Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 6779/2016 & CM APPL. 27871/2016
QUEEN MARYS SCHOOL & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through:
versus
ASHISH SAMUEL & ANR
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Om Prakash Mishra, Advocate
for R-1.
Mr. Yeeshu Jain, ASC with Ms. Jyoti
Tyagi, Ms. Vishruti Pandey and Mr.
Sachin Garg, Advocates for R-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
24.03.2026
%
1.
This petition assails the judgment dated 03rd June, 2016 passed by the
Delhi School Tribunal in Appeal No. 44/2012, whereby the Tribunal set
aside the acceptance of the resignation of Respondent No. 1 and directed his
reinstatement. It is the Petitioners’ case that Respondent No. 1 had resigned
on 30th May, 2012 and stood relieved on 30th June, 2012, and that the
Tribunal erred in its findings on the nature of the resignation, limitation, and
the interpretation of Rule 114A of the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973.
The Controversy
2.
Respondent No. 1 was appointed as a Music Teacher in the Petitioner
school with effect from 01st April, 2005 and his services came to be
confirmed on 28th August, 2008. There is no dispute that he continued in
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
service thereafter. According to the Petitioners, he submitted a handwritten
resignation on 30th May, 2012 requesting that it be accepted after one month,
and was accordingly relieved with effect from 30th June, 2012. The
Petitioners further say that the resignation was never withdrawn and later
stood accepted by the Managing Committee as well.
3.
Respondent No. 1 contests that account on several aspects. His case is
that he resumed duty after the summer vacation on 23 rd June, 2012. During
the heat closure from 02nd July, 2012 to 08th July, 2012, he received a memo
dated 04th July, 2012 calling upon him to report for duty on 05th July, 2012,
failing which his services would be terminated. He asserts that he met the
Principal on 06th July, 2012 and again attended the school on 09th July, 2012.
He was then forced, under threat, to sign papers and write out a resignation,
though the document was made to bear the earlier date of 30 th May, 2012.
He further alleges that on 10th July, 2012 he was stopped at the school gate
and was not allowed to rejoin thereafter.
4.
The record also shows that the dispute did not remain dormant
thereafter. Respondent No. 1 claims to have addressed representations to the
school and other authorities in July, August and September 2012 seeking
permission to resume duty and complaining that the resignation relied upon
by the school was not voluntary. On 08th October, 2012, the school wrote to
him stating that he had voluntarily tendered resignation on 30 th May, 2012
and that it stood accepted. Respondent No. 1 thereafter instituted Appeal No.
44/2012 before the Delhi School Tribunal on 06th November, 2012 under
Section 8(3) of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973.
5.
By the impugned judgment dated 03rd June, 2016, the Tribunal
accepted the employee’s challenge, held against the Petitioners on the issue
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
of voluntariness and validity of the alleged resignation, and directed
reinstatement. Aggrieved thereby, the present writ petition has been filed.
Petitioner’s submissions
6.
Counsel for the Petitioners assails the impugned order on the premise
that the Tribunal accepted a story which, was inherently improbable and
belatedly introduced. Even on the employee’s own showing, the alleged
coercion is said to have occurred on 09th July, 2012, yet no such allegation
was raised at the earliest opportunity and was introduced only subsequently
as an afterthought. Respondent No. 1, was at all times aware of the
resignation dated 30th May, 2012, had himself annexed it with the appeal,
and neither withdrew nor sought to set it aside in any legally recognised
manner. The Tribunal, therefore, erred in disregarding a resignation which
was never directly challenged.
7.
The appeal before the Tribunal was not maintainable. The Tribunal,
exercising jurisdiction under Section 8(3) of the Delhi School Education
Act, 1973, could entertain only a challenge to an order of dismissal, removal
or reduction in rank. In the present case, no such order was impugned, nor
was there any specific challenge to the resignation dated 30 th May, 2012.
Reliance, in this regard, is placed on Radhey Shyam Sharma v. The
Managing Committee, Mahasya Chunni Lal Saraswati Bal Mandir.1 Even
on the employee’s own case, he was denied entry on 10 th July, 2012;
reckoned from that date, the appeal filed on 06 th November, 2012 was
beyond limitation. The letter dated 08th October 2012, it is urged, did not
give rise to any fresh cause of action.
In W.P.(C) No. 3245/2011, decided on 13 th May, 2011.
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
8.
On merits, it is submitted that the resignation dated 30th May, 2012
was voluntary. It was written in the employee’s own hand, tendered with
notice, accepted, and he was relieved with effect from 30th June, 2012. The
resignation was never withdrawn. Reliance is also placed on the fact that the
employee obtained no-dues clearances and settled his accounts, which,
according to the Petitioners, is inconsistent with any case of coercion. The
subsequent allegations of threats, blank papers and backdating are denied as
unsupported and contradictory.
9.
The Tribunal erred in its interpretation of Rule 114A of the Delhi
School Education Rules, 1973. The Rule does not render a resignation
ineffective merely because formal approval is not recorded within a
stipulated period. It is contended that the resignation stood accepted, and in
any event, the approval granted by the Managing Committee on 09 th August,
2012 constituted a valid acceptance. It is further urged that the said meeting
was attended by two nominees of the Directorate of Education, which
satisfies the requirement of approval under the statutory scheme. In this
regard, reliance is placed on the decision in The Managing Committee of
Rani Dutta Arya Vidyalaya & Anr. v. Delhi School Tribunal & Ors.,2 to
contend that once a resignation is accepted and the statutory framework is
complied with, the same attains finality and cannot be lightly disregarded.
10.
The memo dated 04th July, 2012 has been wrongly relied upon. The
same was an inadvertent communication issued after Respondent No. 1 had
already resigned and stood relieved with effect from 30th June, 2012, and
cannot detract from the validity of the resignation. The Petitioners deny that
the employee attended the school thereafter or was wrongfully prevented
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
from doing so.
11.
The Petitioners further rely on the surrounding circumstances,
including communications from the police at Kanpur, to submit that the
resignation was voluntary and motivated by the employee’s personal
situation. It is also contended that, in view of the nature of the allegations
against him, a girls’ school with predominantly female staff could not
reasonably be expected to continue his employment. The plea of coercion is
therefore denied as false and an attempt to re-enter service after having
resigned.
Submissions on behalf of Respondent No. 1
12.
Counsel for Respondent No. 1 supports the impugned order and
submits that the Petitioners’ case is internally inconsistent. It is pointed out
that Respondent No. 1 resumed duties after the summer vacation and was
issued a memo dated 04th July, 2012 directing him to report for duty on 05th
July 2012, failing which his services would be terminated. This is wholly
inconsistent with the stand that he had already resigned on 30 th May, 2012
and stood relieved on 30th June, 2012.
13.
Developing the chronology, it is submitted that Respondent No. 1 met
the Principal on 06th July, 2012. On 09th July, 2012, he attended the school,
marked his attendance, and was then forced under threat, including of arrest,
to write out a resignation which was backdated to 30 th May, 2012. He was
thereafter denied entry from 10th July 2012. The case is that the resignation
was not voluntary but procured under coercion and subsequently backdated.
14.
The plea of coercion was not an afterthought, as the Petitioners now
suggest. Respondent No. 1 raised his grievance from July, 2012 onwards
In W.P.(C) No. 20218-19/2004, decided on 11th January, 2017.
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
through representations to the school and authorities, seeking to resume
duty. Reliance is placed on the continuing correspondence culminating in
the letter dated 08th October, 2012, by which the school for the first time
asserted that the resignation stood accepted. The appeal filed thereafter is
stated to be within limitation.
15.
On limitation and maintainability, it is submitted that the cause of
action cannot be confined to 10th July, 2012 when entry was denied, but
must be read in light of the subsequent correspondence and the school’s
final stand communicated on 08th October, 2012. The absence of a formal
termination order does not assist the Petitioners, as the grievance is precisely
that Respondent No. 1 was unlawfully kept out of service under the guise of
a resignation which he consistently disputed.
16.
Petitioners’ emphasis on non-withdrawal of the resignation is also
disputed. Respondent No. 1 has consistently denied having voluntarily
tendered any resignation and has asserted that the document was obtained by
coercion and fraud. In such circumstances the question of formally
withdrawing the resignation does not arise.
17.
On Rule 114A, it is submitted that the Petitioners’ reliance on
acceptance is misconceived. There was no valid or voluntary resignation in
the first place, the document having been obtained under coercion and
backdated. The statutory requirement of approval was not complied with, as
the resignation was neither shown to have been forwarded within the
prescribed period nor approved by the Directorate of Education. Reliance is
placed on the Managing Committee resolution dated 09th August, 2012,
which records acceptance of the resignation with effect from 30 th June, 2012
subject to approval of the Directorate of Education, to contend that even on
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
the school’s own showing the matter had not attained finality.
18.
The explanation that the memo dated 04th July, 2012 was inadvertent
is disputed. In fact, the memo, coupled with the employee’s continued
attendance till 09th July, 2012, is crucial in demonstrating that the
employment relationship had not ended. The Petitioners are also stated to
have withheld the attendance records which would have corroborated this
position.
19.
As regards the reliance on police notices and personal allegations, it is
submitted that such matters are irrelevant to the validity of the resignation.
These allegations were used as a means of exerting pressure, and in any
event do not establish that the resignation was voluntary.
Submissions on behalf of Respondent No. 2
20.
On behalf of the Directorate of Education, it is submitted that the
Petitioner school is a recognised unaided private school and is, therefore,
governed by the Delhi School Education Act and Rules. At the same time,
the Directorate states that the present dispute is essentially between the
school and Respondent No. 1. The short affidavit also refers to the position
emerging from Raj Kumar v. DoE & Ors.3 and the departmental order dated
20th May, 2016 requiring compliance with Section 8(2) and the connected
rules in the wake of that judgment. Broadly speaking, the Directorate does
not seek to independently justify the school’s action on facts and leaves the
primary contest to be resolved between the employer and the employee.
Discussion and reasons
21.
The controversy in the present writ petition turns on three questions.
First, whether the appeal before the Tribunal was liable to be rejected on the
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
grounds of maintainability or limitation. Second, whether the Petitioners
have been able to establish that Respondent No. 1 voluntarily resigned from
service and stood validly relieved with effect from 30th June, 2012. Third,
whether Rule 114A of the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973, read with
the later resolution of the Managing Committee, is sufficient to cure the
evident defects in the Petitioners’ case.
22.
At the outset, this Court addresses the issue of maintainability . The
Petitioners raises a preliminary objection to the jurisdiction of the Delhi
School Tribunal. The Petitioners contends that Section 8(3) of the Delhi
School Education Act, 1973 only permits appeals against orders of
“dismissal, removal or reduction in rank.” It is argued that a “resignation”
does not fall within these categories and, therefore, the Tribunal had no
authority to entertain the matter. Reliance is placed on Radhey Shyam
Sharma to support this restrictive view.
23.
The objection cannot be accepted. The scope of Section 8(3) has been
settled by the Supreme Court in Shashi Gaur v. NCT of Delhi & Ors.4 In
that case, the Court held that Section 8(3) provides a remedy not only
against major penalties in disciplinary proceedings but also against
“termination otherwise,” except where service ends by a natural efflux of
time. The Supreme Court explicitly cautioned against a narrow construction
of this provision, noting that the Tribunal was established to protect teachers
from being taken out of service by the whims of private management.
(2016) 6 SCC 541.
(2001) 10 SCC 445.
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
24.
This principle has been applied by this Court in Daya Nand Adarsh
Vidyalaya v. Deepa Chibber5 specifically in the context of a disputed
resignation relied upon by the management. The Court clarified that where
an employee asserts that she has been unlawfully kept out of service, and the
management seeks to justify its action on the basis of an alleged resignation,
the Tribunal has jurisdiction to examine whether such resignation was in fact
voluntary and valid. The form in which the management characterizes its
action does not determine jurisdiction. The Court also considered the
reliance placed on Radhey Shyam Sharma by the school and held that the
said decision merely narrated the facts of an earlier proceeding and did not
lay down any principle that the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to examine
whether a resignation was forced.
25.
In the present case, Respondent No. 1 has consistently asserted that he
was unlawfully kept out of service under the guise of a back-dated,
involuntary resignation. Following the ratio in Shashi Gaur, such a dispute
squarely falls within the Tribunal’s jurisdiction to adjudicate whether the
cessation of service was, in substance, an illegal removal. The objection to
maintainability is therefore rejected.
26.
With the question of maintainability thus resolved, the Court turns to
the issue whether Respondent No. 1 voluntarily resigned from service. The
Petitioners’ case is that Respondent No. 1 voluntarily tendered a handwritten
resignation dated 30th May, 2012, that it was accepted at his request, and that
he stood relieved with effect from 30th June, 2012. The subsequent
challenge, according to them, is an afterthought. They rely on the absence of
any withdrawal of resignation, explain the memo dated 04 th July, 2012 as an
In W.P.(C) No. 1009/2012, decided on 19 th September, 2013.
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
‘inadvertent act’, and contend that the later approval by the Managing
Committee, attended by departmental nominees, cured any defect.
27.
The difficulty for the Petitioners is that this position is not borne out
consistently by the record. Respondent No. 1’s appeal before the Tribunal
sets out a chronology which is at variance with the Petitioners’ case: he
resumed duty on 23rd June, 2012; during the heat closure he received the
memo dated 04th July, 2012 directing him to report on 05th July, 2012; he
attended on 06th July, 2012 and again on 09th July, 2012; and on 10th July,
2012 he was stopped at the school gate. He continued to send
representations through July, August and September 2012, and it was only
on 08th October, 2012 that the school communicated in writing that he had
voluntarily resigned on 30th May, 2012.
28.
The inconsistency in the Petitioners’ case emerges from their own
pleadings. While asserting that Respondent No. 1 had resigned of his own
accord and stood relieved with effect from 30th June, 2012, the Petitioners
were also required to explain the memo dated 04th July, 2012. They do not
deny the issuance of the said memo, but attempt to minimize its significance
by characterizing it as an “inadvertent act”. In the opinion of the Court, a
direction calling upon an employee to report for duty, failing which his
services would be terminated, sits uneasily with the argument that the
employment had already come to an end.
29.
Nor does the record stop there. The school’s own record shows that
the issue of resignation was still being processed even after 30 th May, 2012.
The internal note dated 03rd July, 2012 and, later, the resolution of the
Managing Committee dated 09th August, 2012 do not reflect a case of a
clean and completed severance already brought about earlier. The resolution,
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
in particular, records that the resignation with effect from 30 th June, 2012
was accepted ‘subject to the approval of the Directorate of Education’ and
authorises the Principal to file the relevant papers with the Directorate. A
record framed in those terms does not advance the Petitioners’ plea that the
matter had already become final, unconditional and legally closed at an
earlier stage. The later resolution is, therefore, not a clean answer. It forms
part of the same uneven documentary trail.
30.
Viewed cumulatively, the Petitioners’ case does not present a
consistent documentary narrative. On the one hand, it is asserted that the
resignation stood concluded with effect from 30th June, 2012; on the other,
the memo dated 04th July, 2012 is treated as inconsequential, and reliance is
placed on subsequent approvals to sustain the position. These are not merely
alternative formulations but reflect uncertainty in the Petitioners’ own record
as to when and on what basis the severance of service became complete. In
writ jurisdiction, the question is not whether another view is possible, but
whether the Tribunal’s conclusion is untenable. On the material before it, it
cannot be said to be so.
31.
That brings the Court to Rule 114A and the reliance placed by the
Petitioners on The Managing Committee of Rani Dutta Arya Vidyalaya.
The Petitioners are right to the limited extent that Rule 114A does not permit
a school to indefinitely withhold acceptance of a genuine resignation. The
decision in Rani Dutta explains that Rule 114A uses mandatory language
and that, if there is no refusal by the Director within thirty days, resignation
may attain finality on expiry of that period. It also recognises the distinction
between acceptance of resignation and actual relieving under Rule 96(9).
However, that decision equally makes clear why approval by the Director
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
matters in cases where the resignation may not be genuine or may have been
forced upon the employee. In other words, Rani Dutta assists the Petitioners
only if the foundational fact of a genuine resignation is first established. It
does not compel the Court to treat every disputed resignation as final merely
because thirty days have passed.
32.
Read in that light, Rule 114A does not advance the Petitioners’ case.
This is not a case where an admitted resignation was later sought to be
retracted after the statutory period. This is a case where the employee’s
stand from the beginning has been that the document relied on by the
management was procured under coercion and backdated, and where the
management’s own subsequent conduct does not fit neatly with the theory of
a completed severance on 30th June, 2012. The Petitioners’ emphasis on
deemed approval therefore misses the real point. Deeming cannot supply
factual coherence where the surrounding record itself casts doubt on whether
the resignation was voluntary and legally complete in the first place.
33.
The submission that Respondent No. 1 neither withdrew the
resignation nor specifically challenged it is of little assistance. Such an
argument may carry weight where the employee admits having voluntarily
resigned and later seeks to retract. It carries far less force where the
challenge goes to the very character of the document and the manner in
which it came into existence. If the employee asserts that the document was
not a free and valid act of resignation, the absence of a formal withdrawal or
a specifically framed challenge cannot, by itself, validate it. The substance
of the grievance, namely that he was unlawfully kept out of service under
cover of an involuntary resignation, was consistently urged before the
Tribunal.
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
34.
The plea that the allegation of coercion is an afterthought also does
not merit acceptance. The record shows that the employee had been raising
grievances from July 2012 onwards and continued to assert that he had been
wrongfully kept out of service. The Tribunal was therefore justified in
treating the matter as a continuing dispute rather than a belated fabrication.
35.
On limitation, this Court finds no reason to interfere with the
Tribunal’s conclusion. The employee’s grievance may be traced to his
exclusion from duty on 10th July, 2012. Yet, that was not the end of the
matter. The record shows continued correspondence, repeated assertions by
the employee that he be permitted to rejoin, and, ultimately, the school’s
letter dated 08th October, 2012 setting out in writing its stand that he had
voluntarily resigned and that the management had accepted the same. The
appeal was filed on 06th November, 2012. In these circumstances, the
Tribunal was justified in viewing the letter dated 08 th October, 2012 as the
point at which the dispute took a definitive shape. The objection on
limitation cannot, therefore, be accepted as one that ought to have non-suited
the employee at the outset.
36.
In view of the foregoing, no ground for interference under Article 226
of the Constitution of India is made out. The writ petition is accordingly
dismissed, along with pending application(s). The interim order dated 31 st
August, 2016, whereby the operation of the impugned order was stayed,
stands vacated.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
MARCH 24, 2026/hc
W.P.(C) 6779/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 16:14:24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review