Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:38905
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Execution Petition No.1204 of 2024
Reserved on: 07.08.2026
Decided on: 11.09.2026
Uploaded on: 11.09.2026
____________________________________________________________
Puran Chand
...Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. and others
...Respondents
____________________________________________________________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the petitioner:
Mr. V.D. Khidtta and Mr. Nishant
Khidtta, Advocates.
For the respondents:
Ms. Priyanka Chauhan, Deputy
Advocate
General,
for
respondents No.1 to 9-State.
Mr. Deepinder Singh Patwalia and
Mr.
Vikrant
Thakur,
Senior
Advocates with Mr. Shubham
Guleria, Advocate, for respondent
No.10.
Mr. Shiv Pal Manhans, Senior
Panel Counsel for respondent
No.11.
Mr. Sunil Mohan Goel, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Paras Dhaulta,
Advocate, for respondent No.12.
Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge
The petitioner by way of present petition is
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:38905
seeking implementation of the order dated 08.01.2020,
corrected on 10.01.2020 and modified on 13.11.2020,
passed in CWPIL No.135 of 2017, titled, Court on its
own motion vs. State of H.P. & others along with
connected matter in letter and spirit with further direction
to the respondents to pay ₹15,000/- in hand salary per
month along with arrears with effect from 20.01.2020
with 9% interest throughout and further penal interest at
the rate of 15% throughout, as this Court may deem fit,
just, and proper.
2.
This Court vide order dated 08.01.2020, while
disposing of the writ petitions, i.e. CWPIL No.135 of 2017
and CWP No. 2347 of 2017, had directed respondent
No.10
(GVK
Emergency
Management
and
Research
Institute) to enhance the take home salary of each
employee to the tune of ₹15,000 per month (wrongly
typed as ₹1500/- per month which was corrected on
10.01.2020) w.e.f. 20.01.2020, till the dispute is resolved
by the appropriate authority. This enhanced salary is to
be paid to the Pilots (Drivers) and Emergency Medical
Technicians
(Pharmacists)
(‘EMTs’)
employed
with
2026:HHC:38905
respondent No.10 till the dispute is resolved by the
appropriate authority. Further, respondent No.10 was
directed to pay salary to its employees only by cheque by
remitting the same to their bank accounts. In case, there
are no bank accounts of the employees, the same be
opened at the earliest and thereafter their salaries be
remitted to their bank accounts. The petitioner and other
employees
of
respondent
No.10
were
directed
to
approach the competent authority/appropriate labour
authority under the Minimum Wages Act within three
weeks from the date of passing the order, if not already
approached, and thereafter, the competent authority/
appropriate labour authority was directed to decide the
case of the employees of respondent No.10 within six
months, preferably by or before 30.06.2020.
3.
Since there was a typographical mistake in
paragraph 19 of the judgment to the effect that ₹1500/was recorded instead of ₹15,000/-, the said order was
corrected, vide order dated 10.01.2020. Further, vide
order
dated
13.11.2020,
the
earlier
order
dated
08.01.2020, passed by the Court was clarified/rectified to
2026:HHC:38905
the effect that the State Government has to pay
₹15,000/- per month to the Captains of Janani Express102 also, at par with the Pilots and Emergency Medical
Technicians (EMTs) of National Ambulance Service-108,
from the date, as mentioned in para 19 of the order,
dated 08.01.2020, i.e. with effect from 20.01.2020 within
a period of three weeks.
4.
The petitioner has averred in the execution
petition that the application/petition under Sections 20
and 21 of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 was preferred
before
the
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate-cum-competent
authority/appropriate authority, Shimla District, Shimla,
during the second week of June, 2020 for determination of
the minimum wages under the Minimum Wages Act. The
said authority has passed the final order on 30.01.2021,
whereby, respondent No.10 has only been directed to pay
the minimum wages and the differential amount of
overtime w.e.f. 01.05.2015, as calculated in Annexure-C
appended with the order.
5.
The petitioner and respondent No.10 feeling
aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforesaid order
2026:HHC:38905
dated 30.01.2021 passed by the appropriate authority
have preferred the writ petitions before this Court. The
writ petition preferred by respondent No.10-Company is
CWP No.2094 of 2021 and writ petition filed by the
petitioner-Union is CWP No.6433 of 2021. The petitionerUnion is aggrieved by the order only to the extent that
the State Government, along with the Company, should
have also been made liable, jointly and severally, to pay
all the benefits and the relief claimed by the petitionerUnion. The petitioner-Union during the pendency of the
writ petition, had pointed out that respondent No.10 has
not paid the benefit of minimum of ₹15,000/- in hand
salary per month to the workers of the petitioner-Union,
as directed by this Court vide order dated 08.01.2020,
which order was corrected on 10.01.2020 and modified on
13.11.2020.
6.
This Court had passed an order on 30.03.2021
directing the parties to file their respective calculations to
indicate the payments made therein. In compliance with
the aforesaid order dated 30.03.2021, passed by the
Division Bench of this Court, the petitioner-Union had filed
2026:HHC:38905
the calculations in the form of an application in which, by
way of averments and salary slips, it was demonstrated
that the workers of the ambulance service were not being
paid the minimum ₹15,000/- as in hand salary per month,
as per the direction given by this Court. Respondent
No.10-Company has not complied with the order w.e.f.
20.01.2020 till 15.01.2022, and now M/S Medswan
Foundations (Respondent No.12) w.e.f. 16.01.2022, till
date is still not complying with the order/direction given
by this Court to pay a minimum of ₹15,000/- in hand
salary per month to the workers of the petitioner-Union
and thus, the petitioner sought direction to execute the
aforesaid orders.
7.
Respondent No.10-Company has filed personal
affidavit, wherein it has been averred that in compliance
with the order passed by this Court, it has revised the
salary of its employees to ₹15,000/- per month on a Cost
to Company (CTC) basis, which included the employer's
contributions towards statutory dues, such as Provident
Fund,
Employee
State
Insurance
(ESI),
and
other
applicable deductions. After deducting the said statutory
2026:HHC:38905
deductions, the actual net amount disbursed to each
employee came to approximately ₹11,545/- per month.
The
total
financial
outgo
per
employee
on
the
respondent's part was indeed ₹15,000/- per month, and
there was no reduction or deviation from the enhanced
compensation
as
directed.
Respondent
No.10
has
maintained full compliance and transparency in wage
disbursement and the same has been made through bank
transfers to employees' accounts. There was no willful or
deliberate non-compliance with the order of the Court.
The
payment
of
salary
on
CTC
basis
with
lawful
deductions was undertaken in good faith and in the
understanding that the order required enhancement of
monthly
employee
compensation
to
₹15,000/-
per
employee, inclusive of all statutory components. It has
further been submitted that respondent No.10 has
disbursed a total amount of ₹31,54,69,908/- from January,
2020 to January, 2022. Thereafter, the additional affidavit
has also been filed, wherein it has been averred that
respondent No.10 has ceased operation across the State
of Himachal Pradesh w.e.f. 15.01.2022. It has
further
2026:HHC:38905
been submitted that this Court had directed that a salary
of ₹15,000/- per month be paid to the workmen and the
deponent has complied with the said direction and the
chart depicting the said compliance was also drawn.
8.
the
The petitioner has filed the counter affidavit to
additional
affidavit
filed
by
respondent
No.10-
Company and has not denied the factum of payment of
amount as per the chart shown in the additional affidavit.
9.
We have heard the learned counsel for the
parties and also perused the record carefully.
10.
Before adverting to the submissions made at
the Bar, it would be relevant to take note of paras No.19
and 20 of the order dated 08.01.2020 passed by this
Court which are reproduced hereunder:“19. In view of the facts and circumstances of the
case, we direct respondent No. 10 to enhance the
take home salary of each employee to the tune of
₹1500/- per month w.e.f. 20th January, 2020. This
enhanced salary shall be paid to the Pilots and EITs
employed with respondent No. 10 till the dispute is
resolved by the appropriate Authority. Respondent
No. 10 is further directed to pay salary to its
employees only by cheque by remitting the same to
their bank accounts. In case, there are no bank
accounts of the employees, the same be opened at
the earliest and thereafter, their salaries be remitted
to their bank accounts.
2026:HHC:38905
20. The employees of respondent No. 10 are
directed
to
approach
the
competent
Authority/appropriate Labour Authority under the
Minimum Wages Act within three weeks from today,
if not already approached and thereafter, the
competent Authority/appropriate Labour Authority is
directed to decide the case of the employees of
respondent No.10 within six months, preferably by or
before 30th June, 2020.”
11.
Since there was a typographical mistake in
paragraph 19 with respect to the take home salary of
each employee, which was wrongly recorded ₹1500/- per
month, the same was corrected as ₹15,000/- per month
as per order dated 10.01.2020.
12.
A perusal of the aforesaid order clearly reveals
that respondent No.10 was directed to enhance the take
home salary of each employee to the tune of ₹15,000 per
month, w.e.f. 20.1.2020 and further it was mentioned in
unequivocal terms that the enhanced salary shall be paid
to the Pilots and EMTs employed with respondent No.10
till the dispute is resolved by the appropriate authority.
Admittedly the appropriate authority has passed an order
on 30.01.2021 (Annexure E-2), which is now subject
matter in the writ petitions preferred by the union of the
employees as well as by
respondent No.10. This Court
2026:HHC:38905
has only to adjudicate upon the compliance with the
directions passed by this Court. As per the reply filed by
respondent No.10, the take home salary being paid to
each of the employees is ₹12,908/- per month after
making deductions. The chart depicting the amount
mentioned in the additional affidavit filed by respondent
No.10, is reproduced hereunder:Component
Amount (P.M)
Part A
Basic
4,710
HRA
2,355
Conveyance
Attendance
Allowance
Interim Relief
2,568
Shift Spread Over 2,275
Allowance
Gross
12,908
Part B
Percentage of the component
from Gross reflected in payslip
EPF
1,372
ESI
=(12908-HRA)=10355*13%
Employer Contribution=1372
Employee Contribution of
Rupees 1266 deducted & it
reflects in payslip.
=(12908*3.25%)=420-Employer
Contribution
Employee Contribution of
Rupees 97 is deducted every
month & it reflects in Payslip.
2026:HHC:38905
Gratuity
4.8% on basic
GPAP
Accidental Insurance
GTLI
Life Insurance
Salary Per Month
13.
15,000
A perusal of the chart clearly reveals that the
total salary per month comes to ₹15,000/-, however the
gross salary paid to the employee is ₹12,908/-.
14.
Learned counsel representing the petitioner
vehemently argued that since this Court had given
direction to enhance the take home salary of each
employee to the tune of ₹15,000/- per month, w.e.f.
20.01.2020, respondent No.10 was under obligation to
pay the amount of ₹15,000/- per month as take home
salary and not to deduct any amount.
15.
On the other hand, the learned senior counsel
representing respondent No.10 argued that the cost to
company is actually the total amount being paid by it
which is ₹15000/- per month. However, if the order under
execution is perused, this Court had given direction to
respondent No.10-Company to enhance the take home
salary of each employee to the tune of ₹15000/- per
2026:HHC:38905
month w.e.f. 20.01.2020, till the dispute is resolved by the
appropriate authority. The take home salary would be the
actual spendable cash an employee receives each month
after deductions like provident fund, professional tax, and
income tax etc. Thus, the plea taken by the learned
senior counsel for the Company that cost incurred by the
Company is ₹15000/- per month cannot be said to have
complied with the directions sought to be executed.
16.
No doubt, the amount which is statutorily
deducted towards EPF, ESI and Gratuity will ultimately be
received by an employee, except an amount of ₹15/- and
₹58/- deducted towards accidental insurance and life
insurance, but it is the statutorily obligation on the part of
respondent No.10-Company to pay this amount and it
cannot be construed that this amount shall also be
included in the take home salary. Take home salary would
be the actual amount credited in the account of an
employee after a month after all taxes and statutory
deductions are subtracted from his/her gross earnings.
17.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that
since respondent No.10-Company was running the affairs
2026:HHC:38905
till 15.01.2022, the Company is liable to pay the amount
till that date. However, the said contention cannot be
accepted in view of the specific direction given by this
Court, while disposing of the writ petition on 08.01.2020
that the enhanced salary be paid to the employees by
respondent No.10-Company till the dispute is resolved by
the appropriate authority. Once the appropriate authority
has now decided the matter on 30.01.2021, respondent
No.10-Company
was
liable
to
pay
the
amount
of
₹15,000/- per month from 20.01.2020 till 30.01.2021. It is
not in dispute that respondent No.10 as well as the Union
of the employees have preferred the writ petitions before
this Court and the petitioner shall be entitled to the
amount as per the order to be passed by this Court in the
writ petitions. This Court has only to see the compliance
with the order under execution till 30.01.2021, when the
order was passed by the competent authority as directed
by this Court. So far as the liability of respondent No.12 is
concerned, that is not the subject matter of the present
execution petition for the reason that this Court is only
confining to adjudicate the dispute, which was between
2026:HHC:38905
respondent
No.10-Company
and
its
employees
for
respondent
till
30.01.2021.
18.
Learned
counsel
No.10-
Company vehemently argued that since the definition of
take home salary has not been defined, respondent
No.10-Company as per its understanding and the import
of the order passed by this Court, which is sought to be
executed has rightly made the deductions and the total
cost to company per employee comes to ₹15000/-. No
doubt, the definition of take home salary has not been
given, but once this Court had given the specific direction
to respondent No.10-Company to enhance the take home
salary of each employee to the tune of ₹15000/- per
month, the statutory deductions made by respondent
No.10-Company cannot be included in the take home
salary, as the said order does not give respondent No.10
the said liberty, nor any application was filed for making
the said deductions or any clarification was sought.
19.
Consequently, the present execution petition is
allowed and it is held that respondent No.10-Company
shall pay take home salary of ₹15000/- per month to each
2026:HHC:38905
of
the
employee
with
effect
from
20.01.2020
till
30.01.2021 within two months from today. So far as the
amount which has been paid by respondent No.10Company to its employees up to 15 th January, 2022 is
concerned, which is for an excessive period as their
liability was only till the date of decision i.e. 30.01.2021
would be adjusted as per the order to be passed by this
Court in the writ petitions preferred by respondent No.10Company and its employees. No order as to costs.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
( G.S. Sandhawalia )
Chief Justice
11th September, 2026
(Anurag)
( Jiya Lal Bhardwaj )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review