Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 252 of 2026
Rahul Kumar, S/o Sri Ramesh Prasad Gupta, R/o
Village- Bijupura, P.O.- Tangar, P.S.- Chahno, DistrictRanchi, Jharkhand
… … Appellant
Versus
1.
The State of Jharkhand
2.
The Principal Secretary, Department of Home
Government of Jharkhand, having its office at Nepal
House, P.O. & P.S.- Doranda, District- Ranchi
3.
The District Legal Services Authority (DLSA) Ranchi
through its Member Secretary having its office at Civil
Court- Ranchi, P.O.-GPO, P.S.-Kotwali, District- Ranchi
... … Respondents
PRESENT
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RONGON MUKHOPADHYAY
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
For the Appellant
For the Respondents
: Mrs. Snehlika Bhagat, Advocate
: Mr. M. Dubey, A.C. to A.G.
---------
C.A.V. on 27/04/2026
Per Rongon Mukhopadhyay, J.
Pronounced on 19/06/2026
A virulent regressive and a potent attack with acid
on
the
appellant/writ-petitioner
had
not
only
caused
disfigurement of his face but more notably disfigurement of his
soul which has further been compounded by the utter lack of
sensitivity on the part of the State doling out a compensation
which for a male victim in particular, does not even
compensate a miniscule percentage of the trauma
the
appellant writ-petitioner had undergone and which is not likely
to subside in the near future.
2.
Before venturing out to consider the legality and
correctness of the order dated 27.11.2019 passed by the
learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No. 2683 of 2018 the delay in
filing the appeal has to be considered at the first instance. The
application for condonation of delay has been filed through I.A.
No. 11207 of 2025. There has been a delay of 1374 days in
filing the appeal.
Mrs. Snehlika Bhagat, learned counsel appearing for
3.
the appellant has submitted that Section 5 of the Limitation
Act for the purposes of condonation of delay refers to the term
“sufficient cause” and the same would be a valid reason to
condone the delay. The purpose of Section 5 of the Limitation
Act is intended to meet the reasons which must appear
“sufficient” in the facts and circumstances of the case to satisfy
the Court that the person concerned would not have taken
recourse in preferring appeal even if he had wanted to during
the prescribed period of limitation. The preference of an
appeal/ application within the prescribed period of limitation is
a regular routine procedure prescribed but at the same time it
is necessary that this regular procedure is followed strictly in
cases involving contractual claims for specific relief, setting
aside of an exparte decree or regular civil or criminal appeals
etc.
in
which
consciousness
and
efforts
of
the
appellant/applicant regarding limitation would be judged for
“sufficient cause” stricto senso. According to Mrs. Bhagat,
learned counsel for the appellant the present appeal projects
itself as an exceptional case wherein the appellant/ writpetitioner being an acid attack survivor had only two options;
either to prefer an appeal within time and wait for financial aid
or to undergo treatments and surgery first in the hope that the
Courts are always open to protection of his fundamental
rights. It has been submitted that an acid attack survivor is a
victim for lifetime and an appeal preferred by such victim
beyond the period of limitation should not be an impediment in
his quest for redressal of his grievance. The appellant/writpetitioner was undergoing treatment and surgeries as he was
subjected to an acid attack and has suffered 45% disability
and is not leading a normal life which has been permanently
affected. The limitation had expired on 04.01.2020 which was
the peak period of Covid-19 and which was also one of the
reasons for condonation of delay. Advancing her argument
Mrs. Bhagat, learned counsel has submitted that the appellant
has, as yet, undergone 14 plastic surgeries and he has also
lost a major part of his eye-sight apart from the fact that he
has no source of income and is facing a severe financial
crunch. The parents of the appellant are old and ailing persons
and they were not able to hire a lawyer and in fact, the appeal
has been preferred through the High Court Legal Services
Committee. Learned counsel has made further submission that
the appellant is a law-abiding citizen and is nowhere at fault;
moreover, he is the victim of the worse form of social crime in
India. Therefore, protection of his person and life is his
constitutional right and it is prayed and expected that the
Court would not deny his constitutional right and the right to
life due to the delay in filing of the appeal. The appellant has
genuine grounds and has valid reasons which is bona fide and
is in good faith. It has also been submitted that the appellant
has chosen life over litigation and had prioritized his treatment
by his own means as the Doctors have suggested that any
delay in treatment will rot and contaminate his body parts.
Mrs. Snehlika Bhagat, learned counsel has also referred to the
Supplementary Affidavit filed by her wherein various medical
prescriptions have been brought on record. It has thus been
submitted that since the appellant was prevented by sufficient
cause as enumerated above to prefer the appeal within the
time specified the delay in filing of the appeal be condoned.
4.
Learned A.C. to A.G. has opposed the limitation
application and has submitted that the delay of 1374 days in
filing the appeal is an inordinate delay and the appellant has
failed to put forward sufficient cause for condonation of the
delay.
5.
Though there has been a huge delay of 1374 days in
preferring the appeal but the factual aspects of the case and
the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the
appellant clearly reveal a “sufficient cause” for condonation of
the delay. The appellant/writ-petitioner is an acid attack
victim and the medical prescriptions and the photographs
appended to the Memo of Appeal designates the horrific nature
of the crime which has led to a disfigurement of the face of the
appellant and the perennial nature of the underlying trauma
the appellant is experiencing. In cases of this nature delay in
filing of the appeal/application should be considered with
utmost sympathy and the Courts cannot be oblivious to the
psychological distress and physical injury faced by a victim of
acid attack. In the context of the present appeal the delay
becomes insignificant in the face of the appellant having been
traumatized for life.
6.
Thus, on a consideration of the reasons advanced by
the learned counsel for the appellant for condoning the delay of
1374 days in filing the appeal which we conclude to be
sufficient, the delay is accordingly condoned.
7.
I.A. No. 2943 of 2026 stands allowed.
L.P.A. No. 252 of 2026
8.
This appeal is directed against the order dated
27.11.2019 passed in W.P.(C) No. 2683 of 2018 by the learned
Single Judge, whereby and whereunder, the prayer of the
appellant to enhance the compensation from Rs. 3,00,000/- to
Rs. 25,00,000/- under the Victim Compensation Scheme,
2016 has not been acceded to since the appellant has already
received an amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- as compensation.
9.
The precursor to the quest of the appellant/writ
petitioner for enhanced compensation is an incident which
occurred on 31.05.2012 at about 4:00 P.M. wherein while the
appellant was studying in his room his 10-year-old cousin was
playing
outside
the
house
with
another
boy
of
the
neighbourhood. There was a quarrel between the children at
which the mother of the boy from the locality had arrived and
being enraged had started abusing the cousin brother of the
appellant. This led to the appellant intervening and forbidding
the said woman to use filthy language at which she had
rushed back to her house and returned back with a bottle of
liquid and threw the liquid on the face of the appellant. The
face of the appellant started burning and the appellant started
screaming out of the immense pain on account of acid being
thrown upon him. On the next day the statement of the
appellant was recorded by the Police consequent to which
Chano P.S. Case No. 55/2012 was instituted against the
accused u/s 307, 326, 304, 506/34 of the IPC.
It has been averred that due to the said incident the
face of the appellant was disfigured as the chemical had
corroded the face, the eyelids had vanished, both ears have
been burnt, the ear cartilage has been lost and severe burns
had also affected the neck, chest and left upper limb of the
appellant. It has been stated that since the day of the incident
the appellant had to undergo several surgeries including
plastic surgeries and has to regularly take medicines in which
the
appellant
has
Rs.
25,00,000/-.
The
incurred
an
appellant
amount
had
exceeding
approached
for
compensation which was not properly entertained at the first
instance but on the instruction of the District Legal Services
Authority he had received a compensation of an amount of
Rs. 3,00,000/- under the Victim Compensation Scheme, 2016.
The appellant has spent a huge expenditure on his treatment
and he still has to undergo treatment in future and, therefore,
for proper treatment and rehabilitation of the appellant it is
necessary that adequate compensation be extended to him.
With a prayer for enhanced compensation the appellant had
approached this Court by filing a writ application in W.P.(C)
No. 2683 of 2018 which however was disposed of on
27.11.2019 by the learned Single Judge without acceding to
the prayer of the appellant and which is the order impugned to
the present appeal.
10.
After giving a factual insight into the case Mrs.
Snehlika Bhagat, learned counsel for the appellant/writ
petitioner has submitted that as on date on account of the
heavy dose of medicine and the collateral damage the appellant
has been diagnosed with Degenerative Lumber Spondylitis and
needs further corrective treatment for reformation of his face
as well as various parts of his body. Learned counsel for the
appellant in the background facts and circumstances of the
case has formulated the following questions:
(a)
Whether
the
compensation
3,00,000/-
appellant
can
claim
more
than
Rs.
which
is
the
maximum
compensation prescribed for the victims
of acid attack under the Jharkhand
Victim Compensation Scheme, 2016 ?
(b)
Whether the respondents are liable to
bear the entire medical expenditure of
the appellant which is incurred by him
towards the treatment of the damage
caused to his body and face due to the
acid attack ?
(c)
Whether denying the appellant the
compensation and reimbursement of
the
medical
expenses
incurred
including future expenses required to
be incurred in the aforesaid treatment
amounts to violation of “Right to Life”
under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India
and
is
in
violation
to
the
guidelines laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
through
judicial
pronouncements regarding payment of
compensation to the victims of acid
attack ?
(d)
Whether
the
provisions
in
the
notification as submitted by the State
regarding compensation to male and
female victims is highly discriminatory
and
unreasonable
as
well
as
insufficient to compensate the physical
and mental trauma suffered by the
victim of both genders ?
(e)
Whether being a welfare state it was
incumbent to operate on the field of
“equality”
before
law
and
“equal
protection of law” with respect to the
discriminatory
compensation
provisions
of
male
and
for
female
victims ?
(f)
Whether the categorized compensation
scheme of the State for male and female
victims
requires
to
be
revised
by
including transgenders as well ?
(g)
Whether an acid attack victim is liable
for compensation for mental trauma
and distress, psychological damages,
family
sufferings,
social
desertion,
inability to pursue further education,
failure to secure employment due to
such
disability,
status
and
loosing
equality
opportunity
of
and
rehabilitation to live an independent
and respectable life ?
(h)
Whether the impugned order dated
27.11.2019 is liable to be set aside
for
non-consideration
of
the
apparent discrimination with respect
to compensation to male and female
victims ?
11.
Ms. Bhagat, learned counsel for the appellant has by
virtue of the questions formulated by her has canvassed a
larger picture though confined to the State of Jharkhand. It
has
been
submitted
that
despite
the
decision
in
“Laxmi v. Union of India” reported in (2014) 13 SCC 743, the
State of Jharkhand has no effective mechanism to regulate the
sale, purchase, storage and handling of acid which as the
present case would highlight are easily available. It has been
submitted that the learned Single Judge did not consider the
gender discrimination with respect to the payment of victim
compensation though the writ application preferred by the
appellant was heard along with the writ application preferred
by a female victim. The affidavit submitted by the State reveals
about notifications dated 29.09.2016 and 30.07.2019 which
evidently makes a discrimination between male and female
victims and has not even given a thought for inclusion of
transgender. As per Mrs. Snehlika Bhagat, the notified
compensation
scheme
of
the
welfare
State
are
highly
discriminatory, unreasonable and an infringement to right to
life, right to equal protection of law as enshrined and
guaranteed under the Constitution of India. The Schemes of
compensation overlooked and neglected the fact that acid
attack is a crime against human body irrespective of being
male or female or the third gender. The damages, physical
pain, mental distress and trauma, family sufferings, social
desertion and other losses are similar to both male and female;
also, the treatment of procedure are similar. It has further
been submitted that as the acid do not discriminate between a
male and female victim while causing damage hence, acid
attack is not a crime where there should be any discrimination
between male and female or third gender. It is a crime only
against the human body and the sufferings end with the death
of the victim survivor and, therefore, there should not be any
notification giving priority to any gender. All genders deserve
equal compensatory provisions covering all losses, damages
and harm caused by acid attack. As per Mrs. Bhagat all
genders should be treated equally and the State of Jharkhand
being a welfare state was duty bound to ensure appropriate
notifications eradicating such gender bias. The learned Single
Judge has committed an error by confining the appellant to the
four corners of the notification for victim compensation and
not beyond despite the factual aspects indicating disbursement
of a much higher compensation than what has been mentioned
in the Victim Compensation Scheme. The actual loss and
damages, both mental and physical as well as future losses
have not been properly evaluated. It has been pointed out that
the impugned order is limited only to the past medical bills of
the appellant. There is nothing in the order to compensate the
other never-ending losses and damages which continues till
the death of the victim which include (a) mental trauma and
distress (b) psychological damage (c) family sufferings (d) social
desertions by inability to
pursue further
education (e)
generated inequality in employment due to acid attack
injury/disability (f) loss of equality of status and opportunity
and rehabilitation. That the appellant even after the acid
attack has every right to live a respectable and normal life and
every right to carry out his livelihood, social, financial and
family
duties,
right
to
be
treated
equally
without
discrimination and being protected by the Constitution of India
for which the Government’s Notified Schemes provide no
assistance and / or facilities. The impugned order is confined
to payment of past medical bills instead of covering actual
losses and damages including unseen damages and sufferings
which are not physical and for which no bills can be
submitted. She has submitted that in cases of acid attack
victim/survivor
the
relief
and
compensation
should
automatically cover all these damages apart from the cost of
physical harm, medical treatment/surgery bills, for the
protection of the right to life of the victim as guaranteed by the
Constitution. In the backdrop of such elaborate submissions
advanced by Mrs. Bhagat, learned counsel for the appellant
she has prayed for setting aside the impugned order dated
27.11.2019 and grant enhanced compensation to the appellant
commensurating with the mental and physical trauma being
suffered by the appellant.
12.
Learned A.C. to A.G. has submitted that the
impugned order dated 27.11.2019 has dealt with all aspects of
the case and has also directed the appropriate authority to
ensure that the appellant gets the required benefits as
provided in the notifications to the extent of their applicability
on a representation to be submitted by the appellant. Learned
counsel has referred to the Jharkhand Victim Compensation
(Amendment) Scheme, 2016 which has been notified vide
Memo No. 5190 dated 29.09.2016 while submitting that the
said notification contains a schedule which provides for
compensation payable under various offences. The victim of
acid attack will be paid a compensation of Rs. 3,00,000/which has already been received by the writ-petitioner. It has
been submitted that Clause 2 (?k) of a notification no. 5190
dated 29.09.2016 defines the term victim in a broad and
inclusive manner and does not restrict the ambit of the term
“victim” on the basis of gender covering all persons who have
suffered on account of an offence. It has, therefore, been
submitted that since a compensation of Rs. 3,00,000/- has
been extended to the writ-petitioner/appellant no interference
is necessitated in the impugned order dated 27.11.2019.
13.
We have heard the learned counsel for the respective
parties and have also perused the affidavits on record.
14.
There is no disputation that the writ-petitioner is an
acid attack victim and such treacherous attack by the accused
upon the writ-petitioner has caused disfigurement of his face
and also caused corrosive and burn injuries on various parts
of his body. The claim of the writ-petitioner for enhancement of
the compensation amount has been negated by the learned
Single Judge since he had already received an amount of
Rs. 3,00,000/- disbursed through District Legal Services
Authority. However, so far as the treatment facilities in terms
of the notification dated 30.07.2019 is concerned it has been
held that the writ-petitioner is entitled to get the said benefits.
From the various affidavits filed, two notifications concerns the
present case and these notifications hold centre stage. The first
notification is Notification no. 5190 dated 29.09.2016 which is
titled Jharkhand Victim Compensation (Amendment) Scheme,
2016. “Victim” in the Scheme of 2016 has been defined in
Clause 2 (?k). Clause 5 (x ) of the scheme mandates that the
amount of compensation payable to the victim shall be
assessed by the District Legal Services Authority based on the
loss caused to the victim, the cost incurred in treatment etc.
and on consideration of the rehabilitation of the victim. The
amount of compensation shall vary depending on the gravity of
the offence and the facts of the case. Sub-Clause (?k) of Clause
5 demarcates that the minimum compensation payable to the
victim would be as per Schedule-I. Schedule-I appended to the
Scheme of 2016 contains the various categories of offences and
the corresponding compensation payable to the victims of each
of the categories. So far as an acid attack victim is concerned,
the minimum payable amount as per the Scheme of 2016 is
Rs. 3,00,000/-. A bare perusal of the provisions contained in
the Scheme of 2016 and its Schedule clearly demonstrates that
there is no upper limit for compensation to be so awarded.
Though a compensation amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- has been
disbursed to the writ-petitioner by the District Legal Services
Authority but the same does not put fetters on the Court to
extend a higher compensation if the facts and circumstances of
the case so demand.
15.
Another
notification
has
been
issued
vide
notification no. 4052 dated 30.07.2019 based on the Scheme
formulated
by
the
National
Legal
Services
Authority
consequent to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of “Nipun Saxena & Anr. vs. Union of India &
Ors.” (WPC No. 565 of 2012), wherein the State Government
has come out with the Jharkhand Victim Compensation
(Amendment) Scheme, 2019. This scheme is confined to female
victims and Schedule-II of the said scheme demarcates the
compensation amount based on the nature of crime the victim
was faced with. Serial No. 13 of Schedule-II of the said scheme
reads as under:
Sl. Particulars of loss or Minimum Limit Upper Limit of
No. injury
of Compensation Compensation
13 Victims of Acid attack
a. In case of disfigurement Rs. 7 Lakh
of face
b. In case of injury more Rs. 5 Lakh
than 50%
Rs. 8 Lakh
Rs. 8 Lakh
c. In case of injury less than Rs. 3 Lakh
50%
d. In case of injury less than Rs. 3 Lakh
20%
16.
Rs. 5 Lakh
Rs. 4 Lakh
Serial 13 of Schedule-II quoted above deals with
victims of acid attack and various sub categories have been
fixed with variance in compensation depending on the degree
of injury suffered. In case of disfigurement of face the
minimum limit of compensation is Rs. 7 Lakhs while the upper
limit of compensation is Rs. 8 Lakhs. In the scheme an
embargo has been put with respect to the maximum
compensation which is payable to a victim unlike the Scheme
of 2016 which does not put a cap on the limits of
compensation. Though the maximum compensation of the
Scheme of 2016 has not been fixed, but at the same time, we
cannot
be
oblivious
to
the
fact
that
the
minimum
compensation as in the Scheme of 2016 is at wide variance to
the minimum compensation fixed for female victims in the
Scheme of 2019. A decade has passed since the Scheme of
2016 was unveiled and it is time to consider amendment to the
amount of compensation fixed in various categories in the said
scheme to commensurate with the Scheme of 2019, especially
for male victims in order to obliterate the discrimination it
accentuates.
17.
Even if we confine ourselves to the Scheme of 2016
and at the cost of repetition what is glaring is the absence of
any upper limit in the amount payable to a victim as
compensation.
18.
Snehlika
In the context of the aforesaid notification Mrs.
Bhagat,
learned
counsel
for
the
writ-
petitioner/appellant has referred to the case of “Parivartan
Kendra Vs. Union of India” reported in (2016) 3 SCC 571,
wherein it has been held as follows:
“19. The guidelines issued by orders in Laxmi case
[Laxmi v. Union of India, (2014) 4 SCC 427 : (2014) 4
SCC (Cri) 802] , [Laxmi v. Union of India, (2014) 13 SCC
743 : (2014) 5 SCC (Cri) 814] , [Laxmi v. Union of India,
(2016) 3 SCC 669 : (2015) 5 Scale 77] are proper,
except with respect to the compensation amount. We
just need to ensure that these guidelines are
implemented properly. Keeping in view the impact of
acid attack on the victim's social, economical and
personal life, we need to enhance the amount of
compensation. We cannot be oblivious of the fact that
the victim of acid attack requires permanent treatment
for the damaged skin. The mere amount of Rs 3 lakhs
will not be of any help to such a victim. We are
conscious of the fact that enhancement of the
compensation amount will be an additional burden on
the State. But prevention of such a crime is the
responsibility of the State and the liability to pay the
enhanced compensation will be of the State. The
enhancement of the compensation will act in two ways:
(i) It will help the victim in rehabilitation;
(ii) It will also make the State to implement the
guidelines properly as the State will try to comply
with it in its true spirit so that the crime of acid
attack can be prevented in future.
21. In peculiar facts of the case, we are of the view
that victim Chanchal deserves to be awarded a
compensation more than what has been prescribed by
this Court in Laxmi case [Laxmi v. Union of India, (2014)
4 SCC 427 : (2014) 4 SCC (Cri) 802] . Though in this
case we are not issuing any guidelines different from
the guidelines issued in Laxmi case [Laxmi v. Union of
India, (2014) 4 SCC 427 : (2014) 4 SCC (Cri) 802] , we
should not forget that the younger sister was also
injured by the acid attack. Although her degree of
sufferance is not as that of the elder one, but she also
requires treatment and rehabilitation. It is to be noted
that this Court in Laxmi case [Laxmi v. Union of India,
(2016) 3 SCC 669 : (2015) 5 Scale 77] does not put a
bar on the Government to award compensation limited
to Rs 3 lakhs. The State has the discretion to provide
more compensation to the victim in the case of acid
attack as per Laxmi case [Laxmi v. Union of India,
(2016) 3 SCC 669 : (2015) 5 Scale 77] guidelines. It is
also to be noticed that this Court has not put any
condition in Laxmi case [Laxmi v. Union of India, (2016)
3 SCC 669 : (2015) 5 Scale 77] as to the degree of
injuries which a victim has suffered due to acid attack.
In the instant case, the victim's father has already
spent more than Rs 5 lakhs for the treatment of the
victim. In consideration of the severity of the victim's
injury, expenditure with regard to grafting and
reconstruction surgery, physical and mental pain, etc.,
we are of the opinion that the victim (Chanchal) should
be compensated to a tune of at least Rs 10 lakhs.
Suffice it to say that the compensation must not only be
awarded in terms of the physical injury, we have also
to take note of the victim's inability to lead a full life and
to enjoy those amenities which is being robbed of her
as a result of the acid attack. Therefore, this Court
deems it proper to award a compensation of Rs 10
lakhs and accordingly, we direct the Government
concerned to compensate the victim Chanchal to the
tune of Rs 10 lakhs, and in light of the judgment given
in Laxmi case [Laxmi v. Union of India, (2016) 3 SCC
669 : (2015) 5 Scale 77] we direct the State Government
of Bihar concerned to compensate the main victim's
sister, Sonam to a tune of Rs 3 lakhs. Of the total
amount of Rs 13 lakhs, a sum of Rs 5 lakhs shall be
paid to the victim and her family within a period of one
month and the remaining sum of Rs 8 lakhs shall be
paid to the victims within a period of three months from
the date of this order. Furthermore, the State shall upon
itself take full responsibility for the treatment and
rehabilitation of the victims of acid attack as per the
guidelines provided in Laxmi case [Laxmi v. Union of
India, (2016) 3 SCC 669 : (2015) 5 Scale 77] , vide order
dated 10-4-2015.”
19.
The writ-petitioner as we have noticed above had
suffered disfigurement of his face to such an extent that even
after
multiple
surgeries
his
face
reveals
the
physical
deformities an acid attack victim undergoes; the photographs
brought on record being a testament to such fact. What,
however, cannot be fathomed is the immense pain, suffering
and mental trauma the writ-petitioner must have undergone
and is still undergoing. We are aware of the fact that the
physical
and
mental
pain
and
suffering
cannot
be
compensated in terms of money but it is our belief that the
same would go a long way in alleviating to a certain extent
such trauma and may also assist the writ-petitioner in his
rehabilitation. The writ-petitioner as stated by Mrs. Bhagat,
was pursuing his Chartered Accountancy Course and a bright
future beckoned but all the dreams, aspirations and goals of
the writ-petitioner have been scuttled by virtue of a moment of
rage at the hands of the accused.
20.
On the basis of the overall facts and circumstances
discussed above and since Rs. 3,00,000/- extended as victim
compensation is a meagre amount and the fact that there is no
upper limit provided for payment of compensation in the
Scheme of 2016, we enhance the amount of compensation to
Rs. 15,00,000/- (Rs. Fifteen Lakhs) payable to the writpetitioner.
21.
Since, admittedly the writ-petitioner has received an
amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- (Rs. Three Lakhs) the balance
amount of compensation of Rs. 12,00,000/- (Rs. Twelve
Lakhs) shall be extended to him within a period of eight
weeks from the date of receipt / production of a copy of this
order.
22.
We now venture into the field, the parameters of
which demarcate the cost incurred in the treatment of the writpetitioner and the future cost. The writ-petitioner had
preferred a contempt application being Contempt Case (Civil)
No. 133 of 2022 which was disposed of on 18.11.2022 since an
amount of Rs. 4,21,197/- had been paid towards the medical
expenses incurred by the writ-petitioner out of the claimed
amount of Rs. 18,21,588/-. The show cause filed in the
contempt application spells out the reasons for not making
payment of the entire amount claimed. Certain discrepancies
have been pointed out in the said show cause of some bills. If
the respondents feel that some bills require clarification an
immediate response should be sought for from the writpetitioner and once the queries are clarified there should not
be any impediment for the concerned respondents to expedite
the process of payment. Out of the amount claimed of
Rs. 18,21,588/- an amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- has been
claimed as future compensation which has been negated by
the State-respondent and rightly so as the expenses which are
to be reimbursed by the concerned Department should be the
actual expenses incurred. However, as regards the balance of
the expenditure concerned minus the amount which has
already been received by the writ-petitioner the rest amount
should be released in favour of the writ-petitioner expeditiously
and preferably within a period of four weeks from the date of
receipt / production of a copy of this order provided the writpetitioner submits the necessary vouchers, bills etc. if, not
already submitted. Since the writ-petitioner requires further
corrective surgery he has to incur a huge expenditure. Once on
incurring the recurrent expenditure the writ-petitioner submits
the bills, the concerned respondent shall process the same
expeditiously keeping in mind that the writ-petitioner is an
acid attack survivor and shall thereafter make the payment to
the writ-petitioner. In case the expenses for the treatment are
payable to the Hospital the concerned respondent shall
endeavour to directly make payment to the Hospital once the
bills are submitted before him which is one of the processes
being
adopted
to
make
payment
of
an
amount
of
Rs. 7,29,266/- minus an amount of Rs. 4,21,197/- which has
already been paid as could be deciphered from the show cause
filed in Contempt Case (Civil) No. 133 of 2022.
23.
As
a
consequence,
to
the
discussions
made
hereinabove this Letters Patent Appeal stands disposed of with
the aforementioned observations and directions.
24.
Pending Interlocutory Application, if any, stands
closed.
(Rongon Mukhopadhyay, J.)
(Pradeep Kumar Srivastava, J.)
Dated, the 19th June, 2026
A. Sanga/Uploaded on 24 /06/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review