Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 01st OCTOBER, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
#
CNR No. DLHC010590772005
+
ITA 1215/2005 & CM APPL. 44560/2026
RAJ PAL KATYAL
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Rahul Agrawal, Mr. Rajesh
Agrawal and Mr. Sunil Dhamija,
Advocates.
versus
THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Shlok Chandra, Sr. Standing
Counsel with Ms. Naincy Jain, Jr.
Standing Counsel, Mr. Udit Dad and
Mr. Ujjwal Jain, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The challenge in the present Appeal is to the Order dated 02.03.2005
passed by the Ld. Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [‘ITAT’] in ITA
No.4580/DEL/2000 for the Assessment Year 1997-98.
2.
Vide Order dated 16.05.2006, the following substantial question of
law was formulated for determination:
“1. Whether the finding recorded by the ITAT that the
appellate assessee had not proved creditworthiness of
its creditors is perverse?”
3.
Shorn of unnecessary details, the facts leading to the filing of the
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
present Appeal are that the Assessee is an individual and Proprietor of M/s
Kailash Engineers, which is engaged in the business of trading, servicing
and installation of Generators and Generators parts.
4.
The Assessee filed his return on 31.10.1997 declaring income of
Rs.2,02,320/- which, according to the Assessee, was processed on
18.12.1997 under the provisions of Section 143(1) of the Income Tax Act,
1961 [‘IT Act’].
5.
It is stated that a Notice under Section 143(2) of the IT Act was issued
to the Assessee by the Assessing Officer on 20.10.1998 and an Assessment
Order was framed by the Assessing Officer under Section 143(3) of the IT
Act on 30.03.2000, in which the Assessing Officer made additions of
Rs.9,00,400/- treating unsecured loans as undisclosed income under Section
68 of the IT Act.
6.
Thereafter, an Appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax
(Appeals) [‘CIT(A)’] was filed by the Assessee, whereby the Ld. CIT(A)
vide Order dated 17.08.2000 deleted a sum of Rs.2,00,400/- out of
Rs.9,00,400/-. The said Order dated 17.08.2000 was further challenged by
the Assessee before the Ld. ITAT wherein the following ground was raised
by the Assessee:
“The ld AO and ld CIT(A) have erred in law and facts
in making
and confirming the addition of
Rs.7,00,000=00 out of unsecured loans whereby they
have not passed their orders in respect of the above
items after careful consideration of all legal points and
relevant facts and circumstances of the case as brought
out by the documents and evidences filed and
statements on oath of the loan creditors and other
persons recorded before the ld AO".
7.
The Ld. ITAT, by the Impugned Order dated 02.03.2005, rejected the
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
Appeal filed by the Assessee and confirmed the Order dated 17.08.2000
passed by the Ld. CIT(A).
8.
It is this Order dated 02.03.2005 passed by the Ld. ITAT, which is
under challenge in the present Appeal.
9.
Before proceeding further with the case, it is first necessary to refer to
the Order dated 30.03.2000 passed by the Assessing Officer. The Assessing
Officer, in order to ascertain as to whether the amounts could be treated as
undisclosed income or not, asked the Assessee to prove the creditworthiness
of the persons from whom loans have been secured. The Assessing Officer
examined five persons, namely, Sh. Surender Katyal, Sh. Pawan Kumar, Ms.
Vimla Arora, Sh. S. L. Magoo and Ms. Santosh Rani produced by the
Assessee. On analysing the evidence led by these persons, the Assessing
Officer came to the conclusion that the Assessee has failed to discharge his
onus of creditworthiness to secure loans.
10.
The Ld. CIT(A) once again, vide Order dated 17.08.2000 examined
the creditworthiness of these persons and came to the conclusion that out of
total addition of Rs.9,00,400/-, a sum of Rs.7,00,000/- is sustained and the
balance of Rs.2,00,400/- is to be deleted. The relevant portion of the Order
dated 17.08.2000 passed by the Ld. CIT(A) is reproduced as under:
“9ᵗʰ ground is on addition of Rs.9,00,400/- out of
unsecured loans. During the year under consideration
the appellant disclosed loans from friends and relatives
of an amount of Rs.9,00,400/- which was added back
on the ground that the credit worthiness of the
creditors were not proved. The Assessing officer
required the appellant to produce the creditor along
with their confirmation to establish the genuineness of
the loan. From the evidence filed it was noted that
although the credits were mostly by cheques, many of
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
them were no income tax assesses. In the case of some
of the creditors even confirmations were not filed,
affidavits were, however filed in the case of majority of
the cash creditors. Some of the creditors namely
Sh.Surinder Katyal, Pawan Kumar ,Vimla Arora,
S.L.Magoo and Santosh Rani were interrogated.
Details and relevant portion of their statements have
been noted on pages 4 to 7 of the assessment order.
As per the noting in the assessment order the persons
concerned either denied having advanced any loan or
having advanced the loan were not very sure of where
the money came from. The bank a/c of these persons
also had cash entries which could not be explained by
the account holder. On the basis of submission filed the
A.Officer held that the onus of establishing the
creditorworthiness of the loan were not fully
discharged as the creditors were either not produced at
all or that those produced did not offer a satisfactory
explanation to the amounts advanced out of the list of
creditors the amount advanced by only Sandeep Arora
and Sh.J.M.Arora were considered genuine as they
were income tax assesses and the balance amount of
Rs.9,00400/-was deemed as income of the assessee.
The A.R. explained that in the case of the following
creditors involving a total amount of Rs.7,18,000/- all
of them had replied having advanced loan to M/s
Kailash Engineers the proprietory concern of the
appellant
Pawan Kumar
Santosh Rani
Surinder Katyal
Vimla Arora
S.L. Magoo
Total
50,000.00
4,50,000.00
18,000.00
1,00,000.00
1,00,000.00
7,18,000.00
It was explained that the confirmation and affidavits
were filed and the advances having been made by
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
Account Payee cheque the loans received from these
parties should be accepted. It was argued that having
established the source the assessee can not be
presumed to have special knowledge about the source
of the source. As decided by judicial authorities like
Tolaram daga (1966) 59 ITR 632 (Assam) and Daulat
Ram Rawatmull, 87 ITR 349 (SC) etc.
All the above creditors were stated to have admitted to
having advanced loans and therefore there was no
reason to disallow the loan advanced by these parties.
Regarding Narinder Kumar who advanced an amount
of Rs.50,000/- it was stated that Sh. Kumar was
produced for interrogation but the A.Officer did not
record his statement .The identity and genuinity of the
aforementioned parties were stated to have been duly
established and it was for the department to show why
the explanation can not be accepted and why the credit
should be taken as income of the assesses from
suppressed sources. Regarding Loan of Rs.1,32,400/which was received from the following parties it was
stated that the amount were received in the year prior
to the relevant previous year.
Narinder kumar
Anil Sikka
Jagan Nath
Naresh kumar
Parveen Katyal
P.C. Jain & Co.
R.K. Pandey
Total
50,000
22,000
14,000
20,500
27,500
25,000
23,400
1,32,400
It was argued that the amount not having been
received in the relevant year no addition could be
made in this year as held by various courts including
Delhi High Court in the case of O.P. Mahajan & Sons
152 ITR 503. It was also pointed out that the A. officer
was requested to summon the parties u/s 131 but no
such efforts was made. In view of the above
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
explanation it was requested that the credits were
genuine as established on the basis of the evidences
and therefore no addition should have been made in
this regard.
The appellant’s claim relating to the loan of
Rs.7,18,000/- received from the parties mentioned
above is not found to be acceptable as the explanation
offered is not satisfactory.
The only loan amount of Rs.18,000/- received from Sh.
Surinder Katyal a Government servant is found to be
acceptable as being in service it is not difficult for him
to advance a small amount of Rs.18,000/-. In the case
of Sh Pawan Kumar, he has denied having advanced
any loan at all to the appellant. Therefore the addition
of Rs.50,000/- in this account is correct .
Smt. Santosh Rani admitted to having advanced an
amount of Rs.4,50,000/- but could not explain how the
money was raised or even the cash credit in her
account preceding the advancing of the loan. Smt
Vimla Arora’s case was also similar while Sh
S.L.Magοο denied having advanced any loan at all.
Therefore out of the total credit of Rs.718,000/- only
Rs.18,000/- is found to be acceptable and the addition
of Rs.7,00,000/- is confirmed.
Regarding Rs.50,000/- advanced by Sh. Narinder
Kumar, the Assessing officer does not however have
any direct evidence as Sh. N.Kumar’s statement was
not recorded and as there is nothing to prove to the
contrary the benefit of doubt should be allowed to the
appellant and the addition of Rs.50,000/- is deleted.
The loan of Rs.1,32,400/- raised in the year earlier to
the previous year under consideration can not also be
added to the current year income as the loan were not
raised during the current year. Even if the assessing
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
officer rejected these credit entries it should be
considered only in those years when the loans were
raised and it can not be treated as income of the
current year .The addition of Rs.1,32,000/- is also
therefore deleted. Out of the total addition of
Rs.9,00,400/- addition of Rs.7,00,000/- is sustained
and the balance of Rs.2,00,400/- is deleted…..”
11.
The Ld. ITAT once again vide the Impugned Order dated 02.03.2005
analysed the statements given by four persons, namely, Pawan Kumar,
Santosh Rani, Vimla Arora and S.L. Magoo, who according to the Assessee
had advanced cash loans of Rs.50,000/-, Rs.4,50,000/-, 1,00,000/- and
Rs.1,00,000/- respectively, totalling to Rs.7,00,000/-, and came to the
conclusion that the Ld. CIT(A) was justified in holding that the
creditworthiness of these persons has not been established by the Assessee.
12.
This Court has perused the examination of the witnesses produced by
the Assessee and the also the analysis of the witnesses by the three
authorities below. This Court is satisfied that the inference drawn by the
three authorities below regarding the creditworthiness of the witnesses has
not been proved.
13.
Section 68 of the IT Act reads as under:
“Cash credits.
68. Where any sum is found credited in the books of an
assessee maintained for any previous year, and the
assessee offers no explanation about the nature and
source thereof or the explanation offered by him is not,
in the opinion of the Assessing Officer, satisfactory, the
sum so credited may be charged to income-tax as the
income of the assessee of that previous year:
Provided that where the sum so credited consists of
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
loan or borrowing or any such amount, by whatever
name called, any explanation offered by such assessee
shall be deemed to be not satisfactory, unless,—
(a) the person in whose name such credit is
recorded in the books of such assessee also offers
an explanation about the nature and source of
such sum so credited; and
(b) such explanation in the opinion of the
Assessing Officer aforesaid has been found to be
satisfactory:
Provided further that where the assessee is a company
(not being a company in which the public are
substantially interested), and the sum so credited
consists of share application money, share capital,
share premium or any such amount by whatever name
called, any explanation offered by such assesseecompany shall be deemed to be not satisfactory,
unless—
(a) the person, being a resident in whose name such
credit is recorded in the books of such company also
offers an explanation about the nature and source of
such sum so credited; and
(b) such explanation in the opinion of the Assessing
Officer aforesaid has been found to be satisfactory:
Provided also that nothing contained in the first
proviso or second proviso shall apply if the person, in
whose name the sum referred to therein is recorded, is
a venture capital fund or a venture capital company as
referred to in clause (23FB) of section 10.
14.
The parameters that have to be established by an Assessee under
Section 68 of the IT Act has been succinctly explained by the Apex Court in
CIT v. NRA Iron & Steel (P) Ltd., (2019) 15 SCC 529, which read as under:
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
“9. We have heard the learned counsel for the
Revenue, and examined the material on record.
9.1. The issue which arises for determination is
whether the respondent assessee had discharged the
primary onus to establish the genuineness of the
transaction required under Section 68 of the said Act.
9.2. Section 68 of the IT Act (prior to the Finance
Act, 2012) read as follows:
“68. Cash credits.—Where any sum is found
credited in the books of an assessee maintained for any
previous year, and the assessee offers no explanation
about the nature and source thereof or the explanation
offered by him is not, in the opinion of the assessing
officer, satisfactory, the sum so credited may be
charged to income tax as the income of the assessee of
that previous year.”
(emphasis supplied)
The use of the words “any sum found credited in the
books” in Section 68 of the Act indicates that the
section is widely worded, and includes investments
made by the introduction of share capital or share
premium.
9.3. As per settled law, the initial onus is on the
assessee to establish by cogent evidence the
genuineness of the transaction, and creditworthiness of
the investors under Section 68 of the Act. The assessee
is expected to establish to the satisfaction of the
assessing officer [CIT v. Precision Finance (P) Ltd.,
1993 SCC OnLine Cal 384 : (1994) 208 ITR 465] :
• Proof of identity of the creditors;
• Capacity of creditors to advance money; and
• Genuineness of transaction
This Court in the landmark case of Kale Khan Mohd.
Hanif v. CIT [Kale Khan Mohd. Hanif v. CIT, (1963)
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
50 ITR 1] and, Roshan Di Hatti v. CIT [Roshan Di
Hatti v. CIT, (1977) 2 SCC 378 : 1977 SCC (Tax) 292 :
(1977) 107 ITR 938] laid down that the onus of
proving the source of a sum of money found to have
been received by an assessee, is on the assessee. Once
the assessee has submitted the documents relating to
identity, genuineness of the transaction, and
creditworthiness, then the AO must conduct an inquiry,
and call for more details before invoking Section 68. If
the assessee is not able to provide a satisfactory
explanation of the nature and source, of the
investments made, it is open to the Revenue to hold that
it is the income of the assessee, and there would be no
further burden on the Revenue to show that the income
is from any particular source.
9.4. With respect to the issue of genuineness of
transaction, it is for the assessee to prove by cogent
and credible evidence, that the investments made in
share capital are genuine borrowings, since the facts
are exclusively within the assessee's knowledge.
9.5. The Delhi High Court in CIT v. Oasis
Hospitalities (P) Ltd. [CIT v. Oasis Hospitalities (P)
Ltd., 2011 SCC OnLine Del 506 : (2011) 333 ITR 119]
, held that: (SCC OnLine Del para 43)
“43. … the initial onus is upon the assessee to
establish three things necessary to obviate the mischief
of Section 68 of the Act. These are: (i) identity of the
investors; (ii) their creditworthiness/investments; and
(iii) genuineness of the transaction. Only when these
three ingredients are established prima facie, the
department is required to undertake further
exercise….”
9.6. It has been held that merely proving the identity
of the investors does not discharge the onus of the
assessee, if the capacity or creditworthiness has not
been established. In Shankar Ghosh v. CIT [Shankar
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
Ghosh v. CIT, 1985 Tax Pub (DT) 1012 : (1985) 13
ITD 440 : (1985) 23 TTJ 20] , the assessee failed to
prove the financial capacity of the person from whom
he had allegedly taken the loan. The loan amount was
rightly held to be the assessee's own undisclosed
income.
9.7. Reliance was also placed on CIT v. Kamdhenu
Steel & Alloys Ltd. [CIT v. Kamdhenu Steel & Alloys
Ltd., 2011 SCC OnLine Del 5581] wherein the Court
held that: (SCC OnLine Del para 38)
“38. Even in that instant case, it is projected by the
Revenue that the Directorate of Income Tax
(Investigation) had purportedly found such a racket of
floating bogus companies with sole purpose of lending
entries. But, it is unfortunate that all this exercise is
going in vain as few more steps which should have
been taken by the Revenue in order to find out causal
connection between the cash deposited in the bank
accounts of the applicant banks and the assessee were
not taken. It is necessary to link the assessee with the
source when that link is missing, it is difficult to fasten
the assessee with such a liability.”
10. The judgments cited hold that the assessing
officer ought to conduct an independent enquiry to
verify the genuineness of the credit entries.”
15.
Applying the dictum laid down by the Apex Court in the aforesaid
Judgment to the facts of the present case, it cannot be said that the
appreciation of material by the three authorities below i.e., Assessing
Officer, Ld. CIT(A) and Ld. ITAT, is perverse and that the Assessee has
been able to prove the creditworthiness of his creditors.
16.
Reliance placed by the learned Counsel for the Appellant on a
Judgment passed by a Division Bench of this Court in Principal
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
Commissioner of Income-Tax v. KRBL Infrastructure Ltd., (2026) 486 ITR
88 cannot be accepted. In the said Judgment, the Assessing Officer, on the
basis of material, had accepted the creditworthiness of the creditors and the
Assessment Order was upheld by the Ld. CIT(A) and the Ld. ITAT and this
Court
rejected
the
Appeal
preferred
by
the
Appellant/Principal
Commissioner of Income-Tax. The observations made by the Division
Bench of this Court in Paragraph Nos.35 & 36 of the said Judgment have to
be appreciated in the context of the facts of that case. In fact, the Division
Bench of this Court, taking into account the facts of that case, held that the
genuineness of the transactions has been confirmed by two authorities below
and, therefore, the same is a pure question of fact, unlike in the present case
where all three authorities below are of the opinion that the Assessee has not
discharged his initial onus to prove the creditworthiness of the persons from
whom the loan has been secured.
17.
In view of the above, the question of law formulated in the present
Appeal is answered in favour of the Respondent/Department and against the
Assessee.
18.
Resultantly,
the
Appeal
is
dismissed,
along
with
pending
application(s), if any.
SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J
AMIT SHARMA, J
OCTOBER 01, 2026
S. Zakir
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:49:57
ITA 1215/2005
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review