Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 14th January, 2026
%
Pronounced on: 10th March, 2026
RFA 831/2023, CM APPL. 52187/2023 (Stay)
+
RAJ KUMAR SUKHWANI
S/o Shri Vasudev Sukhwani,
R/o Sea-02, 12AP2, 12th Floor,
Tower 2, Sea Court Apartment,
Jaypee Greens, G-Block,
Surajpur Kasna Road, Greater Noida, U.P.
Through:
...... Appellant
Mr. Shiv Charan Garg &Ms.Chanchal
Garg, Advocates.
versus
MANJU DAYAL
W/o Shri Pawan Dayal,
R/o H.No. 2332, Murliwala Kuan,
Subzi Mandi, New Delhi-110007.
Through:
...... Respondent
Appearance not given.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96(2) of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as 'CPC'), has been filed on behalf
of the Appellant, to challenge the Order dated 30.05.2023 of the Learned
Additional District Judge-02, Central, Delhi whereby the Application under
Order 12 Rule 6 CPC, has been allowed and Suit of the Plaintiff for
recovery of Rs. 58,80,000/-, has been decreed.
KUMAR BHATT
16:59:19
RFA 831/2023
2.
The Plaintiff/ Respondent filed a Suit for Recovery of Rs.58,80,000/-.
The brief facts of the case are that the Appellant/Defendant had friendly
relations with the husband of the Plaintiff/Respondent, who had requested
the plaintiff to lend him a friendly loan of Rs.35,00,000/ -, as he was in dire
need of money due to a financial crisis in is business. On assurance of
repayment of the loan and considering the friendly relations between the
Appellant/Defendant and her husband, the Respondent/Plaintiff advanced
Rs.10,00,000/-
on
03.08.2017,
Rs.5,00,000/-
on
04.08.2017
and
Rs.20,00,000/- on 05.08.2017 to the Appellant/Defendant, as loan. The
Appellant/Defendant had promised to repay the amount within one year. It
was also alleged by the Plaintiff that Appellant/Defendant had also taken
various loans from the Respondent/Plaintiff, for which the Appellant had
given Title Deeds of his property, to the Plaintiff.
3.
The Plaintiff/Respondent claimed that Defendant/Appellant failed to
repay the loan, despite repeated requests and reminders. After much
persuasion, the Appellant handed over three cheques bearing no.343690,
343691 and 343692 for Rs.10,00,000/-, Rs. 20,00,000/- and Rs.5,00,000/respectively, drawn on Punjab National Bank, Shakti Nagar Branch, New
Delhi to the Respondent/Plaintiff. However, when the Respondent/Plaintiff
presented the said cheques for encashment, all the cheques were returned
unpaid with the remarks "Funds Insufficient" vide Return Memo dated
06.08.2020. The Plaintiff gave a legal Notice dated11.08.2020 and
thereafter, filed the Suit for recovery of Rs. 58,80,000/- along with pendente
lite and future interest @18% per annum.
4.
The Defendant/Appellant, in his Written Statement, took the
defence that there is no loan Agreement between the parties. In fact, in July,
KUMAR BHATT
16:59:19
RFA 831/2023
2017, the Plaintiff expressed her desire to purchase Flat the No. 0701, 7th
floor, Tower no.16, Unitech Horizon, Greater Noida, U.P., which was
allotted to the Appellant and its possession was handed over to the Appellant
in the year 2012. The Appellant and the Respondent consequently, entered
into an Agreement regarding sale and purchase of the said Flat, for
consideration of Rs.75,00,000/. In furtherance of the said alleged
Agreement, the Plaintiff had paid a sum of Rs.35,00,000/- to the Defendant
in August, 2017. It was decided that if the Flat was not found convenient by
the Plaintiff and was not desirous of fulfilling the deal, she could get the
cheques encashed, or then the Defendant/Appellant would return the amount
back to the Plaintiff.
5.
It has been claimed that in August, 2018, the Respondent agreed to
purchase the Flat and to pay the entire remaining amount, within one month.
She also agreed to return the cheques. The Appellant/Defendant further
asserted that the due to the COVID-19, the rates of the Flat started to fall
drastically. Hence, Respondent neither paid the remaining consideration
amount i.e. Rs.40,00,000/-nor returned the three Cheques to the Appellant.
6.
The Appellant/Defendant has also opposed the contentions of the
Respondent/Plaintiff that any Loan was taken by him. No ITR records have
been filed by the plaintiff, to show that she had given a sum of
Rs.35,00,000/- to the Defendant.
7.
The Plaintiff/Respondent in his Replication averred that the
Appellant has fabricated a false story, to avoid his liability. The
Plaintiff/Respondent has reiterated the assertions made in the Plaint.
8.
The Plaintiff had also emphasized, that in Para Nos.1 (D) & (E), of
Defendant’s Written Statement, he has unambiguously admitted that he
KUMAR BHATT
16:59:19
RFA 831/2023
received the amount of Rs.35,00,000/-, from the Plaintiff/Respondent.
Moreover, the Defendant has not filed a single document on record, to
support his allegation of sale of the Flat to the Respondent bearing Flat
No.0701, 7th Floor, Tower No. 16, Unitech Horizon, Greater Noida, U.P.
9.
The Ld. District Judge, after appreciation of the evidence, held
that the Defendant has admitted receiving the amount of Rs.35,00,000/from the Plaintiff and having issued three cheques to her. The Defendant's
averments that there was an Agreement between the parties regarding sale
and purchase of Defendant's property, appears to be sham and moon shine.
The Application Under Order XII Rule 6 CPC was allowed. Hence, the Suit
of the Plaintiff was decreed in the sum of Rs.58,80,000/-, though no interest
was granted.
10.
Aggrieved by the Decree, present Appeal has been filed. The
grounds of challenge are that the Ld. Additional District Judge has
exceeded his jurisdiction and passed the impugned Order dated 30.05.2023,
without considering the facts and circumstances. It is asserted by the
Appellant/Defendant that in July 2017, the Plaintiff/Respondent had desired
to buy the above-mentioned Flat and it was agreed that the
Plaintiff/Respondent will purchase the suit Flat for Rs.75,00,000/-.
11.
Secondly, as Appellant/Defendant further agitated that there was no
Loan Agreement between the parties and the Plaintiff has concocted a story
in this regard. No document had been filed by the Plaintiff to show that the
aforesaid cheques were given as a blank cheque to the Plaintiff. Moreover,
the Plaintiff did not send any Notice to the Plaintiff for return of the three
cheques, despite which the story of Loan, as projected by the Plaintiff, has
been mechanically believed by the Ld. Trial Court.
KUMAR BHATT
16:59:19
RFA 831/2023
12.
The Plaintiff in his reply to the Appeal, has submitted that in
Paragraph Nos.1 (D) & (E), of Defendant’s Written Statement, he has
unambiguously admitted that he received the amount of Rs. 35,00,000/-from
the Plaintiff/Respondent. Further, no written Agreement has been put on
record by the Appellant to support the claim of Agreement between the
parties for the sale purchase of the suit property, for Rs.75,00,000/-.
Submissions heard and record perused.
13.
Essentially, the background of the dispute is that there was a monetary
transaction of Rs.35,00,000/- between the parties, and this amount was
received by the Defendant/Appellant. While the Plaintiff asserted that it was
a simple Loan transaction, the Appellant/Defendant that it was the money
given for purchase of the suit property for Rs.75,00,000/-, from which the
Plaintiff subsequently, rescinded.
14.
Pertinently, the Defendant/Appellant in the Para no.1 (D) & (E) of the
Written Statement has categorically admitted that he has received the money
and was waiting for the remaining amount of Rs.40,00,000/- from the
Plaintiff/Respondent with respect to the alleged sale Agreement. However,
there is no document to support the Appellant’s claim that there has been any
Agreement between the parties for the sale-purchase of the suit Flat.
15.
The relevant Paragraphs of the Written Statement read as under:
“D. That in the month of July, 2017, the petitioner
showed her desire to purchase the said flat and it was
mutually agreed that she will purchase the said flat for
Rs. 75,00,000/- and in terms of the said settlement, the
petitioner paid a sum of Rs. 35,00,000/- in August,
2017. The defendant had good relation with the
petitioner, hence, it was decided that if the said flat
would not be convenient, then, the defendant would
KUMAR BHATT
16:59:19
RFA 831/2023
return the amount, hence, in pursuance of the said
commitment, the defendant gave 3 cheques with the
assurance that if the petitioner is not desired for this
deal then, the same would be got encashed within 1
(One) month, however, prior intimation of deposit of
cheque, not less than 72 hours would be given to the
defendant, The said cheques were given in July, 2018.
E. That the plaintiff agreed in August, 2018 that she
would make the entire payment of the said flat within 1
month and also agreed to return the cheques, however,
she did not pay the remaining amount and always
sought time for balance payment as well as return of
the cheques. The defendant always accommodated with
the plaintiff being having good relation with her
husband, and having family relation.”
16.
Moreover, The Appellant himself has stated that it was agreed
between the Parties that if the Plaintiff eventually did not intend to purchase
the Flat, the money would be returned. Therefore, even if the defence of the
Appellant is considered, there is an unequivocal admission of having taken
Rs.35,00,000/-. Even though there is no Agreement to Sell executed between
the Parties, but then, it is also admitted by the Defendant that the plaintiff
did not intend to buy the Flat. It is further admitted that the three Cheques
had been given by him, as an assurance. Further, admittedly, the
Appellant/Defendant is in the possession of the suit Flat, which completely
belies his theory of an alleged Agreement to Sell.
17.
If indeed it was an Agreement to Sell, then the defendant had no
reason to secure this amount by giving the three Cheques, which on
presentation, got dishonoured. Clearly, the main dispute of this case is of
purely monetary transaction between the parties, which was categorically
admitted by the Defendant in Para Nos.1 (D) & (E) of his Written Statement.
KUMAR BHATT
16:59:19
RFA 831/2023
18.
In the case of PPA Impex Pvt. Ltd. Vs Mangal Sain Metal, 166 (2010)
DLT 84, it has been held that if the defence amounts to be a sham and
moonshine, it should be summarily dismissed by the Court.
19.
The Ld. District Judge has rightly decreed the Suit under Order XII
Rule 6 CPC, in the light of unambiguous admissions of the Defendant. It is
held that there is no infirmity in the Impugned Order dated 30.05.2023,
granting the recovery of Rs.58,80,000/-, with no orders to interest.
20.
There is no merit in the Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed. The
pending Applications are disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MARCH 10, 2026/R
KUMAR BHATT
16:59:19
RFA 831/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review