Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:454
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA. No. 24 of 2025
Date of Decision: 30.05.2025
Shri. Rabi Debbarma,
Son of Shri. Takhirai Debbarma,
Aged about 35 years
R/o 2/4 Ramdurga Thakur Para
Laxmipur,
VTC: Purba Noabadi,
West Tripura District,
Tripura.
……..Petitioner
- VsState of Meghalaya
Represented by the Superintendent of Police,
East Jaintia Hills District,
Khliehriat, Meghalaya.
……..Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. R. War, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. H. Kharmih, Addl. PP with
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
2025:MLHC:454
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Heard Mr. R. War, learned counsel for the petitioner.
2.
Also heard Mr. H. Kharmih, learned Addl. PP assisted by Mr.
S.A. Sheikh, learned GA for the State respondent.
3.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the case
of the petitioner herein is that his brother, Shri. Prodip Debbarma, who is an
accused person herein was arrested along with one person namely, Shri.
Shishir Debbarma while travelling in a vehicle bearing Registration No. AS
23J-0171 from Tripura and proceeding towards Shillong on 31.07.2023.
However, at around 9:30 PM on the same day, they were intercepted by
police personnel belonging to the ANTF (Anti Narcotic Task Force) at a
place called Umtyra on the National Highway 6. Accordingly, on being so
intercepted, their vehicle was searched and about 37 suspicious packets were
recovered from inside the vehicle. Both the occupants of the said vehicle
including the brother of the petitioner were detained by the police, since the
contents of the said packets appears to be suspected contraband substance.
4.
Accordingly, the police, taking cognizance of the case, on an FIR
filed on 01.08.2023 by Shri. J. Myrom (MPS) Dy. SP HQ, East Jaintia Hills
2025:MLHC:454
District, Khliehriat, indicating the interception and seizure of the said
suspected packets, wherein the suspected contraband substance is said to be
marijuana (ganja). Thereafter, Khliehriat P.S. Case No. 55 (08) 2023 under
Section 20(b)(ii)(C)/29 NDPS Act was registered and investigation was
launched.
5.
It is also the submission of the learned counsel that, in course of
investigation, the seized substance was produced before the learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, East Jaintia Hills District, Khliehriat on 04.08.2023,
wherein out of the 37 packets containing the alleged contraband substance,
only from the packets marked as A30 and A37 were sample taken out, which
proved to be positive for marijuana. On the basis of this evidence and other
determining factors, the Investigating Officer had filed the charge sheet on
21.12.2023 with the opinion that a prima facie case has been found wellestablished against the accused person, and they are to stand trial before the
competent court of jurisdiction for the said offence under the NDPS Act,
which offence among others included that of Section 20(c) of the NDPS Act
referring to seizure of commercial quantity of contraband substance.
6.
The learned counsel further submits that at this point of time, the
evidence of the prosecution witnesses has been recorded, and out of six
witnesses, the recording of three witnesses have been completed.
2025:MLHC:454
7.
The learned counsel has however submitted that the petitioner has
a threefold contention in this regard, firstly, that records would show that the
manner in which the sample was taken from the said seized quantity of the
alleged contraband substance i.e. the 37 packets when they were produced
before the learned Magistrate being kept in a bag, only two of the said
packets were brought out for sampling, the same was not done in accordance
with law.
8.
The learned counsel has also submitted that, when the said
alleged contraband substance was seized on 31.07.2023, they were produced
in court only on 04.08.2023. The same not being produced immediately
before the said Magistrate, there is every doubt that the contents that was
produced before the learned Magistrate, may not be the same which was
seized. Be that as it may, the learned counsel also submits that, since, out of
37 packets, only 2 packets were taken out for sample, which is contrary to
the relevant provision of the NDPS Act i.e. Section 52A and the related Rules
of 2022, which mandates that, sample has to be taken from each and every
seized packets, therefore, it can be presumed that whatever has been seized,
may or may not be marijuana. However, whatever has not been taken out as
samples from the other 35 packets, cannot be assumed or presumed to be
Marijuana.
2025:MLHC:454
9.
The contention of the learned counsel on this issue is that, of the
weight of the said alleged contraband substance taken out for sample, the
same would only constitute 2.073 Kg out of the total weight of the 37 packets
said to weigh about 47.157 Kg, therefore, it cannot be said that the legally
seized quantity falls under commercial quantity as could be seen from
Section 20(c) of the NDPS Act. Accordingly, it can be said that the accused
person in question, though, not admitted, but assumed to have been caught
to be in possession of an intermediate quantity of the alleged contraband
substance. On this ground alone, the learned counsel has submitted that the
accused person is entitled to grant of bail. In this regard, the learned counsel
has cited the authority found in the case of Wali Hasan v. State of U.P in
Criminal Misc. Bail Application No. 18303/2020, wherein vide order dated
07.06.2022 at para 13, the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court has held as
follows:
“13. Considering the submissions of both the parties and
keeping in mind the twin conditions of Section 37 of N.D.P.S.
Act and perusing the evidence on the record, it is very much
established that sampling was done contrary to the Standing
Order / Instruction No.1 of 1989 dated 13.6.1989, which are
mandatory in nature, as such chances of applicant conviction is
weak on the basis of sampling of contraband done in the present
matter as well as on the basis of the ratio of the judgment in the
case of Union of India vs. Shiv Shankar Keshri (supra) larger
mandate of Article 21 of the constitution of India without
expressing any opinion on the merit of the case, I am of the view
after applying section 37 of the N.D.P.S. act that the applicant
2025:MLHC:454
is entitled to be released on bail.”
10.
Another authority cited is the case of Rajan Singh v. Directorate
of Revenue Intelligence in Criminal Miscellaneous Bail Application No.
16323/2023, wherein the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan
Bench, Jaipur vide order dated 20.04.2024 at para 7 of the same has observed
as follows:
“7. In the instant case, as per the prosecution case itself,
samples were not drawn from each pouch. The samples of
contraband heroin were drawn on 01.03.2023 during the
certification of inventory of seized goods and thus, the
arguments of counsel for the petitioner that it cannot be
ascertained beyond all manner of doubt that the recovered
contraband was of commercial quantity is worth considering. It
was imperative for the seizure officer to draw samples from
each pouch in pursuance of the Rules of 2022.”
11.
The next contention of the learned counsel is that the accused
person was incarcerated in custody for almost 2(two) years, and for the delay
in the trial, his personal liberty as guaranteed under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India, should not be trampled even, if the rigors of Section
37 of the NDPS Act is applicable to his case. As has been submitted, having
been in custody for a long period of time, the accused person in question may
be enlarged on bail.
12.
Another contention put forth by the learned counsel is that the
accused person in question has no criminal antecedent, and having to take
2025:MLHC:454
care of his wife and minor child, he may therefore be allowed to be enlarged
on bail with any conditions as deemed fit and proper to be imposed by this
Court.
13.
Per contra, Mr. H. Kharmih, learned Addl. PP has strongly
opposed the prayer made by the learned counsel for the petitioner on the
ground that records would show that, the brother of the petitioner being one
of the occupants of the said vehicle which was intercepted from which the
said 37 packets of contraband goods i.e. marijuana have been seized, is very
much aware of the presence of such contraband substance in the vehicle. This
was clearly indicated in his statement before the authorities taken under
Section 67 of the NDPS Act. Accordingly, being in conscious possession of
the said contraband substance, he may not be enlarged on bail on this count.
As far as the delay in the trial is concerned, the learned Addl. PP has
submitted that the charge sheet being filed on 21.12.2023, and charges
framed on 09.04.2024, and as has been submitted by the learned counsel for
the petitioner that three of the six witnesses have already been examined and
discharged, therefore, there is no question of delay in the trial and this Court
may allow the trial to proceed in its normal course.
14.
As to the antecedent of the accused person in question, the
learned Addl. PP has submitted that the Investigating Officer, during
2025:MLHC:454
investigation, has also obtained crucial information as regard the vehicle they
were travelling in, inasmuch as, it has been found out that the accused person
and the other occupant were using a vehicle with a fake registration number
when, actually, on investigation, it was found that the said vehicle is actually
a vehicle registered in the State of Bihar with Registration No. BR01BS 2941
belonging to one Shri. Vikash Kumar, who has since sold the vehicle to one
Shri. Uttam Kumar. Therefore, under such circumstances, the antecedent of
the accused person in question is doubtful. As such, it is the prayer of the
learned Addl. PP that the prayer made in this petition may not be allowed.
15.
This Court has given careful consideration to the submission
made by the learned counsel for the parties. On the contention of the learned
counsel for the petitioner as regard the defective process carried out in course
of taking samples of the seized contraband substance, which initially were
said to weigh about 47.157 Kg, samples of which were taken from only 2
packets, the said 2 packets weighing about 2.073 Kg, therefore, on this
ground alone, the prosecution may not be able to sustain its case at the trial,
and accordingly, the accused person is entitled to be granted bail.
16.
This Court would say that the case is still under trial with three
witnesses yet to be examined, therefore, at this point of time, it may not be
safe to come to any conclusion as to the strength or weakness of the
2025:MLHC:454
prosecution case, vis-à-vis, the strength or weakness of the case of the
defence including the accused person in question. That is a matter to be left
to the Trial Court, who would consider the body of evidence at the
conclusion of the trial. It is also to be reminded that, even, if the rigors of
Section 37 of the Act is not to be taken into account in this particular case,
yet bail is still within the discretionary realm of the court.
17.
Therefore, this Court is of the considered opinion that, though,
the authorities cited by the petitioner are relevant to the subject matter,
however, the same cannot be made the basis for grant of bail.
18.
As to the contention that the accused person in question has been
incarcerated in custody for a prolonged period of time, if the period of 2 years
or so is taken into account, the same may be true, however, taking into
consideration the fact that the trial has proceeded in its normal course, no
delay could be attributed to the Trial Court. As such, on this ground too, this
Court is not inclined to allow the prayer of the petitioner.
19.
As regard the issue of antecedent of the accused person in
question, it may be true that he has no criminal record so far, but that in itself,
would not qualify him to be enlarged on bail. Even, if this Court has chosen
to ignore the submission of the learned Addl. PP as regard the complicity of
the accused person in question pertaining to the used of a vehicle with fake
2025:MLHC:454
registration number which would be a matter for the prosecution to pursue
independently, the fact that the accused person is involved in a case relating
to contraband substance, be it marijuana, heroin or other dangerous
substance, the offence would qualify as a serious one, the gravity of which
has to be taken note of by this Court. Also not being a resident of this State
as apparently from the records, it is presumed that he is a resident of the State
of Tripura, therefore, the fact that he may be a flight risk, cannot be ruled
out.
20.
In view of the above noted observations, this Court is not inclined
to allow the prayer made in this petition at this point of time. The same is
accordingly rejected.
21.
Before parting, the Trial Court is requested to ensure that the trial
is completed as expeditiously as possible.
Judge
DARIKORDOR NARY
Date: 2025.05.30 19:32:57 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review