Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.05
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 26/2022
Date of order: 08.09.2022
Pynskhemlang Nongrang
Vs.
The Directorate of Soil and Water
Conservation & ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
:
Mr. S.R. Lyngdoh, Adv with
Mr. H.R. Nath, Adv
Mr. K.V.E. Kharnongbak, Adv
For the Respondents :
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA
Mr. S. Sengupta, Adv for R/3
Mr. K. Ch. Gautam, Adv R/4
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The appeal has been carried against a judgment and order of June
10, 2022 passed on the appellant’s petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution. By the order impugned, the appellant’s challenge to the
selection process adopted by the Directorate of Soil and Water
Conservation of the State in course of appointing two drivers has been
repelled.
2.
The order impugned records that the methodology adopted for the
selection process was decided prior to the process being initiated, and as
such, there was no change in the rules midstream, so to say. The order
impugned notices that the selection process was divided into two parts: a
practical driving test and an interview. The Single Bench perceived that
the writ petitioner had no quarrel with the practical driving test but was
aggrieved only with the manner in which marks were allotted in the
interview. The Court observed that it was the settled law that a candidate
having taken part in a selection process could not turn around and
challenge the same upon being unsuccessful.
3.
The primary feature that initially engaged the attention of this
appellate court was that the appellant herein had secured the highest mark
of 84 in the practical examination which tested the candidates’ driving
skills. However, some other candidates who barely met the qualifying
marks to be called for the interview obtained exceptionally high marks in
course of the interview to topple, inter alia, the appellant herein and bag
the posts. Two of the private respondents herein were appointed and such
appointments were made in or about March, 2021.
4.
The methodology adopted for conducting the selection process
was that equal weightage would be given to the practical examination on
driving skills and an interview would be conducted by seven designated
officials. The methodology itself strikes as odd. High authorities now
instruct that except in certain special cases, the weightage given to the
objective examination should be about 70 or 75 per cent and the
weightage given to the subjective assessment in course of an interview or
viva-voce should not exceed 30 to 35 per cent. There is good reason for
such rule. Oftentimes it had been seen that candidates faring exceeding
well in the objective examination obtained low marks in the interview
without any indication as to how or why they were found deficient.
5.
To ensure that the objective part of the examination carries more
weightage and the subjective part cannot completely override the
objective assessment, the recent trend of judgments requires the
subjective element to be kept to the minimum, depending, of course, on
the nature of the job.
6.
When it comes to the appointment of a driver, common sense
instructs that it is the driving skill which should be the paramount
consideration. Here was a candidate who obtained 84 marks out of the
allotted 100 in the driving skill test conducted by the employer and one
of the private respondents obtained only 70 marks in the same test. The
rules of the game, as set out prior to the process being commenced,
provided that persons obtaining 70 or more marks in the driving skill test
would be called for the subsequent interview. One of the private
respondents who was ultimately selected barely scraped through and
started with a 14-mark disadvantage as the selection process entered the
second stage of the interview.
7.
Since the system adopted of allotting equal marks to the objective
examination and equal weightage to the interview appeared somewhat
dubious, the records were called for. The records reveal that a completely
arbitrary and unfair procedure was adopted at the interview unbecoming
of any respectable or acceptable selection process.
8.
Quite apart from the fact that the rules pertaining to the selection
at the outset made it possible for nepotism to rule the day by giving equal
weightage to the driving skill test and the subjective assessment at the
interview, it is evident that seven members were to constitute the
interview board. One of the members was absent and it is submitted on
behalf of the respondent authorities that the rules require a five-member
accessing team and, as such, the absence of one member out of seven did
not stand in the way of the interview being conducted on the scheduled
date.
9.
Even if the absence of one of the seven members on the interview
board is disregarded, the score-sheet of the interview conducted on
February 25, 2021 throws up serious anomalies. As noticed earlier, 100
marks were allotted for the driving skill test and another 100 for the
interview. If six members conducted the interview and each of them had
to mark out of a maximum, elementary arithmetic would reveal that the
maximum marks that could be allotted by each interviewer was 16.66.
10.
The single-page score-sheet is divided into several columns. The
two columns on the extreme left are the serial numbers of the candidates
called for the interview and the roll numbers of such candidates,
respectively. The next seven columns indicate the individual marks
allotted by the interviewers, one of such columns remaining blank in view
of the absence of the relevant interviewer. The column on the extreme
right is the total marks obtained by adding up individual marks allotted
by the individual interviewers. Since the total marks allotted for the
interview was 100, the marks indicated in the extreme right column
would be the marks obtained by the relevant candidate out of the
maximum of 100.
11.
Yet, it is evident from the score-sheets that the second member of
the interview board allotted 18 marks to the candidate bearing roll
number 031 and the fifth member allotted 17 marks to the same
candidate! Surprises never cease. As far as the other successful candidate
was concerned, four of the six interviewers gave him 16 marks.
12.
Thus, on the combined strength of the liberal manner in which the
ultimate successful candidates were marked by the interviewers and the
much less marks awarded to the appellant herein in the interview, the
advantage of the 14 marks that the appellant enjoyed, at the time of
entering the interview room, was whittled down and overhauled.
13.
Ordinarily, any form of assessment would involve certain
parameters. Keeping in mind that this was an interview for the post of a
driver, the parameters may have been awareness of traffic regulations,
knowledge of roads and even an element of presentability. However, it
does not appear that any guidelines were followed in assessing the
candidates called for the interview.
14.
When it comes to a State or other authority within the meaning of
Article 12 of the Constitution inviting applications for appointment, the
selection process must be completely above board since every candidate
who meets the eligibility criteria to participate in the process has to be
dealt with fairly. It is for such purpose that greater weightage is desirable
to be given to the objective part of the assessment since the Indian psyche
is such that the subjective part of the assessment, more often than not, is
tainted, influenced or guided by nepotism or the usual uncle culture or
even more disagreeable extraneous considerations.
15.
Though it would do for the present purpose to confine the
discussion to Article 16 of the Constitution and the equality of
opportunity in matters of public employment that such provision
mandates, the matter may be seen from the wider coverage under Articles
14, 15 and 16 of the Constitution. Article 14 of the Constitution, despite
being one of the shortest, contains the world within it and is the safeguard
against any form of prejudice, discrimination or arbitrariness. Article 15,
in its first clause, prohibits the State from discriminating against any
citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any
of them. Similarly, clauses (1) and (2) of Article 16 ensure equality of
opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to employment or
appointment to any office under the State with the further mandate that
grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth,
residence or any of them may not be used as a ground for ineligibility or
discrimination in respect of any employment or office under the State.
16.
Article 15 of the Constitution saw an early change in the second
year of the Republic by way of the first amendment that provided for
affirmative action. Similarly, the three clauses that followed the second
clause in the original Article 16 made room for affirmative action,
notwithstanding the general rule as provided in clauses (1) and (2) of such
Article. In course of time, clauses (4A), (4B) and (6) have been
incorporated in Article 16 to provide for different categories of
reservation, including for the economically weaker sections by the 103 rd
amendment of 2019.
17.
Notwithstanding the changes effected in both Articles 15 and 16
and the exception to the general rule being carved out for socially and
economically challenged sections, the overwhelming spirit of equality
embodied therein has not been diluted. Equality of opportunity, in the
sense that the expression is used in Article 16 of the Constitution, read
with the impermissible grounds of discrimination as illustrated in the
second clause thereof, does not imply that every candidate applying for a
post would have equal right to it without any other consideration. The
overwhelming message conveyed by Article 16 of the Constitution, as it
keeps close company with Articles 14 and 15, is that in the selection
process
pertaining
to
employment
or
appointment,
irrelevant
considerations must not come into play. Of course, the merits of a
candidate will be assessed so that most suitable for the post is identified.
But just as religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth, residence are
to be kept out of the consideration, favouritism and nepotism would also
have no role to play in the process of selection. At the end of the day it
has to be a fair process and a reasonable procedure adopted for the
selection; or it would fall foul of the constitutional ethos.
18.
It is plain to see in this case that no objective criteria as to how
the subjective assessment would be made at the interview were indicated.
Ordinarily, the total marks allotted in course of an interview ought to be
broken down and individual marks based on certain functional aspects
awarded that would ensure an element of objectivity even in the
subjective assessment. However, in this case all vestiges of objectivity
were thrown to the wind and the marking procedure was completely
arbitrary, even to the extent of two of the interviewers allotting more
marks to the preferred candidate than the maximum marks that they could
have awarded.
19.
Ordinarily, since the record pertaining to the interview reeks of a
completely unfair procedure being adopted and a vile charade being
enacted in the guise of an interview, the entire process ought to have been
annulled. However, other considerations come into play.
20.
It
appears
that
though
the
appellant
herein
was
contemporaneously aware of the conclusion of the selection process and
the publication of the list of successful candidates by the end of February,
2021 and the appellant also applied on March 31, 2021 under the Right
to Information Act, 2005 to obtain information as to the marking at the
two stages, he waited till August 1, 2021 before coming to the Court. By
such time the appointments had already been made and rights had vested
in the private respondent appointees for several months.
21.
It is also evident, as is apparent from the order impugned, that the
petitioner did not question the methodology adopted for selection but
merely complained that he may have been awarded lower marks in the
interview than what he deserved. Since the records had not been called
for by the writ court, such court of the first instance could not appreciate
the colossal mockery that was undertaken in the name of the interview.
22.
The considerations that weigh with the Court at this stage in
granting any relief to the writ petitioner, despite noticing the farcical
manner in which the interview was conducted, are the delay in coming to
Court; the policy of reservation that ought to have applied; and, that
compensation in some form may assuage the appellant’s understandable
indignation. It is equally significant that the appellant did not question
the methodology, but participated in the process and complained only
upon failing to make the cut.
23.
It may be noticed at this stage that despite the policy of
reservation being in place in the State since its inception in 1972, there
was no roster system adopted until earlier this year. As it is elementary,
no reservation policy can be appropriately applied without following the
roster system. The official respondents point out that in the present case
there were seven posts of driver and five posts had previously been filled
up. The selection process in the present case was for the two remaining
positions. The respondents further inform the Court that out of the five
previous appointees, four belonged to the Khasi tribe and one to the Garo
tribe. Of the two new appointees, one belongs to the Khasi tribe and the
other to the Garo tribe.
24.
As per the reservation policy of the State, 40 per cent of all posts
are reserved for members of the Khasi and Jaintia tribes, 40 per cent for
members of the Garo tribe, five per cent for persons belonging to other
scheduled tribes and remaining 15 per cent seats are not reserved. In the
absence of a roster system, the initial five of the seven posts were filled
up without ensuring the reservation ratio. In any event, if there were four
appointees out of seven posts who belonged to the Khasi tribe, no other
Khasi candidate could have been considered for further appointment.
25.
However, so as not to reopen past and concluded matters and
allow the historical blunder that continued till the fiftieth year of the
formation of the State to be given a quietus, the roster system has been
put in place prospectively with every department being required to
prepare the rosters for all entry-level posts from the inception so that the
future appointments can be made by strictly adhering to the reservation
policy. Accordingly, since the appellant is a Khasi candidate,
notwithstanding that one of the appointees was also a Khasi, as on date
the appellant would not qualify to seek an appointment to the relevant
post even if the selection process were to be annulled.
26.
Further, despite it appearing that undue benefit may have been
conferred on at least one or both of the private respondent appointees, it
is evident that the writ petitioner-appellant was not vigilant and may have
slept over his rights for a considerable period of time before approaching
the Court. Though no period of limitation is prescribed for carrying a
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, the writ court is slow to
extend any relief to a laggard. It must be appreciated in the same breath
that even if the schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 were to apply to the
writ petitioner, he approached this Court within months and not years of
the selection process being completed. However, once the appointments
are firmed up and the appointees are in place for several months, the
Court is loath to throw out the appointees. In this case, the matter has to
be considered from the situation as it prevails today, at the time that the
appeal is being decided. However much it appears that the private
respondents may had been unfairly selected, yet the private respondents
had been occupying the position for some 16 or more months and the
appellant herein did not enjoy any interim order since the inception of the
writ petition. The appellant is entitled to some form of relief, though it
may not be in the form that the appellant desires most.
27.
On the basis of the things as they stand today, the appellant may
not be entitled to obtain the cherished relief. However, since it is evident
that the appellant has been unfairly treated by the State, the appellant will
be considered favourably in any future selection process for appointment
in any category for which the appellant is eligible to apply. In addition,
in the event the appellant does not obtain any government job before the
age bar comes into operation, as a result of the wrong done by the
respondent authorities to the appellant, the appellant will be entitled to a
five-year latitude in respect of the age bar to be entitled to apply for
government positions or in the State public sector undertakings.
28.
As far as the respondents are concerned, the matter will be
brought to the notice of the Chief Secretary to the State for it to be
reported to the appropriate vigilance authorities for taking action against
the members who conducted the interview on February 25, 2021 and
hijacked a process without any adherence to ordinary norms of fairness.
The State will also guard against the repetition of such exercise whether
in respect of any State post at any level or in respect of posts under any
State public sector undertaking or corporation or other authority which
may be regarded as having the trappings of the State within the meaning
of Article 12 of the Constitution.
29.
The appropriate department of the State should undertake an
awareness drive and educate the persons who would be involved in the
future selection processes as to the present norms, including the
weightage to be given to the skill or the objective test and the weightage
to be given to the interview. It must be remembered at the end of the day
that a driver may not be judged in how he dresses or how he looks but in
how he manoeuvres the machine that is entrusted to him.
30.
The selection process in the present case completely failed to look
for the best person for the job and this faulty exercise should be made a
model by the State as to what a selection process can never be.
31.
Since it is evident that the writ petitioner has been unfairly treated
and has lost on a lifetime opportunity to obtain a position that the writ
petitioner appears to have deserved, the State and the concerned
prospective employer will pay damages by way of costs assessed at Rs.3
lakh. Such costs have to be paid within three months, failing which it will
carry simple interest at the rate of 7 per cent per annum from the expiry
of three months from date. It will also be open to the State to extract the
costs or a substantial portion thereof from the members of the interview
board.
32.
WA No.26 of 2022 is disposed of on the above basis.
33.
The only silver lining to this sordid saga is the fair and transparent
manner in which the respondent authorities acquitted themselves in
course of this appeal.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
08.09.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review