Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.10.31
TELEN KOM Date:
10:50:00 +05'30'
Mat. App.No.03 of 2021
Mrs. Rahamjan, aged 47 years W/o late Thoiba D/o (Late)
Md. Chaoba of Moijing Thoubalmayum, Khongok, Thoubal
Moijing PO & PS Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur Pin
No.795138.
…. Appellant
-VersusMrs. Sana @ Shana aged about 37 years, W/O (Late) Md.
Thouba of Thoubal Kiyam Litanpok, Thoubal Moijing, PO &
PS Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur Pin No.795138.
... Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the appellants
::
Mr. Md. Jalaluddin, Sr. Adv. assisted by Mr.
Juno Rahman, Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Y. Daljeet, Adv. assisted by Ms. Amee,
Adv.
Date of Reserved
::
09.10.2023.
Judgment & Order
::
30.10.2023
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
(M.V. Muralidaran, J)
[1]
Heard Mr. Juno Rahman, learned counsel assisting Mr. Md.
Jalaluddin, learned senior counsel for the appellant and Ms. W. Amee
learned Jr. Counsel to Mr. Y. Daljeet, learned counsel for the respondent.
[2]
This appeal is filed by the appellant against the judgment and
decree dated 12.4.2021 passed by the learned Judge, Family Court,
Thoubal in Mat. (Decl.) Suit No.7 of 2020 invoking the provision of Order 8,
Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
[3]
The appellant is the defendant and the respondent is the
plaintiff in the suit.
[4]
The respondent filed Mat. (Decl.) Suit No.7 of 2020 for
declaration to declare that she is the legal wife of the deceased Md. Thoiba
and to declare that she is entitled to receive all monetary benefits on the
death of Md. Thoiba. Since the appellant has not filed the written statement,
the learned trial Judge, exercising power under Order 8, Rule 10 of CPC,
decreed the suit. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the appellant
has filed the appeal.
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Page |3
[5]
Mr. Juno Rahman, learned counsel assisting Mr. Md.
Jalaluddin, learned senior counsel for the appellant submitted that after the
receipt of summon in the suit, the appellant had engaged Mr. A. Jatishwor
Singh as counsel to defend her case and despite the appellant’s request
for filing written statement, the learned counsel has not filed the written
statement. Further, the appellant has also no knowledge or information that
her counsel failed to file the written statement or even prayed for time for
filing the written statement. Accordingly, the Family Court, in exercise of
power under Order 8, Rule 10 CPC disposed of the suit on 12.4.2021
without giving proper chance or notice to the appellant for the failure of filing
the written statement by her counsel. There was no fault on the part of the
appellant in filing the written statement.
[6]
The learned counsel further submitted that the learned Judge
failed to examine and consider the factum of the existence of the four issues
and the appellant who is legally married wife and has also failed to consider
the fact that the appellant and the four issues was getting maintenance from
Md. Thoiba while he was in service at the rate of Rs.2,200/- per month. The
question of getting financial benefits and pensionary benefits by the
appellant arising out of the death of her husband is highly permissible under
the law, as passed by the Family Court in Cril. (M) Case No.51 of 2006.
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Page |4
[7]
The learned counsel next submitted that the respondent has
no right to claim to receipt pensionary benefits arising out of the death of
Md. Thoiba. Therefore, the judgment and decree dated 12.4.2021 passed
by the learned trial Judge is illegal and needs to be set aside. The learned
counsel submitted that the appellant is now willing to file her written
statement before the Family Court for fresh trial. Further, in the suit, the
respondent has failed to implead the issues of the appellant and Md.
Thoiba. Since the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties, the
impugned judgment and decree is void and the same is liable to be set
aside for fresh trial for maintaining justice between the family members of
the deceased Md. Thoiba.
[8]
The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that because
of lock down situations, the appellant could not receive the certified copy of
the judgment and decree and she received the copy of the judgment and
decree only on 4.8.2021 and immediately thereafter, the appellant has filed
the appeal. Therefore, there is no delay in filing the appeal. Thus, a prayer
has been made to set aside the judgment and decree of the trial Judge and
give a chance to the appellant to file the written statement in the interest of
justice.
[9]
Per contra, Ms. W. Amee learned Jr. Counsel to Mr. Y. Daljeet,
learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the appellant has
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Page |5
intentionally avoided to appear and file the written statement before the
Family Court and that the appellant has already enjoyed the retirement
benefit of the death of Md. Thoiba. Just after the death of Md. Thoiba, the
appellant instead of appearing before the Family Court, went to the BSNL
office for finalisation of the pension benefits of the deceased Md. Thoiba.
After knowing the act of the appellant, the respondent submitted a
representation on 10.9.2020 to the concerned authority of the BSNL for kept
in abeyance of the process of pension and for disbursement of the
retirement benefits on the death of Md. Thoiba until the final disposal of
Mat. (Decl) Suit No.7 of 2020. However, at the pressure of the appellant,
the authorities of the BSNL had sanctioned family pension benefits to the
appellant vide PPO dated 10.2.2021.
[10]
The learned counsel further submitted that the said factum of
sanction of family pension to the appellant was brought to the notice of the
Family Court and the Family Court directed both the appellant and the
respondent to appear before the Court for amicable settlement. However,
no amicable solution arrived at between the parties. On the same day, the
appellant was also made known to the fact that she has not filed the written
statement. After that, the appellant never appeared nor filed the written
statement in spite of several adjournments through her counsel.
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Page |6
[11]
The learned counsel next submitted that the appellant ought
to have filed the written statement on or before 4.1.2021, but never filed her
written statement. In fact, the Family Court fixed the date on 6.1.2021 for
filing the written statement. Thereafter also, when the matter were fixed on
20.1.2021, 3.2.2021, 20.2.2021, 22.02.2021, 2.3.2021 and 6.4.2021, the
appellant has not filed the written statement, nor the appellant sought leave
to file the written statement after the lapse of the statutory period. It is not
necessary for the Family Court to inform the appellant before passing the
order under Order 8, Rule 10 CPC. Since the judgment and decree of the
Family Court is within the four corners of the provisions of law, the same
needs no interference. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the
appeal.
[12]
This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused
the materials available on record.
[13]
According to the appellant, the non-filing of the written
statement is because of her counsel not intimating the date of hearing and
also despite the request made by her for filing the written statement, the
learned counsel has not filed the written statement. Thus, there was no
fault on the part of the appellant in not filing the written statement within the
statutory period.
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Page |7
[14]
On the other hand, the respondent contended that during the
initial hearing of the suit, both the appellant and the respondent appeared
before the Family Court for amicable settlement and, on the said date of
appearance, the appellant was also made to know the fact that she has not
filed the written statement. No settlement was arrived at between the
parties. Thereafter also, the appellant has failed to appear before the
Family Court, nor has he taken efforts to file the written statement through
her counsel.
[15]
The learned Judge, in his judgment, recorded as under:
“On perusal of records, the present case was filed by the Plaintiff
on 09.09.2020. Summons to the Defendant was properly served
and the Defendant entered appearance only on 07.10.2020
through Ld. Advocate A.Jatishwor Singh. Thereafter, the present
case was listed on 27.10.2020, 24.11.2020, 09.12.2020,
06.01.2021, 20.01.2021, 20.01.2021, 03.02.2021, 20.02.2021,
22.02.2021,
02.03.2021
and
06.04.2021
consecutively.
However, even after the lapse of maximum period of 90 days as
stipulated in Order VIII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908, the written statement of the Defendant was not filed in all
these dates nor did the Defendant approach this Court for
granting leave to file written statement after the lapse of statutory
period. Accordingly, after hearing the Ld. Counsel for the Plaintiff,
this matrimonial declaratory suit is disposed of in exercise of the
powers conferred under Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 …….”
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Page |8
[16]
As per Order 8, Rule 10 CPC, if any person who is required to
file a written statement does not do so within the time period prescribed or
permitted by the Court, the Court shall pronounce the judgment against him
or issue an order, and a decree shall be drawn up on the pronouncement
of the judgment. The provision also makes it clear that the Court cannot
extend the 120 days duration prescribed under Rule 10 under any
circumstances for commercial disputes.
[17]
The question as to the nature of Rule 10 was answered in
various Court decisions. For suits involving non-commercial suits, Rule 10
is merely a directory provision and not mandatory. That is, in exceptional
circumstances, the time period prescribed in Rule 10 can be extended. If
the defendant does not file a written statement, the Court will pass ex parte
decree against the defendant. The Court, in its discretion, can also grant
adjournments for special reasons before passing an ex parte decree, but it
cannot be granted more than three times.
[18]
Admittedly, in the case on hand, the learned trial Judge, after
the appellant entered into appearance on 7.10.2020, has given three
adjournments which covered the statutory period of 120 days for filing the
written statement. It also appears that thereafter also the learned trial
Judge adjourned the suit for several occasion and, on 6.4.2021 finally heard
the matter and passed judgment and decree on 12.4.2021.
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Page |9
[19]
The plea of the appellant is that her counsel has not taken
effective steps for filing the written statement within the statutory period
despite of the appellant’s request.
When the appellant appointed her
counsel to defend her case, she should be more vigilant in following the
proceedings of the suit and she cannot blame her counsel for not filing the
written statement. At the same time, it is also the duty of the representing
counsel for the party to explain the existence of the provision to file the
written statement within the statutory period to the defendant concerned.
Whether or not, on the fault of the appellant or her counsel, the written
statement was not filed is not a debate in the instant case. On the other
hand, the question is whether the appellant has intentionally failed to file
the written statement within the statutory period is the question to be
considered in the instant case, coupled with the status of the parties as also
the nature of the claim made in the suit.
[20]
In the present case, the respondent has filed the suit to
declare her as legally wedded wife of Md. Thoiba alleging that Md. Thoiba
divorced the appellant on 5.1.2006 by giving three talaks before many local
heads and villagers as per the customary and three months after the
divorce, a marriage was solemnized between the respondent and Md.
Thoiba on 15.3.2006 according to Muslim customary and the respondent
begotted three daughters born through Md. Thoiba.
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
Md. Thoiba was
P a g e | 10
suffering from Cancer and died on 24.5.2020 while serving as Mazdoor on
regular basis posted at Power Plant (Telegom Bhawan), Imphal. According
to the respondent, in the service records in nominee column, the
respondent’s name mentioned as wife.
[21]
On the other hand, the appellant contended that she was
married with Md. Thoiba in the year 1985 by holding Nikah and from the
wedlock, four children were born. After the birth of last child, Md. Thoiba
started neglecting the appellant and he started to keep an extra-marital
relationship within other woman.
Unable to tolerate, in the month of
January, 2006, the appellant was turn out of her husband house and went
to her parental house with her minor children.
[22]
The appellant admitted the marriage of Md. Thoiba with the
respondent during April, 2006. Faced with the financial situation, the
appellant and her minor children filed Cril. (M) Case No.51 of 2006 for
maintenance and, by the order dated 19.10.2006, the said case was
disposed of thereby directing Md. Thoiba to give Rs.2,200/- per month as
maintenance from the month of October, 2006. According to the appellant,
she is entitled her admissible financial benefits and pensionary benefits
arising out of the death of her husband Md. Thoiba.
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
P a g e | 11
[23]
Admittedly, the talak between the appellant and Md. Thoiba
alleged by the respondent is to be proved after a full-fledged trial. Similarly,
the Nikah between the respondent and Md. Thoiba is also to be proved only
by way of trial. The respondent admitted that during the pendency of the
suit, the appellant has withdrawn the pension and terminal benefits under
PPO dated 10.2.2021 from the Department of Telecommunications, Office
of the Joint Controller of Communications Accounts North Eastern Telecom
Circle-II, BSNL, OCB Exchange Building, Dimapur. Thus, this Court is of
the view that there are triable issues involved in the suit. Due to non-filing
of the written statement, the trial Court exercising power under Order 8,
Rule 10 CPC cannot decree the suit as prayed for by the respondent.
[24]
Considering the facts and circumstances of the given case
and taking note of the fact that the present suit is non-commercial suit,
coupled with the fact that triable issues are involved and also the prayer
made in the suit, this Court is inclined to treat the present suit as an
exceptional one.
[25]
Time and again, the Apex Court emphazied the exceptional
circumstances of a case as a valid reason for granting permission for filing
a written statement after the expiry of the statutory period. Similarly, in a
catena of judgments, the Apex Court interpreted the provisions of the CPC
which protect the right of the defendant and also provide for the speedy
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
P a g e | 12
delivery of justice to the plaintiff. The Apex Court has explicitly interpreted
the provisions relating to commercial suits and non-commercial suits. In
the case of non-commercial suits, some flexibility is allowed under the
provisions, but only in exceptional cases. As stated supra, the pleadings of
the parties would establish that the present suit is exceptional one. The
reason for not filing the written statement within the statutory period has
been explained by the appellant/defendant.
[26]
It is pertinent to note that, in a case, especially where a written
statement has not been filed within the statutory period, the Court should
be a little cautious in proceeding under Order 8, Rule 10 CPC. Before
passing the judgment against the defendant exercising power under Order
8, Rule 10 CPC, it must see to it that even if the facts set out in the plaint
are treated to have been admitted, a judgment could possibly be passed in
favour of the plaintiff without requiring him to prove any fact mentioned in
the plaint. It is a matter of the Court’s satisfaction and therefore only on
being satisfied that there is no fact which need be proved on account of
deemed admission, the Court can conveniently pass a judgment against
the defendant who has not filed the written statement. But if the plaint itself
indicates that there are disputed questions of fact involved in the case
regarding which two different versions are set out in the plaint itself, it would
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
P a g e | 13
not be safe for the Court to pass a judgment without requiring the plaintiff
to prove the facts so as to settle the factual controversy.
[27]
In the instant case, as stated supra, the respondent sought for
declaration to declare her as legally wedded wife of Md. Thoiba and to
declare that she is entitled to receive all the money benefits on the death of
Md. Thoiba. The factum of marriage between the appellant and Md. Thoiba
as also the children born from the wellock are admitted by the respondent.
When the respondent sought declaration relief to declare that she is the
legally wedded wife of the deceased and also entitled to receive the
monetary benefits on the death of Md. Thoiba, she ought to have impleaded
the children born from the wedlock of the appellant and Md. Thoiba as
defendants in the suit. Similarly, the department in which the deceased
was working has also to be added as defendant in the suit for proper
adjudication. In the instant case, admittedly, the respondent has failed to
do so.
[28]
Therefore, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case
and also in the interest of justice, this Court is inclined to give one more
chance to the appellant to file her defence by way of written statement
within the stipulated time. Considering the nature of claim made in the suit
and also the relationship of the parties, if further time is granted to the
appellant for filing written statement, no prejudice would be caused to the
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
P a g e | 14
respondent, as the respondent herself admitted that the appellant has
withdrawn pension and terminal benefits from the Department.
If the
appellant files the written statement and based on the pleadings, trial
commenced and concluded, the real controversy between the respondent
and the appellant would come to light and also the Court of law would
render justice to the parties. Therefore, this Court is of the view that the
judgment and decree of the Family Court is liable to set aside and
remanded the matter back to the Family Court.
[29]
For all the reasons stated above, while setting aside the
judgment and decree dated 12.4.2021 passed in Mat. (Decl) Suit No.7 of
2020 on the file of Family Court, Thoubal, the case is remanded back to the
Family Court, Thoubal with liberty to the appellant to file written statement
within fifteen days from the date to be fixed by the Family Court upon the
receipt of the copy of this order and thereafter the Family Court shall decide
the lis between the parties on merits and in accordance with law
expeditiously. It is made clear that this Court has not delved into the merits
of the lis in this order. Only in the peculiar facts and circumstances, this
Court passed the aforesaid order. Therefore, this order need not be cited
as precedent in any other case. No costs.
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
P a g e | 15
JUDGE
FR/NFR
John Kom
Mat.App.No.03 of 2021
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review