Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
o[ 3488 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRt APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRIJUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
ITP
OF
Between:
No 4-2-122'
R. Srinivas. S/o. R. Manohar, Aged: 44 yeqs, Occ: Business' R/o' H
Ranisatiji Colony, Adilabad Town, Adilabad Distrrct'
...PETITIONER
AND
for Women'
'1.
' State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary' .Department
Cilii^;;, Di"l6-led dnd Senibr Citizens, Secretariat, Hyderabad'
2.TheAppellateTribunal,TelanganaState]vlaintenanceandWelfareofParents
Adilabad District.
and Senior Citizens, ned. OV ifr" Oi.lrict Coilector, Adilabad
Retire^d'fl/o' H' No 43. R. Manohar, S/o. LateGovindu,Aged 80years, Occ
z-rii, nl.iiaiUicoronv. Aoitaoao iown, Adilabad District - 504001'
"
...RESPONDENTS
in the
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that
court may be
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High
pleasedtoissueanappropriatewrit,orderordirection,moreparticularlyoneinthe
natureofWritofMandamusandDeclaration,andDeclarethesub-rule3ofRule
2loftheTelanganaMaintenanceandWelfareofParentsandSeniorCitizens
i'e'' Maintenance &
Rules, 2011 as Unconstitutional, u/fra vlres to Parent Statute'
WelfareofParentsandSeniorCitizensAct,200Tbeingexcessivedelegation,and
against the
Consequently, set-aside the proceedings bearing C1139412023
Petitioner herein on the file of Respondent No' 2'
lA NO: 1 OF 2t)25
petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
court may be pleased to stay
the affidavit fik-"d in support of the petition, the High
on the file of the Respondent
all further proceedings bearing File No. c1t3g4l2}23
No. 2, pending disposal of the Writ Petition'
lA NO: 2 OF 2'025
stated in
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
be pleased to
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
petition by substituting the words
amend the merin prayer of the affidavit and writ
the
"Consequently, set-aside the proceedings bearing C1t39412023 against
"Consequently' setPetitioner here:in on the file of Respondent No' 2" with words
No' 2 in Procs' No'
aside the Ordt:r dated 15-12-2025 passed by the Respondent
c1139412023-1"
lA NO: 3 OF 2025
stated in
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
pleased to
the affidavit filed in support of the petition' the High Court may be
No' 2 in Procs'
suspend the Order dated 15-12-2025 passed by the Respondent
petition'
No. C1 t3g4l2ct23-1, pending disposal of the present writ
lA NO: 4 OF 2025
stated in
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
be pleased to direct
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
proceedings record of
the Respondent No. 2 to produce the entire record including
pending disposal of the
each date of adjournment in procs. No. C1l394t2023-1,
present Writ Petition.
lA NO: 1 OF 2026
Between:
R. Manohar, s,/o. Late Govindu, Aged: 80 y99r9, occ: Retired,
i#i;;i1i ;oto,',y, Adilabad rown, Adilaoao District - 504001'
R/o' H' No' 4-2-122'
...PETITIONER/RESPONDENT No'3
AND
:'l'r;..:.,:']1iE.if."'rym].:5ij*i,.;.=rJ
1. R. Srinivas, S/o. R. Manohar, Aged:'44 years, Occ: Business, Rl/o. H. No. 4-2122, Ranisatiji Colony, Adilabad Town, Adilabad District.
...RESPONDENT/WRIT PETIT!ONER
2. State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Department for Women,
Children, Disabled and Senior Citizens, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
3. The Appellate Tribunal, Telangana State Maintenance and Welfare of Parents
and Siirior Citizens, Rep. by t6e District Collector, Adilabad Adilabad District.
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENT Nos.1 & 2
Petition under Section 't51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the interim order dated 05-01-2026 in WP No.32591 ot 2025 and dismiss
the said writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI BAGLEKAR AKASH KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondents No.1 & 2: SMT. K. MANI DEEPIKA,
GP FOR WOMEN DEVELOPMENT & CHILD WELFARE
Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI A. PRANEETH, REPRESENTING
SRI P. LAKSHMA REDDY
The Court made the following:
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELIINGANA
AT IIYDERABAI)
THE HON'rBLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH Kt MAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION
o.32S9L of 2o25
DATE: 16 .02.2o126
BETtrIEEN:
R.Srinivas
....Petitioner
A.ND
State of Telangana and 2 others
....Respondent
ORDER
firer Sri Justice G.M.Mohiuddin)
Heard S.ri Baglekar Akash Kumar, learned counsel for the
petitioner; Smt.K.Mani Deepika, learned Government Pleader for
Women and l)evelopment appearing for respondent Nos.l and 2 and
Sri A.Praneeth, learned counsel representing Sri P.Lakshma Reddy,
learned coun:;el for respondent No.3 and perused the record.
2.
This Wr:it Petition is filed, under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, with the following prayer:
"....to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, more particularly one
in the nalure of Writ of Mandamus and Declaration, and Declare the subrule 3 of Rule 21 of tlrc Telangana Maintenance and Welfare of Parents
and Seni'tr Citizens Rules, 2O1I as Unanstitutional, ultra vires to Parent
Statute, i.e., Ilaintenance & Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act,
2007 being excessiue delegation, qnd Consequentlg, set-aside the
proceedir',gs bearing C1/394/2O23 against the Petitioner herein on the
file of Re.;pondent No.2, and pass such other order as fhfs Hon'ble Court
mag deen fit in the best interest of iustice"
.
Factual Matrix (in brieQ
3.
The petitioner is the third son of respondent No.3, a senior
citizen aged about 80 years, who is the absolute owner of residential
prennises bearing H.No.4-2-122, situated .at Ranisatiji
colony,
Adilabad. The genesis of the dispute traces to the year 2023,
respondent No.3 lodged a complaint before the Revenue
when
Divisional
oflicer (RDo), Adilabad, alreging that the petitioner had
unauthorisedly occupied portions of the said house, failed to provide
maintenance, broke open the lock of a shop belonging to the
wife of
respondent No.3 and locked the common latrine, thereby causing
hardship to the aged parents.
4'
The complaint was forwarded to the District Collector, Adilabad,
who, upon issuance of notice and conducting an enquiry, passed
order, dated 27.o2.2o24 in R.c.No.cL/3g4/2o23 (Ex.p6) dismissing
the request for eviction, taking note of thc deposition of the
petitioner's mother that the petitioner and his wife were taking proper
care of them, while advising the children to treat respondent No.3
with dignity.
5.
An appeal preferred by respondent No.3 in Appeal
No.s L /55512024 before the Director/commissioner came
to be
dismissed by order dated L3.o1.2o2a (Ex.pz), affirming the order
of
the District collector and observing that property disputes, if any,
may be resolved in accordance with law.
p
we..mlrwry;w
','ffi;1.F.:.;Ej
":i
:3
,
6.
Subsequently, on 15.o8.2o24,.respondent No.3 lodged FIR in
Crime No.333 of 2024 at Adilabad-t Police Station against the
petitioner and his wife for the offences under Sections 296(bl' 115(2),
351(2) read with 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, alleging
physical assault and abuse on 12.08.2024 (Ex.P8)' Thereafter,
respondent \o.3 once again approached the District Collector seeking
eviction, pursuant to which notice dated 28.09'2024 was issued in
the very sanle file Cll394l2023.
7.
The petitioner questioned the said notice before this court in
w.P.No.2 8567 of 2024 on the ground that the District collector
become fun<:ttts officio and that the principle of res
had
judicata applied'
However, by order dated 13.10.2025, the writ petition was dismissed
by the learned Single Judge, and the petitioner was directed to
participate in the proceedings. A writ appeal in W.A.No.ll73 of 2025
preferred against the said order of learned Single Judge in
w.P.No.28567 of 2024 was also dismissed by the Division Bench on
24.tO.2025.
g.
During the continuation of proceedings before the District
Collector, ce:rtain terms were orally agreed upon between the parties
during the hearing on 22.11.2025, including grant of time to the
petitioner till February, 2026 to secure alternative rented
accommoda::ion, the rent of which was to be borne by respondent
n-y'
No.3 herein and the petitioner would vacate thereupon; and a 'Mutual
.i4z'.
Agreement-cum-Undertaking Deed' subsequently submitted bore only
the signature of respondent No.3 and contained terms at variance
with the oral understanding reached before the District Collector.
9.
Consequently, by order ciated L5.12.2025 in Proceedings
No.Cll394l2023-1, the District Collector rejected the said deed and
directed adherence to the mutually agreed terms. Accordingly, thc
present writ petition was instituted challenging the validity of
sub-rule (3) of Rule 21 of the 2OIL Rules.
Contentions of the petitioner
10. Learned counsel for the petitioner in support of the challenge to
the impugned Rule has raised the follclwing contentions:
i. That the sub-rule (3) of Rule 2I of the 2O11 Rules inserted bv
G.O.Ms.No.4O dated 30. L2.2O22 confers power of eviction upon
the District Collector/District Magistrate, an executive authority
not possessing judicial qualifications, thereby amounting to an
impermissible conferment of judicial power in rriolation of
constitutional principles enunciated by the Honble Supreme
Court in Union oJ India u. R.Gandhi, Presid.ent, Madras Bar
Associationr and Madras Bar Associqtion u. Unlon of India
and another2.
'lzoro;rl scc I
2 (2OL4ltO SCC I
/
,'
ii. That arljudication of eviction disputes, being essentially judicial
in character, which are to be adjudicated by civil Courts, cannot
be entrusted to a sole non-judicial member lacking safeguards of
independence.
iii. That ttre impugned Rule is ultra uires the parent enactment,
namely. Maintenance & Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens
Act,2Or)7 (for short,'2OO7 ActJ. It was argued that Section 32
thereof does not expressly authorize framing of rules providing
for evicr-ion, and that the Act primarily deals with maintenance
and declaration of voidness of transfers under Section 23 of 2OOT
Act.
iv. That placing reliance on Kerq.la SDB v. Thomqs Josephs, it
was contended that the delegated legislation cannot travel
beyond :he scope of the enabling parent statute and that if rule
was beyr>nd the rule-making power conferred by the statute, it is
liable to declare invalid. That the petitioner had earlier
succeedr:d before the District Collector by order dated
27.02.2424 and that subsequent proceedings were barred by
principles of res judicata.
v. That the order dated 15.L2.2O25 was passed in undue haste
despite 'rendency of proceedings before this court and the
fundame etal rights cannot be waived and that dismissal of the
3 (2023l'
l1 SCC 7Cr0
earlier writ petition, would not
preclude a fresh constitutional
challenge
vl That where a provision
is ex
facieunconstitutionar, the court is
empowered to grant protective
interim orders, particurarry
eviction would render the petitioner
homeless.
The learned counser for the pefitioner
11.
contentions has placecr reliance
as
in support of his
on the fo,owing decisions:
i' whirrpoor cotporation a- Registrar
of Trad.e Marksa
ii' straw products Limited, a- rncome
'
:
i
I
I
Tax ofJicer ,A'
Ward Bhopal and. others_s
I
I
I
I
I
iii. Nonda Kishore a. State of htnjaba
iv' Dr. Jaishri Laxmanr,o patil
a. state of Maharastra
and q.notherz
I
II
r
i
I
I
Contentions of the respondents
T
I
L
12.
Learned Government pleader
learneci counser for respondent
;
for respondent Nos.l and 2
T
t
and
+
{
Nc.3 have raised the forowing
i{I
.l
contentions:
:t
:l
i' That the challenge to the impugned
the rule-making power under
Rule is wholly misconceived;
provisions for the protection
life and propert5r of senior citizens.
4 AIR 1999
s AIR 1968
6 (199s)6
7 (2021)
sc 22
sc 579
SCC 614
2 SCC 785
/'
,/
]lrl
't
..'
Section 32 of the Senior citizens
Act is wide enough to encompass
specificalry mandates the
ri
ll
:t
'-i
;
of
section 22 of the Act
state Government to prescribe
;i
a
i
;t
:,! '
iif '
$,
T
c
a!
fi
$t
*t
*t
ilt
-!l
It
it
it
#l
iI:t
iI
rl
;il
4i
comprehensive action plan for providing protection of life and
property of senior citizens. The Impugned Rule, which enables
eviction of children who fail to maintain senior citizens or who
occup)' their property without authority, is a necessary corollary
of this protective mandate; that Sections 22 and 32 of the 2OO7
Act confer wide rule-making power upon the State to frame
measu:es for protection of life and property of senior citizens;
and th,at the power of eviction is implicit and necessary to
effectuate such protection.
ii. That ttre District Magistrate, while exercising powers under the
Rules, acts as a statutory authority discharging quasi-judicial
functions under a welfare legislation, and that the principles laid
down in the Mqdras Bar Association (supra 1 and 2) line of
cases, pertaining to constitution of Tribunals replacing High
Court jurisdiction, are inapplicable to summary proceedings
under the Act.
iii. That the ',r,rit petition is an abuse of process, filed after two
unsuccr:ssful rounds of litigation before this Court, solely to
delay eviction and frustrate the proceedings instituted by the
senior c..tizen.
iv. That th<: conduct of the petitioner, including the registration of
FIR datr:d 15.08.2024 in Crime No.333 of 2024 alleging assault
and abuse, justified invocation of the protective provisions.
a"\
/',
::8::
v. That the impugned Rule does not travel beyond the parent Act,
and that without the power to evict a recalcitrant or abusive
child, the object of ensuring dignity and security to senior
citizens would be rendered nugatory.
vi. That the proceedings before the District Collector were conducted
in compliance with principles of natural justice, and that the
order dated 15.12.2025 was passed after affording adequate
opportunity and even exploring an amicable settlement between
the parties.
13. The learned counsel for respondent No.3 supported the
submissions of the learned Government Pleader and additionally
contended that the present writ petition is an instance of abuse of due
process. The learned counsel for respondent No.3 in support of his
contentions has placed reliance on the following decisions:
i.
Ko,mo,lako,nt Mishra a. Additional Collector and
othersa
ii. Urmila Dixit o. Sunil Sharan Dixit and otherse
L4. Upon consideration of the pleadings, and the material placed on
record, and the rival submissions, the following points are arise for
determination:
i)
whether sub-rule (3) of Rule 21 of the Telangana Maintenance
and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2}lt is
a Civil Appeal (Diary No.42786 of 20251 dated 12.O9.2O2i
e (202512
scc
unconstitutional on the grouSrd that it confers judicial power
upon a non-judicial authoritY?
ii) Whether the said Rule is ultra uires the Maintenance and
Welfe.re of Parents and Senior Citizens Act,2OO7? and
iii) Whether, in the facts of the present case, the writ petition
amournts to an abuse of process of law?
Consideration bY this Court
I.
of
the
15. The rnain controversy of the petitioner's challenge rests upon
the decisic,ns of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Madras Bar
Associatiott's case (supra 1 and 2) which would disclose that they
dealt with the constitutional validity of permanent Tribunals such as
the NCLT/ I.ICLAT, which were constituted to replace the jurisdiction
of High Cotrrts in Company Law matters. The parameters laid down
therein wer,l in the context of bodies exercising powers akin to those
of constitutional Courts and that where a Tribunal is vested n'ith
jurisdiction of a High Court, its members must possess and
qualifications and independence commensurate with that of High
Court judges.
16. The p::esent case stands on an entirely different footing, wherein
the District Magistrate, while exercising power under Rule 21(3), does
not function as a substitute for the High Court or as a permanent
Tribunal vested with plenary judicial powers. The authority acts
under a wellare legislation for a limited statutory purpose, namely, to
--'-'-'-"-;.tr;i;.:=..E.Es.:;-ffimm.:]sBs&r@}hdFlk.-T-.
:: l0::
ensure protection of the life and property of senior citizens. The
proceedings are summary in character and intended to provide
expeditious relief to a vulnerable class, namely, the senior citizens,
who may otherwise be compelled to undergo protracted civil litigation.
L7. Section 22 of tilre 2OO7 Act is extracted hereunder:
22. Authortties who maA be specified for implementing the
prouisions of this Act
1. The State Gouernment mag, confer such powers and impose
such duties on a District Magi"strate as maA be neessary, to
ensure that the prouistons of this Act are properlg carried out and
thie Dist,zct Magbtrate mag spectfg th.e offtcer, subordinate to him,
wha shalt exercise all or ang of the pouers, and perform all or ang
of the duties, so conferred or imposed and the local limits within
which such powers or duties shall be carried out by the offi.cer as
mag be prescribed.
2. The state Gouernment shall prescribe a comprehensiue action
planfor prouiding protection of life and propertg of senior citiz,ens.
18. It is to be noted that Section 22 of the 2ooz Act specifically
empowers the State Government to confer such powers upon the
District Magistrate to ensure that the provisions clf the Act are
properly carried out. Section 22(2) of the Act mandates prescription
of a comprehensive action plan for protection of life and property. The
Rule in question is traceable to this statutory mandate. The District
Magistrate exercises quasi-judicial powers subject to notice,
opportunity of hearing, recording of reasons, and availabilit5r of an
appellate remedy. such conferment of limited adjudicatory power
upon executive authorities under social welfare legislation is neither
novel nor constitutionally impermissible.
::ll::
19. Sub-rule (3) was inserted after sub-rule {21 of Rule 21 byway of
-
an amendrnent contained in G.O.Ms.No.4O dated 30.L2.2O22 to the
Telangana Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens
Rules, 2Oll, prescribing the procedure for eviction from property of
senior citizt:ns/ parents. It reads:
*(g) Pt'ocedure .for euiction from propeftg of
Senior
Citizen/Parents:
(a) (i) A senior citizen/ parent, mag make an application before the
Collector & District Magistrate of hb/ her district, for euiction of
his/htzr children/legal heir from hb/her propertg on account of
his/ her non-maintenance and/ or ill-treatment.
(ii)The Collector & District Magistrate shall immediately foru.tard such
applicttion to the concemed Sub-Diuisional Magistrate/ Reuenue
Diuisi<tnal Officer for uerification of the title of the property and facts
of the case tuithin ftfteen (15) dags from the date of receipt of such
applic,ztion.
(iii) Tte Sub-Diuisional Magistrate/ Reuenue Diuision Olficer shall
tmmec'.iately submit his/her report to the Collector & District
Magisrrate for final orders within sirta 60) days from the date of
receipt of the application.
(iu) The collector & Dtstnct Magistrate during summary proceedings
for thct protection of senior citizens/ parents shall consider all the
releuant prouisions of the Act. If the Collector & District Magistrate is
of tLte opinton that any children/ legal heir of a senior citizen/ parent
is not maintaining the senior citizen/ parent and/ or ill-treating
him/ her/ them and Aet is ocanpying the propertg of the senior
citizen,/ parent and that theg should be euicted, the Collector &
Distric;'. Magistrate shall issue in the manner hereinafter prouided a
notice tn writing calling upon all persorls concerned to show cause as
to uhA an order of euiction should not be issued against
them/lim/hen
(u)The notice shall;-
.i
.i
::12::
(i) spectfu the grounds on uhich the order of euiction i.s proposed to be
made; and
(ii) reqtire all persons concemed, thnt is to say, all persons taho are,
or maV be, in ocatpation of, or claim interest in, the property, to shout
cause, if ang, against the proposed order on or before such date as is
specifted in th-e notice, being a date not earlier than then (10) dags
from the date of bsue thereof.
(b) Eviction ord.er from propettg of senior citizetdparent:
If, after considering the cause, if ang, shown by ang person in
pursuance to the notice and any euidence he/she mag produce in
support of the same and after giuing him/her a reasonable
opportunitg of being heard, the Collector & District Magistrate is
satisfied thnt the euiction order needs to be made, the Collector &
Dbtrict Magi.strate mag make an order of euictton, for reasons to be
recorded therein, directing that the propertg shall be uacated.
(c) Enforcement of orders:-
(i) If ang person refused or fatls to complg utith the order of euiction
within thirtg (30) dags from the date of ifs issue, the Collector &
District Magistrate or anA other olficer dulg authorized bg the
Collector & Dbt'ict Magistrate tn this behalf mag euict that person
from the premises in question and take possession'
(ti) The Collector & District Magistrate shall haue powers to enforce
the euiction orders through police and the District Superintendent of
Police or Commissioner of Police, in case of duties, concerned shall be
bound to carry out exeantion of the euiction order;
(iii) The Collector & Di.strict Magistrate uill further hand ouer the
propertg in question to the concemed senior citizen/ parent; and
(iu) The Collector & Dbtrict Magistrate shalt foruard monthlg report of
such ca.ses to the Director, Department for Empowerment of Persons
with Disabilities, Senior Cttizens and Transgender Persons bg 7tn of
the foltouing month.
(d) Appealt
(i) Ang appeal agatnst the order of the Collector & District Magistrate
shall lle before the Commissioner/ Director, Department for
Empowerrnent of Persons uith Disabilities, Senior Citizens and
-2
r,
-'".:*4
,,:
f7qn5:gender Persons, Telongana within thirtg (3O) days of the issue
of the orders bg the Collector & District Magistrate.
(ii) Prouisions regarding dbposal of appeal"s before Appellate Tribunal
shall apptA mutatis mutand.is to the appeals before the
Comnrissio ner/ Direct:or, Department for Dmpowerment of Persons
with Disabilities, Sentor Citiz,ens and Transgender Persons,
Telanqana."
2o.. It is evident that the said amendment was introduced after the
decision in the case of S. Vanitha u. Commissioner, Bengalunt
Urban District and othersro wherein it was held that the Tribunals
under the ,\ct may order eviction if it is necessary and expedient to
ensure the protection of the senior citizen. The exercise of such power
is contemp,lated keeping in mind the beneficial intention of the
statute. Section 23 of the Act, which is relevant, is referred to herein:
"23. Trotnsfer of propertg to be aoid. in certain circumsto,ncesl (1)
Where a,zy senior citizen who, after the commencement of this Act, has
transferred bA wag of gift or otherwise, his propertg, subiect to the
condition that the transferee shall prouide the basic amenities and basic
physical needs to the transferor and such transferee refuses or fails to
prouide such amenities and phgsical needs, the said transfer of
property shall be deemed to haue been made bg fraud or coercion or
under undue influence and shall at the option of the transferor be
declared uoid bg the TibunaL
(2) Where ang senior citizen hc.s a. right to receiue maintenance out of an
estate ar.d such estate or part thereof is transferred, the right to receiue
maintencnce maA be enforced against the transferee if the transferee
has notice of the right, or if the transfer is gratuitous; but not against the
transferee for consideration and wtthout notice of right.
to
lzozl) 15 soc 730
:,
:;i:,
,i. . /: -f .f.: fd3!:":
,
:
:,i'-
:
I4
(3) If, anA senior citizen is incapable of enforcing the rtghts under sub-
secfions (1) and (2) action mag be talcen on hb behalf bg ang o! the
organization referred to in Dxplanation to sub-section (1) of section 5."
21. The background facts upto lodging of the complaint by
respondent No.3-father indicates invocation of the above provision
alleging disobedience of the order passed in proceedings No.
Cll394/2O23 dated 27.2.2024 by the petitioner for his eviction.
Allegations of abuse, beating and threatening with dire consequences
by the petitioner and his wife were made in an FIR lodged by
respondent No. 3 against the petitioner and his r,vife.
22. [t is to be noted that the foundation of the petitioner's argument
rests upon the premise that every action taken under the 2007 Act,
including an order of eviction, is inherently judicial in character and
therefore, must necessarily be decided only by a regular Civil Court.
This premise, in our considered view, is fundamentally misconceivcd
and proceeds on an incorrect understanding of the statutory
framework.
23. Further, the power to direct eviction from the property of a
senior citizen, as provided under Rule 21(3) of the 2O11 Rules, is not
a power to adjudicate intricate questions of title or to determine
competing proprietary rights in the manner of a civil Court. It is a
protective and preventive power, exercised in a summary manner, to
secure possession and enjoyment of properff by a senior citizen, who
is pima fag/tne lawful owner and who complains of harassment,
:: l5::
4,
L
intimidation, or unlawful occupation. The authority under
t
l
does not sit in judgment over complex civil disputes;
the Rule
rather, it
intervenr:s to restore peace and ensure that the object
of the welfare
legislation is not defeated by familial discord or coercive
occupation.
24. It is well settled that not every conferment of decision_making
authority upon an executive officer amounts to unconstitutional
delegation of judicial power. The distinction between
a Tribunal
replacing the jurisdiction of a High court and a statutory
performing quasi-judicial functions under a beneficial
authority
enactment is
clear ancl well recognized. Thus, this court cannot accept
contention that Rule 21(3) suffers from constitutional infirmity
the
or that
the said Rule does not have the backing of the parent legislation.
25. Further, the Hon'ble Supreme court in tlrmila Dfxtt,s case
(supra 9) has held as under:
24. Be,fore parting with the case at hand, we must clarifg
the
obseruc'-tions made uide the impugned. ord.er
[sunil sharan Dixit u. r]rmila
Dixit, 2')22 SCC onLine Mp 37761 qua the competencg
of the Tribunar to
hand ouer possession of the propertA. /n S. Vanitha
[5. Vanitha u.
commr.. (202r) 15 scc 73oJ , this court obserued. that
rribunars und.er
the Act mag order euiction if it is necessary and
expedient to ensure the
protectic'n of the senior citizen. Therefore, it
cannot be said. that the
Tribunals corstituted under the Act, while exercising jurisdiction
und.er
section .23, cannot order possession to be transferred.
This wourd. defeat
the purpose and object of the Act, which is to prouid.e
speedy, simpre and.
inexpens,iue remedies for the eld_ertg.
rn Kqrnq.lako,nt Mishra's case (supra g), the Apex court has
held that:
:: l6::
7. TtLe framework of the Act clearlg notes that the lutt was enacted to
add.ress tlrc ptight of older personi, 7or their care and protection. Being a
welfare legislation, its prouisions mzsf be qnstrued ltberally so as fo
ad.uance its beneficent purpose. This CourT on seueral occasions has
obserued that the Tribunal is well within its powers to order euiction of a
child or a relatiue from the propertg of a senior citizen, u.then tlere is a
breach of tlrr- obligation to maintain th.e senior citizen.2 In the pre:sent
case, despite being financiallg stable, the respondent has acted in breach
of his statutory obligations in not allowing the appellant to reside in the
properTies owned bg him, therebE frustrating the uery object of the Act.
High Court fell in error in allowing the urit petition on a completely
untenable grcund.
26. In the present case, the eviction contemplated under the
statutory scheme is an incident of the broader power to protect life
and property under Section 22(21 of the 2OO7 Act. [t is essentially
remedial and protective in nature, aimed at safeguarding the person
and property of the senior citiz,en from neglect, abuse, or unlawful
interference. The characterization of such power as equivalent to the
adjudicatory jurisdiction of a civil Court is, therefore, misplaced. The
authority acts within a confined statutory sphere, guided by
principles of natural justice and subject to appellate oversight, and
the nature of the power exercised is protective rather than judicial in
the traditional sense.
II. Whether the Rule is Uttra Vires the Parent Act
27, It is pertinent to note that th.e 2OO7 Act, is not confined merely
to recovery of maintenance under Sections 4 and 5. Chapter V of the
Act expressly deals with 'Protection of Life and Property of Senior
r'"
.l
\
!,
'''ryiI
:zl7::
4'
citizen'. siection 22(21 obligates the state Government to prescribe a
comprehensive action plan for providing such protection. Section 32
empowers the State Government to frame rules to carry out the
purposes of the Act, including matters contemplated under
Section 22 of 2OO7 Act.
28. The cetitioner has not questioned the uires of the Section 7 of
the Act wh..ch relates to the constitution of the Maintenance Tribunal.
Sub-section (2) provides that such Tribunal shall be presided over by
an oflicer not below the rank of Sub Divisional Oflicer of a State. The
impugned rule conlers such power on an officer of the level of District
Magistrate that is above the Sub Divisional Magistrate. As noted
above, the ,mpugned rule was inserted after the decision in the case
of s. vanittha (supra 10) . The impugned rule provides for an enquiry
by the concerned Sub Divisional Magistrate/Revenue Divisional
officer for verilication of the title of the property. The proceedings are
summary in nature for protection of senior citizenlparent. If the
collector and District Magistrate is of the opinion that a child/legal
heir of a senior citizenlparent is not maintaining the senior
citizenlparent and/or ill-treating him/her/them and yet is occupying
the property of the senior citizenlparent and that should be evicted, it
is only therr:upon a notice in writing is to be issued calling upon all
persons concerned to show cause as to why an order of eviction
should not tre issued against them specifying the grounds on which
the order of eviction is proposed to be made and required all persons
(- a
\
::18::
concerned, who are or may be in occupation of, or claim interest in,
the property to show cause if any, against the proposed order by
specified date. It is only after consideration of the cause shown by the
persons pursuant to the notice and any evidence that he or she may
produce in support of the same and after giving him/her a reasonable
opportunity, the Collector and District Magistrate, if satislied that the
eviction order needs to be made, make an order of eviction for reasons
to be recorded therein directing that the property shall be vacated.
The impugned rule also provides for enforcement of the order if the
persons refuses or fails to comply with the order of eviction within 30
days. Sub-clause (d) of the impugned rule 3 provides for an appeal to
the Commissioner/Director of the Department within 30 days of the
issue of the orders of the District Collector and Magistrate.
29. As noted above, the power of the Tribunal to order eviction is
necessary and expedient to ensure protection of senior citizen as
recognized in the case of S. Vanitha (supra 10) and has been further
reiterated in the cases of Unnila Dixit (supra 9) and Kamalakant
Mishra (supra 8). The legal basis is no longer res integra.
30. Further, the protection of property is not an abstract concept. If
a senior citizen is deprived of peaceful possession of his property by
an abusive or non-maintaining child, the ability to secure restoration
of possession is an integral component of protection. The power of
eviction is thus not an extraneous addition but a necessary incident
:: 19::
of the stattttory objective. The contention that delegated legislation
cannot travt:l beyond the Act, as reiterated in Kera,la SEB a. Thomas
Josephll, has no application in the facts and circumstances in the
present case. In the present case, the Rule operates within the four
corners of tiections 22 and 32 of 2OO7 Act. [t merely provides the
procedural rnechanism to effectuate the statutory mandate. It does
not create a nervv substantive right alien to the Act.
31. It is also significant that the petitioner has not challenged the
Constitutional vatidity of the enabling provisions of the Act,
particularly Sections 22 or 32 of 2O07 Act. A rule framed within the
scope of a valid parent statute cannot ordinarily be struck down
unless it is shown to be manifestly arbitrary or violative of
Constitutional provisions. No such case has been made out.
Accordingly, we hold that sub-rule (3) of Rule 21 of the 2OLl Rules is
intra uires the 20O7 Act.
III. Conduct of the oetitioner and Abuse of Process
32. On perusal of the record, it discloses that respondent No.3 is an
80 year olcl father seeking peaceful enjoyment of his property.
Proceedings were initiated before the District Collector; an earlier
round culrninated in an order dated 27.O2.2O24. Subsequent
complaints, ncluding registration of FIR in Crime No.333 of 2024,led
to revival o:: proceedings. The petitioner challenged the notice in
" 1zozs1r r scc 7oo
::20::
W.P.No.28567 of 2024, which was dismissed. The writ appeal there
against was also dismissed. The petitioner instead of complying with
the directions of this Court and participating in the proceedings in
their true spirit, has chosen to mount a constitutional challenge to
the Rule itself at a belated stage, after suffering adverse orders.
Further, multiple interlocutory applications have been filed seeking
stay, amendment, and suspension of orders, thereby prolonging the
Iis.
33. It is trite that the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution is discretionary and equitable. A litigant invoking such
jurisdiction must approach the Court with candour and bona fides.
When a challenge to uires is raised not as a genuine constitutional
grievance but as a tactic to delay implementation of lawful orders, the
Court is entitled to take note of such conduct. Therefore, by
considering the available material on record, we are of the considered
opinion that the present writ petition is not a bona fide constitutional
challenge but a collateral attempt to frustrate the statutory remedy
invoked by an aged parent.
g4. The present case is a sad reflection on the erosion of family
values and respect for parents. The Maintenance of Welfare of
Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2OO7 was enacted precisely to
address such situation and provide a swift remedy to senior citizens.
The law must speak firmly in such cases. It must not merely ensure
' :z2lz:
,,o
expeditious relief to the aggrieved senior citizen but also send a clear
message that harassment of aged parents at the twilight years will not
be tolerated.
Conclusion
35. For ttre foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered
opinion that sub-rule (3) of Rule 2l of the Telangana Maintenance
and Welfarr: of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2OIL is
constitutionzrlly valid and intra uires the Maintenance and Welfare of
Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2OO7. The conferment of power upon
the District Collector/District Magistrate to order eviction, in
appropriate <:ases, is a permissible statutory measure under a welfare
enactment irrtended to secure the life and property of senior citizens
and does not offend any constitutional principle.
36. Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed. The interim order
granted by tLLis Court on 05.01.2026 stands vacated. The proceedings
pending before respondent No.2 in File No.Cll394l2023 shall stand
revived and shall continue from the stage at which they were prior to
the order of stay in present writ petition. Respondent No.2 is directed
to conclude [he said proceedings and pass final orders, strictly in
accordance u,ith law and on the basis of the material available on
record, as e>:peditiously as possible, preferably within a period of
three (3) mon:hs from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
2Z:i
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed. No order as to costs.
SD/.K.BHAVANI SWAMY
ASSTSTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
a
SECTION OFFICER
To
One fair copy to the HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
(For His LordshiP s Kind Perusa!)
..
' One fair copy to the HON'BLE SRt JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
(For His LordshiP's Kind Perusal)
1. The District Collector, Appellate Tribunal, Telangana State Maintenance and
Welfare of Parents and Sdnior Citizens, Adilabad, Adilabad District.
2. 11 L.R. Copies.
3. The Under Secretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, Justice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi.
4. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association Library, High Court
Buildings, Hyderabad
5. One CC to SRI BAGLEKAR AKASH KUMAR, Advocate IOPUC]
O. Two CCs to GP for Women Development & Child Welfare, High Court for the
State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT]
7. One CC to SRI P. LAKSHMA REDDY, Advocate [OPUC]
8. Two CD Copies
MP
BS
I
@
HIGH COURT
DATED:1610212026
t oR IHE ia
S
!:f
i' .l
2 7 ftB 2026
*
't
TCT
ORDER
WP.No.32591 ot 2025
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
l]-r<s
r=[zlza.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review