The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. Thus the classification made by proviso to Rule 20(B)(two) of the Service Bye-Laws 2018 cannot be termed as artificial classification as it has intelligible differentia and nexus with the object sought to be achieved. For the aforesaid reasons, the relief as claimed by petitioners cannot be granted.
23. Accordingly writ petition fails and is dismissed. (Pankaj Purohit, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition (S/B) No.357 of 2021
Rahul Giri and another
….....Petitioners
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and another
….….Respondents
Present:Mr. A.S. Rawat, learned Senior Advocate assisted by Mr. Raveendra Singh Bisht,
learned counsel for the petitioners.
Mr. K.N. Joshi, learned D.A.G. for the State.
Mr. Dharmendra Barthwal, learned counsel for respondent no.2.
Coram :
Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
Per: Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.
By means of this writ petition, petitioners have sought the
following reliefs:(i)
(ii)
(iii)
2.
Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus
declaring Clause 20 (B) of the Uttarakhand Power
Corporation Ltd. Junior Engineer (Electrical & Mechanical)
Service Bye-laws, 2018 (Annexure No.5) as null and void
being ultra virus to the Constitution of India, as the same is
highly discriminatory and provides discrimination between
the petitioners and other similarly situated Technician
Grade-II (TG-II) of the erstwhile UPSEB/UPPCL whose
services are protected.
Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari to
quash Clause (Two) under eligibility and conditions clause
of advertisement dated 14.04.2020 issued by the
Respondent No.2 (Annexure No.6).
Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus
directing the Respondent No.2 to consider the case of
petitioners for promotion with similarly situated employees
of U.P. State Electricity Board/U.P. Power Corporation Ltd.
who have been absorbed in Uttarakhand Power Corporation
Ltd.
Petitioners were appointed as Labour after creation of
Uttarakhand Power Corporation Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as
“UPCL”) and they were thereafter promoted as Technician Grade-II in
the years 2011-2012. Petitioners are challenging Rule 20(B) of UPCL
Junior Engineer (Electrical and Mechanical) Service Bye-Laws, 2018.
3.
According to petitioners, next promotional post available
to Technician Grade-I and Technician Grade-II is that of Junior
Engineer. Clause 20(B)(two) of Service Bye-Laws, 2018 provides that
Technician Grade-I/Technician Grade-II shall be eligible to participate
in departmental examination for promotion upon completing
qualifying service of ten years. However proviso to Rule 20(B)
provides that employees who were absorbed in service of UPCL and
were earlier serving in Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board
(hereinafter referred to as “UPSEB”) or Uttar Pradesh Power
Corporation Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “UPPCL”), Clause 20(B)
would be applicable to them only to the extent permissible under the
Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board Subordinate Electrical and
Mechanical Engineering Service Regulations, 1972 (hereinafter
referred to as “Regulations of 1972”).
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that as per the
Regulations of 1972, persons serving as Technician Grade-II who
possessed High School qualification were eligible for promotion after
putting only five years of service.
5.
Thus it is contended that on account of the proviso to
Rule 20(B) of the Service Bye-Laws, 2018, the members of one
homogeneous class have been segregated into two groups, for one
group of persons, qualifying service needed for promotion is five years
while for the other group, the qualifying service needed for promotion
is ten years.
6.
It is contended that since petitioners were appointed in
UPCL after its creation, therefore they would have to wait for ten years
for their claim for promotion to be considered.
7.
Thus according to learned counsel, it amounts to artificial
classification which does not have any intelligible differentia, and the
classification made is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India.
8.
Learned counsel for the UPCL (respondent no.2) per
contra submits that UPCL came into being on 05.11.2001 and before
its creation, UPPCL was responsible for distribution of electricity. He
submits that upon creation of UPCL, officers/employees of UPPCL
were deemed to be on deputation to UPCL and later on their services
were absorbed in UPCL. He submits that Chairman and Managing
Director of UPCL issued an office memo on 18.12.2002 providing for
absorption of Group-C and Group-D employees w.e.f., 01.01.2003
who were deemed to be on deputation, in UPCL.
9.
The said office memo dated 18.12.2002 is enclosed as
annexure no.2 to the counter affidavit dated 24.06.2022 filed by
respondent no.2.
10.
Learned counsel for the UPCL relies upon Clause 1 of
office memo dated 18.12.2002 where it is mentioned that the service
conditions of employees who are absorbed in UPUCL shall not be
varied to their disadvantage. He submits that proviso to Rule 20(B) of
the Service Bye-Laws, 2018 is referable to the said condition
mentioned in the office memo dated 18.12.2002 issued by Chairman
and Managing Director, UPCL.
11.
Thus it is contended that persons who were appointed in
UPPCL and who later became employee of UPCL by absorption
constitute a separate class in view of the assurance given to them by
the Competent Authority in the year 2002 and petitioners cannot claim
parity with such employees who are protected by the aforesaid office
memo.
12.
Learned counsel for the UPCL submits that Clause 1 of
office memo dated 18.12.2002 is in the nature of a promise to
employees who were absorbed in the service of UPCL. He further
submits that the said promise was given to reassure employees of
UPPCL that no prejudice will be caused to their conditions of service
upon absorption in UPCL. He further submits that initially,
officers/employees of UPPCL were not ready for absorption of their
service in UPCL due to uncertainty about their carrier prospects. He
submits that since a promise was made to persons who became
officers/employees
of
UPCL
by
absorption,
therefore
such
officers/employees were exempted from the requirement of ten years
qualifying service for promotion, introduced in the Service Bye-Laws
framed in 2018.
13.
Learned counsel for the petitioners however submits that
petitioners as well as the other group of persons who have to serve for
five years for promotion, were appointed as Labour and upon their
promotion to the post of Technician Grade-II, they became members
of one homogenous class, therefore they cannot be treated differently.
14.
We are not impressed by the contentions raised on behalf
of the petitioners.
15.
Article 14 of the Constitution of India provides that State
shall not deny to any person equality before law or equal protection of
law within territory of India.
16.
Article 14 of the Constitution of India forbids class
legislation but it does not forbid reasonable classification. The
classification however must not be arbitrary, artificial or evasive, but
must be based on some real and substantial bearing, just and
reasonable relation to the object sought to be achieved by the
classification. Article 14 of the Constitution of India applies where
equals are treated differently without any reasonable basis. But where
equals and unequals are treated differently, Article 14 of the
Constitution of India does not apply. Class legislation is that which
makes an improper discrimination by conferring particular privileges
upon a class of persons arbitrarily selected from a large number of
persons, all of whom stand in the same relation to the privilege
granted.
17.
Classification to be reasonable must fulfil the following
conditions:
I.
The classification must be founded on intelligible
differentia which distinguishes persons or things that are grouped
together from others left out of the group.
II.
The differentia must have a rational relation to the objects
sought to be achieved by the Rule/Bye-law. The differentia which is
basis of the classification and the objective of the classification are two
distinct things. What is necessary that there must be nexus between the
basis of classification and the object of the classification. It is only
when there is no reasonable basis for a classification, then the statute
making such classification may be declared discriminatory.
18.
Now coming back to the facts of the present case. Persons
who were appointed in UPPCL and became employee of the UPCL by
absorption of service constitute a distinct class of persons by virtue of
office memo dated 18.12.2002 as they were promised that their service
conditions prevailing as on date of their absorption will remain
unchanged.
19.
UPCL as an employer can determine service conditions of
its employees including the qualifying service needed for promotion to
the next higher post. UPCL determined service conditions of its
employees by framing Service Bye-Laws in 2018 and provided that for
promotion to the post of Junior Engineer, Technician Grade-II will
have to complete qualifying service of ten years.
20.
The promise extended to employees of UPPCL, who were
appointed by absorption in UPCL however prevented UPCL to apply
the new condition regarding qualifying service to employees who were
protected by office memo dated 18.12.2002.
21.
Since employees covered by office memo dated
18.12.2002 belong to “Protected Class”, while there is no such
protection offered to petitioners, therefore the contention that
petitioners are identically placed to such persons is without substance.
22.
Thus the classification made by proviso to Rule
20(B)(two) of the Service Bye-Laws 2018 cannot be termed as
artificial classification as it has intelligible differentia and nexus with
the object sought to be achieved. For the aforesaid reasons, the relief
as claimed by petitioners cannot be granted.
23.
Accordingly writ petition fails and is dismissed.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
12.06.2026
SK
(Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.)
12.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review