Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH : AMARAVATI
****
W.P.Nos.26079, 14921, 18680, 20819, 24875, 26077, 26078 & 27170 of
1999; 453, 1676, 1842, 4304, 6312, 8343, 9529, 12256, 16354, 19336, 21611
& 21921 of 2000; 2074, 4143, 6755, 9180, 11575, 16726, 17237, 18926,
23243 & 25402 of 2001; 1025, 1033, 2227, 4550, 6296 & 8887 of 2002
W.P.No.26079 of 1999 & Batch
Between:
1. Pioneer Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd., rep by General Manager
P.Rajendra Naidu S/o P.Munireddy Regd. Office at Puttur 517583 , A.P R/o
28 , 2nd Cross Street , West CIT Nagar ,
...Petitioner
AND
1. Transmission Corporation of A P Ltd, rep by chairman Vidyut Soudha ,
Hyderabad
2. The Superintending Engineer, Operation Circle , Transmission Corporation
of A.P Tirupathi
...Respondents
DATE OF JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED: 17.04.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE G. RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD
1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers
may be allowed to see the judgment?
Yes / No
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
marked to Law Reporters / Journals?
Yes / No
3. Whether His Lordship wish to
see the fair copy of the Judgment?
Yes / No
______________________________________
GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD, J
* THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA
PRASAD
+ W.P.Nos.26079, 14921, 18680, 20819, 24875, 26077, 26078 & 27170 of
1999; 453, 1676, 1842, 4304, 6312, 8343, 9529, 12256, 16354, 19336, 21611
& 21921 of 2000; 2074, 4143, 6755, 9180, 11575, 16726, 17237, 18926,
23243 & 25402 of 2001; 1025, 1033, 2227, 4550, 6296 & 8887 of 2002
% 17.04.2026
W.P.No.26079 of 1999 & Batch
Between:
1. Pioneer Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd., rep by General Manager
P.Rajendra Naidu S/o P.Munireddy Regd. Office at Puttur 517583 , A.P R/o
28 , 2nd Cross Street , West CIT Nagar ,
...Petitioner
AND
1. Transmission Corporation of A P Ltd, rep by chairman Vidyut Soudha ,
Hyderabad
2. The Superintending Engineer, Operation Circle , Transmission Corporation
of A.P Tirupathi
...Respondents
! Counsel for
Petitioner/s
: Sri K. Gopal Choudary
^ Counsel for
Respondent/s
: Sri Sk. Md. Umar Abdullah, learned Counsel and
Ms. Jyothi Ratna A, learned Junior Standing
Counsel representing Sri Venkata Rama Rao
Kota, learned Standing Counsel for APSPDCL.
< Gist:
> Head Note:
? Cases referred:
Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of Telangana in Civil Miscellaneous
Appeal No.1593 of 2001 dated 10.09.2024 titled as M/s Deccan Cements
Limited V. Transmission Corporation of Telangana Limited TS TRANSCO
Judgment reserved on
Judgment pronounced on
Judgment uploaded on
APHC010283791999
24.02.2026
17.04.2026
23.04.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY,THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA
PRASAD
W.P.Nos.26079, 14921, 18680, 20819, 24875, 26077, 26078 & 27170 of
1999; 453, 1676, 1842, 4304, 6312, 8343, 9529, 12256, 16354, 19336, 21611
& 21921 of 2000; 2074, 4143, 6755, 9180, 11575, 16726, 17237, 18926,
23243 & 25402 of 2001; 1025, 1033, 2227, 4550, 6296 & 8887 of 2002
W.P.No.26079 of 1999 & Batch
Between:
1. Pioneer Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd., rep by General Manager
P.Rajendra Naidu S/o P.Munireddy Regd. Office at Puttur 517583 , A.P R/o
28 , 2nd Cross Street , West CIT Nagar ,
...Petitioner
AND
1. Transmission Corporation of A P Ltd, rep by chairman Vidyut Soudha ,
Hyderabad
2. The Superintending Engineer, Operation Circle , Transmission Corporation
of A.P Tirupathi
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioner: KATRAGADDA GOPAL CHOUDARY
Counsel for the Respondents: VENKATA RAMA RAO KOTA SC FOR
APSPDCL Counsel for the Respondents:V V SATISH (SC for APEPDCL)
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA
PRASAD
W.P.Nos.26079, 14921, 18680, 20819, 24875, 26077, 26078 & 27170 of
1999; 453, 1676, 1842, 4304, 6312, 8343, 9529, 12256, 16354, 19336, 21611
& 21921 of 2000; 2074, 4143, 6755, 9180, 11575, 16726, 17237, 18926,
23243 & 25402 of 2001; 1025, 1033, 2227, 4550, 6296 & 8887 of 2002
The Court made the following COMMON ORDER:
Heard Sri K. Gopal Choudary, learned Counsel for the Writ Petitioners
appearing online in (W.P.No.26077, 26078, 26079 of 1999, 1842 of 2000)
assisted by Sri Sk. Md. Umar Abdullah, learned Counsel and Ms. Jyothi Ratna
A, learned Junior Standing Counsel representing Sri Venkata Rama Rao Kota,
learned Standing Counsel for APSPDCL.
2.
The above batch of Writ Petitions are heard and disposed of together in
view of the fact that they involve similar issues. Therefore, for the purpose of
convenience, the facts mentioned in W.P.No.26079 of 1999 are referred to
hereunder.
3.
The prayer sought in the W.P.No.26079 of 1999 is as under:
“issue an appropriate Writ, Order or Direction, more
particularly one in the nature of a mandamus or a
declaration, declaring the condition in Clause 1 A and B of
the General Conditions of HT Supply in the tariff
notification B.P. Ms. 62 (Operation & Commercial) dated
28.12.1998 providing for clubbing of the contracted
demands with the Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh and all other sources like APGPCL Mini Hydel,
Wind Power, MPPs, Co-generating Plants, etc. for the
purposes of determining the voltage of supply and the
voltage surcharge as bad in law, arbitrary, illegal,
unconstitutional and void; and
b) issue a appropriate Writ, Order or Direction, more
particularly one in the nature of a mandamus, forbearing
the respondents from demanding or collecting any voltage
surcharges from the petitioner company including the
disputed demands made in the respondent’s bill for
November 1999 dated 26.11.1999; and
c) Pass such further or other orders as this Honourable
Court may deem fit and proper so that justice may be
done.”
4.
At the outset, it is to be stated that the issues in controversy involved in
this batch of Writ Petitions are no more a res integra inasmuch as the said
issues were settled by the Order passed by the Andhra Pradesh Electricity
Regulatory Commission dated 30.03.2011 in O.P.No.2 to 5 of 2011 and Order
of the Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of Telangana in Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal No.1593 of 2001 dated 10.09.2024 titled as M/s
Deccan Cements Limited V. Transmission Corporation of Telangana
Limited TS TRANSCO and that these two Orders have attained finality.
5.
The facts involved in the present case, as emanating from
W.P.No.26079 of 1999, are that the Writ Petitioner herein has entered into a
Memorandum of Understanding on 17.10.1998 (MOU-I) for establishment of a
group captive generating plant by name APGPCL; that it had a share
equivalent to 500 KW out of the generating capacity of the said plant of
APGPCL; that the HT Supply Agreement was executed for the Oil Division
with Contracted Maximum Demand (CMD) of 1400 KVA on 14.10.1990; that
HT Supply Agreement for the Spinning Division of the Writ Petitioner’s
company was executed on 25.02.1995 with Contracted Maximum Demand
(CMD) of 1495 KVA; that the Writ Petitioner has executed another
Memorandum of Understanding on 19.04.1997 (MOU-II) for 172 MW
expansion Stage-II, where, the Writ Petitioner had a share equivalent to 360
KW out of the generating capacity of Stage-II of the plant; that the Writ
Petitioner had entered into Wheeling and Purchase Agreement for Mini Hydel
Power Plant owned by the Writ Petitioner with capacity of 6.2 MW on
04.09.1998.
6.
It is further submitted by the Ld. Counsel for the Writ Petitioner that Oil
Division of the Writ Petitioner Company had entered into High Tension Supply
Agreement with reduced CMD of 500 KVA on 14.11.1998; that however, on
24.05.1998, the Respondent No.1 has issued B.P.Ms.No.27, inter alia,
prescribing the format for notices to be issued to consumers availing supply
from APSEB and also all other sources if the consumers are to switch over to
high voltage of supply by 31.12.1998; and that thereafter, Respondent No.1
has issued B.P.Ms.No.62 on 28.12.1998, thereby, notifying the revised tariff
for the sale of electricity by the APSEB.
7.
It is further submitted that the Writ Petitioners simultaneously receive
and consume electricity that is supplied from various sources including the
source from the Official Respondents herein. The electricity supply from other
sources is also wheeled by the Official Respondents upto the premises of the
Writ Petitioners. The energy supplied by the Official Respondents and the
energy from other sources are received by the Writ Petitioners for the purpose
of consumption through a ‘single meter’ which records the actual maximum
demand from all sources put together (RMD) during the billing month and also
the actual energy delivered for consumption during the billing month. It is
further submitted that for each billing month, the demands and energy
attributable to the other sources are deducted from RMD/total recorded
energy and the remaining demand and energy is billed by the Official
Respondents herein as power supplied by it at the notified tariffs for sale by
them to their consumers.
8.
It is further submitted that with regard to the tariffs that existed under the
previous arrangement, nearly from the year 1981, the Official Respondents
herein have prescribed the voltage surcharge at which the supply was availed
if it is less than the prescribed voltage.
9.
Learned Counsel for the Writ Petitioners would submit that the rationale
behind such provision that was in existence since 1981 was that, for the same
quantum of power, the losses are higher at lower voltages. Therfore, it was
felt, that there should be a prescription for the voltage of supply depending on
the quantum of power availed and there should be a measure of
compensation for the higher losses if the power is availed at voltage less than
the prescribed voltage.
10.
It is also submitted that the Writ Petitioners were receiving their supply
at 11 KV which was the prescribed voltage as their CMD that was less than
1500 KVA.
11.
It is contended that under B.P.Ms.No.27 dated 24.05.1998, the Official
Respondents herein have issued an Order that the consumers availing supply
from APSEB and also other sources must avail supply at the specified voltage
on the basis of the total power from all sources and that the consumers
availing power at voltages less than specified voltage must switch over to the
specified voltage on or before 31.12.1998. The said B.P.Ms.No.27 would also
stipulate that notices in the format enclosed to the said notification would be
issued to consumers availing supply at lower voltages. Despite the fact that
none of the Writ Petitioners have received any such notices from the Official
Respondents, the Official Respondents have issued Tariff Notification bearing
B.P.Ms.No.62 dated 28.12.1998, wherein the prescribed voltage for availing
supply was prescribed in Clause (1) A of the General Conditions for HT supply
for total contracted demand not only with APSEB but also from all other
sources. Clause (1) B prescribed the demand and energy charges applicable
for cases wherein the voltage at which the supply was availed was less than
the prescribed voltages under Clause (1) A.
12.
It is also submitted by the learned Counsel for the Writ Petitioners that
in the bill for November, 1999, the Respondents have charged voltage
surcharge for billing month of November, 1999 without any notice or any
explanation whatsoever. As stated earlier, the Writ Petitioners have sought
explanation and in response to the request of the Writ Petitioners, the Official
Respondents have sent a further demand for the months of February, 1999 to
October, 1999 also. In respect of some other Writ Petitioners, the bill for
December, 1999 also included an amount towards voltage surcharge.
13.
It is pertinent to mention herein that Clause (1) A of the General
conditions of HT Supply, which is impugned herein, in the present Writ
Petitions, provides for the voltage at which supply has to be availed for total
Contracted Demand with APSEB from all other sources too. Clause (1) B,
which is also impugned herein, provides for the rates of demand charges and
energy charges where supply is availed at voltage less than that prescribed.
Clause (1) A and Clause (1) B of B.P.Ms. No.62 (Operation and Commercial)
dated 28.12.1998 titled as (Sale of Electricity To Persons Other Than
Licensees Revised Tariffs). Para Nos. 9 and 10 of the Gazette Notification
dated 28.12.1998 is usefully extracted hereunder:
“GENERAL CONDITIONS OF H.T.SUPPLY
The foregoing tariffs are subject to the following
conditions:(1) A. VOLTAGE OF SUPPLY:
The voltage at which supply has to be availed by
EHT/HT consumer shall be as follows:
For Total Contracted Demand with A.P.S.E. Board
and all other sources like A.P.G.P.C.L., Mini Hydel, Wind
Power, MPPs, Co-Generating Plants etc.
Upto 1500 KVA
1501 KVA to 5000 KVA
Above 5000 KVA
11000 Volts
33000 Volts
132000 Volts or 220000
Volts as may be
decided by the Board.
B. VOLTAGE SURCHARGE
H.T. consumers who are now getting supply at voltage
different from the declared voltages and who want to continue
taking supply at the same voltage will be charged as per the rates
indicated below:
Sl.No
1.
2.
3.
Contracted
Demand of an
existing
consumer (in
KVA)
Voltage at
which Supply
should be
availed (in Kilo
Volts)
Voltage at
which
consumer is
availing (in
Kilo Volts)
70 to 1500
1501 to 5000
Above 5000
132 or 220
6.6 or below
11 or below
33 below
Demand
charge
(Rs.per
KVA/Mo
nth)
Rates
Energy
charges
(Paise
per KWh)
Note: The FCA will be charged extra as notified by Board from time to time.”
14.
It is further submitted that on 15.06.1999, the HT Supply Agreement of
the Spinning Division of the Writ Petitioner Company was reduced to CMD of
995 KVA; that the Respondent No.1 had issued undisputed bills for August1999 on 26.10.1999 and for October-1999 undisputed bill was issued on
26.10.1999; that on 26.11.1999, the Respondent No.1 has raised a bill
showing specified voltage of 33 KV and including demand for differential
voltage surcharge of Rs.2,58,058.51 Ps on 26.11.1999.
15.
It is further submitted that having been aggrieved of the bill issued by
the Respondent No.1 in the month of November-1999, the Writ Petitioner had
addressed a Letter disputing the said bill and sought clear calculation and
explanation for the billed amount on 09.12.1999; that despite the request of
the Writ Petitioner, the Respondent No.2 had raised additional demand of
Rs.41.45 lakhs for the period February-1999 to October-1999 apart from the
demand raised through the bill of November-1999 vide Proceeding dated
17.12.1999.
16.
Writ Petitions were filed challenging the new conditions set-out in
Clause (1) A & B of the General Conditions of HT supply in B.P.Ms.No.62
dated 28.12.1998 providing for clubbing of the contracted demands with the
APSEB and APTRANSCO and all other sources and also challenging the
demands of the Official Respondents for voltage surcharges.
17.
Similar demands were raised in respect of the other Writ Petitioners and
therefore, various Writ Petitions were filed, which are included in the present
batch of Writ Petitions along with W.P.No.26077 of 1999.
It is further
submitted that on 29.12.1999 an Interim Order was granted in favour of the
Writ Petitioner in W.P.M.P.No.32933 of 1999 in W.P.No.26077 of 1999 on the
condition that the Writ Petitioner deposits 1/4th of the disputed surcharge.
18.
Learned Counsel for the Writ Petitioners would contend that the above
mentioned conditions are grossly unreasonable, unjustified and arbitrary
because the terms of ‘contracted demand’ is relevant only with respect to the
supply from APSEB and APTRANSCO but does not have any relevance in
respect of the power received from all other sources. It is also contended that
power sources such as mini hydel power are ‘inherently infirm’ and the
consumption of electricity from such sources is always in substitution, but not
at all in addition to the power from the APSEB and APTRANSCO. It is further
submitted that power sources from mini hydel power is taken only when such
power is actually available, and therefore, there cannot be any clubbing of
power from such renewable sources of the power from APSEB and
APTRANSCO.
19.
Insofar as levy of voltage surcharge is concerned, it is contended by the
Writ Petitioners that only the actual recorded demand during a billing month
from all sources taken together than can reasonably be considered as
relevant. It is further submitted that it is only when the recorded demand
exceeds the limit of demand specified for supply at the prescribed voltage, the
levy of voltage surcharge is justified.
20.
It is pertinent to mention herein that Andhra Pradesh Electricity
Regulatory Commission (APERC) had examined the issue in the course of
tariff proceedings for the years 2011-2012 and it had categorically held on
30.03.2011 that it is only the Recorded Maximum Demand or the Contracted
Maximum Demand, whichever is higher, shall be the basis for levying voltage
surcharge.
It is also submitted that this view of APERC was upheld and
followed by the Division Bench of Hon’ble High Court of Telangana in CMA
No.1593 of 2001 dated 10.09.2024. It is further submitted that both these
Orders have attained finality.
21.
The Respondents have filed Counter-Affidavit in W.P.No.26077 of 1999
on 27.07.2000, thereby, justifying the demand raised by them. In any case, at
the time of filing of Counter Affidavit, they did not have the benefit of the Order
of APERC dated 30.03.2011 nor the Order of the Division Bench of Hon’ble
High Court of Telangana, inasmuch as the said Orders have originated
subsequent to the filing of the Counter Affidavit. However, after having taken
note of the subsequent Orders of the APERC dated 30.03.2011 and Order of
the Hon’ble Division Bench dated 10.09.2024, the Ld. Counsel would fairly
admit that they have attained finality.
22.
It is submitted that without appreciating the contentions of the Writ
Petitioners, Ld. Single Judge of this Hon’ble Court, vide Common Order dated
22.09.2008, was pleased to dismiss the W.P.No.26077 of 1999 including
batch of the Writ Petitions. Having been aggrieved of the same, the Writ
Petitioners have filed Review Petitions against the Common Order dated
22.09.2008 on 05.03.2009.
23.
The Writ Appeals were filed by all the Writ Petitioners against the
Common Order dated 22.09.2008 despite pendency of the Review Petitions. It
is further submitted that the Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court, after
having considered the matters on merit, was pleased to allow all the Writ
Appeals by setting aside the impugned Common Order of the Ld. Single
Judge dated 22.09.2008.
The Hon’ble Division Bench had consequently
dismissed the Review Petitions as having become infructuous in view of the
Order of the Division Bench dated 23.06.2016 in the Writ Appeals remanding
the Writ Petitions for consideration and disposal afresh.
24.
On 30.03.2011, the Hon’ble Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission, vide Common Order had disposed of the batch of Original
Petitions bearing O.P. Nos. 2 to 5 of 2011, holding in Para No.134 as under:
“134. M/s Pioneer spinning and weaving mills Itd stated
that there is a voltage surcharge levy based on
"contracted demand with licensee and other sources". The
Voltage surcharge is levied considering the aggregate of
the contracted demand with the licensee and the average
demand in respect of supply of other sources. They state
that this does not consider whether the supply from such
other source is in lieu of / substitution of some part of the
energy contracted with licensee.
They illustrated this issue with an example.
A consumer has 1400 kVA as CMD with a DISCOM and
300 kVA as average demand contracted with say, a mini
hydel plant. As hydel plants are seasonal, there are long
periods when there is no supply from them and the entire
recorded demand of say, 1300 kVA is met by DISCOM.
However when there is hydel generation and 300 kVA is
supplied by the hydel plant, the recorded demand is still
1300 kVA but 300 kVA came from hydel and 1000 kVA
came from DISCOM. The recorded demand never
exceeded 1500 kVA.
Yet in the present dispensation, the aggregate demand
would be taken as 1400 KVA (CMD) + 300 KVA = 1700
kVA and it is construed that the consumer is required to
take supply at higher voltage or has to pay Voltage
surcharge. The actual power drawn is well below the 1500
KVA limit of Voltage supply.
They also stated that it is not in anyone's interest to supply
at higher voltage when the actual power is only 1300 kVA.
This was said to be causing lot of problems.
They requested that the existing provisions be suitably
modified so that a recorded maximum demand alone is
the basis for levy of voltage surcharge.
Replies of Licensees: Based on the contracted demands
the required capacities of lines and power transformers
are determined and installed accordingly. Surcharges will
naturally be levied on contracted demands with licensee
and all other sources but not on utilization or recorded
demand.
Commission's views: Reply of the DISCOMs is not
meeting the situation described. The contracted
maximum demand is never being exceeded here and
so the line capacities and transformer capacities
created with the contracted demand in mind are not
being put under strain. As long as the consumer does
not cross the maximum contracted demand, which the
system has factored in already, the explanation of
DISCOM does not hold. The provision is therefore
modified as:
In case of consumers who are having supply
arrangements from one or more than one source, the
RMD or CMD only with the Licensee, whichever is
higher shall be the basis for levying voltage
surcharge.
Requests of railways for tariffs lower than Rs.4/- per
unit”
(emphasis supplied)
25.
In view of the remand Order passed by the Division Bench on
23.06.2016, in the batch of Writ Appeals, the Writ Petitions were restored to
their original file, which are now being considered by this Court. As indicated
earlier, that the issues raised in the present batch of Writ Petitions are no
more res integra inasmuch as the issue that is decided by the APERC in
O.P.Nos.2 to 5 of 2011 dated 30.03.2011 is in favour of the Writ Petitioners
and also the Order passed by the Hon’ble Division Bench of the Hon’ble High
Court of Telangana in Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No. 1593 of 2001 dated
10.09.2024.
26.
The Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of Telangana, had
allowed the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed by the Appellant therein by
referring to the Common Order passed by the APERC dated 30.03.2011 in
O.P.Nos.2 to 11 of 2011. The relevant portion Para Nos.11 to 17 of the Order
passed by the Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of Telangana in Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal No.1593 of 2001 dated 10.09.2024, is usefully
extracted hereunder:
“11. According to learned counsel for the appellant, the
Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission itself
subsequently after the subsequent years for other
establishments including the appellant's establishment has
accepted the stand of the appellant vide their order dated
30.03.2011 in a batch of petitions, wherein the Andhra
Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission did not agree
to the DISCOMS contentions. It had categorically held
that in case of “consumers who are having supply
arrangement from one or more than one sources, the
RMD or CMD only with the licensee, whichever is
higher shall be the basis for levying voltage
surcharge". It was the view of the Andhra Pradesh
Electricity Regulatory Commission itself that since the
CMD is never being exceeded, therefore the
transformers exceeds created with the contracted
demand in mind are not being put to strain. It was also
the view of the Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission that as long as the consumer does not
cross the CMD which the system has factored in
already, the contention of DISCOMS does not hold
good. The view of the Andhra Pradesh Electricity
Regulatory Commission was fortified and substantiated by
way of an illustration given in its order which was accepted
by Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission and
which again for ready reference is reproduced herein
under, viz.,
"A consumer has 1400 kVA as CMD with a
DISCOM and 300 kVA as average demand
contracted with say, a mini hydel plant. As
hydel plants are seasonal, there are long
period when there is no supply from them
and the entire recorded demand of say, 1300
kVA is met by DISCOM. However when
there is hydel generation and 300 kVA is
supplied by the hydel plant, the recorded
demand is still 1300 kVA but 300 kVA came
from hydel and 1000 kVA came from
DISCOM. The recorded demand never
exceeded 1500 KVA.
Yet in the present dispensation, the
aggregate demand would be taken as 1400
kVA (CMD) + 300 kVA = 700 kVA and it is
construed that the consumer is required to
take supply at higher voltage or has to pay
Voltage surcharge. The actual power drawn
is well below the 1500 kVA limit of Voltage
supply.
They also stated that is is not in anyone's
interest to supply at higher voltage when the
actual power is only 1300 kVA. This was said
to be causing lot of problems.
They required that the existing provisions be
suitably modified so that a recorded
maximum demand alone is the basis for levy
of voltage surcharge.”
12. It was this illustration which has been accepted by
Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory commission
and on the basis of which the view of Andhra Pradesh
Electricity Regulatory commission that the levy of
voltage surcharge would be strictly in accordance
with the CMD after due verification as to whether the
limits under the CMD is ever being exceeded or not. If
it is not being exceeded, there shall be no levying of
voltage surcharge. This decision of Andhra Pradesh
Electricity Regulatory Commission and the view taken
by the Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission on 30.03.2011 still holds good and is still
being applied even on the appellant's establishment
for the relevant period which is not challenged vide
the present appeal where a different view was taken
by
Andhra
Pradesh
Electricity
Regulatory
Commission vide the impugned order.
13. Though the learned Standing Counsel for the
respondent contended that since the appellant had more
than one sources of generation and the total voltage in
addition to the electricity supplied by the TRANSCO, all
added together exceeds the CMD of the appellant of 4995
kVA and the total kVA adding the electricity supplied by
way of CMD and the electricity generated by way of wind
energy and Mini Hydel power project comes to 9415.09
kVA. Hence, the appellant was not liable to incur levy of
voltage surcharge as admittedly they were availing power
supply of more than 5000 kVA.
14.
We do not find any substance in the stand taken by
TRANSCO, particularly when there is no dispute to the
fact that the demand of electricity at the appellant's
establishment is less than 4995 kVA. Even if the appellant
is consuming the electricity generated from wind energy
as also from the Hydel project, even then the appellant
would only be requiring the balance of electricity from the
CMD which they have. Moreover, there is no material
whatsoever produced either before the Andhra Pradesh
Electricity Regulatory Commission or before this court in
the present appeal by TRANSCO to show that the
appellant had ever crossed the CMD of 4995 kVA and that
the balance of electricity was being that which was
generated from wind energy and Hydel project.
15. From the aforesaid admitted factual matrix, what
is culled out is that in the event the appellant is
availing more than 4995 kVA, only in that situation
would arise a question of additional transmission and
transformer losses. However, once when the recorded
consumption is less than 4995 kVA i.e. the CMD, then
it cannot be said that there are any additional losses
suffered. In the said circumstances the levy of voltage
surcharge in the opinion of this Bench is irrational
and arbitrary.
16. As has been earlier contended by the learned
Standing Counsel for the respondent, we do not find force
in their argument when they say that the energy generated
by the appellant both under the wind energy as also from
the Hydel power plant are fed into the grid of TRANSCO
from the two locations where it is generated. Whereas, the
appellant establishment is availing the supply made by
TRANSCO at their cement plant itself. Thus, the clubbing
of the demand from the various sources does not seem to
be logical and justified.
17. For all the aforesaid reasons and also particularly
the stand of the Andhra Pradesh Electricity
Regulatory Commission itself for the subsequent
periods gives a strength to the contention and
arguments of the learned counsel for the appellant
and for the said reason, we are inclined to allow the
present appeal by setting aside the impugned order
dated 25.05.2001 in I.A.No.15 of 2000 in O.P.No.347 of
2000 by the Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory
Commission and granting approval to the tariff
revision made by the TRANSCO on 06.04.2000, both of
which being bad in law and arbitrary. Further, it is
categorically held that the appellant will not be liable
to pay voltage surcharge as long as the consumption
of power does not exceed the CMD with the
TRANSCO.”
27.
In Para-15 of the above extract of the Division Bench of the Hon’ble
High Court of Telangana, it has been categorically stated that the levy of
voltage surcharge in the opinion of the Bench is irrational and arbitrary and
therefore, the impugned Order therein is unsustainable. In the light of the
above two Orders mentioned herein above namely the Common Order of the
Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission, dated 30.03.2011 and the
Order of the Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of Telangana in
C.M.A.No.1593 of 2001 dated 10.09.2024, which is the latest one, it is held
that the actual Recorded Maximum Demand (RMD) of all the sources taken
altogether
or
the
Contract
Maximum
Demand
(CMD)
with
the
APSEB/Licensee, whichever is higher, in a billing month shall be the basis of
determining the voltage of supply and the application of voltage surcharge. It
is also held that if the RMD or CMD, whichever is higher, does not exceed the
specified limit of demand for the existing voltage of supply, they shall be no
voltage surcharge applicable.
28.
Accordingly, the present batch of Writ Petitions is allowed in terms of
the directions as under:
i.
The actual Recorded Demand of the Writ Petitioners with
respect to all sources together for any billing month never
exceeded 1500 KVA which is the specified limit for availing
supply at 11 KV. Therefore, no voltage surcharge applies to
the Writ Petitioners.
ii.
Clause (1)B provides for the demand charges and energy
charges to be applied in lieu of the normal rates only on the
demand and energy supplied by the APSEB / APTRANSCO
where voltage surcharge is applicable. There is no provision
for applying any rate on the demand and energy availed on
other sources. The levy of a notional differential amount
between the voltage surcharge rates in Clause (1)B and the
normal tariff rates of APSEB on the demand and energy
availed from other sources is without any basis or authority.
29.
Consequently, the licensee may verify the factual position with respect
to each of the Writ Petitioners and communicate the applicability or otherwise
in the case of each Writ Petitioner individually and complete the entire process
within a period of three (03) months from the date of receipt of the Order of
this Court. It is clarified that if the voltage Surcharge is not applicable to the
Writ Petitioners, the amounts deposited/paid pending the present Writ
Petitions shall be refunded by way of adjustment in the subsequent monthly
CC bills of the Writ Petitioners. No Order as to Costs.
30.
Interlocutory Applications, if any, stand closed in terms of this order.
______________________________________
GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD, J
Dt:17.04.2026
MNR/JKS
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE GANNAMANENI RAMAKRISHNA PRASAD
W.P.Nos.26079, 14921, 18680, 20819, 24875, 26077, 26078 & 27170 of
1999; 453, 1676, 1842, 4304, 6312, 8343, 9529, 12256, 16354, 19336, 21611
& 21921 of 2000; 2074, 4143, 6755, 9180, 11575, 16726, 17237, 18926,
23243 & 25402 of 2001; 1025, 1033, 2227, 4550, 6296 & 8887 of 2002
Dt: 17.04.2026
MNR/JKS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review