The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. In this view of the matter, this Court is not inclined to entertain this review petition, which is hereby dismissed.
24. Pending interlocutory application, if any, is closed. (Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.) Dated: 11.02.2026 Uploaded On: Mukul/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:3788
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Civil Review No. 94 of 2023
Rajendra Prasad aged about 60 years, son of Late Ramnath Prasad,
resident of Halud Boni, P.O. and P.S. Parsudih, District- Singhbhum East
through his constituted attorney namely Dindayal Prasad, son of Tribeni
Prasad Saw, resident of Parsudih, C/o Shyam Talkies, Parsudih, P.O. and
P.S. Parsudih, District- Singhbhum East
… …
Petitioner/Appellant/Petitioner
-Versus1. State of Jharkhand
2. Commissioner, South Chotanagpur Division, Ranchi, P.O. Ranchi, P.S.
Kotwali, District-Ranchi
3. Deputy Commissioner, East Singhbhum at Jamshedpur, P.O. & P.S.
Jamshedpur, District- East Singhbhum
4. Special Officer, Scheduled Areas Regulation, Jamshedpur Town,
Jamshedpur, P.O. & P.S.- Jamshedpur, District- East Singhbhum
5. Jitu Bhumij, son of Late Doman Bhumij, resident of village Halud
Boni, P.O. andP.S. Parsudih, District Singhbhum East
… …
Respondents/Respondents/Opposite Parties
--CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Petitioner
: Mr. Amar Kumar Sinha, Advocate
Mr. K. K. Ambastha, Advocate
Mr. Sandeep Verma, Advocate
Mr. Anurag Chandra, Advocate
For the Respondents
: Mr. Shalini Shahdeo, Advocate
--th
05/11 February 2026
1.
Heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the parties.
2.
This petition has been filed for review of the judgment dated
14.08.2018 passed by this Court in W.P. (C) No. 3896 of 2003, which has
been dismissed vide judgment dated 14.08.2018.
3.
The Letters Patent Appeal, against the judgment passed in W.P. (C)
No. 3896 of 2003, being L.P.A. No. 765 of 2019 was also dismissed as
not pressed.
2026:JHHC:3788
Arguments of the petitioner
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the
appellant had prayed for not to press the aforesaid L.P.A., so as to file a
review application and accordingly the present review application has
been filed.
5.
The learned counsel has submitted that the petitioner has placed
Annexure-3 series, which are the rent receipts and also placed the
documents relating to mutation as contained in Annexure-9 series and
Annexure-10 is the report of the Circle Officer.
6.
The learned counsel submits that on the basis of the rent receipts
and the mutation register, it is apparent that the petitioner is in possession
of the property since 1965-66. He has also submitted that in Annexure-10
series, there is a report of the Circle Officer which was called for at the
appellate stage i.e. S.A.R. Appeal No. 59/1997-98 and as per the report,
the petitioner was in possession of the property since 1965-66.
7.
The learned counsel submits that as per the finding recorded by the
Writ Court, the petitioner had totally failed to establish before any of the
authorities that he was in possession of the property since 1940 or 1965.
He has submitted that the entire records of the appellate authority was not
called for at the time of final hearing. The records of the appellate
authority would have demonstrated that the petitioner has been in
possession since 1965-66 and the application for restoration of land was
filed way back in the year 1996-97 in S.A.R. Case No. 27/1996-97. The
mutation was allowed in Mutation Case No. 251/1965-66. Neither the
exact date of mutation is available in the review application nor the order
of mutation has been annexed. The learned counsel for the petitioner is
unable to give the exact date of filing of the S.A.R. Case. However, the
case number is S.A.R. Case No. 27/1996-97. The compromise decree is
dated 22.04.1965.
8.
During the course of argument, it also transpired that the appellant
had filed two compromise petitions in the present case. One is in Title
2026:JHHC:3788
Suit No. 565/1964 which is dated 10.08.1964 and the other is in Title Suit
No. 1475/1964 which is dated 22.04.1965.
9.
The learned counsel has submitted that in the writ petition only one
compromise petition was filed which is relating to Title Suit No. 565/1964
and the compromise in Title Suit No. 1475/1964 was not filed. The
learned counsel submits that both the compromise are in connection with
the same property. The learned counsel submits that the compromise
decree in Title Suit No. 565/1964 is in relation to Khata No. 184 which is
the property involved in the present case.
10.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has fairly submitted that there
is no apparent error on record, so far as the judgment passed by the writ
court is concerned, but there is mistake on the part of the petitioner who
has not produced all the relevant documents at earlier stage before the writ
court.
11.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the judgment
passed by the Hon’ble Calcutta High Court reported in 2024 Supreme
(Cal) 446 (Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. & Anr. vs. Sarvesh Kumar &
Others), paragraph 16 which in turn has referred to the judgement of the
Hon’ble supreme court reported in (1955) 1 SCR 520 to submit that a
court may allow review in terms of order 47 rule 1 on any of the three
specified grounds: (i) discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after
the exercise of due diligence, was not within the applicant’s
knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the
decree was passed.
(ii) mistake or error apparent on the face of the record.
(iii) For any other sufficient reason. It has been held by the
judicial Committee that the words “any other sufficient reason”
must mean “a reason sufficient on grounds, at least analogous to
those specified in the rule” but the said rule is not universal.”
Arguments of the respondents
12.
The learned counsel for the respondents has opposed the prayer and
has submitted that it was the case of the petitioner throughout that he was
2026:JHHC:3788
in possession of the property since 1940. The learned counsel further
submits that the rent receipts were also issued in the name of private
respondent which is apparent from the order of the Deputy Commissioner
in S.A.R. Appeal No. 59/1997-98, wherein it has been recorded that the
rent up to the year 1996-97 was paid to the State of Bihar by RespondentJitu Bhumij on behalf of himself and his co-sharers. The learned counsel
has submitted that apparently there are parallel rent receipts for
overlapping period between the petitioner and the private respondent.
13.
The learned counsel has also submitted that as per the order of the
Commissioner and the argument advanced on behalf of the petitioner
before the learned Commissioner, they claimed the property to be in
possession since 1940 and also asserted that the raiyats had left the village
and settled in Bengal and suddenly in the year 1964, they started
disturbing the possession of the petitioner. She has submitted that the
possession of the petitioner remained disturbed since 1964 itself.
Findings of this Court
14.
After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, this Court finds
that before the authorities, the petitioner has been claiming that he was in
possession since 1946 and the private respondent had disturbed their
possession suddenly in the year 1964 and ultimately title Suit was filed
which ended in compromise.
15.
Numerous documents are sought to be placed on record by the
learned counsel for the petitioner, which were not placed in the writ
record and they were not forming part of the proceedings before the
concerned authorities. These documents have been filed for the first time
in the review proceedings by stating that these documents are very old and
could not be procured by the petitioner and therefore the documents could
not have been produced at earlier stage.
16.
During the course of argument, it also transpired that it has been
asserted in the review petition that there was amicable partition between
the Ramnath Prasad and Rajnath Prasad and 43 decimals came in the
2026:JHHC:3788
share of each one of them. There is no limitation as prescribed under
Section 71-A of the Chhota Nagpur Tenancy Act. However, law is well
settled that such application for restoration cannot be filed after inordinate
delay and particularly when the possession remained undisturbed from the
side of the member of the Schedule Tribe concerned.
17.
The impugned judgment reveal that the petitioner claimed
possession since 1940. Their possession was sought to be disturbed in
1964 and thereafter two suits were filed which ended in compromise. In
the compromise petitions also, the date of possession of the petitioner has
not been acknowledged and in the compromise, it has been stated that the
concerned Tribal will not disturb the possession of the plaintiff. The
compromise petition itself reveals that the defendant undertook not to
disturb with the right, title and interest of the plaintiff with respect to the
land in future.
18.
In the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Patna High Court (Ranchi
Bench) reported in (2000) 4 PLJR 787 (Kesho Sao & Anr. vs. Additional
Member, Board of Revenue & Others), it has been held that a non-tribal
cannot acquire title through compromise. Portion of the said judgement
relevant for the purposes of this case is quoted as under: -
19.
“ 4. ……………………………………………………………………
It is well settled that compromise decree passed by Civil Court
declaring title and possession of a party who is not a member
of Schedule Tribe in respect of land of recorded raiyat
belonging to member of Schedule Tribe cannot be given effect
to and such decree will amount to dispossessing the raiyat by
fraudulent method. Suffice it to refer only one Division Bench
decision of this Court in the case of “Ramnarain Sah v. State
of Bihar (1975, BBCJ-433).
……………………………………………………………………….”
This Court finds that the petitioner is trying to make out a
completely new case with respect to date of possession and the possession
of the petitioner remained questioned as back as in the year 1964 itself
and as is apparent from the impugned judgment, the rent receipts was
2026:JHHC:3788
issued not only in favour of the petitioner, but also in favour of the private
respondent.
20.
In the judgment passed in S.A.R. Appeal No. 59/1997-98, the
specific case of the petitioner has been recorded, wherein the petitioner
had taken a stand that the predecessor of the petitioner got their name
mutated in Register-II of the Anchal Officer and had been in possession of
the land in question of the year 1965.
21.
This Court finds that the documents, which have been sought to be
brought on record, are not such documents which can be said that the
petitioner has discovered new and important matter of evidence which
after the exercise of due diligence was not within the petitioner’s
knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the
judgment of the writ court was passed or the order of the authorities was
passed and accordingly, the new documents, which are sought to be
introduced by the petitioner in this review petition, cannot be entertained.
22.
The law is well-settled that with respect to exercise of power of
certiorari under writ jurisdiction, the scope of interference is very limited
and now in the review application of the writ order, for the first time, the
petitioner is trying to introduced new documents and new facts, which are
contrary to the stand and facts placed on record before the authorities
concerned/before the writ proceedings. Further, the review has been filed
after withdrawal of L.P.A.
23.
In this view of the matter, this Court is not inclined to entertain this
review petition, which is hereby dismissed.
24.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, is closed.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Dated: 11.02.2026
Uploaded On:
Mukul/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review