Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:3291 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
OMP No. 1236 of 2025 in
Civil Suit No. 39 of 2025
Reserved on: 06.01.2026
Date of decision: 09.01.2026
_____________________________________________________
Dr. Rajeev Bindal
…..Applicant/plaintiff.
Versus
Kapil Garg @ Monty Garg
……Non-applicant/defendant.
________________________________________________
Coram
The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sushil Kukreja, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the applicant:
Mr. Sudhir Thakur, Senior
Advocate, with Mr. Karun Negi and
Mr. Somesh Sharma, Advocates.
For non-applicant:
Mr. Nitin Thakur, Advocate.
Sushil Kukreja, Judge.
The instant application has been preferred by the
applicant (plaintiff) under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of Code of Civil
Procedure (CPC) read with Section 151 CPC with the prayer that
the non-applicant be restrained from circulating, publishing,
posting articles, news items on his facebook account, whatsapp,
twitter or any other social media platforms concerning the
applicant in any manner and to cause imputation to the applicant
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:3291 )
in any manner during the pendency of the instant civil suit.
2.
It is averred in the application that the applicant was
Speaker of Himachal Pradesh Vidhan Sabha from January, 2018.
He is also an elected member of Himachal Pradesh Legislative
Assembly from Nahan constituency for two consecutive terms and
earlier he was member of Legislative Assembly from Solan
Constituency. It is further averred that the respondent is councilor
of Municipal Council Nahan, District Sirmour, and he is actively
involved in the activities of a political party and due to political
differences with the applicant and to create false narrative against
him, the non-applicant makes imputation against him on social
media by using facebook account in the name of Monty Garg and
by making false representation in this regard, just to tarnish the
reputation of the applicant in the High Command in BJP circle,
amongst relatives, friends, nears and dears and the general public
at large. As per the applicant, the non-applicant is indulging in
unfair and malafide tactics and acts to gain political mileage and
for doing so he is raising unfounded allegations of corruption
against him to harm his reputation.
3.
The non-applicant, by filing reply to the application,
raised preliminary objections, viz., maintainability of the application
2026:HHC:3291 )
and the same being bad in law, bad for mis-joinder/non-joinder of
necessary parties. On merits, the non-applicant denied that he is
making false narrative against the applicant so as to tarnish his
reputation in the High Command in the BJP Circle, amongst the
relatives, friends, nears and dears and the general public at large.
He also denied that he is indulging in unfair and malafide tactics to
gain political mileage.
He admitted that there are political
differences between the applicant and him and the instant
applicant has been filed just to harass and create pressure upon
the non-applicant, as he wants to contest forth coming Municipal
Council Elections from MC Nahan and there is every likelihood of
his success. Lastly, the non-applicant prayed for dismissal of the
instant application.
4.
The learned Senior Counsel for the applicant/plaintiff
contended the defendant has been raising unfounded allegations
of corruption against him on his Facebook account knowingly and
intentionally, which are not genuine and authentic and
which has
tarnished his reputation and integrity, therefore, he submitted that
the defendant may be
restrained from circulating, publishing,
posting articles, news items on Facebook account(s) maintained
by him or on any other social media.
2026:HHC:3291 )
5.
Conversely, the learned counsel for the non-applicant
contended that the instant civil suit and the application is an
outcome of political vendetta and also to harass the non-applicant,
as there are political differences between the applicant and nonapplicant.
He also contended that the applicant wants to gain
political mileage, therefore, he has filed the instant suit and the
application.
He further submitted
that the Indian Constitution
guarantees freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)
(a) and in a democratic society, freedom of expression is
paramount and cannot be curtailed merely due to dissent or
criticism.
6.
I have heard the learned Senior Counsel/counsel for
the parties and meticulously examined the entire material available
on record.
7.
Freedom of speech and expression as envisaged
under Article 19(1) of the Constitution of India is not an absolute
right and the same is subject to the reasonable restrictions
provided under Article 19(2) of the Constitution.The position of law
as to the prior restraint on the publication has been revisited by
the Supreme Court in a number of cases. In Reliance
Petrochemicals Ltd vs. Proprietors Of Indian Express, AIR
2026:HHC:3291 )
1989 SC 190 Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that the Court can
pass interim orders restraining the publication if the Court finds
that there exists a real and imminent danger that the continuance
of
the
publication
would
result
in
interference
with
the
administration of justice. It further held that everyone has the right
to freedom of expression, but since the exercise of this freedom
carries with it duties and responsibilities, it may be subject to such
formalities, conditions, restrictions or penalties as are prescribed
by law and are necessary in a democratic society for the
protection of the reputation or rights of others. The relevant portion
of the aforesaid judgement reads as under:
“14.The law on this aspect has been adverted to in the decision
of this Court in Indian Express Newspapers (Bombay) Pvt. Ltd.
& Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., [1985] 1 SCC 641, where at
page 659 of the report, Justice Venkataramiah referred to the
importance of freedom of Press in a democratic society and the
role of Courts. Though the Indian Constitution does not use the
expression 'freedom of press' in Article 19 but it is included as
one of the guarantees in Article 19 [1] [a]. The freedom of
Press, as noted by Venkataramiah J., is one of the around
which the greatest and the bitterest of constitutional struggles
have been PG NO 225 waged in all countries where liberal
constitutions prevail. Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights, 1948 declares the freedom of Press and so
does Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights, 1966. Article 10 of the European Convention on
Human Rights, provides as follows:
"Article 10-(1) Everyone has the right to freedom of
expression. This right shall include freedom to hold
opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas
without interference by public authority and regardless of
frontiers. This Article shall not prevent States from
requiring the licensing of broadcasting, television or
2026:HHC:3291 )
cinema enterprise.
(2) The exercise of these freedoms, since it carries with it
duties and responsibilities, may be subject to such
formalities, conditions, restrictions or penalties as are
prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic
society, in the interests of national security, territorial
integrity or public safety, for the prevention of disorder or
crime, for the protection of health or morals, for the
protection of the reputation or rights of others, for
preventing the disclosure of information received in
confidence, or for maintaining the authority and
impartiality of the judiciary."
8.
In Express Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. & Ors vs. Union
Of India, AIR 1986 SC 872, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
emphasized that though the freedom of press is an inalienable
right, but the same is not absolute and is subject to Article 19 (2),
as uncontrolled right to speech leads to anarchism. The Supreme
Court observed thus:
"76.I would only like to stress that the freedom of thought and
expression, and the freedom of the press are not only valuable
freedoms in themselves but are basic to a democratic form of
Government which proceeds on the theory that problems of the
Government can be solved by the free exchange of thought and
by public discussion of the various issues facing the nation. It is
necessary to emphasize and one must not forget that the vital
importance of freedom of speech and expression involves the
freedom to dissent to a free democracy like ours. Democracy
relies on the freedom of the press. It is the inalienable right of
everyone to comment freely upon any matter of public
importance. This right is one of the pillars of individual libertyfreedom of speech, which our Court has always unfailingly
guarded. I wish to add that however precious and cherished the
freedom of speech is under Art.19(1)(a), this freedom is not
absolute and unlimited at all times and under all circumstances
2026:HHC:3291 )
but is subject to the restrictions contained in Art. 19(2). That
must be so because unrestricted freedom of speech and
expression which includes the freedom of the press and is
wholly free from restraints, amounts to uncontrolled licence
which would lead to disorder and anarchy and it would be
hazardous to ignore the vital importance of our social and
national interest in public order and security of the State."
9.
In the case of Sahara India Real Estate Corporation
Limited and Others vs. Securities and Exchange Board of
India & Another, (2012) 10 SCC 603, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has laid down principles governing the passing of the prior
restraint order against the publication in some exceptional cases
and discussed in detail the exceptions involved.
10.
Tested on the anvil of the aforesaid pronouncement of
law, in the present case, the plaintiff admittedly was the Speaker of
Himachal Pradesh Vidhan Sabha and was an elected Member of
the Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly for two successive
terms and had also remained as
Health Minister of Himachal
Pradesh. The plaintiff is well known figure in the society and at
present he is the President of State Unit of a National Political
Party. As per the plaintiff, the defendant has been raising
unfounded allegations of corruption against him knowing fully well
that the same are false and the defendant has indulged in
2026:HHC:3291 )
tarnishing reputation and integrity of the plaintiff in the estimation
of public at large, political circle, relatives, friends social circle and
the High Command of his own political party by publishing
defamatory and derogatory statements on his Facebook account
maintained by him with the sole motive to degrade and demean
the reputation of the plaintiff in the estimation of public at large and
with the motive to gain some political mileage.
11.
On the other hand, the defendant has denied such
allegations levelled by the plaintiff. It has been averred by the
defendant that the suit/application filed by the plaintiff is not
maintainable and fundamental right of speech of the defendant
cannot be curtailed by such false, frivolous and vexatious
suit/application. It has been denied that the defendant is making
false narrative against the plaintiff so as to tarnish the reputation of
the plaintiff. It has also been denied that the defendant has been
indulging in posting defamatory and unfounded allegations in his
Facebook account maintained by him against the plaintiff.
12.
Needless to state that at the stage of deciding the
present application, no conclusive findings can be given in order to
ascertain the correctness or falsity of the allegations. However, on
perusal of the material available on record, the plaintiff has been
2026:HHC:3291 )
able to make out a strong prima facie case in his favour as in my
opinion, the
un-verified allegations can tarnish the image and
reputation of the plaintiff in the eyes of public at large, his near and
dear ones, his social circle, family, friends and his political circle.
The balance of the convenience is also in favour of the plaintiff as
the degree of the prejudice is far more excessive than that of the
defendant. In case interim relief is denied to him, irreparable loss
and injury shall ensue to the plaintiff at this stage and not to the
defendant and which cannot be compensated in terms of money if
such publications are not postponed.
13.
As observed earlier, one's fundamental right to
freedom of speech and expression is not absolute. It is not
extended to the extent of causing harm to the interest of others
and bring down others name and fame. One can swing his
umbrella freely as he likes but it comes to an end when it touches
other man's nose. Thus, in the facts and circumstances of the
case, the arguments based on Article 19(i)(a) of the Constitution of
India made by the learned Counsel for the defendant cannot be
accepted.
14.
Hence, in view of my aforementioned discussion, non-
applicant/defendant is restrained from circulating, publishing,
2026:HHC:3291 )
posting articles, news items on Facebook account(s), maintained
by him under different ID(s), Whatsapp, Twitter or any other social
media and media platforms concerning the applicant/plaintiff in any
manner and to cause imputation to the applicant/plaintiff in any
manner either by non-applicant/defendant or through his agents,
servants, assignees, family members etc., during the pendency of
the present suit.
15.
Be it stated that any expression of opinion given in this
order does not mean an expression of opinion on the merits of the
case and the same has been given only for the purpose of
deciding the present application.
The application stands disposed of.
( Sushil Kukreja )
Judge
9th January, 2026
(raman)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review