Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
::1::
APHC010705422022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3329]
THURSDAY,THE SECOND DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU
NIMMAGADDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 41665/2022
Between:
1. R AMUDA, D/O LATE R. RAMASWAMY, AGED ABOUT 52
YEARS, OCC. SWEEPER LAST GRADE SERVICE, R/O.
D.NO.3-162, PAGADAMANU STREET, GREAMS PET
AND POST, CHITTOOR, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. ITS
PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY,
TRIBAL
WELFARE
DEPARTMENT,
SECRETARIAT,
VELAGAPUDI,
AMARAVATI, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
2. THE A P SCHEDULED TRIBE COOP FINANCE
CORPORATION LTD, (TRICOR), REPRESENTED BY ITS
MANAGING
DIRECTOR,
TRIBAL
WELFARE
DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF A.P., AT AMARAVATI.
3. THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR/CHAIRMAN,
CHITTOOR DISTRICT
TRICOR,
4. THE DISTRICT TRIBAL WELFARE OFFICER/MEMBER
SECRETARY,
TRICOR,
CHITTOOR
DISTRICT,
::2::
CHITTOOR.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the
High Court may be pleased topleased to issue any appropriate
Writ, Order or direction, preferably a Writ in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus declaring the impugned notice vide proceedings
No.RC.No.A1/241/TRICOR/2022-23, dated 15.12.2022, issued
by the Respondent No.4 dispensing with the services of the
petitioner from 16.12.2022 as illegal, arbitrary and violative of
Article 14, 21 of the Constitution of India and amounts to
circumventing the orders of this Hon'ble High Court in
W.P.No.8859 of 2015 and consequently direct the respondents to
continue the petitioner as Sweeper cum Attender in 4th
respondent corporation by suspending the notice vide
proceedings No. RC. No.A1/241/TRICOR/2022-23, dated
15.12.2022, forthwith pending disposal of the above writ petition
and to pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. T BALAJI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. RAMALINGESWARA RAO KOCHARLA KOTA
2. BOBBA HARI PRASAD REDDY
3. .
4. GP FOR SERVICES II
::3::
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
W.P.No.41665 of 2022
This Court made the following
ORDER:
The Writ Petition No.41665 of 2022 has been filed under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India by the petitioner for the
following relief:
“..to declare the impugned notice vide proceedings
No.RC.No.A1/241/TRICOR/2022-23,
dated
15.12.2022,
issued by the Respondent No.4 dispensing with the services of
the petitioner from 16.12.2022 as illegal, arbitrary and violative
of Articles 14, 21 of the Constitution of India and amounts to
circumventing the orders of this Hon’ble High Court in
W.P.No.8859 of 2015 and consequently direct the
respondents to continue the petitioner as Sweeper-cumAttender in 4th respondent corporation by setting aside the
notice vide proceedings No.RC.No.A1/241/TRICOR/2022-23,
dated 15.12.2022, forthwith pending disposal of the above writ
petition and to pass…”
Brief facts of the case:
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the case of the
petitioner succinctly is that the petitioner was joined as Sweeper in
the office of the 4th respondent in the year 1989 on monthly wage of
Rs.50/- initially and the same was enhanced from time to time.
Thereafter
the
4th
respondent
issued
proceedings
in
::4::
R.C.No.TR/A1/396/04, dated
-07-2004 by sanctioning the pay
fixation attached to the Last Grade Service as the petitioner
continuously working for more than 10 years.
In fact, the 4th
respondent has been paying petitioner’s provident fund contribution
from the year 1992 onwards. Learned counsel submits that at the
time of absorbing her services at the Last Grade Service, the 4th
respondent also absorbed the services of one Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar
in the post of Junior Inspector / Junior Assistant while sanctioning
the pay attached to the said post. As per the said proceedings the
petitioner is also entitled to draw salary attached to the post of Last
Grade Service w.e.f., August, 2004. But the petitioner was not paid
the salary attached to the Last Grade Service but a meager amount
of Rs.6,700/- only per month was being paid to the petitioner.
Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner filed W.P.No.8859/2015 and
this Hon’ble Court was pleased to pass interim orders by sanctioning
all increments attached to the Last Grade Service.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that even though
the claim of the petitioner is similar to one Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar,
who is joined along with the petitioner but services of Sri K.T.
Muthu Kumar was absorbed as Junior Assistant and sanctioned
pay attached to the said post but the said benefit was not
::5::
conferred to the petitioner even though she is entitled to draw the
salary attached to the Last Grade Service w.e.f. August, 2004.
Even though the petitioner submitted representations and
requested for regularization as well as payment of salary attached
to the Last Grade Service on par with Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar, the
respondents did not consider the same but being paid a meager
amount of Rs.6,700/- per month. He further asserted that having
no other option the petitioner preferred W.P.No.8859/2015 on the
file of this Hon’ble Court seeking for sanction of increments and
pay fixation including revision of pay scales from the year 1999 to
2010 and pay arrears thereon, wherein this Hon’ble Court after
hearing both sides allowed the W.P.No.8859/2015 directing the
respondents to sanction increments from time to time and also
pay fixation in RPS-1999 and RPS-2000 and RPS-2010 and
extend all the monitory benefits with arrears within a period of
three (03) months from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.
He further argued that without implementing the order of this
Court, the Corporation preferred Writ Appeal No.342/2022
challenging the orders dated 06.12.2021 in W.P.No.8859/2015
wherein a Division Bench of this Hon’ble Court disposed of the
said writ appeal by observing and modifying the order of learned
::6::
Single Judge and declared that the petitioner is entitled to the
same benefits as have been paying to K.T. Muthu Kumar by way
of proceedings dated 26.05.2017 and also directed to issue same
proceedings in favour of the writ petitioner within a period of three
(03) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.
4.
Learned Senior Counsel also submits that even though this
Hon’ble Court clearly and categorically directed the respondents
to confer all the benefits not only service benefits but also all
other payment benefits on par with Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar, whose
services were regularized and who has been paying salaries on
par with post attached to the Junior Assistant.
As such, the
petitioner is also entitled to the payment of salary to the post
attached to the Last Grade Service. Even after lapse of four (04)
months, the respondents did not implement the orders passed in
the writ appeal.
Hence the learned counsel for the petitioner
preferred contempt petition in C.C.No.5043 of 2022 before the
Division Bench of this Hon’ble Court for non-implementation o the
orders dated 07.07.2022 in W.A.No.342/2022 and same is
pending consideration. While so, the petitioner was issued
proceedings
in
R.c.No.A1/241/TRICOR/2022-23,
dated
15.12.2022 directing the petitioner not to attend the office from
::7::
16.12.2022 by observing that there is no sanctioned post of
Sweeper at the 4th respondent Corporation. He also argued that
while considering the orders of this Hon’ble Court in Writ Petition
No.8859/2015,
dated
06.12.2021as
well
as
Writ
Appeal
No.342/2022, dated 07.07.2022, this Hon’ble Court was pleased
to grant interim direction on 26.12.2022 suspending the impugned
proceedings dated 15.12.2022 and specifically directed the
respondents to continue the services of the petitioner. But even
after receipt of interim order dated 26.12.2022 of this Court, the
respondents neither allowed the petitioner to continue her
services nor paid the salaries by which, deliberately and
intentionally flouted the orders o this Hon’ble Court. He further
submits that having no other option, the petitioner also preferred
contempt petition in C.C.No.745/2023 on the file o this Hon’ble
Court which is pending consideration.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in view of
judgments rendered by this Court in W.A.No.342/2022, dated
07.07.2022, the petitioner herein is entitled for regularization and
payment of salaries on par with K.T. Muthu Kumar. The said
judgment of this Court rendered in W.A.No.342/2022 was
became final.
Therefore, the respondents neither dodge nor
::8::
escape from the implementation of the orders of this Court.
Having suffered orders of this Court and issuing impugned
proceedings terminating the services of the petitioner on the
ground that there is no sanctioned post is nothing but the
respondents are trying to circumvent the orders of this Court.
Learned counsel for the petitioner also relied upon the judgment
of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dharam Singh & others vs. State
of U.P and Another1.
6.
Respondent No.2 filed counter contending as under:
“12. It is further submitted that the 2nd respondent having come to
notice that the petitioner herein while working in the office of
DTWO, Chittoor, suppressed the fact that she was also working in
another Government office and therefore conducted an enquiry
and found that the petitioner herein also worked as Sweeper in the
Office of District Economics and Statistics Office, Chittoor till
October, 2018 and drawn wages @ Rs.790/- per month from July,
2011 to August, 2013 @ Rs.1,623/- per month from September,
2013 to November, 2017 and @ Rs.4,000/- per month from
December, 2017 to October, 2018 in terms of G.O.Ms.No.193,
Finance (HR-III) Dept. dated 07.10.2016 and G.O.Ms.No.57,
Finance (Budget-1) Dept. dated 07.04.2017, which details are
reported by the Chief Planning Officer, Chittoor vide
Lr.Rc.No.10/SA2/2021, dated 17.08.2023.
13. It is humbly submitted that the petitioner herein worked as part
time sweeper in two offices viz., 1) Office of the District Tribal
Welfare Officer, Chittoor, 2) Office of the Chief Planning Officer
Chittoor. She has claimed remuneration for the work done as part
time sweeper in both the offices. In the office of Chief Planning
Officer, Chittoor, she claimed remuneration from 2011 to 2018.
Apart from that she also claimed full time contingent salary in the
2025 insc 998
::9::
office of the District Tribal Welfare Officer, Chittoor for the period
from 2005 to 2017 on par with Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar as full time
Contingent worker in the office of the District Tribal Welfare
Officer, Chittoor by virtue of orders of the Hon’ble High Court. At
this juncture a review petition has been filed before Hon’ble High
Court vide IASR No.86848/2023 on 21.09.2023 bringing the facts
about the fraud committed by the petitioner.
Apart from that the petitioner submitted fake transfer
certificate which was verified and stated by the Head Master of
the School that the petitioner did not study in this school and
confirmed by the District Educational Officer, Chittoor. Further,
the petitioner claimed full time contingent salary on par with Sri
K.T. Muthu Kumar who is working as full-time contingent worker
in the office of the District Tribal Welfare Officer, Chittoor is illegal
and arbitrary. Hence, it is prayed this Hon’ble Court to amend the
orders of the WA No.342/2022 issued by the Division Bench of
this Hon’ble High Court.
7.
Learned counsel for respondents submits that while
considering the services of the petitioner, the respondents
conducted a detailed enquiry in respect of services of the
petitioner, wherein it is found by the respondents that the
petitioner suppressed the fact that she was working in another
Government Office and also drawn wages and a report was
called for by the Chief Planning Officer, Chittoor, dated
::10::
17.08.2023 in which she was worked simultaneously in another
department from 2011 to 2018.
Therefore on perusal of the
enquiry report it is proved that the petitioner herein worked in two
different offices at the same time but now seeking regularization
in respect of the respondent Corporation. It is also found that the
leave certificate submitted by the petitioner as if she studied 8th
class which was also not genuine and fabricated one. Therefore,
there are suppression of material facts by the petitioner and
praying for regularization as well as Revised Pay Scale on par
with other person i.e., Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar is contrary to law
and she is not entitled for such reliefs having suppressed the
material facts and played fraud against the respondent while
submitting the documents proof on her eligibility. Moreover at
persent there is no office of the 4th respondent at Chittoor to
regularize the services of the petitioner and there is no
sanctioned post to address the claim of the petitioner and comply
with the orders of this Hon’ble Court.
8.
He further submits that immediately after passing of interim
direction by this Hon’ble Court dated 26.12.2022 filed vacate stay
petition seeking to vacate the interim orders and same is pending
::11::
for consideration before this Hon’ble Court. Learned Government
Pleader also reiterates that in compliance of the orders of this
Court, the petitioner was paid all the arrears of salary in two
spells i.e., Rs.7,98,449/- on 14.11.2022 and Rs.70,620/- on
15.12.2022.
9.
Heard both the counsel and perused the material placed on
record.
10.
It is an admitted fact that the petitioner herein was engaged as
part time contingent worker as Sweeper w.e.f 01.01.1992 and
continued as Sweeper till 15.12.2022. In fact the petitioner has been
paying salaries @ minimum wages i.e., Rs.6,800/- per month for all
these years without there being any break. It is further observed that
the 2nd respondent Corporation is a State owned Corporation to
achieve an object to render financial services/assistance for
betterment of the Scheduled Tribe Community not only in customary
segments but also in commercial field within the State of Andhra
Pradesh.
Therefore, the source of funds and finances for its
administration would be borne by the 1st respondent herein. The
contention of learned counsel for respondents is that the services of
the petitioner cannot be regularized for the reason that there is no
::12::
sanctioned post of Sweeper at 4th respondent office and more so,
the office itself was closed, as such the petitioner is not entitled for
regularization on par with one Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar whose services
were already regularized in the year 2017 itself, the said plea lacks
merits and is contrary to the settled proposition of law and also the
ratio rendered by this Hon’ble Court at the instance of the petitioner
herein. As such, the contention of the learned Government Pleader
for respondents is liable to be rejected in view of the judgments of
this Court in W.P.No.8859/2015 and W.A.No.342 of 2022 as
extracted hereunder:
“ Orders dated 06.12.2021 in W.P.No.8859 of 2015:
In view of the same, the Writ Petition is allowed and the
respondents are directed to sanction increments to the
petitioner from time to time and also pay fixation in RPS-1999
and RPS-2000 and RPS-2010 and extend the monetary
benefits along with arrears within a period of three (03) months
from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
Orders dated 07.07.2022 in W.A.No.342 of 2022:
In view of the submissions made by the learned Government
Pleader that separate proceedings have been issued to Muthu
Kumar in the year 2017 granting monetary benefits along with
the benefit of Revised Pay Scales, we modify the order of the
learned Single Judge to the effect that the writ petitioner
(respondent herein) is entitled to the same benefits as have
been made admissible to Muthu Kumar by way of proceedings
dated 26.05.2017. The appellants shall issue proceedings in
favour of the writ petitioner (respondent herein) granting similar
benefits as have been granted to Muthu Kumar, within a period
of three weeks from today.
::13::
11.
On perusal of the judgments as stated supra, the respondents
were clearly and categorically directed to absorb the services of the
petitioner on par with one K.T. Muthu Kumar and also directed to
pay the salaries on par with K.T. Muthu Kumar since 2017. It seems
that the respondent implemented one part of the orders i.e.,
regarding the arrears of payment of salaries from 2017 to 2022 but
not absorbed the services of the petitioner.
On the other hand
terminated the services of the petitioner from 16.12.2022 on the
ground that there is no sanctioned post, is nothing but circumventing
the orders of this Court on the part of the respondents. It is a fact
that a contempt case is pending before the Hon’ble Division Bench
of this Court for non-implementation of the orders of this Court.
Pending contempt petition terminating the services of the petitioner
is nothing but a deliberate attempt made by the respondents flouting
the orders of the Hon’ble Division Bench in W.A.No.342/2022. The
other contention of learned counsel for respondents that since the
petitioner suppressed the material facts, and in view of self-styled
enquiry said to have been conducted by them alleging that the
petitioner has been worked not only in the 2nd respondent –
Corporation but also some other Government Organization i.e.,
Chief Planning Officer, Chittoor cannot be taken into consideration
::14::
since the said enquiry was not conducted after providing opportunity
to the petitioner and same was conducted behind the back of the
petitioner. Even assuming that the petitioner has been worked with
the alleged office for a short period of six or seven years, it cannot
be blamed since the respondents extracted the services of the
petitioner decades together by paying meager amounts. The action
of the respondents itself forced the petitioner to render services with
some other department or organization for getting some more
income to eke out her livelihood and for her family needs. Therefore,
the same cannot be found fault with the petitioner and respondents
cannot be allowed to contend that the petitioner has been
suppressed the material facts.
12.
As contended by the learned counsel for the petitioner that
having admitted and extracted the services of the petitioner since
1992 to 2022 continuously without there being any break, the
petitioner is entitled not only for regularization and also all other
consequential monitory benefits on par with Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar
from the year 2005 to 2017.
Learned counsel relied upon the
judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in Dharam Singh & others vs.
::15::
Sate of U.P and another (Supra 1) wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court
observed as under:
“3. By the impugned order, the Division Bench of the High Court
affirmed the dismissal of the writ petition on the premise that
the appellants were engaged on daily-wage basis and that
there were no rules in the U.P. Higher Education Services
Commission1 (Respondent No.2 herein) for regularization.
Moreover, the Court observed that no vacancies existed
against which the appellants could be considered.
4.1. The appellants were engaged by the Commission between
1989 and 1992. Appellant Nos. 1 to 5 served as Class-IV
employees (Peon/attendant duties), and 1 In short, “the
Commission” Appellant No. 6 served as Driver (Class-III).
They were paid as daily wagers and, with effect from
08.04.1997, received consolidated monthly amounts (₹1,500
for Class-IV; ₹2,000 for Driver), while discharging ministerial
and support functions during regular office hours. The
Commission, established under the U.P. Higher Education
Services Commission Act, 1980, processes large recruitment
cycles for teachers and principals and requires ministerial
support for scrutiny of applications, dispatch, and connected
administrative work.
4.2. On 24.10.1991, the Commission resolved to create fourteen
posts in Class-III and Class-IV and sought sanction from the
State Government 2. On 27.12.1997, the State sought
particulars of daily-wage hands and their service details. On
11.02.1998, the Commission furnished a list of fourteen daily
wagers which included the present appellants.
4.3. On 16.10.1999, the Commission reiterated its request,
seeking sanction of two posts of Driver and ten posts for
Peon/Mali/Chowkidar, adverted to administrative exigencies,
and referred to earlier correspondence. By 2 In short, “the
State” letter dated 11.11.1999, the State rejected the proposal
citing financial constraints.
4.5. On 24.04.2002, the High Court directed the Commission to
send a fresh recommendation for sanction of appropriate
Group-C/Group-D posts and directed the State to take a fresh
::16::
decision thereon. In the meantime, having regard to the
appellants’ long engagement, the Commission was directed to
pay them the minimum of the applicable pay scale.
19. Having regard to the long, undisputed service of the
appellants, the admitted perennial nature of their duties, and the
material indicating vacancies and comparator regularisations, we
issue the following directions:
i. Regularization and creation of Supernumerary posts: All
appellants shall stand regularized with effect
from
24.04.2002, the date on which the High Court directed a
fresh recommendation by the Commission and a fresh
decision by the State on sanctioning posts for the
appellants. For this purpose, the State and the successor
establishment (U.P. Education Services Selection
Commission) shall create supernumerary posts in the
corresponding cadres, Class-III (Driver or equivalent) and
Class-IV (Peon/Attendant/Guard or equivalent) without any
caveats or preconditions. On regularization, each appellant
shall be placed at not less than the minimum of the regular
pay-scale for the post, with protection of last-drawn wages
if higher and the appellants shall be entitled to the
subsequent increments in the pay scale as per the pay
grade. For seniority and promotion, service shall count
from the date of regularization as given above.
ii. Financial consequences and arrears: Each appellant shall
be paid as arrears the full difference between (a) the pay
and admissible allowances at the minimum of the regular
pay-level for the post from time to time, and (b) the
amounts actually paid, for the period from 24.04.2002 until
the date of regularization /retirement/death, as the case
may be. Amounts already paid under previous interim
directions shall be so adjusted. The net arrears shall be
released within three months and if in default, the unpaid
amount shall carry compound interest at 6% per annum
from the date of default until payment.
iii. Retired appellants: Any appellant who has already retired
shall be granted regularization with effect from 24.04.2002
until the date of superannuation for pay fixation, arrears
under clause (ii), and recalculation of pension, gratuity and
other terminal dues. The revised pension and terminal dues
shall be paid within three months of this Judgement.
20. We have framed these directions comprehensively because,
case after case, orders of this Court in such matters have
been met with fresh technicalities, rolling “reconsiderations,”
::17::
and administrative drift which further prolongs the insecurity for
those who have already laboured for years on daily wages.
Therefore, we have learned that Justice in such cases cannot
rest on simpliciter directions, but it demands imposition of clear
duties, fixed timelines, and verifiable compliance. As a
constitutional employer, the State is held to a higher standard
and therefore it must organise its perennial workers on a
sanctioned footing, create a budget for lawful engagement,
and implement judicial directions in letter and spirit. Delay to
follow these obligations is not mere negligence but rather it is
a conscious method of denial that erodes livelihoods and
dignity for these workers. The operative scheme we have set
here comprising of creation of supernumerary posts, full
regularization, subsequent financial benefits, and a sworn
affidavit of compliance, is therefore a pathway designed to
convert rights into outcomes and to reaffirm that fairness in
engagement and transparency in administration are not
matters of grace, but obligations under Articles 14, 16 and 21
of the Constitution of India.”
13.
In view of the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court as stated supra
as well as judgment of this Hon’ble Court in W.A.No.342/2022, the
petitioner shall entitle for regularization by setting aside the
termination proceedings dated 15.12.2022 is valid and sustainable in
view of the judgment rendered by this Court and having suffered the
judgments and became final.
The action of the respondents in
issuing termination proceedings dated 15.12.2022 is nothing but
circumventing the orders of this Court.
14.
It is settled proposition of law that once the petitioner
continued the services more than three decades, the right of the
petitioner for absorption as regular employee cannot be denied on
the ground of there is no sanctioned post and after extraction of
::18::
services for a period more than 30 years is against the principle laid
down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Dharam Singh & others vs.
Sate of U.P and another (Supra 1) and also in State of Karnataka
vs. Uma Devi2.
15.
Therefore, in view of the reasons stated above and in view of
ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court as well as this Court, the
Writ Petition is allowed directing the respondents to regularize the
services of the petitioner on par with Sri K.T. Muthu Kumar in terms
of the judgment in W.A.No.342 of 2022, dated 07.07.2022 within a
period of three (03) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications, if any pending, shall
stand closed.
_________________________________
VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA, J
DT: 02.04.2026
krk
(2006) 4 SCC 1,
::19::
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
W.P.No.41665 of 2022
DT: .02.04.2026
krk
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review