Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:37388
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr. Revision No. 528 of 2026
Reserved on: 20.08.2026
Date of Decision: 03.09.2026
Rachna Verma
...Petitioner
Versus
Inderjeet Singh
...Respondent
Coram
Hon’ble Mr Justice Rakesh Kainthla, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1 No
For the Petitioner
:
Mr Vijay Panchta, Legal Aid
Counsel.
For the respondent
:
Nemo
Rakesh Kainthla, Judge
The present revision is directed against the judgment
dated 23.05.2026 passed by learned Chairman, H.P. STAT,
exercising the powers of Additional Sessions Judge, Hamirpur
(learned Revisional Court), vide which the order dated 07.02.2025
passed by learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Court No.3,
Hamirpur (learned Trial Court) was upheld. (The parties shall
hereinafter be referred to in the same manner as they were arrayed
before the learned Trial Court for convenience.)
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2.
2026:HHC:37388
Briefly stated, the facts giving rise to the present
revision are that the applicant filed an application under Section 23
of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2025 (DV
Act) for seeking various reliefs, including interim maintenance,
protection order and residence order. It was asserted that the
applicant and respondent were married to each other on
22.10.2023. The respondent maltreated the applicant, and he
compelled her to sleep on the floor. He continuously taunted her
for bringing insufficient dowry. The respondent locked the Kitchen
and denied her access to food. A compromise was effected between
the parties in which the respondent apologised for his behaviour
and requested her to return to her matrimonial home. When the
applicant attempted to return to her matrimonial home on
22.12.2023, she was thrown out of the matrimonial home and was
threatened with dire consequences. The respondent is employed as
an Assistant Professor in a Government College. He is earning a
monthly salary of ₹1,00,000/-. Hence, an application for interim
maintenance of ₹40,000/- per month was sought along with the
other reliefs.
3.
The application was opposed by filing a reply. It was
admitted that the marriage between the applicant and respondent
2026:HHC:37388
was solemnised. It was asserted that the applicant resided in her
matrimonial home for 4-5 days and the applicant treated the
respondent as a stranger. Her behaviour was abnormal from the
very beginning, and she even refused to participate in the wedding
photograph. The applicant persistently refused to cohabit with the
respondent and misbehaved with him and his family members. The
respondent shared his concerns with the applicant’s father on
28.10.2023, who said that he would counsel the applicant to lead a
normal matrimonial life. He also requested the respondent to leave
the applicant in her parental home. The respondent left the
applicant in her parental home. The applicant made a false
complaint before the police on 02.11.2023. The matter was
compromised between the parties at the Police Station. The
applicant and her family members entered into the respondent's
house and created a scene. The applicant and her family members
abused them and violently behaved with the respondent’s family.
The applicant is employed as an Assistant Professor, and she has
filed a false complaint. Hence, it was prayed that the present
application be dismissed.
4.
Learned Trial Court held that the marriage between the
parties was solemnised on 22.10.2023 and the parties were residing
2026:HHC:37388
separately since 28.10.2023. The compromise dated 03.11.2023
mentioned that the parties had mutually agreed to reside
separately due to some misunderstanding between them. No
reference was made to any domestic violence committed against
the applicant. The plea taken by the respondent that he was treated
as a stranger and was not permitted to consummate the marriage
was believable. The applicant was financially independent and did
not require any maintenance for her subsistence. Therefore, the
application was dismissed.
5.
Being aggrieved by the order passed by the learned Trial
Court, the applicant filed an appeal, which was decided by the
learned Chairman, H.P. STAT, exercising the powers of Additional
Sessions Judge, Hamirpur (learned Appellate Court). The learned
Appellate Court concurred with the findings recorded by the
learned Trial Court that the parties had resided together for a short
time. A compromise was effected between the parties in which it
was stated that they were residing separately because of some
misunderstanding between them. No reference was made to any
cruelty inflicted upon the applicant. The applicant was employed as
an Assistant Professor, and she was in a position to maintain
herself. The applicant had failed to establish domestic violence,
2026:HHC:37388
which is necessary to grant relief. The Court cannot grant
maintenance in the absence of Domestic Violence. The learned
Trial Court had rightly dismissed the application. There was no
infirmity in the order passed by the learned Trial Court. Hence, the
appeal was dismissed.
6.
Being aggrieved by the judgment and order passed by
the learned Courts below, the applicant has filed the present
revision asserting that a prima facie case was made out by the
applicant for grant of interim maintenance. The applicant had
disclosed the acts of domestic violence in her petition, which were
ignored by the learned Courts below. The respondent is employed
as an Assistant Professor and is drawing a salary of ₹1,00,000/per month. The applicant is entitled to interim maintenance of
₹40,000/- per month. The learned Courts below erred in treating
the compromise deed/statements dated 02.11.2023 and 03.11.2023
as the waivers of the applicant’s rights. The applicant is the legally
wedded wife of the respondent and is entitled to maintenance.
Therefore, it was prayed that the present revision be allowed and
the judgment and order passed by learned Courts below be set
aside.
7.
2026:HHC:37388
I have heard Mr Vijay Panchta, learned Legal Aid
Counsel for the petitioner, who submitted that the learned Courts
below erred in dismissing the application. The applicant had
pleaded necessary ingredients to show that the respondent had
treated her with cruelty. She was continuously taunted and
harassed in her matrimonial home, which made it difficult for her
to reside in it. These allegations are to be prima facie accepted as
correct, and learned Courts below appreciated the material as if
they were deciding the final petition. The applicant is a legally
wedded wife of the respondent and is entitled to maintenance from
the respondent. Therefore, he prayed that the present revision be
allowed and the judgment and order passed by learned Courts
below be set aside.
8.
I have given considerable thought to the submissions
made at the bar and have gone through the records carefully.
9.
It is undisputed that the applicant is employed as an
Assistant Professor in Nalanda College. The respondent is also
employed as an Assistant Professor. Therefore, the financial
condition of the applicant and the respondent are almost equal,
and it cannot be said that the applicant is unable to maintain
herself.
10.
2026:HHC:37388
It is undisputed that the parties had entered into a
compromise. Both the learned Courts below referred to the
compromise and found that the parties had agreed to separate
from each other due to misunderstanding between them. There
was no reference to the domestic violence in the compromise, and
the plea taken by the applicant that she was treated with cruelty by
the respondent was not corroborated by the contemporaneous
document. Thus, the learned Courts below had rightly held that the
applicant had prima facie failed to establish the domestic violence.
It was laid down by this Court in Anil Kumar versus Shashi Bala and
others, 2017 (2) Shim. L.C. 900 that where no specific allegations of
beating were made, no report was made to any person, no
independent person proved the beatings, the domestic violence is
not established. No relief can be granted under the Protection of
Women from Domestic Violence Act, in such a situation. It was
observed: “[14] This Court, solely with a view to ascertaining the
perversity, if any, in the impugned judgment passed by the
appellate court, carefully perused pleadings as well as the
evidence adduced on record by the respective parties, perusal
whereof certainly compels this Court to agree with the
contentions raised by learned counsel representing
petitioner that learned appellate Court below has failed to
appreciate evidence adduced on record by respective parties
in its right perspective, as a result of which, erroneous
findings have come on record. Bare perusal of the impugned
2026:HHC:37388
judgment passed by the learned appellate Court below itself
suggests that even the appellate court was not convinced of
the evidence led on record, which could make the
complainant entitled to protection as claimed by way of an
application under Section 12 of the Act. The learned appellate
Court below, in para 16 of the impugned judgment, has
categorically stated that from the record, it appears that
serious allegations had been levelled against the
complainant and no evidence had been brought for providing
maintenance and as such she was not held entitled to
protection, residence and custody order in her favour. It has
also come in the judgment passed by the learned Court below
that no violence, if any, on the part of the petitioner was
proved. While granting compensation of Rs.1,000/- per
month, in favour of the complainant, the learned appellate
Court below took into consideration the status of the
complainant, who admittedly had to live and maintain
herself and she had no independent source of income. But, if
the evidence led on record by the complainant before the
learned trial Court, to prove the contents of her application
under Section 12 of the Act, is seen and perused carefully, it
nowhere suggests that maltreatment and violence as defined
under the Act was ever meted out to the complainant. There
is no specific allegation, if any, of beatings given by the
husband or family members; rather, there is a bald
statement of the complainant (AW-1) that she was
maltreated, but no specific instance as such has been
reported with regard to violence, if any, done on her by the
respondents. The Father of the complainant (AW-3), namely
Bihari Lal, has also not stated anywhere anything specific
with regard to violence, if any, committed by the petitioner
or his family members. Apart from the above, no
independent witness, if any, from the locality was associated
to prove allegations of maltreatment and violence in terms
of provisions contained in the Act. As far as allegations with
regard to throwing the complainant from the house are
concerned, there is evidence led on record by the petitioner
that the complainant left the house on her own, after being
caught red-handed with one Jeet Ram, with whom she had
illicit relations (as stood proved in the divorce petition). All
2026:HHC:37388
the witnesses of the respondent have stated that the
complainant left the house to answer the call of nature and
never turned up thereafter.
[15] This Court, after having bestowed its thoughtful
consideration to the pleadings available on record, has no
hesitation to conclude that the appellate court below, while
granting maintenance of Rs.1,000/- to the complainant, got
swayed by emotions and completely ignored overwhelming
evidence available on record suggestive of the fact that
complainant herself had left the house. Since there was no
evidence with regard to maltreatment or violence, the
learned appellate Court below ought not to have granted any
amount on account of maintenance. Moreover, as has been
noticed above, the marriage between the parties has been
dissolved vide judgment dated 3.3.2011, which has been
further upheld by his Court, and as such, this Court sees no
force, much less substantial, in the complaint of the
complainant, which was rightly rejected by the learned trial
Court.”
11.
This judgment was followed in Manohar Singh V/S Dropti
Devi 2021 Law Suit (HP) 341, and it was held: “[9] Evidence led on record by the respondent-wife nowhere
proves any kind of domestic violence, and as such, courts
below have erred in granting maintenance in favour of the
respondent-wife. Since there was no evidence of
maltreatment of the respondent-wife, the courts below
ought
not
to
have
granted
any
amount
of
maintenance/compensation. If the entire scheme of the DV
Act is perused, it clearly suggests that the very object and
purpose of the provisions contained under the Act is to give
relief to the respondent-wife on account of Domestic
violence, as defined under the Act, allegedly meted out to her
by husband and other family members. Maintenance under
Domestic Violence can be granted on three counts, i.e.
physical abuse, mental abuse and economic abuse, which
otherwise have been specifically defined in the definition of
"Domestic Violence" as provided under section 3 of the Act.”
12.
2026:HHC:37388
Therefore, the wife is not entitled to any maintenance or
any other relief on failure to prove the domestic violence and
learned Courts below had rightly held that the applicant, having
failed to prove the domestic violence, was not entitled to
maintenance. There is no jurisdictional error committed by learned
Courts below requiring any interference from this Court.
13.
No other point was urged.
14.
In view of the above, the present revision petition fails,
and is dismissed. All the pending applications, if any, also stand
disposed of.
15.
A copy of the judgment be sent to the learned courts
below for information.
3rd September, 2026
(Nikita)
(Rakesh Kainthla)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review