Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
Cr.MP(M) No. 797 of 2026
Reserved on.: 24.06.2026
Announced on: 25.06.2026
____________________________________________________________
Raj Kumar
.......Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
……Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge
1 Whether approved for reporting?
Yes.
For the petitioner:
Mr.
Yashveer
Advocate.
Singh
Rathore,
For the respondent:
-State
Mr. Pawan Kumar Nadda, Additional
Advocate General for Respondents.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge
Bail petitioner [Raj Kumar], being in custody
since
05.02.2025
has
under
seeking
bail,
Nagarik
Suraksha
come
up
before
Section
of
Sanhita,
(referred
this
the
to
Court,
Bharatiya
as
BNSS)
originating from FIR No. 33 of 2025 dated 05.02.2025,
registered
at
Police
Station
Nurpur,
Police
District
Nurpur, Kangra [H.P.], under Section 21, 25 and 29 of
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
the
Narcotic
Drugs
-2-
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
Psychotropic
Substances
and
Act
(referred to as the NDPS Act).
FACTUAL MATRIX:
2.
Case set up by Learned Counsel is that the
bail petitioner [Raj Kumar] was detained by the police
and was subsequently arrested on 05.02.2025 and has
been falsely implicated. It is averred that there is no
corroborative evidence directly or indirectly to reveal the
conscious and direct involvement either in procurement,
possession or trafficking of the alleged narcotic substances.
It is averred that bail petitioner has been implicated
on absurd, baseless and imaginary story and the police
has carved out a concocted story against him.
2(i).
It is averred that the grounds of detention
were not communicated to him. It is averred that the
bail petitioner has no role in the commission of the
offence and bail petitioner was not at all instrumental
either in arrangement and transportation of the alleged
contraband
in
question.
It
is
averred
that
the
bail
petitioner has no concerned relating to the accusation of
sale and purchase of contraband. It is further averred
-3-
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
that the bail petitioner has not committed any offence
and the mere recovery of alleged contraband from the
vehicle owned [on affidavit] by the co-accused, namely,
Roop Lal, cannot be attributed to the petitioner. It is
averred
that
nothing
has
come
in
the
investigation
against the bail petitioner and the trial is likely to take
considerable time and delay in trial cannot form basis
prolonging
the incarceration
of
the
bail
petitioner,
in
the instant case.
2(ii).
was
It is further averred that the bail petitioner
ready
and
willing
to
furnish
the
personal
bond
with surety bonds and shall comply with such other
conditions as may be imposed by this Court. It has been
undertaken that the bail petitioner will neither influence
the
witnesses
or
tamper
with
the
evidence
in
any
manner. It is averred that the bail petitioner has no
past
criminal
Narcotic
antecedents
Drugs
and
either
Psychotropic
in
relation
to
the
Substances
or
any
other criminal case.
In
has
been
this
filed,
backdrop,
through
his
the
instant
brother
with
application
the
prayer
-4-
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
for releasing the petitioner on bail.
STAND OF THE STATE AUTHORITIES:
3.
Pursuant to the issuance of notice by this
Court, on 08.05.2026, the State Authorities have filed
the
Status
Report
dated
21.05.2026
of
SHO
Police
Station Nurpur, Police District Nurpur in Kangra [HP]
and during the course of hearing on 22.05.2026, a copy
of
the
Counsel
Status
Report
for
petitioner,
the
was
furnished
who
prayed
to
Learned
for
time
to
go through the Status Report and make submissions.
4.
Heard, Mr. Yashveer Singh Rathore, Advocate,
for the petitioner and Mr. Pawan Kumar Nadda, Learned
Additional Advocate General for Respondent-State.
MANDATE OF LAW ON BAIL IN GENERAL:
5.
In general, the broad parameters regulating
the claim for bail have been spelt out in Gurbaksh
Singh Sibbia versus State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC
565, Ram Govind Upadhyay versus Sudarshan Singh
(2002) 3 SCC 598; Kalyan Chandra Sarkar versus
Rajesh Ranjan, (2004) 7 SCC 528; Prasanta Kumar
Sarkar versus Ashish Chatterjee, (2010) 14 SCC 496;
-5-
reiterated
in
P.
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
Chidambaram
versus
Directorate
of Enforcement, (2019) 9 SCC 24, Sushila Aggarwal
versus
State-NCT Delhi, (2020) 5 SCC 01; CBI
versus
Santosh
Karnani
(2023)
SCALE
250;
which have been reiterated by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court
State
in
of
Haryana
versus
Dharamraj,
2023 SCC Online SC 1085, that bail is to be granted
where
the
allegations
are
frivolous
or
groundless
and incase neither any prima facie case nor reasonable
grounds
exists
to
believe
or
point
towards
the
accusation. However, depending upon the facts of
each case, the bail can be refused, in case, prima
facie case or reasonable grounds exits and if an
offence is serious. Severity of punishment, including
reasonable
apprehension
investigation
and
trial;
of
and
fleeing
the
away
from
character;
past
antecedents; behavior; means; position and standing
of an accused; likelihood of offence being repeated;
reasonable apprehension of witnesses being influenced
and danger of justice being thwarted by grant of
-6-
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
bail etc. are relevant factors for denying the concession
of
bail. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Criminal Appeal
No.
of
2023,
Saumya
Churasia
versus
Directorate of Enforcement, decided on 14.12.2023
held that the claim for bail, is to be examined by a
Court, without delving into the evidence on merits
but by forming a prima-facie opinion on totality of
facts in light of broad-parameters referred to above.
MANDATE
OF
LAW
ON
BAIL
INVOLVING
COMMERCIAL
QUANTITY
OF
CONTRABAND
UNDER NDPS :
6.
claim
In NDPS matters, while dealing with the
for
bail
involving
commercial
quantity,
the
Court has to bear in mind that the provisions of
Section 37 of the NDPS Act are mandatory in nature
and the sine qua non for granting bail to an accused
involved in such offences is to grant an opportunity
to the Public Prosecutor to oppose the application for
release and a Court has to record its satisfaction
on twin conditions, firstly, that there are reasonable
grounds for believing that an accused is not guilty
-7-
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
of the alleged offence and secondly, the accused is
not likely to commit any offence while on bail as
per the mandate of law declared by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the cases of State of Madhya Pradesh vs
Kajad, (2001) 7 SCC
673;
and by Three Judge
Bench in NCB vs Mohit Aggarwal (2022) 18 SCC
374; Union of India vs Ajay Kumar Singh alias
Pappu 2023 SCC OnLine SC 346; Narcotics Control
Bureau vs Kashif (2024) 11 SCC 372; and in State
of Meghalaya vs Lalrintluanga Sailo and another
(2024) 15 SCC 36; State of Punjab vs Sukhwinder
Singh
@
Gora
SCC
OnLine
SC
and
recording of such satisfaction, on twin aspects, by a
Court, is not a mere formality but a mandatory
pre-condition and without recording its satisfaction
the claim for bail cannot sustain and though the right
to speedy trial rooted in Article 21 of the Constitution
is undoubtedly a precious Constitutional right; and
even under special enactment such as the NDPS
Act, particularly where the recovery is of commercial
-8-
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
quantity, the said right under Article 21 must be
exercised within the framework of Section 37 and
cannot be pressed into service solely on the ground
of delay to override it. The constitutional right under
Article 21 and the special provision of law under
Section 37 NDPS Act are to be read harmoniously
and not placed in opposition to each other; and the
aforesaid principle has been reiterated by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the recent judgement in the case
of State of Punjab vs Balraj Singh alias Billa, 2026
SCC OnLine SC 1058.
ANALYSIS OF CLAIM FOR BAIL IN INSTANT CASE:
7.
Based
on
the principles outlined by law,
on bail in general and even for bail in offences
involving commercial quantity of contraband under
NDPS Act, and after taking into account the entirety
of
facts
and
circumstances
and
the
material
on
record as is borne out from Status Report(s), this
Court proceeds to analyse the claim of the petitioner
for
bail,
in
instant
case
entitling
the
petitioner
-9-
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
[Raj Kumar] to be enlarged on bail for following
reasons:SATISFACTION OF COURT ON TWIN CONDITIONS
OF SECTION 37(1)(b) OF NDPS ACT :
8.
For appreciating the claim with reference to
the twin conditions in Section 37(1)(b) of the NDPS
Act, the material aspects, read as under:
[A]
REASONABLE GROUNDS EXIST THAT PETITIONER
NOT GUILTY :
Based
on
the
mandate
of
Section
(1)(b) of NDPS Act, this Court deals with the first
condition
that
there
are
reasonable
grounds
to
believe that the petitioner is not guilty of the offence
for the following reasons:
PROSECUTION STORY AS IN STATUS REPORT:
8(i).
Status Report dated 21.05.2026 indicates
that prosecution story is that police party head by
ASI
Satender
Singh
received
a
secret
information
at about 10.25 A.M that two persons, namely, Raj
Kumar and Roop Lal were sitting in White Hyundai
Xcent bearing registration No. HP-01K-5700, parked
- 10 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
near Government Hospital Nurpur on Defence Road
behind
Ekant
Hotel
near
Shiv
temple
who
were
alleged to be involved in business of Narcotic substance/
Charas in the area. On receipt of information, the
Investigating
Officer
after
associating
independent
witnesses Khushal Singh and Ajay Kumar reached
the spot and found that co-accused Roop Lal was
found sitting on the seat next to the driver whereas
Raj Kumar [bail petitioner] was sitting on drivers seat.
Status Report indicate that upon search of vehicle,
six packets wrapped with Khaki coloured tape were
found
containing
substance
i.e.
sticks
and
round
Charas-Cannabis
and
shaped
on
solid
weighing,
the contraband came out to be 2 Kgs. 950 grams
and
after
accused
completing
codal
formalities
were detained
and
thereafter
both
the
arrested
by
the police as per procedure.
NO
RECOVERY
PETITIONER :
8(ii).
OF
CONTRABAND
FROM
Material on record and the Status Report
- 11 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
goes on to establish that the alleged contraband was
found from the Vehicle No. HP-01K-5700, which was
owned by one Shri Rakesh Kumar but the same was
sold on affidavit to Roop Lal, co-accused. Status
Report further indicates that co-accused Roop Lal, being
the owner of the vehicle, was sitting on the left side
in the said vehicle [next to driver seat] and the alleged
contraband was recovered from the plastic cover of
left door of the said vehicle.
Nothing has been spelt
out nor suggested in the Status Report that the
contraband in question was recovered from the bail
petitioner. Nothing has transpired during investigation
[as per Status Report] that any recovery of contraband
was affected from the petitioner [Raj Kumar] herein.
In absence of any recovery from the petitioner [Raj
Kumar] there are reasonable grounds to believe that
the petitioner is not guilty of the offence.
ABSENCE OF KNOWLEDGE TO PETITIONER
ABOUT CONTRABAND IN VEHICLE OWNED BY
ROOP LAL:
8(iii).
Perusal
of
the
Status
Report
indicates
- 12 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
that during the course of investigation, it has come
on record, that co-accused Roop Lal, being the owner
of the vehicle had informed the petitioner [Raj Kumar]
that he should reach Padhar and both shall go for
an outing to Pathankot and it was on this assertion
that the petitioner reached Padhar, from where, both
started for Pathankot but were intercepted by the
police.
It
has
come
in
Status
Report
that
the
petitioner [Raj Kumar] had no knowledge that the
co-accused
[Roop
Lal]
had
planted-kept
or
was
carrying the alleged contraband in the said vehicle.
No
nexus
contraband
between
the
has
pointed
been
petitioner
any
evidence
to
establish
had
knowledge
of
the
and
out.
In
that
the
contraband
alleged
absence
of
petitioner
having
been
planted-kept in the vehicle by Roop Lal, then this
Court,
is
satisfied
at
this
stage
that
the
bail
petitioner [Raj Kumar] is not guilty of the offence
in question, in the instant case.
[B].
PETITIONER
NOT
LIKELY
TO
COMMIT
ANY
- 13 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
OFFENCE WHILE ON BAIL:
8(iv).
the
Perusal of the Status Report indicates that
State
Authorities
have
not
pointed
out
any
material to infer that the bail petitioner is likely
to commit any offence after his release on bail, in
instant
case.
Even,
the
averments
made
in
the
bail petition that the petitioner has no past criminal
antecedents have not been disputed by the State
Authorities in the Status Report.
Based on the above discussion, this Court
is of the considered view that the twin conditions
enumerated
under
Section
37(1)(b)
of
NDPS
Act
that there are reasonable grounds for believing that
the bail petitioner is not guilty of the offence and
he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail
are
satisfied
in
instant
case,
when
neither
any
recovery was affected from the petitioner nor the
petitioner had any knowledge that the co-accused
Roop Lal had planted-kept or was carrying contraband
in his vehicle, leads to the reasonable belief that the
- 14 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
petitioner is not guilty of the offence coupled with
the fact that no adversial circumstances has been
placed on record to establish that the bail petitioner
shall commit any offence after release on bail and
once the petitioner has no past criminal antecedents,
therefore,
curtail
the
the
prolongation
personal
liberty
of
incarceration
and
shall
would
defeat
the
ends of justice; entitling the petitioner [Raj Kumar]
to bail. Accordingly, the claim for bail is accepted.
PRESUMPTION OF GUILT UNDER SECTION 20, 25
AND 29 IMPERMISSIBLE AT THIS STAGE :
8(v).
The accusation under Section 20 of the
NDPS Act appears to be untenable at this stage.
Status Report indicates that the alleged vehicle being
registration No. HP-01K-5700 was owned by Roop Lal,
in which the alleged contraband was recovered from
cover of the left door and the Status Report nowhere
points
out
that
any
recovery
of
contraband
was
affected from the bail petitioner and even the Status
Report
indicates
that
the
bail
petitioner
had
no
- 15 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
knowledge that the co-accused Roop Lal had planted
or kept the alleged contraband in his car whereas
it is the prosecution story that the petitioner was
called for an outing by co-accused [Roop Lal] to
accompany him from Padhar to Pathankot. Status
Report does not point out any violation of Section
20 of the NDPS Act by the petitioner at this stage.
Moreover, the accusation under Section 20 of the
NDPS
Act
condition
of
that
the
petitioner
any
licence
had
granted
to
violated
the
him
had
or
cultivated the cannabis plant or he possessed or
resorts
to
sale,
purchase
and
transportation
of
alleged cannabis-Charas is a matter to be examined,
tested and proved during the trial.
So far accusation under Section 25 of the
NDPS Act is concerned, once the vehicle in question
was owned by co-accused Roop Lal and the Status
Report
corroborates
that
the
bail
petitioner
had
merely accompanied the co-accused for an outing
on his asking from Padhar to Pathankot and the
- 16 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
fact that the bail petitioner had no knowledge that
the alleged contraband was planted or kept by the
said
co-accused
circumstances
in
the
his
vehicle,
accusation
then
in
these
against
the
bail
petitioner appears to be incredible, which is a matter
to be examined, tested and proved during the trial.
So far as the accusation under Section 29
of NDPS Act is concerned, the factum of abetment
and
criminal
this
stage.
conspiracy
Mere
cannot
suspicion
or
be
prejudged
at
preponderance
of
portability, cannot lead to the inference of abetment
or criminal conspiracy against the bail petitioner,
which is a matter to be examined, tested and proved
during the trial.
CLAIM FOR BAIL INVOLVING COMMERCIAL
QUANTITY UNDER SECTION 37 HAS TO BE
HARMONIOUSLY CONSTRUED IN LIGHT OF
ARTICLE 21 :
9.
Though
in
facts
of
instant
case,
the
accusation under Section 37(1)(b) is not made out
yet
while
dealing
with
the
claim
for
bail
under
- 17 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
Special Enactments and rigors of Section 45 (1) (ii)
of MPLA and proviso to Section 43-D (5) of Unlawful
Activities [Prevention] Act, 1967 and Section 37 of
NDPS Act, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Criminal
Appeal No. 4011 of 2024, in V. Senthil Balaji
versus
The
Deputy
Director,
Directorate
of
Enforcement, has mandated that rigors in Special
Enactments, including Section 37 of NDPS Act, will
melt
down
where
there
is
no
likelihood
of
trial
being completed in a reasonable time and prolonged
incarceration
so
as
to
prevent the
deprivation
of
curtailment of personal liberty and right to speedy
trial in terms of Article 21 of Constitution of India,
in the following terms:“24.
There are a few penal statutes that make a
departure from
the provisions of Sections
437, 438, and 439 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure,
1973.
A
higher
threshold
is
provided in these statutes for the grant of
bail. By way of illustration, we may refer
to Section
45(1)(ii) of
PMLA,
proviso
to Section 43D(5) of the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967 and Section 37 of
- 18 the
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
Narcotic
Drugs
and
Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985 (for short, ‘NDPS
Act’). The provisions regarding bail in some of
such statutes start with a non obstante clause
for
overriding
the
provisions
of Sections
437 to 439 of the CrPC. The legislature has
done so to secure the object of making the
penal provisions in such enactments. For
example,
the
PMLA
provides
for Section
45(1)(ii) as money laundering poses a serious
threat not only to the country's financial
system
but
also
to
its
integrity
and
sovereignty.
25.
Considering the gravity of the offences in
such
statutes,
expeditious
disposal
of
trials for the crimes under these statutes
is contemplated. Moreover, such statutes
contain provisions laying down higher
threshold
for
the
grant
of
bail.
The
expeditious disposal of the trial is also
warranted considering the higher threshold
set
for
the
grant
of
bail.
Hence,
the
requirement of expeditious disposal of cases
must be read into these statutes. Inordinate
delay in the conclusion of the trial and the
higher threshold for the grant of bail
cannot go together. It is a well settled
principle of our criminal jurisprudence
that “bail is the rule, and jail is the
exception.”
These
regarding
the
stringent
grant
of
provisions
bail,
such
as Section 45(1)(iii) of the PMLA, cannot
become a tool which can be used to
- 19 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
incarcerate the accused without trial for
an unreasonably long time.
26.
There are a series of decisions of this
Court starting from the decision in the
case of K.A. Najeeb, which hold that such
stringent provisions for the grant of bail
do
not
take
away
the
power
of
Constitutional Courts to grant bail on the
grounds of violation of Part III of the
Constitution of India. We have already
referred
to
paragraph
of the
said
decision, which lays down that the rigours
of such provisions will melt down where
there
is
no
likelihood
of
trial
being
completed in a reasonable time and the
period of incarceration already undergone
has exceeded a substantial part of the
prescribed sentence. One of the reasons is
that
if,
because
of
such
provisions,
incarceration of an under-trial accused is
continued for an unreasonably long time,
the provisions may be exposed to the vice
of
being
violative
of Article
21 of
the
Constitution of India.
27.
Under the Statutes like PMLA, the minimum
sentence is three years, and the maximum is
seven years. The minimum sentence is higher
when
the
scheduled
offence
is
under
the NDPS Act. When the trial of the complaint
under PMLA is likely to prolong beyond
reasonable limits, the Constitutional Courts
will have to consider exercising their powers to
- 20 grant
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
bail.
The
reason
is
that Section
45(1)(ii) does not confer power on the State to
detain an accused for an unreasonably long
time, especially when there is no possibility of
trial concluding within a reasonable time.
What a reasonable time is will depend on the
provisions under which the accused is being
tried and other factors. One of the most
relevant factor is the duration of the minimum
and
maximum
sentence
for
the
offence.
Another important consideration is the higher
threshold or stringent conditions which a
statute provides for the grant of bail. Even an
outer limit provided by the relevant law for the
completion of the trial, if any, is also a factor
to be considered. The extraordinary powers,
as held in the case of K.A. Najeeb, can
only be exercised by the Constitutional
Courts. The Judges of the Constitutional
Courts have vast experience. Based on
the facts on record, if the Judges conclude
that there is no possibility of a trial
concluding
in
a
reasonable
time,
the
power of granting bail can always be
exercised by the Constitutional Courts on
the grounds of violation of Part III of the
Constitution
of
India
notwithstanding
the statutory provisions. The Constitutional
Courts can always exercise its jurisdiction
under Article 32 or Article 226, as the case
may be. The Constitutional Courts have to
bear in mind while dealing with the cases
under
the
PMLA
that,
except
in
a
few
- 21 exceptional
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
cases,
the
maximum
sentence
can be of seven years. The Constitutional
Courts
cannot
allow
provisions
like
Section 45 (1) (ii) to become instruments
in
the
hands
of
the
ED
to
continue
incarceration for a long time when there
is
no
possibility
of
a
trial
of
the
scheduled offence and the PMLA offence
concluding within a reasonable time. If
the Constitutional Courts do not exercise
their jurisdiction in such cases, the rights
of
the
undertrials
under Article
21 of
the Constitution of India will be defeated.
In a given case, if an undue delay in the
disposal of the trial of scheduled offences or
disposal of
trial under the PMLA can be
substantially attributed to the accused, the
Constitutional Courts can always decline to
exercise
jurisdiction
to
issue
prerogative
writs. An exception will also be in a case
where, considering the antecedents of the
accused, there is every possibility of the
accused becoming a real threat to society
if enlarged on bail. The jurisdiction to issue
prerogative writs is always discretionary.
29.
As
been
earlier,
the
appellant
incarcerated
for
stated
has
months
or
more for the offence punishable under
the PMLA. In the facts of the case, the
trial
of
the
scheduled
offences
and,
consequently, the PMLA offence is not
likely to be completed in three to four
years or even more. If the appellant's
- 22 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
detention is continued, it will amount
to an infringement of his fundamental
right under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India of speedy trial.
31.
Therefore, the appeal is allowed, and
the appellant shall be enlarged on bail
till the final disposal of CC No. 9 of
2023 pending before the Principal Session
Judge, Chennai, on the following conditions
………”.
9(i).
The
Supreme
Court,
2020,
titled
Hon’ble
Three
Judge
in
Criminal
Appeal
Amrit
Singh
Moni
Pradesh,
has
enlarged
on
who
facing
trial
3.285
kilograms
was
charas
from
a
of
the
No.
of
State
of
v.
Himachal
bail,
Bench
the
for
accused
recovery
vehicle
of
alongwith
four other persons for having been in detention for
more than 2 years and there is no further progress
in the trial.
9(ii).
While
dealing
the
claim
for
bail
by
a
person involved in commercial quantity of contraband,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has extended the benefit
of bail in Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal
- 23 -
(Crl.)
No(s).1904/2023,
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
titled
Sunil
as
Kumar
Versus The State of Himachal Pradesh, decided
on 29.03.2023, in the following terms:“It is noted that the petitioner has been
in custody for more that one and a half
years
and
the
trial
is
yet
to
conclude. Earlier, the petitioner had been
granted interim bail on two occasions and
has not misused the liberty of interim bail or
violated any of the bail conditions imposed
upon him but has thereafter, surrendered
back.
Therefore,
keeping
all
these
aspects
in
view, the petitioner is ordered to be released
on bail subject to appropriate conditions being
imposed by the Trial Court including the
condition that the petitioner shall diligently
participate in the trial. Ordered accordingly.”
9(iii).
Accepting the prayer for bail by accused
of commercial quantity in
Petition(s)
Leave
No(s).4648/2024,
as
to
Ankur
Pradesh,
Appeal
(Crl.)
Chaudhary
Versus
decided
28.05.2024,
on
State
for
Special
titled
of
Madhya
the
Hon’ble
Supreme Court has extended the benefit of bail, in
a
case,
where
the
trial
was
not
concluded
and
- 24 -
by
invoking
Article
which
mandates
defeats
fundamental
rights
override
that
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
of
the
Constitution
India
prolonged
incarceration
and
fundamental
rights
the
of
statutory
the
embargo
in
Section
37 (1) (b) of NDPS Act in the following terms:“Now, on examination, the panch witnesses
have not supported the case of prosecution.
On facts, we are not inclined to consider the
Investigation Officer as a panch witness. It is
to observe that failure to conclude the
trial within a reasonable time resulting in
prolonged incarceration militates against
the
precious
fundamental
guaranteed
under
Article
Constitution
of
conditional
liberty
India,
and
right
of
the
as
such,
overriding
the
statutory embargo created under Section
37(1)(b) of the NDPS Act may, in such
circumstances, be considered.
In view of the above, we are inclined to allow
this
petition
and
direct
to
enlarge
the
petitioner on bail on furnishing the suitable
bail bonds and sureties and on such other
terms and conditions as may be deemed fit
by the trial Court.”
9(iv).
the
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has extended
concession
of
bail
to
an
accused
allegedly
- 25 -
involved
in
commercial
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
quantity,
who
was
facing
incarceration of one year and four months and in
Petition(s)
for
Special
Leave
No(s).7115/2024,
titled
The
Madhya
State
of
as
to
Sohrab
Pradesh,
Appeal
(Crl.)
Khan
Versus
decided
on
13.08.2024, in the following terms:“The petitioner is an accused for the alleged
offences punishable under Sections 8/22 and
29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act. His bail application was
dismissed by the High Court. He has already
undergone
about
one
year
and
four
months in jail. The petitioner and com
accused were found in possession of 80 grams
of MD powder each of which commercial
quantity is 50 grams.
Considering the fact that the petitioner
criminal antecedents and the entire facts
and circumstances has no of this case, we
are of the opinion that a case of bail is made
out for the petitioner and therefore, the
prayer of the petitioner is allowed.
Accordingly, the petitioner is directed to be
released on bail forthwith on the usual terms
and conditions to be decided by the concerned
Court.”
9(v).
The
claim
for
bail
in
case
involving
- 26 -
commercial
quantity
of
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
an
accused
who
was
facing incarceration for 1 year and 6 months was
accepted by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Petition(s)
for Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No(s). 9510/
2024,
titled
as
Ram
Lal
Versus
The
State
of
Rajasthan, decided on 17.09.2024, as in this case,
in the following terms:“The petitioner and the other accused persons
are accused for the offences punishable under
Sections 8/21 & 8/29 of the Narcotic Drugs
and
Psychotropic
Substances
Act
and
allegation is that 450 gm of smack has been
recovered from them. The bail application of
the petitioner was dismissed by the High
Court. Hence, he approached this Court. He
has already undergone about 1 year and 6
months in jail.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner. As
per office report Rated 13.09.2924, the service
is deemed complete on the sole respondentState but no one has appeared for the state.
Considering the period of incarceration of
the
petitioner
and
the
fact
that
the
petitioner has no criminal antecedents, we
are of the opinion that a case of bail is
made out for the petitioner.
- 27 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
Accordingly, the
petitioner is directed to
be released on bail forthwith on the usual
terms and conditions to be decided by the
concerned Court.”
9(vi).
While
dealing
with
the
claim
for
bail
involving commercial quantity of Ganza under Section
20 of the NDPS Act, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
accepted the prayer for bail, in SLP (Criminal) No.
of
2026,
Satyajeet
Bhoi
versus
State
of Chhattisgarh and another, decided on 16.03.2026
when nothing was brought on record to establish
any
nexus
alleged
between
contraband
the
bail
coupled
petitioner
with
the
and
the
factum
of
prolonged incarceration and the fact that the trial
was likely to be delayed.
9(vii).
While dealing with claim for bail of an
accused, who was
in custody for
about 2 years
being involved in commercial quantity of contraband,
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
State
of
Punjab
vs Sukhwinder Singh @ Gora 2026 SCC OnLine
SC 671 has outlined that the claim under Section
- 28 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
37 and the right to speedy trial under Article 21
have to be read harmoniously and the right under
Article 21 must be exercised within the framework
of Section 37 of the NDPS Act and Article 21 cannot
be
pressed
into
service
solely
on
the
ground
of
delay to override Section 37 of the NDPS Act in
the following terms:
10.
The
impugned
order,
on
its
own
showing, does not record the satisfaction
mandated under Section 37(1)(b)(ii) of the
NDPS
Act.
Far
from
recording
such
satisfaction, the High Court has gone on
to
observe
that
'the
rigours
of
Section 37 of the NDPS Act can be diluted
bearing in mind the right to a speedy
trial.'
Such
an
approach
is
plainly
contrary to the settled law laid down
by this Court and deserves to be set
aside on this ground alone. The right
to speedy trial, rooted in Article 21
of the Constitution, is undoubtedly
a precious Constitutional right. That
said,
in
matters
special enactment
NDPS
Act,
governed
such
particularly
by
a
as
the
where
the
recovery is of commercial quantity,
- 29 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
the said right under Article 21 must
be
exercised
within
the
framework
of
Section 37 and cannot be pressed
into service solely on the ground of
delay to override it. The constitutional
right under Article 21 and the special
provision
of
law
under Section
37,
NDPS Act are to be read harmoniously
and not placed in opposition to each
other. The High Court, by failing to
record
its
conditions
satisfaction
on
the
under Section
37,
twin
has
in
this Court’s view, committed an error.
9(viii).
While
involving
commercial
dealing
with
the
claim
for
bail
quantity
of
contraband,
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
Ahmed
versus
State
Government
Delhi
Crl.
Appeal
the
of
of
Tasleem
of
NCT
case
[@
SLP
of
(Crl.)
No.2867 of 2026] has held that the issue as to
what would be the correct approach to bail under
special
statutes,
incarceration
[under
where
and
Section
Article
statutory
37(1)(b)
in
and
prolonged
restrictions
intersect
the
instant
case],
the
matter was referred to a larger bench, yet the bail
- 30 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
was granted with the observation that an accused
cannot
be
made
to
suffer
merely
because
the
which
stands
referred
to
settlement,
in
question
has
arisen
Larger
Bench
for
authoritative
the following terms:
21. The question, therefore, is not whether
Article 21 survives Section 43D(5). It
undoubtedly does. The true question
is how Article 21 is to be applied in
a statutory field where Parliament has
consciously
imposed
restrictions
on
bail in respect of offences alleged to
affect the security of the State and
the stability of civic life.
23.
We are, therefore, of the considered view
that the issue requires consideration by
Bench to be constituted by the Hon’ble
Chief Justice of India. This is necessary
not merely for the present batch
matters,
approach
but
to
to
settle
bail
of
the
correct
under
special
statutes where Article 21, prolonged
incarceration and statutory restrictions
intersect.
24.
Having regard to the importance of the
issue,
we
are
of
the
view
that
the
questions requiring consideration need not
- 31 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
be confined to the correctness of any one
decision.
The
controversy
broader
question
raises
concerning
a
the
manner in which constitutional courts
are to approach bail where prolonged
incarceration
is
asserted
prosecutions
governed
by
statutes
imposing
in
special
restrictive
bail
conditions. In this background it would
be imperative or in other words necessary
for the appropriate bench that may be
constituted by the Hon’ble Chief Justice of
India,
to
clarify
or
law
laid
position
of
Najeeb’s
case,
expound
the
down
in
K.A.
particularly
in
the
backdrop of the
rigour of 43D
(5)
which imposes restriction consciously
and has received the assent of the
Parliament,
which
obviously
was
brought
in
keeping
in
the
valuable
right
enshrined
mind
in
Article
21 of the Constitution of India.
27.
Having said so, we cannot lose sight of the
fact that the present appellants have
undergone
substantial
incarceration;
that the trial is not likely to conclude
immediately;
that
the
appellants
themselves have invoked the principle of
calibrated
constitutional
discretion
recognised in Gulfisha Fatima; and that
- 32 the
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
determination
of
the
issues
may
consume further time. The appellants
cannot be made to suffer continued
incarceration
merely
because
an
important question of law has arisen
for authoritative settlement. Without
expressing any opinion on merits, and
subject to stringent safeguards, we are
inclined to grant interim bail to the
appellants pending further orders.
9(ix).
vs
Further, in the case of State of Punjab
Balraj
Singh
alias
Billa,
SCC
OnLine
SC 1058 the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that
in case the twin conditions of Section 37 of the
NDPS Act were not fulfilled, which are mandatory
and
in
such
circumstances,
mere
prolongation
of
incarceration will not warrant interference in view
of Article 21 of the Constitution of Inda, is in the
following terms:
17.
Keeping in view the above expositions of
law, we now proceed to examine the
impugned
order.
decisions
of
this
The
abovementioned
Court
display
the
consistent view that when it comes to
cases involving commercial quantity of
- 33 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
narcotics, the mandatory requirements
of Section 37 ought to be considered. It is
not in dispute that the case at hand,
involves commercial quantity. In such a
scenario, consideration and reference to
the
twin
conditions
enumerated
under Section 37 of the NDPS Act was
mandatory. Upon a bare perusal of the
impugned order, it is evident that there
has been no consideration at all by the
High Court on the twin conditions. In
such a scenario, the impugned order
cannot be sustained in the eyes of law.
19.
Moreover,
the
respondent
has
only
undergone 1 year 7 months, and if
found guilty a maximum sentence of
twenty years may be imposed upon him.
Therefore, it cannot be said that he has
suffered incarceration for a long period,
warranting interference in view of Article
21 of the Constitution.
outlined
By
taking
into
account
the
by
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
principles
in
the
aforesaid judgements and in facts of instant case,
this Court having already recorded satisfaction that
by applying the twin conditions of Section 37 (1)(b)
of the NDPS Act, once reasonable grounds exists
- 34 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
to believe that the petitioner [Raj Kumar] is not
guilty of the offences in question, as no recovery
was made from the bail petitioner and the Status
Report itself establishes that bail petitioner had no
knowledge that co-accused [Roop Lal] had planted
or kept or was carrying the alleged contraband in
vehicle owned by him, in which they had travelled
from Padhar to Pathankot for an outing then in
these
circumstances
the
personal
liberty
and
the
fundamental right of speedy trial under Article 21
cannot
be
sacrificed
or
negated,
is
at
nascent
to
take
when
the
trial
stage
and
its
conclusion
is
likely
considerable
time
therefore,
the
petitioner
is entitled for bail in instant case.
INFRINGMENT OF PERSONAL LIBERTY UNDER
ARTICLE 21 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA:
10.
While reiterating the principle that bail is
a rule and jail is an exception and no accused can
be deprived of personal liberty on mere accusation
and an accused is to be treated as innocent in the
- 35 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
eyes of law, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has outlined
the object of bail, in Guddan alias Roop Narayan
Versus State of Rajasthan, 2023 SCC OnLine SC
1242, in the following terms:“11. In the case of Sanjay Chandra V. Central
Bureau of Investigation, (2012) 1 SCC 40,
while hearing a bail Application in a case
of an alleged economic offence, this court
held that the object of bail is neither
punitive nor preventative. It was observed
as under:
"21.
In bail applications, generally, it has
been laid down from the earliest
times that the object of bail is to
secure the appearance of the accused
person at his trial by reasonable
amount of bail. The object of
bail
is
neither
punitive
nor
preventative. Deprivation of liberty
must be considered a punishment,
unless it is required to ensure that
an accused person will stand his trial
when called upon. The courts owe
more than verbal respect to the
principle that punishment begins
after conviction, and that every
man is deemed to be innocent until
duly tried and duly found guilty.
23.
Apart from the question of prevention
being the object of refusal of
bail, one must not lose sight of
the fact that any imprisonment
before conviction has a substantial
punitive content and it would be
improper for any court to refuse
bail as a mark of disapproval
of former conduct whether the
- 36 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
accused has been convicted for
it or not or to refuse bail to
an unconvicted person for the
purpose of giving him a taste
of imprisonment as a lesson.
25.
27.
12.
The provisions of Cr PC confer
discretionary jurisdiction on criminal
courts to grant bail to the accused
pending trial or in appeal against
convictions; since the jurisdiction
is discretionary, it has to be
exercised with great care and
caution by balancing the valuable
right of liberty of an individual
and the interest of the society
in general. In our view, the reasoning
adopted by the learned District
Judge, which is affirmed by the
High Court, in our opinion, is a
denial of the whole basis of our
system of law and normal rule
of bail system. It transcends
respect for the requirement that
a
man
shall
be
considered
innocent until he is found guilty.
If such power is recognised, then
it may lead to chaotic situation
and would jeopardise the personal
liberty of an individual.
This Court, time and again, has
stated that bail is the rule and
committal to jail an exception. It
has also observed that refusal
of bail is a restriction on the
personal liberty of the individual
guaranteed under Article 21 of
the Constitution."
Further, in the case of Sandeep Jain v.
National Capital Territory of Delhi, (2000)
2 SCC 66, this Court, while hearing a
bail application held that conditions for
- 37 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
grant of bail cannot become so onerous
that their existence itself is tantamount
to refusal of bail. This Court held as
under:
"We are unable to appreciate even the
first order passed by the Metropolitan
Magistrate
imposing
the
onerous
condition that an accused at the FIR
stage should pay a huge sum of Rs.
2 lakhs to be set at liberty. If he had
paid it is a different matter. But the
fact that he was not able to pay
that amount and in default thereof
he is to languish in jail for more
than 10 months now, is sufficient
indication that he was unable to make
up the amount. Can he be detained
in custody endlessly for his inability
to pay the amount in the range of
Rs.2 lakhs? If the cheques issued by
his surety were dishonoured, the Court
could perhaps have taken it as a
ground to suggest to the payee of
the cheques to resort to the legal
remedies provided by law.
Similarly if the Court was dissatisfied
with the conduct of the surety as for
his failure to raise funds for honouring
the cheques issued by him, the Court
could have directed the appellant to
substitute him with another surety.
But to keep him in prison for such
a long period, that too in a case
where bail would normally be granted
for the offences alleged, is not only
hard but improper. It must be
remembered that the Court has not
even come to the conclusion that the
allegations made in the FIR are true.
That can be decided only when the
trial concludes, if the case is chargesheeted by the police."
- 38 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
REFORMATIVE INTENT AND CLAIM FOR BAIL:
11.
While
dealing
with
the
concept
of
bail
which has humanist and reformative intent coupled
with
the
fact
that
accused
under
Article
India
sacrosanct,
is
the
the
personal
liberty
of
an
of
Constitution
of
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court,
held in Criminal Appeal No. 2787 of 2024, titled
as Javed
Gulam
Nabi
Shaikh
Versus
State
of
Maharashtra and Another.
NO PAST CRIMINAL ANTECEDENTS:
12.
Learned
Counsel
for
asserts
that
the
petitioner
has
antecedents.
The
status
any
past
criminal
the
bail
petitioner
no
past
criminal
report
does
not
indicate
antecedents
and,
therefore,
in
view of these facts, the present accusation which is
yet to be tested, examined and proved during the
trial,
cannot
be
made
the
basis
for
prolonging
the incarceration of the bail petitioner in facts of
in the instant case.
- 39 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
NOTHING ADVERSARIAL REGARDING TAMPERING
WITH EVIDENCE OR WITNESSES ETC :
13.
have
Status
neither
material
Reports filed
pointed
revealing
out
by
State
Authorities
cogent
and
convincing
adversarial
circumstances
that
after release on bail, the petitioner is likely to tamper
with evidence or may cause inducement, threat or
promise to any person or persons acquainted with
the facts of the case. However, the apprehension if
any, of the State Authorities are being safeguarded,
by imposing stringent conditions in this bail order.
NOTHING ADVERSARIAL LIKELIHOOD OF FLEEING
AWAY FROM TRIAL OR JURISDICTION OF COURT:
14.
In order to safeguard the rights of bail
petitioner and to take care of apprehensions of State
that bail petitioner may flee away [notwithstanding
the fact that no such apprehension has been pointed
out in Status Report] yet, in peculiar facts of this
case,
this
Court
stringent
conditions
orders, in later part of this order.
CONCLUSION:
in
the
bail
- 40 -
15.
In
facts
of
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
instant
case,
as
discussed
above, the plea of petitioner for bail carries weight,
for
the
reason,
that
firstly,
there
are
reasonable
grounds to believe that the bail petitioner is not
guilty and is not likely to commit any offence while
on bail and the accusation under Section 37(1)(b) is
not made out, at this stage, as discussed hereinabove;
and secondly, the Status Report reveals that bail
petitioner
is
in
custody
since
5.02.2025
and
is
undergoing incarceration for about one year and
four months; and thirdly, conclusion of trial is
likely to take considerable time, when, out of
witnesses
only 2
PWs
have
been
examined
as yet and the trial is likely to take considerable time;
and fourthly, the delay in trial is not attributable
to the petitioner ; and fifthly, reasonable grounds
exist to believe that bail petitioner is not guilty and
is not likely to commit any offence while on bail;
and sixthly, the continued detention can neither
be
punitive
nor
preventative
and seventhly, the
- 41 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
continued detention of the petitioner in guise of
penalizing
him
by
permitted;
and
eighthly,
presuming
guilt
nothing
cannot
cogent
be
and
convincing has been placed on record
that there
is
from
possibility
of
accused
fleeing
away
the
trial or an accused is likely to threaten witnesses
or
is
likely
to
thwart
justice;
and
ninthly,
once
neither any recovery of contraband has been effected
by the police from the petitioner nor the petitioner
[Raj Kumar] had any
[Roop
Lal],
planted-kept
who
or
was
was
knowledge that the co-accused
the
owner
carrying
of
vehicle
contraband
in
had
said
vehicle, who told the petitioner to accompany him
from Padhar to Pathankot for an outing; and otherwise
the accusation against the petitioner is yet to be
tested, examined and proved during the trial; and
lastly, in order to safeguard the interest of State vis-à-vis
the right of petitioner, this Court imposes stringent
condition in this order and in case of any violation or
misuse of the concession-liberty, the State Authority can
- 42 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
seek cancellation of bail granted to the petitioner.
Denial of bail shall deprive and curtail the sacrosanct
fundamental rights of personal liberty and right of
speedy trial under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India of the petitioner at this stage. On totality of
facts and circumstances and the mandate of law
as referred to above, the claim of the petitioner [Raj
Kumar], for enlargement on bail, carries weight, in
peculiar
facts-situation
of
this
case,
as
discussed
above.
DIRECTIONS:
16.
Taking
into
account
the
entirety
of
the
facts and the material on record and the mandate
of law and the reasons recorded hereinabove and
in the peculiar facts of case, the instant petition
is allowed; and the State Authorities are directed to
release the petitioner [Raj Kumar] on bail, subject to
the observance of following conditions:(i)
Respondent-State Authorities shall release
bail petitioner [Raj Kumar] on furnishing
personal bond of Rs.75,000/- {Rs Seventy
- 43 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
Five Thousand} with two sureties of the
like amount, to the satisfaction of the Learned
Trial Court concerned, if not required
in any other case;
(ii)
Petitioner shall undertake and shall also
appear on every date of trial hereinafter;
(iii)
Petitioner shall abide by all or any other
condition(s), which may be imposed by
the Learned Trial Court, in view of this
order;
(iv)
Petitioner shall neither involve himself nor
shall abet the commission of any offence
hereinafter. Involvement in any offence
whatsoever or abetting thereof shall entail
automatic cancellation of bail granted in
terms of this order ;
(v)
Petitioner shall disclose her functional
E-Mail IDs/ WhatsApp number and that of
his surety to the Learned Trial Court;
(vi)
Petitioner after release, shall report to the
Investigating Officer or SHO of Police
Station concerned, on 2nd Sunday of every
month at 11.00 a.m., only for having an
update on good conduct and behaviour;
(vii)
Petitioner shall not jump over the bail and
also shall not leave the country without
the prior information of the Court;
(viii) Petitioner shall not tamper with the evidence
in any manner;
(ix)
Petitioner shall not cause any inducement,
threat or promise {directly or indirectly} to
witnesses of any other person acquainted with
the case;
- 44 -
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
(x)
Petitioner is free to seek modification of
any condition contained hereinabove, if
need arises;
(xi)
State Authorities are free to move this
Court for seeking alteration/modification of
any of the condition contained in this
order or any condition imposed by the
Learned Trial Court as a sequel to this
order, in fact situation of instant case
or circumstances so necessitate, at any
time herein-after;
(xii)
State Authorities are free to move this
Court for seeking cancellation of the
concession of bail, in case, the petitioner
violates any of the conditions contained
in this order; and
(xiii) The concession granted to petitioner in
terms of this order shall abide by the
outcome of orders to be passed in the
reference
made
to
Larger
Bench
in
Tasleem Ahmed versus State Government
of NCT of Delhi Crl. Appeal 2795 of 2026
[@
SLP
(Crl.)
No.
of
2026]
dated 22.05.2026.
17.
Observations made in this judgment shall
not be construed in any manner as an indictive of
findings, for or against the parties herein, either for
the purpose of investigation or for trial, which shall
proceed in-accordance with law, irrespective of any of
the observations contained hereinabove.
- 45 -
18.
[ 2026:HHC:24831 ]
Petitioner is permitted to produce/use copy
of this order, downloaded from the web-page of the
High Court of Himachal Pradesh, before the authorities
concerned, and the said authorities shall not insist
for production of a certified copy, but if required,
may verify about the passing of this order from
the Website of this Court.
19.
Registry is directed to forward a copy of
this order to Superintendent of Police, Police District
Nurpur for information and with the further direction
to intimate the SHO, Police Station, Nurpur to keep
an update on good conduct and behavior of the bail
petitioner [Raj Kumar] in terms of this order.
In aforesaid terms, the instant petition and
all pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall
accordingly stand disposed of.
(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
25th June, 2026
( tm)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review