Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:39161
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. : 649 of 2025
Decided on : 10.09.2026
Rajeev Kumar & Others
…Petitioners
Versus
Shyam Singh & Others
…Respondents
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Y.P. Sood & Mr. Praveen
Chauhan, Advocates.
For the respondents
:
Mr. Uday Singh Banyal,
Advocate, for respondent No.1
and 2.
Virender Singh, Judge (Oral)
Petitioners have filed the present petition, under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, against the order
dated
18.08.2025,
passed
by
the
Court
of
learned
Additional District Judge(1), Kangra at Dharamshala,
District Kangra, H.P. (hereinafter referred to as the ‘First
Appellate Court’), in Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No. 8
DXIV/2024, titled as ‘Rajeev Kumar & Others versus
Shyam Singh & Others’.
Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2.
2026:HHC:39161
By way of order dated 18.08.2025, the learned
First Appellate Court has dismissed the appeal preferred by
petitioners. The said appeal was preferred by them against
the order dated 21.03.2024, passed by the Court of learned
Civil Judge, Court No.1, Dharamshala, District Kangra
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the trial Court’), in CMA No.187
of 2023, titled as ‘Shyam Singh & Another versus Rajeev
Kumar & Others’.
3.
By way of order dated 21.03.2024, the learned
trial Court has allowed the application under Order 39
Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the CPC’) and directed the parties to
maintain status quo, qua the nature, construction and
possession of the suit land till the disposal of the suit.
4.
Parties to the present lis are hereinafter referred
to, in the same manner, in which, they were referred to, by
the learned trial Court.
5.
Brief facts, leading to the filing of the present
petition, before this Court, as borne out from the record,
may be summed up, as under:
5.1.
2026:HHC:39161
Plaintiffs have filed the suit for permanent
prohibitory injunction with a prayer to restrain the
defendants, their relatives, servants, family members,
masons, employees and assignees etc., from interfering in
the land, raising construction over the suit land and
changing the nature of the suit land by digging the same,
cutting any trees standing thereon and collecting building
material, raising any type of construction temporary or
permanent thereon, comprising in Khata No.18, Khatauni
Nо.28, 29, 30, 31, 32, Khasra No. 8, 13, 10, 7, 9, area
measuring 008794 Hects situated at Mohal Bhatehar,
Patwar Circle Sheela, Tehsil Dharamshala, Distt. Kangra
H.P. (hereinafter referred to as the suit land). In addition
to this, relief of mandatory injunction has also been
sought, directing the defendants to restore the suit land
into its original position and nature, in case, they succeed
to change the same, illegally and forcibly during the
pendency of the present suit.
5.2.
According to the plaintiffs, the suit land is
jointly owned by the plaintiffs along with defendants with
2026:HHC:39161
other cosharers, however, they have asserted their status
as ownersinpossession of the suit land.
5.3.
According to the plaintiffs, defendants are head
strong persons and defendant No.4 & 5 raised shops and
other construction by occupying the land, more than their
share of front side. Similarly, defendant No.6 also raised
construction of college, by occupying front portion of the
suit land, whereas, the land falling in the share of plaintiffs
is lying vacant and defendants No.1 to 3, put iron gate and
started construction in the suit and and also other
defendants have started to raise construction of boundary
walls and trying to occupying almost the front side of the
suit land.
6.
On the basis of the above facts, the relief, as
claimed in the plaint, has been sought.
7.
When put to notice, the suit has been contested
by the defendants.
8.
Defendants No.1 to 3 have filed their joint
written statemen,t by taking the preliminary objections,
that the suit is not maintainable; the plaintiffs have
estopped to file the present suit on account of their own act
2026:HHC:39161
and conduct; plaintiff on account of mutual partition never
objected to the construction raised by father of defendants
No.1 and 2 and husband of defendant No.3, who by
spending huge amount of money have raised more than
7/8 feet high retaining wall over the land, which he
obtained in mutual partition and constructed a Tin roofed
house; the suit of the plaintiffs is barred on account of
their act, conduct and acquiescence, as plaintiffs allowed
all other cosharers to raise construction even when
objected to and pointed out by the defendants in replies to
applications under Order 39 Rule 7 CPC and Section 151
CPC and the plaintiffs filed another suit, titled as Shyam
Singh versus Servjeet, which, according to them, is
persuaded with snails pace, as till date, service has not
been got affected upon the defendants; the plaintiffs have
suppressed material facts from the Court; the plaintiffs
have no cause of action; and the plaintiffs have no locus
standi to file the present suit.
9.
On merits, the suit has been contested by
pleading
that
the
suit
has
already
been
mutually
partitioned amongst all the cosharers and all the co
2026:HHC:39161
sharers are in separate possession and have developed the
plots falling in their shares, as per their wish, without
objections of any cosharers.
It has been admitted that
defendants No.4 and 5 has raised constructions of shops
and defendant No.6 has constructed big building having
four storeys, in which college is running in the name of
Awasthi College. It has also been admitted that defendants
No.1 and 2 have put iron gate about 2025 years back,
when he started work of supply of construction material.
9.1.
It is the further case of the defendants No.1 to 3
that they have raised 810 feet retaining wall and
developed their plots, by spending huge amount of money
and constructed two rooms having its tin roof.
At that
time, the plaintiffs or any other cosharers raised no
objection.
10.
Defendant No.4, has filed separate reply, by
pleading that plaintiff No.1 is cosharer to the extent of
3/384 share, out of 192 share, area measuring 00068
hectares, in the suit land measuring 08794 hectares and
plaintiff No.2 is the cosharer to the extent of 1/192 share,
2026:HHC:39161
area measuring 000046 hectares in the suit land
measuring 08794 hectares.
10.1.
Admitting the fact that the suit land is joint
only in the revenue record, according to defendant No.4
every cosharer is in separate possession on the spot.
11.
Plaintiffs
filed
replication
to
the
written
statements filed by the defendants, by denying the
preliminary objections, as well as the allegations, upon
which the suit has been contested.
12.
Along with the suit, application, under Order 39
Rules 1 and 2 CPC, has also been filed with a prayer to
restrain the defendants from interfering in the suit land,
raising any sort of construction, changing the nature,
cutting any trees and collecting building material, over the
suit land, during the pendency of the lis.
13.
This application has also been contested on the
similar grounds, upon which, the main suit has been
contested.
14.
The learned trial Court, after hearing learned
counsel for the parties has allowed the application, as
2026:HHC:39161
referred to above and the said order has unsuccessfully
been assailed before the learned First Appellate Court.
15.
Now, the unsuccessful defendants No.1 to 3
have assailed the said order, before this Court, under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, on the ground that
both the Courts below have committed grave illegality and
material irregularity, as both the Courts below have failed
to appreciate the pleadings of the parties.
16.
According to the petitionersdefendants No.1 to
3, the status quo order has been passed by the learned
trial Court merely on the basis of the fact that the suit land
is recorded as joint in the revenue record, but, both the
Courts below have failed to appreciate the fact that the
entries in the revenue record did not reflect the factual
position of the spot, in view of the specific stand taken by
the parties in their pleadings, according to which, the suit
land has mutually been partitioned amongst all the co
sharers
and
thereafter,
the
cosharers
have
raised
construction on the spot.
17.
It is the further case of the petitioners
defendants No.1 to 3 that the relief has wrongly been
2026:HHC:39161
granted to the plaintiff ignoring the fact that merely
because a cosharer is raising construction does not entitle
the other cosharer to seek injunction.
18.
The findings have further been assailed on the
ground that the learned trial Court has failed to appreciate
the fact that the house of petitioners is existing there on
the spot, which was constructed about 2030 years ago
from the date of filing the suit.
19.
The findings have further been assailed on the
ground that the one of the cosharers has raised a big
building and is runnig a B.Ed. College, and the said
construction was raised without any objection, as such,
according to defendant No.1, plaintiffs are not entitled to
the relief, as claimed in the application.
20.
On the basis of the above facts, Mr. Y.P. Sood,
Advocate, appearing for petitonersdefendants No.1 to 3,
has prayed that the present petition may kindly be allowed,
by setting aside the order, passed by the learned trial
Court and the application, under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2
CPC, may kindly be dismissed.
21.
2026:HHC:39161
Per contra, Mr. Uday Singh Banyal, Advocate
appearing for the plaintiffs, has supported the order by
arguing that the learned trial Court has rightly appreciated
the stand taken by the parties, in their pleadings and the
said order does not require any interference by this Court,
as, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, this
Court can only interfere, when, it has been held that the
order passed by the learned trial Court suffers from
perversity and the learned trial Court has wrongly
exercised the jurisdiction vested in it or failed to exercise
the jurisdiction vested in it.
In the present case, the
jurisdiction vested in the Court has been exercised
properly. Hence, a prayer has been made to dismiss the
petition.
22.
Heard.
23.
Admittedly, the parties to the lis are cosharers.
In this case, it is the admitted position of fact that none of
the cosharers has even bothered to file the suit for
partition. So far as the plea of private partition, as taken
by the defendants, in the present case is concerned, in the
revenue record, the suit land is still joint, as depicted from
2026:HHC:39161
the perusal of Jamabandi, in which, in the column of
possession against Khasra No.13, names of Shri Ashok
Kumar and Smt. Veena Devi have been mentioned.
Similarly, in
the column of possession against Khasra
No.10, names of Shri Mahinder Singh, Shyam Singh,
Sheela Devi Surinder Singh, Jagtar Singh, has been
mentioned, whereas, against Khasra No.7, names of
Awasthi College Awasthi Educational Society, has been
mentioned in the column of possession and in Khasra
No.9, name of Kashmir Singh has been recorded. As such,
at this stage, it cannot be said that the suit land is joint
between the parties.
24.
It is not the case of the defendants that they
have moved application under Section 123 of the H.P. Land
Revenue Act, for affecting the private partition in the
revenue record.
25.
Admittedly, none of the parties has bothered to
file application for partition of the suit land.
26.
In para 3 of the plaint, the plaintiffs have
asserted the fact that defendant No.4 & 5 raised shops and
other construction by occupying the land, more than their
2026:HHC:39161
share and defendant No 6 also raised construction of
college by occupying front portion. Meaning thereby, the
cosharers have already raised construction, without any
objection raised by the plaintiffs.
As such, defendants
No.1 to 3 cannot be segregated by the plaintiffs at their
sweet will.
27.
Pleadings of the plaintiffs are too short to
conclude, at this stage, that if the relief, as claimed, in the
application, is granted to the plaintiffs, the same would
amount to ouster of the other cosharers from the suit
land.
Such type of plea has also not been taken by the
plaintiffs in their suit. They have not asserted the fact that
the defendants have no share in the suit land.
28.
Situation would have been otherwise, had the
plaintiffs filed suit seeking injunction, restraining the
defendants from raising construction, changing the nature
of the suit land, till the suit land is partitioned by metes
and bounds.
29.
Moreover, the defendants cannot be vexed
twice; firstly, in the suit and secondly, in the partition
2026:HHC:39161
proceedings. The relief of injunction is equitable relief. The
person, who is seeking equity must do equity.
30.
At the cost of repetition, it can be said that the
plaintiffs have not made any efforts to get the suit land
partitioned and without making any efforts, they have
dragged the defendants in the litigation, in which, a prayer
has been made to restrain them from raising any sort of
construction, even when they are held to be cosharers.
31.
Considering
the
peculiar
facts
and
circumstances of the present case, since the plaintiffs have
already raised constructions over the suit land, the
defendants
cannot
be
restrained
construction over the suit land.
from
raising
the
As such, the plaintiffs
have miserably failed to make out a case, seeking
injunction against the defendants from raising any sort of
construction.
32.
Consequently, this Court is of the view that the
findings recorded by the learned trial Court are suffering
from perversity and the learned trial Court has exceeded its
jurisdiction,
while
deciding
the
application,
without
2026:HHC:39161
considering the acts and conduct of the plaintiffs, in not
moving the application, for partition of the suit land.
33.
Accordingly, the present petition is allowed and
the order dated 21.03.2024, passed by the learned trial
Court, as upheld by the learned First Appellate Court, is
set aside. Consequently, the application, under Order 39
Rules 1 and 2 CPC, is dismissed.
34.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any,
shall also stand disposed of.
35.
Parties,
through
the
learned
counsel,
are
directed to appear before the learned trial Court on 28th
September, 2026, at 10.00 a.m.
36.
Any of the observations made herein above
shall not be taken as an expression of opinion on the
merits of the case, as these observations are confined only
to the disposal of the present petition.
Record be sent back immediately.
September 10, 2026( ps )
( Virender Singh )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review