The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. 06.2025; Arbitration Case No.332 of 2025, In Re; Meena Kumari Versus The Land Acquisition Officer and another, decided on 19.11.2025; and Arbitration Case No.384 of 2025, In Re; Balak Ram Versus Secretary National Highway Authority Delhi and another, decided on 23.12.2025, whereby, the mandate of Learned Arbitrator was extended by this Court, with directions to conclude the arbitral proceedings within six months from the date of entirety of the receipt of copy of the judgment. DIRECTIONS:
12. Taking into account the facts and circumstances and the object and intent 2026:HHC:801 of arbitral proceedings, this Court allows the instant petition, in the following terms:- In (i) Order dated 05.04.2023 [Annexure P-1] in Case No.39 of 2019 by Learned Arbitrator-cum-Divisional Commissioner, Shimla is quashed and set aside; (ii) Arbitrator- cum- Divisional Commissioner Shimla is mandated to complete the arbitral proceedings and to pass the Award in accordance with law within six months from the date of receipt of copy of this judgment; and (iii) Costs made easy for respective parties. aforesaid terms, the instant petition stands disposed of alongwith pending miscellaneous application(s), if any. January 02, 2026 [Bhardwaj] (Ranjan Sharma) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:801
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
Arbitration Case No.367 of 2025
Decided on: 02.01.2026
__________________________________________________________
Rajeev Kumar Verma
.....Petitioner
Versus
Secretary National High Authority
and another
....Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge
1Whether approved for reporting?
For the petitioner:
Mr. H.C. Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Ms. Sneh Bhimta, Advocate vice
Ms. Shreya Chauhan, Advocate,
for Respondent No.1-NHAI
Ms. Ayushi Negi, Deputy Advocate
General, for Respondent No.2State.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge
Petitioner-Rajeev Kumar Verma, has come
up before this Court in instant petition filed under
Section 29-A of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, seeking following relief:“It is, therefore, most respectfully prayed
that this application/petition may very
kindly be allowed and the impugned order
dated
05.04.2023
No.39/19
alongwith
passed
other
in
Case
connected
matter may kindly be set aside/quashed
and the time period in this case may
kindly be extended and the Ld. Arbitrator1
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
cum-Divisional
2026:HHC:801
Commissioner,
Shimla
may kindly be directed to decide the Case
No.39/2019 in a time bound manner and
justice be done.”
2.
Grievance of the petitioner is that pursuant
to passing of the Award by CALA concerned, the
parties
offered themselves
for arbitral proceedings,
before Learned Arbitrator-cum-Divisional Commissioner,
Shimla,
vide
who
Case
arbitral
commenced
No.39/2019. It
proceedings
the
arbitral
proceedings
is averred that
continued
since
though
but
Learned Arbitrator passed an order on 05.04.2023
[Annexure P-1], for keeping the arbitral proceedings
in abeyance. It is in this background, the present
petition has been filed, with the prayer to direct
Learned
Arbitrator
to
conclude
the
arbitral
proceedings within a stipulated period by extending
the
time
for
concluding
the
arbitral
proceedings
under Section 29 A of Arbitration and Conciliation
Act,
by
quashing
the
order
dated
05.04.2023
[Annexure P-1].
3.
Pursuant to the issuance of notice by this
Court on 19.11.2025, Respondents were directed to file
Reply and the matter was directed to be listed on
2026:HHC:801
16.12.2025, when, Respondents sought more time to file
Reply and accordingly the matter was posted for today
[02.01.2026].
However, upon listing of the case today,
Learned Counsel for both the Respondents state that
no reply is intended to be filed on behalf of the
Respondents.
4.
for
On query by this Court, Learned Counsel
the
petitioner
submits
that
identical
matters
have been allowed by granting extension to Learned
Arbitrator-cum-Divisional
Commissioner,
Shimla,
Himachal
concluding
arbitral
Pradesh
for
the
proceedings.
5.
Heard, Mr. H.C. Sharma, Advocate for the
petitioner, Ms. Sneh Bhimta, Learned Vice Counsel
appearing on behalf of Ms. Shreya Chauhan, Learned
Counsel for Respondent No.1 for Respondent No.1National Highway Authority of India and Ms. Ayushi
Negi, Learned Deputy Advocate General for Respondent
No.2-State.
6.
Ms. Sneh Bhimta, Learned Vice Counsel for
Respondent No.1-NHAI does not dispute the factual
matrix that the arbitral proceedings commenced in
the
year 2019 and since
then, the
parties have
2026:HHC:801
participated in these proceedings. It is not in dispute
that in other identical cases relating to the same
subject-land though the arbitral proceedings were kept
in abeyance and the mandate of the Arbitrator was
terminated but consequent upon the intervention of
this
Court,
the
time
was
enlarged/extended
for
concluding the arbitral proceedings. Pursuant to the
orders passed in similar cases arbitral process are
underway and/or in some case the same have been
concluded.
7.
While dealing with a similar fact-situation,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in TATA Sons Pvt. Ltd.
(Formerly
TATA
Sons
Ltd.)
vs.
Siva
Industries
and Holdings Ltd. and others, reported in 2023 (1)
SCALE 793, held that the mandate of an Arbitrator
is liable to be extended by the Court, under Section
29A(4) and 29A(5) of the Act, in the following terms:“24
The provisions of Section 29A, as
originally introduced into the statute,
mandated that all awards shall be made
within a period of twelve months from the
date on which the arbitral tribunal enters
upon the reference. The explanation
clarified when the arbitral tribunal would
be deemed to have entered upon the
reference, namely, the date on which the
arbitrator has received written notice of
the appointment. The mandatory nature
of the provisions of Section 29A(1) and
2026:HHC:801
their application to all arbitrations
conducted under the Act, domestic or
international commercial, was evident
from the use of the word “shall”. In terms
of Section 29A(4), in case the arbitral
award was not rendered within the
twelve or eighteen month period as the
case may be, the mandate of the
arbitrator(s) would stand terminated,
unless on an application made by any
of the parties, the court extended time
on sufficient cause being shown.
xxxx.
26.
xxx…
xxx..
Sub-section (3) of Section 29A empowers
parties, by consent, to extend the period
specified in sub-section (1) for making the
award by a further period not exceeding
six months. Thereafter, if the award is not
made within the period which is specified
in sub-section (1) or the extended period
specified in sub-section (3), the mandate
of the arbitrator shall terminate unless
the court has extended the period either
prior to or after the expiry of the period so
specified. In other words, the timeline of
twelve months for making the award
(in matters other than international
commercial arbitration), is qualified by
the consensual entrustment to the
parties under sub-section (3) to extend the
period by six months after which the court
is empowered in terms of sub-section (4) to
extend the period for making the award.
The submission of the second respondent
is that the provisions of sub-section (3)
and sub-section (4) must also apply to an
international commercial arbitration. This
would merit close scrutiny. The legislature
has
not
expressly
excluded
the
applicability of sub-sections (3) and (4) of
Section
29A
to
an
international
commercial arbitration. But, at the same
time, it must be noticed that the
rationale underlying sub-section (3) is
to ensure that despite the stipulation
2026:HHC:801
of twelve months for the making of an
arbitral award in the domestic context,
parties may by consent agree to an
extension of time by a further period of
six months. Such an extension of six
months is envisaged in the case of a
domestic arbitration since there is a
mandate that the award shall be made
within a period of twelve months. A
further extension has, however, been
entrusted to the court in terms of subsection (4) of Section29A. However,
insofar as an international commercial
arbitration is concerned, the statutory
regime is clear by the substantive part of
sub-section 1 of Section 29A in terms of
which the timeline of twelve months for
making an arbitral award is not applicable
to it. In an international commercial
arbitration, the legislature has only
indicated that the award should be made
as expeditiously as possible and that an
endeavour may be made to dispose of the
matter within a period of twelve months
from the completion of pleadings.”
(emphasis supplied)
8.
While
dealing
with
a
similar
situation,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Civil Appeal No.10620
of 2024 [Arising out of
Special Leave
Petition
(Civil) No.23320 of 2023] titled as Rohan Builders
(India) Private Limited versus Berger Paints India
Limited, decided on 12.09.2024, has reiterated that
mandate of an Arbitrator is liable to be extended in
view of sufficient cause to the satisfaction of the Court,
in the following terms:“15. Rohan Builders (India) Pvt. Ltd. (supra)
2026:HHC:801
highlights that an interpretation allowing
an extension application post the expiry
period would encourage rogue litigants
and render the timeline for making the
award inconsequential. However, it is
apposite to note that under Section
29A(5), the power of the court to
extend the time is to be exercised only
in cases where there is sufficient cause
for such extension. Such extension is
not granted mechanically on filing of
the application. The judicial discretion of
the court in terms of the enactment acts
as a deterrent against any party abusing
the process of law or espousing a frivolous
or vexatious application. Further, the
court can impose terms and conditions
while granting an extension. Delay, even
on the part of the arbitral tribunal, is not
countenanced.28 The first proviso to
Section 29A(4) permits a fee reduction of
up to five percent for each month of delay
attributable to the arbitral tribunal.
16.
Lastly, Section 29A(6) does not support
the
narrow
interpretation
of
the
expression “terminate”. It states that the
court – while deciding an extension
application under Section 29A(4) – may
substitute one or all the arbitrators.
Section 29A(7) states that if a new
arbitrator(s)
is
appointed,
the
reconstituted arbitral tribunal shall be
deemed to be in continuation of the
previously appointed arbitral tribunal.
This obliterates the need to file a fresh
application under Section 11 of the A & C
Act for the appointment of an arbitrator.
In
the
event
of
substitution
of
arbitrator(s), the arbitral proceedings will
commence from the stage already reached.
Evidence or material already on record is
deemed to be received by the newly
constituted
tribunal.
The
aforesaid
deeming
provisions
underscore
the
legislative intent to effectuate efficiency
and expediency in the arbitral process.
2026:HHC:801
17.
18.
This intent is also demonstrated in
Sections 29A(8) and 29A(9). The court in
terms of Section 29A(8) has the power to
impose actual or exemplary costs upon
the parties. Lastly, Section 29A(9)
stipulates
that
an
application
for
extension under sub-section (5) must be
disposed of expeditiously, with the
endeavour of doing so within sixty days
from the date of filing.
As per the second proviso to Section
29A(4), the mandate of the arbitral
tribunal continues where an application
under
sub-section
(5)
is
pending.
However, an application for extension
of period of the arbitral tribunal is to be
decided by the court in terms of subsection (5), and sub-sections (6) to (8)
may be invoked. The power to extend
time period for making of the award
vests with the court, and not with the
arbitral tribunal. Therefore, the arbitral
tribunal may not pronounce the award
till an application under Section 29A(5)
of the A & C Act is sub-judice before
the court. In a given case, where an
award is pronounced during the pendency
of an application for extension of period of
the arbitral tribunal, the court must still
decide the application under sub-section
(5), and may even, where an award has
been pronounced, invoke, when required
and justified, sub-sections (6) to (8), or the
first and third proviso to Section 29A(4) of
the A & C Act.
While interpreting a statute, we must
strive to give meaningful life to an
enactment or rule and avoid cadaveric
consequences that result in unworkable
or
impracticable
scenarios.
An
interpretation which produces an
unreasonable result is not to be
imputed to a statute if there is some
other equally possible construction
which is acceptable, practical and
pragmatic.”
2026:HHC:801
9.
Even a perusal of the Statute prescribes
that arbitral proceedings are to be completed within
12 months and same were extendable by 6 months
with
consent
of
parties.
Though,
the
arbitral
proceedings were to be completed within 18 months
but
they
continued
from
till
the
passing
impugned order on 05.04.2023 [Annexure P-1] when,
the mandate of Learned Arbitrator stood terminated
and
arbitral
proceedings
were
kept
in
abeyance.
Material on record suggests that even after expiry of
months
period,
the
arbitral
proceedings
were
delayed primarily at the instance of respondent; and
due to procedural delays and due to administrative
delays for which parties cannot be made to suffer.
The parties have neither objected to the continuance
of
arbitral
proceedings
beyond
permissible
period
nor placed any material to show that any of the
parties
had
prayed
or
was
granted
extension
in
arbitral proceedings by this Court, earlier.
10.
to
Respondent No.1-NHAI cannot be permitted
raise
the
indisputably
similarly
delay
and
similar extension
was
given
to
Once
the
parties
placed
plea
of
landowners.
laches
when,
other
to
2026:HHC:801
arbitral proceedings, including the Respondents-NHAI
had
participated
permissible
in
period,
arbitral
therefore,
proceedings
the
mandate
beyond
of
the
Statute, [i.e. Arbitration and Conciliation Act] was to be
given a meaningful life, so as to make it workable
and practicable. Further, once the non-conclusion of
the arbitral proceedings was not attributable to the
petitioner;
therefore,
the
Respondents-NHAI
cannot
be permitted to raise the plea of delay and laches so
as to defeat the object and intent of the Enactment
but
efforts
should
be
to
make
it
practical
and
pragmatic, so as to enable the parties to settle their
disputes
by
alternative
resolution, in
an
effective,
efficient and expedient manner by arbitration. In these
circumstances,
sufficient
cause
for
enlargement
of
time for concluding the arbitral proceedings is made
out, in facts of instant case.
11.
Parties are also ad idem that based on
the mandate of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Tata Sons
Pvt. Ltd. and Rohan Builders (India) Private Limited
(supra) the matter is covered by the judgment of this
Court in Arbitration Case No.22 of 2025, titled as
Ghanshyam
Mahajan
versus
Land
Acquisition
2026:HHC:801
Officer-cum-Competent Authority
& Ors.,
decided
on 07.03.2025.
Likewise, Learned Counsel(s) place reliance
on
the
judgments
Arbitration
Case
passed
No.811
by
of
this
2024;
Court
in
re;
Hari
In
Ram Versus Collector Land Acquisition National
Highways Authority of India & Others, decided on
20.06.2025;
Arbitration
Case
In Re; Hari
Singh
Saini
Acquisition
Officer
&
&
No.126
Anr.
Another,
of
2025,
Versus
Land
decided
on
27.06.2025; Arbitration Case No.332 of 2025, In
Re; Meena Kumari Versus The Land Acquisition
Officer and another, decided on 19.11.2025; and
Arbitration Case No.384 of 2025, In Re; Balak Ram
Versus
Secretary
National
Highway
Authority
Delhi and another, decided on 23.12.2025, whereby,
the mandate of Learned Arbitrator was extended by
this Court, with directions to conclude the arbitral
proceedings
within
six
months
from
the
date
of
entirety
of
the
receipt of copy of the judgment.
DIRECTIONS:
12.
Taking
into
account
the
facts and circumstances and the object and intent
2026:HHC:801
of
arbitral
proceedings,
this
Court
allows
the
instant petition, in the following terms:-
In
(i)
Order dated 05.04.2023 [Annexure P-1]
in Case No.39 of 2019 by Learned
Arbitrator-cum-Divisional Commissioner,
Shimla is quashed and set aside;
(ii)
Arbitrator- cum- Divisional Commissioner
Shimla
is
mandated
to
complete
the arbitral proceedings and to pass
the Award in accordance with law
within six months from the date of
receipt of copy of this judgment; and
(iii)
Costs made easy for respective parties.
aforesaid
terms,
the
instant
petition
stands disposed of alongwith pending miscellaneous
application(s), if any.
January 02, 2026
[Bhardwaj]
(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review