Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3301 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Originat Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE FIRST DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NO: 27899 oF 2026
Between:
1. Puppala Prasanthi, Wo. G. Muralidhar, aged about 38 years, Occ- House
Wife, Rl/o. H. No. 8-8/39, Plot No. 39, NSL Cotony, phase - 2, Near Hanuman
Temple, Ashok Nagar, Ameenpur, Sanga Reddy District.
2. Guddeti Muralidhar,, S/o. Guddeti Krishna Murthy, aged about - 38 years,
Occ- Employee, Fi/ o. H. No. 8-8/39, Ptot No. 39, NSL Colony, phase - 2,
Near Hanuman Temple, Ashok Nagar, Ameenpur, Sanga Reddy District
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Stamps and
Registration Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The District Registrar,, Sanga Reddy District.
3. The Sub - Registrar,, Jogipet, Sanga Reddy District
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arlicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of
[\,4andamus declaring the action of Respondent No. 3 in issuing the lntimation of
Refusal vide Refusal order No. 269 of 2023 dated 15.12.2023 as illegal, arbitrary
and contrary to the provisions of Registration Act, 1908 and to the order passed by
the Hon'ble Apex Court in K. Gopi Vs_ The Sub- Registrar and orders passed by this
Hon'ble Court in WP. No. 4836 of 2026 and set-aside the same and consequenfly
direct the Respondent No.3 to register and release the sale Deed (p 166t2023)
dated 01.03.2023 presented by the Petitioner in respect of House constructed on
Plot No. 222, admeasuring 150 Sq. Yards ot 125.4 Sq. l/ebrs with an plinth area
200 Sq.Feet, in Sy. No. 1004/Part, Roof covered with ACC, situated at Ameenpur
I\t'lunicipality and Ameenpur Mandal, sanga Reddy District without reference to
Refusal Order No. 269 ol 2023 dated 15.12.2023.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under section 151 cPC praying that in the circu rstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court rnay br: pleased to direct the
Respondent No. 3 to register and release the sale Deec (p 166/2023) dated
01 .03.2023 presented by the Petitioner in respect of House constructed on plot No.
222, admeasuring 'l 50 Sq. Yards or 125.4 Sq. Meters with an plinth area 200
Sq.Feet, in Sy. No. 10O4lPan, Roof covered with ACC, s;ituated at Ameenpur
I\ilunicipality and Ameenpur Mandal, sanga Reddy District without reference to
Refusal order No. 269 of 2023 dared 15.12.2023 forthwith pr:nding disposal of the
above Writ Petition.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2026
Petition under section .151 cpc praying that in the circurnstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to grant
permission to the Petitioner to file the better affidavit and allow the petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI E.AKASH REDDy REPRESE:NTING
SRI S. SRIDHAR
Counsel for the Respondents: Gp FOR STAMpS AND REGISTRATION
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION No.27899 OF 2026
Between:
l"t SEPTEMBF'R,2026.
Puppala Prasanthi and another
Pctitioncrs
AND
Thc Sr.arc of Tclangana.
Rcp. br its Prinr ipal St.crcrarr.
Stamps & Ilcgistrarion [)cpa rtm cr.rr
Sccrctariat. llr clcrabad and orhcrs.
Rcspondcnts
ORDER
With thc consclll of bor h thc- partics. this Wrir [)c.tlLion is
takcn up for drsposal aL Lhc adrnission stagc rtsclf
2.
Th
js Wrjt Pcrition is lilccl aggricvcd b1. rhc acrion of
rcspondcnt No.3 in rcfusing [o rcgistcr and rc]casc thc Sale
I)ccd uzde pcnding I)ocumcnr Ir. No. I 6(>/2023 datcd O I .03.2023
by issuing Rcfursal Or<icr/lntimatjon No.269 ol. 2023 rjatcd
J5. 12.2023 in rcspccI ol I)]ot bcaring No.2.22 admcasunng
l50
sq. -r-ards or its cqutvalcnt ro 125..1 sc1 . rnctcrs u.ith an plinth
area 200 sq. Iect in Sv.No. 100,1/part, roof covered ll,ith ACC
o
sltLratcd a1 Amcenpllr MLrnictpalitv and Manda.l. Sangarcddr
Distric:t, as illcgal attd arbitrarr',
3.
i.lcard Sri E. ,,\kash l{cddi. lcarnccl .ssnSrrl rcprcsenting
Sri S. Sndhar, lcarttcd counscl appcaring for :hc pctitioncrs
and k:arned Go",crnmcnt Plcad<:r for Stamps arLd Rcgrstration
appciiring lor thc rcsPond('nt s
4.
l,carncd counscl for thc pctitioncrs sLrbmits that rhc
pctilioncrs cnLcred inLo salc clccd u ith his r.cndor l\4r' Kohinoor
Chancira Sckhar and cxcculccl a salc dccd c n 0 1 .03.2023
Hou e r,'cr. n'hcn Lhc pctitioncrs approa<:hed respc'ndcnt. No 3 for
re gistration
ol thc salc dced. thc same rnrtiail.r kept pending
urclc rlocr-rmcn1 I).No. 166 ol 202il. datcd O 1 .03.:1023. rcspotrclcnt
No.,-l has refrtscd Lo rr:gistcr thc salc dr:c:t1, uhich rs uhoil,v
r.insustainablc. It is futrthcr suLbmittcd that the issuc involvcd in
rh is Writ I)erition is
sctrritrr:lr crr,,'crr-'c1 br. tlrc o tlcr ltarssr:cl ltt
this Coutrt in W.t'].No. i 6;3 1O of 2079 and batch datcd
11.01.2023 and also rcccnt Judgmcnt of thc [{,rn'blt: Strprcme
Ccrurt rn K,Gopi u. The Sub'Registrdrl arrrd rcrlr-testcd to pass
sirnilar ordt:r rn thrs Wrtt l)t:ti1 ion arlso
li),1., S(,L (trl-inr- SC ,i ltl
5.
Le
arncd Govcrnmcn t
Plcadcr appcarlng for
the
rcsporrdcnts ['rad not dispurcd t.hc surbm ission madc bv thc
learncd counscl ior thc pctitioncrs
6.
A perusal o[ the impugncd rcfusal order dated
15.12.2023, discloscs thaL thc rcgislration ol thc sale dced
prcscnLcd b-r' thc pctitionr:rs ,,'as rcluscd on thc lollor.r.ing
TCASONS:
( l) Rcgrstrarron of thc docurlcnt is r-cluscd as it is parl of an
unattrhorizcd lat,out and is in r rol:rtron of thc (lommissionr-.r arrd
lnspcctor ()cnora.l. Rcgrslratror.r ancl sL.tmps Mt'mo \o
G)1257 t20 t9. l)t: 26.08.2020 & 29.l2 2020
(2) /\s pcr thc instructions of thc Commrssioner and lnspcclor
General oI Registration and SLamps Endorsement No. CIG
MAIL/AR/2008, I)t: 02.0 1 2008 unregiste re d and validated
do(Lrmcr.ll (iainnot IJC acccptcd as a r.alid l,ink I)ocumcnt for
rcgrslration.
7.
In this contcx[, it is to cx[ract thc rc]cvant portion ol thc
order in W.P.No.1(>310 of 20t9 and batch dared 11.O1 .2023.
r'vh ich is as undr-'r
Ili. '1'hc poucr ol thc r-cgisLcring ilLtthorit\ to rclusc rcgrstr:rti,,l
is onlv, jl anv ol- lhc grounds or objcct rot.rs Lhrtt arc (]nLlmcralcd
under Lhc provisions ol thc llcgrstraIion Act. ]908, and Lhc Rulcs
made thereundcr rn parl.icular Scctrons 19.20,21,22 A,34,35
and rule 58 of thc 'lclangana Rulcs r-rndcr the Rcgistration Act.
1908. are cxisting in rcspccL of anr suc:h documcnt presentcd for
thc r-c-'gr s trati on . I,)xccpt, rhc gror-rnds or oblccLions that arc
cnlrmor:tLcd u nc.lcr thc provisions ol Lh(-- Rcglstration n ct, I908,
thc rcgisLcring eruthoritiCs har t' no :luthoriLv to rcfusc
rcgjsLralion o1 a docLrmcnL on anv othcr gt ound As alrcadl
notcd abovc, lhc ground otr r,r,hrch thc rntl'rr-rgncd rc:fusal ordcrs
in all thcsc batch ol \\'r'ir I)cLrrions alc passr_.d is that thc link
documcnL shc-,un in thc rcspccrrrc (locurrcnls rs ti r.alidatcd and
iur Ln.lrcgislcr('d clocumr:r.rt. Ili. lool<ing into it \ alil:[rt\ of thc lrn]<
clocur-trcnt. thi: registcnng arrlhontv is incLirccth vcrifving
,.rhcLhcr Lhc c\c( LllarlrLs ol lltc icspcttiic docL,ntcnrs:rrc harrng
rltlrcl lillc or r1o1 to c),((Ll1(. thc rlocrrlncrrIs ir-i c1,-Lr.sLrr,n. As hc]cl
iit Lltc iibovc rc[errcri -1r-rrlgllcrrt jn lltc c:rsc oI I)i-. \ arc I:L l{arncsl.t
li:udrL il srrpr:L). Llrc rcgrstcr.irrg aLrLhorrt\ is ltot r.Lr itlr,cl to qo
into thc litlr: ol tl-rc par'11cs t-o thc (locLrmCnt. ll is:r sr:ttlccl larr
1ha1 lhc r crrdce LLnclcr a rlocLrnrcrrt \\ill ltot q(,1 a bclLar tillc that.t
lLrs rcrrcLor eurci trr r:trsi ii-ri.ndor ts nol hei\lltg a '.:rirC ,.Ltlc rtlcr
iix P|oPcrtr rrlrrr:lt is LItr. sLrit-1CcL m:1L1cr o1 l,l lt:lrttcul:tr
(locLuncnt. thi'icrtrlcc L-i|<lct ilir. sitrcl docrrmc|i (LOCS tol gcL :uty
tiLlc ovcr slLch prr.,Pcrl-r' :rrrd mcrc rcgistr:1tlolt of srLch doclrmcr-rt
rrill not har c :tn e flcct on lhc propcrl\ u.hic1'r is thc sL.rb]cct
mattcr of thc said ciocLrrncrrt.
i4 r\s r-rghtlv conccdcd br thc lcarnccl CovcrLrmcli [)Lcrrdcr for
SLamps ancl licgrsLration, Lhc rcBLStcrlng ar-rLhor ilr ts arc rror
cnLitlcd to refusc rcgistratlon 01 a docLrmcnt orr mcrc !.round that
tl:Ic tlLlc of 1l'rc cxccrLt:rnts of thc rcspcctive docurnrcnl is bascd
rrpon thc validatccl clo('Llmcnt. ltrough the s.lmt ts r:ornpuisorilv
rcgrstcraltlc documcr.rt cannot l)c acccptccl and srtith lr qrourrcl is
rot :u irrlablc l() tlrc r( grslclng,1Lrrh()ntlcs lo lt.lus(. L1\L.r1t,rr
'ri a cloc rtmcnl o1r l lral qroLrn(l.
i':l lLr thc light of tlrc abor c. tl-ris Cor-irt is LLultcsita|L to holcl tl-rat
lhc rrrspelldcnl rcqi:;ti'rinq aLlthoritics :rrc not entitlcC trt rcfusc
rcgis1i-litrorr oI a c]oCrLmcrl or.l lllc groLlird thar iltr: llrrl.- ilocumcnI
r.r:lt'r::"cl to u.] Lhc r( spc(:Lr\ c clocumcnt is a i alir[arc<.] d r<'umcnt or
to r cfrlsc rcglstrall lolt rli strcl.r rlOcumeni 1;r' olacing -c1i:ritcc orr
r-'r'rcior sc;ncnt. datc(l 01.01 .1008. issuccl bl lhc (-olritrLssrotrtr
arncl 1i-tspcctor Ccrcral oI Sramps unc.l llcgrst]:atiou ,1c,:ordingl-r',
Ll c imprrgne d ordcrs irL Lhc rcspccll! e Writ l)ctiLiotls :r-c sct asrdc
:rrrcl WrLt l)ctltions arc arllor,,cd r',lth a [urthcr r]ircc'-ion to thc
lcspondcnt rcgistcring arrthoritics to rcccivc Lh( reLurncd
documents and to process thc same subjcct to thc condition oI
thc said docurncnts complvrnu ,,r,'itl'r 1hc provistcns of thc
llo.qrstr:itron ,\ct, I 908 aLrci thc lndiatr St:rmp r\r:r. l8(.1 )
8.
ln K,Gopi's casc (i supra), tl-rc l lcn'b1c Srrprcmc Court
hcld as undcr:
'"l 1rc rcgistert[rg ofliccr is not Conccrrred tvith thr: Lirlc hcld bv
rlr(' c\cciL1?ult llc l-tas rro trrltLrrlic'atorr' I)o!\er lo rlcci l,. ulrr.tltcr
Ll-rc crcculant has :rt]\ trLlc. l.-r r,rr iI an (.\ccLlla]lt cxcltrtcs .r s: c
clcctl or rL lr-'asc irr rcspcct o[:r ianrl jr.r rcspcct of rr;hrr:l ]rc i'r:rs t-ro
title. thc rcgisterlng officcr ca.nnot rclLlsc to r(,gistcr Lhc
documcnt il alI thc proccdural r:omplianccs are nta,lc ancl rhc
Ileccssarv sramp clrLtl as ucij as rcgtslration charllits,/1cr. arc
paid. Wc may notc here LhaL undcr tl're sche mc ol ,.hr' 1908 Act,
it ts not thc fLlnction oI thc Sub-llegistrar or tl.,'gistcring
\LLtllortl\ to :rsccl t:rl-r Nhcthct Lh(. \-cn(l()1- ltits r. llr. to iltc
propcrt-\ v,hrch hc is secking to Lr cltrsli'r. On(jc Lhc r(
BtstCr[tg
allIhori1\. is s:,rtislicd th;,rr the p:rrtics ro rhc documcnt arc:
prcscnt bcfor' l-rim and the partics admit cxecutir)n thcrcoI
bcforc him. subject t.o making procedural compliances as
narratcd abo\.c, thc docLlmcnt mLtst bc rcgistercd. Thc cxccutron
and rcgisLration of a documcnt havc thc clfccL of transferring
onlr thosc rights. iI' an,\. ihat thc e xccutant posscsscs. Il Lhc:
cxc('uLant has r-ro nghL. titlc. or inlcrcst in rhc propertv. rhc
rcgisLcrcd doc:umcnt cannot cffccl artv transfcr
9.
In vicu' of thc ordcr rn W.l). No. I 63 I O ol 20 I 9 nnd batch
datcd I 1.O1.2023 as \\'cll as rhc .Jr_rdgmcnt oI thc Honble
Surprcmc CourL in K. Gopi,s casc (l sr-rpra) and in tcrms
therco1", this Writ l)cIirion is clisposcd ol drrecting thc
rcspondcnt authoritics to receivc. rcgister and rclease the
documcnt br:aring P.No.79 12023 prcscntcd b1,. the pctitioncrs in
rcspcct ol thc subjccl. propcrt\., u.ithout rcfcrcncc to the
IntimaLion of llefusal No. '269 of' 2023 dalcd ) r.)2.2023.
subjccl to thc condition that thc said docuntent compltcs u.ith
thc provisions of thc l?cgistrarion Act. l90g and thc [ndian
Stamp Act, 1899.
Misccllaneous pct.ilions, if an_v, pending shall slancl
closed. Thcrc shall bc no ordcr as to cosLs.
//TRUE COPY//
SD/- A.H.S.GOWRI SHANKAR
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Principal Secretary. Stamps and Registration Department,
Telangana. Secretariat. Hyderabad.
State of
2. The District Registrar,, Sanga Reddy District.
3. The Sub - Registrar,, Jogipet, Sanga Reddy District
4. One CC to SRl. S SRIDHAR, Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two CCs to GP FOR STAMPS AND REGISTRATION, High Court for the
State of Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
6. Two CD Copies
DAN
TKS
v
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0110912026
1?. E
STAT e,
q
ORDER
f,
a
o
0 7 srP 2026
+
WP.No.27899 of 2026
* a)i (' / r'4. r(,t')
,
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
,6,
\ -tr
i
tU
."\ ,*
z
o
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review