Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
No
Date
Office Notes,
reports, orders or
proceedings or
directions and
Registrar’s order
with Signatures
COURT’S OR JUDGES’S ORDERS
C- 528 No. 2059 of 2025
H o n ’ b l e A l o k M a h r a , J.
Mr. Jit endra Chaudhary, learned counsel
for t he applicant .
2.
Mr. Jai Prakash, learned Brief Holder for
t he St at e.
3.
Mr. H.C. Pat hak,
respondent no. 2.
learned
counsel
for
4.
Mr. Vij ay Bhat t and Mr. Harshit Sanwal,
learned counsel for respondent nos. 3, 4 and 5.
The present crim inal m isc. applicat ion
5.
has been filed by t he applicant s challenging
t he order dat ed 21.05.2025 passed by ACJM,
Nainit al in Crim inal Case No. 3264 of 2019,
St at e Vs. Sant osh Kum ar Joshi, w hereby, t he
applicat ion m oved by t he applicant under
Sect ion 319 Cr.P.C. for sum m oning t he
respondent nos. 2 t o 5 has been r ej ect ed and
also t he order dat ed 28.10.2025 passed by
Session Judge, Nainit al in Crim inal Revision
No. 14 of 2025.
6.
Lear ned counsel for t he applicant s would
subm it t hat since it has com e in evidence t hat
t he power of at t orney was ex ecut ed by t he
applicant in favour of Sant osh Kum ar Joshi in
respect of t heir bhum idhari land sit uat ed in
Dhungsil Talla, but , on t he basis of t his power
of at t orney Sant osh Kum ar Joshi has execut ed
t he sale deed in favour of all above privat e
respondent s in respect of t he land sit uat ed in
Dhungsil Malla. I t is furt her subm it t ed t hat
bot h t he Dhungsil Talla and Dhungsil Malla are
separat e villages and as such t he privat e
respondent no. 2 was t he t hen Sub- Regist rar ,
at t he t im e of which, t he said sale deed was
regist ered, t her efore, she ought t o have
per used
t he
revenue
r ecords
befor e
per m it t ing t he said sale deed t o be regist ered.
7.
Lear ned counsel for t he respondent nos.
3, 4 and 5 w ould furt her subm it t hat
respondent s are bonafide pur chaser s and t he
sale deed was execut ed aft er put t ing due
considerat ion. Thus, t he orders passed by t he
learned Magist rat e concer ned and Sessions
Judge concer ned does not war rant any
int erference. Lear ned counsel appearing for
respondent nos. 3, 4 and 5 hav e r elied upon a
j udgm ent passed by Hon’ble Supr em e Court
in t he case of S. Anand Vs. St at e of Tam il
Nadu and Anot her , 2026 SCC OnLine SC 702.
For ready r efer ence, paragraph no. 24 of t he
aforesaid j udgm ent is ext ract ed her einbelow : “ 2 4 . As a m at t er of fact , even if t he allegat ion of t he
respondent No.2- com plainant , t hat t he Will was
forged, is found t o be subst ant iat ed, t he purchaser s
of t he propert y would be t he persons aggr ieved
because in such circum st ances, t heir t it le over t he
propert y in quest ion would land in disput e,
having Crl. Appeal@ SLP ( Crl.) No ( s) . 12177 of
2022 being acquired fr om t he vendor who used t he
so- called fabricat ed will t o execut e t he regist er ed
sale deeds. The sit uat ion at hand is squarely covered
by t he j udgm ent in t he case of Moham m ed I brahim
and Ot hers v. St at e of Bihar and Anot her.4, w her ein
t his Court held as below : “ 20. When a sale deed is execut ed conv eying a
propert y claim ing ow nership t her et o, it m ay be
possible for t he purchaser under such sale deed t o
allege t hat t he v endor has cheat ed him by m aking a
false r epr esent at ion of ownership and fraudulent ly
induced him t o part wit h t he sale considerat ion. But
in t his case t he com plaint is not by t he purchaser .
On t he ot her hand, t he pur chaser is m ade a coaccused.
21. I t is not t he case of t he com plainant t hat any of
t he accused t ried t o deceive him eit her by m aking a
false or m isleading represent at ion or by any ot her
act ion or om ission, nor is it his case t hat t hey offered
him any fraudulent or dishonest inducem ent t o
deliver any pr opert y or t o consent t o t he r et ent ion
t hereof by any person or t o int ent ionally induce him
t o do or om it t o do anyt hing which he would not do
or om it if he were not so deceived. Nor did t he
com plainant allege t hat t he first appellant pret ended
t o be t he com plainant while execut ing t he sale
deeds.
Ther efor e, it cannot be said t hat t he first accused by
t he act of ex ecut ing sale deeds in favour of t he
second accused or t he second accused by reason of
being t he purchaser, or t he t hird, fourt h and fift h
accused, by r eason of being t he wit ness, scribe and
st am p vendor in regard t o t he sale deeds, deceived
t he com plainant in any m anner.
..................................................................
23. When we say t hat ex ecut ion of a sale deed by a
per son, purport ing t o convey a propert y which is not
his, as his propert y , is not m aking a false docum ent
and t her efor e not forgery, w e should not be
underst ood as holding t hat such an act can never be
a crim inal offence. I f a person sells a propert y
knowing t hat it does not belong t o him , and t her eby
defrauds t he person who pur chased t he pr opert y, t he
per son defrauded, t hat is, t he purchaser, m ay
com plain t hat t he vendor com m it t ed t he fraudulent
act of cheat ing. But a t hird part y who is not t he
purchaser under t he deed m ay not be able t o m ake
such com plaint .”
8.
Mr. H.C. Pat hak, learned counsel for
respondent no. 2 would subm it t hat t he
Regist ry Officer is not r esponsible for t he t it le
and he/ she is not em pow ered t o go int o t he
quest ion of t he t it le of t he person execut ing
t he docum ent for t ransfer ring t he propert y .
He has no adj udicat ory pow er t o decide
whet her t he ex ecut ant s have any t it le.
Lear ned counsel has relied upon a j udgm ent
passed by Hon’ble Suprem e Court in t he case
of K. Gopi Vs. Sub- Regist rar and Ot hers, 2025
SCC OnLine SC 740. For ready reference,
Paragr aph no. 15 of t he aforesaid j udgm ent is
ext ract ed her einbelow: “ 1 5 . The r egist ering officer is not concerned wit h t he
t it le held by t he execut ant . He has no adj udicat or y
power t o decide whet her t he ex ecut ant has any t it le.
Ev en if an execut ant ex ecut es a sale deed or a lease
in respect of a land in respect of which he has no
t it le, t he regist ering officer cannot refuse t o regist er
t he docum ent if all t he procedural com pliances are
m ade and t he necessary st am p dut y as w ell as
regist rat ion charges/ fee ar e paid. We m ay not e her e
t hat under t he schem e of t he 1908 Act , it is not t he
funct ion of t he Sub- Regist rar or Regist ering
Aut horit y t o ascert ain whet her t he v endor has t it le t o
t he propert y which he is seeking t o t ransfer . Once
t he regist ering aut horit y is sat isfied t hat t he part ies
t o t he docum ent ar e present befor e him and t he
part ies adm it execut ion t her eof before him , subj ect
t o m aking procedural com pliances as nar rat ed
abov e, t he docum ent m ust be r egist er ed. The
ex ecut ion and regist rat ion of a docum ent have t he
effect of t ransferring only t hose right s, if any, t hat
t he ex ecut ant possesses. I f t he ex ecut ant has no
right , t it le, or int erest in t he propert y, t he regist er ed
docum ent cannot effect any t ransfer.”
9.
Hear d lear ned counsel for t he part ies
and per used t he r ecord.
10. Per usal of t he im pugned order dat ed
21.05.2025
rev eals
t hat
t he
evidence
collect ed was placed befor e t he lear ned court
below , w hich, aft er applying it s j udicial m ind,
has right ly rej ect ed t he applicat ion of t he
applicant under Sect ion 311 of Cr.P.C.
11. The court concer ned has consider ed &
discussed all relev ant aspect s. Thus, t he view
t aken by t he learned Judicial Magist rat e
concer ned cannot be fault ed. This Court does
not find any infirm it y or illegalit y in t he
im pugned order dat ed 21.05.2025 passed by
ACJM, Nainit al in Crim inal Case No. 3264 of
2019, St at e Vs. Sant osh Kum ar Joshi and also
t he order dat ed 28.10.2025 passed by
Session Judge, Nainit al in Crim inal Revision
No. 14 of 2025. Hence, t his Court does not
find any r eason t o int erfer e wit h t he
im pugned or ders.
12. Accordingly,
t he
crim inal
m isc.
applicat ion fails and is her eby dism issed.
( A l o k M a h r a J.)
05.05.2026
Uj j wal
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review