Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
CR No. 91 of 2026
Decided on : 28.9.2026
Puran Chand & others
Versus
… Petitioners
Gian Chand & others
…Respondents
_____________________________ _____ _________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? yes
___________________________________________________
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Sunil Mohan Goel, Senior
Advocate, assisted by Mr.
Raman Jamalta, Advocate.
For the Respondents :
Mr. Kiran Kumar, Advocate,
for respondents No. 1(a) to 1(e)
and 2.
Mr. S.S. Rathore, Advocate, for
respondent No. 3.
Virender Singh, Judge
Petitioners Puran Chand and others have filed
the present petition, under Section 115 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, against the judgment dated 12.9.2025,
passed by the learned District Judge Kullu, (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the First Appellate Court’), in Civil Appeal
No.40 of 2024, titled as, ‘Puran Chand and others versus
Gian Chand and others’.
2.
Vide judgment dated 12.9.2025, the learned First
Appellate Court has dismissed the appeal, preferred by
the
petitioners, affirming the order dated 18.9.2024,
passed by the learned Senior Civil Judge, Lahaul and
Spiti at Kullu, (hereinafter referred to as, ‘the trial
Court’), in Civil Suit No. 21 of 2023, titled as, ‘Gian
Chand & anr. versus Puran Chand & ors.’.
3.
By way of order dated 18.9.2024, the learned
trial Court has dismissed the application, under Order 7
Rule 11 CPC, read with Section 151 CPC, moved by the
petitioners, in the said suit.
4.
Parties to the lis are hereinafter referred to by the
learned trial Court, as referred to, by the learned trial
Court.
5.
Brief facts leading to filing of the present petition,
before this Court, are that
plaintiffs Gian Chand and
Pinku have filed the suit for declaration, against the
defendants to the effect that father and grandfather of
the plaintiffs died intestate, leaving behind the plaintiffs
as his legal heirs, and after his death, the plaintiffs have
inherited the land comprised in Khasra No. 941/727,
kita no. 112/277, situated in Mohal Haat, Patwar Circle,
Bajaura, Kanungo Circle, and tehsil Bhuntar, District
Kullu, HP, (hereinafter referred to as, ‘the suit land’),
and the Will No. 95, dated 15.2.1990, purported to have
been executed by late Shri Ghanthu, in favour of Tej
Ram, predecessor-in-interest of the defendants, is forged
and
fictitious document, having been procured and
manipulated by Tej Ram, in connivance with the
marginal witnesses.
5.1
The plaintiffs have also challenged mutation No.
468 dated 31.7.1990, attested on the basis of mutation
No. 2158, attested in favour of defendants, after the
death of Tej Ram, qua the suit land.
Further, the
mortgage of the part of the suit land by defendant No. 1,
in favour of defendant No. 4, is also prayed to be
declared as null and void, with a consequential relief of
permanent
prohibitory
injunction,
restraining
the
defendants from alienating or creating any charge over
the suit land.
5.2
The said suit has been filed on the ground that
the suit land was earlier owned and possessed by Shri
Ghanthu Ram, as per Jamabandi for the year 2013-14.
Ghanthu Ram was having two sons, namely Gian
Chand, plaintiff No. 1 and
Khajanu, the father of
plaintiff No. 2. Ghanthu died intestate, leaving behind
plaintiff No. 1 and Khajanu, as his LRs.
5.3
After the death of Ghanthu, the suit land has
been inherited by the aforesaid two sons, and after the
death of Khajanu, his share in the suit land has been
inherited by plaintiff No.2, being his son. After the death
of Ghanthu, the plaintiffs are enjoying the usufruct of
the suit land peacefully and without any interference.
5.4
It is the further case of the plaintiffs that in the
last week of September 2021, the defendants started
causing unlawful interference, over the suit land, by
proclaiming that they have become the owners of the
same, on the basis of some alleged Will and tried to
interfere in the possession of the plaintiffs. Thereafter,
the plaintiffs visited the Patwari and obtained the
relevant documents. After perusing the same, they came
to know about the fact that Tej Ram, the predecessor-ininterest
of
the
defendants,
had
manipulated
and
fabricated Will No. 95 dated 15.2.1990. Thereafter, they
had approached the defendants and apprised them that
the said document has been forged by them, upon
which, the defendants assuredly agreed to get the same
cancelled.
5.5
Thereafter, the plaintiffs enjoyed the usufruct of
the suit land peacefully and without any interference,
from any quarter, under the impression that the
defendants might have done the needful, as promised by
them, but to the utter surprise of the plaintiffs, on
20.3.2023, defendants again came to the suit land and
proclaimed that they would obtain the possession
forcibly from the plaintiffs.
5.6
On 21.3.2023, the plaintiffs procured their
revenue papers, from the revenue agency and came to
know that Tej Ram, the predecessor-in-interest of
defendants No. 1 to 3, has manipulated and fabricated
the forged and fictitious Will No. 95, dated 15.2.1990, in
order to grab the suit land.
5.7
Highlighting the physical and mental incapacity
of Ghanthu Ram, the plaintiffs have further pleaded that
the eviction proceedings were initiated against Ghanthu
Ram
by
the
Revenue
Ghanthu Ram submitted
Department,
wherein,
said
all the documents, by putting
his thumb impression, as he could not sign any paper,
being illiterate.
5.8
According to the plaintiffs, the suit land was
allotted to Ghanthu Ram as Nautor land, vide Patta No.
47/7, dated 8.6.1976, and mutation to this effect was
attested on 5.2.1981.
5.9
Another fact to challenge the Will has also been
pleaded that Ghanthu Ram was living with his family,
i.e. the plaintiffs, at Gram Panchayat, Bajaura. In this
regard, the plaintiffs have relied upon the copy of the
Pariwar Register, according to which, he never lived with
Tej Ram or his family members, at any point of time.
5.10
It is the further case of the plaintiffs that Tej
Ram was having no relations with Ghanthu, nor
Tej
Ram or his family ever rendered any kind of service
towards him. Ghanthu Ram was living with plaintiffs
and he was looked
after by the plaintiffs, till his last
breath.
5.11
The plaintiffs further pleaded that after the death
of Ghanthu, Tej Ram got sanctioned
mutation No. 88
dated 31.7.1990, in his favour, and after the death of Tej
Ram, defendant also got sanctioned mutation No. 2158
attested, in their favour, and defendant No. 1 got the
suit land mortgaged with defendant No. 4. All such
mutations and mortgage are pleaded to be wrong, illegal,
null and void.
5.12
According to the plaintiffs, after procuring all the
documents, plaintiffs again asked the defendants to get
the mutation attested, on the basis of forged and
fictitious Will, cancelled. But, the defendants since
4.3.2023, had started threatening to dispossess them
from the suit land.
5.13
According to the plaintiffs, the cause of action
had accrued to them, for filing the suit in the month of
September, 2021, when, the defendants started causing
interference over the suit land by proclaiming that they
had become owners of the suit land, on the basis of the
Will, and thereafter they admitted to get the revenue
entries corrected, but since 20.3.2023, they had started
again causing unlawful interference in the suit land, and
lastly on 4.3.2023, when, defendants have flatly refused
to admit the claim of the plaintiffs.
5.14
On the basis of the above facts, a prayer has
been made to decree the suit.
6.
In the said suit, the defendants have moved an
application, under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC, for
rejection of the plaint, on the grounds that the suit is
barred by limitation; and the plaintiffs have no cause of
action to file the present suit, as the plaintiffs have every
knowledge and notice of mutation No. 468 dated
4/1/1991 and they were also aware about the fact that
mutation qua the suit land was attested and accepted,
in the presence of witnesses and plaintiff No. 1.
According to the defendants, the plaintiffs were having
the knowledge about rapat No. 438, entered in the
revenue records, qua the possession of said Tej Ram
over the suit land.
6.1
According to the
defendants, plaintiffs and
entire family had every knowledge and notice of the Will
in question. The suit land is stated to have been
acquired by NHPC for the construction of Bridge, vide
award No. 6 of 2002, dated 19.1.2002 and notice qua
the same was published, in the year 2001, calling for the
objection against the said acquisition. The compensation
had already been paid to defendant No.1 and father of
defendant Nos. 2 and 3. However, the plaintiffs had not
objected to the said acquisition.
6.2
The objections have also been made on the
ground that plaintiff No. 1 had
stood surety for
defendant No. 1 before non-defendant No. 4 for the loan
sanction, on the suit land.
6.3
Asserting the knowledge of the Will in question, a
prayer has been made that the suit of the plaintiffs is
hopelessly barred by limitation, as the same has been
filed after 32 years, from the date of
sanction of
mutation No. 468 dated 4.4.1991.
6.4
Lastly, the defendants have also pleaded that the
plaintiffs have no cause of action to file the present suit,
as they have every knowledge about Rapat No. 438,
entered in the revenue record, qua the possession of said
Tej Ram, over the suit land.
7.
The application has been contested by the
plaintiffs by filing the reply, in which, they have taken
the
preliminary
objections
qua
the
fact
that
the
application is not maintainable, as Tej Ram, the
predecessor-in-interest of the defendants, was not at all
related to Ganthu, in any manner. As such, according to
them, the question of execution of the Will by Ganthu in
favour of Tej Ram, does not arise. According to the
defendants, the said document is a result of fraud. The
application is stated to have been filed, just to prolong
the litigation.
7.1
On merits, the factual position, as mentioned in
the application has not been disputed and according to
them, suit is not barred by limitation. The plaintiffs have
every knowledge of mutation No. 468 dated 4/4/1991.
Relying upon the contents of the plaint, a prayer has
been made to dismiss the application.
8.
The learned trial court has dismissed the said
application, vide order dated 8.1.2024, by holding that
the defendants could not put forward any ground to
reject the plaint, under the provisions of Order 7 Rule 11
of the CPC.
9.
The
said
order
has
unsuccessfully
been
challenged by the defendants, before the learned First
Appellate Court.
10.
Aggrieved from the order, passed by the
learned First Appellate Court, now the defendants are
before this Court, by way of the present revision.
11.
The order passed by the learned trial Court, as
upheld by the learned First Appellate Court has been
challenged, mainly on the grounds, as taken in the
application, under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC.
12.
According to the defendants, suit of the plaintiffs
is liable to be rejected, at the threshold, and both the
Courts below have ignored the admitted and disputed
facts that the stale suit has been filed, after 32 years.
According to them, the declaration or cancellation of the
document should have been filed within a period of three
years, from the date of right of accrual or knowledge of
the fact, whereas, the Will was registered, in the year
1990 and the mutation was entered, in the year 1991
and the award of acquisition of the land was passed in
the year 2002.
13.
Highlighting the registration of the Will, the order
passed by the learned trial Court, as upheld by
the
learned First Appellate Court, has been assailed on the
ground that the registration of the
Will carries a
presumption of genuineness, under the Evidence Act.
14.
On the basis of the above facts, Mr. Sunil Mohan
Goel, Senior Advocate, assisted by Mr. Raman Jamalta,
Advocate, appearing for defendants No. 1 to 3 has
prayed that the present petition may be allowed, by
setting aside the order passed by the learned trial Court,
as upheld by the learned First Appellate Court and the
plaint may kindly be rejected, under the provisions of
Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC, by allowing the application.
15.
Per
contra,
Mr.
Kiran
Kumar,
Advocate,
appearing for the plaintiffs has supported the orders
passed by the learned trial Court, as upheld by the
learned First Appellate Court, on the ground, that it is
no longer res- integra that the question of limitation is a
mixed question of law and facts, which, cannot be
adjudicated under the provisions of Order 7 Rule 11 of
the CPC.
16.
Asserting the fact that the plaintiffs have every
cause of action to file the suit,
from the date of
knowledge of the Will, according to the plaintiffs, the suit
filed by them is within limitation.
17.
On the basis of above facts, a prayer has been
made to dismiss the petition.
18.
The defendants are before this Court, under
Section 115 of the CPC. The scope of interference, under
Section 115 CPC, as well as, under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, has elaborately been discussed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in a case titled as, ‘Bhudev
Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & anr. versus Ranajit
Ghoshal & ors.’, 2025 INSC 175. Relevant paragraphs
53, 54 and 55 of the judgment are reproduced as under:
53. We are a bit disappointed with the manner in which
the High Court dealt with the present litigation, more
particularly while deciding the revision application filed
by the appellants herein against the order passed by the
executing court. All that the High Court has said in one
line is that it did not find any jurisdictional error in the
order passed by the executing court ordering arrest,
detention in a civil prison and attachment of the property
of the appellants. We fail to understand, why the High
Court was not able to see the gross error in the order
passed by the executing court, be it called an error of law
or a jurisdictional error. Undoubtedly, the High Court in
exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under Article
227 of the Constitution must ascertain before interfering
with any order passed by a subordinate court or tribunal
whether the same suffers from any jurisdictional error. At
times in litigation like the one on hand, the court should
be guided by its conscience, more particularly keeping in
mind the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case
and not strictly go by the term “jurisdictional error”. It is
very easy for the High Court to say that there is no
jurisdictional error and, therefore, no interference is
warranted but before saying so, the High Court should be
mindful of the consequences that would follow like arrest,
detention in civil prison and attachment of property.
54. What is a jurisdictional error has been the subject of
a legion of illuminating judicial decisions. In this case,
however, we need concern ourselves with only one aspect
of that matter and it is enough for us to refer in this
connection to the decision of the Privy Council in the case
of Joy Chand Lal Babu v. Kamalaksha Chaudhury, AIR
1949 PC 239, where Sir John Beaumont, delivering the
judgment of the Board, observed inter alia as follows:“although error in a decision of a Subordinate Court does
not by itself involve that the subordinate Court has acted
illegally or with material irregularity so as to justify
interference in revision under Subsection (c). nevertheless
if the erroneous decision results in the subordinate Court
exercising a jurisdiction, not vested in it by law or failing
to exercise a jurisdiction so vested, a case for revision
arises under Sub-section (a) or Sub-section (b) and Sub
section (c) can be ignored.”
55. If, therefore, an error, be it an error of fact or of law,
is such that the erroneous decision has resulted in the
subordinate Court or tribunal exercising jurisdiction, not
vested in it by law, or in its having failed to exercise
jurisdiction, vested in it by law, that will come within the
scope of Section 115 of the Code or, for the matter of
that, of Article 227 of the Constitution, as the case may
be. This error may have resulted from a violation of rules
of natural justice, by taking into consideration matters
which are extraneous and irrelevant, or by substituting
judicial consideration by bias, based on suspicion, arising
from those extraneous matters or from any other cause
whatsoever but if it has affected the assumption or
exercise of jurisdiction, as envisaged above, it will be a
jurisdictional error for purposes of the above Article.”
19.
Being guided by the above decision, now this
Court would proceed further to ascertain the fact
whether the application, under Order 7 Rule 11 of the
CPC has wrongly been dismissed, by the learned trial
Court?
20.
At the time of deciding the said application, no
amount of evidence or merit of the controversy can be
examined, as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in a
case titled as, Eldeco Housing and Industries Ltd.
versus Ashok Vidyarthi & others, reported in 2023 Live
Law SC1033. Relevant paragraph-26 of the judgment is
reproduced as under:
“26. However, the fact remains that all the aforesaid
documents, referred to by the respondent in support of
his plea for rejection of the plaint, cannot be considered
at this stage, as these are not part of the record with the
Court filed under Order VII Rule 11 CPC. As noticed
above, no amount of evidence or merits of the controversy
can be examined at the stage of decision of the
application, under Order VII Rule 11 CPC. Hence, in our
view, the impugned order of the High Court, passed in
the Review Application deserves to be set aside. Ordered
accordingly.”
21.
In
this
case,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
defendants has relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in a case titled as, Raghwendra Sharan
Singh versus Ram Prasanna Singh (dead) by legal
representatives’
reported
in
(16)
SCC
601.
Relevant paragraph 9 of the judgment is reproduced as
under:
“9. Now, so far as the application on behalf of the original
plaintiff and even the observations made by the learned
trial Court as well as the High Court that the question
with respect to the limitation is a mixed question of law
and facts, which can be decided only after the parties
lead the evidence is concerned, as observed and held by
this
Court
in
the
cases
of
Sham
Lal
alias Kuldip (supra); N.V. Srinivas Murthy (supra) as well
as in the case of Ram Prakash Gupta (supra), considering
the averments in the plaint if it is found that the suit is
clearly barred by law of limitation, the same can be
rejected in exercise of powers under Order 7 Rule 11(d) of
the CPC.”
22.
In view of paragraph-4 of the plaint,
the
plaintiffs have pleaded that in the last week of
September 2021, the defendants had started causing
unlawful interference in the suit land, by proclaiming
themselves to be the owners of the suit land, on the
basis of some alleged Will, and according to the
plaintiffs, thereafter, they had contacted the revenue
officials and then, came to know about the sanctioning
of mutation No. 95 dated 15.02.1990.
23.
Admittedly, in para-6 of the plaint, the plaintiffs
have again stated that on 20.03.2023, when, the
defendants again came to the suit land and proclaimed
themselves to be the owners of the suit land, then the
plaintiffs, after obtaining the revenue papers, came to
know that Tej Ram, the predecessor-in-interest of the
defendants No. 1 to 3, manipulated and fabricated the
Will No. 95 dated 15.02.1990.
24.
At the best, it can be said that the present case
is a classical example of loose drafting, as the knowledge
of the Will No. 95 has been pleaded twice, firstly, in the
month of September, 2021 and thereafter, in the month
of March, 2023.
25.
Considering the low legal literacy of the Indian
masses, the said fact, to the considered opinion of this
Court, is not fatal for the case of the plaintiffs,
warranting
the
interference,
that
too,
under
the
provisions of Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC.
26.
At the best, it can be said that the plaintiffs came
to know about the Will, allegedly executed by Ghanthu
in the month of September, 2021. As such, the suit,
which has been filed by them, in the month of April,
2023, cannot be said to be barred by limitation, from
any stretch of imagination.
27.
In this regard, the plaintiffs have pleaded the
cause of action in paragraph 17 of the plaint, which is
reproduced as under:
“ 17. That the cause of action arose in favour of the
plaintiffs firstly in the month of September, 2021 when
the defendants started causing interference over the suit
land by proclaiming that they have become owners of the
suit land on the basis of alleged will and thereafter they
admitted to get the revenue entries corrected, but since
20th day of March, 2023 they again started causing
unlawful interference in the suit land and lastly on 1 day
of April, st 2023 when the defendants have flatly refused
to admit the claim of the plaintiffs within the jurisdiction
of this Hon’ble Court and as such, this Hon’ble Court has
got jurisdiction to try and decide the present suit.”
28.
The term "cause of action" has nowhere been
defined in the CPC, however, the cause of action means
a bundle of essential facts, which are required to be
established by the plaintiffs to succeed in a lis.
29.
Bare reading of the plaint nowhere leads this
Court to conclude that the suit of the plaintiffs is barred
by limitation. Moreover, the question of limitation is
mixed question of law and facts, as held by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in ‘Babasaheb Ramdas Shirole & ors.
versus Rohit Enterprises & ors’, reported in 2025 (4)
CCC 346. Relevant paragraphs 7 to 9 of the judgment is
reproduced as under:
“7. As regards the first aspect, it is well settled that
limitation is a mixed question of law and fact and unless
the same is patently and unequivocally clear, it cannot
form a ground under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC for
non-suiting a plaintiff. In the case on hand, perusal of the
plaint indicates that the plaintiffs claimed that the cause
of action arose in October 2023, when defendant No. 1
started quarrelling with them for the first time, showing
his true colors by trying to grab the suit properties and
interfering with their peaceful possession over the same.
8. In the light of this averment, the High Court clearly
erred in jumping to the conclusion that there was a delay
of 10 years on the part of the plaintiffs in assailing the
sale deed executed in the year 2013. The High Court lost
sight of the fact that it was the plaintiffs' case that the
said sale deed was only a sham and was coupled with a
development agreement executed on the same day.
9. These were issues that required to be examined on
evidence and could not have been summarily rejected by
the High Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Order VII
Rule 11 of the CPC.”
30.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in a case titled as,
‘Sopan Sukhdev Sable and others versus Assistant
Charity Commissioner and others’ reported in 2004 (3)
SCC 137, has given the directions as to how the
pleadings
are
to
be
considered
for
deciding
the
application, under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC. Relevant
paragraph 15 of the judgment is reproduced as under:
“15.
There
cannot
be
any
compartmentalization,
dissection, segregation and inversions of the language of
various paragraphs in the plaint. If such a course is
adopted it would run counter to the cardinal canon of
interpretation according to which a pleading has to be
read as a whole to ascertain its true import. It is not
permissible to cull out a sentence or a passage and to
read it out of the context in isolation. Although it is the
substance and not merely the form that has to be looked
into, the pleading has to be construed as it stands
without addition or subtraction or words or change of its
apparent grammatical sense. The intention of the party
concerned is to be gathered primarily from the tenor and
terms of his pleadings taken as a whole. At the same time
it should be borne in mind that no pedantic approach
should be adopted to defeat justice on hair-splitting
technicalities.”
31.
Considering all these facts, there is no occasion
for this Court to interfere with the well-reasoned order,
passed by the learned trial Court, which has rightly
been upheld by the learned First Appellate Court.
32.
With these observations, the present petition is
dismissed.
33.
The parties to the lis, through their counsel, are
directed to appear before the learned Trial Court, on
12.10.2026.
34.
The pending application(s), if any, are also
disposed of.
35.
Any of the observations, made hereinabove, shall
not be taken as an expression of opinion, on the merits
of the case, as these observations, are confined, only, to
the disposal of the present application.
36.
Record be sent back forthwith.
28.9.2026
(Kalpana)
(Virender Singh)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review