies of the notarized GPA, Agreement to Sell, Receipt, and Will,
all dated 18.11.1994 in support of their defence.
26.
The learned Civil Judge relied upon the Judgment of the Supreme
Court in Suraj Lamps and Industries P. Ltd. vs. State of Haryana, (2009) 7
SCC 363, (2012) 1 SCC 656, to observe that the Agreement to Sell, etc.
aside from being unregistered documents, did not confer any ownership or
title in the Suit Property on Defendant No.2. On the other hand, the Plaintiff
had the Sale Deed Ex.PW1/2 and the registered Relinquishment Deed
Ex.PW1/11 in favour of Vikram Grover, legal heir of Smt. Suchint Kumari.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
It was thus, held that the Plaintiff was the owner of the Suit Property.
27.
Furthermore, reference was made to the Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016
wherein it was clearly recorded that Defendant No.1 Rajesh Aggarwal was a
tenant @ Rs.40/- per month.
It was thus, held that there existed a
relationship of landlord-tenant between the Plaintiff and the Defendants.
28.
Consequently, the Suit of the Plaintiff was decreed and the Plaintiff
was
declared
as
the
owner
of
the
Suit
Property
and
the
Defendants/Appellants were restrained from creating third party rights.
Moreover, the recovery of arrears of rent @ Rs.40/- per month from
01.01.2017 were directed to be paid by Defendant No.1 Rajesh Aggarwal
till he was in occupation of the Suit Property.
29.
The RCA No. 27/2024 was filed by the Defendants / Appellants
before the Court of learned Senior Civil Judge, who vide the Impugned
Judgment dated 20.08.2025, upheld the Order dated 07.10.2024 of the
learned Civil Judge and also dismissed the Application under Order 41 Rule
27 CPC that had been filed by the Respondents, for placing additional
documents on record.
30.
Aggrieved by the dismissal of the Appeal, the present Regular
Second Appeal, has been filed.
31.
The grounds of challenge by the Appellants are that the most crucial
fact to be proved by the Plaintiff was the existence of relationship of
landlord-tenant between himself and Defendant No.1. The learned Trial
Court has erroneously relied upon the Sale Deed in favour of the Plaintiff.
32.
In the case of Ramji Dayawala and Sons (Pvt.) Ltd. vs. Invest Import,
(1981) 1 SCC 80 it has been held that mere proof of a document’s
handwriting or execution, does not, by itself, establish the truth of the facts
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
stated therein.
33.
Ld. Counsel for Appellant has submitted that when the veracity of the
document’s contents is in question, those facts must be proved
independently, through admissible evidence from persons capable of
attesting to their truth.
34.
Reliance is also placed on Union of India vs. Ibraim Uddin and Anr.
(2012) 8 SCC 148, wherein reference was made to Section 90 of the Indian
Evidence Act in respect of 30 years old documents produced from proper
custody with due signatures, execution and attestation, to observe that the
contents of such a document to be true or had been acted upon, has to be
proved like any other fact.
35.
The Defendants / Appellants stated that the Sale Deed in question, is a
bilateral document having averments about some third party and cannot be
used against such third party.
36.
It is asserted that Defendant No.2 is the owner of the Suit Property
and there is no relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties. It
has been erroneously observed that the sale documents have not been proved
by the Defendants when in fact, Mark-PX-1 is the Sale Deed in favour of
Smt. Suchint Kumari which also forms part of chain documents of Plaintiff
and he claims to have the originals in his possession.
37.
It was the Plaintiff in fact, who was required to prove these
documents. In these documents, it is clearly mentioned that Defendant No.2
was a tenant in the said documents.
38.
Additionally, the Plaintiff in his deposition dated 16.02.2019 and
25.09.2019, had unequivocally admitted in his cross-examination that
Defendant No.2 Shri Sita Ram Aggarwal is the tenant in the Suit Property.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
In light of these facts and circumstances, the Trial Court should have taken
an adverse inference against the Plaintiff for concealing material facts, but
these facts have been misconstrued against the Defendants.
39.
It is further stated that the Trial Court failed in understanding the
defence of the Defendants that a presumption existed in favour of a duly
registered document under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, and that it is
presumed that official acts are performed in a proper and regular manner
under Section 114, illustration-e of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
40.
That the Trial Court had further failed in considering that the
Defendants had not pleaded that the document was not executed, presented
or registered. Rather, their defence was that since Smt. Suchint Kumari had
already sold the property vide Agreement to Sale, GPA, etc. all dated
18.11.1994, no further sale could have been made in favour of the
subsequent purchasers or the Plaintiff.
41.
The learned Trial Court’s has erroneously made the observation that
there was no doubt or suspicion created by the Defendants in respect of the
genuineness, authenticity and validity of the Relinquishment Deed, or that
the Defendants could not object to further sale of the property by Mr.
Vikram Grover to Sh. Deepak and thereafter, to the Plaintiff.
42.
The Defendants further stated that the genuineness, authenticity or
validity had nothing to do with the right, title or interest and authority of the
person executing the documents which were in question.
43.
The Defendants thus, contended that it was erroneously observed by
the learned Civil Judge that the defence of Defendant No.2, of being the
owner in the Suit Property, is meritless and holds no water, with reliance
being placed on Section 17 and 49 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 and
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
the judgements in Suraj Lamp & Industries P. Ltd. (supra); Bishan Chand
vs. Ved Prakash, 2018 SCC OnLine Del 11408; and Shakeel Ahmed vs. Syed
Akhlaq Hussain 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1526.
44.
That the learned Trial Court failed to take into account that neither
these judgments nor Section 17 or 49 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908
lay down that a Will is required to be registered or that a Will which is not
registered, cannot be received in evidence even after the demise of the
testator. The existence of a Will, reflects that Smt. Suchint Kumari had not
died intestate, but had executed the Will, despite which, this aspect has not
been considered.
45.
The circumstances that the documents of Title, were filed by the
Defendants, clearly created a doubt on the title of the Plaintiff. Though it
was claimed that Smt. Suchint Kumari issued Rent Receipts from 1982 to
1994, but the same had not been placed on record.
46.
The finding that upon a specific query during cross-examination, the
Defendant No.2 Sita Ram Aggarwal was unable to name the children of
Smt. Suchint Kumari, is highly immaterial.
47.
Furthermore, the assumptions and presumptions drawn by the two
learned Courts, are incorrect for the simple reason that the stamp papers on
which documents had been executed in favour of the Plaintiff, are from Sr.
No. 2710 till 2712, issued in favour of Smt. Suchint Kumari, on 18.11.1994.
The name of the Stamp Vendor Naresh Kumar, License No.317 is mentioned
and the place of issue is Kashmere Gate, Delhi. The seal of Notary Public is
that of M.S Mehta Notary which bears his signatures, which is ascertainable.
48.
Once the Defendant No.2 had become the owner, there was no
requirement of him keeping the Rent Receipts from 1982 to 1994. Some of
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
the Rent Receipts have been filed by the Defendants in Appeal along with
Application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, though the Application was
dismissed. Furthermore, it is not in dispute that the Defendant No.2 has
been in possession of the Suit Property since long.
There was no
requirement to prove this fact, when it was an admitted fact.
49.
Furthermore, the Sale Deed from Badrinath to Suchint Kumari,
clearly mentions that the Defendant No.2 was the tenant @ Rs.35/- and had
been instructed to pay the rent to Suchint Kumari. The Mutation does not
create or extinguish any rights in the property. The impugned Judgment
granting
Permanent
Injunction
or
declaring
that
the
Plaintiff/Respondent is the owner, is not substantiated on the facts of
the case.
50.
It was incumbent upon the Plaintiff to seek Declaration in respect of
Will dated 18.11.1994 as Null and Void, prior to claiming a Declaration of
ownership. He was under an obligation to take one or more objections
available under the Indian Succession Act. The genuineness of the Will in
terms of Indian Succession Act, has not been judged.
51.
The Plaintiff was required to prove the Relinquishment Deed dated
05.08.2011, which has not been proved. The succession of the estate of
Smt. Suchint Kumari, took place as per Section 15 of the Hindu Succession
Act and it would have been succeeded by her husband, sons and daughters,
in equal share of 1/5th each. There is nothing to show that Nanak Chand
died intestate, as it has not even been mentioned in the pleadings. The
necessary particulars whether the mother of Shri Nanak Chand, had died or
not, has also not been mentioned, because 1/5th share of Shri Nanak Chand
in the Suit Property of Suchint Kumari, would then have been inherited by
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
the mother. Moreover, there are other legal heirs/successors of Shri Nanak
Chand, namely, Vimmi, Jyoti, Vikram and Pankaj.
52.
It is asserted that none can claim a title better than what he himself
has, which principle is recognized in various judgments including P.
Kishore Kumar vs. Vittal K. Patkar, Civil Appeal No.7210 of 2011, decided
on 20.11.2023, wherein it was observed by the Supreme Court that a vendor
cannot transfer a title to the vendee, better than he himself.
53.
Since Smt. Suchint Kumari did not die intestate but had executed a
Will; Vimmi, Jyoti, Vikram and Pankaj did not inherit anything.
The
Relinquishment Deed dated 06.08.2011 was a document executed without
any right, title and no right could have been created in favour of the
Plaintiff.
54.
Furthermore, the learned Trial Court failed to read the judgment of
Suraj Lamps & Industries P. Ltd. (supra), in its correct context. Reliance is
also placed on Bishan Chand (supra).
55.
It is further stated that the Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016, it is
mentioned that the Defendant No.1 is a tenant in the property. However,
how can this Sale Deed be believed wherein it has also been stated that
Vendor has handed over physical and peaceful vacant possession to the
Vendee and that the same had been taken on the spot.
56.
The monthly rent of the property in fact, as per Sale Deed dated
02.07.1982 was Rs.35/- per month, while the learned Trial Court has
wrongly concluded the rent to be Rs.40/- per month as per Sale Deed dated
20.12.2016. As per the Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016, the tax liability of the
Respondent/Plaintiff started only after 20.12.2016 when he had purchased
the property, but it was stated in the Plaint that the Plaintiff has cleared all
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
the arrears of House Tax vide Receipt dated 03.01.2017 amounting to
Rs.32,373/-. The House Tax cannot be for a period subsequent to the Sale
Deed i.e., for the period from 27.12.2016 to 03.01.2017. The liability to pay
House Tax upto 05.07.2013, was upon Vikram Grover. These facts have
been completely overlooked by the learned Trial Court. Even otherwise, the
reference to deposit of House Tax, was irrelevant to establish the ownership
in the Suit Property.
57.
The Civil Courts are not a post office to receive and conceive any
document, pleading and hypothesis offered by a Plaintiff, who has
approached the Court for a relief. The Plaintiff’s case has to stand on its own
legs.
58.
The Defendant No.1 is mentioned as a tenant in the Sale Deed
executed by Deepak, but these facts had not been mentioned in the Sale
Deed of Badrinath through which Deepak had eventually purchased the
property.
59.
A Letter dated 20.12.2016 had been issued by Deepak to Defendant
No.1, but this Letter also did not mention that Defendant No.1, is a tenant.
This Letter stated that Defendant No.1 shall be paying rent to Vijay Kumar
from the date of letter itself i.e., 20.12.2016 which means the Defendant
No.1 must have paid the rent till 19.12.2016. However, there is no mention
of this fact and the same has not been proved by the Plaintiff.
60.
It is not clear why the Plaintiff is claiming rent from 01 st January,
2017 and not from 20.12.2016, which is the mandate of the Letter dated
20.12.2016.
61.
It is asserted that there is no pleading in the Plaint in regard to the
arrears of rent or the Legal Notice dated 31.01.2017 issued on behalf of the
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
Plaintiff / Respondent Vijay Kumar, the Plaintiff / Respondent or about the
payment of rent for the previous periods to the erstwhile owners. Except the
rate of rent as Rs.40 per month, none of the other details have been
mentioned in the Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016 or in the Letter dated
20.12.2016 of the original landlord. There is no pleading in the Plaint about
the terms agreed between the original landlord and Defendant No.1. It was
not stated that the tenancy was for a period of three years or that the rent was
exclusive of electricity and water charges or that it was payable in advance,
in each calendar month.
62.
It is thus, claimed that Defendant No.2 / Appellant No.2 is in
possession since long, having acquired the ownership rights from Smt.
Suchint Kumari and is carrying all his family business, from the Suit
Property.
63.
The requisite documents of Defendant No.2 which had not been
placed on record, for which Application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC was
filed, which have been erroneously not allowed to be taken on record.
64.
The Declaration of ownership in favour of the Plaintiff, is erroneous
since the property had already been purchased by the Defendant No.2, from
Smt. Suchint Kumari. In the Plaint, there is not even a whisper about the
status of Defendant No.2 and his relationship to the Suit Property. This is a
material concealment about his status in the Suit Property.
65.
It has been completely overlooked that PW1 is not a credible witness.
It has not been considered that the facts have been manipulated by the
Plaintiff, as there was no mention of Sale Deed in the Letter dated
20.12.2016.
66.
Moreover, the relief claimed in the Plaint or in the Application under
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
Section14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 that there was an oral
Agreement between his predecessor and Defendant No.1, is contrary to the
deposition of PW1 in his cross-examination that the previous owner Deepak,
had not handed over the Rent Agreement between him and the tenant, in
respect of the Suit Property. PW1 did not state that there was no Rent
Agreement or that it was an oral tenancy.
67.
Both the Courts below have taken an adverse inference against the
Defendants for not producing the 25 years old Rent Receipts for the period
1982 to 1994, but no adverse inference had been drawn against the Plaintiff
who though claimed that Defendant No.1 was the tenant, but failed to
produce even a single receipt or payment of rent by him, to his predecessor.
The cross-examination of DW1 has not been considered, wherein he had
explained the entire transaction and the status or the Appellant in the Suit
Property.
68.
The substantial questions of law as raised by the Appellants, are:
(i)
Whether a substantial error of law was
committed by holding that the Sale Deed itself
established the relationship of landlord and
tenant between the Plaintiff and Defendant No.1,
without any independent proof?
(ii)
Whether any valid landlord-tenant relationship
existed between the Respondent and Appellant
No.1 so as to justify a decree for arrears of
rent, particularly when no rent had previously
been paid or demanded?
(iii)
Whether the burden of proving the landlord-
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
tenant relationship was wrongly placed on the
Appellants, contrary to the settled principle that
the party asserting tenancy must prove it?
(iv)
Whether the Courts below erred in relying on a
bilateral Sale Deed containing recitals about the
third party?
(v)
Whether the two Courts erred in disregarding
the valid and executed Will and other documents
in favour of the Appellants?
(vi)
Whether the Courts misapplied the statutory
principles governing burden of proof by
requiring the Defendants to prove Issue No.4,
when the assertion of ownership and existence
of tenancy was solely placed on the Plaintiff?
(vii) Whether the Courts below did not apply
correctly the legal test by not insisting that
Plaintiff prove both ownership of the Suit
Property and existence of relationship of
landlord and tenant with Defendant No.1?
(viii) Whether the Trial Court has committed an error
by decreeing a Suit for recovery of rent despite
the bar of Section 50 Delhi Rent Control Act?
(ix)
Whether the Courts erred in holding that the
Will had not been produced and presumed
intestacy of Suchint Kumari despite the evidence
on record?
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
(x)
Whether the Judgment of Suraj Lamp has been
erroneously applied to discard the possessory
and equitable rights of the Appellant No.2 under
the Agreement to Sell etc.?
(xi)
Whether the principles laid down in Suraj Lamp
and
subsequent
retrospectively
transactions
so
and
judgements
were
applied
as
defeat
earlier
to
long-standing
possession,
without considering the peculiar facts of the
case?
(xii) Whether the open, undisturbed possession of the
Appellant for over 20 years supported by the
Agreement to Sell, etc. can be ignored by relying
on technicalities of registration, contrary to law
on adverse possession and part performance
under Section 53A of the TPA?
(xiii) Whether
non-consideration
of
material
evidence, mis-appreciation of burden of proof
and drawing of adverse presumptions without
pleadings constitute substantial errors of law
warranting interference under Section 100
CPC?
(xiv) Whether the Courts below wrongly assumed
pecuniary jurisdiction when the admitted value
of the Suit Property is Rs.15,00,000/-?
(xv)
Whether the Courts below erred in law by
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
treating the mutation entry as proof of title,
despite the settled position that such entries
serve
only
fiscal
purposes
and
do
not
confer ownership?
69.
Hence, a prayer is made that the Impugned Judgment of learned Civil
Judge as well as that of learned Senior Civil Judge, be set aside and the
matter be remanded back for fresh adjudication, with a proper opportunity to
the Appellants.
Submissions heard and record perused.
70.
The Substantial Questions of Law as suggested by the Appellant are
reframed as under :
(i) Whether the Respondent/Appellant was able to
establish his ownership in the Suit Property on the basis
of Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016 executed in his favour by
Shri Deepak?
(ii)
Whether Shri Sita Ram the Appellant No.2
acquired ownership in the Suit Property by virtue of
Agreement to Sell, GPA etc. dated 18.11.1994 executed
in his favour by Smt. Suchint Kumari?
(iii)
Whether the undisturbed possession of the
Appellant for over 20 years supported with Agreement to
Sell etc. can be ignored by relying on technicalities of
Registration contrary to law on adverse possession and
part performance of the Section 53 TPA?
71.
The Plaintiff/Respondent had filed a Suit for Declaration of
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
ownership and arrears of rent from the Appellants.
I.
Whether the Respondent Vijay Kumar is the Owner of the Suit
Property:
72.
The first challenge raised by the Appellant in the present second
Regular Appeal is that the Respondent could not have claimed his ownership
on the basis of Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016 executed in his favour by
predecessor in interest, Shri Deepak who had earlier purchased the property
vide registered Sale Deed dated 05.07.2013 from Sh. Vikram Grover,
son/legal heir of erstwhile owner, Smt. Suchint Kumari.
73.
The Appellants admitted the ownership of Smt. Suchint Kumari, who
had purchased the Suit Property by virtue of Sale Deed dated 02.07.1982
from Badri Nath.
74.
The Respondent had explained that Smt. Suchint Kumari died
intestate and was survived by Vimmi, Jyoti, Vikram and Pankaj. The
Relinquishment Deed dated 06.08.2011 Ex.PW1/11 by the three legal heirs
in favour of Shri Vikram Grover, was duly proved, establishing that he
became the absolute owner. Vikram Grover in turn, sold the property vide
Registered Sale Deed dated 05.07.2013 in favour of Deepak, from whom the
Suit Property had been purchased by the Respondent/Plaintiff.
75.
The main contention of the Appellants was that once Smt. Suchint
Kumari had sold the property though on the basis of GPA, Agreement to
Sell, Will, etc. dated 18.11.1994 to the Appellant No.2 Sita Ram, she was
left with no right, title, interest in the Suit Property, and on her demise the
Suit Property could not have devolved on her legal heirs.
76.
The learned Civil Judge rightly observed that when there was no
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
doubt or suspicion raised on the Relinquishment Deed Ex.PW1/11 executed
in favour of Shri Vikram Grover, and the same stood duly proved. Vikram
Grover had executed the registered Sale Deed dated 05.07.2013
Ex.PW1/10 in favour of the Shri Deepak, the predecessor in interest and
thereafter, a Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016 Ex.PW1/2 was executed in
favour of the Plaintiff, establishing the ownership of the Respondent in
the Suit Property.
77.
In the context of the challenge raised by the Appellant with respect to
the Relinquishment Deed executed in favour of Vikram Grover, reference be
made to Section 27 of the Limitation Act, 1963 which provides for the
Extinguishment of Right to Property. It states that at the determination of a
period thereby limited to any person for instituting a Suit for Possession of
any Property, his right to such property shall be extinguished.
78.
In the present case, the Appellants never questioned the
Relinquishment Deed in favour of Vikram Grover or the subsequent Sale
Deed dated 05.07.2013 Ex.PW-1/10 at any point of time and therefore, any
challenge to any defect in the Relinquishment Deed stands extinguished in
terms of Section 27 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
79.
Moreover, though there may have been an Agreement to Sell in
favour of Sita Ram, but it never fructified into a Sale Deed, thereby
extinguishing the rights of Suchint Kumari in the Suit Property.
80.
The aforesaid documents including Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016 as
duly proved by the Respondent Vijay Kumar, clearly establishes his
ownership in the Suit Property.
81.
In light of the Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016 Ex.PW1/2 coupled with all
the chain documents of ownership, it was rightly observed by the two
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
Courts that the Plaintiff had proved the ownership in the Suit Property;
accordingly, held the Respondent as the owner of the Suit Property.
II. Whether Appellant No.2, Sita Ram is the Owner of the Suit Property:
82.
The Appellant No.1 had claimed that in fact, it was Appellant No.2
Sita Ram, who was initially inducted as a tenant in the Suit Property by
Jagan Nath, father of Sh. Badri Nath. The Suit Property was then sold by
Badri Nath to Smt. Suchint Kumari through a registered Sale Deed dated
02.07.1982, under whom Appellant No.2 Sita Ram became a tenant.
Appellant No. 2 Sita Ram, thereafter purchased the Suit Property from Smt.
Suchint Kumari on the basis of Agreement to Sell, GPA, etc., dated
18.11.1994, and he became the Owner.
83.
The claim of ownership of Appellant No.2 Sita Ram was solely based
on the notarized GPA Ex.DW2/A, Agreement to Sell Ex.DW2/B, Affidavit
Ex.DW2/C, Will Ex.DW2/D, and Receipt Ex.DW2/E, all dated 18.11.1994,
but it is a settled law that these documents may confer a right to a party to
get the Sale Deed executed, but per se, they are not the documents of
ownership, in favour of the holder of the documents.
84.
Significantly, the original documents were not produced by Appellant
No. 2 Sita Ram. Even if it is accepted that there were GPA, Agreement to
Sell, etc., executed in favour of the Appellant No.2, but till such time a Sale
Deed on the basis of that Agreement to Sell was executed, no ownership
rights can be claimed in the Suit Property, as observed in the case of Suraj
Lamp (supra). Furthermore, these documents relied upon by the Appellant,
are not even registered to have entitled them for the protection under Section
53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Hereinafter referred to as
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
„TPA‟). The contentions of the Appellants that Sita Ram became the owner
of the Suit Property, therefore, was not proved on record.
85.
It was further contended that the Agreement to Sell, GPA, etc., in
favour of Sita Ram were of 1994 and the Judgement of Suraj Lamp (supra)
came in the year 2009, and it cannot be given retrospective effect.
86.
However, this contention that the Judgment was not applicable to the
documents executed in 1994, is absolutely fallacious for the simple reason
that an Agreement to Sell, GPA, etc., do not ipso facto create any ownership
in favour of the person holding these documents, as has been held in the case
of Suraj Lamp (supra). In the Judgment of Suraj Lamp (supra), it was
extensively discussed that the Agreement to Sell, Will, GPA, etc., do not
create any right in the immovable property, though the holder of the
documents may seek specific performance of these documents or may seek
protection of his Possession under Section 53(A) TPA, in case the documents
are registered.
87.
The learned Trial Court as well as the Appellate Court, therefore,
rightly held that even if these documents in favour of Appellant No.2 are
admitted, they do not confer any ownership right in respect of the Suit
Property in his favour, in terms of Suraj Lamp (supra).
88.
The Appellants have further contended that there was a Will dated
18.11.1994 also executed by Smt. Suchint Kumari, in favour of Defendant /
Appellant No.2 and she did not die intestate. However, this Will was not
propagated for all these years by the Appellants and not even proved during
the trial, in accordance with law.
89.
The original document i.e., Will dated 18.11.1994, has neither been
produced nor has it been proved on behalf of the Appellants, in accordance
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
with Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. No attesting witness has
been examined to establish the authenticity of the Will.
90.
In order to assert a claim on the basis of the Will, the onus was on the
Defendants / Appellants to have proved the Will, in accordance with law,
which they have miserably failed to do. Thus, it cannot be said that
Defendant No.2 succeeded in establishing an ownership in his favour, by
virtue of the Will dated 18.11.1994.
91.
Further, Section 49 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 provides that
a document which is unregistered, does not affect the immovable property
and cannot be received in evidence. Merely by referring to documents
without proving the same, cannot confer any right, title or interest on the
Appellant No.2. The learned Trial Court as well as the Appellate Court,
therefore, rightly discarded the plea of ownership, in favour of Appellant
No.2.
92.
It is, therefore, concluded that the Appellants had miserably
failed to prove that Appellant No.2 Sita Ram had acquired ownership
rights in 1994 or was occupying the property in the said capacity of
owner.
III.
Whether Rajesh Aggarwal / Appellant No.1 was the Tenant in the
Suit Property:
93.
The next significant question is whether Sh. Rajesh Aggarwal,
Appellant No.1 is a Tenant, in the Suit Property. Appellant No.1 Rajesh has
completely denied being a tenant, by asserting the original tenancy in the
name of his father and has taken a stand of never being a tenant in the Suit
Property.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
94.
It was admitted that the Appellant No.2, Sita Ram Aggarwal, in fact,
had been inducted as a tenant, way back in 1982.
95.
The Appellants had filed an Application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC
in the First Appeal, to place on record various Rent Receipts. This
Application, was however dismissed. Even if these Rent Receipts are
considered, they only supplement the Sale Deed Mark-PX-1 dated
02.07.1982 of Badrinath in favour of Smt. Suchint Kumari, wherein it was
clearly stated that Appellant No.2 Sita Ram was the tenant. There is no
evidence whatsoever, to establish when Appellant No.1 Rajesh was ever
inducted as a tenant.
96.
The Appellant No.1 Rajesh has categorically denied being a tenant in
the Suit Property, by claiming that he was doing business in the Suit
Property with his father, who had initially been inducted as a tenant, but had
thereafter acquired ownership by virtue of the Agreement to Sell, GPA, etc.
This defence had been replicated in the Written Statement. The Appellant
No.1 Rajesh, therefore, had rightly contended that he was never a tenant in
the Suit Property and expressly repudiated the status of a tenant in the Suit
Property.
97.
This confusion about Appellant No.1 Rajesh being a tenant,
commenced from the Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016 Ex.PW1/2, executed by
Sh. Deepak in favour of Sh. Vijay Kumar, wherein Appellant No.1 Rajesh
Aggarwal was stated to be the tenant in the Suit Property, at the monthly
rent of Rs. 40/- and it was also recorded that hence forth, Plaintiff /
Respondent shall be entitled to recover the Rent from Appellant No.1
Rajesh.
98.
Not only this, Sh. Deepak, the erstwhile owner, also served a Letter
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
dated 20.12.2016 of attornment to the Respondent and also to Appellant No.
1 Rajesh Aggarwal, stating that the Suit Property was sold by Sh. Deepak to
the Plaintiff / Respondent Vijay Kumar, and that the Plaintiff / Respondent
Vijay shall be entitled to Recovery of Rent from Appellant No.1 @ Rs.40/per month, from the date of letter itself i.e., 20.12.2016.
99.
The contents of the Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016 Ex.PW1/2 as well as
Letter dated 20.12.2016 of attornment, thus, narrated that it was Appellant
No.1 Rajesh Aggarwal, who was the tenant.
100. The Plaintiff / Respondent, being the subsequent purchaser, had no
personal knowledge about who was the original tenant. On the basis of the
information conveyed to him, he had issued a Legal Notice dated
31.01.2017, which had been served upon Appellant No.1 Rajesh Aggarwal
for claiming the arrears of rent.
101. In response to this Letter of the Landlord, Appellant No.1 Rajesh had
sent a Reply dated 15.02.2017 clarifying that Sita Ram, father of the
Appellant No.1 Rajesh, was the owner of the shop since the last 20 years,
which was purchased from its erstwhile owner Smt. Suchint Kumari.
102.
There is not an iota of evidence to establish that Appellant No.1
Rajesh was ever inducted as a tenant, as has also been claimed by him. The
confusion occurred due to recitals in subsequent Sale Deed dated 20.12.2016
Ex.PW1/2, but Sh. Deepak was not a privy to the earlier events and this
recital was contradictory to the earlier sale documents. It has been
established that Appellant No.1 Rajesh was merely in occupation of the Suit
Property along with his father, Appellant No.2 Sita Ram who had initially
been inducted as a tenant, and was never inducted as a tenant. His status,
even as per himself, is not that of a tenant, but of an occupant along with
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
his father, Appellant No.2 Sita Ram.
IV.
Whether there existed a Relationship of Landlord-Tenant between
the Appellants and the Respondent:
103. The next aspect which has been raised in the Second Appeal was,
whether Appellant No.2 Sita Ram had been in occupation of the Suit
Property as an owner as he claimed to have purchased the Suit Property in
1994, and therefore, whether there existed no relationship of landlordtenant between the parties.
104. The Appellant No.2 Sita Ram had taken a categorical defence that
though he had been initially inducted as a tenant, but he ceased to be so
since 18.11.1994 when he acquired ownership by virtue of the Agreement to
Sell, GPA, etc. It has already been held that these documents did not confer
any right any ownership on Appellant No.2 Sita Ram.
105.
The question of law which emerges is, what is the status of a
tenant who denounces being a tenant in the Suit Property. It raises an
interesting proposition of law as to whether such claim of Appellant No.2,
resulted in forfeiture of his status as a tenant.
106. Section 111(g) TPA deals with Determination of Lease and provides
for circumstances in which the lease of immovable property gets
determined. It reads as under:
By forfeiture; that is to say,
(1) in case the lessee breaks an express condition which provides that,
on breach thereof, the lessor may re-enter; or
(2) in case the lessee renounces his character as such by setting up a
title in a third person or by claiming title in himself; or
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
(3) the lessee is adjudicated an insolvent and the lease provides that
the lessor may re-enter on the happening of such event; and in any of
these cases the lessor or his transferee gives notice in writing to the
lessee of his intention to determine the lease.
107. In Mohammad Amir Ahmad Khan vs. Municipal Board of Sitapur and
Ors., MANU/SC/0326/1964, while making a reference to the case of
Maharaja of Jeypore vs. Rukmini Pattamahadevi, MANU/PR/0154/1919,
AIR 1919 PC 1, the Apex Court observed that the principles embodied in
Section 111(g) TPA are equally applicable to tenancies in which the TPA
does not apply, on the ground of the same being in consonance with justice,
equity, and good conscious. It was further observed that it was clear law that
permanent tenancies are within the rule and are liable to forfeiture, if there
is a disclaimer of tenancy or denial of the landlord‟s title. This disclaimer
of repudiation of landlord’s title, must be clear and unequivocal and made to
the knowledge of the landlord. It was further observed that where there is a
disclaimer of tenancy and repudiation of landlord’s title, it would amount to
forfeiture of relationship of landlord and tenant.
108. In Kundan Mal vs. Gurudutta, MANU/SC/0280/1989, JT 1989 (1) SC
147, it was held that the principle of forfeiture on disclaimer is founded on
the rule that a man cannot approbate and reprobate at the same time. Since
the consequence of applying the rule is very serious, it must be held that the
denial has to be clear and in unequivocal terms.
109. Similar observations were made by the Supreme Court in Majati
Subbarao vs. P.V.K. Krishna Rao (Deceased) by Lrs. AIR 1989 SC 2187. It
was observed that it is abundantly clear from the decision of the Apex Court
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
in Kundan Mal vs. Gurudutta, JT 1989 (1) SC 147, that the principle of
forfeiture on disclaimer was founded on the rule that a man cannot
approbate and reprobate at the same time. Since the consequence of
applying the rule was very serious, it must be held that the denial of title has
to be clear and in unequivocal terms. It was further noted that where there
is a provision under the Rent Act for eviction on the ground of repudiation
of the title, then the remedy with the landlord is only to approach under the
Rent Act, as was the case in Rajasthan Rent Law.
110. Certain State tenancy laws provide denial of title of landlord, as a
ground for eviction, in which case the remedy for the landlord is to approach
under Rent Law, but where there is no such provision in Rent Act as in
Delhi, the only remedy remains under the general civil law, to which the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is applicable.
111. In the case of Hatimullah and Ors. vs. Mahamad Arju Choudhury
MANU/WB/0396/1927, 113 Ind. Cas. 13, this aspect was further explained
by observing that where the tenant denies the Plaintiff’s title to recover rent
on the bona fide ground of seeking information of such title or having such
title established in a Court of law in order to protect himself, he cannot be
charged with disclaiming the Plaintiff’s title. But, where the disclaimer is
done not with this object, but with expressed repudiation of tenancy under
the Plaintiff, it would operate as forfeiture.
112. The principle of forfeiture as recognized, was initially stated to be that
a denial of title in the Written Statement, cannot be taken advantage of in
that Suit, but can be taken advantage of only in a subsequent Suit to be filed
by the landlord.
113. However, in the case of Sada Ram & Ors. vs. Gajjan Shiama
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
MANU/PH/0080/1970, AIR 1970 P&H 511; Shiv Parshad vs. Smt. Shila
Rani MANU/HP/0009/1974, AIR 1974 HP 22, it has been held that the
proposition that a denial of title in the Written Statement cannot be taken
advantage of that Suit, but can be taken advantage of only in a subsequent
Suit to be filed by the landlord, would only lead to unnecessary multiplicity
of legal proceedings as the landlord would then be obliged to file a second
suit for ejectment of the tenant on the ground of forfeiture, entailed by the
tenants’ denial of his character as a tenant in the Written Statement.
114. In Sheikh Miadhar vs. Rajani Kanta Roy, MANU/WB/0481/1909, 5
Ind. Cas. 708, more light was thrown on this aspect, wherein it was held that
where in a suit for rent the Defendant denies the Plaintiff’s title and claims
to hold under a third party, the Defendant can be, in a Suit for ejectment by
the landlord, debarred from pleading his tenancy and claiming protection of
possession on that ground. It was further observed that this principle was
embodied in Section 111(g) TPA, wherein one of the grounds for forfeiture,
was to set up a title in the third person or in himself.
115. In the case of Arjunlal Bhatt Mall Gothani and Ors. vs. Girish
Chandra Dutta and Ors., MANU/SC/0326/1973, AIR 1973 SC 2256,
similar plea of having acquired ownership by virtue of documents of
purchase was raised by the tenant, who further claimed that because of this
Agreement, the old relationship of landlord and tenant, had come to any end.
It was held that the rights of the parties had to be worked out, on the basis of
this subsequent Agreement. It was obvious that when such Agreements
stood cancelled, the landlord would automatically be entitled to
possession, under the terms of the Agreement.
116. In the case of Guru Amarjit Singh vs. Rattan Chand and Ors.,
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
MANU/SC/0065/1994, AIR 1994 SC 227, the doctrine of forfeiture was
explained to be founded upon the existence of a lease under jural
relationship between a lessor and a lessee, as contemplated under Section
105 TPA. It is implicit that if the lease is in operation, the lessor has been
given a right to determine the lease for committing breach of a covenant or
for disclaimer by the lessee on the happening of any of the events specified
therein.
The tenant, by repudiation of the relationship of landlord-tenant,
exposes himself to the risk of forfeiting his lease and giving a right to the
lessor to determine the lease. The repudiation, however, must be clear and
unequivocal and anterior to the issuance of the notice determining the lease.
Where there was an unequivocal admission of the earlier relationship of
landlord-tenant, but denial in the subsequent litigation, the tenant
forfeits its right to lease.
117. The Principles of Forfeiture as encapsulated in Section 111(g)(2),
may be crystallized as under:
(i)
There is denial of title of landlord or the status as a tenant; and
(ii)
It must be clear and unequivocal and anterior to the issuance of
the notice determining the lease.
118. Applying the aforesaid principles, in the present case, it is evident that
the Appellants had, categorically in clear and unequivocal terms, repudiated
the ownership of the Respondent by asserting that the documents of sale on
the basis of which they were claiming their ownership was illegal and was
not capable of conferring any ownership rights on the Respondent. The
Appellants have completely denied the ownership tile of the Respondent
Vijay, though it has been proved otherwise.
119. Not only this, in the Reply dated 15.02.2017 given by the Appellants,
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
a specific plea was taken that Sita Ram had acquired ownership of the Suit
Property, and there existed no relationship of landlord and tenant between
the parties.
120. The Appellant Sita Ram, as per his own assertions, ceased to be a
tenant as his status allegedly, metamorphosised into that of an owner, though
the documents of title as discussed above, do not confer ownership on him.
121. There is overwhelming evidence on record to show that there was a
complete repudiation of the ownership of the Respondent in the Suit
Property. Further, there was complete repudiation of the status of
Appellant No. 2 Sita Ram in the Suit Property, as a tenant.
122. The status of appellants as tenant, thus, stood forfeited and it is
held that the relationship of Landlord-tenant ceased to exist between
the parties.
V.
Whether the Suit was barred under Section 50 Delhi Rent Control
Act, 1958:
123. An objection has been taken by the Appellants that the present Suit
was barred under Section 50 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 since the
rate of rent was Rs.40/- per month.
124. It has been exhaustively discussed that there is no relationship of
landlord tenant, and therefore, Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 is not
applicable.
125. Moreover, it has been rightly argued on behalf of the Respondent that
there is no provision whatsoever under the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958
either for declaration of the title or for recovery of rent. These two aspects
clearly fall within the domain of Civil Suit and therefore, the present Suit
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
was maintainable. It is only the eviction or the standard rent, which has
specifically governed by the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958; therefore, this
objection is also not tenable.
Conclusion:
126.
In the light of the above discussion, it is concluded the Appellants
have forfeited their status as tenants under Section 111(g) TPA and it is
held that there exists no relationship of Landlord-tenant between the
parties.
127.
They being in occupation of the Suit Property without any legal right,
title or entitlement or even as a tenant, are liable to pay the occupation
charges.
128. The present Suit was for recovery of arrears of occupation
charges (though described as rent), is thus, maintainable. The Plaintiff /
Respondent had limited his claim to the rate of Rs.40/- per month, which has
been rightly granted by the learned Civil judge and rightly upheld in First
Regular Appeal.
129. For the reasons discussed above, the present Appeal, is hereby,
dismissed.
130. The pending Application(s), if any, also stand disposed of,
accordingly.
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J
MARCH 23, 2026/va
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:16:00
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review