Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$
*
%
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 12.05.2026
Judgment delivered on: 03.07.2026
Judgment uploaded on: As per Digital Signature~
LPA 550/2013
PYARE LAL (SINCE DECEASED) THR LRS
.....APPELLANTS
versus
DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION
.....RESPONDENT
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Appellants
:
Mr. Arun Bhardwaj, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Pranava Rastogi and Ms. Ashu Tiwari,
Advocates.
For the Respondent
:
Ms. Avnish Ahlawat SC, DTC, Mr. Uday
Singh Ahlawat, Ms. Tania Ahlawat, Mr.
Nitish Kumar Singh, Mr. Nitesh Kumar
Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam and Mr. Mohnish
Sehrawat, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J.
1.
This appeal lays a challenge to the order dated 05.10.2012 passed by
the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No.17192/2006 whereby the learned
Single Judge has allowed the writ petition filed by respondent/ Delhi
Transport Corporation (in short ‘Corporation’) challenging the orders dated
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
07.05.1997 and 11.02.1999 (impugned orders) passed by the learned
Presiding Officer: Industrial Tribunal-II, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi (Presiding
Officer) in OP No. 245/1993. The Presiding Officer vide the impugned
orders held that proper enquiry was not conducted by the Corporation and
thus he dismissed the approval application under Section 33(2) (b) of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (the Act) as the deceased employee - Pyare
Lal was not guilty of the misconduct regarding the unauthorised absence
because the absence period was treated as ‘leave without pay’.
2.
At the outset, we may state the employee Pyare Lal had expired and
the petition was filed against the legal representatives of the deceased Pyare
Lal, who are the appellants herein.
3.
The learned Single Judge while allowing the petition filed by the
Corporation has noted the relevant facts in as much the deceased employee
Pyare Lal was appointed as a driver by the Corporation on 23.05.1977. On
27.04.1979, the deceased employee was absent from the duty and was
accordingly cautioned. Similar was the position on 30.08.1984 and also on
25.09.1989 when he was again absent from 07.06.1989 to 28.08.1989. He
again absented from the duty on 20.05.1990 and was advised. He availed 61
days leave without pay for the period from January to April, 1991 and was
accordingly advised on 03.05.1991. In the year 1991 he availed 107 days
leave without pay for which the penalty of stoppage of next due increment
with cumulative effect was imposed.
In the month of February, 1993 the
deceased employee was issued a charge sheet as he was absent without
permission for 22 days, which amounts to misconduct.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
4.
The deceased employee did not reply to the charge sheet. He was
called to appear in the proceedings on 02.03.1993, but he did not join the
same. He was again informed vide letter dated 03.03.1993 to appear in the
enquiry on 09.03.1993, but he did not appear. Even on 10.03.1993 he was
intimated to appear in the proceedings scheduled on 16.03.1993. But on that
date also the deceased employee was absent. Finally, the Enquiry Officer
had submitted his report on 19.03.1993 wherein he proved the charges
against the deceased employee.
5.
After issuance of the show cause notice dated 23.03.1993, the penalty
of removal from service was imposed on the deceased employee on
27.04.1993.
On the said date, the respondent-corporation remitted one
month’s wages and filed an application under Section 33(2) (b) of the Act,
which was registered as OP No.245/1993. The Corporation produced the
record of the proceedings as well as the past record of the deceased
employee.
6.
A preliminary issue was framed by the Presiding Officer on the
validity of the domestic enquiry conducted by the Corporation, which
resulted in the order dated 07.05.1997 whereby the Presiding Officer has
held as under:“In this case, the applicant in support of its prayer for
granting removal of the respondent from its service to had
relief upon a departmental enquiry at fist instance and a
preliminary issue was framed about the validity of the
enquiry as the respondent had challenged the same. Since it
was for the applicant to establish that before ordering the
removal of the respondent form its service it had conducted
a proper enquiry and it having failed to adduce any
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
evidence it has to be held that no proper enquiry was held
by the applicant, therefore, preliminary issues decided
against the respondent.
However, in view of the fact that applicant had also prayed
for an opportunity for adducing evidence before this
tribunal to establish the alleged misconduct in the event of
the preliminary issue being decided against it has to be
given that opportunity. Accordingly, the following issues are
framed :1. Whether the respondent committed the misconduct for
which he was charge sheeted?
2. Relief.
Put up for evidence of the applicant on the issue framed
today by way of affidavit on 10.7.97.”
7.
The Presiding Officer while dismissing the application under Section
33(2) (b) of the Act vide order dated 11.02.1999, inter alia, held as under:“That management sole witness Sh. Ramesh Chand, on
whose report disciplinary proceedings were initiated
against the respondent, stated in his examination that the
respondent had remained absent from duty unauthorisedly
for the period in dispute. However, in his cross examination
this witness of the management admitted that the entire
period of absence of the respondent had been treated as
leave without pay. The witness stated that "It is correct that
the entire period of absence of 214 days had been treated as
leave without pay as mentioned in Ex. AW 1/1. The period
of absence of 22 days is included in the total period of 214
days. Similarly the period of absence of 107 days in the year
1991 was treated as "Leave Without Pay." These answers
given by the management's witness clearly establish that the
respondent was not guilty at all of any misconduct. It is now
well settled that if an employer treats the period of absence
of any employee as leave without pay there remains no
misconduct on the part of that employee. This has been so
held by Andhra Pradesh High Court in a judgment reported
in AIR 1976 A.P. 75. Therefore, the decision of the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
management for the removal of the respondent from its
service cannot be said to be bonafide and cannot be
accorded approval by this tribunal.”
8.
The learned Single Judge in the challenge made by the Corporation
while allowing the writ petition has in paragraph 5 onwards held as under:“5. The Respondent did not reply to the charge-sheet. He
was called for the domestic enquiry on the 2nd March, 1993
but he did not appear. Despite repeated intimation he did
not appear and finally on the basis of the report of the
enquiry officer a show cause notice was issued to the
Respondent on 23rd March, 1993. The Respondent did not
even reply to the said show cause notice and finally he was
removed from service on 27th April, 1973. He was
simultaneously remitted one month’s wages and an
application under Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 (in short the ID Act) was filed before the
learned Trial Court for approval of its action as an
industrial dispute concerning DTC workers for demand of
implementing Fourth Pay Commission’s report was pending
adjudication. The Respondent opposed the application and
challenged the validity of the enquiry report. A preliminary
issue regarding the validity of the domestic enquiry
conducted by the Petitioner was framed. The preliminary
issue was decided against the Petitioner vide order dated
7th May, 1992 and it was held that the enquiry was not fair
and just and contrary to the principles of natural justice.
However, the Petitioner was given opportunity to adduce
evidence before the Trial Court to establish the misconduct
of the Respondent. Thus, management produced its witness
Shri Ramesh Chand on whose report disciplinary enquiry
was conducted. AW1 Ramesh Chand tendered his evidence
by way of affidavit Ex.AW1/A and the documents AW1/1.
AW1 also placed on record the dates on which the
Respondent was absent in the form of leave statement. It
also stated that the enquiry officer had since retired from
the Corporation and the enquiry was conducted as per rules
and the principles of natural justice and despite sufficient
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
opportunity, the Respondent failed to defend himself or
appear before the enquiry officer. In the cross-examination
of AW1 it was admitted that the entire period of absence of
214 days has been treated as leave without pay as
mentioned in Ex.AW1/1. It was also stated that the period of
absence of 107 days in the year 1991 was also treated as
leave without pay. The learned Trial Court in view of the
admission of the witness that the entire period of absence of
214 days has been treated as leave without pay and even
period of absence of 107 days in the year 1991 was treated
as leave without pay, came to the conclusion that the
Respondent was not guilty at all of any misconduct.
6. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Madhya Pradesh
Vs. Harihar Gopal (supra) held:
“7. It was urged before the High Court on behalf of
the State that the order granting leave was only for
the purpose of regularizing the absence from duty
and for maintaining a true account of absence from
duty, and had not the effect of first sanctioning leave
to the respondent to which he was entitled, and then
removing him from service for absence from duty.
The High Court rejected this contention observing:
“……..when the leave was granted even though
belatedly, it had the effect of authorizing with
retrospective effect the petitioner’s (respondent’s)
absence from duty during the period for which it was
sanctioned. Having thus authorized the petitioner’s
(respondent’s) absence from duty, it was not open to
the State Government to proceed on the basis that
his absence was unauthorized.” These observations
proceed upon a misconception of the sequence in the
orders passed by the State Government and the true
effect of the order granting leave. The order
granting leave was made after the order terminating
the employment and it was made only for the
purpose of maintaining a correct record of the
duration of service, and adjustment of leave due to
the respondent and for regularizing his absence
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
from duty. Our attention has not been invited to any
rules governing the respondent’s service conditions
under which an order regularizing absence from
duty subsequent to termination of employment has
the effect of invalidating termination. Both the
orders, one terminating the employment of the
respondent, and the other granting leave are made
“by order and in the name of the Governor of
Madhya Pradesh”, and they are signed by L.B.
Sarje, Deputy Secretary to the Government of
Madhya
Pradesh,
General
Administration
Department. We are unable to hold that the
authority after terminating the employment of the
respondent intended to pass an order invalidating
the earlier order by sanctioning leave so that the
respondent was to be deemed not to have remained
absent from duty without leave duly granted.
8. There is another aspect of the case which also
does not appear to have been considered by the
High Court. The charge against the respondent was
that he had absented himself “without obtaining
leave in advance”. The Enquiry Officer
characterized the conduct of the respondent as
“irresponsible in extreme and can hardly be
justified.” The Enquiry Officer clearly intended that
in failing to report for duty and remaining absent
without obtaining leave, the respondent had acted in
manner irresponsible and unjustified. On the finding
of the Enquiry Officer that charge was proved and
the order, dated March 9, 1962, had no effect on the
charge that the respondent had remained absent
without obtaining leave in advance.”
7. Further in Delhi Transport Corporation Vs. Sardar Singh
(supra) their Lordships held:
“11. Great emphasis was laid by learned counsel for
the respondent- employee on the absence being
treated as leave without pay. As was observed by
this Court in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Harihar
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
Gopal 1969 (3) SLR 274 by a three-judge Bench of
this Court, even when an order is passed for treating
absence as leave without pay after passing an order
of termination that is for the purpose of maintaining
correct record of service. The charge in that case
was, as in the present case, absence without
obtaining leave in advance. The conduct of the
employees in this case is nothing but irresponsible in
extreme and can hardly be justified. The charge in
this case was misconduct by absence. In view of the
Governing Standing Orders unauthorized leave can
be treated as misconduct.
12. Conclusions regarding negligence and lack of
interest can be arrived at by looking into the period
of absence, more particularly, when same is
unauthorized. Burden is on the employee who claims
that there was no negligence and/or lack of interest
to establish it by placing relevant materials. Clause
(ii) of Para 4 of the Standing Order shows the
seriousness attached to habitual absence. In clause
(i) thereof, there is requirement of prior permission.
Only exception made is in case of sudden illness.
There also conditions are stipulated, nonobservance of which renders the absence
unauthorized.
13. The Tribunal proceeded in all these cases on the
basis as if the leave was sanctioned because of the
noted leave without pay. Treating as leave without
pay is not same as sanctioned or approved leave.”
8. Thus, in view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court,
even if the absence is treated as leave without pay, the same
does not absolve the employee of his misconduct of absence.
Thus, the learned Trial Court grossly erred in holding the
same to be not a misconduct.
9. Learned counsel for the Respondent has further stressed
that when the impugned award was passed the law laid
down by the Supreme Court in DTC Vs. Sardar Singh was
not applicable and thus the decision rendered was not
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
contrary the law. It may be noted that the decision of the
Trial Court is clearly contrary to the earlier decision of the
Supreme Court in case of State of M.P. Vs. Harihar Gopal
(supra) and thus this contention of the learned counsel for
the Respondent holds no ground. As regards the next
contention of the learned counsel for the Respondent that
the charges are vague, it may be noted that in the present
case a leave statement was placed on record. The dates on
which the Respondent was absent need not and could not
have been spelt out in the charge framed against the
Respondent. The same was enclosed and placed before the
Trial Court. Thus, there was sufficient notice to the
Respondent for the case he had to meet. The decision
rendered in Union of India & Ors. Vs. Gyan Chand Chattar
has no application to the facts of the case as in the said case
their Lordships were dealing with the charges of corruption
and in that respect their Lordships held that the serious
charges of corruption are required to be proved to the hilt
as it brings civil and criminal consequences upon the
employee concerned. In Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.
(supra) their Lordships held that when details were given in
the charge the High Court was wrong in coming to the
conclusion that the charges were vague and indefinite. In
Management of Northern Railway Cooperative Credit
Society Ltd. (supra) the charges against the Respondent
therein were to instigate and conspire to paralyse the
working of the society, disobedience of orders in not
attending for Medical Examination, taking part in the issue
and distribution of certain leaflets issued etc., thus it was
held that the charges were vague as no specific dates or
incidents were given.
10. In the present case the charges informed the period i.e.
the number of days the Respondent has been absent during
the year, hence the same cannot be said to be vague. In view
of the aforesaid discussion the order of termination by the
Petitioner does not suffer from any illegality and the
regularization of leave without pay is only for the purpose
of maintaining correct record of service which does not
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
interfere nor obliterate the order of dismissal from service.
11. As regards the contention of the learned counsel for the
Respondent regarding delay in filing the writ petition, it
may be noted that in writ petition, sufficient cause for delay
has been explained. Ordinarily, a writ petition filed after
three years should not be entertained though no period of
limitation is prescribed. However, where sufficient cause is
explained which in this case is due to negligence of the
counsel, a belated writ petition can be entertained. In
Devendra Swami (supra) it was held:
“5. Having heard the learned counsel for the
parties, we are satisfied that in the facts and
circumstances of this case, the Division Bench did
not err in condoning the delay in filing the appeal.
The lawyer engaged by the respondent Corporation
was holding the papers and did not inform the
Corporation of the decision in the writ petition. The
Corporation, having felt convinced of the default on
the part of the lawyer, removed him from the panel
of the Corporation and engaged another counsel
through whom the writ appeal was filed. Sufficient
cause for condoning the delay in filing the appeal
was made out. Discretion to condone delay under
Section 5 of the Limitation Act has been judiciously
exercised by the High Court, placing reasons on
record and is not open to interference by this
Court.”
12. In view of the aforesaid discussion, I find that the
impugned order dated 11th February, 1999 of the Trial
Court is contrary to the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. The same is set aside. The approval
application is decided in favour of the Petitioner. Petition is
disposed of accordingly.”
9.
It may stated here that the primary ground on which the Presiding
Officer has refused to grant the approval to the penalty of removal under
Section 33(2)(b) of the Act was essentially that the deceased employee was
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
not guilty of any misconduct. This according to the Presiding Officer is
because the period of the absence was decided as leave without pay, as such
there remains no misconduct on the part of the employee. The learned
Single Judge has by referring to the decisions of the Supreme Court in the
cases of State of Madhya Pradesh v. Harihar Gopal, 1969 SLR 274 and
Delhi Transport Corporation v. Sardar Singh, 2004 (6) SCALE 613,
wherein it is held even if the absence is treated as leave without pay, the
same does not absolve the employee of misconduct or lapses. In that sense,
the conclusion drawn by the Presiding Officer was contrary to the law laid
down by the Supreme Court.
10.
We agree with the said conclusion drawn by the learned Single Judge.
One of the submissions made on behalf of the deceased employee was that
the charges are vague.
In that regard, the learned Single Judge noted that
the dates on which deceased employee was absent, need not and could not
have been spelt out in the charges framed against him, and the same was
enclosed and placed before the Presiding Officer. It follows, there was
sufficient notice to the deceased employee on the charge he had to meet. It
was also held by the learned Single Judge that the charges contained the
information including the period i.e., the number of days on which the
deceased employee was absent during the year. In that sense also the charges
cannot be said to be vague.
11.
In view of the limited challenge made before the learned Single
Judge, to the order of the rejection of the application filed by the
Corporation under Section 33(2)(b) of the Act; we are of the view that the
learned Single Judge is justified in the facts of this case to set aside the order
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
passed by the Presiding Officer. Further the deceased employee was given
proper opportunity to defend himself and merely because the leave was
without pay shall not mean that, the leave which was not sanctioned is not a
misconduct.
12.
No interference is called for with the impugned order passed by the
learned Single Judge.
13.
The appeal being bereft of merit is dismissed.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JULY 03, 2026
M
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 550/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review