Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURTOF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on:21stAugust, 2026
Pronounced on: 09th October, 2026
Uploaded on: 09th October,2026
%
#
CNR No.DLHC010650132024
+
RFA 656/2024, CM APPL. 56907/2024
MRS. RADHA GOYAL
D/oLate Sh. Dinesh Chand Goyal
W/o Shri Amit Garg
R/o 1682/2, LGF Govind Puri Extension
Kalkaji, New Delhi-110019.
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. K.K. Bhati, Mr. Trilok Nath
Saxena, Ms. Shalu Bhati, Dr. Shiv
Kumar Tiwari, Advocates.
versus
1.
GAURAV GOYAL
S/o Late Shri Dinesh Chand Goyal
R/o1691/2, Gopal Ice Cream,
Gopal House, Govind Puri Extension,
Kalkaji, New Delhi-110019.
2.
MRS. UMA GARG
D/o Late Sh. Dinesh Chand Goyal
W/o Shri Mukesh Garg
R/o L-15 Third Floor, Kalkaji,
New Delhi-110019.
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Neelakshi Bhadauria,Mr. Sarthak
Karol, Ms. Tanishka Pawar, Mr.
Shashank Sharma,Advocates for R-1
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular First Appeal under Section 96 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟) has been filed by
the Plaintiff/Appellant, Mrs Radha Goyal, against the Judgment and Decree
dated 18.05.2024, passed by the learned District Judge, Delhi, whereby the
Suit of the Plaintiff/Appellant for Partition, Possession, Rendition of
Accounts, and grant of Permanent Injunction, was rejected under Order VII
Rule 11(b) and (d) of CPC.
2.
The Plaintiff filed the Suit bearing CS No. 150/2014 for Partition
before the court of learned ASCJ wherein Notice was issued against the
Defendants. The Defendant No. 1, in his Written statement, took various
objections in regard to the jurisdiction of the Court by asserting that the
value of the suit property was more than ₹3,00,00,000/- and the suit was
beyond the territorial jurisdiction of the learned Judge.
3.
The learned, ASCJ passed the Order dated 26.05.2014 by the virtue of
which, the Suit CS No. 150/2014 was dismissed as withdrawn with the
liberty to the Plaintiff to file a fresh before the Competent Court. The Suit
bearing No. 2442/14 was filed by the Plaintiff before this Hon’ble Court on
14.08.2014.
The Plaintiff, Mrs. Radha Goyal, thereafter filed the Suit
bearing CS (OS) No. 2442/2014 filed before this Court on 14.08.2014 for
Partition, Possession, Rendition of Accounts, and Grant of Permanent
Injunction. However, vide Order dated 09.02.2016, it was directed by this
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
Court to be transferred to District Court, Delhi as the suit for partition was
valued at less than Rs. 2,00,00,000/-.
4.
The Plaintiff, Mrs. Radha Goyal then filed Civil suit bearing
No.53/2017 seeking a decree of Partition, Possession, Rendition of
accounts and grant of Permanent Injunction against Defendant No.
1/Respondent No. 1 i.e. Sh. Gaurav Goyal and Defendant No. 2/Respondent
No. 2 i.e. Mrs. Uma Gargin respect of:
(i)
property bearing No. 1675/2 Govind Puri Extension Kalkaji,
New Delhi; ad-measuring about 170 sq. yards;
(ii)
Entire property including Shop No. 1 to 4 of the property
bearing No. 1691/2 Govind Puri, Extension, Delhi; admeasuring 200 sq. yards;
(iii)
Flat No. B-3 Ganga Vatika, LaxmanJhula Road, Rishikesh,
Uttarakhand;
(iv)
Cash and other valuables left behind by the parents of the
parties; and
(v)
the income generated by the Defendant No. 1 from the business
“Gopal Ice Cream” and the income generated by Respondent
No. 1/Defendant No. 1 by renting out parts of the above noted
immovable
properties;
(hereinafter
referred
as
“suit
properties”).
5.
The Defendant No. 1 filed an Application before this Court, under
Order VII Rule 11 read with Section 151 CPC and under Section 8 of the
Suits Valuation Act, 1887. The Rejection of the Suit was sought on the
ground that the Plaintiff had not valued the suit for the purpose of Court fees
and jurisdiction properly, as she had failed to disclose the value of the
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
property in respect of which she had sought Partition and Rendition of
Accounts. However, during the arguments on I.A. No. 17987/2014, the
counsel of Defendant No.1 withdrew the Application and it was dismissed as
withdrawn, vide Order dated 13.03.2015.
6.
The Plaintiff asserted that her father, Sh. Dinesh Chand Goyal and the
mother, Mrs. Rajni Goyal were joint owners in respect of Property No (i).
The father was the owner of Property No. (ii) and(iii).
7.
The father had also been running a business the name and style of
“Gopal Ice Cream”as the proprietor at the aforesaid shops. It was claimed
that all the aforesaid properties were self-acquired properties of the father,
late Shri Dinesh Chand Goyal. The father i.e. Sh. Dinesh Goyal and mother,
Mrs. Rajni Goyal, died intestate on 13.02.2006 and 17.12.2010 respectively.
8.
The Defendant No. 1, Gaurav Goyal, the brother and Defendant No. 2,
Mrs. Uma Garg, is the sister of the Plaintiff. The movable and immovable
assets of Dinesh Goyal and Mrs. Rajni Goyal devolved on all the legal heirs
in equal share, as per the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and ought to be
distributed amongst all the legal heirs as per law.
9.
The Plaintiff got married in 2008, though she got separated by way of
divorce, wherein she got ₹11,00,000/- as alimony. The Plaintiff got
remarried on 20.03.2010 and since her second marriage was a love marriage,
no dowry article was given in her marriage. However, from the above
alimony, the Plaintiff purchased a flat bearing No. 1682/2, LGF, Kalkaji,
Delhi in her name.
10.
After marriage, the Plaintiff requested the Defendants to mutually
partition the suit properties by metes and bounds and give her respective
shares in the suit properties, to which Defendant No. 1 stated that the
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
Plaintiff would have to sign some documents, for the purpose of Partition of
properties and business. Accordingly, the Plaintiff, at the behest of
Defendant No. 1 and in good faith, signed some blank documents
innocently. However, when the Plaintiff again approached Defendant No. 1,
he did not agree to Partition and did not even admit the claim of Plaintiff
over the suit properties and business, since he had an intention to
misappropriate the suit properties after selling it to third parties and he was
already in negotiation with several parties in the locality, for disposing of the
suit properties.
11.
The Plaintiff claims that as a counter-blast, Defendant No. 1 filed
false and frivolous Suit bearing No. 300/2014 against the Plaintiff, in
respect of the flat which had been purchased by the Plaintiff in her name
from her own alimony, which is pending adjudication in the court of ADJ,
Saket Court, though Defendant No. 1 claimed it to have been purchased by
him.
12.
The Suit was contested by the Defendant No. 1, who in his Amended
Written Statement, took the preliminary objection that the suit is not
maintainable as the Suit had not been properly valued and has not paid the
proper court fees, as the Plaintiff was not in possession of any portion of the
property for which she has sought the partition; that this Hon’ble Court did
not have pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain the suit; and the suit was barred
by time.
13.
An objection was also taken that the Plaintiff has verified the Plaint as
true and correct on oath, knowing that those are false and the Plaintiff is
liable to be prosecuted under Section 340 of Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 for perjury.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
14.
Further, the Defendant No. 1 took the objection that the Suit of the
Plaintiff is not maintainable without seeking decree of Declaration in respect
of the property which stood transferred vide Gift Deed dated 17.11.2009 of
which the Plaintiff herself has been a witness.
15.
The Defendant No. 1 further asserted that the plaint is without any
cause of action and is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
16.
The Defendant No. 1 also took the objection that the Property (i) has
been built by the parents of Defendant No. 1 and was not jointly owned by
mother and father of the parties, but they had their separate portions, vide
separate Sale documents. It was asserted that Shop No. 3 of propertyNo.
1691/2 is an individual property of Defendant No. 1 and the business under
the name and style of ‘M/s Gopal Ice Cream’ was also earlier in
partnership which stood dissolved and thereafter, the Defendant No. 1
became its sole proprietor. Further, the property bearing No.1691/2, Govind
Puri Extension, Delhi belongs to the Defendant No. 1 and it is purchased by
him. So far as Property (iii) is concerned, it was built by his father, Sh.
Dinesh Chand Goyal and mother, Mrs. Rajni Goyal and is well within the
knowledge of the Plaintiff, as well as the Defendant No. 2.
17.
It was asserted that the following properties by the virtue of Wills,
was bequeathed in favour of Defendant No. 1:
Particulars of
Property
Particulars of Will
1. 1675/4A
measuring
40 sq. yards
Will
11.03.2002
Status of Property
Dated Defendant No. 1 executed sale
deed dated 18.08.2006 in favour
of his wife and thereafter she
conveyed it back to Defendant
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
No. 1 vide Gift Deed dated
17.11.2009. The said Gift Deed
has been witnessed by the
Plaintiff.
2. 1675/4
measuring
40 sq. yards
Separated
Will dated 11.03.2002
3. 1675/4,
Will
Govind Puri 17.04.2002
Extension,
New Delhi
measuring
45 sq. yards
dated Defendant No. 1 executed sale
deed dated 18.08.2006 in favour
of his wife and thereafter she
conveyed it back to Defendant
No. 1 vide Gift Deed dated
17.11.2009. The said Gift Deed
has been witnessed by the
Plaintiff.
4. Godown in Will
property
11.02.2002
bearing No.
1691/2 i.e.
Shop 1 & 2
dated Defendant No. 1 executed sale
deed in favour of his wife and
thereafter she conveyed it back
to Defendant No. 1 vide Gift
Deed. The said Gift Deed has
been witnessed by the Plaintiff.
5. Shop No. 4, Separate Will dated
property
11.02.2002
No. 1691/2
admeasuring
10 ft. x 10
ft.
6. Entire estate Will
of the father 26.04.2003
i.e.
Sh.
Dinesh
Goyal
Defendant No. 1 executed sale
deed in favour of his wife and
thereafter she conveyed it back
to Defendant No. 1 vide Gift
Deed. The said Gift Deed has
been witnessed by the Plaintiff.
dated Bequeathed in the favour of the
Defendant No. 1 and disinherited
all other legal heirs and as such
the Plaintiff and Defendant No.
2 had no right or share in any
property or business.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
18.
Further, the Defendant No. 1 purchased the Shop No. 3 of 1691/2,vide
Sale Deed dated 24.05.2011 for consideration amount of Rs. 35,00,000/-.
Similarly, property bearing No. 1691, Gali No. 2 measuring 200 sq. yards
out of Kharsa No. 25, situated at Govind Puri Extension, Kalkaji, New
Delhi was purchased by Defendant No. 1 from his own funds, vide Sale
Deed dated 13.05.2011, for consideration amount of Rs. 75,00,000/-.
Therefore, the Plaintiff and Defendant No. 2 had nothing to do with the said
properties.
19.
On merits, the Defendant asserted that Sh. Amit Garg, who is the
present husband of the Plaintiff, owes lakhs of rupees to the Defendant No. 1
and since the Defendant No. 1 was demanding his money, the Plaintiff filed
the false and frivolous suit.
20.
It was asserted that the estates of the deceased parents were
bequeathed in favour of Defendant No. 1 by the virtue of the Wills and that
neither the Plaintiff, nor the Defendant No. 2 has anything to do with the
estate left behind by the parents.
21.
The Defendant No. 1 further denied that no dowry was given, when
the Plaintiff re-married on 20.03.2010. The Flat no. 1682/2, LGF, Kalkaji,
Delhi was purchased in the name of Plaintiff, but the whole amount was paid
by Defendant No.1 and the Plaintiff had promised to pay it back within one
year or else agreed to transfer the property to Defendant No. 1, who entered
into the Agreement to purchase and paid the amount. It is further denied that
Defendant No. 1 ever asked the Plaintiff to sign some blank
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
papers/documents for the purpose of the partition of properties and business,
or that the Plaintiff innocently signed the documents.
22.
The Defendant No. 1 accordingly, prayed for dismissal of the suit with
exemplary cost.
23.
The Plaintiff filed her Replication, wherein she reiterated the
averments made in the Plaint and denied the assertions contained in the
Amended Written Statement filed by the Defendant No. 1. The
Plaintiffasserted that the Defendant No. 1 does not want to give the share to
his sisters i.e. Plaintiff and Defendant No. 2 and had not come with clean
hands before the Hon’ble Court.
24.
The Plaintiff asserted that the parents of the parties died intestate and
there is no question of any Will being executed in the favour of the
Defendant No. 1, with respect to the suit properties. Further, it was stated by
the Plaintiff that the annexed Wills with the Written Statement, are false and
forged and baseless and the Defendant No. 1 did not obtain the Probate in
respect of these alleged Wills from the competent court, because the same
are forged.
25.
The following Issues were framed, on 12.12.2019:
1. “Whether the suit is bad for want of proper court fees? OPD
2. Whether the suit is bad in view of four wills, all dated 11.03.2020
executed by parents of the parties in favour of the Defendant No. 1?
OPD
3. Whether present suit is bad for including self-acquired property of
Defendant No. 1? OPD
4. Whether present suit is non maintainable without seeking decree of
declaration in view of para no. 3 of the written statement? OPD
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
5. Whether plaintiff is entitled to decree of partition as prayed for? OPP
6. Whether plaintiff is entitled to decree of possession as prayed for?
OPP
7. Whether plaintiff is entitled to rendition of account as prayed for?
OPP
8. Whether plaintiff is entitled to decree of permanent injunction? OPP
Relief.”
26.
The Plaintiff asserted that from the transfer of the suit, the issues were
framed vide order dated 12.12.2019. However, the evidence could not
beeven after more than one and half years.
27.
The learned ADJ, vide Order dated 21.08.2021, observed that the
Plaintiff must disclose the valuation for each of the reliefs separately, and
further state the Court fees which is required to be paid. The Plaintiff, in the
Suit for Partition, was supposed to disclose if she was in possession of any
part of the suit properties sought to be partitioned; as a fixed Court fees as
per Article 17(vi) of the Court-Fees Act, 1870 is then payable; and if she
was not in possession, then she was required to pay ad-valorem Court fees,
as per the value of her share in the properties sought to be partitioned.
28.
The learned ADJ, vide Order dated 24.09.2021 observed that in case
the requisite amendment in paragraph 11 of the Plaint was not carried out
properly for all the reliefs, the plaint of the Suit would be rejected under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
29.
The Plaintiff filed Application under Order VI Rule 17 read with
Section 151 CPC on 10.02.2023, but the learned ADJ neither issue Notice,
nor decided this Application on merits.
30.
The learned ADJ passed the Order dated 16.02.2023, rejecting the
Plaint under Order VII Rule 11(b) CPC. It was observed that the logical
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
question for the consideration was whether the Plaintiff complied regarding
valuation of a suit, for the purpose of jurisdiction and court-fees. It was held
that the proposed amended plaint filed by the Plaintiff on 10.02.2023 also
does not comply regarding valuation of a suit for the purpose of jurisdiction
and court-fees.
31.
The Plaintiff had again, not specified:
“a) what is the value of relief of rendition of accounts for the purpose
of jurisdiction and court-fees, what court-fees is payable by the
plaintiff qua the relief of rendition of accounts (re: Section 7(iv)(f) of
the Court-fees Act, 1870) and what part of total court-fees viz.
Rs.530/- paid by the plaintiff till date, is in respect of the said relief
and
(b) what is the value of relief of partition, for the purpose of courtfees, what court-fees is payable by the plaintiff qua the relief of
partition and what part of total court-fees viz. Rs.530/- paid by the
plaintiff till date, is in respect of the said relief.”
32.
It was further held that the plaintiff has created a dichotomy by taking
inconsistent pleas regarding the court-fees payable by the plaintiff qua the
relief of partition. At one stage, the plaintiff has pleaded that the court-fees
payable by her, is fixed court-fees of Rs.20/- because she is in joint
possession of the immovable properties, sought to be partitioned, by way of
this suit. At another stage, the plaintiff has undertaken to pay the court-fees
as per her 1/3rd share in all the suit properties, at the time of drawing up of
decree in this suit.
33.
The Order dated 16.02.2023passed by learned ADJ was challenged
before this Hon’ble Court vide RFA No. 470/2023, which was decided vide
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
Order dated 19.09.2023. The impugned judgment dated 16.02.2023 was set
aside and the Suit was remanded back to the learned Trial Court,for
consideration of the Application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC filed by the
Plaintiff.
34.
The Application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC read with Section 151
CPC filed on 10.02.2023 filed by the Plaintiff, was dismissed on 22.11.2023,
andit was observed that the Plaintiff is not in possession of any of the suit
properties and that she cannot avoid payment of ad-valorem Court Fees
under Section 7(iv)(b) of the Court-fees Act, and these observations had
become final. The Plaintiff did not challenge the Order dated 22.11.2023.
35.
Thereafter, the matter was fixed for consideration of the Application
under Order VII Rule 11(b) CPC. The Plaintiff filed Application under
Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 CPC, on 15.12.2023. The learned
ADJ dismissed the Application, vide Order dated 15.01.2024.
36.
The Plaintiff filed a Civil Revision Petition bearing CRP No.
100/2024 challenging the Order dated 15.01.2024 vide which the second
Application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, was dismissed. However, the
Revision Petition was dismissed by this Court, vide Order dated 01.04.2024,
by observing that instead of filing an Application to comply with the
observations of the Court in regard to the reliefs being separately valued, the
Plaintiff had tried to mould the amendment in a way that the Plaintiff may
not have to pay the requisite Court Fees on the reliefs claimed by her, which
was an abuse of the process of law.
37.
Thereafter, learned District Judge, rejected the Plaint under Order
VII Rule 11(b) and (d) CPC. In the impugned Order dated 18.05.2024, by
observing that the plaintiff must clearly state valuation for each of the reliefs
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
separately, and further state the amount of court-fees which is being paid by
the Plaintiff. The Defendant No.1, along with his Written Statement in
earlier Suit No.150/2014, had filed registered Wills, MOU, Gift Deed, Sale
Deeds, etc. The Plaintiff thus had knowledge of the Gift Deed, Sale Deed,
MOU, and Affidavit prior to the filing of the Partition Suit in 2014, which
facts had been suppressed and concealed by her, in order to circumvent the
provisions of Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
38.
Further, the Court held that Defendant no. 1 had produced a copy of
the Will by which the properties had been bequeathed to him, despite which
the plaintiff had neither disclosed about the Will nor challenged it, and thus,
the Suit for Partition, simplicitor was not maintainable. The period of
limitation seeking declaration of validity of a Will qua the suit properties,
was three years, which expired long before the filing of the Suit for Partition,
in 2014.The Plaintiff failed to amend the Suit, in terms of directions given
by the Court on 24.09.2021.
39.
Hence, the Suit was rejected for non-payment of Court fees as well
as being barred by limitation.
40.
Aggrieved by the impugned Judgment dated 18.05.2024, the
Plaintiff/Appellant has been preferred the present Regular First Appeal.
41.
The first challenge is that in paragraph 3 of the Plaint, it was clearly
mentioned that the Plaintiff was in joint possession of the Suit Properties and
therefore, the learned trial court wrongly concluded that the Plaintiff was not
in possession, while deciding the Application under Order VI Rule 17 read
with Section 151 CPC, vide order dated 22.11.2023, which got reaffirmed
in the Judgment dated 18.05.2024.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
42.
It was wrongly held that the plaintiff did not comply with Order dated
21.08.2021 and 24.09.2021. The Trial Court wrongly held that the Plaintiff
did not amended the Plaint within time, when the Applications under Order
VI Rule 17 were dismissed by the learned Trial Court, without considering
the actual facts and circumstances of the case; thus, no question arises to
give time to plaintiff for amending the plaint and to pay court fees.
43.
The second challenge is that, since the Plaintiff had clearly mentioned
in the Plaint that she was in join possession of the suit properties and had
paid the requisite fixed court fees.
44.
Furthermore, an issue was framed about whether the Suit was bad for
proper Court fees, which without taking any evidence, has been decided
against the Plaintiff under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
45.
The third challenge is that the learned Trial Court has observed that
there was a violation of Section 11 of the Suits Valuation Act. However, the
Suit has been erroneously rejected since the issue had been framed in regard
to the Court fees, which could have been decided only by leading evidence.
The learned trial court failed to consider that the present case is pending for
adjudication, since 2014 and listed in Evidence. However, due to outbreak of
Covid-19, evidence could not be completed. Despite ongoing recoding of the
evidence, the trial court took suo moto action regarding the valuation and
court fee and theSuit has been rejected. The Plaintiff asserted that it
isabsolutely against the principal of law and this issue in regard to Court
Fees, should have been decided on merits of the case, along with all the
issues framed.
46.
The fourth challenge is that it has been wrongly held that the Suit of
the Plaintiff, was barred by limitation. It was stated that since the parents
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
of the parents died intestate, so, the cause of action will continue, till the suit
property is partitioned, as per law.
47.
It is therefore, submitted that the impugned Order dated 18.05.2024
be set aside.
48.
The Written synopsis was filed by the Plaintiff/Appellant, reiterating
the assertions made in the grounds of appeal.
49.
The Defendant No.1/Respondent No. 1, in the Written Submissions
had stated that the plaint valued the composite relief of Partition, Possession,
and Rendition of accounts, at ₹1.5 crores and merely undertook to pay the
Court fees, after the determination of the Suit. It did not value the relief
separately or identify the Court fees payable on each relief.
50.
The learned Trial Court had identified this defect in its Orders dated
21.08.2021 and 24.09.2021, which is also evident from paragraph 11 of the
Plaint itself. Despite an opportunity being given, there was no amendment
made of paragraph 11 of the Plaint, and therefore the Suit has been rightly
rejected, under Order VII Rule 11 CPC. In the second amended
Application, it proposed an overall jurisdictional value of ₹5.94 crores and
claimed to pay fixed Court fees on the footing of joint possession, but
simultaneously undertook to pay the court fees once the Appellant’s share
was determined.
51.
The learned Trial Court had thus, dismissed the Application under
Order VI Rule 17 CPC, which Order has been confirmed in CRP No.
100/2024, on 22.11.2023. This Order remained unchallenged. The third
attempt of amendment was also rejected on 15.01.2024, in CRP No.
100/2024.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
52.
It is further submitted that a bare plea of joint possession, to avoid ad-
valorem Court fees was evident from the reading of the Plaint itself, and
therefore, it was held that she was not in possession of any of the Suit
properties. These findings in the Order dated 22.11.2023 rejecting the
amendment Application have remained unchallenged.
53.
Insofar as the framing of issues was concerned, it was contended that
the rejection of the Suit under Order VII Rule 11(b) CPC, is expressly
contemplated in case the Suit is not valued properly, for the purpose of Court
fees and jurisdiction.
54.
It was therefore, submitted that there is no merit in the Appeal, which
is liable to be dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused.
55.
The short ground on which the Suit has been rejected is on the failure
to value each relief separately and to pay the ad-valorem Court fees. The
question for adjudication before this Hon’ble Court is, whether the learned
Trial Court was justified in rejecting the plaint under Order VII Rule 11(b)
and (d) of the CPC, upon the failure of appellant to comply with repeated
directions videOrder dated 21.08.2021 and 24.09.2021 concerning valuation
and payment of requisite court fees and also as barred of limitation, as is
apparent from the Plaint and admissions made, therein.
56.
The paragraph 11 of the Plaint read as under:
“11. That the value of the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction is
assessed by the Plaintiff at Rs. 1.5 Crores for the relief at Partition,
Possession and Rendition of Accounts, however, the Plaintiff
undertakes to pay the court fees after the determination of the same by
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
this Hon‟ble Court. However, for the other relief of permanent
injunction, the suit is valued at Rs. 130/- and accordingly the same is
affixed hereto.”
57.
However, on the holistic reading of the Plaint, it was found evident
that Plaint did not clearly disclose that plaintiff was in physical possession of
any suit property, in respect of which possession was sought. Therefore, advalorem court fees were required to be paid.
58.
In the Application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC dated 10.02.2023
proposed the amendment in the Plaint. The paragraph 11 of the proposed
amended plaint filed by the Plaintiff on 10.02.2023 is reproduced below:
“11. That the value of the suit for the purpose of
jurisdiction is assessed by the plaintiff at Rs. 5 Crores 94
Lacs (Rupees Five Crore and Ninety Four Lakhs) for the
reliefs of partition, possession and rendition of accounts.
The details of the immovable and moveable properties as
under:
(A)
(i) The property bearing no.1675/2, Govind Puri
Extension, Delhi measuring about 170 sq. yards having
its approximately value Rs.88,00,000/- (Rupees Eighty
Eight Lakhs Only);
(ii) The property No.1691/2 including four shops at
Govind Puri Extension, Delhi measuring 200 sq. yards
having its approximately value Rs.2.86 Crores (Rupees
Two Crores Eighty Six Lakhs Only).
(iii) The Property bearing Flat No. B-3, Ganga Vatika,
Laxman Jhula Road, Rishikesh, Uttarakhand, having its
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
approximately value Rs.25,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty File
Lakhs Only).
However. the plaintiff is in joint possession in the above
said immovable suit properties. So, the fixed court fees
has been paid Rs.20/- as per the articles 17(vi) of the
court fee Act, 1870.
(B)
(i) The income from Business "Gopal Ice
Cream‟ having Rs. 60 Lakhs since the year 2010. The
said amount may be low or high rendering true accounts
by defendant No.1 and adjudicated by this Hon'ble Court.
(ii)
The
Gold
ornament
approximately
value
Rs.25,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Lakhs Only) and
cash amount Rs.50,00,000/- (Rupees Fifty Lakhs Only)
and rental income since the year 2010 Rs.60,00,000/(Rupees Sixty Lakhs Only), the said amount may be low
or high rendering true accounts by defendant No.1 and
adjudicated by this Hon'ble Court. The total value of said
moveable properties is Rs.1,35,00,000/- (Rupees One
Crore Thirty Five Lakhs Only).
(C) That the plaintiff undertakes will pay the requisite
court fees on her share i.e. 1/3rd or such share in the
suit properties. as may be determined by this Hon'ble
Court, finally, before the decree is drawn.
For, the other relief of permanent injunction suit is
valued at Rs.130/- on which the prescribed court fees is
prayed, with regard to court fees paid for the above
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
relief(s), if any deficiency found will be made good by
plaintiff before the decree is drawn finally, as the plaintiff
presently has no means to pay, who is housewife.”
59.
The learned ADJ vide Order dated 16.02.2023, held that the proposed
amended plaint filed by the Plaintiff, also does not comply regarding
valuation of the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction and court-fees.
60.
The Plaintiff had filed Application under Order VI Rule 17 read with
Section 151 CPC, on 15.12.2023. The learned ADJ dismissed the
Application, vide Order dated 15.01.2024.
61.
The Order dated 15.01.2024 was confirmed in Civil Revision Petition
bearing CRP No. 100/2024 whereby the Application under Order VI Rule
17 CPC was dismissed, and thus attained finality.
62.
It is evident from the Plaint itself that the Plaintiff was not in
possession of any of the suit properties in respect of which she had claimed
partition, and thus, ad-valorem Court fees was required to be paid. The
Plaintiff made several attempts for amendment of the Plaint, but it had been
evident that every time she avoided evaluating each relief separately. Even
in the Amendment Application, she had stated that she would pay her part
of the Court fees, after the decree is passed. Therefore, it is evident that
despite several opportunities, the Plaintiff failed to value the suit correctly,
in respect of each relief.
63.
The power under Order VII Rule 11 CPC is undoubtedly, drastic in
consequence and must be exercised with circumspection. The provision is
intended to ensure that a Plaintiff cannot prosecute a suit on a valuation,
which is not legally sustainable or avoid payment of court fees, which are
otherwise payable on the reliefs claimed. However, where a plaintiff, despite
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
being specifically directed to correct the valuation of the suit and to pay the
requisite court fee within the time granted by the Court, fails to do so the
statutory consequence of rejection of the Suit, was inevitable, under Order
VII Rule 11 CPC.
64.
The Plaintiff failed to amend the plaint or pay the requisite Court
Fees. Despite several opportunities, the Suit was rightly rejected for want of
proper Court fees, under Order VII Rule 11(b) CPC.
65.
The reliefs of Possession, Rendition of Accounts and grant of
Permanent Injunction are dependent upon the Plaintiff establishing her
entitlement to a share in the suit properties. Here, the suit properties are
stated to have been bequeathed in favour of Defendant No.1 under Wills,
and the plaintiff is admittedly aware of such Wills. A Suit for Partition
cannot be maintained, while deliberately leaving the instrument which stands
in the way of the claimed title, unchallenged. The learned Trial Court was,
therefore, justified in examining whether the suit, as framed, was legally
maintainable on the date of its institution.
66.
Further, it is evident that Plaintiff had the knowledge of the Will and
the documents affecting the suit properties since 2014 when the Defendant
No.1 had filed the Suit against the Plaintiff. If the claim of the Plaintiff was
that the Will or the subsequent documents were invalid, non-binding or
otherwise incapable of affecting her rights, an appropriate Declaratory Relief
was required to be raised, within the period prescribed by law. The Trial
Court has recorded that the limitation for seeking such Declaration had
expired long, prior to the institution of the present proceedings. On the facts
recorded in the impugned order, there is no reason to take a different view.
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
67.
The Plaintiff has failed to demonstrate any error in the impugned
Order dated 18.05.2024, which would warrant any interference.
68.
The learned District Judge has rightly rejected the Suit of the Plaintiff,
under Order VII Rule 11(b) and (d) CPC. There is no merit in the present
Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed.
69.
Pending Applications are disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
OCTOBER 09, 2026
va
Digitally Signed
By:VIKAS ARORA
19:03:10
RFA 656/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review