Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
Date of Decision: 21.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010449302026
+
LPA 750/2026 & CM APPL. 64566/2026
RABI GHOSH
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Abhinav Agnihotri, Mr. Sahil
Gupta and Mr. Harshit Arun,
Advocates.
versus
NEW DELHI MUNICIPAL COUNCIL
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Saurabh Seth, Standing Counsel
with Mr. Raghav Alok, ASI NDMC;
Mr. Abhiroop Rathore, Mr. Kabir
Dev and Mr. Sukhvir Singh,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ. (ORAL)
CM APPL. 64565/2026 (Exemption)
1.
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The Application stands disposed of.
CM APPL. 64564/2026 (Delay of 119 days in filing the Appeal) & CM
APPL. 64567/2026 (Delay of 35 days in re-filing the Appeal)
1.
These Applications have been filed on behalf of the Appellant seeking
condonation of delay of 119 days in filing and 35 days in re-filing the
present Appeal, respectively.
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
2.
Having heard the learned Counsel for the Parties and perused the
averments made in the Applications, the same are allowed. The delay of 119
days in filing as well as 35 days in re-filing the present Appeal is hereby
condoned.
3.
Accordingly, the Applications stand disposed of.
LPA 750/2026 & CM APPL. 64566/2026
1.
The instant intra-court appeal challenges the order dated 11.03.2026
passed by learned Single Judge whereby, W.P.(C) 17451/2024 instituted by
the appellant against the order dated 22.12.2022 passed by Deputy Director
(Estate-I) of New Delhi Municipal Council (hereinafter referred to as
‘NDMC’) has been dismissed. By the same order CM (Main) 152/2021, a
petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, instituted by NDMC
against the order dated 01.02.2020 passed by District & Sessions Judge on
an appeal under Section 9 of Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised
Occupants) Act, 1971 (hereinafter referred to as ‘PP Act’) has been
declared to have been rendered infructuous.
2.
The subject premises, namely, shop-cum-flat No. 27, Main Market,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi – 110003 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Subject
Property’) was licensed by the NDMC vide license deed dated 11.04.1997
in favour of the appellant and one Mr. Anil Jain. The term of the license as
per the said license deed dated 11.04.1997 was from 03.02.1997 up to
02.02.2002.
3.
Thereafter, another license deed was executed by NDMC in the sole
name of the appellant on 23.01.2013, considering the request made by the
appellant for deletion of the name of Mr. Anil Jain, the earlier co-allottee
and renewal of the license in his favour. The license was, thus, renewed in
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
the sole name of the appellant vide license deed dated 23.01.2013 for a
period from 14.05.2011 up to 31.03.2015. During subsistence of the said
license dated 23.01.2013, a letter was received by the NDMC from HDB
Financial Services Limited informing therein that the appellant in his
capacity as Director of M/s. YSF Hotels & Resorts Pvt. Ltd. had mortgaged
the subject/licensed property with HDB Financial Services Limited against a
term loan. Consequently, the NDMC issued a Show Cause Notice to the
appellant on 20.10.2014 requiring from him an explanation for violation of
the terms of license deed by mortgaging the subject property with HDB
Financial Services Limited.
4.
Relying on a letter dated 13.11.2014 said to have been issued by HDB
Financial Services Limited, the appellant denied that subject property was
mortgaged. It is on record that though the appellant submitted before the
NDMC that subject property was not mortgaged relying on the letter dated
13.11.2014 issued by HDB Financial Services Limited, however, the loan
document dated 11.08.2014 which was sent by HDB Financial Services
Limited to the appellant listed the subject property as additional collateral
security for a loan. The said document contains the signature of the appellant
at three different places.
5.
In the meantime, a money decree was passed on 08.09.2016 in favour
of one M/s. Santosh Hospitality LLP against M/s. YSF Hotels & Resorts
Pvt. Ltd. and the appellant, who is the Managing Director of the said
company. In Execution Petition bearing no.155/2016 this Court vide order
dated 08.12.2016 attached various properties of the appellant, including the
subject property. On coming to know of the aforesaid developments, NDMC
again issued a Show Cause Notice to the appellant on 01.03.2017 calling
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
upon the appellant to explain the mortgage of the subject property and about
the subject property having been allowed to be attached in the execution of
money decree.
6.
In Execution Petition No.155/2016 a Memorandum of Understanding
(hereinafter referred to as ‘MoU) was executed by the appellant on
25.09.2017 wherein, the appellant stated that he is ready to part away with
the subject property and hand it over to the decree holder in discharge of the
debt which he owed to the decree holder. In the Execution Petition, the
appellant and the decree holder moved a joint application seeking
adjournment of the proceedings of the Execution Petition for a period of six
months so that the terms of MoU may be implemented. In the proceedings
of the Execution Petition, an order was passed on 26.10.2017 wherein,
submission on behalf of the appellant was recorded to the effect that he had
handed over the subject property to the decree holder and that the same was
affirmed by the decree holder.
7.
The attachment order dated 08.12.2016 was withdrawn only on
30.07.2018 for the reason that the attachment order was said to be an
impediment for renewal of the license deed, whose term had already expired
on 31.03.2015. The NDMC also received a letter from the Advocate
representing the decree holder, dated 31.05.2018 wherein it was stated that
the decree holder did not have any objection, in case the license deed in
respect of the subject property is renewed in favour of the appellant.
8.
In the background of the aforesaid facts, the NDMC initiated
proceedings against the appellant for eviction and payment of rent/damages
in respect of the subject property under Section 5/7 of the PP Act, however,
the Estate Officer, rejected the said application vide his order dated
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
12.03.2019 which was challenged by NDMC before the District & Sessions
Judge concerned in an appeal filed under Section 9 of the PP Act bearing no.
PPA No.7/2019 which, however, was dismissed by order dated 01.02.2020
by the District & Sessions Judge.
9.
The order dated 01.02.2020 passed by the Appellate Authority under
Section 9 of the PP Act became subject matter of challenge of CM(Main)
152/2021, proceedings of which were instituted by the NDMC which has
been found to have been rendered infructuous by learned Single Judge vide
impugned order dated 11.03.2026.
10.
Several other developments also took place. The decree holder moved
an application in Execution Petition No.155/2016 on 14.09.2020 whereby,
the Execution Petition was sought to be revived, proceedings of which were
closed on the basis of MoU dated 25.09.2017. The decree holder also sought
a modification of the order passed by this Court in the said execution
proceedings on 26.09.2017 wherein, it was recorded that the possession of
the subject property was handed over to the decree holder. This Court vide
its order dated 21.10.2020 allowed the said modification application and
modified the order dated 26.09.2017 by clearly recording that possession of
the subject property was never handed over to the decree holder by the
appellant and further that a cancellation deed dated 03.09.2020 was also
executed whereby, MoU dated 25.09.2017 was sought to be cancelled.
11.
The appellant had also instituted W.P.(C) 11188/2020 with a prayer
to quash the notices issued to him on 20.10.2014 and 01.03.2017 with a
further prayer to direct the NDMC to renew the license deed for the subject
property. The said writ petition was, however, disposed of by means of an
order dated 22.09.2022 whereby, the appellant was permitted to approach
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
the concerned authority/Chairman of the NDMC along with copy of the said
writ petition/representation. The NDMC was directed to dispose of the
representation of the appellant by passing a detailed and reasoned order in
accordance with law.
12.
It is pursuant to the said order passed by this Court dated 22.09.2022
in W.P.(C) 11188/2020 which was instituted by the appellant, that the order
dated 22.12.2022 was passed by NDMC rejecting the claim of the appellant
for renewal of the license deed that became subject matter of challenge in
W.P.(C) 17451/2024 before learned Single Judge which has been dismissed
by the impugned order dated 11.03.2026.
13.
Learned counsel representing the appellant has drawn our attention to
certain findings recorded by the learned Single Judge in the impugned order
wherein, it has been observed that the order dated 22.12.2022 passed by
NDMC correctly records that cancellation deed dated 03.09.2020 was
created after NDMC filed CM(Main) 152/2021 on 18.08.2020 to seek
renewal of the license deed. The impugned order also records a finding that
cancellation of MoU was, therefore, purely an afterthought and was done
fraudulently to obtain renewal of license.
14.
Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the finding
regarding cancellation of MoU having been done fraudulently to obtain
renewal of license is not correct for the reason that during the course of the
proceedings of the Execution Petition, the said MoU was entered into and if
two parties had arrived at some kind of understanding, the same cannot be
termed to be fraudulent. Learned counsel for the appellant has also drawn
our attention to the letter dated 13.11.2014 which was submitted by the
appellant vide his letter dated 14.11.2014 to the NDMC in response to the
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
Show Cause Noticed dated 20.10.2014. On the said basis it has been stated
that HDB Financial Services Limited in the said letter had clearly stated that
the subject property, namely, shop/flat no. 27, Main Market, Lodhi colony
was not mortgaged under the facility of loan extended by HDB Financial
Services Limited to the appellant and in this view, it cannot be said that any
mortgage was created in the subject property and, therefore, the findings
recorded by NDMC while passing the order dated 22.12.2022 are incorrect.
The submission further is that in any case, no action on the part of the
appellant can be said to be fraudulent, however, the learned Single Judge
while passing the impugned order dated 11.03.2026, as also the NDMC
while passing the order dated 22.12.2022 have erred in law in not
appreciating the aforesaid aspects of the matter.
15.
Learned counsel representing the NDMC has, however, vehemently,
argued that the intra-court appeal does not bear any good ground and further
that the findings recorded by the learned Single Judge in the impugned order
are based on the material available on record and hence, the same is not
liable to be interfered with in this appeal.
16.
It has further been stated on behalf of NDMC that the letter dated
13.11.2014 on which reliance has been placed by the appellant, which is said
to be written by HDB Financial Services Limited to the appellant stating
therein that subject property was not mortgaged for procuring the loan, is a
procured and fabricated document for the reason that the appellant has not
been able to place any material to deny the letter dated 11.08.2014 which
formed part of the loan agreement between the appellant and HDB Financial
Services Limited wherein, it is clearly stated that the loan was advanced on
the basis of additional collateral security furnished by the appellant that
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
comprised of the subject property i.e. shop/flat no. 27, Main Market, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi – 110003. The said document could not be disputed and
therefore, the submissions made by learned counsel for the appellant are
baseless.
17.
On behalf of NDMC it has also been argued vehemently that all along
the conduct of the appellant has been such that he initially submitted the
subject property as additional collateral security for procuring a loan from
HDB Financial Services and thereafter, even entered into a MoU in
execution proceedings agreeing that the subject property may be handed
over to the decree holder in satisfaction of the money decree passed against
the appellant. The submission is that the appellant has all along conducted
himself in a manner which defeats the terms and condition of the license
deed dated 23.01.2013 and, therefore, the order dated 22.12.2022 passed by
NDMC, refusing renewal of the license, has rightly been passed.
18.
It is also submitted that in fact, the appellant has fraudulently acted to
defeat the terms and conditions of the license and in this view, he is not
entitled for renewal of license deed dated 23.01.2013 by the NDMC and that
the learned Single Judge after considering all the aforesaid facts and
circumstances of the case has rightly upheld the order dated 22.12.2022
passed by NDMC whereby, the prayer for renewal of license in favour of the
appellant has been refused.
19.
Having considered the respective submissions made by learned
counsel for the parties and perused the records available before us we are
unable to agree with the submissions made by learned counsel for the
appellant and affirm the impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge.
20.
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
The learned Single Judge after recording the facts which have already
LPA 750/2026
been narrated herein above, has recorded a finding that the loan sanction
letter dated 11.08.2014 clearly shows that the subject property was offered
as an additional collateral security by the appellant to HDB Financial
Services. The said document also bears the signature of the appellant. Such
finding recorded by learned Single Judge is apparent from a bare perusal of
the loan sanction letter dated 11.08.2014 which could not be disputed by the
appellant by any cogent evidence.
21.
The Learned Single Judge has also referred to the MoU dated
25.09.2017 which was entered into between the appellant and the decree
holder wherein, it was recorded that the appellant would hand over the
possession of the subject property to the decree holder. Learned Single
Judge has also recorded the finding that though the appellant had several
opportunities available to him to seek modification of the attachment order
dated 08.12.2016, however, he approached this Court for modification only
in July, 2018 for the reason that NDMC refused to renew his license and
further that this Court while withdrawing the attachment order has clearly
recorded in its order dated 30.07.2018 that NDMC had raised objection for
renewal of license in view of the attachment of the subject property. The
learned Single Judge has, thus, concluded that the appellant was acting
collusively with the decree holder, only with the aim of getting the license
renewed which could then be transferred to the decree holder.
22.
The impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge has also
referred to the findings recorded in the order dated 22.12.2022 passed by
NDMC wherein, it was found that the cancellation deed dated 03.09.2020
was created only after NDMC had filed CM(Main) 152/2021, that too, only
to seek renewal of the license deed and in the light of these facts, the learned
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
Single Judge further proceeds to record a finding that cancellation of MoU
was purely an afterthought and was done fraudulently to obtain renewal of
the license.
23.
If we examine the conduct of the appellant throughout, he has been
making attempts, one after the other, to get the license renewed, whose term
had already expired on 31.03.2015 by taking certain remedial recourse, only
after firstly mortgaging the subject property as collateral security for
procuring a loan and thereafter, by entering into the MoU with the intent to
hand over the possession in favour of the decree holder. The order dated
22.12.2022 passed by NDMC is a detailed order which has considered all
the relevant aspects of the matter and has recorded the facts which are
undeniable and, accordingly, the order reaches the conclusion that the
appellant has indulged in misuse of the subject property and violation of the
terms of the license and therefore, the renewal of the license cannot be done.
24.
We do not find any material available on record which can be put to
service to refute the findings recorded by NDMC in its order dated
22.12.2022. The appellant, as already observed above, has all along been
acting in a deceitful and dishonest manner. We have already observed above
that the appellant firstly subjected the property in question to collateral
security for procuring a loan from HDB Financial Services Limited and,
thereafter, he even attempted to enter into a MoU with the decree holder in
execution of some money decree, though, the term of the license had already
expired on 31.03.2015. Later he made attempts, so as to enable him to hand
over the subject property to the decree holder in execution of the decree
although; the appellant had lost all his rights on determination of the license
on 31.03.2015.
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
25.
The NDMC is a public authority and as such it has to, in all
circumstances, act in public interest. Renewal of license in favour of the
appellant, in the circumstances and facts noted above, could not have been
in public interest for the reason that any such renewal would amount to
succumbing to deceitful means attempted by the appellant for getting the
license renewed which had already expired on 31.03.2015.
26.
For the reasons aforesaid, we do not find any good ground to interfere
with the impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge. The appeal is,
thus, dismissed with a cost of Rs.50,000/- to be paid by the appellant to the
NDMC within a month from today. In case the cost, as directed herein, is
not paid by the appellant to the NDMC, the same shall be recovered as
arrears of land revenue.
27.
Application(s), if any, stand disposed of.
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
TEJAS KARIA, J
SEPTEMBER 21, 2026/MJ
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:56:32
LPA 750/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review